WO2023021685A1 - 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法 - Google Patents

契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法 Download PDF

Info

Publication number
WO2023021685A1
WO2023021685A1 PCT/JP2021/030550 JP2021030550W WO2023021685A1 WO 2023021685 A1 WO2023021685 A1 WO 2023021685A1 JP 2021030550 W JP2021030550 W JP 2021030550W WO 2023021685 A1 WO2023021685 A1 WO 2023021685A1
Authority
WO
WIPO (PCT)
Prior art keywords
contract
comment
unit
review
comments
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Ceased
Application number
PCT/JP2021/030550
Other languages
English (en)
French (fr)
Japanese (ja)
Inventor
隆裕 村田
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
LegalOn Technologies Inc
Original Assignee
LegalOn Technologies Inc
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by LegalOn Technologies Inc filed Critical LegalOn Technologies Inc
Priority to JP2022540765A priority Critical patent/JP7761276B2/ja
Priority to PCT/JP2021/030550 priority patent/WO2023021685A1/ja
Priority to US18/684,474 priority patent/US20240403982A1/en
Publication of WO2023021685A1 publication Critical patent/WO2023021685A1/ja
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical
Priority to JP2025170123A priority patent/JP2025188162A/ja
Ceased legal-status Critical Current

Links

Images

Classifications

    • G—PHYSICS
    • G06—COMPUTING OR CALCULATING; COUNTING
    • G06Q—INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
    • G06Q50/00—Information and communication technology [ICT] specially adapted for implementation of business processes of specific business sectors, e.g. utilities or tourism
    • G06Q50/10—Services
    • G06Q50/18—Legal services
    • G—PHYSICS
    • G06—COMPUTING OR CALCULATING; COUNTING
    • G06F—ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING
    • G06F40/00—Handling natural language data
    • G06F40/10—Text processing
    • G06F40/166—Editing, e.g. inserting or deleting
    • G06F40/169—Annotation, e.g. comment data or footnotes
    • G—PHYSICS
    • G06—COMPUTING OR CALCULATING; COUNTING
    • G06Q—INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
    • G06Q10/00—Administration; Management
    • G06Q10/10—Office automation; Time management

Definitions

  • the present invention relates to a contract review program, and more particularly to a contract review program that allows a computer to review contracts.
  • the present invention also relates to a contract review device and a contract review method for reviewing a contract.
  • Patent Document 1 describes a legal document review program, a legal document review method, and a legal document review system.
  • This legal document review system is configured to input legal document data and score whether or not the character content included in the legal document data is advantageous to the user using determination rules. Also, the scoring result is displayed in association with the character content as display content indicating whether or not it is advantageous to the user using color, size, shape, and the like.
  • contracts some legal documents such as contracts do not complete the content with just one document, and the content can be completed with multiple documents.
  • contracts there are cases where one contract and another related contract complete the contents of one contract.
  • a basic contract and an individual contract, a (basic) contract and a change contract (including a change memorandum, etc.) fall under such a contract.
  • the legal document review system described in Patent Document 1 is a system that scores whether or not the content of a legal document is advantageous to the user. Subject to change due to the existence of other legal instruments related to this. That is, in the legal document review system described in Patent Document 1, even if an evaluation is presented for a certain content of one legal document, if there is another related legal document, the content is presented. It may be different from the evaluation given.
  • the present invention provides a contract review program that allows a computer to review a contract, the program causing the computer to read at least a first contract and a second contract related thereto.
  • a contract reading unit for reading the contract document file into a computer; and a comment generating unit for generating comments on at least the clauses included in the first contract based on the document file read by the contract reading unit.
  • a comment correction unit that modifies, including additions, changes and/or deletions, based on the content of the second contract to the comments generated by this comment generation unit; It is characterized by functioning as a comment output unit that outputs comments on the clauses of the first contract that have been modified by the department.
  • the document files of the first and second contracts are read by the contract reading unit, and based on these document files, the comment generation unit creates the first contract. Comments are generated for included clauses. Further, the comment correction unit modifies the generated comment, including additions, changes and/or deletions, based on the content of the second contract, and the comment output unit outputs the modified comment. be done.
  • the comment for the first contract generated by the comment generation unit is corrected by the comment correction unit based on the contents of the second contract. contract can be reviewed with sufficient accuracy even if the contract exists.
  • the program further preferentially applies the terms contained in the first contract or the terms contained in the second contract read by the contract reading unit.
  • the comment generation unit generates comments based on the setting by the preferred contract setting unit
  • the comment correction unit sets the preferred contract Modify comments based on department settings.
  • the priority contract setting unit can set the contract with priority, so that more appropriate comments can be generated and/or comments can be corrected. .
  • the program further extracts, from the document files of the first contract and the second contract, a priority clause that specifies which contract has priority over which clause is included.
  • the computer functions as a clause extractor, the comment generator generates comments based on the content of the preferential clauses, and/or the comment modifier modifies the comments based on the preferential clauses.
  • the priority clause is extracted by the priority clause extracting unit, and the content of the priority clause is taken into consideration. can be modified.
  • the program further causes the computer to function as an item acquisition unit that acquires standard items from an item database that stores items that should normally be included in a predetermined contract, Among them, if there is a missing item that is not described in the first contract, a missing notification comment is generated to notify that there is a missing item in the first contract. Correct the missing notice comment if it is stated in the contract in 2.
  • the item acquisition unit acquires standard items that should normally be included in a given contract, so it is possible to prevent omission of necessary items in the contract. Also, even if there is a missing item in the first contract, if the item is described in the second contract, the missing notice comment will be corrected, so that the first and second contracts Accurately reviews missing items in completed contracts.
  • one of the first contract and the second contract is a basic contract, and the other of the first contract and the second contract is an individual contract is.
  • one of the first contract and the second contract is a basic contract and the other is an individual contract, so the basic contracts that complement each other Be able to accurately review the contents of contracts based on contracts and individual contracts.
  • the present invention also provides a contract review device for reviewing a contract, comprising a contract reading unit for reading at least document files of a first contract and a second contract related thereto into a computer.
  • a comment generation unit for generating comments on the clauses included in at least the first contract based on the document file read by the contract reading unit; Based on the contents of the contract in 2, the first contract generated by the comment modification unit that makes modifications including additions, changes and / or deletions, and the comment generation unit and modified by the comment modification unit and a comment output unit for outputting a comment on the clause.
  • the present invention is a contract review method for reviewing a contract by a computer, wherein at least document files of a first contract and a second contract related thereto are read into a computer.
  • a reading step a comment generating step for generating comments for clauses included in at least the first contract based on the document file read by the contract reading step; , based on the contents of the second contract, the first contract generated by the comment correction step of making corrections including additions, changes and / or deletions, and the comment generation step and corrected by the comment correction step and a comment output step of outputting a comment on the clause of the document.
  • the contracts can be reviewed with sufficient accuracy.
  • FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an environment in which a contract review program according to an embodiment of the present invention operates;
  • FIG. It is a block diagram showing a configuration example of a server device in which the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention operates.
  • FIG. 4 is a block diagram showing functional units realized within the server device by executing the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention; It is a flow chart which shows an outline of processing of a contract review program by an embodiment of the present invention.
  • FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a screen on the display showing a state in which a contract document file has been uploaded from a terminal in the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention;
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the terminal display by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing the review results when the contract is reviewed independently.
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the terminal display by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing the review results when the contract is reviewed independently.
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the terminal display by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing the review results when the contract is reviewed independently.
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the terminal display by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing the review results when the contract is reviewed independently.
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the display of a terminal by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing review results when a plurality of contracts are reviewed simultaneously; .
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the display of a terminal by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing review results when a plurality of contracts are reviewed simultaneously; .
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the display of a terminal by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing review results when a plurality of contracts are reviewed simultaneously; .
  • FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a review result screen displayed on the display of a terminal by executing the contract review program of the embodiment of the present invention, showing review results when a plurality of contracts are reviewed simultaneously; .
  • FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an environment in which a contract review program according to an embodiment of the present invention operates.
  • FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing a configuration example of a server device on which the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention operates.
  • FIG. 3 is a block diagram showing functional units realized within the server device by executing the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention.
  • the contract review program operates in an environment in which a server device 1, which is a computer, and a terminal 2 are communicably connected to each other via a network 3, as shown in FIG.
  • the terminal 2 is operated by the user A who uses the review of the contract.
  • the server device 1 is a server-type information processing device that operates in response to a request from the terminal 2.
  • the server device 1 includes a CPU (Central Processing Unit) having a function for processing information, a flash memory, and the like. It has an electronic circuit made up of electronic components. It should be noted that the server device 1 does not necessarily have to be composed of a single information processing device. There may be.
  • CPU Central Processing Unit
  • the terminal 2 is an information processing device such as a PC (Personal Computer) or a tablet terminal, and is equipped with electronic components such as a CPU and flash memory that have functions for processing information within the main body.
  • the network 3 is a communication network capable of high-speed communication.
  • a wired or wireless communication network such as the Internet with security measures, an intranet, or a LAN (Local Area Network) can be used as a network.
  • LAN Local Area Network
  • the server device 1 installed with the contract review program reviews the contract based on user A's operation.
  • User A uploads the document files of the first contract and the related second contract from the terminal 2 to the server device 1, and then, by operating from the terminal 2, the first and second contract reviews are performed.
  • the document files of the first and second contracts do not necessarily have to be uploaded from a single terminal 2, and may be uploaded from separate terminals. Also, the contracts to be reviewed need not be two, and the present invention can be configured to review one or more than two contracts.
  • the server device 1 includes a central processing unit 4 which is a processor, a main storage device 5, an input/output interface device 6, an input device 7, an auxiliary storage device 8, and an output device 9. , can be included. These devices are connected to each other by a data bus and/or a control bus.
  • the auxiliary storage device 8 is composed of a storage medium such as a hard disk device and flash memory, and is configured to store information.
  • the contract review program 10 of this embodiment is stored in the auxiliary storage device 8, and is read into the main storage device 5 when executed to review the contract.
  • the central processing unit 4 sequentially loads instructions and data (computer programs) constituting a specific application stored in the auxiliary storage device 8 into the main storage device 5, and loads them. Instructions and data can be computed. Thereby, the central processing unit 4 controls the output device 9 via the input/output interface device 6, or controls other devices (for example, the terminal 2 etc.) via the input/output interface device 6 and the network 3. Various information (data) can be transmitted and received between
  • the server device 1 can function as a web server by executing a specific installed application.
  • the server device 1 executes various operations related to the review of the contract, which will be described later, via a web page transmitted to the terminal 2 (and a computer program incorporated in the web page and executed by the terminal 2). can do.
  • the server device 1 can function as an application server by executing a specific installed application. Accordingly, the server device 1 can perform similar operations.
  • the server device 1 operates as the control unit 12 by executing the contract review program 10 of the present embodiment, and includes a user authentication unit 18, a contract reading unit 20, a comment generation unit 22, a comment correction unit 24, a priority contract Functions such as a book setting unit 26, a priority clause extraction unit 28, an item acquisition unit 30, a comment output unit 32, and the like are realized.
  • the user authentication unit 18 When the user authentication unit 18 receives an authentication request together with information such as a user ID and password from the terminal 2, the user information 34 including the user ID and password registered in advance and stored in the auxiliary storage device 8 is authenticated. Refer to it and authenticate the user.
  • the contract reading unit 20 receives the contract document file 36 from the terminal 2 operated by the user A and stores it in the auxiliary storage device 8 .
  • the contract reading unit 20 operates to read the document files of the first contract and the related second contract into the server device 1 .
  • the contract reading unit 20 may receive the contract document files 36 from a plurality of terminals.
  • the present invention can also be configured so that anonymization processing is performed when accepting the document file 36 of the contract read by the contract reading unit 20 and storing it in the auxiliary storage device 8 . That is, in the anonymization process, the names of the contracting parties, etc. written in the contract are replaced with predetermined character strings, etc., to anonymize the contracting parties, etc. Specifically, the parties to the contract are anonymized by extracting the proper nouns of the parties to the contract included in the document file 36 of the contract and replacing the character strings representing the extracted proper nouns with specific character strings. In addition to contract parties, it is preferable to anonymize specific product names, service names, project names, and the like. As a result, the risk of leakage of confidential information caused by uploading the contract to the server device 1 can be minimized.
  • the comment generation unit 22 functions to generate comments on the clauses included in the contract based on the document file read by the contract reading unit 20.
  • the comment generation unit 22 generates comments for each of the plurality of contracts read by the contract reading unit 20. Of these, it is sufficient that a comment is generated for at least one contract.
  • the comments generated by the comment generation unit 22 include, for example: (1) pointing out whether the terms contained in the contract are advantageous or disadvantageous to user A, and their scoring; As a result, (2) advice on amendments and deletions to clauses included in the contract, (3) pointing out that items that should normally be included in the contract are missing, and suggestions for items to be added, etc. can be mentioned.
  • the comment generation unit 22 first analyzes the contents of the contract from the document file of the read contract and extracts information indicating the contract status.
  • the method of extracting information from the contents of the contract may be a method of extracting information that matches a predetermined keyword and alphanumeric characters included in the vicinity of the keyword, morphological analysis, syntactic analysis, semantic analysis, It may be extracted by performing contextual analysis, or may be extracted by performing labeling based on machine learning.
  • the comment generation unit 22 applies a preset conditional rule to the extracted information, and selects an example comment that matches the extracted contract information.
  • Example sentences of comments that match each piece of contract information are stored in the auxiliary storage device 8 as a comment database 40, and the comment generator 22 selects the most appropriate comment that matches the conditions from the comment database 40.
  • a processing method such as natural language processing can be appropriately used.
  • the comment generation unit 22 generates a comment by correcting the selected comment example sentence in accordance with the wording of the contract being analyzed.
  • the comment correction unit 24 functions to make corrections including additions, changes and/or deletions to the comments generated by the comment generation unit 22.
  • the comment correction unit 24 corrects the second contract based on the content of the second contract related to the first contract. It functions to make corrections to the comments on one contract.
  • the comment correction unit 24 corrects the comment based on the content of the contract other than the contract for which the comment is generated by the comment generation unit 22. acts like adding
  • "modification" includes addition, change and/or deletion of comments.
  • the priority contract setting unit 26 uses which of the terms included in the first contract read by the contract reading unit 20 and the terms included in the second contract should be preferentially applied. It functions so that person A can set it.
  • the present invention can also be configured so that the user can set the priority order of contracts when three or more contracts are read.
  • This priority contract setting unit 26 prioritizes which clause of the contract among the contracts read by the contract reading unit 20 over the clauses of other contracts. It is configured so that the user A can set whether it is applied. For example, when the first contract and the second contract are read by the contract reading unit 20, the user A operates the terminal 2 to display the first contract and the second contract on the display 2a of the terminal 2. Specify the contract that takes precedence among the second contracts.
  • the comment generation unit 22 functions to generate comments based on the setting by the priority contract setting unit 26 .
  • the comment correction section 24 functions to correct the comment based on the setting by the priority contract setting section 26 .
  • the priority clause extraction unit 28 functions to extract, from the document file of the contract read by the contract reading unit 20, the priority clause that specifies which contract has priority. For example, when the document files of the first contract and the second contract are read, the priority clause extracting unit 28 extracts the priority clause that specifies which contract has priority. to extract Note that the comment generation unit 22 can generate a comment based on the content of the priority clause extracted by the priority clause extraction unit 28 . Furthermore, the comment correction unit 24 can correct the comment based on the content of the priority clause.
  • either one of the priority contract setting unit 26 and the priority clause extraction unit 28 described above can be omitted.
  • the preferential clause extracting unit 28 when the preferential clause extracting unit 28 is provided, the present invention is implemented so that the preferentially applicable contract is automatically selected based on the preferential clause extracted by the preferential clause extracting unit 28. Can also be configured. If both the priority contract setting unit 26 and the priority clause extracting unit 28 are provided, and the contract is not selected by the priority contract setting unit 26, the contract to be preferentially applied is automatically selected.
  • the present invention can also be configured so that Alternatively, the present invention can be configured so that the priority contract setting unit 26 can set "automatic selection". When this "automatic selection" is set, the preferentially applied contract is set by the preferential clause extraction unit 28 based on the extracted preferential clause.
  • the item database 38 is stored in the auxiliary storage device 8 .
  • This item database 38 lists items that should normally be included in a given contract.
  • the items included in the item database 38 include standard items for worker dispatch contracts, standard items for sales contracts, standard items for lease contracts, etc. can be mentioned.
  • the item acquisition unit 30 of the control unit 12 acquires from the item database 38 standard items, which are items normally included in the contract, according to the contract read by the contract reading unit 20 . If there is a missing item not described in the first contract among the standard items acquired by the item acquiring unit 30, the comment generating unit 22 notifies that there is a missing item in the first contract. Generate a missing notification comment to Also, the comment correction unit 24 corrects the missing notification comment generated by the comment generation unit 22 when the missing item is described in the second contract.
  • the comment output unit 32 functions to output to the terminal 2 the comment generated by the comment generation unit 22 and corrected by the comment correction unit 24 for the terms of the contract. That is, the comment output unit 32 outputs the comment on the reviewed contract from the input/output interface device 6 to the terminal 2 in order to display it on the display 2a of the terminal 2.
  • FIG. In this embodiment, the terms of the reviewed contract are displayed on the display 2a of the terminal 2, and the comments are displayed in the comment column adjacent to the displayed terms.
  • FIG. 4 is a flow chart outlining the processing of the contract review program according to the embodiment of the present invention.
  • FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a screen on the display 2a showing a state in which a contract document file has been uploaded from the terminal 2.
  • FIG. 6 to 12 are diagrams showing examples of review result screens displayed on the display 2a of the terminal 2 by executing the contract review program of this embodiment.
  • step S1 of FIG. 4 the server device 1 receives a service login request sent by the user A operating the terminal 2 .
  • the terminal 2 transmits an authentication request to the server device 1 together with the information, and the server device 1 receives the authentication request.
  • the user authentication unit 18 of the server device 1 When the user authentication unit 18 of the server device 1 receives an authentication request together with information such as the user ID and password from the terminal 2, it refers to the user information 34 including the user ID and password registered in advance, and Authenticate person A.
  • step S2 As a contract reading step, the document file of the contract to be reviewed is uploaded by User A's operation of the terminal 2, and the server device 1 reads it. That is, as shown in FIG. 5, the user A clicks the "Add File” button on the display 2a of the terminal 2 to add the contract document file stored in the storage device built into the terminal 2. to select.
  • the terminal 2 uploads the document file selected by the user A to the server device 1 .
  • the server device 1 also receives the type of the uploaded contract entered by the user A via the terminal 2 and the position of the user A in the contract.
  • the contract reading unit 20 of the server device 1 accepts the document file 36 from the terminal 2 by the operation of the user A and stores it in the auxiliary storage device 8 .
  • the contract reading unit 20 displays a list of the document files 36 received from the terminal 2 on the display 2a of the terminal 2.
  • a document file of "Basic Contract for Worker Dispatching” and a document file of "Individual Contract for Worker Dispatching” are uploaded and displayed on the display 2a.
  • the server device 1 receives the information of the contract that is preferentially applied among the uploaded document files.
  • the user selects which clause of the contract should be preferentially applied from among the document files 36 of each contract displayed on the display 2 a of the terminal 2 .
  • the priority contract setting unit 26 of the server device 1 displays “ ⁇ (white circle)” at the beginning of the document file name of each contract displayed on the display 2a of the terminal 2.
  • FIG. User A clicks on the " ⁇ ” attached to the document file of the contract with priority, the display changes to " ⁇ (double circle)", the contract with priority is set, and this information is input to the server device 1 .
  • "individual worker dispatch contract” is selected as the preferentially applied contract, and the symbol on the left side of the document name is changed to ".largecircle.”.
  • step S4 of FIG. 4 the server device 1 generates a comment based on the operation of the terminal 2 by the user A. That is, when the user A clicks the "execute review" button displayed on the display 2a of the terminal 2, the comment generation unit 22 of the server device 1 analyzes each contract and generates a comment as a comment generation step. do. As a comment correction process, the comment correction unit 24 corrects the comment generated in the comment generation process, taking into consideration the preferentially applied contract set in step S3. It should be noted that if there is only one document file of the contract uploaded in step S2, the contract is reviewed independently and the comments are not corrected.
  • step S2 if the user A clicks the "execute review" button without selecting a contract to be preferentially applied, the preferential clause extracting unit 28 It extracts the preferred terms from the file and automatically sets the preferred agreement based on the content of the extracted preferred terms. Note that when the contract to be preferentially applied is automatically selected, the selected contract is displayed on the display 2 a of the terminal 2 . Also, if the contract that should be applied preferentially cannot be automatically selected, such as when none of the contracts includes a priority clause, the message "Cannot identify the contract that should be prioritized. Please select a contract.” message is displayed on the display 2a of the terminal 2 to prompt the user A to select the contract to be preferentially applied.
  • step S5 of FIG. 4 the server device 1 causes the display 2a of the terminal 2 to output the review result obtained by executing the review as a comment output step. That is, the comments generated by the execution of the review are output to the display 2a by the comment output unit 32 together with the terms of the contract that have been reviewed, and the processing of the flowchart shown in FIG. 4 is terminated.
  • the document file of the contract that has been reviewed and comments can be configured so that user A can edit it via terminal 2 . User A corrects the document file by referring to the comments, and clicks the "review" button again, so that the user A can see the comments on the contract after the correction and can easily complete the contract. can.
  • FIGS. 6 to 12 are the results of executing a review on the "worker dispatch basic contract" alone (only the "worker dispatch basic contract” is uploaded and the "execute review” button is clicked. 3 shows the display screen of the result when clicked. 9 to 12 show the result of simultaneously reviewing the "worker dispatch basic contract” and the "worker dispatch individual contract” (when the "execute review” button is clicked in the state shown in Fig. 5 The display screen of the case result) is shown.
  • FIGS. 6 to 12 are examples of review results when the user A is in the position of the dispatcher of the worker dispatch contract.
  • the “Basic Contract for Worker Dispatching” illustrated here includes “Article 1 (Purpose)”, “Article 2 (Scope of Application)”, “Article 3 (Individual Contract)”, “Article 4 (Dispatch fee)”, “Article 5 (Money handling, use of automobiles and other special work)”, “Article 6 (Use of machines, etc.)”, “Article 7 (Employment conditions, etc.)”, “Article 7 Article 8 (Safety and Health, etc.)”, “Article 9 (Responsible Person and Commander)”, “Article 10 (Replacement of Dispatched Workers)”, “Article 11 (Complaint Handling)”, “Article 12 Article 13 (Ownership of Intellectual Property Rights)”, “Article 14 (Prohibition of Employment)”, “Article 15 (Prohibition of Dispatched Workers )”, “Article 16 (Confidentiality)”, “Article 17 (Prot
  • Article 5 of the Worker Dispatching Basic Contract states, "The dispatched company will provide the dispatched worker with cash, securities and other similar securities and valuables.” It is prohibited to have them handle special work, such as work that uses vehicles.” Then, this clause is highlighted on the display 2a, an arrow is drawn toward the right column of the display 2a, and a comment on the highlighted clause is displayed in the comment column on the right side of the arrow. ing.
  • the item acquisition unit 30 of the control unit 12 acquires from the item database 38 stored in the auxiliary storage device 8 standard items that should normally be included in the type of worker dispatch contract. If a missing item that is included in the standard item and not included in the worker dispatch basic contract under review is found, the comment generating unit 22 generates a missing notification comment and identifies the missing item. notify you that there is In other words, in the above example, it was discovered that if the dispatched employee violated the confidentiality obligation, the item that the dispatched company can be held jointly and severally liable was missing, and the missing notification comment was "The temporary employee violated the confidentiality obligation. If you do so, you can pursue joint and several liability to the dispatching agency.”
  • Article 4 (dispatching fee) of the basic contract states, "1. Each time the contract is concluded, the dispatch destination and the dispatch source will decide after consultation, depending on the work content, etc.”. For this article, "[Medium] The provision regarding late payment charges is missing. Correction policy: Please add it to the highlighted article.”
  • the comment generating unit 22 generates the comment “Add or add.” These comments are also generated by comparing the standard terms retrieved from the terms database 38 with the worker dispatch master contract being reviewed.
  • Figures 6 to 8 show the review results when the worker dispatch basic contract was reviewed independently.
  • the comment generation unit 22 when the worker dispatch basic contract and the worker dispatch individual contract are reviewed at the same time (when the "execute review" button is clicked in the state shown in FIG. 5), the comment generation unit 22 generates The comment correcting section 24 corrects the comment. That is, the comment correction unit 24 modifies the comment generated by the comment generation unit 22 on the first contract based on the contents of the second contract, including additions, changes and/or deletions. is configured to
  • FIGS. 9 to 12 show the result of simultaneously reviewing the "worker dispatch basic contract” and the "worker dispatch individual contract” (when the "execute review” button is clicked in the state shown in FIG. result) is shown.
  • the comments on the worker dispatch basic contract, which is the first contract were corrected based on the contents of the worker dispatch individual contract, which is the second contract. has been added.
  • Article 4 (dispatch fee) of the worker dispatch basic contract states, "1. shall be determined through consultation between the dispatching destination and the dispatching agency depending on the content of the work each time an individual contract is concluded.” This clause is the same as the worker dispatching basic contract shown in Figure 6. .
  • item 15 of the worker dispatch individual contract (Fig. 11), which is reviewed at the same time as the worker dispatch basic contract, states "(1) Fee: Hourly wage 2000 yen (tax included)", and "(4) Delay damages If the dispatch destination delays payment of the monetary obligations owed to the dispatcher based on this contract, delay damages will be charged at a rate of 3% per year from the day following the due date until payment has been completed. money must be paid.”
  • the comment correction by the comment correction unit 24 described above is based on the review results under the condition that the worker dispatch individual contract is preferentially applied to the worker dispatch basic contract.
  • the preferential contract setting unit 26 sets the worker dispatch basic contract to be preferentially applied, the comments on Article 5 in FIG. 12 are different.
  • the Worker Dispatching Basic Contract is applied preferentially, Article 5 of the Worker Dispatching Basic Contract should be changed to “In Paragraph 16 of the Individual Contract, cash, securities Although it is stipulated that other handling is allowed, this article is preferentially applied, and a temporary worker cannot be allowed to handle cash, securities, or other items.” is generated by the comment generation unit 22.
  • the comment generating unit 22 generates comments based on the preferentially applied contract set by the preferential contract setting unit 26 .
  • the comment correction unit 24 corrects the comment based on the preferentially applied contract set by the preferential contract setting unit 26 . If multiple contracts reviewed at the same time have overlapping or conflicting provisions, the present invention can be configured so that comments are added only to the terms of the contract that are preferentially applied.
  • the priority contract setting unit 26 does not set a priority contract
  • a contract to be preferentially applied is set based on the priority clause extracted by the priority clause extraction unit 28.
  • the comment generator 22 generates comments based on the priority clause extracted by the priority clause extractor 28 .
  • the comment correction unit 24 corrects the comment based on the priority clause extracted by the priority clause extraction unit 28 .
  • the priority contract setting unit 26 has set the worker dispatch individual contract to have priority (FIG. 5)
  • the present invention can also be configured so that, when a priority clause is extracted that gives priority to the temporary staffing basic contract, a comment calling attention to this point is generated. For example, generate a comment saying "The individual worker dispatch contract is set to take precedence, but there is a clause that gives priority to the worker dispatch basic contract.”
  • the present invention can also be configured as follows.
  • the comment on the worker dispatch basic contract which is the first contract
  • the comment on the worker dispatch individual contract which is the second contract.
  • comments on the provisions of the worker dispatch basic contract were displayed.
  • the present invention can be configured so that comments on individual worker dispatch contracts are also displayed.
  • the comments on the Worker Dispatching Individual Contract, which is the first contract will be revised based on the contents of the Worker Dispatching Basic Contract, which is the second contract, and the Worker Dispatching Individual Contract A comment for the clause is displayed.
  • the comment generation unit 22 and the comment correction unit 24 are specified as separate functional units, but these functional units may be integrated. In this case, the comments once generated by the comment generation unit 22 are not corrected by the comment correction unit 24, but the comments after being added, changed, and/or deleted by the integrated function unit generated.
  • the contract review program 10 was installed in the server device 1 and operated via the terminal 2 to review the contract.
  • the present invention can also be configured so that the contract review program 10 is installed on a stand-alone computer and used.
  • the present invention can be configured as a contract review device by incorporating the contract review program 10 into dedicated hardware.
  • the comment on the first contract generated by the comment generation unit 22 is corrected by the comment correction unit 24 based on the content of the second contract. Since it is added, the contract can be reviewed with sufficient accuracy even if there are multiple contracts.
  • the priority contract can be set by the priority contract setting unit 26, so that more appropriate comment generation and/or comment correction can be performed. It can be carried out.
  • the priority clause is extracted by the priority clause extraction unit 28, and the content of the priority clause is taken into consideration. and/or corrections to the comments can be made.
  • the item acquisition unit 30 acquires standard items that should normally be included in a given contract, so it is possible to prevent omission of necessary items in the contract. Also, even if there is a missing item in the first contract, if the item is described in the second contract, the missing notification comment will be deleted. Accurately reviews missing items in completed contracts.
  • one of the first contract and the second contract is a basic contract, and the other is an individual contract. Can accurately review the contents of the contract based on the basic contract and individual contract.
  • the contract review program of the present invention was used for reviewing worker dispatch contracts, but the present invention can Can be applied to any contract review.
  • the contract review program of the present invention reviews the basic contract and the individual contract at the same time.
  • the present invention can be applied to the review of a plurality of written contracts.
  • contract means a legal document describing the content of the agreement between the parties, and does not limit the name of the document.
  • server device (computer) 2 terminal 3 network 4 central processing unit 5 main storage unit 6 input/output interface device 7 input device 8 auxiliary storage device 9 output device 10 contract review program 12 control unit 18 user authentication unit 20 contract reading unit 22 comment generation unit 24 comment correction unit 26 priority contract setting unit 28 priority clause extraction unit 30 item acquisition unit 32 comment output unit 34 user information 36 document file 38 item database 40 comment database

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Business, Economics & Management (AREA)
  • Theoretical Computer Science (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Tourism & Hospitality (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Human Resources & Organizations (AREA)
  • Strategic Management (AREA)
  • Economics (AREA)
  • Marketing (AREA)
  • General Business, Economics & Management (AREA)
  • General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Computational Linguistics (AREA)
  • Audiology, Speech & Language Pathology (AREA)
  • Primary Health Care (AREA)
  • Artificial Intelligence (AREA)
  • Technology Law (AREA)
  • Entrepreneurship & Innovation (AREA)
  • Quality & Reliability (AREA)
  • Operations Research (AREA)
  • Data Mining & Analysis (AREA)
  • Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)
PCT/JP2021/030550 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法 Ceased WO2023021685A1 (ja)

Priority Applications (4)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP2022540765A JP7761276B2 (ja) 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法
PCT/JP2021/030550 WO2023021685A1 (ja) 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法
US18/684,474 US20240403982A1 (en) 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 Contract document review program, contract document review apparatus, and contract document review method
JP2025170123A JP2025188162A (ja) 2021-08-20 2025-10-08 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
PCT/JP2021/030550 WO2023021685A1 (ja) 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
WO2023021685A1 true WO2023021685A1 (ja) 2023-02-23

Family

ID=85240459

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
PCT/JP2021/030550 Ceased WO2023021685A1 (ja) 2021-08-20 2021-08-20 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法

Country Status (3)

Country Link
US (1) US20240403982A1 (cg-RX-API-DMAC7.html)
JP (2) JP7761276B2 (cg-RX-API-DMAC7.html)
WO (1) WO2023021685A1 (cg-RX-API-DMAC7.html)

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP7506867B1 (ja) 2023-04-27 2024-06-27 株式会社リセ 文書修正プログラム、文書修正装置および文書修正方法
WO2024201679A1 (ja) * 2023-03-27 2024-10-03 株式会社LegalOn Technologies 情報処理方法、情報処理装置、情報処理システム及び情報処理プログラム

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2014238629A (ja) * 2013-06-06 2014-12-18 株式会社野村総合研究所 契約書分析システム、プログラム及び方法
JP2020144421A (ja) * 2019-03-04 2020-09-10 株式会社日本法務システム研究所 情報処理システム及び情報処理方法
JP2020160971A (ja) * 2019-03-27 2020-10-01 Gva Tech株式会社 契約書校正システム、契約書校正プログラム及び契約書校正方法

Family Cites Families (9)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6560620B1 (en) * 1999-08-03 2003-05-06 Aplix Research, Inc. Hierarchical document comparison system and method
US20040148280A1 (en) * 2002-12-30 2004-07-29 Moriyuki Chimura Management information processing method and keyword determination method
US20040163050A1 (en) * 2003-02-14 2004-08-19 Matter Bruce Edward Systems and methods for managing negotiated transactions
US10216733B2 (en) * 2006-04-14 2019-02-26 Gregg S. Homer Smart commenting software
JP5184290B2 (ja) * 2008-10-07 2013-04-17 株式会社エヌ・ティ・ティ・データ 文書作成支援装置、文書作成支援方法およびプログラム
US20130204833A1 (en) * 2012-02-02 2013-08-08 Bo PANG Personalized recommendation of user comments
US20170124039A1 (en) * 2014-06-02 2017-05-04 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Digital note creation
JP7409061B2 (ja) * 2019-12-13 2024-01-09 富士フイルムビジネスイノベーション株式会社 文書管理装置及び文書管理プログラム
US11755973B2 (en) * 2021-02-12 2023-09-12 Accenture Global Solutions Limited System and method for intelligent contract guidance

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2014238629A (ja) * 2013-06-06 2014-12-18 株式会社野村総合研究所 契約書分析システム、プログラム及び方法
JP2020144421A (ja) * 2019-03-04 2020-09-10 株式会社日本法務システム研究所 情報処理システム及び情報処理方法
JP2020160971A (ja) * 2019-03-27 2020-10-01 Gva Tech株式会社 契約書校正システム、契約書校正プログラム及び契約書校正方法

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2024201679A1 (ja) * 2023-03-27 2024-10-03 株式会社LegalOn Technologies 情報処理方法、情報処理装置、情報処理システム及び情報処理プログラム
JP7506867B1 (ja) 2023-04-27 2024-06-27 株式会社リセ 文書修正プログラム、文書修正装置および文書修正方法

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
US20240403982A1 (en) 2024-12-05
JP2025188162A (ja) 2025-12-25
JPWO2023021685A1 (cg-RX-API-DMAC7.html) 2023-02-23
JP7761276B2 (ja) 2025-10-28

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
JP6561305B2 (ja) 法律文書レビュープログラム、法律文書レビュー方法、及び法律文書レビューシステム
US12430593B2 (en) Due diligence systems and methods
US20090281853A1 (en) Legal Instrument Management Platform
US20090241165A1 (en) Compliance policy management systems and methods
JP2025188162A (ja) 契約書レビュープログラム、契約書レビュー装置、及び契約書レビュー方法
US20130013996A1 (en) Method for Improving Document Review Performance
JP5735403B2 (ja) 文書管理装置
Uberti-Bona Marin et al. Are companies taking AI risks seriously? A systematic analysis of companies’ AI risk disclosures in SEC 10-K forms
JP4034284B2 (ja) 企業診断報告作成装置
US20210287315A1 (en) Architectures and methods for generating and transferring electronically signed document data packages
JP2020184245A (ja) 裁判外紛争解決手続システム
JP6531311B1 (ja) 変更登記申請支援システム、変更登記申請支援方法及び変更登記申請支援プログラム
JP4034283B2 (ja) 企業診断報告作成装置
JP7826554B1 (ja) 情報処理システム、情報処理方法、及び、情報処理プログラム
JP2004310193A (ja) 提案管理システム、提案管理方法および提案管理用プログラム
Choe-Groves et al. Promises and Perils: The Role of Artificial Intelligence in the Courts
JP2024032450A (ja) 契約書作成システム、契約書作成サーバープログラム及び契約書作成装置
WO2025134402A1 (ja) 情報処理方法、及び情報処理装置
Clare ‘We Have Voices But We Can’t Really Speak’: transnational privatisation and (de) juridification of women’s employment in global export manufacturing—a case study of Hansae Vietnam Co Ltd
Al-Tarawneh Translating Mergers and Acquisitions Legalese
Ashoor et al. Blockchain infrastructure acceptance in the gulf cooperation council countries: An overview
WO2026063437A1 (ja) 情報処理方法、及び情報処理装置
Austin et al. Understanding and Managing Privileges in Today's Interconnected World: A complicated web of communications in a global world presents real-world challenges.
Lawson et al. Developments in ethics guidelines for CPAs
Reetz Update on Al Policies for Lawyers

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
ENP Entry into the national phase

Ref document number: 2022540765

Country of ref document: JP

Kind code of ref document: A

121 Ep: the epo has been informed by wipo that ep was designated in this application

Ref document number: 21954253

Country of ref document: EP

Kind code of ref document: A1

NENP Non-entry into the national phase

Ref country code: DE

122 Ep: pct application non-entry in european phase

Ref document number: 21954253

Country of ref document: EP

Kind code of ref document: A1