EP3114524B1

EP3114524B1 - Relay lens system for broadband imaging

Info

Publication number: EP3114524B1
Application number: EP15758256.0A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Frederick Allen MOORE
Original assignee: Stryker European Operations Ltd
Current assignee: Stryker European Operations Ltd
Priority date: 2014-03-04
Filing date: 2015-03-03
Publication date: 2021-09-22
Anticipated expiration: 2035-03-03
Also published as: CA2941273C; US12004716B2; US20220218179A1; KR101949571B1; JP2017509019A; WO2015131278A1; CA2941273A1; KR20160127121A; JP2019049730A; US11304592B2; CN106605164A; CN106605164B; US20150256721A1; EP3114524A4; EP3114524A1; JP6660444B2

Description

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present disclosure relates generally to the field of optical lens systems.
More specifically, the disclosure relates to rod-type relay lens systems for use in broadband imaging.

BACKGROUND

Medical endoscopes are used to view internal body organs and tissue through small openings created in and through the body wall or skin or by way of existing openings or orifices. For example, fluorescence endoscopy is an endoscopic examination method in which fluorescent dye is administered to patients and excited with light having a specific excitation wavelength.
The excited fluorescent dye emits light of a specific emission wavelength, which is longer than the excitation wavelength, so that visualization of tissue and/or vessels containing the dye can be enhanced relative to conventional white-light endoscopy.
US 2008/0273247 discloses an optical device which comprises an elongated tube configured for insertion into a body and optical members located in the tube. The optical members are configured to have an optical invariant- to-clear aperture semidiameter ratio greater than about 0.05 and an optical path difference less than about a value of the optical invariant divided by at least 250 times a midrange wavelength in a spectral range from about 435.8 nm to about 656.3 nm, and are preferably formed of an extraordinary dispersion optical material. A method includes conducting polychromatic light through at least one optical member located in an elongated tube configured for insertion into a body, where the optical members have an optical invariant to- clear aperture semidiameter ratio greater than about 0.05 and an optical path difference less than about a value of an optical invariant divided by at least 250 times the midrange wavelength from about 435.8 to about 656.3 nm.
US 2013/0194667 is directed to provide a clear, bright optical image by suitably correcting a secondary spectrum. The latter is achieved by providing a rigid-scope optical system including: an objective optical system; and at least one relay optical systems that are formed of positive front groups, middle groups, and back groups in this order from an entrance side and that reimage an optical image imaged at imaging planes at the entrance side onto imaging planes at an exit side, wherein axial chromatic aberration between two wavelengths is corrected by an optical system other than the diffractive optical element, and axial chromatic aberration between the two wavelengths and another wavelength is corrected by the diffractive optical element.

SUMMARY

According to a first aspect is provided an optical system, including a first relay rod of a first material, a second relay rod of a second material, different from the first material, and a lens between the first and second relay rods.
The first and second materials are selected to reduce the wavefront error across the field of view of the optical system as compared with using a same material for both the first and second relay rods. The first and second relay rods may have no optical power. The first and second relay rods may have no optically powered surfaces.
The first and second relay rods are geometrically symmetric to one another relative to a pupil or conjugate pupil of the optical system. The lens includes a first relay objective and a second relay objective. The first and second relay objectives may have a same design and material. A pupil region of the system may be in air. The pupil or conjugate pupil are located between the first and second relay rods.
The optical system may include a third relay rod of a third material, a fourth relay rod of a fourth material, the fourth material being different from the third material; and a lens between the third and fourth relay rods. The first and third materials are the same and the second and fourth materials may be the same.
The optical system may include a detector to detect light from 460 nm to 850 nm.
The optical system may be in an endoscope.
According to a second aspect is provided a method of compensating for dispersion in a relay lens system, the method including providing a first relay rod of a first material, providing a second relay rod of a second material, different from the first material, and providing a lens between the first and second relay rods.
The lens includes a first relay objective and a second relay objective.
The first and second materials are selected to reduce the wavefront error across the field of view of the optical system as compared with using a same material for both the first and second relay rods (116, 126).
The first and second relay rods (116, 126) are geometrically symmetric to one another relative to a pupil or conjugate pupil of the optical system, the pupil or conjugate pupil being located between the first and second relay rods.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Features will become apparent to those of skill in the art by describing in detail exemplary embodiments with reference to the attached drawings in which:

FIGS. 1A and IB illustrate a relay pair according to an embodiment;
FIG. 1C illustrates a plurality of relay pairs according to an embodiment;
FIG. 2 illustrates how index and Abbe values interplay through a relay set;
FIG. 3 is a graph of refractive index versus wavelength for exemplary glass types;
FIG. 4 is a graph illustrating partial dispersion versus inverse dispersion for various glass types;
FIG. 5 is a graph illustrating refractive index versus Abbe number for exemplary glasses; and
FIGS. 6A to 6C illustrate plots of MTF versus spatial frequency for comparative examples and an example according to an embodiment.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Example embodiments will now be described more fully hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings; however, they may be embodied in different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein. Rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will be thorough and complete, and will fully convey exemplary implementations to those skilled in the art. Generally, corresponding or similar reference numbers will be used, when possible, throughout the drawings to refer to the same or corresponding parts.
Optical design requirements for endoscopes have changed with the introduction of new technologies, such as image sensors and solid state illumination. An endoscope designed for visual use only may be optimized for F,d,C light, which spans the region of 486 nm through to 656 nm. An endoscope designed for machine vision, where a camera will display an image on a monitor, may operate with illumination wavelengths extending further into the blue, for example to 460 nm. Additionally, there is demand to visualize tissue and body structures in other waveband regimes beyond that of visible bands, e.g., near infrared regions (700 nm to 900 nm) where tissue is maximally transparent to light and where dyes such as Indocyanine Green (ICG) fluoresce and are used as markers. Additionally, the resolution required of endoscopes has increased with the introduction of high definition (HD) video image sensors having smaller and more numerous pixels than earlier NTSC or PAL formats. In both diagnostic and therapeutic procedures where endoscopes are used, it is advantageous to provide guiding imagery and fluorescent markers. Accordingly, high resolution imaging is desired in the visible bands as well as in longer wavelength regions beyond that of human vision.
Imaging optical systems, including endoscopes, must be designed with the operational wavelengths in mind. The refractive properties of materials are such that light of different wavelengths will propagate along slightly different paths through an optical system, and arrive at slightly different image planes. In order to ensure that the image planes for different wavelengths are sufficiently close so as not to degrade image quality, the design of the system must take into consideration these refractive properties.
A system designed for use across a broadband of wavelengths, e.g., between 460 nm to 850 nm, may have one or more image sensors. If the system has two sensors, e.g., one for the visible region and one for the near infrared region, then the design of the system may consider separately the problems of image quality for the visible and image quality for the near infrared region, since each region will have its own corresponding sensor. If however, the system operates with a single image sensor, then the system must focus all light throughout its operational waveband onto one image plane. This latter condition is more difficult, but also offers more utility to the remainder of the design, as a single sensor maybe used.
A system designed for broadband use, for example visible and near infrared, and designed for single sensor operation, requires tight control over chromatic aberrations, such as axial color. Light of different wavelengths focus at different distances from the optics. Axial color arises from dispersion, i.e., the variation of refractive index versus wavelength in refractive materials. Sensitivity to dispersion increases as the f/# is faster. Therefore, one or more embodiments are directed to providing a relay lens system that offsets the effect of dispersion as light propagates through the system, as discussed in detail below.
According to an embodiment, there is provided an optical system comprising a first relay rod of a first material, a second relay rod of a second material, different from the first material, and a lens between the first and second relay rods. The lens includes a first relay objective and a second relay objective. The first and second materials are selected to reduce the wavefront error across the field of view of the optical system as compared with using a same material for both the first and second relay rods. In other embodiments, the first and second relay rods have no optical power, or have no optically powered surfaces. The first and second relay rods are geometrically symmetric to one another relative to a pupil or conjugate pupil of the optical system.
In yet another embodiment, the optical system may further comprise a third relay rod of a third material, a fourth relay rod of a fourth material, the fourth material being different from the third material, and a lens between the third and fourth relay rods. In an embodiment, the first and third materials are the same and the second and fourth materials are the same.
FIGS. 1A and IB illustrate an exemplary relay pair 100 for a broadband system using a single detector. FIG. 1A illustrates the on-axis beam and FIG. IB illustrates the off-axis beam. FIG. 1C illustrates an odd number of relay pairs to produce an upright image at a detector 200. In particular, the image after an objective lens 10 is inverted, so any odd number of relay pairs, e.g., 1, 3, 5, 7, and so forth, will produce an upright image.
The relay pair includes a first relay rod lens assembly 110 and a second relay rod lens assembly 120. Each of the first and second relay rod lens assemblies 110, 120 includes a rod 116, 126, respectively, and a plurality of bonded lenses selected to provide color correction from a lower limit, e.g., 460 nm, to an upper limit, e.g., 850 nm. In particular, the bonded lenses may include a relay field lens 102 and a relay objective 104, here both shown as doublets.
The rods 116, 126 are made of different materials that compensate for residual wavefront error in the relay pair 100 as illustrated in FIG. 2. The diffraction-limited relay pair in FIG. 2 illustrates refractive index symmetry about the pupil region P, and Abbe number asymmetry about the pupil region P.
The relay pair 100 operates with unit magnification. The bonded lenses of the relay rod lens assemblies 110 and 120 are symmetric or mirrored about a pupil (or aperture stop) 130 between the first and second relay rod assemblies 110, 120. In other words, the relay field lenses 102 and the relay objectives 104 are the same, i.e., the same material, the same prescription, and so forth, throughout the relay pair 100.
Although a design is optimized based on wavefront error and MTF performance, and although this process will offset some aberrations through constructive introduction of other aberrations, it may be helpful to explore the problem in traditional terms, such as may be found by considering the system in terms of Seidel errors. While typical, symmetrical design of the relay pair will correct for odd Seidel aberrations, e.g., coma, distortion, lateral chromatic aberration, and so forth, even Seidel aberrations, e.g., spherical, astigmatism, field curvature, axial chromatic, and so forth, are not corrected by such symmetry. Axial chromatic aberration is of particular concern as the wavelength bandwidth increases, while the image plane remains constrained to a single detector. Additional lenses or different lenses on different sides of the relay pupil may be used to correct for the dispersion, but this increases cost and complexity.
However, by using different materials for the relay rod in the first and second relay rod lens assemblies 110, 120 in accordance with an embodiment, the basic form of the relay pair 100 may be maintained. In other words, since the material of the relay rods introduce dispersion themselves, by selecting appropriate materials for the relay rods 116, 126 in the first and second relay rod lens assemblies 110, 120, the
dispersion over the relay pair 100 may be compensated, while otherwise using the same elements throughout the relay pair 100. The relay rod carries no optical power, but instead is used to make the space between powered elements appear to have a shorter optical path distance, without using total internal reflection.
Thus, by treating the material of the relay rod as another degree of freedom, dispersion in the relay pair 100 may be altered, i.e., corrected, without modifying the basic form. The relay rod lens assemblies 110 and 120 will have nearly identical focal lengths in order to meet the required unit magnification. The first rod 116 and the second rod 126 are symmetrical to one another relative to the pupil. However, as noted above, the first rod 116 is made of a first glass type and the second rod 126 is made of a second glass type. The second glass type is different from the first glass type. In design, the first glass type and the second glass type are selected to reduce residual wavefront error within the optical system. Otherwise, the pair of relay and rod lens assembly is identically configured, e.g., identical lengths, identical lens elements, identical geometric form, and so forth, while using different rod materials.
Referring to FIG. 3, it can be seen that for any wavelength, different materials have different local tangents (derivatives). Thus, glass materials not only exhibit different aggregate dispersion (different inverse Abbe numbers) but also exhibit different partial dispersion, which is a measure of dispersion over a subset of the bandwidth. FIG. 4 illustrates how partial dispersion (P¾F) varies with inverse dispersion (Abbe number or Va) for SCHOTT®'s optical glass assortment.
Relay rod glass material is selected first for its transmission properties; a designer may build a design-specific list of materials ranked according to transmission, then draw upon the top candidates for their remainder attributes (such as index,
dispersion, thermal coefficient, etc). In general, optical glasses that are reasonably well suited for use in relay rods tend to occur at abbe numbers between 35 and 65, and indices of refraction between 1.5 and 1.65 (refer to the plot of refractive index versus Abbe number of FIG. 5, in which some suitable glasses made by SCHOTT® with Abbe numbers between 50 and 65 include, e.g., N-PSK3, N-BALF5, N-SK2, N-BAK2, N-K5 and N-KF9). Glasses that will form the outer elements may be then selected based on other design requirements, such as their thermal coefficients relative to their neighbor glass on the other side of a lens bond. Optimization for minimum wavefront error across all field positions will drive the form to be symmetric about the pupil in regard to index of refraction, and asymmetric about the pupil in regard to Abbe number (or inverse dispersion). An example of a diffraction-limited solution is illustrated in FIG. 2. The outer elements, i.e., the relay objectives and field lenses will be the same on both sides of the relay pupil. The focal lengths for each relay rod lens assembly are nearly identical, but the partial dispersions of the relay rod lens assemblies due to the different rod materials have compensatory effects on residual wavefront error.
FIGS. 6A to 6C illustrate dispersion in a comparative example and an example according to an embodiment. FIG. 6A shows a plot of the modulus of the optical transfer function (OTF) (MTF) versus spatial frequency in cycles per mm for an F/4.5 relay in which the same material, here N-PSK3, is used for both relay rods in a relay system for a 30 cm visible-near infrared endoscope having three relay pairs. FIG. 6B shows a plot of MTF versus spatial frequency in which elements of the same relay system as used for FIG. 6A are used, except the same material for the relay rods is N-BALF5. FIG. 6C shows a plot of MTF versus spatial frequency in which elements of the same relay system as used for FIG. 6A are used, except different materials are used for the relay rods on opposite sides of the relay pupil. For example, a first material, here N-PSK3, is used for the first relay rod, and a second material, here N-BALF5, is used for the second material. The comparing FIGS. 6A to 6C, the MTF for the transverse off-axis ray is significantly improved by use two different materials for the relay rods.
By way of summation and review, endoscopes typically include a long, thin, rigid or semi-rigid optical cylinder that is mounted on or to a viewing mechanism or imager. When the endoscope is inserted and positioned for use, an image of the object being viewed is formed by an objective lens at the inserted or distal end of the endoscope. The image passes through a relay lens system, comprising of one or more sets of relay lenses, along the cylinder to a viewer comprising an eyepiece or viewing lens or a video camera or imager at the viewing or proximal end of the endoscope.
A relay lens system will reconstruct the image formed at the objective lens one or more times, depending on the number of relays used. A single relay will form one image. Additional relays may be used to form additional images. The purpose of these elements is not to produce many images, but rather to carry the image field to another position. Endoscopes are narrow in order to reduce the size of an incision. Endoscopes are long because the object under study may be deep within the body. The image formed by the objective lens at the distal end is relayed along the length of the endoscope to the proximal end by the relay lens system.
When used in endoscopes, the relay lenses may be very narrow, e.g., less than 6.5 mm in diameter and approximately 20 mm to 50 mm long. Most endoscopes require three or more sets of relay lenses for proper operation. The number of lenses generally depends on the length and specific requirements of the particular endoscope and/or the application for which it is intended. Because the objective and each relay set is producing an image with unit magnification which is turned upside down, and because a standard endoscope should produce an upright image, usually an odd number of relay lenses are used so that the image produced by the optical system at the ocular or at the detector, is upright.
For good image quality, the optical system of an endoscope should be well corrected for the major lens aberrations. A relay lens typically operates with unit magnification with lenses configured to be symmetric about the relay's internal stop plane, i.e., the pupil within the relay. This set of conditions will result in the odd Seidel aberrations formed by the lenses before the relay's pupil to be cancelled out by the lenses after the relay's pupil. However, the even Seidel aberrations are not corrected. As noted above, these even Seidel aberrations may become more problematic as an operational waveband over which the optical system is to perform increases.
According to an embodiment discussed above, using different materials for relay rods on opposite sides of the relay pupil may allow dispersion to be compensated without changing the basic form of the relay. In other words, by using different rod materials on opposite sides of the relay pupil, other elements, e.g., objectives and field lenses, on opposite sides of the relay pupil may be identical, such that the pair of relay rod lens assemblies are otherwise identically configured, e.g., identical lengths, identical lens elements, identical geometric form, and so forth, while using different rod materials.
According to another embodiment, there is further provided a method of compensating for dispersion in a relay lens system. The method comprises providing a first relay rod of a first material, providing a second relay rod of a second material, different from the first material, and providing a lens between the first and second relay rods.
As an example, there is provided a kit comprising a first relay rod of a first material, a second relay rod of a second material, different from the first material, and a lens to be inserted between the first and second relay rods.
The lens includes a first relay objective and a second relay objective. In an embodiment, the first and second relay objectives have a same design and material.
Example embodiments have been disclosed herein, and although specific terms are employed, they are used and are to be interpreted in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purpose of limitation. In some instances, as would be apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art as of the filing of the present application, features, characteristics, and/or elements described in connection with a particular embodiment may be used singly or in combination with features, characteristics, and/or elements described in connection with other embodiments unless otherwise specifically indicated. Accordingly, it will be understood by those of skill in the art that various changes in form and details may be made without departing from the invention as set forth in the following claims. For example, while specific examples have been directed to endoscopes, embodiments may be used with other imaging system with similar waveband and single detector requirements, e.g., borescopes.

Claims

An optical system (100), comprising:
a first relay rod (116) of a first material;

a second relay rod (126) of a second material, different from the first material; and

a lens between the first and second relay rods (116, 126), wherein the lens includes a first relay objective (104) and a second relay objective (104),

wherein the first and second materials are selected to reduce the wavefront error across the field of view of the optical system (100) as compared with using a same material for both the first and second relay rods,

characterized in that, the first and second relay rods (116, 126) are geometrically symmetric to one another relative to a pupil or conjugate pupil of the optical system, the pupil or conjugate pupil being located between the first and second relay rods.
The optical system (100) as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first and second relay rods (116, 126) have no optical power.
The optical system (100) as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first and second relay rods (116, 126) have no optically powered surfaces.
The optical system (100) as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the first and second relay objectives (104) have a same design and material.
The optical system (100) as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein a pupil region (P) of the system is in air.
The optical system (100) as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 5, further comprising:
a third relay rod of a third material;

a fourth relay rod of a fourth material, the fourth material being different from the third material; and

a lens between the third and fourth relay rods.
The optical system (100) as claimed in claim 6, wherein the first and third materials are the same and the second and fourth materials are the same.
The optical system (100) as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 7, further comprising a detector to detect light from 460 nm to 850 nm.
An endoscope including the optical system (100) as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 8.
A method of compensating for dispersion in an optical system (100), the method comprising:
providing a first relay rod (116) of a first material;

providing a second relay rod (126) of a second material, different from the first material; and

providing a lens (104) between the first and second relay rods, wherein the lens includes a first relay objective (104) and a second relay objective (104),

wherein the first and second materials are selected to reduce the wavefront error across the field of view of the optical system as compared with using a same material for both the first and second relay rods (116, 126),

characterized in that the first and second relay rods (116, 126) are geometrically symmetric to one another relative to a pupil or conjugate pupil of the optical system, the pupil or conjugate pupil being located between the first and second relay rods.