CN112362803B - Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties - Google Patents

Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN112362803B
CN112362803B CN202011001533.3A CN202011001533A CN112362803B CN 112362803 B CN112362803 B CN 112362803B CN 202011001533 A CN202011001533 A CN 202011001533A CN 112362803 B CN112362803 B CN 112362803B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
nitrogen
rice
nue
ndre
growth
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Active
Application number
CN202011001533.3A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN112362803A (en
Inventor
吴贤婷
朱仁山
龚龑
彭漪
方圣辉
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Wuhan University WHU
Original Assignee
Wuhan University WHU
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Wuhan University WHU filed Critical Wuhan University WHU
Priority to CN202011001533.3A priority Critical patent/CN112362803B/en
Publication of CN112362803A publication Critical patent/CN112362803A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN112362803B publication Critical patent/CN112362803B/en
Active legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G01MEASURING; TESTING
    • G01NINVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
    • G01N33/00Investigating or analysing materials by specific methods not covered by groups G01N1/00 - G01N31/00
    • G01N33/0098Plants or trees
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A01AGRICULTURE; FORESTRY; ANIMAL HUSBANDRY; HUNTING; TRAPPING; FISHING
    • A01HNEW PLANTS OR NON-TRANSGENIC PROCESSES FOR OBTAINING THEM; PLANT REPRODUCTION BY TISSUE CULTURE TECHNIQUES
    • A01H1/00Processes for modifying genotypes ; Plants characterised by associated natural traits
    • A01H1/04Processes of selection involving genotypic or phenotypic markers; Methods of using phenotypic markers for selection
    • GPHYSICS
    • G01MEASURING; TESTING
    • G01NINVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
    • G01N21/00Investigating or analysing materials by the use of optical means, i.e. using sub-millimetre waves, infrared, visible or ultraviolet light
    • G01N21/17Systems in which incident light is modified in accordance with the properties of the material investigated
    • G01N21/25Colour; Spectral properties, i.e. comparison of effect of material on the light at two or more different wavelengths or wavelength bands
    • GPHYSICS
    • G01MEASURING; TESTING
    • G01NINVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
    • G01N21/00Investigating or analysing materials by the use of optical means, i.e. using sub-millimetre waves, infrared, visible or ultraviolet light
    • G01N21/17Systems in which incident light is modified in accordance with the properties of the material investigated
    • G01N2021/1793Remote sensing
    • G01N2021/1797Remote sensing in landscape, e.g. crops
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02ATECHNOLOGIES FOR ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02A40/00Adaptation technologies in agriculture, forestry, livestock or agroalimentary production
    • Y02A40/10Adaptation technologies in agriculture, forestry, livestock or agroalimentary production in agriculture

Landscapes

  • Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
  • General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Botany (AREA)
  • Genetics & Genomics (AREA)
  • Pathology (AREA)
  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Immunology (AREA)
  • Analytical Chemistry (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Biochemistry (AREA)
  • Developmental Biology & Embryology (AREA)
  • Medicinal Chemistry (AREA)
  • Food Science & Technology (AREA)
  • Wood Science & Technology (AREA)
  • Environmental Sciences (AREA)
  • Spectroscopy & Molecular Physics (AREA)
  • Cultivation Of Plants (AREA)
  • Breeding Of Plants And Reproduction By Means Of Culturing (AREA)

Abstract

The invention relates to application of nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties and a method for screening the high NUE rice varieties. The invention discloses a LY9348 with high NUE characteristic, discloses a nitrogen-related trait of LY9348, and a method for high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties by using LY9348 and the nitrogen-related trait thereof. Based on the content of the invention, a person skilled in the art can monitor the vegetation index or the nitrogen content calculated from the vegetation index in the rice growth process in a large-scale and high-throughput manner by using an unmanned aerial vehicle and a remote sensing technology, and then easily screen the rice variety with high NUE, thereby overcoming the dependence of high nitrogen fertilizer in the field of rice planting at the present stage, reducing the cost and reducing the environmental damage caused by the application of the high nitrogen fertilizer. The invention is a new attempt from traditional breeding to modern breeding, and is a further exploration towards intelligent agriculture and precision agriculture.

Description

LY9348在高通量筛选高NUE水稻品种中的应用Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high-NUE rice varieties

基金支持Fund support

本项目的研发受到国家水稻产业体系(CARS-01-07)的资助。The research and development of this project was funded by the National Rice Industry System (CARS-01-07).

技术领域technical field

本发明涉及智慧农业领域,更特别地,涉及LY9348在高通量筛选高NUE水稻品种中的应用。The present invention relates to the field of smart agriculture, more particularly, to the application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high-NUE rice varieties.

背景技术Background technique

氮元素(N)是植物生长不可或缺的营养元素,无论在光合作用、能量转换、结构组成还是生物合成方面都起着重要作用。植物从土壤吸收N,并通过维管系统转运至特定的器官中积累为含氮化合物,然后分解并迁移至目的器官参与到植物的各项生命活动中,维持植物内部的营养平衡。Nitrogen (N) is an indispensable nutrient element for plant growth and plays an important role in photosynthesis, energy conversion, structural composition or biosynthesis. Plants absorb N from the soil and transport it through the vascular system to specific organs to accumulate as nitrogen compounds, and then decompose and migrate to the target organs to participate in various life activities of the plant and maintain the nutrient balance within the plant.

粮食生产中,高氮肥的施用是影响产量的关键因素之一。然而,近年来,随着氮肥施用的增长,粮食作物产量的并没有相应增长,而是达到了平台期。从1980年到2010年,我国氮肥施用量增长了512%,而谷物产量只增长了65%。过度的氮肥施用不仅提高了成本,而且导致了氮利用率降低以及氮损失。田间氮肥的溢出,进入到土壤和水中,还会引起一些严重的环境问题。根据测算,如果氮利用效率提高1%,全世界每年的肥料成本可降低23亿美元。In grain production, the application of high nitrogen fertilizer is one of the key factors affecting yield. However, in recent years, with the increase of nitrogen fertilizer application, the yield of food crops has not increased correspondingly, but has reached a plateau. From 1980 to 2010, my country's nitrogen fertilizer application increased by 512%, while grain production increased by only 65%. Excessive nitrogen application not only increases costs, but also leads to reduced nitrogen use efficiency and nitrogen loss. The overflow of nitrogen fertilizer in the field, into the soil and water, can also cause some serious environmental problems. According to estimates, if nitrogen use efficiency is improved by 1%, the annual cost of fertilizers in the world can be reduced by 2.3 billion US dollars.

水稻是世界上重要的粮食作物之一,为全球近一半的人口提供食物。我国的水稻产量世界最高,但是,我国稻田中的平均氮肥施用量为180-209kg/hm2,远高于世界平均水平105kg/hm2,并且实际使用效率仅有约30-35%。通过优化田间管理来提高水稻的氮利用效率(Nitrogen Use Efficiency,NUE)可将氮肥施用量降至150-165kg/hm2。然而,为了达到最大产量潜能(10-15Mt/hm2),绝大多数超级稻品种需要高达300kg/hm2的氮肥施用量。因此,单单从田间管理的角度来降低氮肥施用量不能从根本上解决氮利用效率的问题。育种者希望能够筛选具有高NUE的水稻品种,以彻底解决这个问题。Rice is one of the most important food crops in the world, providing food for nearly half of the world's population. China's rice yield is the highest in the world, but the average nitrogen fertilizer application rate in China's rice fields is 180-209 kg/hm 2 , much higher than the world average of 105 kg/hm 2 , and the actual use efficiency is only about 30-35%. Improving the nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) of rice by optimizing field management can reduce the nitrogen application rate to 150-165 kg/hm 2 . However, to reach maximum yield potential (10-15 Mt/hm 2 ), most super rice varieties require nitrogen application rates as high as 300 kg/hm 2 . Therefore, reducing the nitrogen application rate from the perspective of field management alone cannot fundamentally solve the problem of nitrogen use efficiency. Breeders hope to be able to screen for rice varieties with high NUE to completely solve this problem.

水稻育种领域对高NUE育种选择做了许多努力,但是迄今仍然进展缓慢。主要障碍是,没有一种简单易行的方法来捕捉水稻中的氮含量变化,并进一步表征为氮利用效率。因为,水稻中的氮含量变化既表现在空间水平方面(冠层形态变化),又表现时间水平方面(整个生育周期中的发育变化,例如营养生长和生殖生长的转换)。Many efforts have been made in the field of rice breeding to select for high NUE breeding, but progress has so far been slow. The main obstacle is that there is no simple and easy way to capture changes in nitrogen content in rice and further characterize it as nitrogen use efficiency. Because nitrogen content changes in rice are expressed both at the spatial level (canopy morphological changes) and at the temporal level (developmental changes throughout the growth cycle, such as transitions between vegetative growth and reproductive growth).

由于水稻对氮的摄取和利用是一个复杂的综合行为,涉及多种生命活动,目前育种者尚且无法找到某一个基因或归集一个基因群来作为高NUE的分子标志。依靠传统的方法在特定的生育阶段(例如抽穗期或乳熟期)采集水稻样本测定氮含量来表征NUE,一方面无法准确表征氮利用率,另一方面费时费力,无法用于高通量筛选。Since the uptake and utilization of nitrogen by rice is a complex and comprehensive behavior involving multiple life activities, breeders are currently unable to find a certain gene or group a gene group as a molecular marker of high NUE. Relying on traditional methods to collect rice samples at specific growth stages (such as heading stage or milk maturity stage) to measure nitrogen content to characterize NUE, on the one hand, cannot accurately characterize nitrogen use efficiency, on the other hand, it is time-consuming and labor-intensive, and cannot be used for high-throughput screening. .

因此,一方面,需要找到具有高NUE性状的植株,另一方面,需要新的描述高NUE性状的方法,以适用于高通量筛选。Therefore, on the one hand, there is a need to find plants with high NUE traits, and on the other hand, new methods for characterizing high NUE traits are needed to be suitable for high-throughput screening.

随着遥感技术和无人机的发展,以及摄像头分辨率的提高,其与遥感技术的结合逐渐用于农业生产和研究。Lukas Prey等将光谱仪置于小麦冠层上方约1m处,测量冠层的反射率并用以评估相应的生理数据。南京农业大学的郑恒彪等使用无人机搭载相机拍摄作物影像,并以这些影像为基础来分析和评估作物的生理参数,显示出一些生理参数与无人机拍摄的影像计算的VI之间存在一定的相关性。然而,这些研究都集中于探索使用VI估算相关生理参数的测量方法学上,目前没有研究将这些测量方法学上的成果应用于探索NUE表型的描述上,以及如何筛选高NUE的水稻品种。With the development of remote sensing technology and UAV, as well as the improvement of camera resolution, its combination with remote sensing technology is gradually used in agricultural production and research. Lukas Prey et al. placed a spectrometer about 1 m above the wheat canopy to measure the reflectance of the canopy and to evaluate the corresponding physiological data. Zheng Hengbiao from Nanjing Agricultural University and others used drones with cameras to capture crop images, and used these images as the basis to analyze and evaluate the physiological parameters of crops. correlation. However, these studies have focused on exploring the measurement methodologies for estimating relevant physiological parameters using VI, and no studies have applied the results of these measurement methodologies to explore the description of NUE phenotypes and how to screen high NUE rice varieties.

因此,需要一种具有标准高NUE性状的水稻品种,以及根据该品种的相关性状来筛选高NUE水稻品种。Therefore, there is a need for a rice cultivar with standard high NUE traits, and selection of high NUE rice cultivars based on the related traits of the cultivar.

发明内容SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

为解决以上问题,本团队在研究过程中发现,水稻品种LY9348具有高NUE的特性,具体体现在,与父本、母本和其他水稻品种相比,具有较高的氮摄取效率和氮转化效率,即,在低氮肥施用的条件下可以在体内积累更多的氮,并且产量不受低氮肥施用的影响。In order to solve the above problems, the team found in the research process that the rice variety LY9348 has the characteristics of high NUE, which is embodied in that it has higher nitrogen uptake efficiency and nitrogen conversion efficiency compared with the male parent, female parent and other rice varieties. , that is, more nitrogen can be accumulated in the body under the condition of low nitrogen fertilizer application, and yield is not affected by low nitrogen fertilizer application.

基于以上研究,本发明提供了LY9348的氮相关性状在高通量筛选高NUE水稻品种中的应用。Based on the above research, the present invention provides the application of nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high-NUE rice varieties.

本发明还提供了一种筛选高NUE水稻品种的方法,包括使用LY9348的氮相关性状作为筛选标准的步骤。The present invention also provides a method for screening high-NUE rice varieties, including the step of using the nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 as screening criteria.

在一个优选实施方案中,所述氮相关性状为LY9348的两个或更多个生育时期的植被指数或氮含量。In a preferred embodiment, the nitrogen-related trait is vegetation index or nitrogen content for two or more growth periods of LY9348.

优选地,所述植被指数为NDRE值。Preferably, the vegetation index is an NDRE value.

优选地,所述氮含量为使用NDRE值计算得到的氮含量。Preferably, the nitrogen content is the nitrogen content calculated using the NDRE value.

通过使用NDRE值或NDRE值计算得到的氮含量来筛选高NUE水稻品种,我们可以利用无人机结合遥感技术,还获取水稻种植区的影像,然后根据影像计算出NDRE值,并进一步计算得到氮含量。然后比较NDRE值或氮含量来确定待筛选的水稻品种是否具有高NUE。By using the NDRE value or the nitrogen content calculated from the NDRE value to screen high-NUE rice varieties, we can use drones combined with remote sensing technology to obtain images of the rice planting area, and then calculate the NDRE value based on the image, and further calculate the nitrogen content. The NDRE value or nitrogen content is then compared to determine whether the rice variety to be screened has a high NUE.

在一个具体实施方案中,所述方法包括以下步骤:In a specific embodiment, the method comprises the steps of:

S1:获取LY9348在特定环境下多个生育时期中的氮相关性状;S1: Obtain the nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 in multiple growth periods in a specific environment;

S2:获取待筛选的水稻品种在相应环境下的相应生育时期中的氮相关性状;S2: obtaining nitrogen-related traits in the corresponding growth period of the rice variety to be screened in the corresponding environment;

S3:将所述待筛选的水稻品种的氮相关性状与LY9348的氮相关性状比较,当所述待筛选的水稻品种的氮相关性状均与LY9348的氮相关性状相同或高于LY9348的氮相关性状,则将所述待筛选的水稻品种为高NUE的水稻品种。S3: Comparing the nitrogen-related traits of the rice variety to be screened with the nitrogen-related traits of LY9348, when the nitrogen-related traits of the rice variety to be screened are all the same as or higher than the nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 , the rice variety to be screened is a high NUE rice variety.

本发明公开了LY9348具有高NUE的特性,并且披露了LY9348的氮相关性状,以及使用LY9348及其氮相关性状来高通量筛选高NUE的水稻品种的方法。基于本发明的内容,本领域技术人员可在使用无人机结合遥感技术大规模高通量地监测水稻生长过程中的植被指数或由植被指数计算得到的含氮量,进而容易地筛选高NUE的水稻品种,从而克服现阶段水稻种植领域中的高氮肥依赖,减小成本,降低因高氮肥施用带来的环境损害。本发明是传统育种向现代化育种的新尝试,是向智慧农业和精准农业的进一步探索。The invention discloses that LY9348 has the characteristics of high NUE, and discloses the nitrogen-related traits of LY9348, and a method for high-throughput screening of high-NUE rice varieties by using LY9348 and its nitrogen-related traits. Based on the content of the present invention, those skilled in the art can use unmanned aerial vehicle combined with remote sensing technology to monitor the vegetation index or nitrogen content calculated from the vegetation index in large-scale and high-throughput rice growth process, and then easily screen high NUE Therefore, it can overcome the dependence of high nitrogen fertilizer in the current rice planting field, reduce the cost, and reduce the environmental damage caused by the application of high nitrogen fertilizer. The invention is a new attempt from traditional breeding to modern breeding, and a further exploration to smart agriculture and precision agriculture.

附图说明Description of drawings

图1为使用不同方法测定的同一个试验田中种植的LY9348及其亲本(LH4B、CH9348)以及另外两个水稻品种R8108和LY8水稻植株生长的6个生长时期内的氮含量变化。Figure 1 shows the nitrogen content changes in 6 growth periods of LY9348 and its parents (LH4B, CH9348) and two other rice varieties R8108 and LY8 grown in the same experimental field using different methods.

图2为氮施用田间试验中FLY4H和LY9348的农学性状比较,其中,A为每穂谷粒数;B为结实率(%);C为每株植物的稻谷产量(g);D为NUE(每千克氮的稻谷产量)。n=30,*、**、***分别表示P<0.05、0.01和0.001。Figure 2 shows the comparison of agronomic traits between FLY4H and LY9348 in the nitrogen application field test, where A is the number of grains per plant; B is the seed setting rate (%); C is the rice yield per plant (g); D is the NUE (per rice yield in kilograms of nitrogen). n=30, *, **, *** represent P<0.05, 0.01 and 0.001, respectively.

图3为使用无人机采集的51个水稻品种的6个生育期的RGB图像和NDRE图像,其中:A为6个生育期的RGB图像,a为TS期,b为JS期,c为PIS期,d为BS期,e为FHS期,f为MRS期;B为6个生育期的NDRE图像,a为TS期,b为JS期,c为PIS期,d为BS期,e为FHS期,f为MRS期。Figure 3 shows the RGB images and NDRE images of 51 rice varieties in 6 growth stages collected by drone, where: A is the RGB images of the 6 growth stages, a is the TS stage, b is the JS stage, and c is the PIS stage, d is BS stage, e is FHS stage, f is MRS stage; B is NDRE image of 6 reproductive stages, a is TS stage, b is JS stage, c is PIS stage, d is BS stage, e is FHS stage period, f is the MRS period.

图4为51个水稻品种的6个生育期数据关系以及构建的回归模型,其中:A为6个生育期SPAD与NDRE之间的关系,n=306;B为除TS期外的5个生育期数据构建的SPAD与NDRE之间的回归模型,R2>0.81,n=255;C为6个生育期N%与NDRE之间的关系,n=306;B为除TS期外的5个生育期数据构建的SPAD与NDRE之间的回归模型,R2>0.61,n=255。Figure 4 shows the data relationship of 51 rice varieties in 6 growth stages and the constructed regression model, in which: A is the relationship between SPAD and NDRE in 6 growth stages, n=306; B is 5 growth stages except TS stage Regression model between SPAD and NDRE constructed from period data, R 2 >0.81, n=255; C is the relationship between N% and NDRE in 6 growth periods, n=306; B is 5 periods except TS period Regression model between SPAD and NDRE constructed from growth period data, R 2 >0.61, n=255.

图5为FHS期SPAD、N%与NDRE之间的关系,其中:A为所有水稻品种中SPAD与NDRE的关系(n=51);B为早成熟(EM)水稻品种中SPAD与NDRE的关系(n=34);C为迟成熟(LM)水稻品种中SPAD与NDRE的关系(n=17);D为所有水稻品种中N%与NDRE的关系(n=51);E为早成熟(EM)水稻品种中N%与NDRE的关系(n=34);F为迟成熟(LM)水稻品种中N%与NDRE的关系(n=17)。***p<0.001。Figure 5 shows the relationship between SPAD, N% and NDRE in the FHS stage, where: A is the relationship between SPAD and NDRE in all rice varieties (n=51); B is the relationship between SPAD and NDRE in early mature (EM) rice varieties (n=34); C is the relationship between SPAD and NDRE in late-maturing (LM) rice varieties (n=17); D is the relationship between N% and NDRE in all rice varieties (n=51); E is early-maturing ( EM) Relationship between N% and NDRE in rice varieties (n=34); F is the relationship between N% and NDRE in late maturing (LM) rice varieties (n=17). ***p<0.001.

图6为海南种植的42个水稻品种的6个生育期的数据构建的N%*LAI与NDRE之间非线性回归模型。Figure 6 shows the nonlinear regression model between N%*LAI and NDRE constructed from the data of 42 rice varieties grown in Hainan at 6 growth stages.

图7为针对51个水稻品种的全生育周期,使用EQA法(A)测量的氮含量变化曲线与根据无人机采集的图像和计算的NDRE值分别使用ModelI(B)和ModelII(C)估算的氮含量变化曲线的比较。Figure 7 shows the nitrogen content change curve measured by the EQA method (A) and the NDRE value estimated by the images collected by the UAV and the calculated NDRE value using Model I (B) and Model II (C) for the whole growth cycle of 51 rice varieties, respectively. Comparison of nitrogen content change curves.

具体实施方式Detailed ways

1、珞优9348(LY9348)的氮利用特性1. Nitrogen utilization characteristics of Luoyou 9348 (LY9348)

LY9348是本团队用不育系“珞红4B”和恢复系“成恢9348”配组育成的杂交水稻品种,2016年通过湖北省农作物品种审定委员会审定,品种审定编号为鄂审稻2016014。LY9348 is a hybrid rice variety bred by the team using the sterile line "Luohong 4B" and the restorer line "Chenghui 9348". It was approved by the Hubei Provincial Crop Variety Approval Committee in 2016, and the variety approval number is Hubei Shenda 2016014.

1.1、LY9348的氮含量变化曲线1.1. Nitrogen content change curve of LY9348

将LY9348及其亲本(LH4B、CH9348)以及另外两个水稻品种R8108和LY8H种植到一个试验田中,分别在水稻植株生长的6个生长时期内采集植株样品,使用元素定量分析(EQA)测定这5个水稻品种的氮含量变化。6个生长时期包括:分蘖期(TS)、拔节期(JS)、穗分化期(PIS)、孕穗期(BS)、抽穗期(FHS)和乳熟期(MRS)。LY9348 and its parents (LH4B, CH9348) and two other rice varieties, R8108 and LY8H, were planted in an experimental field, and plant samples were collected during 6 growth periods of rice plants, respectively. Elemental quantitative analysis (EQA) was used to determine these 5. Changes in nitrogen content of rice cultivars. The six growth stages included: tillering stage (TS), jointing stage (JS), ear differentiation stage (PIS), booting stage (BS), heading stage (FHS) and milk ripening stage (MRS).

EQA法步骤如下:选择3个植株,采集功能叶,80℃烤干至恒重,研磨,过100目筛,检测氮含量。3个植株数据的平均值作为相应水稻品种的精确叶片氮含量值。The steps of the EQA method are as follows: 3 plants are selected, functional leaves are collected, dried at 80°C to constant weight, ground, passed through a 100-mesh sieve, and the nitrogen content is detected. The average value of the 3 plant data was used as the precise leaf nitrogen content value of the corresponding rice variety.

结果如图1所示,LY9348从JS期开始维持更高的氮含量,并且该状态持续到MRS期结束。由于无论父本还是母本均显示出低得多的氮含量。这说明,LY9348更高的氮积累能力并非遗传自亲本,而是杂交优势组合导致的。由于这5个品种生长于相同的田地中,受到相同的水肥管理,LY9348中更高的氮积累证明其更高的氮摄取效率(NUpE)。The results are shown in Fig. 1, LY9348 maintained a higher nitrogen content from the JS phase, and this state continued until the end of the MRS phase. Because both male and female parents showed much lower nitrogen content. This indicated that the higher nitrogen accumulation ability of LY9348 was not inherited from the parents, but resulted from the combination of heterosis. Since the five cultivars were grown in the same fields and received the same water and fertilizer management, the higher nitrogen accumulation in LY9348 was evidenced by its higher nitrogen uptake efficiency (NUpE).

1.2、田地氮施用量跟踪试验1.2. Field nitrogen application rate tracking test

进行田地氮施用量跟踪实验,将LY9348和FLY4(CK),测试4个氮施用量(0kg/ha、120kg/ha,180kg/ha和240kg/ha)。2018年12月10日播种于陵水,2019年1月移栽。每个施用量3个重复被随机布置在田地中,形成12个实验小区,每两个小区之间间隔0.4m,并且每个小区上覆盖0.4m薄膜。每个实验小区约30m2,分成两半,一半种LY9348,另一半种FLY4(CK)。每个小区种植432个植株,穴距15cm×18cm,分成24排,每排18株。在移栽前,所有的实验小区都施用基肥,过磷酸盐(90kg/ha P2O5)和硫酸钾(180kg/ha K2O)。尿素(N)分三次施用,分别在播种时、分蘖期和孕穗期施用。在移栽后,每个实验小区均维持5cm水深。收获前第10天,排干水以方便收获。使用30个植株计算每穂谷粒数、每穂结实率和每株谷物产量(g)。基于每个小区中央区域收获的100个植株谷物产量估计每kg N的谷物产量,并且通过计算时扣除13.5%的标准含水量来校准。The field nitrogen application rate tracking experiment was carried out, LY9348 and FLY4(CK) were tested for 4 nitrogen application rates (0kg/ha, 120kg/ha, 180kg/ha and 240kg/ha). It was sown in Lingshui on December 10, 2018, and transplanted in January 2019. Three replicates of each application rate were randomly placed in the field to form 12 experimental plots with a 0.4 m interval between each two plots, and each plot was covered with a 0.4 m film. Each experimental plot is about 30m 2 , and it is divided into two halves, one half is planted with LY9348, and the other half is planted with FLY4(CK). 432 plants were planted in each plot, with a hole spacing of 15cm × 18cm, divided into 24 rows with 18 plants in each row. Before transplanting, all experimental plots were applied with basal fertilizers, superphosphate (90 kg/ha P 2 O 5 ) and potassium sulfate (180 kg/ha K 2 O). Urea (N) was applied three times at sowing, tillering and booting stages. After transplanting, each experimental plot was maintained at a water depth of 5 cm. On the 10th day before harvest, drain the water to facilitate harvesting. 30 plants were used to calculate the number of grains per plant, the rate of seed setting per plant, and the grain yield (g) per plant. Grain yield per kg N was estimated based on 100 plants harvested in the central area of each plot and calibrated by subtracting 13.5% of the standard moisture content from the calculation.

结果显示,与对照组FLY4H相比,LY9348的每穂谷粒数(图2A)、每穂结实率(图2B)和产量(图2C)均更高,这个差异在0kg/ha N施用小区比120、180和240kg/ha N施用小区更明显。进一步研究发现,氮肥的施用并没有提高LY9348的产量。这说明,LY9348能够高效吸收和利用土壤中已有的氮,无需大量施用氮肥,提示LY9348是具有更高氮利用/积累效率(NUtE)的品种,并且每kg氮产生的产量随着氮施用量的增加而降低(图2D)。The results showed that compared with the control group FLY4H, LY9348 had higher grain number per row (Fig. 2A), seed setting rate per row (Fig. 2B) and yield (Fig. 2C), and this difference was higher in the 0kg/ha N application plot than 120 , 180 and 240kg/ha N application plots were more obvious. Further study found that the application of nitrogen fertilizer did not improve the yield of LY9348. This shows that LY9348 can efficiently absorb and utilize the existing nitrogen in the soil without the need to apply a large amount of nitrogen fertilizer, suggesting that LY9348 is a variety with higher nitrogen use/accumulation efficiency (NUtE), and the yield per kg of nitrogen increases with the amount of nitrogen application. increased and decreased (Fig. 2D).

上述实验显示,LY9348具有高的NUpE和NUtE,我们可以下结论,LY9348具有高氮利用效率(NUE)的品种(NUE=NUpE x NUtE=稻谷产量/土壤氮施用量)。因此,我们可以将LY9348作为高NUE水稻品种的标杆,并利用该标杆来筛选高NUE的水稻品种。The above experiments show that LY9348 has high NUpE and NUtE, we can conclude that LY9348 has a high nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) variety (NUE=NUpE x NUtE=rice yield/soil nitrogen application rate). Therefore, we can use LY9348 as a benchmark for high NUE rice varieties, and use this benchmark to screen for high NUE rice varieties.

为此,我们对高NUE性状进行了基于遥感技术的定义,根据该定义设计了新的筛选方法,并对该方法进行了实验验证。To this end, we defined the high NUE trait based on remote sensing technology, designed a new screening method according to the definition, and verified the method experimentally.

2、植物材料及种植2. Plant material and planting

从3000个基因组项目中选择NUE较高的50个品种(籼稻、澳洲稻及两者之间的品种),加上一个紫稻,共51个水稻品种(表1),种植于湖北鄂州的武汉大学水稻实验和研究基地(30.3756°N,114.7448°E)。这些鄂州的水稻于2017年5月10日水稻播种,5月31日移栽。陵水的水稻于2017年12月10日萌发,2018年1月6日移栽。50 varieties with higher NUE (indica rice, Australian rice and varieties in between) were selected from the 3000 genome project, plus a purple rice, a total of 51 rice varieties (Table 1), planted in Wuhan, Ezhou, Hubei University Rice Experiment and Research Base (30.3756°N, 114.7448°E). These rice from Ezhou were sown on May 10, 2017 and transplanted on May 31. The rice in Lingshui germinated on December 10, 2017, and was transplanted on January 6, 2018.

表1 51个水稻品种的品种信息Table 1 Variety information of 51 rice varieties

Figure GDA0003457501670000071
Figure GDA0003457501670000071

Figure GDA0003457501670000081
Figure GDA0003457501670000081

从中国的育种项目选择41个籼稻品种,加上一个紫稻,共42个水稻品种(表2),种植于海南陵水的武汉大学杂交水稻实验和研究基地(18°03′147.1″N,110°03′34.9″E)。水稻于2017年12月10日播种,并在2018年1月5日移栽。41 indica rice cultivars were selected from Chinese breeding programs, plus one purple rice, for a total of 42 rice cultivars (Table 2), which were planted in the Wuhan University Hybrid Rice Experiment and Research Base in Lingshui, Hainan (18°03′147.1″N, 110°03'34.9"E). Rice was sown on December 10, 2017 and transplanted on January 5, 2018.

表2 42个水稻品种的品种信息Table 2 Variety information of 42 rice varieties

Figure GDA0003457501670000082
Figure GDA0003457501670000082

以上水稻品种除了紫稻和LY9348外,均NUE较高但达不到优异的水稻品种。上述水稻品种的种植密度为每公顷225000株,总生长时间为6至7个月,根据品种而不同。每个品种种植60株,10株一行,共6行,行距20cm,株距16cm。每6行空1行,以利于品种区别和UAV信息处理。Except for purple rice and LY9348, the above rice cultivars are all rice cultivars with high NUE but not excellent. The planting density of the above rice varieties is 225,000 plants per hectare, and the total growth time is 6 to 7 months, depending on the variety. Each variety is planted with 60 plants, 10 plants in a row, a total of 6 rows, the row spacing is 20cm, and the plant spacing is 16cm. Every 6 lines is empty for 1 line to facilitate the differentiation of varieties and processing of UAV information.

每公顷施用复合肥375Kg(氮磷钾比率为15-15-15),进行常规稻田管理。在每个实验的每个发育时期,均安排一架UAV无人机获取所有水稻田块的图像,并且每块水稻田反复测量5次。375Kg of compound fertilizer (NPK ratio of 15-15-15) was applied per hectare for conventional paddy field management. In each developmental period of each experiment, a UAV drone was arranged to acquire images of all paddy fields, and each paddy field was repeatedly measured 5 times.

3、数据收集3. Data collection

3.1、传统方法测量氮含量3.1. Traditional methods to measure nitrogen content

在每个发育时期中,采集叶片样品进行精确的氮含量和叶绿素含量检测。从顶端的剑叶起往下数3片功能叶,用于测量叶绿素含量和氮含量。每个品种3个重复,记录SPAD平均数和氮含量平均数(N%)。During each developmental stage, leaf samples were collected for precise nitrogen and chlorophyll content determination. Three functional leaves were counted down from the top sword leaf to measure chlorophyll content and nitrogen content. Each variety was replicated in 3 replicates, and the mean SPAD and nitrogen content (N%) were recorded.

使用氮测量仪N-Pen N 110测量氮含量,在各发育阶段选择三株植株采集叶样品,进行测量。长出剑叶前的阶段取1.5叶龄的叶子(长度为剑叶的2倍),长出剑叶后的阶段取剑叶下的第二片叶子。NDGI=(R780-R560)/(R780-R560)。使用土壤植物分析发育(SPAD)叶绿素含量测量仪(SPAD-502)测量叶绿素含量。Nitrogen content was measured using a nitrogen measuring instrument N-Pen N 110, and leaf samples were collected from three plants at each developmental stage for measurement. At the stage before the sword leaf grows, the leaves at the age of 1.5 (the length is twice that of the sword leaf) are taken, and at the stage after the sword leaf is grown, the second leaf under the sword leaf is obtained. NDGI=(R780-R560)/(R780-R560). Chlorophyll content was measured using a Soil Plant Analysis and Development (SPAD) Chlorophyll Content Meter (SPAD-502).

在本研究中,每个发育时期对每个品种进行测量总氮含量值(三个重复),鄂州51个水稻品种共306个总氮值数据和叶绿素含量数据,陵水42个水稻品种共252个总氮值数据和叶绿素含量数据。In this study, the total nitrogen content value of each variety was measured at each developmental stage (three replicates). There were 306 total nitrogen value data and chlorophyll content data for 51 rice varieties in Ezhou, and 252 data for 42 rice varieties in Lingshui. Total nitrogen value data and chlorophyll content data.

本研究中还使用了元素定量分析法(EQA)测定氮含量,方法如下:选择3个植株,采集功能叶,80℃烤干至恒重,研磨,过100目筛,检测氮含量。3个植株数据的平均值作为相应水稻品种的精确叶片氮含量值。In this study, elemental quantitative analysis (EQA) was also used to determine nitrogen content. The method was as follows: 3 plants were selected, functional leaves were collected, dried at 80°C to constant weight, ground, and passed through a 100-mesh sieve to detect nitrogen content. The average value of the 3 plant data was used as the precise leaf nitrogen content value of the corresponding rice variety.

3.2、叶面积指数测量3.2. Leaf area index measurement

本研究中还收集了叶面积指数(LAI),方法如下:随机选取5个植株用于测量叶面积指数。如果50%以上的部分为黄色,则叶片判定黄叶,剔除。由于本研究对水稻材料进行了毁灭性测量,并且多个生育期都需要采样测试,因此从上述5个植株中选2株绿叶最多的植株作为每个水稻品种和每个生育期的代表性样品。将这两个植株的包括所有分蘖的整个植株带根挖出。剥下所有绿叶,扫描用于计算叶面积(Leaf AreaMeter LI-3100C)。将这两个植株的所有叶片的平均叶面积作为单株植物叶面积(LA)的代表值。考虑到1平方米的植物密度(d),LAI=LA×d。Leaf area index (LAI) was also collected in this study by the following method: 5 plants were randomly selected for LAI measurement. If more than 50% of the parts are yellow, the leaves are judged to be yellow leaves and removed. Since the rice material was destructively measured in this study, and multiple growth periods required sampling and testing, the 2 plants with the most green leaves were selected from the above 5 plants as a representative sample for each rice variety and each growth period. The entire plant, including all tillers, of both plants was excavated with roots. All green leaves were stripped and scanned for leaf area calculation (Leaf AreaMeter LI-3100C). The average leaf area of all leaves of the two plants was taken as a representative value of leaf area (LA) per plant. Considering a plant density (d) of 1 square meter, LAI=LA×d.

3.3、作物冠层漫反射光谱收集3.3. Collection of Diffuse Reflectance Spectra of Crop Canopy

通过ASD FieldSpec Pro FR光谱仪测量作物漫反射光谱。从作物冠层正上方1.0m处收集收据,选择在天气晴朗日子的10am-2pm之间收集,每5天收集一次。每个试验小区进行5次重复测量,取平均数作为小区冠层光谱反射率。通过时间校正中的标准白板纸去除仪器噪音影响,去除低信噪比的1301-2500nm波段光谱数据。Crop diffuse reflectance spectra were measured by ASD FieldSpec Pro FR spectrometer. Collect receipts from 1.0m directly above the crop canopy, choose to collect between 10am-2pm on a sunny day, and collect every 5 days. Five repeated measurements were performed in each experimental plot, and the average was taken as the spectral reflectance of the plot canopy. The influence of instrument noise is removed by standard whiteboard paper in time correction, and the spectral data in the 1301-2500 nm band with low signal-to-noise ratio is removed.

3.4、无人机(UAV)飞行和图像采集3.4. Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) flight and image acquisition

使用安装在无人机(S1000,大疆)上的Mini-MCA系统获取目标研究小区的影像,从移栽后开始每五天采集影像,直至作物成熟。Mini-MCA包括由12个单独的微型数码摄像头组成的阵列。每个传感器通道可产生10bit SXGA数据,并且图像解析度可达到1m/130公顷。每个摄像头配备定制的带通滤波器,分别以波长490,520,550,570,670,680,700,720,800,850,900或950nm为中心。在UAV图像采集后,立即原位进行相应的实地测量。Images of the target research plot were acquired using the Mini-MCA system mounted on a UAV (S1000, DJI), and images were collected every five days from transplanting until the crops matured. The Mini-MCA consists of an array of 12 individual miniature digital cameras. Each sensor channel can generate 10bit SXGA data, and the image resolution can reach 1m/130 hectares. Each camera is equipped with a custom bandpass filter centered at wavelengths 490, 520, 550, 570, 670, 680, 700, 720, 800, 850, 900 or 950nm. Corresponding field measurements were performed in situ immediately after UAV image acquisition.

MCA系统通过常平架连接在UAV上,以防受UAV运动的影响,通过在飞前共配的12个摄像头来控制摄像头的配不准效应。每次UAV飞行均在晴朗少云的天空条件下进行,时间介于10am至2pm之间,这是太阳高度角变化最小。鄂州实验中UAV飞行高度为目标小区上方50m,空间分辨率约2.7cm。42个水稻品种实验,UAV飞行高度为目标小区上方200m,空间分辨率约10.8cm。The MCA system is connected to the UAV through a gimbal to prevent it from being affected by the movement of the UAV, and the misregistration effect of the cameras is controlled by a total of 12 cameras before the flight. Each UAV flight took place under clear, less cloudy sky conditions between 10am and 2pm, which is the minimum change in the sun's altitude angle. In the Ezhou experiment, the UAV flying height was 50m above the target cell, and the spatial resolution was about 2.7cm. For the experiment of 42 rice varieties, the flying height of UAV was 200m above the target plot, and the spatial resolution was about 10.8cm.

使用经验线性校正方法将图像数字量化值(DN)转换成表面反射率(ρλ)。通过6个地面校准目标构成的标准来进行图像辐射校正,在每次飞行先放置于摄像头视场中。研究的小区和所有地面校准目标被包含在同一张照片中。在本文中,地面校准目标分别提供了对可见光至近红外波长的相对稳定的反射率0.03、0.12、0.24、0.36、0.56和0.80。由于假设DN与ρλ之间存在线性关系,水稻品种的反射率方程可为:The image digital quantization value (DN) was converted into surface reflectance (ρλ) using empirical linear correction method. Image radiometric correction is performed by a standard consisting of 6 ground calibration targets, which are first placed in the camera field of view on each flight. The studied cell and all ground calibration targets are included in the same photo. In this paper, the ground calibration targets provided relatively stable reflectances of 0.03, 0.12, 0.24, 0.36, 0.56, and 0.80 for visible to near-infrared wavelengths, respectively. Since a linear relationship between DN and ρλ is assumed, the reflectance equation for rice varieties can be:

pλ=DNλ×Gainλ+Offsetλ p λ =DN λ ×Gain λ +Offset λ

(λ=490,520,550,570,670,680,700,720,800,850,900 and 900nm) (1)(λ=490, 520, 550, 570, 670, 680, 700, 720, 800, 850, 900 and 900nm) (1)

其中ρλ和DNλ为波长λ处的表面反射率和指定像素的图像数字量化值。Gainλ和Offsetλ为摄像头在波长λ处的摄像头增益和偏差。Gainλ和Offsetλ可用最小二乘法根据ρ值和DN值计算。where ρ λ and DN λ are the surface reflectance at wavelength λ and the image digital quantization value of the specified pixel. Gainλ and Offsetλ are the camera gain and offset of the camera at wavelength λ. Gain λ and Offset λ can be calculated according to the ρ value and the DN value by the least square method.

Figure GDA0003457501670000111
Figure GDA0003457501670000111

3.5、统计分析和Vegetative Index计算3.5. Statistical analysis and calculation of Vegetative Index

数据分析和统计描述通过IBM SPSS Statistics进行(Statistical Product andService Solutions 22.0,IBM,Armonk,NY,United States)。使用GraphPad software(Version 5.0.,Harvey Motulsky&Arthur Christopoulos,San Diego,California,USA)作图。根据需求对氮含量(N%)、叶绿素含量(SPAD)和叶面积指数(LAI)数据集进行统计评价,显示分布正常。使用泊松相关系数(r)作为相关性分析的结果。分析和比较校正的R2和p值,进行回归分析。将最佳拟合曲线转化为方程作为回归模型,来表示N%、SPAD、LAI*N%与归一化差异红边(NDRE)或其他植被指数(VI)之间的相关性。各VI的计算公式如表3所示。Data analysis and statistical description were performed by IBM SPSS Statistics (Statistical Product and Service Solutions 22.0, IBM, Armonk, NY, United States). Graphs were made using GraphPad software (Version 5.0., Harvey Motulsky & Arthur Christopoulos, San Diego, California, USA). Statistical evaluation of nitrogen content (N%), chlorophyll content (SPAD) and leaf area index (LAI) datasets according to demand showed normal distribution. The Poisson correlation coefficient (r) was used as the result of the correlation analysis. Regression analysis was performed to analyze and compare adjusted R2 and p -values. The best fit curves were converted into equations as regression models to represent the correlation between N%, SPAD, LAI*N% and normalized difference red edge (NDRE) or other vegetation indices (VI). The calculation formula of each VI is shown in Table 3.

表3 VI计算公式Table 3 VI calculation formula

Figure GDA0003457501670000121
Figure GDA0003457501670000121

4、几种VI与氮含量和叶绿素之间的相关性4. Correlations between several VIs and nitrogen content and chlorophyll

前人使用距水稻上方1m的光谱仪收集冠层光谱反射率数据,对生育周期中的6个关键阶段的数据进行分析,以确定哪个生长阶段是选定的VI用于评估叶绿素和氮含量的最佳阶段。Canopy spectral reflectance data were collected using a spectrometer 1 m above rice, and data from 6 key stages in the growth cycle were analyzed to determine which growth stage was the most selected VI for assessing chlorophyll and nitrogen content. good stage.

总体而言,所有VI都表现出与叶绿素(0.5-0.65)的相关性强于氮含量(0.29-0.49)。但是,对于每个VI,其与叶绿素和氮含量的相关模式是相同的:NDRE显示出最强的相关性,NDVI显示出最弱的相关性。对于叶绿素相关性,NDGI(R2=0.6146)>CIrededge(R2=0.5953)>CIgreen(R2=0.5171)。对于氮含量,CIrededge(R2=0.4634)>NDGI(R2=0.4555)>CIgreen(R2=0.4083)。因此,NDRE是评估叶绿素和氮含量最优的VI。Overall, all VIs showed stronger correlations with chlorophyll (0.5-0.65) than nitrogen content (0.29-0.49). However, for each VI, the correlation patterns with chlorophyll and nitrogen content were the same: NDRE showed the strongest correlation and NDVI the weakest. For chlorophyll correlation, NDGI (R 2 =0.6146)>CIrededge (R 2 =0.5953)>CIgreen (R 2 =0.5171). For nitrogen content, CIrededge (R 2 =0.4634)>NDGI (R 2 =0.4555)>CIgreen (R 2 =0.4083). Therefore, NDRE is the best VI for evaluating chlorophyll and nitrogen content.

5、NDRE实时模式可逆向分析水稻品种间的生长差异5. NDRE real-time mode can reversely analyze the growth differences between rice varieties

为了分析从移栽时期到收获时期整个生育周期,将51个水稻品种种植于矩形小区(1.2m×1.6m)中,每5-7天(根据阳光条件决定)试用UAV收集图像数据。RGB图像(图3A)和NDRE(图3B)示出了6个时期的图像。测试组中包括一个紫稻品种作为内部控制,由于该紫稻品种含有的花青素高于叶绿素,因此在数据处理时有利于在反射特征上与其他品种相区别。NDRE值介于冷蓝色0与暖红色的1之间,因此,相对而言,较暖的颜色表示较高的叶绿素含量、氮积累和光合速率,较冷的颜色反之。所有品种的生育周期中,从TS期、JS期到PIS期,NDRE值逐渐升高,BS期之后迅速下降。In order to analyze the entire growth cycle from the transplanting period to the harvesting period, 51 rice varieties were planted in rectangular plots (1.2m × 1.6m), and image data were collected by trial UAV every 5-7 days (depending on sunlight conditions). RGB images (Fig. 3A) and NDRE (Fig. 3B) show images for 6 epochs. A purple rice variety was included in the test group as an internal control. Since this purple rice variety contains more anthocyanins than chlorophyll, it is beneficial to distinguish it from other varieties in reflection characteristics during data processing. NDRE values are between 0 for cool blues and 1 for warm reds, so, relatively speaking, warmer colors indicate higher chlorophyll content, nitrogen accumulation, and photosynthetic rates, and cooler colors conversely. In the growth cycle of all varieties, the NDRE value gradually increased from TS stage, JS stage to PIS stage, and decreased rapidly after BS stage.

51个水稻品种各生育期的NDRE值范围如下:TS期(0.4121-0.5473),JS期(0.4555-0.6173),PIS期(0.3762-0.5762),BS期(0.3506-0.5394),FHS期(0.1931-0.4134),MRS期(0.1487-0.3343)。其中,TS、JS、PIS和BS在水稻品种#33(Qingtai Ai)中观察到最高NDRE,FHS和MRS在水稻品种#1(LY9348)中观察到最高NDRE。#17(ARC11777,TS),#4(Luohong 4B,JS和PIS),#16(MaMaGu,BS),#7(ZuiHou,FHS)和#28(MoMi,MRS)中观察到最低NDRE。The range of NDRE values of 51 rice varieties at each growth stage is as follows: TS stage (0.4121-0.5473), JS stage (0.4555-0.6173), PIS stage (0.3762-0.5762), BS stage (0.3506-0.5394), FHS stage (0.1931- 0.4134), MRS period (0.1487-0.3343). Among them, TS, JS, PIS and BS observed the highest NDRE in rice cultivar #33 (Qingtai Ai), and FHS and MRS observed the highest NDRE in rice cultivar #1 (LY9348). The lowest NDREs were observed in #17 (ARC11777, TS), #4 (Luohong 4B, JS and PIS), #16 (MaMaGu, BS), #7 (ZuiHou, FHS) and #28 (MoMi, MRS).

所有水稻品种的JS期、PIS期和BS期都观察到0.5以上的高NDRE值,这与水稻发育相关,因为JS期是营养生长期间生物量快速累积的时期,PIS/BS期是营养生长向生殖生长的转化阶段,这说明叶和茎的生长比之后的花和种子产生需要更多的能量。但是,在51个水稻品种中的同一时期,或者在同一个品种的不同时期,精确的最大NDRE值、达到最大NDRE值以及从最大NDRE值回落的时刻差异很大。这说明,叶绿素含量、光合速率、氮吸收、转运、累积和维持氮水平的能力在这些品种中各不相同,在整个生育周期中的不同时期也不一样。因此,NDRE可作为测量和评估叶绿素和氮积累实时变化的参数。High NDRE values above 0.5 were observed at JS, PIS and BS stages of all rice cultivars, which were related to rice development, because JS stage is the period of rapid biomass accumulation during vegetative growth, and PIS/BS stage is the vegetative growth direction. The transformation stage of reproductive growth, which states that leaf and stem growth requires more energy than subsequent flower and seed production. However, the exact maximum NDRE value, the time of reaching the maximum NDRE value, and the time of falling back from the maximum NDRE value varied widely in the same period among the 51 rice varieties, or in different periods of the same variety. This suggests that chlorophyll content, photosynthetic rate, nitrogen uptake, transport, accumulation, and ability to maintain nitrogen levels vary among these cultivars and at different times throughout the growth cycle. Therefore, NDRE can be used as a parameter to measure and evaluate real-time changes in chlorophyll and nitrogen accumulation.

6、预测模型的优化及modelⅠ和Ⅱ的建立6. Optimization of prediction model and establishment of model I and II

6.1、modelⅠ的建立6.1. Establishment of model I

为了确定在不同生育期NDRE与叶绿素和氮的相关性为何发生变化,对51个水稻品种6个生育期总共306个数据绘制散点图用于分析(图4A和C)。在移栽后,水稻植株从小植株(40cm高,5-6叶)发育成大植株(120cm,16-18叶)。生物量的成长和冠层修饰基于叶绿素和氮的积累。To determine why the correlations of NDRE with chlorophyll and nitrogen varied at different growth stages, scatter plots were drawn for a total of 306 data from 51 rice varieties at 6 growth stages for analysis (Figure 4A and C). After transplantation, rice plants developed from small plants (40 cm high, 5-6 leaves) to large plants (120 cm, 16-18 leaves). Biomass growth and canopy modification are based on chlorophyll and nitrogen accumulation.

考虑到TS阶段的生物量小、叶片窄、植株小,叶绿素和氮含量可能被错误地高估了,该时期的反射率其实是植株本身与稻田水体的混合特征。基于该推断,我们剔除TS期数据,重新建立回归模型,NDRE与叶绿素具有更好的相关性R2=0.8127,NDRE与N%也具有更好的相关系数R2在0.60以上(图4B和D)。由于N%是通过元素定量分析(EQA)法测量得到的,因此,我们认为,回归模型(y=5.754x2+8.167x+0.5752)是基于实际测量值的预测模型,作为modelⅠ,用于下面的进一步分析。Considering the small biomass, narrow leaves, and small plants at the TS stage, the chlorophyll and nitrogen contents may have been falsely overestimated, and the reflectance at this stage is actually a mixed characteristic of the plant itself and the paddy water body. Based on this inference, we removed the TS period data and re-established the regression model, NDRE and chlorophyll had a better correlation R 2 =0.8127, NDRE and N% also had a better correlation coefficient R 2 above 0.60 (Figure 4B and D ). Since N% is measured by the Elemental Quantitative Analysis (EQA) method, we consider that the regression model (y=5.754x 2 +8.167x+0.5752) is a prediction model based on the actual measured value, which is used as model I for the following further analysis.

总之,仅将冠层充分覆盖水面后的生育期(JS期及以后)的数据用于数据处理,NDRE与叶绿素和氮含量具有更好的相关性。所建立的NDRE与氮含量模型的R2显著提高。In conclusion, only the data of the growth period (JS period and later) after the canopy fully covered the water surface was used for data processing, and NDRE had better correlation with chlorophyll and nitrogen content. The R2 of the established NDRE versus nitrogen content model was significantly improved.

6.2、LAI对NDRE与氮含量的相关性有影响及modelⅡ的建立。6.2. LAI has influence on the correlation between NDRE and nitrogen content and the establishment of model II.

为了确定冠层结构是否是影响氮含量与NDRE相关性的关键因素,使用42个水稻品种的训练数据集(2017,表2)进行分析。测量叶面积指数(LAI)和氮含量(EQA),通过UAV数据计算NDRE。使用N%LAI而非N%作为相关性分析的参数。得到了非线性模型y=1.05571e4.5666x(modelⅡ),R2为0.86(图6)。该模型的相关性比ModelI更好。因此,以上实验证明,将冠层结构例如LAI纳入考虑后,NDRE与氮含量表现出强相关。To determine whether canopy structure is a key factor affecting the correlation of nitrogen content with NDRE, the analysis was performed using a training dataset of 42 rice cultivars (2017, Table 2). Leaf area index (LAI) and nitrogen content (EQA) were measured and NDRE was calculated from UAV data. Use N%LAI instead of N% as the parameter for correlation analysis. The nonlinear model y = 1.05571e 4.5666x (model II) was obtained, with an R 2 of 0.86 (Fig. 6). This model correlates better than ModelI. Therefore, the above experiments demonstrate that NDRE exhibits a strong correlation with nitrogen content after taking into account the canopy structure such as LAI.

7、LY9348各时期的VI和氮含量与其他水稻品种的比较7. Comparison of VI and nitrogen content of LY9348 with other rice varieties in different periods

7.1、NDRE值的比较7.1. Comparison of NDRE values

我们仔细分析LY9348在整个生育周期中氮含量的变化曲线和NDRE值发现,与51个水稻品种的NDRE值相比,LY9348在FHS和MRS期的NDRE值最高。另一方,在营养生长时期(TS期(0.41-0.55),JS期(0.46-0.62),PIS期(0.38-0.58),BS期(0.35-0.54)),LY9348的NDRE值相对较高但不是最高(TS(0.50),JS(0.56),PIS(0.54)和BS(0.51))。We carefully analyzed the change curve of nitrogen content and NDRE value of LY9348 in the whole growth cycle and found that compared with the NDRE value of 51 rice varieties, LY9348 had the highest NDRE value in FHS and MRS stages. On the other hand, in the vegetative growth period (TS period (0.41-0.55), JS period (0.46-0.62), PIS period (0.38-0.58), BS period (0.35-0.54)), the NDRE value of LY9348 was relatively high but not highest (TS(0.50), JS(0.56), PIS(0.54) and BS(0.51)).

尽管LY9348与其他品种之间的明显氮含量差异出现在穂和籽粒发育时期,但是较早时期的氮含量水平也值得监控。许多之前的研究显示,TS和BS期增加氮肥可有效增加分蘖数、生物量和光合产物。但是,这些时期过度的氮施用可能产生更多的无效分蘖、浅根、不健康的植物形态结构,以及延迟营养生长向生殖生长的转化,从而导致减产。此外,在PIS和BS期正确地施用氮肥,可增加穂的数量、每穂颖花数、结实率和籽粒,但是如果过度施用氮肥,这些产量相关特征将会降低。因此,从全局评价的角度而言,高NUE表型不仅仅局限于生殖阶段(FHS期和MRS期)的高氮含量水平,在营养生长阶段以及在营养-生殖过渡阶段,氮含量处于适度高水平是高NUE表型的一部分。Although the obvious difference in nitrogen content between LY9348 and other cultivars appeared during the period of rice and grain development, nitrogen levels at earlier periods were also worth monitoring. Many previous studies have shown that increasing nitrogen fertilizer during TS and BS periods can effectively increase tiller number, biomass, and photosynthesis. However, excessive nitrogen application during these periods may produce more ineffective tillers, shallow roots, unhealthy plant morphology, and delayed conversion of vegetative to reproductive growth, leading to reduced yields. In addition, correct nitrogen application during the PIS and BS periods can increase the number of stalks, spikelets per stalk, seed setting and grain, but these yield-related traits will decrease if nitrogen is over-applied. Therefore, from a global evaluation point of view, the high NUE phenotype is not limited to high nitrogen levels during reproductive stages (FHS and MRS), but moderately high nitrogen levels during vegetative growth and vegetative-reproductive transitions levels are part of the high NUE phenotype.

以上实验和分析说明,通过遥感技术获得反射率数据计算的NDRE值,估算的水稻整个生育周期内或部分生育周期内的氮含量变化曲线是每个水稻品种在特定的环境下的稳定性状,可以作为NUE表型。The above experiments and analysis show that the NDRE value calculated from the reflectance data obtained by remote sensing technology, the estimated nitrogen content change curve in the entire growth cycle or part of the growth cycle of rice is the stability of each rice variety in a specific environment, which can be as a NUE phenotype.

7.2、氮含量的比较7.2. Comparison of nitrogen content

我们对51个水稻品种的6个生育期的数据进行了进一步分析。EQA法进行氮含量估计显示,在51个水稻品种中,LY9348所有6个时期均维持较高的氮含量,但是在MRS期比其他水稻品种都高(图7A)。ModelI和ModelII都检测到LY9348在营养生长时期维持较高但非最高的氮含量水平,在FHS和MRS期具有最高氮含量水平(图7B和C)。但是,ModelI得到的51个水稻品种TS、JS、PIS到BS期的氮含量变化曲线比ModelII更平,因此,ModelII似乎具有更好的检测敏感性和精度。We conducted further analysis of the data from 51 rice cultivars at 6 growth stages. Nitrogen content estimation by EQA method showed that, among 51 rice cultivars, LY9348 maintained higher nitrogen content in all 6 periods, but higher than other rice cultivars during the MRS stage (Fig. 7A). Both Model I and Model II detected that LY9348 maintained higher, but not the highest, nitrogen levels during vegetative growth and had the highest nitrogen levels during FHS and MRS (Figure 7B and C). However, the nitrogen content variation curves of 51 rice cultivars from TS, JS, PIS to BS stages obtained by ModelI were flatter than those obtained by Model II, so Model II seemed to have better detection sensitivity and precision.

有趣的是,我们使用测氮仪N-pen N110 meter检测氮含量,绘制氮含量变化曲线,结果显示,尽管测氮仪检测的氮含量与EQA测量的氮含量具有高相关性(R2为0.68-0.89),但是它未能在FHS和MRS期将LY9348与其他品种区分出来。这可能是因为通过掌上测氮仪测量和估计的反射率特征的饱和度无法检测低于2%的氮含量。Interestingly, we used the N-pen N110 meter to detect nitrogen content and plotted the nitrogen content change curve, and the results showed that although the nitrogen content measured by the nitrogen meter had a high correlation with the nitrogen content measured by EQA (R2 was 0.68 ) . -0.89), but it failed to differentiate LY9348 from other varieties during FHS and MRS periods. This may be because the saturation of reflectance features measured and estimated by the handheld nitrogen meter cannot detect nitrogen levels below 2%.

我们的实验还证明,获取反射率的高度(50-200m)不影响对氮含量的估算。此外,无论是在ModelI还是ModelII中,我们都没有对叶和穂进行区分以用于氮含量估计,仅仅将每个品种的总反射率特征用于对氮含量进行混合估计。Our experiments also demonstrate that the height (50-200m) at which the reflectance is obtained does not affect the estimation of nitrogen content. Furthermore, neither in Model I nor Model II, we did not distinguish between leaves and stalks for nitrogen content estimation, only the total reflectance feature of each variety was used for mixed estimation of nitrogen content.

需要说明的是,尽管我们尽量将modelI与ModelII的数据与EQA测量结果相拟合,但是,EQA的测量方式是采样测量,也存在系统误差,而ModelI和II是宏观数据测算结果,事实上我们不能完全确定到底是ModelI和II估算结果与真实氮含量之间的误差大,还是EQA测量结果与真实氮含量之间的误差大。这种系统误差可能就是EQA法未能比modelI与ModelII更好地从群体中区分出高NUE的LY9348的原因。It should be noted that although we try to fit the data of model I and Model II with the measurement results of EQA, the measurement method of EQA is sampling measurement, and there are also systematic errors, while Model I and II are the results of macro data calculation. In fact, we It is not entirely certain whether the error between the Model I and II estimates and the true nitrogen content is large, or whether the error between the EQA measurements and the true nitrogen content is large. This systematic error may be the reason why the EQA method failed to distinguish the high NUE LY9348 from the population better than model I and model II.

我们根据以上实验可得出结论,LY9348在6个生长时期的NDRE值或由NDRE值计算的氮含量构成的独特的变化曲线在相同或相似的环境条件是稳定的性状,因此,可用于高通量筛选高NUE的水稻品种,由此得到的筛选方法在从大量水稻品种中高通量筛选高NUE品种的是可行并且可靠的Based on the above experiments, we can conclude that the NDRE value of LY9348 or the unique change curve composed of nitrogen content calculated from the NDRE value in the six growth periods is a stable trait under the same or similar environmental conditions, therefore, it can be used for high-pass quantitative screening of high-NUE rice varieties, and the resulting screening method is feasible and reliable for high-throughput screening of high-NUE varieties from a large number of rice varieties

我们使用该方法LY9348的氮含量变化曲线作为标准筛选到了几种可能的高NUE水稻品种,正在进行进一步的实验验证。Using this method, the nitrogen content change curve of LY9348 was used as a standard to screen several possible high-NUE rice varieties, and further experimental verification is underway.

此外,尽管本发明的实施例部分一直围绕水稻和NUE进行描述,但是,本发明的方法也可适应性地应用到其他植物(例如小麦、玉米等)和其他营养元素(例如磷、钾等)中。In addition, although the example section of the present invention has been described around rice and NUE, the method of the present invention can also be adapted to other plants (eg, wheat, corn, etc.) and other nutrients (eg, phosphorus, potassium, etc.) middle.

以上所述仅为本发明的较佳实施例,并不用以限制本发明。凡在本发明的精神和原则之内,所作的任何修改、等同替换、改进等,均应包含在本发明的保护范围之内。The above descriptions are only preferred embodiments of the present invention, and are not intended to limit the present invention. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention shall be included within the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims (1)

  1. The application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties is characterized by comprising the step of using nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 as screening standards, and the method comprises the following steps;
    s1: acquiring nitrogen-related traits of LY9348 in multiple growth periods under a specific environment;
    s2: acquiring nitrogen-related characters of the rice variety to be screened in a corresponding growth period under a corresponding environment;
    s3: comparing the nitrogen-related traits of the rice variety to be screened with those of LY9348, and when the nitrogen-related traits of the rice variety to be screened are the same as or higher than those of LY9348, making the rice variety to be screened be a high-NUE rice variety;
    the nitrogen-related traits are nitrogen contents of a plurality of growth periods, wherein the plurality of growth periods comprise a tillering period, an elongation period, an ear differentiation period, a booting period, a heading period and a milk stage;
    the nitrogen content is a nitrogen content calculated using the NDRE value.
CN202011001533.3A 2020-09-22 2020-09-22 Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties Active CN112362803B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202011001533.3A CN112362803B (en) 2020-09-22 2020-09-22 Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202011001533.3A CN112362803B (en) 2020-09-22 2020-09-22 Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN112362803A CN112362803A (en) 2021-02-12
CN112362803B true CN112362803B (en) 2022-04-22

Family

ID=74516399

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN202011001533.3A Active CN112362803B (en) 2020-09-22 2020-09-22 Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN112362803B (en)

Families Citing this family (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN116308866B (en) * 2023-05-23 2023-07-28 武汉大学 Rice ear biomass estimation method and system based on canopy reflection spectrum

Citations (10)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2012103452A1 (en) * 2011-01-27 2012-08-02 Syngenta Participations Ag Novel use of a dense and erect panicle 1 gene in improving nitrogen utilization efficiency
CN103262790A (en) * 2013-06-14 2013-08-28 武汉大学 Method for selectively breeding Honglian type rice blast-resistant sterile lines
CN106576728A (en) * 2016-11-17 2017-04-26 甘肃农业大学 Method for screening varieties with high utilization rate of nitrogen from multiple wheat varieties
CN108157170A (en) * 2017-12-29 2018-06-15 中国水稻研究所 A kind of screening technique of nitrogen high-efficiency rice kind
CN108254507A (en) * 2018-01-25 2018-07-06 中国水稻研究所 A kind of efficient Varieties In The Seedling Stage identification method of rice nitrogen
CN109042314A (en) * 2018-08-17 2018-12-21 中国农业科学院油料作物研究所 A method of the efficient rape variety of nitrogen is screened using seedling stage cabbage type rape culture experiment
CN109042176A (en) * 2018-09-18 2018-12-21 扬州大学 A kind of screening technique of high nitrogen fertilizer utilization efficiency rice varieties
CN109169266A (en) * 2018-10-16 2019-01-11 湖北省农业科学院粮食作物研究所 A kind of heat-resisting rice screening technique of high throughput
CN109187398A (en) * 2018-11-08 2019-01-11 河南省农业科学院植物营养与资源环境研究所 A kind of EO-1 hyperion measuring method of wheat plant nitrogen content
CN110214658A (en) * 2019-07-26 2019-09-10 湖北省地质科学研究院(湖北省富硒产业研究院) A kind of selenium-rich rice implantation methods controlling Se content

Family Cites Families (11)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
PT1827078E (en) * 2004-12-21 2014-05-26 Monsanto Technology Llc Transgenic plants with enhanced agronomic traits
US20090199308A1 (en) * 2005-08-30 2009-08-06 Kimberly Zobrist Duff Transgenic plants with enhanced agronomic traits
US20090011516A1 (en) * 2007-07-03 2009-01-08 Pioneer Hi-Bred International, Inc. Methods and Assays for the Detection of Nitrogen Uptake by a Plant and Uses Thereof
WO2010083178A1 (en) * 2009-01-16 2010-07-22 Monsanto Technology Llc Isolated novel nucleic acid and protein molecules from corn and methods of using those molecules to generate transgenic plants with enhanced agronomic traits
EA201391174A1 (en) * 2011-02-28 2014-04-30 Басф Плант Сайенс Компани Гмбх PLANTS WITH IMPROVED PRODUCTIVITY AND METHOD OF THEIR RECEPTION
WO2016089934A1 (en) * 2014-12-03 2016-06-09 Monsanto Technology Llc Transgenic plants with enhanced traits
CN106290197A (en) * 2016-09-06 2017-01-04 西北农林科技大学 The estimation of rice leaf total nitrogen content EO-1 hyperion and estimation models construction method
CN106577268A (en) * 2016-11-17 2017-04-26 甘肃农业大学 Method for screening variety with high phosphorus utilization efficiency from multiple wheat varieties
CN107980512B (en) * 2017-11-27 2020-03-27 河南农业大学 Screening and evaluating method for high-yield multi-resistance high-quality wheat variety
CN108901823A (en) * 2018-06-22 2018-11-30 安徽袁粮水稻产业有限公司 A kind of method of efficient breeding low-kalium resistant high-yield rice breeding material
CN109315286B (en) * 2018-10-12 2021-09-24 四川省农业科学院土壤肥料研究所 Method for screening corn genotype for improving nitrogen efficiency of corn/soybean intercropping system

Patent Citations (10)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2012103452A1 (en) * 2011-01-27 2012-08-02 Syngenta Participations Ag Novel use of a dense and erect panicle 1 gene in improving nitrogen utilization efficiency
CN103262790A (en) * 2013-06-14 2013-08-28 武汉大学 Method for selectively breeding Honglian type rice blast-resistant sterile lines
CN106576728A (en) * 2016-11-17 2017-04-26 甘肃农业大学 Method for screening varieties with high utilization rate of nitrogen from multiple wheat varieties
CN108157170A (en) * 2017-12-29 2018-06-15 中国水稻研究所 A kind of screening technique of nitrogen high-efficiency rice kind
CN108254507A (en) * 2018-01-25 2018-07-06 中国水稻研究所 A kind of efficient Varieties In The Seedling Stage identification method of rice nitrogen
CN109042314A (en) * 2018-08-17 2018-12-21 中国农业科学院油料作物研究所 A method of the efficient rape variety of nitrogen is screened using seedling stage cabbage type rape culture experiment
CN109042176A (en) * 2018-09-18 2018-12-21 扬州大学 A kind of screening technique of high nitrogen fertilizer utilization efficiency rice varieties
CN109169266A (en) * 2018-10-16 2019-01-11 湖北省农业科学院粮食作物研究所 A kind of heat-resisting rice screening technique of high throughput
CN109187398A (en) * 2018-11-08 2019-01-11 河南省农业科学院植物营养与资源环境研究所 A kind of EO-1 hyperion measuring method of wheat plant nitrogen content
CN110214658A (en) * 2019-07-26 2019-09-10 湖北省地质科学研究院(湖北省富硒产业研究院) A kind of selenium-rich rice implantation methods controlling Se content

Non-Patent Citations (11)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
2016年我国审定的水稻品种及基本特性分析;林海 等;《中国稻米》;20171231(第6期);第1-6,12页 *
Remote Estimation of Rice Yield With Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Data and Spectral Mixture Analysis;Bo Duan et al.;《Frontiers in Plant Science》;20190227;第10卷(第204期);第1-14页 *
Screening and comprehensive evaluation of low nitrogen tolerance of Zhejiang photosensitive japonica rice cultivars;Zhai RongRong et al.;《Journal of Zhejiang University (Agriculture and Life Sciences)》;20161231;第42卷(第5期);第565-572页 *
The control of the brown planthopper by the rice Bph14 gene is affected by nitrogen;Sun Ze et al.;《Pest Management Science》;20200630;第76卷(第11期);第3649-3656页 *
光、氮、密及其互作对杂交稻产量形成和氮肥利用率的影响;谢小兵;《中国博士学位论文全文数据库 农业科技辑》;中国学术期刊(光盘版)电子杂志社;20190515(第5期);第D047-16页 *
冬小麦生物量及氮积累量的植被指数动态模型研究;吴亚鹏 等;《作物学报》;20190510;第45卷(第8期);第1238-1249页 *
基于无人机遥感影像的冬小麦播种效果与空间变异评价;何小安;《中国优秀硕士学位论文全文数据库 农业科技辑》;中国学术期刊(光盘版)电子杂志社;20190115(第1期);第D043-11页 *
水稻OsSEC18和OsVPS37基因的功能研究;孙允芳;《中国博士学位论文全文数据库 农业科技辑》;中国学术期刊(光盘版)电子杂志社;20180715(第7期);第D047-7页 *
水稻在不同生态点的产量及其氮素利用率差异比较;单双吕 等;《中国稻米》;20150909(第4期);第56-61页 *
红莲型细胞质雄性不育的发现利用研究及展望;胡骏 等;《科学通报》;20161220;第61卷(第35期);第3813-3821页 *
绿色优质高产水稻新品种的选育与应用;高方远 等;《生命科学》;20181015;第30卷(第10期);第1113-1119页 *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN112362803A (en) 2021-02-12

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
Shao et al. Genotypic difference in the plasticity of root system architecture of field-grown maize in response to plant density
CN116308866B (en) Rice ear biomass estimation method and system based on canopy reflection spectrum
CN112345467B (en) A Model for Estimating Rice Physiological Parameters Using Remote Sensing Technology and Its Application
CN112362803B (en) Application of LY9348 in high-throughput screening of high NUE rice varieties
Williams II Few crop traits accurately predict variables important to productivity of processing sweet corn
del Pozo et al. Aerial and ground-based phenotyping of an alfalfa diversity panel to assess adaptation to a prolonged drought period in a Mediterranean environment of central Chile
CN112285062B (en) A kind of high NUE rice screening marker and screening method
CN113179883B (en) Evaluation method of yin-resistant wheat
Celestina et al. Use of spike moisture content to define physiological maturity and quantify progress through grain development in wheat and barley
CN116482041B (en) A method and system for non-destructive and rapid identification of rice heading stage based on reflection spectrum
CN117837441A (en) Evaluation and identification method for heat resistance of alfalfa
Prastowo et al. Morphological variations of robusta coffee as a response to different altitude in Lampung
Siband et al. Analysis of the yield of two groups of tropical maize cultivars. Varietal characteristics, yield potentials, optimum densities
Seo et al. Model based on temperature parameters predicts optimal harvest date for ‘Whasan’Asian pear
Yeo et al. Quantum yield for sun-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (ΦF) captures rice plant dynamics under interplant competition
MUSTAFA et al. Chlorophyll content and leaf area correlated with corn (Zea mays) yield components in F1 hybrids
Orozco-Moran et al. Irrigation scheduling of an almond orchard using the water balance and remote and proximal sensing
Walta Evaluation of drone imagery as a method for selection criteria in soybean breeding
Jong et al. Simple estimation of green area rate using image analysis and quantitative traits related to plant architecture and biomass in rice seedling
Duca et al. Drought effect on quantitative traits of sunflower genotypes.
Elos et al. Chlorophyll concentration and morphological diversity in corn lines at different vegetative stages
Romero Vergel et al. A crop modelling strategy to improve Cacao quality and produc-tivity. Plants 2022; 11: 157
Ryandini et al. Identification of the Diversity of Morphological Characteristics of Some Local Upland Rice Cultivars in East Aceh
Van Laere et al. Stable isotope composition of long and short term carbon pools can screen drought tolerance in cassava
CN112293247A (en) An Image Acquisition System for Rice Variety Screening Based on Remote Sensing Technology

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
GR01 Patent grant
GR01 Patent grant