Classifications

• • F—MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
  • F17—STORING OR DISTRIBUTING GASES OR LIQUIDS
  • F17D—PIPE-LINE SYSTEMS; PIPE-LINES
  • F17D3/00—Arrangements for supervising or controlling working operations
• • G—PHYSICS
  • G01—MEASURING; TESTING
  • G01N—INVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
  • G01N30/00—Investigating or analysing materials by separation into components using adsorption, absorption or similar phenomena or using ion-exchange, e.g. chromatography or field flow fractionation
  • G01N30/02—Column chromatography
  • G01N30/26—Conditioning of the fluid carrier; Flow patterns
  • G01N30/28—Control of physical parameters of the fluid carrier
  • G01N30/34—Control of physical parameters of the fluid carrier of fluid composition, e.g. gradient
• • G—PHYSICS
  • G05—CONTROLLING; REGULATING
  • G05D—SYSTEMS FOR CONTROLLING OR REGULATING NON-ELECTRIC VARIABLES
  • G05D21/00—Control of chemical or physico-chemical variables, e.g. pH value
  • G05D21/02—Control of chemical or physico-chemical variables, e.g. pH value characterised by the use of electric means
• • Y—GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
  • Y10—TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC
  • Y10T—TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER US CLASSIFICATION
  • Y10T137/00—Fluid handling
  • Y10T137/0318—Processes
  • Y10T137/0324—With control of flow by a condition or characteristic of a fluid
  • Y10T137/0329—Mixing of plural fluids of diverse characteristics or conditions

Definitions

• the present invention relates to the preparation of liquid mixtures, and more particularly to the preparation of mixed liquid flows, such as buffer flows, having predefined characteristics.
• liquids of precisely known composition and/or other characteristics such as pH, ionic strength, viscosity, density etc. It is further not uncommon that the composition of the liquid should not only be at each moment precisely known and controlled, but also should vary with time in a precise and controlled manner.
• Such liquids are usually obtained by mixing or blending two or more liquids with each other, typically using a blending system, usually an on-site blending system, which may provide for both isocratic and gradient blending modes (step gradient and linear gradient).
• composition of liquids is of utmost importance is in the field of liquid chromatography, when buffers having a specified pH and optionally also ionic strength are utilized, the pH and ionic strength of the eluent being the two most important parameters that control selectivity of protein separations in
• Blending systems for delivery on-line of a desired liquid composition are typically based on two different approaches, i.e. (i) use of sensor feedback control of measured liquid parameters to set the proportions of liquid components giving the desired composition, and (ii) flow feedback control, wherein a recipe or formula for the mixing ratios of the liquid components to obtain the desired liquid composition are
• conductivity of the recirculated solution is sensed by a conductivity sensor
• NIR near infrared
• a different approach to liquid blending is to determine the exact relative component proportions or ratios in which liquids are to be blended to obtain a desired liquid mixture having the pre-defined characteristics, typically using an appropriate algorithm, and then produce a liquid mixture flow by feeding the different liquids by a metering system in the predetermined ratios.
• an apparatus for liquid chromatography comprises an on-line metering device capable of feeding into a chromatographic separation device an eluent of one or more buffering species, an acid or a base, optionally a salt, and a solvent.
• the metering device calculates, by the use of an approximation of the Debye-Huckel equation, the relative proportions of the components required to obtain an eluent of a selected pH at a given salt concentration. This is accomplished by an iterative procedure where the different components are concomitantly varied in such a way as to take into account the interrelationship of the pH and the ionic strength in the liquid mixture.
• a mixer control unit is provided to control the relative component proportions using the equation of Debye- Huckel, wherein the ion size a in the Debye-Huckel equation is determined as the weighted mean ion size of all species contributing to the ionic strength of the liquid mixture, wherein the ionic strength of each species is used as weighting parameter.
• the exact composition is first calculated and the liquid mixture, typically a buffer, is subsequently prepared in a single step.
• the buffer definition is obtained in-line in a continuous process.
• liquid blending method which provides a mixed liquid flow, typically a buffer flow, having desired characteristics by mixing at least three different liquid flows, wherein two (or more) of the liquids have different values of a desired property and the proportions of which are varied to obtain the desired property.
• a buffer flow for example, having predetermined buffer
• concentration and pH and optionally also conductivity and/ or salt concentration, or pH and conductivity may be obtained by mixing flows of buffer components, solvent (typically water), and optionally salt.
• a basic feature of the method when preparing, for instance, a buffer flow having a desired pH and buffer concentration, resides in first preparing a buffer flow having the desired buffer concentration using initial preselected mutual proportions of basic and acidic buffer component flows (typically of respective stock concentrations), and then adjusting the pH to the desired pH value by varying the buffer component flows, preferably by while simultaneously varying the other liquid flow or flows to maintain the buffer concentration constant.
• the method of the invention is, however, not restricted to preparing buffer flows, but a variety of other mixed liquid flows may be prepared.
• the predetermined characteristics or properties are not limited to pH and buffer concentration.
• the present invention therefore provides a method of preparing a mixed liquid flow having predetermined characteristics, including a predetermined value of a first property and a predetermined value of a second property, comprising the steps of:
• step e) above the liquid flows of the first and second sets may be varied
• the first and second properties are typically selected from pH, conductivity, concentration and absorbance.
• the first property of the first and second sets of liquid flows generally is a true property of the liquids, excluding liquids devoid of the property, i.e. the property values are different from zero.
• a constant flow rate of the mixed liquid flow is maintained by variation of at least one liquid flow of the third set.
• the solvent is typically an aqueous liquid, preferably water, it may also be another liquid, such as an organic liquid or liquids.
• the mixed liquid flow is typically a buffer flow.
• each liquid flow of the first set contains at least one basic buffer component and each liquid flow of the second set of liquid flows contains at least one acidic buffer component, or vice versa.
• at least one basic buffer component is replaced by a strong base, or at least one acidic buffer component is replaced by a strong acid.
• buffer component is to be interpreted in a broad sense, including any substance having buffering properties.
• a liquid flow may contain more than one buffer component in order to prepare a buffer mixture, for example.
• a buffer mixture may, of course, also be prepared by mixing two or more liquid flows each containing a single buffer component.
• the first property is pH and the second property is buffer concentration.
• Step e) of the method above then comprises varying the at least one of the liquid flows of the first and second sets to adjust the pH to its predetermined value.
• the first property is a property other than pH, typically
• Step e) of the method then comprises varying the at least one of the liquid flows of the first and second sets to adjust the first property to its predetermined value.
• the first property is pH and the second property is a property other than buffer concentration and pH, typically conductivity or absorbance.
• Step e) of the method then comprises varying the at least one of the liquid flows of the first and second sets to adjust the pH and the second property to their predetermined values.
• pH may also be determined by an indirect method.
• An exemplary such indirect method comprises measuring conductivity as described in Swedish patent application number 1051344-8, filed on December 17, 2010 (the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference herein). That document describes prediction of the conductivity of a liquid solution, such as a buffer by solving the exact concentrations of the different ions present in solution including the equilibrium concentration of each of the charged species of a weak electrolyte, determining the molar conductivity of each of the charged species, calculating the corresponding conductivities, and summing up all the individual conductivities to obtain the total conductivity of the liquid mixture.
• a corresponding device for measuring pH comprises a conductivity sensor and means for calculating pH from measured conductivity using the conductivity prediction steps in a backwards calculation mode.
• Determination of the buffer concentration of the mixed liquid flow may be performed by measuring conductivity or measuring absorbance by a spectroscopic method, preferably (but not limited to) UV or NIR spectroscopy.
• the buffer concentration of the mixed liquid flow is determined by measuring the flow rates of the liquid flows containing buffer components (including strong acid or base), and calculating the buffer concentration from known (stock) concentrations of the respective liquid flows.
• determination of buffer concentration comprises measuring the conductivity or measuring absorbance by a spectroscopic method, preferably (but not limited to) UV or NIR spectroscopy on each of the liquid flows of the first and second sets, and determining from the measurements on the different liquid flows the buffer concentration of the mixed liquid flow.
• a spectroscopic method preferably (but not limited to) UV or NIR spectroscopy
• liquid flows of the first set and the liquid flows of the second set are combined prior to being combined with the third set of liquid flows.
• the desired characteristics of the mixed liquid flow may, however, include one or more further desired properties in addition to the above-mentioned first and second properties and/ or the method may include the provision of a fourth and, optionally, more sets of liquid flows.
• the method may comprise providing a fourth set of liquid flows each containing at least one additive, combining the fourth set of liquid flows with the first, second and third sets of liquid flows, and regulating the fourth liquid flow or flows of the fourth set to adjust the at least third property to its predetermined value or values.
• a typical additive is a non-buffering salt, but other additives, such as detergents, may optionally also be provided.
• the first property is pH
• the second property is buffer concentration
• the third property is additive concentration, preferably salt concentration.
• the first property is pH
• the second property is buffer
• concentration and the third property is conductivity or absorbance.
• the first property is pH
• the second property is conductivity
• the third property is selected from additive concentration, conductivity and absorbance.
• the first and second sets of liquid flows and the third set of liquid flows are combined prior to being combined with the fourth set of liquid flows.
• the different predetermined property values of the mixed liquid flow may be measured and/ or calculated.
• the properties of the mixed liquid flow are measured.
• a variant of carrying out the method of the invention comprises providing a formula of a set of different liquid flows for obtaining the mixed liquid flow having the
• Another method variant comprises measuring the properties of the mixed liquid flows while varying the different liquid flows to adjust the properties to their predetermined values, determining the required liquid flows, and then controlling the different liquid flows by flow feedback.
• Yet another method variant comprises providing a formula of a set of different liquid flows for obtaining the mixed liquid flow having the predetermined characteristics, and controlling the different liquid flows by flow-feedback according to the formula, and then fine-adjusting the different liquid flows by measuring the properties of the mixed liquid flow while varying the different liquid flows to adjust the respective properties to their predetermined values.
• Still another method variant comprises measuring the properties of the mixed liquid flow while varying the different liquid flows to adjust the respective properties to their predetermined values, determining a formula of liquid flows (e.g. by using a so-called analogy machine) for obtaining the mixed liquid flow having the predetermined characteristics, and then controlling the different liquid flows by flow-feedback according to the formula.
• the different liquid flows are typically controlled by means of pumps and/or valves.
• a first set of measured properties may be used to obtain the mixed liquid flow having the predetermined characteristics, while a second set of measured properties may be used for verification.
• a property of the mixed liquid flow may be determined by measuring an alternative property.
• the liquid flows are first varied to a set-point for the property by feedback from measuring one of the property and the alternative property.
• the liquid flows are then varied to the set-point by feedback from measuring the other of the property and the alternative property.
• the one of the property and the alternative property that gives the fastest feedback is used first to quickly reach a set-point, and the other (more accurate) property is then used for fine adjustment to the set-point.
• the method may additionally comprise measuring characteristics of one or more of the first, second, third and fourth liquid flows to aid in ensuring the desired characteristics of the mixed liquid flow.
• alarm limits are provided for at least some of the predetermined characteristics of the mixed liquid flow to permit only the correct mixed liquid to leave the system.
• the invention is, however, not limited to the preparation of buffer flows, but other types of liquid mixtures or blends may be prepared by the method.
• various types of alcohol mixtures may be prepared which have, for instance, predetermined fatty properties.
• the above-mentioned first set of liquid flows may then comprise a first alcohol having a first fatty property value, and the above- mentioned second set of liquid flows may comprise an alcohol having a second fatty property value, wherein mixing of the two alcohols in proper proportions will give the desired fatty value of the alcohol mixture.
• a method of preparing a buffer flow having a predetermined buffer concentration and a predetermined pH comprising the steps of:
• predetermined buffer concentration by varying the third liquid flow.
• varying the first and second liquid flows maintains a constant delivery rate of buffer to the combined liquid flow, and the combined liquid flow (i.e. the total buffer flow) is kept constant by varying the third liquid flow.
• the desired buffer flow also has a predetermined concentration of salt.
• the method further comprises, between method steps d) and e) above, the step of providing a fourth liquid flow containing salt of stock concentration, combining the fourth liquid flow with the first, second and third flows to provide said combined liquid flow, and regulating the proportion of the fourth liquid flow to obtain said predetermined salt concentration in the combined liquid flow, while maintaining the combined liquid flow constant by varying the third liquid flow.
• the desired buffer flow also has a predetermined concentration of salt.
• the method further comprises, between method steps d) and e) above, the step of providing a fourth liquid flow containing salt of stock concentration, combining the fourth liquid flow with the first, second and third flows to provide said combined liquid flow, and regulating the proportion of the fourth liquid flow to obtain said predetermined salt concentration in the combined liquid flow, while maintaining the combined liquid flow constant by varying the third liquid flow.
• the method further comprises, between method steps d) and e) above, the step of providing a fourth liquid flow containing salt of stock concentration, combining the fourth liquid flow with the first, second and third liquid flows to provide said combined liquid flow, and regulating the proportion of the fourth liquid flow to obtain said predetermined conductivity of the combined liquid flow, while maintaining the combined liquid flow constant by varying the third liquid flow.
• the desired buffer flow has a predetermined pH but a predetermined conductivity rather than buffer concentration.
• the method comprises selecting an initial buffer concentration, and adjusting the pH as well as the conductivity of the combined liquid so that the predetermined pH and conductivity are obtained.
• the pH and conductivity adjustments may be performed sequentially (and optionally repeated) or simultaneously.
• such a variant comprises the steps of:
• the method may conveniently be implemented by software run on an electrical data processing device, such as a computer.
• an electrical data processing device such as a computer.
• Such software may be provided to the computer on any suitable computer-readable medium, including a record medium, a read-only memory, or an electrical or optical signal which may be conveyed via electrical or optical cable or by radio or other means.
• Another aspect of the invention therefore relates to a computer program product comprising instructions for causing a computer to perform the method steps of any one of the above-mentioned method variants.
• Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of a liquid blending system which may be used in the method of the present invention.
• Figure 2 is a set of graphs showing the variation of the total flow, pH, and
• Figure 3 shows two diagrams indicating the variation of process parameters during a blending operation for the preparation of salt gradients using two different strategies.
• Figure 4 shows two diagrams indicating the variation of process parameters during a blending operation using constant buffer concentration (top) and pH gradient
• the present invention relates to an improved method of producing a mixed liquid flow having predetermined characteristics.
• the mixed liquid flow is typically a buffer liquid flow having, for example, predefined buffer
• a liquid flow having the predefined buffer concentration is first set using initial calculated proportions of buffer component flows of stock concentration and an aqueous flow. If required, salt is then added by a separate flow, the predefined buffer concentration being maintained by regulating the aqueous flow to keep the total buffer flow constant. Finally, the pH of the buffer flow is adjusted to the predefined pH by regulating the mutual buffer component flow proportions while regulating the other liquid flow or flows to maintain the predefined buffer
• the final ratios are obtained automatically when the system reaches steady state and the mixing ratios can instead be read from the system which makes the buffer mixtures at the predefined pH, buffer concentration and conductivity (or salt concentration), when required. In this way, the correct buffer concentration will be obtained even if salt is used in the mixture.
• an equation for the conservation of mass is used to calculate how much the flow corresponding to one of the buffer components should be increased when the other component is decreased (or kept constant) upon a signal from the controlling pH sensor.
• the pH value describes the degree of acidity in a solution and is defined as the negative logarithm of the activity of hydrogen ions (or protons). Most biological processes are affected by pH changes, the reason being that pH affects the
• pH is a crucial parameter for the interaction between monoclonal antibodies and protein A chromatographic media.
• the buffer is a kind of molecule that is able to accept or donate hydrogen ion. By adding a large number of such molecules to a solution, pH control can be attained by effectively reducing the rate of pH change as a function of the amount of hydrogen or hydroxyl ions. This "buffer capacity" is proportional to the buffer concentration. It is also possible to control pH by deliberate combination of the buffer molecule in two different protonation states. Since macroscopic chemical reagents must be electrically neutral, those that work as buffers can be forced to different protonation states by the presence of the appropriate amount of counter ions. This may, for example, be obtained by combining a "weak acid” with a corresponding weak base. For environmental or human safety reasons, this is preferable to combining the weak acid with a strong base (like NaOH) , or a weak base with a strong acid (like HC1).
• a key parameter for a buffer substance is its pK a value which is the pH value at which 50% of the buffer molecules are in each of two different protonation states.
• Some buffer substances like phosphate and citrate have several pK a values (polyprotic buffers).
• the pK a values of a substance can shift dramatically when the conductivity increases, for instance by adding salt to the buffer solution. The knowledge of the magnitude of such shifts for different buffer systems at different salt concentrations can be used for accurate pH control.
• buffer substances are weak electrolytes there is no simple model that can relate the conductivity as a function of the concentration. Contributions to the conductivity of a buffer arise from different components which correspond to different protonation steps. The exact proportions of the different states depend upon the equilibrium and thus vary with the pH etc. An important contribution to the conductivity comes from strong electrolytes, for instance Na + and CI- ions, especially at higher salt
• Conductivity control is important because the conductivity (or the ionic strength) also can effect intermolecular interactions and can therefore be used to control the chromatographic processes for bio-pharmaceutical production, especially such using ion exchange chromatography or hydrophobic interaction
• the buffer concentration is important mainly because of two major reasons. The main reason is related to the circumstance that the buffer capacity is proportional to the buffer concentration. Understanding the dependence of the buffer capacity on the buffer composition is of outmost value since use of buffers with too low buffer capacity during purification can lead to low process robustness and poor yields.
• the buffering capacity of a particular system is itself sensitive to mainly two factors: the pK a value of the buffering substance is one of them and the buffer concentration the other. As a rule of thumb the pH will be stable in a symmetric interval around the pK a value. However the width of the interval with good buffer capacity is dependent on the buffer concentration with the relation the higher the buffer concentration the wider the interval.
• the real center of the interval, the so-called pKa ' value is almost always shifted from the tabulated pK a value which is an interpolation to the ideal case infinite dilution.
• the requirement for good buffer capacity usually sets a lower limit to the buffer concentration.
• a higher limit to the buffer concentration is usually set by non desired effects of having too much buffer in the solution. One of these effects may be too high conductivity. In other cases, however, high conductivity may be desirable which leads to the second use or importance of buffer concentration, i.e. for some applications it may be appropriate to use the buffering salt to adjust the conductivity to high levels without the use of non-buffering salt.
• Fig. 1 shows in diagrammatic form an embodiment of blending system or arrangement which can be used for preparing buffers having predefined buffer concentration, pH and optionally conductivity or salt concentration, for example for use in chromatography, in accordance with the method of the present invention.
• a flow of stock solution of an acidic buffer component B 1 is supplied through a conduit 1
• stock solution flow of a basic buffer component B2 is supplied through a conduit 2.
• Conduits 1 and 2 are joined at a first junction 3.
• Water (WFI - water for injection) is supplied through a conduit 4, and, when required, salt solution is supplied through a conduit 5.
• Conduits 4 and 5 are joined at a second junction 6.
• the first and second junctions 3 and 6 are connected through respective conduits 8 and 9 to a third junction 7, which in turn connects to a buffer delivery conduit 10.
• the conduit 10 is provided with a pH sensor 1 1 and a conductivity sensor 12.
• one or more additives may be added, for example, detergent, organic solvent (e.g. DMSO), etc.
• ql , q2, q3, q4 and qn in Fig. 1 denote the flow rates (e.g. L/h), or alternatively the proportions (e.g. %), of B l , B2, salt solution, WFI, and additive (if any), respectively, of the total flow.
• the system further comprises pumps and flow meters (not shown), and optionally one or more additional sensors.
• a buffer with a predefined pH having a specific buffer concentration C and a specific salt concentration may be
• Buffer components B l and B2 may be a corresponding acid/base buffering substance pair, or one of them may be a strong acid or base and the other a buffering substance.
• a buffer component B 1 or B2 may also be a mixture of two or more components.
• Exemplary buffers that may be produced using this liquid blending system include phosphate, acetate, citrate, tris and bis-tris buffers, mixed acetate/ phosphate buffer, and mixed acetate/ format/phosphate buffer, just to mention a few.
• the acidic component B l may be e.g. HC1 and the basic component B2 may be a mixture of e.g. sodium acetate, sodium formate and sodium phosphate. It is also assumed that the total flow gT is known and constant. It has been taken into consideration that even if the salt is not a buffer, the change in ionic strength may lead to a shift in the pK a values of the buffering substances.
• non-buffering salts include, for instance, sodium chloride and calcium chloride.
• B l and B2 Calculate initial proportions (percentages), for B l and B2 as follows.
• C is buffer concentration
• ql to q4 denote flow or, alternatively, percentage of B l , B2, salt, and WFI, respectively.
• the buffer concentration C is specified for Cases 1 , 3 and 4, whereas Case 2 has no specification for buffer concentration. In the latter case, a suitable initial buffer concentration is therefore selected in Step 1 , e.g. 50 mM.
• the buffer concentration will be correct already from the beginning, for example in the case of weak acid - weak base with 0.5C coming from each stock B l and B2.
• the B l /B2 proportions are calculated to provide a pH in the vicinity of the desired predefined pH value.
• q4 100 - ql - q2 - q3.
• ql increases if pH is above target and decreases if pH is below target.
• q2 decreases if pH is above target and increases if pH is below target.
• q4 100 - ql - q2 - q3
• Epsilon is a small value, typically about 0.02 pH units or smaller.
• q2 decreases if pH is above target and increases if pH is below target.
• q4 100 - ql - q2 - q3
• q2 is kept constant.
• q4 100 - ql - q2 - q3 It is to be noted that in this alternative, the pH and conductivity adjustment procedures are not performed simultaneously but one at a time.
• pH and conductivity are regulated simultaneously as follows to level off the difference between desired values and actual values, e.g. through ⁇ and ACond, respectively.
• Aq P H is the change in B l and B2, respectively, for pH adjustment
• Aqc is the change in B l and B2, respectively, for conductivity adjustment
• the software used for controlling the chromatography system may be used.
• An exemplary such software is the UnicornTM control system (GE Healthcare Bio-Sciences AB, Uppsala, Sweden), which is based on a controller and I/O interface with a computer graphical user interface, being an integral part of the control system.
• a liquid blending system basically corresponding to that shown in Fig. 1 , was used to prepare a liquid flow of three buffer mixtures A3, C3 and P6, as specified in Table 2 below. The flow, conductivity and pH of the prepared buffer were continuously monitored.
• Fig. 2 The results of the run of buffer C3 is shown in Fig. 2 and described below.
• the top curve is the combined flow
• the middle curve is pH
• the bottom curve is the conductivity.
• a liquid blending system basically corresponding to that shown in Fig. 1 , was used for buffer formulation according to method of the invention. The results are shown in Figures 3 and 4.
• salt gradients were prepared using 20 mM citrate, pH, 3.5, 0- lM NaCl, and flow rates 400 (top) and 300 (bottom) L/h, respectively. Two different strategies were used. Top diagram: pH feedback for the base (flow rate is curve a) and the acid (curve b) combined with flow feedback for the salt (curve c) and the WFI (curve d). Bottom diagram: Flow feedback with recipe for all the components where the recipe is continuously updated along the gradient. Total flow rate is shown in curve e, conductivity in curve f, and pH in curve g.
• Curve f is
• the bottom diagram shows the application of a pH gradient using pH

Landscapes

• Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
• General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
• Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
• Immunology (AREA)
• Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
• Biochemistry (AREA)
• General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
• Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
• Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
• Pathology (AREA)
• Analytical Chemistry (AREA)
• Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
• Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
• General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
• Investigating Or Analyzing Materials By The Use Of Electric Means (AREA)
• Accessories For Mixers (AREA)
• Detergent Compositions (AREA)

Priority Applications (5)

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Publications (1)

Family

ID=45371782

Family Applications (1)

Country Status (6)

Cited By (10)

Families Citing this family (14)

Citations (5)

Family Cites Families (19)

• 2011
  • 2011-05-05 CN CN201180030718.XA patent/CN102947768B/zh active Active
  • 2011-05-05 JP JP2013516523A patent/JP6014588B2/ja active Active
  • 2011-05-05 EP EP11798441.9A patent/EP2585887B1/en active Active
  • 2011-05-05 US US13/704,270 patent/US10955092B2/en active Active
  • 2011-05-05 CA CA2798873A patent/CA2798873C/en active Active
  • 2011-05-05 WO PCT/SE2011/050563 patent/WO2011162666A1/en not_active Ceased

Patent Citations (5)

Also Published As

Similar Documents

Legal Events