WO2009025659A1

WO2009025659A1 - Variable case depth powder metal gear and method thereof

Info

Publication number: WO2009025659A1
Application number: PCT/US2007/076170
Authority: WO
Inventors: Timothy E. Geiman
Original assignee: Gkn Sinter Metals, Llc
Priority date: 2007-08-17
Filing date: 2007-08-17
Publication date: 2009-02-26
Also published as: DE112007003622T5; CN101827673B; CN101827673A; JP2010537047A; DE112007003622B4; JP5443358B2

Abstract

A gear and a method of making a forged powder metal gear having a plurality of teeth and a variable case depth profile forged in the plurality of teeth. Each tooth of the plurality of teeth has a first surface and a tooth root. A variable case depth profile is formed in each tooth of the plurality of teeth, whereby the variable case depth profile exhibits greater tooth wear resistance on the first surface and greater impact resistance in the tooth root.

Description

Variable Case Depth Powder Metal Gear and Method Thereof

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a forged powder metal part and more particularly to a variable case depth powder metal part, including a method of manufacture thereof.

Background Of The Invention

[0002] There is continuing demand for manufacturing processes that may lessen the cost, time or steps in producing a part. More often than not, the benefits resultantly associated with improving the manufacturing process are necessitated in the first instance by customer requirements to develop and improve products to have superior dimensional, mechanical and/ or performance properties. For instance a typical differential side gear may have any or all of the following performance requirements such as: the spline area requiring dimensional precision, high shear strength and brinnelling resistance; the hub and thrust faces requiring dimensional precision, surface finish and case compatibility; the gear geometry requiring dimensional precision, surface finish and optimised profile; and the tooth and core strength may require impact resistance, wear resistance, spalling resistance, and different surface and core metallurgies. Different non-compatible manufacturing processes, i.e. casting, steel forging or powder metal forging, obtain different performance requirements for the same part, advantageously or otherwise.

[0003] Referring to Figure 1, in order to meet some of these performance requirements, a gear 10 is made by forging a powder metal 14 and then case carburizing the gear to achieve a nearly constant effective case depth 16. The constant effective case depth 16 for each gear tooth 12 is shown in the partial cross-sectional view of Figure 1. The parameters to be controlled to achieve nearly constant carburization of a fully dense part of specific hardness, case depth and carbon gradient are generally known.

6162046 . 1 However, a nearly constant case depth does not necessarily achieve desired mechanical properties such as enhanced tooth wear and fatigue strength. It would be advantageous to achieve a better-controlled balance of these performance requirements in the final product, uncompromised by the manufacturing process thereby saving time, processing or cost.

[0004] A manufacturing process to improve the performance requirements of powder metal parts in a process known today as "sint-carb" is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,992,763 titled "Method of Making Powdered Metal Parts." The process teaches carburization during or subsequent to sintering, and prior to forging, to enhance the case depth at a critical wall of the final forged product, eliminating the need for subsequent heat treating processes for achieving a case hardness. U.S. Pat. No. 4,002,471 titled "Method of Making a Through-Hardened Scale-Free Forged Powdered Metal Article Without Heat Treatment After Forging", discloses a method of making forged powder iron base metal articles of high Rc hardness without need for further machining, surface treatment or heat treatment after quenching.

[0005] However, the above-mentioned patents do not teach or suggest any processes in which a variable case depth may be obtained in a final forged product to enhance performance features such as improved load bearing upon the tooth flank of a gear while providing impact resistance and bending fatigue resistance upon the tooth root.

[0006] Therefore, there is a need for a variable case depth powder metal gear exhibiting improved tooth wear resistance and load bearing at its flank surface, and improved impact resistance and bending fatigue in the tooth root. There is also a need for a method of manufacture of a variable case depth powder metal gear.

Summary Of The Invention

[0007] In accordance with the above mentioned needs, a gear and a method of making a forged powder metal gear having a plurality of teeth and a variable case depth profile forged in the plurality of teeth is disclosed. Each tooth of the plurality of teeth has a first surface and a tooth root. A variable case depth profile is formed in each tooth of the plurality of teeth, whereby the variable case depth profile exhibits improved tooth wear resistance or load bearing on the first surface, and improved impact resistance and bending fatigue in the tooth root or core.

Brief Description Of The Drawings

[0008] For a more complete understanding of this invention, reference should now be made to the inventive aspects illustrated in greater detail in the accompanying drawings and described below.

[0009] Figure 1 shows a partial cross-sectional view of a case carburized gear.

[0010] Figure 2 shows a partial cross-sectional view of a first differential side gear inventively having a variable case depth profile in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.

[0011] Figure 3 shows the microstructure below the effective case depth of the inventive gear shown in Figure 2.

[0012] Figure 4 shows the microstructure within the effective case depth of the inventive gear shown in Figure 2.

[0013] Figure 5 shows an isometric view of a preform after sintering representative of aspects of the invention required to obtain the inventive product after forging.

[0014] Figure 6 shows a partial cross-sectional view of the representative preform of Figure 5 after carburization process.

[0015] Figure 7 shows an isometric view of the first differential side gear of

Figure 2 made from the preform of Figure 6 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. [0016] Figure 8 shows a schematic layout of an embodiment of a process according to the invention to obtain a variable case depth powder metal gear.

Detailed Description

[0017] In all figures, the same reference numerals are used to identify like parts in the various views. Thus, simultaneous reference to the various figures is appropriate. In some instances, for clarity, equivalent parts in different figures may have different item numbers.

[0018] Figure 2 shows a partial cross-sectional view of a first differential side gear 50 having a variable case depth profile 58 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. Figure 7 shows an isometric view of the first differential side gear 50 of Figure 2 made from the preform 85 of Figure 6 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.

[0019] The first differential side gear 50 includes plurality of teeth 52 and a variable case depth profile 58. Each tooth of the plurality of teeth 52 has a first surface 54 and a tooth core or root 56. The first differential side gear 50 has a rotational axis 60, wherein the teeth 52 extend radially in the same general direction as the rotational axis of the gear, but are inclined with respect to the rotational axis. The first differential side gear 50 further includes an axially splined internal section 62 axially aligned with the rotational axis 60.

[0020] The variable case depth profile 58 is formed in the plurality of teeth 52.

The variable case depth profile 58 advantageously provides a gear having greater tooth wear resistance on the first surface 54 and greater impact resistance in the tooth root 56. The variable case depth profile 58 is representative of the effective case depth profile achieved after forging, by carbon diffusion prior to forging the gear. The variable case depth profile 58 resultantly achieved by the forging process is discussed herein. [0021] While the process is described with respect to a differential side gear 50, it is anticipated that the variable case depth profile 58 may be achieved on other parts or gears, including bevel, differential or pinion gears, without limitation.

[0022] The differential side gear 50 may be made from a low alloy, fully compacted, ferrous powder metal material. However, it is anticipated that the gear may be made of various other types of forged powder metal steels.

[0023] Turning to Figure 2, the first surface 54 of each tooth of the differential side gear 50 includes a tip surface 64, a pitch line surface 66, a root fillet surface 68 and a root diameter or land surface 70. The variable case depth profile 58 is substantially represented by effective case depth of: 2.4 mm at the tip surface 64; 1.9 mm at the pitch line surface 66; 0.4 mm at the root fillet surface 68; and 0.8 mm at the root land surface 70. This results from the carbon diffusion and subsequent forging of a preform. While specific numbers are presented in the present embodiment, it is recognized that the variable case depth may have any non-constant effective case depth profile over a particular surface cross-section and is not limited to the specific profile here presented.

[0024] The variable case depth profile 58 may also be represented by a case depth ratio. The effective case depth ratio is given by comparing case depths measured at the tip surface 64 to the root fillet surface 68, the pitch line surface 66 to the root fillet surface 68, or the root land surface 70 to the root fillet surface 68. For example, the variable case depth ratio for the tip surface 64 to the root fillet surface 68 is 6:1, the pitch line surface 66 to the root fillet surface 68 is 19:4, and the root land surface 70 to the root fillet surface 68 is 2:1. A case depth ratio of nearly 1:1 is considered to be within the effective range of a constant case depth 16 of the gear 10 shown in Figure 1.

[0025] Advantageously, the case depth ratio may be 6:1 over the variable case depth profile 58 from the greatest depth to the shallower depth of effective case hardness, thereby achieving greater mechanical properties such as tooth wear and impact resistance. [0026] The tooth root 56 of the gear 50 may include a mid-tooth section 74 having hardness of about 43 HRC, a root section 76 having hardness of about 31 HRC and a core section 78 having hardness of about 32 HRC. While these hardness numbers are only representative of a gear having improved mechanical properties, a core hardness ratio is obtained between the mid-tooth section 74 and the root or core sections 76, 78 of nearly 4 to 3. A higher core hardness ratio is representative of a gear having greater tooth impact resistance, i.e. ductility. Whereas a gear, like the one represented in Figure 1, would have nearly a 1 to 1 core hardness ratio and thus, less ductility.

[0027] Figure 3 shows the microstructure below the effective case depth of the inventive gear shown in Figure 2, and Figure 4 shows the microstructure within the effective case depth of the inventive gear shown in Figure 2. The depth boundary is the point where the effective carbon content of the material becomes nearly constant and may be effectively represented by the variable case depth profile 58.

[0028] Turning to the method of making the inventive variable case depth powder metal gear, a process is shown in Figure 8. The process begins with the steps of mixing 20 and continues with some of the possible steps of filling 22, compacting 24, sintering 26, carburizing 28, preheating 30, variable forging 32, and cooling 34. Post forging operations 36 may also be used to further enhance the gear. For brevity, and because some of these process steps are well known to those in the art of forging powder metals, only certain aspects of the inventive process are discussed below. In this regard, material selection, temperature processing and compaction pressures are discussed only briefly.

[0029] The mixing step 20 readies the metal powder, including any needed binders or lubricants, by mixing until a nearly uniform mixture is achieved ready for filling into a compacting form during the filling step 22. The compacting step 24 comprises compacting a metal powder into a preform having a nearly uniform initial carbon content throughout the preform. The initial carbon content is achieved by mixing of the metal powder with constituent amounts of graphite together with necessary binders or lubricants to make the preform. The preform includes at least one cross-sectional surface in which the final forged part resultantly obtains a variable case depth profile, as discussed herein.

[0030] The sintering and carburizing steps 26, 28 may be accomplished simultaneously or the carburizing step may be completed after sintering of the preform. Sintering the preform binds the metal powder. Carburizing the preform substantially increases the initial carbon content in developing a carbon gradient from the surface of the preform into the core. The carbon gradient is produced by providing a controlled carbon atmosphere and maintaining the preform in the controlled atmosphere for a predetermined period of time. It is necessary to obtain a substantially constant carbon case depth in the preform in order to enhance critical flow of metal during forging for achieving the desired variable case depth profile in the post forged part. Of course, density gradient, part geometry and carburizing conditions dictate the uniformity of the carburizing process. The case depth of carbon necessary in the preform is determined by the preform geometry and the desired areas of critical metal flow during forging. To achieve the variable case depth profile in gear 50 mentioned above as measured by the ratios presented, the preform is carburized to a case depth of 1 /4 the tooth height, but may also be satisfied by carburizing to a case depth of 1/20 the tooth height or to 7/8 the tooth height. It is anticipated that too little case depth in the preform may result in non-carburized areas. It is also anticipated that too much case depth in the preform may result in a nearly constant case depth profile. Figure 6 shows a partial cross- sectional view of the carburized preform 85 of the representative preform 84 of Figure 5 after carburization process. The preform 85 has substantially constant carbon case depth 86 achieved after sintering and carburizing the preform.

[0031] The variable forging step 32 comprises forging the carburized preform at a forge temperature and a forge pressure to obtain a substantially dense, net shape, part. The variable case depth profile for the gear results in nearly symmetrical profiles for each tooth because of the symmetrical nature of the forging dies and the carburized preform. However, it is recognized that different carburization schemes and forging steps may be used to obtain multiple variable case depth profiles.

[0032] The variable case depth profile is achieved by utilizing a die set of the forge to variably enhance critical flow of the carburized metal portion during the forging process. Essentially, the constant case depth of the carburized powder metal preform is strategically compressed into the die sections, wherein portions of the preform are stretched and thinned during forging and other portions of the preform are thickened and deepened with the carburized powder metal. Again, case depth that is too shallow or too deep in the carburized powder metal preform prior to forging will not produce the variable case depth profile in the final product.

[0033] The cooling step 34 allows the forged part to obtain a particular metallurgy resulting in a gear having the desired variable case depth profile. Cooling of the forged part may be by quenching in oil, water, air or by other methods suitable to the powder metal forging process.

[0034] Prior to cooling, including a dwelling step of the forged part for a dwell period may allow for enhanced properties by allowing temperature stabilization of the material of the part.

[0035] The optional preheating step of the preform to a pre-forge temperature prior to forging may enhance the desired metal flow during the forging process.

[0036] Optional post forging operations step 36 may include, turning, facing, surface grinding, splining, and broaching of the product depending upon final specification requirements, thereby being ready for washing, packing, or shipping.

[0037] With proper selection and combinations of powder metal, compaction dies, processing times, processing temperatures, processing pressures, forging dies, and cooling method, a near net shape, fully dense product may be obtained having the variable case depth profile, thereby requiring minimal if any machining operations facilitating cost savings and performance improvements. [0038] While various process steps have been presented, they are intended only to be limited in scope or order as indicated in the claims of this invention. Further, while the invention has been described in connection with several embodiments, it should be understood that the invention is not limited to those embodiments. Thus, the invention covers all alternatives, modifications, and equivalents as may be included in the spirit and scope of the appended claims.

Claims

What Is Claimed Is:

1. A gear comprising: a plurality of teeth, each tooth having a first surface and a tooth root; and a variable case depth profile formed in said plurality of teeth, whereby said variable case depth profile exhibits improved tooth loading on said first surface and improved bending fatigue in said tooth root.

2. The gear of claim 1 wherein said gear is a bevel gear, said bevel gear having a rotational axis, said teeth extending radially in the same general direction as said rotational axis of said bevel gear, but inclined with respect to said rotational axis of said bevel gear.

3. The gear of claim 2 wherein said bevel gear is a differential side gear, said differential side gear having an axially splined internal section.

4. The gear of claim 1 wherein said gear is a low alloy ferrous metal gear.

5. The gear of claim 1 wherein said first surface of each tooth comprises a tip surface, a pitch line surface, a root fillet surface and a root land surface.

6. The gear of claim 5 wherein said variable case depth profile is substantially represented by effective case depth of approximately 2.4 mm at said tip surface, approximately 1.9 mm at said pitch line surface, approximately 0.4 mm at said root fillet surface and approximately 0.8 mm at said root land surface.

7. The gear of claim 5 wherein said variable case depth profile is represented by a case depth ratio of said root land surface to said root fillet surface of approximately 2:1.

8. The gear of claim 5 wherein said variable case depth profile is represented by an effective case depth ratio of said tip surface to said root fillet surface of approximately 6:1.

9. The gear of claim 1 wherein said tooth root comprises a mid-tooth section having hardness of about 43 HRC, a root section having hardness of about 31 HRC and a core section having hardness of about 32 HRC.

10. The gear of claim 1 wherein said tooth root comprises a mid-tooth section, a root section and a core section, having a core hardness ratio between said mid-tooth section and said root or core sections of approximately 4:3.

11. A method for obtaining a gear made from powder metal having a variable case depth profile formed in a plurality of teeth comprising the sequential steps of: compacting a metal powder into a preform having a nearly uniform initial carbon content throughout said preform, said preform having at least one cross- sectional surface desired to have a variable case depth profile; sintering and carburizing, sequentially or simultaneously, said preform at a desired temperature, said carburizing substantially increasing an initial carbon content to provide a controlled carbon atmosphere, and maintaining said preform in said controlled atmosphere for a predetermined period of time to obtain a substantially constant carbon case depth; forging said preform at a forge temperature and a forge pressure to obtain a substantially dense, net shape, forged part with said variable case depth profile symmetrical about said plurality of teeth, wherein said variable case depth profile is achieved by utilizing a die set of the forge to variably enhance critical flow of metal while forming said plurality of teeth of said forged part during forging; and cooling said forged part.

12. The method of claim 11 further comprising preheating said preform to a pre-forge temperature prior to forging, and cooling said forged part by quenching.

13. The method of claim 11 further comprising dwelling said forged part for a dwell period to allow for temperature stabilization after forging and prior to quenching.

14. The method of claim 11 further comprising splining said gear after cooling.

15. The method of claim 11 comprising, after cooling, scaling, surfacing, turning, or shot peening.

16. The method of claim 11 wherein said metal powder is a low alloy ferrous metal powder.

17. A bevel gear produced in accordance with the method of claim 11, said bevel gear having a rotational axis, and said plurality of teeth comprising a plurality of radial teeth, said radial teeth extending in the same general direction as the rotational axis of said bevel gear, but inclined with respect to the rotational axis of said bevel gear.

18. The bevel gear according to claim 17, wherein the bevel gear is a splined differential side gear.

19. The method of claim 11 wherein said gear is near net shape after forging and cooling.

20. A gear produced in accordance with a process for obtaining a powder metal part having a variable case depth profile substantially symmetrical about a plurality of teeth comprising the sequential steps of: compacting a metal powder into a preform having a nearly uniform initial carbon content throughout said preform, said preform having at least one cross- sectional surface desired to have a variable case depth profile; sintering and carburizing, sequentially or simultaneously, said preform at a desired temperature, said carburizing substantially increasing an initial carbon content to provide a controlled carbon atmosphere, and maintaining said preform in said controlled atmosphere for a predetermined period of time to obtain a substantially constant carbon case depth; forging said preform at a desired temperature to a desired density to obtain said forged part with said variable case depth profile symmetrical about said plurality of teeth, wherein said variable case depth profile is achieved by utilizing a designed die set in a forge to variably enhance critical flow of metal while forming said plurality of teeth of said forged part during forging; and cooling said forged part.

21. The gear of claim 20 wherein said variable case depth profile is represented by a case depth ratio satisfied by at least one of a root land surface to a root fillet surface of approximately 2:1, a tip surface to said root fillet surface of approximately 6:1, or a pitch line surface to said root fillet surface of approximately 19:4.

22. A powder forged gear, comprising: a plurality of teeth, each tooth having a first surface including a tooth tip surface and a tooth root surface; and a variable case depth profile formed in said first surfaces of said plurality of teeth, whereby said variable case depth profile of each first surface has a depth at the tooth tip surface that is deeper than the depth at the tooth root surface, said case depth profile being formed by carburizing, prior to forging, a surface of a powder metal preform of the gear that becomes the first surface of the gear after forging to a substantially constant depth, and forging the carburized preform to cause the case depth of the carburized surface between the tooth tip surface and the tooth root surface to be reduced so as to impart different wear, fatigue strength and impact resistance characteristics between the tooth tip surface and the tooth root surface.