Classifications

• • H—ELECTRICITY
  • H03—ELECTRONIC CIRCUITRY
  • H03D—DEMODULATION OR TRANSFERENCE OF MODULATION FROM ONE CARRIER TO ANOTHER
  • H03D7/00—Transference of modulation from one carrier to another, e.g. frequency-changing
  • H03D7/14—Balanced arrangements
  • H03D7/1425—Balanced arrangements with transistors
• • H—ELECTRICITY
  • H03—ELECTRONIC CIRCUITRY
  • H03D—DEMODULATION OR TRANSFERENCE OF MODULATION FROM ONE CARRIER TO ANOTHER
  • H03D7/00—Transference of modulation from one carrier to another, e.g. frequency-changing
  • H03D7/14—Balanced arrangements
  • H03D7/1408—Balanced arrangements with diodes
• • H—ELECTRICITY
  • H03—ELECTRONIC CIRCUITRY
  • H03D—DEMODULATION OR TRANSFERENCE OF MODULATION FROM ONE CARRIER TO ANOTHER
  • H03D2200/00—Indexing scheme relating to details of demodulation or transference of modulation from one carrier to another covered by H03D
  • H03D2200/0041—Functional aspects of demodulators
  • H03D2200/0086—Reduction or prevention of harmonic frequencies

Definitions

• the invention relates generally to radio transmitters utilizing a mixer to produce an output signal of a given frequency.
• the invention relates to circuits containing mixers that combine a first signal LO with a second signal RF to yield a third signal IF, especially in a relatively high-frequency application. More particularly, this invention relates to such circuits for use in satellites,
• a common way to combine two input signals to produce an output signal is to employ a mixer.
• a key feature of a mixer circuit is one or more mixing elements, which generally comprise a nonlinear device such as a diode, field effect transistor, or bipolar junction transistor.
• Mixing elements combine two frequency inputs to yield other frequency outputs, which vary according to the features of the particular mixing elements.
• mixing elements are designed to output second order frequencies, which include the sum and difference of the two input signal frequencies.
• an LO signal and an RF signal enter the mixer element, which then outputs an IF signal that is either the sum or difference of the input frequencies.
• mixers receive a radio frequency input signal (RF) and a signal from a local oscillator (LO), and combine them to produce an output signal.
• the output signal comprises the Intermediate Frequency signal (IF) at a frequency that is either the difference or the total of the frequencies of the RF and LO signals.
• the IF signal is typically the useful or desired portion of the output signal, and it carries the information of the RF signal a different desired frequency.
• mixers are non-linear, mixers output additional signals with frequencies other than the desired IF signal.
• the additional frequencies are various other combinations of the RP and LO frequencies, typically multiples of the RP or LO frequencies, or sums and differences of multiples of the input signal frequencies.
• These mixer by-products are referred to as spurious frequencies (“spurs"), or collectively as interrnodulation distortion (IMD).
• spurious frequencies spurspurs
• IMD interrnodulation distortion
• the spurs may be very close to the frequencies of the output signal.
• a potential problem encountered can be seen in the graph of FIG. 4, which shows the inputs and some of the outputs of a mixer.
• the mixer receives a radio-frequency (RP) input signal 201 at a frequency of 30 GHz and a local oscillator (LO) signal 202 with a frequency of 9.5 GHz.
• one of the spurs produced by the mixer is a harmonic signal 204 of the LO signal 202, with a frequency two times the LO frequency, i.e., 2 x 9.5 GHz - 1 GHz. This is fairly close to the IF frequency of 20.5 GHz.
• a common method to reduce the spurious output of the mixer while retaining the desired IF signal is to exclude the unwanted frequencies through the use of high- or low- pass filters, either alone or together as band-pass or notch filters, that filter out some of the spurs but let the desired frequency pass.
• a mixer circuit comprises a first component configured to receive a first input signal having a first frequency of at least one gigahertz (GHz) and to output two output signals at the first frequency that are 180 degrees out of phase with respect to each other.
• the circuit further comprises first and second mixer elements each connected with the first component and configured to each receive a respective one of the output signals from it, to each receive a second input signal having a second frequency of at least one gigahertz and to each mix the respective output signal with the second input signal so as to derive respective mixer output signals.
• Each of the mixer output signals includes a primary output signal at a third frequency that is a sum or a difference of the first and second frequencies, and at least one spur signal that is a harmonic of the first or second input signal, with either the primary output signals or the spur signals are 180 degrees out of phase with respect to each other.
• a signal combining component is connected with the first and second mixer elements and configured to receive and combine the mixer output signals so as to produce a combined output signal comprising the primary output signal, and in which the spur signals partially or totally cancel each other.
• a method of generating a signal comprises supplying a first signal having a first frequency above 1 GHz, and processing the first signal so as to produce two first output signals that are 180 degrees out of phase relative to each other.
• the method further comprises supplying a second signal having a second frequency above 1 GHz, and mixing each of the first output signals with the second signal in respective mixers so as to produce two mixer product signals.
• the mixer product signals are combined such that the spur signals substantially cancel each other out and so as to yield a combined signal comprising a combination of the primary output signals.
• a telecommunication system comprises a source of radio-frequency (RF) signal and a source of local-oscillator (LO) signal, both of the signals having respective frequencies in the gigahertz frequency range.
• a light-weight mixer circuit is supported within a housing and configured for use on a satellite in space.
• the mixer circuit comprises a thin-film ceramic substrate.
• a thin film RF balun is on the substrate and has an RF signal input connected with the source of the RF signal.
• the RF balun has first and second RF signal outputs transmitting first and second RF output signals respectively, the second RF output signal being substantially 180 degrees out of phase with respect to the first RF output signal.
• the first and second RF output signals have substantially equal amplitudes.
• First and second thin-film mixer elements are also on the substrate.
• Each mixer element comprises a balanced mixer using a beam lead quad diode formed on the substrate and has two mixer inputs and one mixer output.
• Each mixer element has one of the mixer inputs thereof connected with a respective RF signal output and receiving the respective RF output signal from it.
• a thin-film LO transmission structure on the substrate provides electrical communication between the source of the LO signal and each of the mixer elements, receiving the LO signal and transmitting the LO signal as first and second LO input signals to the other of the inputs of the first and second mixers respectively .
• the LO transmission structure including an LO phase adjuster element adjustable so that the first and second signal inputs are substantially in phase with each other at the inputs of the mixer elements.
• the first and second mixer elements provide first and second mixing output signals, respectively, at their mixer outputs.
• the first and second mixing output signals include mixer product signals that include an IF signal with a frequency substantially equal to a difference between the frequency of the LO signal and the frequency of the RF signal frequency, and a spur signal having a frequency that is an integral multiple of the frequency of the LO signal.
• the IF signal of the first mixing output signal at the first mixer output is substantially 180 degrees out of phase with the IF signal of the second mixing output signal at the second mixer output
• the spur signal of the first mixing output signal at the first mixer output is substantially in phase with the spur signal of the second mixing output signal at the second mixer output.
• a thin film output balun is supported on the substrate and has an output and two inputs. Each of the inputs is connected with a respective mixer output and receives the respective mixer output signal from it.
• the output balun produces a shifted mixer output signal from one of the mixing signal outputs.
• the IF signal in the shifted signal is substantially in phase with the IF signal of the other of the mixer output signals and the spur signal in the shifted signal is substantially 180 degrees out of phase with the spur signal of the other of the mixer output signals.
• the output balun combines the shifted mixing signal output with the other of the mixing output signals so as to produce a circuit output signal wherein the spur signals substantially cancel each other out and the IF signals are combined substantially in phase.
• the circuit output signal is transmitted via the output of the output balun.
• the circuit is of " thin-film construction which possesses a multilayer structure.
• This embodiment has a support substrate, with no air gap below it.
• the mixing elements may be built all on the top side of the substrate without cavities beneath the substrate.
• the signal paths created for each signal in the circuit are chosen such that the circuit achieves maximum attenuation of the undesired harmonics of the LO source in the IF output.
• the construction is easily modeled, allowing for predictable performance, and it is also scalable to integrated circuit materials. This modeling can be performed using existing non-linear circuit software.
• the invention is therefore easily tuned to various frequencies.
• the invention may be used in satellite communications applications on several commonly used frequency channels such as, e.g., the KA, K, and KU bands.
• frequency channels such as, e.g., the KA, K, and KU bands.
• FIG. 1 shows a diagram illustrating a communications satellite orbiting the Earth and both receiving and transmitting radio signals to and from ground stations;
• FIG. 2 is a diagram of the general functional circuitry of a telecommunications satellite such as in FIG. 1 ;
• FIG. 3 is a diagram of a mixing circuit according to the invention.
• FIG 4 is a graph of exemplary inputs and outputs of mixers according to the invention.
• FIG. 5 is a diagram showing the pattern of thin-layered materials on a substrate for a mixer circuit according to the invention.
• the lightweight mixer design described here is particularly applicable to circuitry used in satellites to process high-frequency wireless radio signals. Weight is a particular concern in orbital devices, due to the high cost of launch based on weight. An exemplary system is therefore shown herein on a satellite, although it will be understood that the invention may have a wide range of terrestrial uses as well.
• a satellite 100 is shown in orbit above the Earth 200 (or potentially some other celestial body).
• the satellite 100 is provided with antennae 101 and 102.
• antenna 101 receives one or more wireless radio signals indicated generally at 104 from an earth station indicated at A.
• These radio signals are normally high-frequency RF signals, i.e., with a frequency of 10 to 50 GHz, and may be television, audio, telephonic, data or electronic command communications to the satellite, or virtually any kind of communication signal, all of which are well known in the art.
• Satellite 100 also transmits a wireless high-frequency RF signal 105 back to earth station B via antenna 102.
• the transmitted signals may also be any type of transmission or broadcast, such as a transmission of video from a camera on the satellite.
• the satellite 100 is a communications satellite that functions as a "bent pipe" system, i.e., the satellite receives video, audio or data content via the upload signals 104, does some amplification, encryption, or other on-board processing, in the satellite's internal circuitry, and then transmits the content back to Earth in signals 105, which can be at a frequency that is the same as or different from the frequency of signals 104.
• the satellite 100 has internal circuitry that receives and processes the radio signals 104 and otherwise controls the operation of the satellite.
• the on-board circuitry is preferably in a hermetically sealed environment inside a carrier or protective case inside the satellite housing 107.
• the housing 107 is preferably of stainless steel and shields the internal components of the satellite from radiation and other potentially deleterious influences found in space.
• the satellite circuitry may be hardened by methods well-known in the art to prevent damage to the circuitry by radiation outside the Earth's atmosphere.
• FIG. 2 shows a schematic diagram of the general internal operation of the satellite 100.
• Receiver antenna circuitry 3 is connected with antenna 101 and receives the radio signal over a conductor linking them.
• Receiver antenna circuitry 3 transmits a raw received RF signal along a conductor to incoming signal process circuit 5, which converts the RF signal to a different, usually lower, frequency for processing on the satellite.
• incoming signal process circuit 5 which converts the RF signal to a different, usually lower, frequency for processing on the satellite.
• down-conversion allows for easier manipulation, amplification or other processing of the content of the RF signal than at the high frequency at which it is received.
• the converted RF signal is transmitted by conductor to the internal satellite circuitry 7 for any kind of processing in accord with the function of the satellite, e.g., as data, as commands for control of the satellite 100 or as content re-transmission back to Earth.
• the program content in the RF signal may be amplified and then possibly encrypted to yield a processed signal for transmission.
• the outgoing signal or signals generated by the internal satellite electronics 7 are transmitted over an electrical conductor to outgoing signal process circuit 9. This circuitry 9 changes the frequency of the signal from internal electronics 7 to a transmission signal at a transmission frequency, usually higher than the incoming frequency.
• the transmission signal is sent by an electrical conductor to transmitting antenna circuitry 1 1 , which wirelessly transmits it via antenna 102 to a receiver or receivers on Earth.
• FIG. 3 is a more detailed block diagram of a circuit according to an aspect of the invention. This circuit is used in down-conversion circuitry of incoming process circuit 5 or in the outgoing signal process circuit 9.
• a radio frequency (RF) signal source 13 e.g., the receiver antenna 101 and associated circuitry 103, is connected to an input of an input balun 15 and supplies an RF signal to it.
• the input balun 15 has two outputs 17 and 19. Internally the balun 15 splits the RF signal.
• balun 15 outputs a first RF signal that has a phase shift ⁇ of zero (0) degrees, and at output 19, balun 15 outputs a second RF signal that has been delayed or otherwise processed so as to impart to it a 180-degree phase shift ⁇ .
• the two RF signals produced are therefore 180 degrees out-of-phase, or antiphase, relative to each other.
• a local oscillator (LO) 21 provides a -sinusoidal local-oscillator signal LO to the circuit on conductor 23, which has a simple branch into two conductors 25 and 27, which both carry a respective split LO signal. Both of the LO signals have a phase shift ⁇ of zero degrees, i.e., no phase shift, and are perfectly in phase with each other.
• the frequencies of the LO and RF signals are above 1 GHz.
• the circuit shown is used with Ka band (26.5 to 40 GHz signal) downconverters and receivers. It is also scalable to other frequency applications, such as K band (20 to 40 GHz) or K u band (12 to 18 GHz) applications.
• the RF signal preferably has a frequency in the range from 10 to 40 GHz, and most preferably a frequency of approximately 30 GHz
• the LO signal has a frequency in the range from 5 to 20 GHz, and most preferably a frequency of approximately 9.5 GHz.
• Mixer element 1 indicated at 31, has two inputs. One of the inputs is connected with line 1 and receives the first RF signal from it with zero-degrees phase shift ⁇ . The other input is connected with line 25 and receives one of the LO signals from it, also with zero- degrees phase shift ⁇ .
• Mixer element 2, indicated at 32 has two inputs as well. One of these inputs is connected with line 19 and receives the second RF signal from it with 180-degrees phase shift ⁇ , and the other input is connected with line 27 and receives from it the other LO signal with zero-degrees phase shift ⁇ .
• the mixer elements 31 and 32 constitute a 180 degree balanced set of mixers, and both have essentially identical configurations as will be described below.
• the mixer elements 31 and 32 mix the RF and LO signals supplied to them at the inputs and produce an IF signal provided at the respective mixer outputs 33 or 35.
• the mixer output signals each comprise a number of combined signals, including an IF signal that has a frequency that is the difference or the sum of the frequencies of the RF and LO signals. Also, a number of additional signals with other frequencies are typically produced by the mixing process and are present in the mixer output signals with the IF signal. These signals include spur signals formed as second and higher-order harmonics of the LO or RF input signals.
• FIG. 4 illustrates some of the signals applied to or produced by the mixer elements 31 and 32 where the circuit is used to down-convert 30 GHz RF signal 201 to a lower frequency by mixing with a 9.5 GHz LO signal 202.
• the mixer output signal includes the desired output signal, IF signal 203, which has a frequency of 20.5 GHz.
• the mixer output signal also includes spurs and noise, including spur signal 204, which is the second order harmonic of the LO signal input to the mixer, with a frequency of 2 * 9.5 GHz ⁇ 19 GHz, and disagreeably close to the desired IF signal at 20.5 GHz.
• the mixer elements 31 and 32 both produce the IF signal 203 and the second LO harmonic 2*LO spur signal 204 in their respective outputs. However, because the mixer elements 31 and 32 receive the respective RF input signals 180-degrees out of phase with each other, the resulting IF signals in the two mixer output signals are also 180-degrees out of phase to each other. In contrast, the LO signals received by the mixer elements 31 and 32 are in-phase with each other, i.e., zero degrees out-of-phase and the 2*LO second harmonic spur signals 204 are also in-phase with each other in the two mixer output signals. [0049] This difference in phase-shift of the desired IF signal and the second LO harmonic spur signal allows for removal of the spur signal.
• balun 37 This is accomplished by supplying the mixer output signals along conductors 33 and 35 to two inputs of output balun 37, which is configured to give a phase shift of 180 degrees to one of the signals at one of its inputs, and then to combine that phase-shifted signal with the signal from the other input.
• the combined-signal result is transmitted at the single output of balun 37.
• the input signals to the balun 37 in the circuit of FIG. 3 include the IF signals in antiphase and the second spur signals in phase.
• the IF signals are placed in phase and the spur signals are put 180-degrees out of phase.
• the out-of-phase spur signals partly or totally cancel each other out. Any of the other noise or spur signals in the mixer output signals that are in-phase between the two mixer output signals (e.g., higher order even harmonics of the LO signal) will also cancel each other out in balun 37.
• the IF signals are 180 degrees out of phase in the mixer output signals, so when one IF signal is phase-shifted 180 degrees and the two signals are combined, the IF signals are combined in phase, resulting in a strong IF signal.
• a final balun output signal, including the IF signal, is transmitted by conductor to subsequent processing of the IF signal by circuitry on the satellite, or to be transmitted via an antenna, generally indicated at 39.
• the circuit of the invention is scalable to frequencies other than the ranges of frequencies described herein. This circuit is beneficial for eliminating spur signals without relying on heavy filters, and with a greater degree of precision. For example, it is possible to use the present circuit where the LO signal frequency is 9.8 GHz and the RF signal frequency is 30 GHz. The resulting IF signal frequency is 20.2 GHz, while the second LO harmonic spur signal has a frequency of 19,6 GHz, a separation of only 0.6 GHz, which would be very difficult to carve out with a filter. Nonetheless, the phase-shifted mixing circuit described here allows for effective mixing of the signals even where the harmonic spur frequency and the IF signal frequency are separated by as little as 0.5 or 0.6 GHz, [0053] FIG. 5 is a detailed plan view of an embodiment of the mixer circuit that has been described more generally above. The baluns 15 and 37 and the mixer elements 31 and 32 are generally indicated by the same reference numbers as in FIG. 3, as are the conductors or contacts identified in FIG. 3.
• the circuit shown is manufactured using a multi-layer thin-film approach in which a layered material is etched or otherwise selectively removed so as to form a lightweight circuit.
• the process and materials used are available from the company Applied Thin-Film Products, with a place of business at 3439 Edison Way, Fremont, CA 94538, and a website at www.thinfilm.com.
• the use of a multilayer structure as shown allows the use of a thick support substrate, with no air gap below it, which is different from typical balanced mixer designs.
• the circuit may be a single component as shown, or may be part of a larger circuit.
• the circuit can also be manufactured using microwave integrated circuit technologies.
• the circuit 41 is supported on a ceramic substrate sheet 43, preferably of a consistent thickness.
• the substrate material is typically polished alumina, with a dielectric constant of 9.9.
• the RF input 13 and the LO input 21 are thin film gold transmission lines.
• the RF signal input 13 connects with the input of input 180° balun 15.
• Input balun 15 is of known design, and is comprised of gold film conductors overlying a layer of polyimide material 45 on the substrate 43.
• Input balun 15 also has ground connections 47 that extend through the substrate 43 to contact ground on the other side of the substrate 43.
• Input balun 15 splits the incoming RF signal and produces balanced output such that the split RF signals are transmitted to respective gold-film lines 17 and 19, with the RF signal on line 17 having a 180 degree phase shift, as described above.
• the balun 21 is constructed to maximize its performance at a set RF frequency or frequency range, and its design may include structure that substantially prevents impedance from interfering with transmission of the RF signal.
• the balun 15 in the embodiment shown can split and phase shift RF signals in a frequency range of 23 to 34 GHz, appropriate in the present embodiment configured for use with an RF with a frequency of 30 GHz.
• the design of course can be modified for different RF frequencies if appropriate.
• LO signal input contact 21 connects to gold-film line 23, which leads to an LO signal splitting structure 49, also of gold film.
• Splitting structure 49 includes adjustment structures 51 and 53, which may be used to adjust the precise distance that the LO signal must travel to the mixer elements 31 and 32.
• a resistor 55 bridges the split LO signal lines 25 and 27 and balances the split signals on lines 25 and 27.
• Line 25 proceeds via jumper 57 to mixer element 31 and line 27 proceeds to mixer element 32, passing through another adjustment structure 59, which provides for smaller phase adjustment than adjustment structures 51 and 53. Preferably this is done to ensure that the LO signals are configured to arrive at the mixers 31 and 32 substantially in phase with each other,
• Mixer elements 31 and 32 are essentially identical configurations.
• the mixer structure is effectively all on the upper side of the substrate 43, not suspended, without a cavity in the structure.
• Each mixer 31 or 32 comprises a mixer input balun 61 connecting with a diode 63,
• Each of the mixer input baluns 61 has a single input connected with a respective RF signal line 17 or 19.
• the mixer input baluns 61 are also of gold film overhang a layer of polyimide material.
• the mixer input baluns 61 have access to ground through vias 69, which extend through to the other side of the substrate 43 to contact ground,
• Diodes 63 are chips inserted into the circuit 41.
• the diodes 63 are commercially available crossover quad diodes connected between the mixer input baluns 61 to respective LO/IF diplexer baluns 65 through gold-film conductors 71.
• LO signal lines 25 and 27 also each connect across a resistor 77 with respective diplexer baluns 65 and supply the LO signals thereto. Resistors 77 make the diplexer baluns 65 less sensitive to the drive level of the LO signals.
• the LO/IF diplexer baluns 65 are also formed of gold film on a polyimide layer 73, and vias 75 extend through the substrate 43 and provide connection to ground for the baluns 65.
• the diplexer baluns 65 each has a balun loop 79 that is sized to correspond to the diode 63 configuration and parameters, as is well known in the art.
• the mixer output signals are each transmitted to respective outputs of the diplexer baluns 65 to gold-film lines 33 and 35. As described above, the IF signals in these mixer output signals are out of phase relative to each other, and the second LO harmonic spur signals in the two mixer output signals are in phase relative to each other.
• Balun 37 is also formed of gold film on a polyimide layer 81, and it has vias 83 to ground extending through the substrate 43. As described previously, the balun 37 introduces a 180 degree phase shift to the first mixer output signal, making the spur signals out-of- phase, and the two mixer output signals are then combined so that the spur signals cancel each other without affecting the IF signals.
• the output balun 37 is configured in the present embodiment to process signals that fall in the frequency range of 16 to 24 GHz, suitable for, e.g., an IF frequency of 20.5 GHz and a second LO harmonic of 19 GHz, as has been discussed herein.
• Output balun 37 transmits the signal that is derived from combining the mixer output signals along conductor 85 to the IF contact 39, where the circuit 41 connects with other electronics, not shown, that process the IF signal or transmit it wirelessly, as has been described above.
• mixer circuits are made with metal conductor patterns on both sides of a relatively thin substrate, with coupling through the substrate.
• the influence of ground on, e.g., balun structures of the underside of the circuit is prevented by providing a separating cavity between ground and the metal pattern on the substrate.
• the coupling of the gold conductors in the balun or mixer structures takes place in the polyimide layer, which is very thin, e.g., 4 microns to 5 microns thick, preferably about 4.5 microns thick.
• the substrate used in the present design is a thicker substrate, e.g., 10 to 20 times thicker than usual, e.g., 200 to 300 microns thick, most preferably about 254 microns thick. This larger thickness separates the ground on one side of the substrate from the circuitry on the other side, eliminating the need for a cavity or air clearance, with the result that the structure is markedly stronger,
• the mixer circuit described herein can be used in either upconversion or
• circuit may be used in combination with other equipment, e.g. where additional components receive an RF signal from an antenna, modify the signal received, and then pass the modified signal to the RF port of a circuit of the present design.
• additional equipment may receive the IF signal output and modify it before transmission, e.g. by amplification of the signal with an electronic amplifier.
• the present invention is agnostic as to whether the RF signal is broadcast and later received via antenna, if it exists entirely within a contained system and is never transmitted wirelessly before or after it is processed by a circuit or circuits as herein described, or if it undergoes one or more transformation steps before or after mixing by a circuit as described.
• the RF signal may contain additional frequencies in some instances, and may use amplitude or frequency modulation, and may otherwise vary widely in form.
• the present invention may be practiced in several other variations.
• the circuit may be adapted to their use by providing additional parallel paths of RF and LO signals to the additional mixing elements, and then from the mixing elements to the final output balun.
• the signals provided to the various mixer elements are then adjusted such that the vector sum of the mixer products at the output balun results in substantial cancellation of the LO and 2*LO output signals, while retaining the desired IF output signal.
• two intersecting electrical paths in the circuit may avoid electrical contact by the use of jumpers, such as ribbon jumper 57 or 87,

Landscapes

• Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
• Power Engineering (AREA)
• Transceivers (AREA)
• Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
• Astronomy & Astrophysics (AREA)
• Aviation & Aerospace Engineering (AREA)
• General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
• Computer Networks & Wireless Communication (AREA)
• Signal Processing (AREA)

Priority Applications (3)

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Publications (1)

Family

ID=51529223

Family Applications (1)

Country Status (5)

Families Citing this family (5)

Citations (3)

Family Cites Families (8)

• 2013
  • 2013-03-15 US US13/840,816 patent/US20140273814A1/en not_active Abandoned
• 2014
  • 2014-03-14 JP JP2016502719A patent/JP2016516359A/ja active Pending
  • 2014-03-14 EP EP14765202.8A patent/EP2973851A4/en not_active Withdrawn
  • 2014-03-14 CA CA2907223A patent/CA2907223A1/en not_active Abandoned
  • 2014-03-14 WO PCT/US2014/028158 patent/WO2014143956A1/en not_active Ceased

Patent Citations (3)

Non-Patent Citations (1)

Also Published As

Similar Documents

Legal Events