JPH0539542A - Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability - Google Patents

Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability

Info

Publication number
JPH0539542A
JPH0539542A JP21929391A JP21929391A JPH0539542A JP H0539542 A JPH0539542 A JP H0539542A JP 21929391 A JP21929391 A JP 21929391A JP 21929391 A JP21929391 A JP 21929391A JP H0539542 A JPH0539542 A JP H0539542A
Authority
JP
Japan
Prior art keywords
electron beam
steel
toughness
less
pressure vessel
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
JP21929391A
Other languages
Japanese (ja)
Inventor
Yukio Tomita
幸男 冨田
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Nippon Steel Corp
Original Assignee
Nippon Steel Corp
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Nippon Steel Corp filed Critical Nippon Steel Corp
Priority to JP21929391A priority Critical patent/JPH0539542A/en
Publication of JPH0539542A publication Critical patent/JPH0539542A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Landscapes

  • Welding Or Cutting Using Electron Beams (AREA)

Abstract

PURPOSE:To provide a steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability. CONSTITUTION:The objective steel for a pressure vessel is constituted of a compsn. contg., as essential components, 0.17 to 0.35% C, 0.05 to 0.45% Si, 0.6 to 1.7% Mn, <=0.010% P, <=0.010% S, 0.005 to 0.040% Al, 0.0003 to 0.0012% B and <=0.006% N and contg., at need, one or >= two kinds among the elemental group for improving its strength of Cu, Ni, Cr, Mo, Nb and V. This steel has good toughness by electron beam welding, laser beam welding and flash butt welding.

Description

【発明の詳細な説明】Detailed Description of the Invention

【0001】[0001]

【産業上の利用分野】本発明は電子ビーム溶接特性の優
れた圧力容器用鋼材に関するものである。
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 1. Field of the Invention The present invention relates to a pressure vessel steel having excellent electron beam welding characteristics.

【0002】[0002]

【従来の技術】ボイラー・圧力容器設備の安全性、特に
水圧試験時の安全性に関して十分な配慮がなされ、圧力
容器用鋼材に対しても一定の靱性が必要とされる。その
要求は当然構造物の一部を構成する溶接部に対してもな
される。従来の圧力容器用鋼材の溶接は潜孤溶接(SA
W)が主体である。これらの溶接では板厚が厚くなるに
従って加速度的に積層数が増加していく。たとえば、板
厚100mmの材料では狭開先の施工をしてもSAW溶
接では20パス以上の積層が必要となってくる。それに
伴う施工時間は膨大なものとなる。これらの溶接施工効
率の向上と靱性要求に答えるために、電子ビーム溶接の
適用が考えられるようになってきた。電子ビーム溶接は
従来のアーク溶接(SAW溶接)と比べて、板厚50m
mを超える範囲でコスト的に有利な領域となり、板厚が
厚くなるほどその効果は大きくなる。ただ、電子ビーム
溶接は従来の溶接法と異なって、鋼板そのものを溶融さ
せ接合するものであるため、鋼板の製造に当たってはこ
の溶接部、特に靱性を考慮した成分設計を行う必要があ
る。これまで、構造用鋼に関する公知文献としては、特
開平2−77557号、特開平2−77561号、特開
平2−77562号及び特開平2−277743号公報
があるが、さらに一層電子ビーム溶接部靱性の優れた構
造用鋼が求められている。
2. Description of the Related Art Sufficient consideration has been given to the safety of boiler / pressure vessel equipment, especially the safety at the time of water pressure test, and a certain toughness is also required for steel for pressure vessels. The demand is naturally made also on the welded portion forming a part of the structure. Conventional welding of steel for pressure vessels is performed by latent welding (SA
W) is the main subject. In these weldings, the number of laminated layers increases at an accelerating rate as the plate thickness increases. For example, with a material having a plate thickness of 100 mm, it is necessary to stack 20 passes or more in SAW welding even if a narrow groove is applied. The construction time associated therewith becomes enormous. In order to improve the welding efficiency and meet the toughness requirements, application of electron beam welding has come to be considered. Electron beam welding is 50m thicker than conventional arc welding (SAW welding)
In the range exceeding m, it becomes a region advantageous in terms of cost, and the effect increases as the plate thickness increases. However, unlike conventional welding methods, electron beam welding involves melting and joining the steel sheet itself, and therefore in the production of the steel sheet, it is necessary to design the composition in consideration of this welded portion, particularly toughness. Heretofore, as publicly known documents relating to structural steel, there are JP-A-2-77557, JP-A-2-77561, JP-A-2-77562 and JP-A-2-277743, but the electron beam welded portion is further improved. Structural steel with excellent toughness is required.

【0003】[0003]

【発明が解決しようとする課題】本発明の目的は以上の
点を鑑みなされたもので、電子ビーム溶接による溶接を
行っても溶接部の低温靱性の良好な電子ビーム溶接特性
の優れた圧力容器用鋼材を提供することにある。
The object of the present invention was made in view of the above points, and a pressure vessel having excellent electron beam welding characteristics with good low temperature toughness of the welded portion even if welding by electron beam welding is performed. It is to provide steel materials for use.

【0004】[0004]

【課題を解決するための手段】本発明は重量%で、C:
0.17〜0.35%、Si:0.05〜0.45%、
Mn:0.6〜1.70%、P:0.010%以下、
S:0.010%以下、Al:0.005〜0.040
%、B:0.0003〜0.0012%、N:0.00
6%以下、残部Fe、及び不可避的不純物からなること
を特徴とする電子ビーム溶接特性の優れた圧力容器用鋼
材、及び、重量%で、C:0.17〜0.35%、S
i:0.05〜0.45%、Mn:0.6〜1.70
%、P:0.010%以下、S:0.010%以下、A
l:0.005〜0.040%、B:0.0003〜
0.0012%、N:0.006%以下、を基本成分と
し、さらに、Cu≦2.0%、Ni≦4.0%、Cr≦
1.0%、Mo≦1.0%、Nb≦0.1%、V≦0.
1%からなる強度改善元素群のうちの1種または2種以
上を含有し、残部Fe、及び不可避的不純物からなるこ
とを特徴とする電子ビーム溶接特性の優れた圧力容器用
鋼材である。
The present invention, in% by weight, comprises C:
0.17 to 0.35%, Si: 0.05 to 0.45%,
Mn: 0.6 to 1.70%, P: 0.010% or less,
S: 0.010% or less, Al: 0.005-0.040
%, B: 0.0003 to 0.0012%, N: 0.00
6% or less, balance Fe, and inevitable impurities, steel material for pressure vessel having excellent electron beam welding characteristics, and C: 0.17 to 0.35% by weight, S
i: 0.05 to 0.45%, Mn: 0.6 to 1.70
%, P: 0.010% or less, S: 0.010% or less, A
1: 0.005-0.040%, B: 0.0003-
0.0012%, N: 0.006% or less as a basic component, and Cu ≦ 2.0%, Ni ≦ 4.0%, Cr ≦
1.0%, Mo ≦ 1.0%, Nb ≦ 0.1%, V ≦ 0.
A steel material for a pressure vessel having excellent electron beam welding characteristics, characterized in that it contains one or more kinds of a strength improving element group consisting of 1% and the balance is Fe and inevitable impurities.

【0005】[0005]

【作用】電子ビーム溶接は従来の溶接法のように溶接部
に別の材料を供給し、溶接部の特性向上を図るのではな
く、鋼板そのものを溶融させ溶接するものである。その
ため、鋼板製造にあたって細粒化などの方法により高靱
性を有する鋼板に調整させるが、これが高温で溶融され
るため靱性の低いものとなってしまう。特開平2−77
557号、特開平2−77561号、特開平2−775
62号及び特開平2−277743号公報で示されてい
る知見は、電子ビーム溶接部の粒内、粒界に析出する粗
大な炭化物、窒化物が電子ビーム溶接部の靱性を低下さ
せるというものである。発明者らは、ここにおいて、電
子ビーム溶接部でさらに良好な靱性を有する鋼材を開発
すべく種々検討した結果、靱性の低いものでは、溶接部
の靱性を評価するシャルピー試験の破壊の起点付近に凝
固偏析に沿ったマイクロクラックが発生する。これが靱
性を大幅に低下する。つまり、電子ビーム溶接部の靱性
向上のためには、マイクロクラックをなくすことが重要
で、このためには、凝固偏析軽減が必要であることを見
出したものである。この凝固偏析を軽減するためには、
P,Nの含有量をある範囲に収めること、つまり、これ
らの効果の重畳作用により著しく電子ビーム溶接部の靱
性が向上することを見い出した。さらに、Cの凝固偏析
防止には、B添加によるセメンタイトの粒内への均一析
出が有効であることも見出した。
In the electron beam welding, unlike the conventional welding method, another material is supplied to the welded portion to improve the characteristics of the welded portion, and the steel sheet itself is melted and welded. Therefore, a steel plate having high toughness is adjusted by a method such as grain refinement in the production of a steel plate, but since this is melted at a high temperature, the toughness becomes low. JP-A-2-77
557, JP-A-2-77561, and JP-A-2-775.
No. 62 and Japanese Patent Laid-Open No. 2-277743 disclose that coarse carbides and nitrides precipitated in the grain of the electron beam weld and at grain boundaries reduce the toughness of the electron beam weld. is there. As a result of various investigations to develop a steel material having a better toughness in the electron beam welded portion, the inventors have found that, in the case where the toughness is low, it is close to the point of failure of the Charpy test for evaluating the toughness of the welded portion. Microcracks are generated along with solidification segregation. This significantly reduces toughness. That is, it has been found that it is important to eliminate microcracks in order to improve the toughness of the electron beam welded portion, and for this purpose, solidification segregation reduction is necessary. In order to reduce this solidification segregation,
It has been found that the P and N contents are kept within a certain range, that is, the superposition of these effects significantly improves the toughness of the electron beam weld. Further, it was found that uniform precipitation of cementite in the grain by adding B is effective for preventing solidification segregation of C.

【0006】図1は電子ビーム溶接部のシャルピー衝撃
試験値vE_10に及ぼすPとN量の影響を示す図であ
る。C量は0.23%である。P量を0.010%以
下、N量を0.006%以下にすることによりvE_10
≧6kgf・mの良靱性が得られる。しかも個々の成分
の影響は直線的でない。たとえば、N:0.009%で
Pが0.015から0.010%に低下した場合は、v
E_10が0.8から1.3kgf・mにしかならないの
に、N:0.006%でPが0.015から0.010
%に低下した場合は、vE_10が1.0から6.5kg
f・mと大幅に向上する。以下に成分の限定理由を述べ
る。Cは強度を確保するために必要な元素で、最低0.
17%は必要である。しかし、0.35%を超えると電
子ビーム溶接部の靱性が著しく低下するため上限を0.
35%とする。Siは低温靱性、溶接性を低下させる元
素なので、極力低減させ0.45%を上限とする。しか
し、製鋼上0.05%は必要である。Mnは強度を確保
するために必要な元素で、0.6%以上添加する必要が
あるが、1.7%を超えて含有させると、溶接性が低下
するばかりでなく、コスト上昇を招き、経済的でないた
め、1.7%を上限とする。Pは先に述べたように、
C,Nとの重畳作用により凝固偏析によるマイクロクラ
ック発生のために電子ビーム溶接部の靱性を低減するた
め、0.010%以下に低減することが必要である。S
は靱性に有害な元素であり、0.010%以下に限定す
る。
FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the influence of the amounts of P and N on the Charpy impact test value vE_ 10 of the electron beam welded portion. The amount of C is 0.23%. By setting the P content to 0.010% or less and the N content to 0.006% or less, vE_ 10
A toughness of ≧ 6 kgf · m can be obtained. Moreover, the effects of the individual components are not linear. For example, when N is 0.009% and P is decreased from 0.015 to 0.010%, v
To E_ 10 is not only to 1.3kgf · m from 0.8, N: P is from 0.015 at 0.006% or 0.010
If you drop in%, 6.5 kg from VE_ 10 1.0
Greatly improved to f ・ m. The reasons for limiting the components will be described below. C is an element necessary to secure the strength, and is at least 0.
17% is required. However, if it exceeds 0.35%, the toughness of the electron beam welded portion is remarkably reduced, so the upper limit is set to 0.
35%. Since Si is an element that lowers the low temperature toughness and weldability, it is reduced as much as possible and 0.45% is made the upper limit. However, 0.05% is necessary for steelmaking. Mn is an element necessary to secure the strength, and it is necessary to add it in an amount of 0.6% or more. However, if it exceeds 1.7%, not only the weldability is deteriorated but also the cost is increased. Since it is not economical, the upper limit is 1.7%. As mentioned above, P is
It is necessary to reduce the toughness of the electron beam welded portion to 0.010% or less in order to reduce the toughness of the electron beam welded portion due to the generation of microcracks due to solidification segregation due to the overlapping action with C and N. S
Is an element harmful to toughness and is limited to 0.010% or less.

【0007】Alは脱酸上0.005%以上必要である
が、0.040%を超えるとNとの比が小さくなりすぎ
AlN析出物が粗大化し、靱性がかえって低下するた
め、上限を0.040%とする。Bは電子ビーム溶接部
靱性を向上させるのに不可欠な元素で、0.0003%
以上添加するが、0.0012%を超えると母材強度を
上げすぎるため上限は0.0012%とする。Nは先に
述べたように、Pとの相乗作用により凝固偏析によるマ
イクロクラック発生のために電子ビーム溶接部の靱性を
低減するため、0.006%を上限とする。Cu,N
i,Cr,Mo,Nb及びVは鋼の強度を上昇させると
いう均等的作用を持つもので、必要に応じて1種または
2種以上含有させるが、それぞれCu:2.0%、N
i:4.0%、Cr:1.0%、Mo:1.0%、N
b:0.1%及びV:0.1%の含有上限値を超えて含
有させても、その作用効果が飽和したり、コスト上昇を
招き、経済的でないため、上記の強度改善元素群のそれ
ぞれの成分の含有量を上記の通り定めた。この鋼を溶製
するにあたっては電気炉、転炉のいづれを用いてもよ
い。鋼板とするにあたっては、鍛造、圧延のいづれを用
いてもよい。また鋼板の熱処理は圧延まま、焼きなら
し、焼きならし−焼戻し、あるいは厚手材の場合は加速
冷却を使用することも可能である。
Al is required to be 0.005% or more for deoxidation, but if it exceeds 0.040%, the ratio with N becomes too small and the AlN precipitates become coarse and the toughness deteriorates, so the upper limit is 0. 0.040%. B is an essential element for improving the toughness of electron beam welds, and 0.0003%
Although it is added as described above, if it exceeds 0.0012%, the base material strength is excessively increased, so the upper limit is made 0.0012%. As described above, N reduces the toughness of the electron beam welded portion due to the generation of microcracks due to solidification segregation due to the synergistic action with P, so the upper limit is 0.006%. Cu, N
i, Cr, Mo, Nb and V have an equal effect of increasing the strength of steel, and if necessary, one or more of them may be contained. Cu: 2.0%, N
i: 4.0%, Cr: 1.0%, Mo: 1.0%, N
Even if the content exceeds the upper limit of the content of b: 0.1% and V: 0.1%, the effect is saturated, the cost is increased, and it is not economical. The content of each component was determined as described above. Either an electric furnace or a converter may be used for melting this steel. In forming the steel sheet, either forging or rolling may be used. Further, as the heat treatment of the steel sheet, it is possible to use normalizing, normalizing-tempering, or accelerating cooling in the case of thick material, as it is rolled.

【0008】[0008]

【実施例】表1に示す化学成分のうち1〜10は本発明
鋼で、11〜20は比較鋼である。鋼の溶製は転炉によ
り行い、常法によりスラブとしたのち表1に示す板厚に
厚板圧延した。鋼板の熱処理は1,2,11〜13は圧
延まま、3,4,6,7,14,15は910℃の焼き
ならし、5,16は加速冷却、8〜10、17〜20は
910℃焼きならし−650℃の焼戻しである。表1に
これらの鋼の母材の引張試験、シャルピー衝撃試験及び
電子ビーム溶接部のシャルピー衝撃試験結果を示す。但
し、電子ビーム溶接条件は電圧150kV、電流180
mA、速度20cm/min.である。電子ビーム溶接
部のシャルピー衝撃試験のノッチ位置は溶接金属中央で
ある。
EXAMPLES Among the chemical components shown in Table 1, 1 to 10 are steels of the present invention, and 11 to 20 are comparative steels. Smelting of steel was carried out by a converter, and a slab was formed by a conventional method, and then rolled into a plate thickness shown in Table 1. In the heat treatment of the steel sheet, 1, 2, 11 to 13 are as-rolled, 3, 4, 6, 7, 14, 15 are normalized at 910 ° C., 5 and 16 are accelerated cooling, and 8 to 10 and 17 to 910 are 910. C. Normalization-Temperature of -650.degree. Table 1 shows the results of the tensile test, the Charpy impact test, and the electron beam welded Charpy impact test of the base materials of these steels. However, electron beam welding conditions are voltage 150 kV, current 180
mA, speed 20 cm / min. The notch position of the Charpy impact test of the electron beam weld is the center of the weld metal.

【0009】[0009]

【表1A】 [Table 1A]

【0010】[0010]

【表1B】 [Table 1B]

【0011】本発明の鋼1〜10はPとN量を適切な範
囲に入れることにより、それらの相乗作用により良好な
電子ビーム溶接部の低温靱性を有している。母材特性も
良好である。次に、鋼11,12はPが高く、鋼13は
Nが高く、鋼14,15はPが高く、鋼16はNが高
く、鋼17はPが高くそれぞれ電子ビーム溶接部の靱性
が低い。鋼18はCが低いため強度が低くなっている。
鋼19はBが低く、電子ビーム溶接部の靱性が低い。鋼
20はBが高く、母材強度が高すぎ、母材靱性及び電子
ビーム溶接部の靱性が低い。
The steels 1 to 10 according to the present invention have good low temperature toughness of the electron beam welded portion due to their synergistic effect by adjusting the amounts of P and N in the appropriate ranges. The base material properties are also good. Next, the steels 11 and 12 have high P, the steel 13 has high N, the steels 14 and 15 have high P, the steel 16 has high N, the steel 17 has high P, and the electron beam welded portions have low toughness. .. Steel 18 has a low strength because of its low C content.
Steel 19 has a low B and the toughness of the electron beam weld is low. Steel 20 has high B, too high base metal strength, and low base metal toughness and electron beam welded toughness.

【0012】[0012]

【発明の効果】以上述べたように、本発明によればC,
PとNの適切な範囲への成分限定することにより、凝固
偏析によるマイクロクラック発生防止が図られ、電子ビ
ーム溶接部の靱性の高い圧力容器用鋼材を経済的に提供
するものであり、産業上多大な効果を奏するものであ
る。
As described above, according to the present invention, C,
By limiting the components of P and N to an appropriate range, it is possible to prevent the generation of microcracks due to solidification segregation, and to economically provide a steel material for pressure vessels with high toughness in the electron beam welded portion. It has a great effect.

【図面の簡単な説明】[Brief description of drawings]

【図1】電子ビーム溶接部のシャルピー衝撃試験値に及
ぼすP量とN量の影響を示す図である。
FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an influence of P amount and N amount on a Charpy impact test value of an electron beam welded portion.

Claims (2)

【特許請求の範囲】[Claims] 【請求項1】 重量%で、 C :0.17〜0.35% Si :0.05〜0.45% Mn :0.6〜1.70% P :0.010%以下 S :0.010%以下 Al :0.005〜0.040% B :0.0003〜0.0012% N :0.006%以下 残部Fe、及び不可避的不純物からなることを特徴とす
る電子ビーム溶接特性の優れた圧力容器用鋼材。
1. By weight%, C: 0.17 to 0.35% Si: 0.05 to 0.45% Mn: 0.6 to 1.70% P: 0.010% or less S: 0.0. 010% or less Al: 0.005 to 0.040% B: 0.0003 to 0.0012% N: 0.006% or less The balance of Fe and inevitable impurities is excellent in electron beam welding characteristics. Steel for pressure vessels.
【請求項2】 重量%で、 C :0.17〜0.35% Si :0.05〜0.45% Mn :0.6〜1.70% P :0.010%以下 S :0.010%以下 Al :0.005〜0.040% B :0.0003〜0.0012% N :0.006%以下 を基本成分とし、さらに、 Cu ≦2.0% Ni ≦4.0% Cr ≦1.0% Mo ≦1.0% Nb ≦0.1% V ≦0.1% からなる強度改善元素群のうちの1種または2種以上を
含有し、残部Fe、及び不可避的不純物からなることを
特徴とする電子ビーム溶接特性の優れた圧力容器用鋼
材。
2. C .: 0.17 to 0.35% Si: 0.05 to 0.45% Mn: 0.6 to 1.70% P: 0.010% or less S: 0.0. 010% or less Al: 0.005 to 0.040% B: 0.0003 to 0.0012% N: 0.006% or less as a basic component, and further Cu ≤ 2.0% Ni ≤ 4.0% Cr. ≦ 1.0% Mo ≦ 1.0% Nb ≦ 0.1% V ≦ 0.1% One or more members of the strength improving element group is contained, and the balance Fe and unavoidable impurities are included. A steel material for pressure vessels with excellent electron beam welding characteristics.
JP21929391A 1991-08-06 1991-08-06 Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability Pending JPH0539542A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP21929391A JPH0539542A (en) 1991-08-06 1991-08-06 Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP21929391A JPH0539542A (en) 1991-08-06 1991-08-06 Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
JPH0539542A true JPH0539542A (en) 1993-02-19

Family

ID=16733232

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
JP21929391A Pending JPH0539542A (en) 1991-08-06 1991-08-06 Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability

Country Status (1)

Country Link
JP (1) JPH0539542A (en)

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
JP6460292B1 (en) High Mn steel and manufacturing method thereof
US20190352749A1 (en) Steel material for high heat input welding
JP2003213366A (en) Steel having excellent toughness in base metal and large -small heat input weld heat-affected zone
KR100709521B1 (en) Welding joint of large heat input welding and welding method thereof
JP4276576B2 (en) Thick high-strength steel sheet with excellent heat input and heat-affected zone toughness
JP2009127104A (en) Steel having excellent weld heat-affected zone toughness, and method for producing the same
JP2001001181A (en) Wire for gas shielded arc welding
JP3407668B2 (en) Shipbuilding steel plate with excellent laser weldability
JP2898447B2 (en) Steel plates for pressure vessels with excellent electron beam welding characteristics
JPH0539542A (en) Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability
US20220134489A1 (en) WELDING MATERIAL FOR HIGH Cr FERRITE HEAT RESISTANT STEEL
JPH093600A (en) Steel for welding structure excellent in toughness weld heat affected zone
JP2889022B2 (en) Steel for pressure vessels with excellent electron beam welding properties
JP2001064749A (en) Hic-resisting non-heat treated high tensile strength steel product excellent in toughness in weld heat-affected zone
JPWO2020036090A1 (en) Steel plate and method of manufacturing the same
JPH05295480A (en) Thick steel plate for welded structure excellent in toughness of electron beam weld zone
JP3371712B2 (en) Manufacturing method of earthquake resistant building steel with excellent fire resistance
JPH0539540A (en) Steel for structure excellent in electron beam weldability
JPH0539541A (en) Steel for pressure vessel excellent in electron beam weldability
JPH07252586A (en) Steel for welding structure excellent in ctod in multilayer build-up weld heat-affected zone and toughness in high heat input weld heat-affected zone
JP2891805B2 (en) Structural steel with excellent electron beam welding properties
JPH0539539A (en) Steel sheet for structure excellent in electron beam weldability
JPH07323392A (en) Low hydrogen type coated arc electrode and welding method
JPH0588297B2 (en)
JPH05105983A (en) Production of steel for welding structure excellent in toughness in weld zone