JP2009282621A - Performance evaluation management server - Google Patents

Abstract

<P>PROBLEM TO BE SOLVED: To provide a performance evaluation management server for improving the conviction nature of a performance evaluation target person. <P>SOLUTION: This performance evaluation management server 1 is provided with: a primary performance evaluation storage means for storing primary performance evaluation information received from a client device 2b for a primary performance evaluator; a performance evaluation transmission means for transmitting the primary performance evaluation information to the client device 2a for a performance evaluation target person in response to a primary performance evaluation information display request from a client device 2a for a performance evaluation target person; and a primary performance evaluation high order provision means for transmitting the primary performance evaluation information to a client device 2c for a secondary performance evaluator in response to a primary performance evaluation information display request from the client device 2 for the secondary performance evaluator only when consensus information corresponding to the primary performance evaluation information is received from the client device 2a for the performance evaluation target person, and for inputting the secondary performance evaluation information or approval information to the primary performance evaluation information in the client device 2c for the secondary performance evaluator. <P>COPYRIGHT: (C)2010,JPO&INPIT

Description

  The present invention relates to an appraisal management server used in an appraisal system such as personnel appraisal, and more particularly to an appraisal management server that can improve the persuasiveness of a person to be evaluated.

As an evaluation method for improving the persuasion of the person to be evaluated, there is a method of gradually reflecting the personnel evaluation described in Patent Document 1 below. In this method, in addition to the basic variable of the number of appraisal points for the appraisal item, the amount of professional salary, bonus, etc. is calculated with a predetermined formula using the previous term amount such as bonus amount in the previous term and the functional salary before salary increase as variables. By doing so, we are trying to ensure the fairness of the personnel evaluation and increase the persuasion of the person being evaluated.
JP-A-10-97568

  However, the above method does not confirm whether or not the appraisal is satisfied when determining the number of appraisal points, which is a basic variable. There was a problem that no personnel evaluation would be convincing for the appraisers.

  The present invention solves the above-described problems, and an object thereof is to provide an appraisal management server that can improve the persuasiveness of the examinee.

  The appraisal management server of the present invention can communicate with a plurality of client devices and receives primary appraisal information received from the client device used by the primary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for primary appraisers”). In response to a primary appraisal information display request from the client device used by the appraisal (hereinafter referred to as “client device for appraisal”). The appraisal transmission means for transmitting the appraisal to the client device for the appraisal, and the client used by the secondary appraiser only when the agreement information for the primary appraisal information has been received from the client device for the appraisal In response to a primary appraisal information display request from a device (hereinafter referred to as “client device for secondary appraisers”), the primary appraisal information is sent to the secondary appraiser client. And a primary appraisal higher-level submitting means that transmits to the ant device in a displayable manner and allows the secondary appraiser client device to input secondary appraisal information or approval information for the primary appraisal information. To do. According to this, the primary appraisal information that is not convinced by the appraisal is not submitted to the secondary appraiser, and the secondary appraisal information or approval information is not input, so the appraisal of the appraisal can be improved. It is.

  Here, only when the primary appraisal upper submission means has received the agreement information for the primary appraisal information from the client device for the appraiser, in response to a request from the client device for the primary appraiser The primary appraisal submission operation unit for transmitting the request for submitting the primary appraisal information to the appraisal management server is transmitted to the client device for the primary appraiser so that the primary appraisal submission operation unit is operated. The primary appraisal information is sent to the secondary appraisal in response to the primary appraisal information display request from the client device for secondary appraisers only when the request for submitting the primary appraisal information has been received. The secondary appraisal client device can input the secondary appraisal information or the approval information with respect to the previous primary appraisal information. It may be. This is because the primary appraiser can control the time to submit the primary appraisal information to the secondary appraiser.

  In addition, when disagreement information with respect to the primary appraisal information is received from the client device for the appraisal, the appraisal interview request means for transmitting the appraisal interview request to the client device for the primary appraiser may be provided. . This is because the interview will be conducted until the person to be considered is satisfied, and the satisfaction of the person to be evaluated can be further improved.

  In addition, target storage means for storing target information received from the client device for the appraiser, and the target information for the primary approver in response to a target information display request from the client device for the primary appraiser Target transmission means for transmitting to the client device in a displayable manner, target interview record storage means for storing the target interview record received from the primary appraiser client device with respect to the target information, and the client device for the appraisal In response to a target interview record display request from the target interview record transmitting means for transmitting the target interview record to the client device for the examinee, and an agreement on the target interview record from the client device for the examinee Only when the information has been received, the client device (hereinafter referred to as “upper level”) used by a predetermined evaluator higher than the primary evaluator. In response to a target information display request from the appraisal client device ”), the target information is transmitted to the upper appraiser client device in a displayable manner, and the target information is approved by the upper appraiser client device. It is good also as having the target high-order submission means which enables input of information. This is because it is possible to improve the persuasiveness of the person to be evaluated in setting the target.

  A prospective entry requesting means for transmitting a prospective entry request to the client apparatus for the assessed person in response to a request for filling out the target achievement prospect from the client apparatus for the primary assessor; and the client for the assessed person In response to a prospect information display request from the client device for primary appraisers, a prospect storage means for storing a target achievement prospect (hereinafter referred to as “forecast information”) received from the apparatus, A line-of-sight transmission means for transmitting to the primary appraiser client device in a displayable manner, a line-of-sight interview record storage means for storing a line-of-sight interview record received from the primary appraiser client device for the line-of-sight information; In response to a view interview record display request from the appraisal client device, the view interview record is stored in the client device for the appraisal. When a disagreement information for the prospective interview record is received from the prospective client device, the prospective interview request is transmitted to the primary assessor client device. It is good also as having a prospect re-interview request means. This is because the achievement of the goal can be supported.

  In addition, only when the appraisal result storage means for storing the appraisal result and the request for disclosure of the appraisal result have been received from the client device for the primary appraiser, the appraisal result display request from the appraisal client device is made. Accordingly, there may be provided an evaluation result transmitting means for transmitting the evaluation result to the client device for the appraisal in a displayable manner. This is because the primary appraiser can explain the appraisal result to the appraisal, and then can disclose the appraisal result to the appraisal.

  The program of the present invention stores primary appraisal information received from the client device used by a primary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for primary appraisers”) that can communicate with a plurality of client devices. In response to a primary appraisal information display request from the client device used by the appraisal (hereinafter referred to as “client device for appraisal”), the primary appraisal information is stored in the appraisal. The appraisal transmission means for transmitting to the client device for persons to be displayed, and the client apparatus used by the secondary appraiser only when the agreement information for the primary appraisal information has been received from the client apparatus for the appraisers Hereinafter, in response to a primary appraisal information display request from “secondary appraiser client device”), the primary appraisal information is sent to the secondary appraiser. It is transmitted as displayable to a client device, and functions as a primary appraisal higher-level submitting means that enables input of secondary appraisal information or approval information for the primary appraisal information in the client device for secondary appraisers. To do.

  The appraisal management server of the present invention transmits the primary appraisal information to the secondary appraisal client device so that it can be displayed only when the agreement information for the primary appraisal information has been received from the client device for the appraisal. Since the next appraisal information or the approval information can be input, the primary appraisal information that is not convinced by the examinee is not submitted to the secondary appraiser, and the secondary appraisal information and the approval information are not input. For this reason, the persuasiveness of the examinee can be improved.

  Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. As shown in FIG. 1, the appraisal system S includes an appraisal management server (hereinafter abbreviated as “server”) 1 and a plurality of client devices (hereinafter abbreviated as “clients”) 2. Each client 2 can communicate with the appraisal management server 1 via a communication line including the Internet. In the present embodiment, the primary appraisers, secondary appraisers, department heads (corresponding to the third appraisers), and the appraisal members of the appraisal committee are placed in this order on the appraisers. When the clients 2 to be used are distinguished from each other, the symbols 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d, and 2e are used as shown in parentheses in FIG. In other words, in the ranking, the person who is located immediately above the person to be assessed is the primary person to be assessed, the person who is immediately above the primary person to be assessed is the secondary person to be assessed, and so on. Are assessed first by the primary assessor, then by the secondary assessor, and so on.

  The server 1 includes one or a plurality of computers, and includes an input unit 11, a calculation / control unit 12, a storage unit 13, a communication unit 14, and a display unit 15. The server 1 is installed with an OS (operating system) and various programs such as a Web server program and an appraisal management program that operate on the OS. The input unit 11 includes a pointing device such as a mouse, a keyboard, and the like, and inputs various data, various commands, and the like to the calculation / control unit 12 in accordance with a user operation. The storage unit 13 includes a semiconductor memory, a hard disk device, a compact disk device, and the like. For each period and for each appraisal, target information, outlook information, primary appraisal information, secondary appraisal information, department appraisal information, various information Memorize interview records, appraisal results, etc. In addition, in the storage unit 13, a person who is associated with the ID (identification information) of each appraisal in advance and is positioned above the appraisal (in this embodiment, the primary appraiser, the secondary appraiser, and ID, name, email address, etc. are stored. The calculation / control unit 12 includes a CPU, a RAM that is a work area of the CPU, a ROM that stores fixed data, and the like. The communication unit 14 is a part serving as an interface for connecting the server 1 and other computers including the client 2 via a communication line. The display unit 15 includes a CRT, a liquid crystal display, or the like, and displays various screens according to display commands from the calculation / control unit 12.

  The appraisal management program includes a computer for primary appraisal storage means, appraisal transmission means, primary appraisal upper submission means, appraisal interview request means, secondary appraisal storage means, secondary appraisal upper submission means, target storage means, and target transmission means. , Target interview record storage means, target interview record transmission means, higher order submission means, outlook entry request means, outlook storage means, outlook transmission means, outlook interview record storage means, outlook interview record transmission means, outlook re-interview request means, evaluation This is for functioning as result storage means and appraisal result transmission means. By installing this appraisal management program, the calculation / control unit 12 cooperates with the storage unit 13, the communication unit 14, etc. , Function as each of the above means.

  Each client 2 is a personal computer, and includes an input unit 21, a calculation / control unit 22, a storage unit 23, a communication unit 24, and a display unit 25, as shown in FIG. Each client 2 is installed with an OS and a program operating on the OS such as a Web browser. The input unit 21 includes a pointing device such as a mouse, a keyboard, and the like, and inputs various data, various commands, and the like to the calculation / control unit 22 in accordance with a user operation. The storage unit 23 includes a semiconductor memory, a hard disk device, a compact disk device, and the like. The calculation / control unit 22 includes a CPU, a RAM serving as a work area for the CPU, a ROM storing fixed data, and the like. The communication unit 24 is a part that serves as an interface when connecting the client 2 and another computer such as the server 1 via a communication line. The display unit 25 includes a CRT, a liquid crystal display, or the like, and displays various screens according to display commands from the calculation / control unit 22.

  Next, with regard to the operation of the server 1 and the client 2, taking an example of an appraisal person “XX child”, the target setting process for setting a target, the interview process for making an outlook for the achievement of the target, and the evaluation are recorded. Will be described in turn, the feedback process for feeding back the final evaluation results. In the following description, when “the server 1 displays a screen on the client 2”, “the server 1 transmits a screen (that is, data that can display the screen, such as an HTML file) to the client 2. The client 2 displays a screen based on the data ”.

<Target setting process>
The target setting process will be described with reference to FIGS. At the beginning of the period, the primary appraiser performs a display request operation for the appraisal GAS sheet screen for the appraisal “XXA child” in the client 2b, and the server 1 responds to the client 2b as shown in FIG. A GAS sheet screen for an appraiser is displayed (steps S101 and S102 in FIG. 2-1). A GAS (Goal Achievement Support) sheet is a sheet (table) into which target information is input. Further, the term is a term in a business year such as the first half or the second half of 2008, and in the example of FIG. Each period, each person to be evaluated sets a target in the GAS sheet, and is evaluated based on the GAS sheet. The primary appraiser inputs a target (expected target) expected for the appraisal into the GAS sheet based on the company goal and department goal that have been input in advance, and a confirm operation (here, confirm button 30 When clicking (same for the following confirmation operation) is performed (S103), the GAS sheet including the expected target is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1. The server 1 stores (saves) the received GAS sheet in the storage unit 13, changes the state (status) of the GAS sheet from the initial value “Not Existing” to “Creating”, and completes the expected target input. An email is transmitted to the client 2a used by the appraisal (S104, S105).

  The examinee inputs his / her ID in the client 2a and performs a display request operation for the GAS sheet screen for the examinee. In response to this, the server 1 reads the GAS sheet of the appraisal stored in the storage unit 13 and displays the GAS sheet screen for the appraisal on which the GAS sheet is displayed on the client 2a (S106, 107). As shown in FIG. 7, the GAS sheet screen for the appraisal shows the expected target entered by the primary appraiser, so that the appraisal is required to achieve his / her expected goal. The target (item) is input to the GAS sheet together with its weight, achievement criteria, measures and means for achievement, and the submit button 31 on the screen is clicked (S108). Then, a GAS sheet including target information (target, weight, achievement standard, etc.) is transmitted from the client 2a to the server 1, and the server 1 stores (updates and saves) the received GAS sheet in the storage unit 13 [target storage means] The GAS sheet state is set to “meeting”, and a GAS sheet creation completion mail is transmitted to the client 2b (S109, 110).

  The primary appraiser knows that the appraisal has entered the target information in the GAS sheet by looking at the GAS sheet creation completion mail, and performs a display request operation for the appraisal GAS sheet screen in the client 2b. The target information display request is transmitted from the server 1 to the server 1, and in response to this, the server 1 displays the GAS sheet screen for the assessor on the client 2b [target transmission means]. This screen is updated from the state of FIG. 6 and displays the contents of the GAS sheet input by the examinee, that is, the target information, in the same manner as the GAS sheet screen for the examinee shown in FIG. The primary examiner interviews the examiner while looking at the GAS sheet, and instructs the examiner to correct the GAS sheet if necessary.

  The primary appraiser performs a display request operation for the target interview recording screen in the client 2b. In response to this, the server 1 displays a target interview recording screen as shown in FIG. 8 on the client 2b (S111, 112). The primary appraiser inputs the interview record (target interview record) on this screen, and if the GAS sheet needs to be corrected, select “GAS sheet needs to be corrected” on the screen and perform the confirmation operation ( S113). Then, the target interview record is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, the server 1 stores the target interview record in the storage unit 13 [target interview record storage means], and transmits an interview record confirmation request mail to the client 2a (S114, 115).

  The examinee performs a request operation for displaying a target interview record confirmation screen, and in response to the target interview record display request transmitted by this operation, the server 1 displays a target interview record confirmation screen as shown in FIG. 9 on the client 2a. (S116, 117 in FIG. 2-2) [Target interview record transmission means]. The examinee looks at the target interview record displayed on the interview record confirmation screen, and if there is no problem, selects “There is no problem with this interview content” (ie, “Agreement”) on the screen (S121 or S124) If there is, “Please ask again” (ie, “Re-interview”) is selected (S118). In “Agreement”, when “No target correction” is displayed in the correction presence / absence column 32 (that is, when correction is not necessary) (S121), “Please correct the target” is displayed. (S124).

  When “re-consultation” is selected, disagreement information indicating that the agreement has not been reached is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 transmits a re-interview request mail to the client 2b of the primary appraiser (S119, 120). . The primary appraiser will have another interview with the appraisal. Thereafter, the processes of steps S111 to S117 are repeated.

  When “Agreement” is selected when correction is necessary (S124), information indicating that the correction has been agreed is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 returns the status of the GAS sheet to “Creating” An agreement mail is transmitted to the client 2b of the primary appraiser (S125). The examinee displays the GAS sheet screen for the examinee on the client 2a and corrects the GAS sheet (S106, 107). Thereafter, the processes of steps S108 to S117 are repeated.

  On the other hand, when “Agreement” is selected in the case where correction is not required (S121), information indicating that the target has been agreed (corresponding to the agreement information for the target interview record) is transmitted to the server 1. The server 1 changes the status of the GAS sheet from “busy” to “unapproved (waiting for approval from the department head)” only when information indicating that the target has been agreed is received. An agreement mail is transmitted to 2b (S122, 123). In addition, the server 1 transmits an agreement mail to the client 2d used by the department head (S127, S128).

  The department head performs a display request operation for the member list screen on the client 2d, and in response to this, the server 1 displays a member list screen as shown in FIG. 10 on the client 2d. This screen displays a list of GAS sheet statuses for all members belonging to the department of the department head who requested the display, and a GAS sheet button 33 for members whose GAS sheet status is “Unapproved”. The On the other hand, GAS sheets for members whose GAS sheet status is lower than "Unapproved" ("Not approved". That is, "Does not exist", "Creating", or "Interviewing") The button 33 is not displayed. That is, the server 1 determines whether or not the department head can view the GAS sheet based on the state of the GAS sheet, and the state is “not approved” or more (that is, “not approved”, “approved”, Alternatively, the GAS sheet button 33 is displayed because it is determined that it can be browsed for “completed”), but the GAS sheet button 33 is not displayed because it is determined that browsing is not possible for items below “unapproved”.

  When the department head clicks the GAS sheet button 33, a target information display request is transmitted from the client 2d to the server 1, and the server 1 displays a department head GAS sheet screen (not shown) on the client 2d (S129, 130). [Target high-ranking means] A GAS sheet is displayed on the department manager GAS sheet screen in the same manner as the GAS sheet screen for the appraisal person shown in FIG. 7, but an item addition edit button 34 for adding or editing an item is not provided. An approval button is provided instead of the submit button 31. The department head checks the contents of the GAS sheet on this screen and clicks the approval button (S131). Then, information indicating approval (corresponding to approval information) is input to the client 2 d and transmitted to the server 1. The server 1 that has received the approval information changes the state of the GAS sheet to “approval” (S132).

  The GAS sheet whose status is “approved” is displayed on the client 2e in response to a display request from the client 2e of the assessment committee (S133, 134). On the other hand, a GAS sheet whose status is lower than “approved” is not displayed on the client 2e. When a predetermined operation is performed in the client 2e, the server 1 changes the state of the GAS sheet from “approved” to “completed”.

  As described above, when the primary examiner inputs an expected target or the like to the GAS sheet and performs a confirmation operation, the server 1 changes the state of the GAS sheet from “not existing” to “being created” When the target information is input to the GAS sheet and confirmed by the user, the status is changed from “being created” to “being interviewed”. Only when the consensus information for the target interview record is received from the appraisal, the status of the GAS sheet is changed to “Unapproved” from “Interviewing”. The GAS sheet button 33 is displayed on the client 2d, and when the button 33 is clicked, the GAS sheet of the member is displayed and the GAS sheet can be approved. For members who are lower than "", the GAS sheet button 33 is not displayed on the client 2d, and neither the GAS sheet display nor the approval information can be input.

  That is, the server 1 can display the GAS sheet on the client 2d in response to the target information display request from the department head client 2d only when the agreement information for the target interview record has been received from the client 2a of the appraisal. (Ie, in a displayable form such as an HTML file, for example), and the approval button for the GAS sheet can be input by displaying an approval button together with the GAS sheet in the client 2d. Therefore, only the goals that the appraisers have agreed with in the interview with the primary appraisers will be submitted to the higher appraisers (in this case, department heads) for approval. High target setting is possible.

<Interim interview processing>
Interim interview processing will be described with reference to FIG. Interim interviews are interviews held during the period. The primary examiner performs a display request operation for the landing prospect interview screen for the subject to be evaluated in the client 2b, and in response to this, the server 1 displays a landing prospect interview screen as shown in FIG. 11 on the client 2b (FIG. 11). 3 steps S201, 202). On the landing prospecting interview screen, the names of all the appraisers to be evaluated by the primary appraiser are displayed in a selectable list, and an entry request button 35 is provided. The primary appraiser performs an operation of selecting the appraisal person who wants to request the entry of the landing prospect, and clicks the entry request button 35 (S203). Then, a request for filling in the target achievement prospect for the selected appraisal is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, and in response to this, the server 1 instructs the client 2a of the selected appraisal to create a landing prospect. An email (corresponding to the prospect entry request) is transmitted (S204, 205) [outlook entry request means].

  The examinee performs a display request operation for the landing prospect registration screen on the client 2a, and in response thereto, the server 1 displays a landing prospect registration screen as shown in FIG. 12 on the client 2a (S206, 207). On the landing prospect registration screen, the target (item) in the target information and the achievement standard are displayed, and the examinee inputs the landing prospect for each target. The landing prospect is an achievement achievement target of how far the target can be achieved in that period, and corresponds to the prospect information. When the examinee inputs the landing prospect and performs a confirmation operation (S208), the landing prospect is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 stores the received landing prospect in the storage unit 13 [line of sight storage means] A prospective input completion mail is transmitted to the client 2b of the primary examiner (S209, 210).

  The primary appraiser sees the landing prospect input completion email, knows that the appraisal has entered the landing prospect, conducts an interview with the appraisal while looking at the landing prospect registration screen, and if necessary, on the GAS sheet Instruct the appraiser to make corrections.

  The primary examiner clicks the interview record entry button 44 (see FIG. 11) on the landing prospect interview screen on the client 2b. Then, in response to the prospect information display request transmitted by this operation, the server 1 transmits a landing prospect interview recording screen to the client 2b, and the client 2b displays the prospect information on which the prospect information is displayed as shown in FIG. An interview recording screen is displayed (S211, 212) [line of sight transmission means]. The primary appraiser inputs the prospective interview record on this screen, and when the GAS sheet needs to be corrected, selects “GAS sheet needs to be corrected” on the screen and performs a confirmation operation (S213). Then, the line-of-sight interview record is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, the server 1 stores the line-of-sight interview record in the storage unit 13 [line-of-sight interview record storage means], and transmits an interview record confirmation request mail to the client 2a (S214, 215).

  The examinee performs a request for displaying the landing prospect interview record confirmation screen, and the server 1 displays the landing prospect interview record confirmation screen on the client 2a in response to the prospect interview record display request transmitted by this operation (S216, 217) [Line-of-sight interview record transmission means]. Although the landing prospecting interview record confirmation screen is not shown, the prospective interview record is displayed and whether or not the GAS sheet needs to be corrected is displayed in the same manner as the target interview record confirmation screen shown in FIG. "Can be selected. The examinee looks at the prospect interview record, selects "Agree" if there is no problem (S221 or S224), and selects "re-interview" if there is a problem (S218).

  When “re-meeting” is selected (S218), information indicating that the agreement has not been reached is transmitted to the server 1 (corresponding to disagreement information regarding the prospective interview record), and the server 1 receives the client 2b of the primary appraiser. A re-interview request email (corresponding to a prospect interview request) is transmitted (S219, S220) [prospect interview request means]. The primary examiner looks at the re-interview request email and re-interviews with the examinee. Thereafter, the processes of steps S211 to S217 are repeated.

  If “Agreement” is selected when correction is necessary (S224), information indicating that the correction has been agreed is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 sets the status of the GAS sheet to “being changed”. The agreement mail is transmitted to the client 2b of the primary appraiser (S225, S226). The examinee displays the GAS sheet screen for the examinee on the client 2a and corrects the GAS sheet. Thereafter, the processing after step S106 is repeated.

  On the other hand, when “Agreement” is selected when correction is not required (S221), information indicating that the prospect interview record has been agreed is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 sends it to the client 2b of the primary appraiser. An agreement mail is transmitted (S222, 223).

  As described above, according to the server 1, it is possible to prompt the examinee to fill in the prospect of achievement of the objective. Therefore, if the interview is conducted based on the prospect, the achievement of the target can be supported, and further, the interview record can be recorded. When the appraisers do not agree, a re-interview request email is sent from the server 1 to the client 2b, so the primary appraisers are encouraged to re-interview and the interviews are repeated until the appraisers are satisfied. It is possible to improve the persuasiveness of the appraiser.

<Appraisal process>
The appraisal process will be described with reference to FIGS. After the period is over, the appraisal performs a request to display an appraisal information screen in the client 2a in order to perform self-appraisal, and the server 1 displays an appraisal information screen as shown in FIG. 14 on the client 2a. Before the self-assessment is performed for the period ended, the state of the appraisal for that period is “Self-assessment in progress”, and the state of the GAS sheet is “unconsidered”. When the examinee clicks the edit button 36, the server 1 displays a self-assessment screen as shown in FIG. 15 on the client 2a (steps S301 and S302 in FIG. 4A). On the self-assessment screen, each target (item) input to the GAS sheet, its weight and achievement criteria are displayed.

  When the person to be assessed inputs self-assessment (achievement level and self-evaluation) on the self-assessment screen and performs a confirmation operation, a “Submit to Primary Assessor” button (not shown) is displayed when returning to the assessment information screen. Since it is displayed, the examinee clicks the button (S303). Then, the self-assessment is transmitted from the client 2a to the server 1, the server 1 stores the self-assessment in the storage unit 13, the state of the appraisal is “preparing for the primary appraiser interview”, and the state of the GAS sheet is “self-assessment” The interview request mail is transmitted to the client 2b as “completed” (S304, 305). From this email, the primary appraisal knows that the appraisal has conducted self-assessment.

  In order to perform the primary appraisal, the primary appraiser performs a display request operation for the primary appraisal screen for the appraisal in the client 2b, and the server 1 displays the primary appraisal screen as shown in FIG. 16 on the client 2b. Is displayed (steps S401 and 402 in FIG. 4B). On the primary appraisal screen, each target (item) input to the GAS sheet, its weight and achievement criteria are displayed. When the primary appraiser enters the achievement level, comments, contents of non-target achievements and points, and the contents of the overall evaluation as the primary appraisal on the primary appraisal screen, the server 1 determines the weight of each target. Then, based on the degree of achievement and the score of the non-target performance, the overall score is calculated by a predetermined formula and input (displayed) in the score field 37. When the primary appraiser performs a confirmation operation on the primary appraisal screen (S403), the primary appraisal is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, and the server 1 stores the primary appraisal in the storage unit 13 and the state of the GAS sheet. Is “assessed” (S404).

  Next, when the primary appraiser performs a display request operation for the screen for the primary appraisers in the client 2b, the server 1 causes the client 2b to list the appraisers for the primary appraisers as shown in FIG. A screen is displayed (S405, 406). This screen displays a list of GAS sheet statuses for all of the appraisers subject to the appraisal of the primary appraiser, and the appraisal status is “Preparing for the primary appraiser interview”. That is, the appraisal input completion button 38 is displayed only for the appraisers who have been self-assessed. When the primary appraiser clicks the appraisal input completion button 38 (S407), information to that effect is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 sets the status of the appraisal to “Interviewing the primary appraiser” (S408).

  In addition, although the primary appraiser performed the primary appraisal after self-assessment here, you may perform the primary appraisal before self-assessment. In any case, if both the self-assessment and the primary appraisal are not transmitted and stored in the server 1, the server 1 does not display the appraisal input completion button 38 for the subject.

  The appraisal and the primary appraiser conduct an appraisal interview while viewing the self appraisal and the primary appraisal on the screen to determine the primary appraisal. Then, the primary appraiser performs a display request operation of the appraisal interview recording screen in the client 2b, and in response to this, the server 1 displays the appraisal interview recording first screen as shown in FIG. 18 on the client 2b (S501, 502). The appraisal interview recording screen is composed of an appraisal interview recording first screen and an appraisal interview recording second screen described later. The appraisal before the interview is a temporary appraisal, and the appraisal after the interview is a true appraisal. Until the appraisal after the interview is entered, the first screen of the appraisal interview record displays “Unappraised”. Has been.

  The primary appraiser inputs the interview record on this screen and clicks the appraisal result entry button 39. Then, an appraisal interview recording second screen as shown in FIG. 19 is displayed on the client 2b. This screen displays the appraisal (evaluation) before the interview. The primary appraiser inputs the primary appraisal (achievement level, comments, non-target results, etc.) determined by the appraisal interview on this screen. The server 1 calculates the overall score by a predetermined formula based on the weight and achievement level of each target and the score of non-target results, and inputs (displays) the score in the score column 50. When the primary appraiser performs a confirmation operation on the appraisal interview record second screen (S503), the interview record is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, and the server 1 records the interview record and the primary appraisal (the primary appraisal after the interview). Is stored in the storage unit 13 [primary appraisal storage means], and an interview record confirmation request mail is transmitted to the client 2a (S504, 505).

  The appraisal performs a request to display the appraisal interview record confirmation screen, and by this operation, a primary appraisal information display request is transmitted from the client 2a to the server 1, and the server 1 responds to the client 2a as shown in FIG. A review screen for confirming the interview is displayed (S506, 507). The examinee confirms the interview record (contents of the interview) displayed on the appraisal interview record confirmation screen. When the result display button 40 on the screen is clicked, a primary appraisal information display request is transmitted to the server 1, and in response thereto, the server 1 displays a primary appraisal display screen on the client 2a [appraisal transmission means]. Although the primary appraisal display screen is not shown, the primary appraisal information is displayed on the screen. The examinee selects “Agree” on the screen if there is no problem in the interview record and the primary appraisal (S511), and selects “re-interview” if there is a problem (S508).

  When “re-interview” is selected on the appraisal interview record confirmation screen (S509), information indicating that the agreement has not been reached (corresponding to disagreement information for the primary appraisal information) is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 A re-interview request email (corresponding to an appraisal interview request) is transmitted to the client 2b of the primary appraiser (S509, 510) [appraisal interview request means]. The primary examiner looks at the re-interview request email and re-interviews with the examinee. Thereafter, the processes of steps S501 to S507 are repeated.

  On the other hand, when “agreement” is selected (S511), information indicating that the agreement has been reached (corresponding to the agreement information for the primary appraisal information) is transmitted to the server 1. The server 1 sets the state of the appraisal to “primary appraisal completed” and transmits an agreement mail to the client 2b of the primary appraiser (S512, 513). The primary appraisal looks at the agreement mail and performs a display request operation for the primary appraiser list screen on the client 2b. In response to the request transmitted by this operation, the server 1 sends the request to the client 2b as shown in FIG. A screen for a list of appraisers for primary appraisers as shown in Fig. 5 is displayed (S514, 515). In this screen, the submit button 41 (corresponding to the primary appraisal submission operation unit) is only displayed for the appraisal whose appraisal status is “primary appraisal completed” (that is, the appraisal who agreed with the primary appraisal). Is displayed. When the primary appraiser clicks the submit button 41 (S516), the server 1 receives a request for submitting the primary appraisal information about the subject to whom the submit button 41 is clicked. Only for the appraiser, the appraisal state is set to “advanced appraisal in progress”, and an approval request mail is transmitted to the secondary appraisers (S517, 518).

  The secondary appraiser performs a display request operation for the screen for the secondary appraisers in the client 2c, and the server 1 displays the screen for the secondary appraisers in the client 2c. On this screen, as shown in FIG. 22-1, only for the appraisal whose appraisal status is “Upper Appraisal Appraisal” (ie, the appraisal for which the primary appraiser clicked the submit button 41), A GAS sheet button 42 is displayed. When the secondary appraiser clicks on the GAS sheet button 42 for the appraisal person who wants to input the secondary appraisal, the primary appraisal information display request is transmitted to the server 1, and in response to this, the server 1 sends the secondary appraisal to the client 2c. A screen is displayed (S519, 520). Although the secondary appraisal screen is not shown, it has the same configuration as the appraisal interview recording second screen shown in FIG. 19, and each goal, weight, and achievement criteria are displayed, and the primary appraisal is displayed. Furthermore, the secondary appraisal (corresponding to the secondary appraisal information) can be input [primary appraisal upper submission means].

  Note that the 2GAS sheet button 42 is not displayed for the appraisers whose status is lower than “Upper appraisers are being evaluated”, so the primary appraisal is not displayed on the client 2c, and the secondary appraisal is entered on the client 2c. I can't do that either.

  The secondary appraiser enters the degree of achievement and comments for each goal, the content and score of the non-target results, and the content of the overall evaluation as the secondary appraisal on the secondary appraisal screen, and the “Appraisal Complete” button on the screen When is clicked (S521), the secondary appraisal is transmitted from the client 2c to the server 1, and the server 1 stores the secondary appraisal in the storage unit 13 [secondary appraisal storage means]. In the secondary appraisal, the server 1 calculates the overall score based on the input achievement level and the like, and displays it on the secondary appraisal screen.

  The server 1 determines whether or not the primary appraisal and the secondary appraisal are equivalent. In the present embodiment, it is assumed that if the score (overall score) is the same for the primary appraisal and the secondary appraisal, they are equivalent, and if they are not the same, they are not equivalent. If it is the same, the state of the appraisal is set to “upper appraiser appraisal completed”, and if it is not the same, a change mail is transmitted to the client 2b (S522, 523).

  The primary appraiser who received the change email must re-interview with the appraisal to explain the appraisal change to the appraisal. This re-interview process will be described with reference to FIG. The appraiser and primary appraiser conduct an interview (appraisal interview) while viewing the secondary appraisal on the screen. Then, the primary appraiser performs a request for displaying the appraisal interview recording screen on the client 2b, and in response to this, the server 1 displays the appraisal interview recording first screen on the client 2b (S523-1, 523-2). The primary examiner inputs the interview record on this screen and performs a confirmation operation (S523-3). Then, the interview record is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, the server 1 stores the interview record in the storage unit 13, and transmits an interview record confirmation request mail to the client 2a (S523-4, 523-5).

  The examinee performs a display request operation for the appraisal interview record confirmation screen, and in response to this, the server 1 displays the appraisal interview record confirmation screen on the client 2a (S523-6, 523-7). The examinee confirms the interview record displayed on the appraisal interview record confirmation screen. If there is no problem, “Agree” is selected on the screen (S523-11), and if there is a problem, “Re-interview” is selected ( S523-8).

  When “re-meeting” is selected, information indicating that the agreement has not been reached is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 transmits a re-meeting request mail to the client 2b (S523-9, 523-10). The primary appraiser will have another interview with the appraisal. Thereafter, the processes of steps S523-1 to S523-7 are repeated. On the other hand, when “agreement” is selected, information indicating that the agreement has been reached is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 sets the state of the assessment as “upper-level assessor assessment completed” and sends an agreement mail to the client 2b ( S523-13).

  Next, returning to FIG. 4-4 and explaining from step S524, when the secondary appraiser causes the client 2c to display the screen for list of appraisers for secondary appraisers, As shown in FIG. 22-2, the submit button (secondary appraisal submission operation unit) 43 is displayed for the appraisal person whose appraisal status is “upper appraiser appraisal completed” (S524, 525). Note that the status of the appraisal is lower than “Completion of appraisal of the higher appraisal” (ie, “Self-assessment is being created”, “Preparing for the first appraiser interview”, “Interviewing the first appraiser”, “Completion of the first appraisal” Or, the submit button 43 is not displayed for the appraisal person who is “in the process of appraisal of the higher appraisers”. When the secondary appraiser clicks the submit button 43 (S526), a request for submitting secondary appraisal information about the subject to whom the submit button 43 is clicked is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 that has received the request submits the request. Only for the person to be evaluated, the state of the evaluation is again set to “higher evaluation”, and an evaluation submission completion mail is transmitted to the department head (S527, 528).

  When the department manager performs a display request operation for the department manager appraisal screen in the client 2d, a secondary appraisal information display request is transmitted from the client 2d to the server 1, and the server 1 displays the department manager appraisal screen on the client 2d (FIG. 4). −6, steps S529 and 530). Although the department head appraisal screen is not shown, it has the same structure as the appraisal interview recording second screen shown in FIG. 19, and each target, its weight and achievement criteria are displayed for the appraisal, and the secondary appraisal is displayed. In addition, for an appraisal who has received a request for submission of secondary appraisal information, it is configured such that a department appraisal (evaluation by the department head. Corresponding to the third appraisal information) can be input [secondary appraisal. Top submission means]. Note that the department head appraisal screen is configured so that, for an appraisal who has not received a request for submission of secondary appraisal information, the secondary appraisal is displayed, but the tertiary appraisal cannot be entered.

  When the department head inputs the degree of achievement and comments of each goal, the contents and points of non-target results, and the contents of the overall evaluation as the department appraisal, and clicks the “Appraisal Complete” button on the screen (S531), The department appraisal is transmitted from the client 2 d to the server 1, and the server 1 stores the department appraisal in the storage unit 13. In the department appraisal, the server 1 calculates the overall score and displays it on the department manager appraisal screen.

  The server 1 determines whether or not the secondary appraisal and the department appraisal are equivalent based on whether or not the overall scores are the same. If they are the same, the status of the appraisal is set to “departmental appraisal completed”. A change mail is transmitted to the client 2c (S532). The secondary assessor who has seen the change mail explains the change to the primary assessor, and the primary assessor conducts a re-interview with the examiner. Thereafter, the re-interview process is performed as described with reference to FIGS. However, when the server 1 receives the information indicating that the agreement has been made, the server 1 sets the state of the appraisal to “department manager appraisal completed”.

  When the department head performs a display request operation for the department appraisal list screen on the client 2d, the server 1 displays a department appraisal list screen as shown in FIG. 23 on the client 2d accordingly. On the department appraisal list screen, the scores of the secondary appraisals (overall grades) of all the members belonging to the department head of the department are displayed, and a reference button 51 for browsing the contents of the GAS sheet is provided. . When the department head clicks the submit button 52 on the department appraisal list screen (S535), the server 1 receives the information to that effect, and the appraisal status is only for the appraisal person whose appraisal status is “department manager appraisal completed”. Assume that the assessment committee has been submitted (S536).

  When the assessment committee performs a display request operation for the department appraisal result screen in the client 2e, the server 1 displays the department appraisal result screen on the client 2e. Although this screen is not shown, as with the department appraisal list screen shown in FIG. 23, the names of the members belonging to the selected department are displayed in a list, and for the members whose appraisal status is “Appraisal Committee Submitted” The overall score and a reference button are displayed. Then, when the reference button is clicked, a department appraisal detail screen for the member is displayed. Although the department appraisal detail screen is not shown, it has the same configuration as the appraisal interview recording second screen shown in FIG. 19 and displays each goal, its weight and achievement criteria, and the department appraisal (S537). 538). On the other hand, for the members whose status of appraisal is lower than “submitted to the appraisal committee”, the overall score and the reference button are not displayed, so the appraisal member cannot view the department appraisal.

  As described above, the server 1 performs the primary assessment for the subject appraisal in response to the primary appraisal information display request from the client 2c only when the agreement information for the primary appraisal has been received from the client 2a of the subject appraisal. The appraisal is displayed and a secondary appraisal screen on which the secondary appraisal can be input is transmitted to the client 2c. That is, only when the appraiser agrees with the primary appraisal, the secondary appraiser can view the primary appraisal and enter the secondary appraisal, so the primary appraisal that the appraisal is not satisfied is secondary The secondary appraisal will not be entered after being submitted to the appraiser. For this reason, it is possible to improve the persuasiveness of the person to be evaluated with respect to the evaluation.

  The server 1 displays the primary appraiser list screen for the primary appraiser in response to a request from the client 2b only when the consensus information for the primary appraisal has been received from the client 2a of the appraisal. The primary appraisal is displayed only in response to the primary appraisal information display request from the client 2c only when the submit button 41 is displayed for the appraisal and the primary appraisal request by clicking the submit button 41 has been received. The display screen is transmitted to the client 2c. In other words, only when the appraisal agrees to the primary appraisal, the primary appraiser can submit the primary appraisal to the secondary appraiser. The appraisers can view the primary appraisals and enter the secondary appraisals, so the primary appraisers can control the time of submission of the primary appraisal to the secondary appraisers, and all the primary appraises they have evaluated This is useful when you want to submit the documents after they have been collected (that is, after all of them have been agreed).

  In addition, when the appraisal does not agree with the primary appraisal, a re-interview request mail is transmitted from the server 1 to the client 2b, so that the primary appraiser can be prompted to re-interview, and the appraisal is convinced. It is possible to further improve the persuasiveness of the appraisers.

  Furthermore, the server 1 displays the secondary appraisal for the appraisal in response to the secondary appraisal information display request from the client 2d only when the primary appraisal and the secondary appraisal for the appraisal are equivalent. At the same time, the department manager appraisal screen on which the third appraisal can be input is transmitted to the client 2d. That is, only when the primary appraisal agreed by the appraisal and the secondary appraisal are equivalent, the third appraisal can view the secondary appraisal and enter the tertiary appraisal. The secondary appraisal that is not convinced is not submitted to the third appraiser and the third appraisal is not entered. For this reason, it is possible to further improve the persuasiveness of the person to be evaluated with respect to the evaluation.

  It should be noted that the server 1 displays the list of screened subjects for the secondary appraiser in response to a request from the client 2c only when the primary appraisal and the secondary appraisal for the appraisal are equivalent. A submit button 43 is displayed for the subject. The server 1 displays the secondary appraisal for the appraisal in response to the secondary appraisal information display request from the client 2d only when the submission request for the secondary appraisal by clicking the submit button 43 has been received. At the same time, the department manager appraisal screen on which the third appraisal can be input is transmitted to the client 2d. According to this, the secondary appraiser can control the submission time of the secondary appraisal to the tertiary appraiser.

<Feedback processing>
The feedback process will be described with reference to FIGS. The appraisal member performs an appraisal based on the department appraisal, inputs the appraisal result (appraisal result) on the appraisal result input screen (not shown) transmitted from the server 1 to the client 2e, and performs a confirmation operation. Then, the assessment result is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 stores the assessment result in the storage unit 13 [assessment result storage unit]. Next, the assessor performs a feedback screen display request operation on the client 2e, and in response to this, the server 1 displays a feedback screen (not shown) on the client 2e (steps S601 and 602 in FIG. 5A). . In this screen, the assessor selects a department and clicks the “Feedback” button. Then, the server 1 sets the evaluation state of all the members belonging to the selected department to “feedback preparation in progress”, and sends an email indicating that the evaluation result has been disclosed to the primary assessor belonging to the department (S604).

  The primary appraiser who received this mail (S605) performs a display request operation for the appraisal result list screen for the appraisers in the client 2b, and in response to this, the server 1 uses the client 2b for the appraisers as shown in FIG. The assessment result list screen is displayed (S606, 607). On the appraisal result list screen for the appraiser, an appraisal result display button 53 and an appraisal result disclosure button 54 are provided for each appraisal subject to the appraisal of the primary appraiser, and the appraisal result display button 53 is clicked. The evaluation result for the appraised person is displayed, and when the assessment result disclosure button 54 is clicked, an appraisal result disclosure request for the appraisal is sent to the server 1. After confirming the assessment result, the primary assessor clicks the assessment result disclosure button 54 (S608). Then, the server 1 receives the appraisal result disclosure request, and sets the appraisal status to “feedback” only for the appraisal subject who is the subject of this request (ie, the assessment result disclosure button 54 has been clicked). (S609).

  The appraisal performs a display request operation for the appraisal result screen for the appraisal for displaying the appraisal result in the client 2a. In response to this, the server 1 determines whether the appraisal result can be viewed by the appraisal person based on the state of the appraisal. That is, if the appraisal state of the appraiser is “feedback” (that is, the appraisal result disclosure request has been received), the appraisal is judged to be viewable. Here, since the state of the appraisal is “feedback” in step S609, it is determined that browsing is possible, and the appraisal result screen for the appraisal is provided with the assessment result display button 55 as shown in FIG. It is displayed on the client 2a (S610, 611). When the appraiser clicks the assessment result display button 55 (S612), an appraisal result display request is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 displays the appraisal result on the client 2a in response to this request (S613, 614). Transmission means]. If the assessment state is not “feedback”, the assessment result display button 55 is not displayed, so that the assessment result is not displayed on the client 2a.

  The examinee and the primary examiner conduct an interview (feedback interview) while viewing the evaluation result on the screen. The primary examiner displays a feedback interview recording screen (not shown) on the client 2b (steps S615 and S616 in FIG. 5-2), inputs the interview recording on the screen, and performs a confirmation operation (S617). . Then, the interview record is transmitted from the client 2b to the server 1, the server 1 stores the interview record in the storage unit 13, and transmits an interview record confirmation request mail to the client 2a (S618, 619).

  The examinee displays a feedback interview record confirmation screen (not shown) on the client 2a (S620, 621), confirms the interview record displayed on the screen, and if there is no problem, "consent" is displayed on the screen. Select (S625), and if there is a problem, select "re-interview" (S622).

  When “re-interview” is selected, information indicating that the evaluation result has not been agreed is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 transmits a re-interview request mail to the client 2b (S623, 624). The primary appraiser will have another interview with the appraisal. Thereafter, the processes in steps S615 to S620 are repeated. On the other hand, when “agreement” is selected, information indicating that the evaluation result has been agreed is transmitted to the server 1, and the server 1 sets the evaluation status to “feedback completed” and transmits an agreement mail to the client 2b. The client 2b receives the agreement mail (S627).

  As described above, the server 1 displays the evaluation result on the client 2a in response to the evaluation result display request from the client 2a only when the request for disclosure of the evaluation result has been received from the client 2b. The primary evaluator who is immediately higher can provide feedback when the prepared person is ready to explain the evaluation result to the evaluator, and the persuasion of the evaluator can be improved.

<Other embodiments>
The embodiment of the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and, for example, the following embodiment can also be adopted.

  In the above embodiment, the server 1 displays the GAS sheet button 42 only for the appraisal person whose appraisal status is “Upper Appraisal Appraisal”, and allows the secondary appraiser to browse the primary appraisal and perform the secondary appraisal. The GAS sheet button 42 is also displayed for the appraisers whose status of the appraisal is lower than “Upper appraisers are being evaluated”, and the secondary appraisers can view the primary appraisals. However, the secondary appraisal may not be input. That is, even if the primary appraisal that the appraisal does not agree with is allowed to be viewed by the secondary appraiser, the secondary appraisal may not be input to the primary appraisal.

  Similarly, on the department appraisal result screen displayed by the appraisal member on the client 2e (S537, 538), the overall evaluation and reference buttons are also displayed for the members whose appraisal status is lower than "Appraisal Committee Submitted", By clicking the browse button, the appraisal member can view the department appraisal, but the appraisal member cannot operate the department appraisal (for example, input of approval information, input of appraisal, etc.) It is good to do.

  Similarly, in the target setting process, the GAS sheet button 33 is also displayed for the appraisal person whose GAS sheet status is lower than “unapproved”, and the GAS sheet can be viewed by the department head. It is possible to make it impossible to input the approval information without displaying.

  Similarly, in steps S133 and S134, the GAS sheet of the appraisal person whose GAS sheet status is lower than “approved” is displayed on the client 2e and can be viewed by the assessment committee member. A predetermined operation for setting the state to “complete” may not be performed.

  If the secondary appraiser is an approver of the primary appraisal, approval information may be input instead of the secondary appraisal. The same applies to the third evaluation.

  In the above embodiment, the department manager is a predetermined assessor that is higher than the primary assessor who inputs the approval information for the target information, but may be a secondary assessor.

  In the above embodiment, the evaluation result received from the client 2e is stored in the storage unit 13, but a recording medium on which the evaluation result is recorded is loaded in the storage unit 13 (for example, a compact disk is attached to the compact disk device). The appraisal result storage means may be configured by mounting).

  Further, in the above-described embodiment, the server 1 is the department head only when the secondary appraisal storage means for storing the secondary appraisal information received from the client 2c, and the primary appraisal information and the secondary appraisal information are equivalent. In response to the secondary appraisal information display request from the client 2d used by the (third appraiser), the secondary appraisal information is transmitted to the client 2d so that it can be displayed and the client 2d inputs the tertiary appraisal information for the secondary appraisal information. The secondary appraisal higher-ranking means to be enabled is included. If the primary appraisal information and the secondary appraisal information are equivalent in the secondary appraisal upper-level submission means, or the secondary appraisal from the client 2a. Only when the consensus information for the information is received (that is, the appraisal agrees to the secondary appraisal), in response to the secondary appraisal information display request from the client 2d, May be capable of inputting cubic appraisals information for secondary evaluation information in the client 2d transmits the Ant 2d can be displayed secondary appraisals information. In addition, regardless of whether the primary appraisal information and the secondary appraisal information are equivalent, the secondary appraisal information display request from the client 2d is received only when the agreement information for the secondary appraisal information is received from the client 2a. Accordingly, the secondary appraisal information may be transmitted to the client 2d in a displayable manner, and the third appraisal information for the secondary appraisal information may be input to the client 2d.

It is a block diagram of the appraisal system containing the appraisal management server which concerns on one Embodiment of this invention. It is a flowchart of a target setting process. It is a flowchart of a target setting process. It is a flowchart of an interview process. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of appraisal processing. It is a flowchart of a feedback process. It is a flowchart of a feedback process. It is an example of the GAS sheet screen for appraisers. It is an example of the GAS sheet screen for an appraisal person. It is an example of a target interview recording screen. It is an example of a target interview record confirmation screen. It is an example of a member list screen. It is an example of a landing prospecting interview screen. It is an example of a landing prospect registration screen. It is an example of a landing prospecting interview recording screen. It is an example of an appraisal information screen. It is an example of a self-assessment screen. It is an example of a primary appraisal screen. It is an example of the screened person list screen for primary appraisers. It is an example of the 1st screen of appraisal interview record. It is an example of the appraisal interview recording second screen. It is an example of an appraisal interview record confirmation screen. It is an example of the screened person list screen for primary appraisers. It is an example of the to-be-examined person list screen for secondary assessors. It is an example of the to-be-examined person list screen for secondary assessors. It is an example of a department appraisal list screen. It is an example of the appraisal result list screen for appraisers. It is an example of the appraisal result screen for appraisers.

Explanation of symbols

1 ... Appraisal management server 2 ... Client device

Claims (7)

An appraisal management server capable of communicating with a plurality of client devices,
Primary appraisal storage means for storing primary appraisal information received from the client device used by the primary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for primary appraiser”);
The primary appraisal information can be displayed on the appraisal client device in response to a primary appraisal information display request from the client device used by the appraisal (hereinafter referred to as “client device for the appraisal”). Appraisal transmission means to transmit to,
Only when the consensus information for the primary appraisal information has been received from the client device for the appraisal, from the client device used by the secondary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for the secondary appraiser”). In response to a primary appraisal information display request, the primary appraisal information is transmitted to the secondary appraiser client device in a displayable manner, and the secondary appraisal information for the primary appraisal information in the secondary appraiser client device is displayed. Alternatively, the primary appraisal higher-level submission means that allows input of approval information,
An appraisal management server characterized by comprising: In response to a request from the client device for primary appraisers, only when the primary appraisal upper submission means has received the agreement information for the primary appraisal information from the client device for appraisers, The primary appraisal submission operation unit for transmitting a request for submitting the next appraisal information to the appraisal management server is transmitted so as to be displayed on the client device for primary appraisers, and the primary appraisal submission operation unit is operated. The primary appraisal client receives the primary appraisal information in response to the primary appraisal information display request from the secondary appraiser client device only when the request for submitting the primary appraisal information has been received by the client. The secondary appraisal client device can transmit the secondary appraisal information or the approval information for the previous primary appraisal information in the client device for secondary appraisers. The appraisal management server according to claim 1.   The system further comprises an appraisal interview request means for transmitting an appraisal interview request to the client device for primary appraisers when disagreement information for the primary appraisal information is received from the client device for appraisers. Item 1 or 2 appraisal management server. Target storage means for storing target information received from the client device for the appraisal;
In response to a target information display request from the primary appraiser client device, target transmission means for transmitting the target information to the primary appraiser client device in a displayable manner;
A target interview record storage means for storing a target interview record received from the primary appraiser client device for the target information;
In response to a target interview record display request from the client device for the appraisal, target interview record transmission means for transmitting the target interview record to be displayed on the client device for the appraisal,
The client device (hereinafter referred to as “upper assessor client”) used by a predetermined assessor higher than the primary assessor only when the agreement information for the target interview record has already been received from the client device for the assessee. In response to a target information display request from the “device”), the target information can be transmitted to the higher appraiser client device in a displayable manner, and approval information for the target information can be input in the higher appraiser client device. Goal higher-level submission means and
The appraisal management server according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized by comprising: A prospective entry requesting means for transmitting a prospective entry request to the client apparatus for the assessed person in response to a request for filling out the target achievement prospect from the client apparatus for the primary assessor;
A prospect storage means for storing a goal achievement prospect (hereinafter referred to as “prospect information”) received from the client device for the appraisal;
A line-of-sight transmission means for transmitting the line-of-sight information in a displayable manner to the client apparatus for the primary assessor in response to a line-of-sight information display request from the client apparatus for the primary assessor;
A line-of-sight interview record storage means for storing a line-of-sight interview record received from the client device for the primary assessor with respect to the line-of-sight information;
A line-of-sight interview record transmission means for transmitting the line-of-sight interview record so as to be displayed on the client apparatus for the examinee in response to a line-of-sight interview record display request from the client apparatus for the examinee;
A prospect re-interview request means for transmitting a prospect interview request to the primary assessor client apparatus when receiving disagreement information for the prospect interview record from the client apparatus for the examinee;
The appraisal management server according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized by comprising: An appraisal result storage means for storing appraisal results;
Only when the request for disclosure of the appraisal result has been received from the client device for the primary appraiser, the appraisal result is sent to the client for the appraisal in response to the appraisal result display request from the client device for the appraisal. An appraisal result transmission means for transmitting to the apparatus in a displayable manner;
The appraisal management server according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized by comprising: A computer that can communicate with multiple client devices
Primary appraisal storage means for storing primary appraisal information received from the client device used by the primary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for primary appraiser”);
The primary appraisal information can be displayed on the appraisal client device in response to a primary appraisal information display request from the client device used by the appraisal (hereinafter referred to as “client device for the appraisal”). Appraisal transmission means to send to
as well as,
Only when the consensus information for the primary appraisal information has been received from the client device for the appraisal, from the client device used by the secondary appraiser (hereinafter referred to as “client device for the secondary appraiser”). In response to a primary appraisal information display request, the primary appraisal information is transmitted to the secondary appraiser client device in a displayable manner, and the secondary appraisal information for the primary appraisal information in the secondary appraiser client device is displayed. Or the primary appraisal higher submission means that allows you to enter approval information,
Program to function as.

Images