GB2163274A - Low temperature reduction process for photomasks - Google Patents

Abstract

Glass photomasks having a high resolution stain pattern with a roll off or the pattern edge of one micron or less are made by migrating stain-producing ions into the surface of a glass substrate, and reducing and agglomerating the stain-producing ions in the presence of pure hydrogen under pressure at relatively low temperatures to produce a high resolution stain pattern. To prepare large glass photomasks the reduction is carried out by heating the mask in an inert liquid saturated with hydrogen under pressure.

Description

1

GB2163 274A 1

SPECIFICATION

Low temperature reduction process for photomasks

5

The present invention relates generally to the art of producing stain patterns in glass, and more particularly to the conditions for reducing and agglomerating the stain-producing ca-10 tions in a high resolution photomask pattern.

Photomasks are used in photolithographic processes for printing electrical circuit wiring patterns and other precision photofabricated parts. In a typical photolithographic process, a 15 substrate is covered with a layer of photoresist material over which a photomask is superimposed. The photomask has a pattern of opaque and transparent areas with respect to actinic radiation, typically ultraviolet light, 20 which is passed through the photomask to reproduce the pattern in the photoresist material. The pattern is developed as a relief image in the photoresist material by means of different solubilities of the exposed and unex-25 posed portions of the photoresist material.

Since the preparation of a photomask requires a substantial amount of time, labour and material, it is desirable that a photomask be sufficiently durable for repeated use in the 30 manufacture of photofabricated articles. It is also desirable to maximize the resolution of the pattern carried by a photomask in order to improve the precision of the image it transfers to the photofabricated articles. 35 Photolithographic processes have employed photomasks comprising a sheet of glass carrying a patterned coating of chromium, iron oxide or photographic emulsion. While iron oxide and chromium films are considerably 40 more durable than photographic emulsions, all coated photomasks are subject to scratching and other mechanical damage which shortens their useful life. In addition, the etching required to produce a desired pattern in chrom-45 ium or iron oxide films produces a loss of resolution as a result of the etch factor, the fact that an etched groove grows wider as it grows deeper.

Photomasks of improved durability compris-50 ing a stained pattern within a glass substrate are disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 3,573,948 to Tarnopol and U.S. Patent No. 3,732,792 to Tarnopol et al. Although these stained glass photomasks have improved durability, the 55 step of etching a pattern through a stained layer of the glass in the former or the step of etching through a tin oxide coating in the latter results in insufficient resolution for some applications. U.S. Patent No. 3,561,963 to 60 Kiba discloses a stained glass photomask wherein the desired pattern is etched into a copper film on a glass substrate, and copper ions are subsequently migrated into the glass by heating. Although the stained photomask 65 pattern is more durable than a coating, resolution is compromised in this process as a result of the etching of the film and the migration step which results in lateral spreading of the stained areas into the adjacent unstained areas.

U.S. Patent No. 2,927,042 to Hall et al and U.S. Patent No. 3,620,795 to Kiba disclose methods designed to minimize the lateral diffusion of staining ions in the aforementioned processes. The Hall patent describes depositing a film of stain-producing metal onto glass and removing portions of the film by photoetching. An electrical field is then passed through the glass so that the patterned film migrates into the glass substrate. The Kiba patent discloses etching a pattern into a metal film and migrating stain-producing ions through apertures in the metal film by heating in an electric field. Both methods suffer a loss of resolution as a result of the etching step. U.S. Patents No. 2,732,298 and 2,911,749 to Stookey both disclose the production of a stained image within a glass plate by heating a developed silver-containing Photographic emulsion on the glass. However, the use of relatively high temperatures of 400 to 650°C results in a loss of resolution of the stained pattern, and the obtainable optical density is not as high as may be required.

U.S. Patent No. 4,155,735 to Ernsberger discloses an improved method for making stained glass photomasks. The method comprises developing a patterned photoresist layer on a glass substrate and applying an electric field to enhance the migration of staining ions through apertures in the photoresist pattern into the surface of the glass substrate. The staining ions are then reduced and agglomerated to form a stained pattern within the surface of the glass by heating the glass in the presence of a reducing agent such as tin or copper ions, or in a reducing atmosphere such as forming gas, preferably at temperatures of 400 to 500°C.

In U.S. Patent No. 4,309,495, Ernsberger describes producing stained glass photomask patterns by exposing and developing a photographic emulsion on a sheet of glass and migrating silver ions from the emulsion into the surface of the glass under the influence of an electric field and moderately elevated temperatures. These silver ions are then reduced and agglomerated to form a stained pattern within the surface of the glass by maintaining the glass at an elevated temperature in the presence of a reducing agent. The reducing agent may be reducing ions such as cuprous ions migrated into the glass, or the stannous ions inherently present near the surface of glass produced by the float process, in which case an optimized rate may be obtained at temperatures of 475 to 525°C. In an alternative embodiment, the reducing agent may be a reducing atmosphere such as forming gas in

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

2

GB2 163 274A 2

the heating chamber during the reducing and agglomerating heat treatment, in which case practical rates can be realized at lower temperatures in the range of 350 to 400°C.

5 Microscopic examination of stained patterns in glass photomasks made in accordance with the aforementioned methods shows that the pattern edges are slightly blurred. A microden-sitometer scan shows that the optical density 10 profile of such an edge is sloped, requiring as much as fifteen microns (about 0.006 inches) to go from maximum to minimum density.

This sloping profile is known as the "roll-off region". The ideal optical density profile of an 15 edge, which could be described as perfect edge definition, would be rectangular. For certain purposes such as photomasks intended for use in the silicon integrated circuit industry, pattern lines only five to ten microns wide 20 are necessary. Therefore, edge definition must be very good. A roll-off region of one micron width may be the upper tolerable limit.

Microscopic examination of stained patterns in glass photomasks made in accordance with 25 the aforementioned methods also shows that when the reduction and agglomeration of stain-producing ions are carried out in a forming gas atmosphere at high temperatures, the stained pattern contains a significant portion 30 of the reduced stain-producing ions in an over-agglomerated form; that is, typically spherical particles of microscopically-resolvable size. This method of producing a stained pattern is therefore somewhat inefficient, 35 since stain particles of sueh dimensions contribute very little to the ultraviolet radiation absorption band, which is produced predominantly by the resonant light absorption of particles of submicroscopic colloidal dimen-40 sions. The magnitude of this inefficiency can be appreciated from the fact that one spherical particle one micrometre in diameter would contain enough silver, for example, to yield a million particles of the preferred diameter, 45 0.01 micrometres. Thus, a given quantity of silver per unit area will provide a much greater absorbence (optical density) in the desired spectral region of ultraviolet radiation if agglomeration is effected under conditions 50 which yield submicroscopic particles.

The present invention relates to the production of high resolution stain patterns within a glass substrate. According to the present invention, stain-producing ions are 55 electromigrated into a glass at relatively low temperatures (around 200°C) as in previous methods. However, rather than reducing and agglomerating the stain-producing ions at relatively high temperatures in the presence of 60 reducing agents such as cuprous or stannous ions or in a forming gas atmosphere as in previous methods, the present invention involves the reduction and agglomeration of the stain-producing ions in the presence of pure 65 hydrogen under superatmospheric pressure.

Temperatures in the same range as the temperatures utilized during the electromigration of the stain-producing ions, for example 150 to 200°C, are sufficient to produce high resolution stained patterns in the glass using pure hydrogen as the reducing agent at pressures above atmospheric, for example ten to 100 atmospheres, in a practical length of time.

Such pressures are readily and safely attainable only for relatively small substrates. The present invention also relates to the production of high resolution stain patterns within a large glass substrate. According to the present invention, stain-producing ions are electromigrated into the glass at relatively low temperatures (around 200°C) as in previous methods.' However, rather than reducing and agglomerating the stain-producing ions at relatively high temperatures in the presence of reducing agents such as cuprous or stannous ions or in a forming gas atmosphere as in previous methods, the present invention involves the reduction and agglomeration of the stain-producing ions in a pressure vessel containing an inert liquid saturated with hydrogen under pressure. Temperatures in the same range as the temperatures utilized during the electromigration of the stain-producing ions, typically 1 50 to 200°C, are sufficient to produce high resolution stain patterns in the glass using pure hydrogen in an inert liquid as the reducing agent at pressures above atmospheric, preferably pressures up to about ten atmospheres. \

The cited references illustrate the development of methods for producing durable stained patterns in glass photomasks. However, certain photolithographic processes require high resolution patterns with pattern lines only five to ten microns in width and with very sharp edge definition.

It has been discovered that, although the pattern of injected staining ions is initially very sharp, edge definition deteriorates during the high temperature reduction and agglomeration of the staining ions to produce the photomask pattern. It has been discovered that the principal reason for this deterioration of the edge definition of the pattern is random diffusion of the stain-producing ions during the early stages of the reduction treatment. The stain-producing ions that are not yet reduced and incorporated into a pattern of colloidal particles diffuse in all directions including laterally, that is, in a plane parallel to the surface. Thus, a portion of the stain-producing ions diffuse outside the intended limits of the pattern before encountering a reducing agent and being converted to relatively immobile stain particles.

Another factor that can adversely affect edge definition is the injection of too great a quantity of stain-producing ions during the electromigration step. The intense electical field within the glass tends to suppress lateral

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

3

GB2 163 274A

3

motion of the stainproducing ions as they are injected into the glass. However, the electrical field is not truly unidirectional at any time after the injection of stain-producing ions be-5 gins, because the region of glass in which sodium ions have been replaced by stain-producing ions has substantially higher resistance than the remainder, leading to the development of a divergent fringe field at the 10 edges of the pattern. As a result of this fringe field, the profile of stain-producing ion injection is presumably trapezoidal. The characteristic angle of this trapezoid is not known, but could be as large as 135 degrees. If this be 1 5 the case, the edge of the pattern would be displaced by one micron for each micron of injection depth. Therefore, edge definition may be improved by limiting the depth of stain-producing ions, preferably to less than 20 one micron.

The diffusive spreading of the stain-producing ions can be diminished by carying out the reduction and agglomeration steps at lower temperatures. However, the rate of reduction 25 would likewise be decreased. The compensating increase in the time required for reduction would give more time for diffusive spreading, thereby nullifying the benefit of the lower temperature. This logical consequence is, in 30 fact, found to exist in practice when the stain-producing ions are reduced by reducing ions such as tin or copper in the glass surface layer. However, it has been discovered in accordance with the present invention that 35 when pure hydrogen is the reducing agent, there is a substantial net benefit in lowering the temperature of the operation, especially at increased pressure.-The explanation for this benefit in using 40 pure hydrogen as the reducing agent at lower temperatures may be explained by the nature of the diffusion of hydrogen in glass. The activation energy for permeation of hydrogen in vitreous silica is known to be about seven 45 to eight kilocalories per gram atom, while the activation energy for silver ions, for example, is at least 35 kilocalories per gram atom. A principle of physical chemistry is that the temperature coefficient of an activated process 50 is related in an exponential manner to the activation energy of that process. Accordingly, the rate of silver diffusion drops steeply with decreasing temperature, becoming almost negligible at 1 50°C, while the diffusion of 55 hydrogen declines relatively little.

Despite the low activation energy, transport of hydrogen in glass is inherently slow because of the low solubility of hydrogen in glass. The concentration of dissolved hydro-60 gen can be increased to useful levels for the reduction of stain-producing ions to form photomask patterns in accordance with the present invention by employing pure hydrogen at pressures above atmospheric. Moreover, the 65 utilization of stain-producing ions in accordance with the present invention is so efficient that the depth of injection of stain-producing ions may be limited to one micron or less. While there is substantial latitude in the choice of process variables that will produce high resolution photomask patterns in glass substrates in accordance with the present invention, preferred conditions include temperatures below 300°C, preferably below 200°C, and pressures substantially above atmospheric, preferably above ten atmospheres, and more preferably above 1000 pounds per square inch (about 70 atmospheres).

There is substantial latitude in the choice of process variables that will produce high resolution photomask patterns in large glass substrates in accordance with the present invention. Preferred conditions include temperatures below 300°C, preferably below 200°C, and pressures substantially above atmospheric. While pressures of ten to 100 atmospheres may be readily and safely attainable for relatively small substrates, the problems of building a large autoclave capable of withstanding such pressures, as well as the safe handling of large quantities of hydrogen under such pressures, are significant. The present invention avoids these problems, while still obtaining efficient reduction and agglomeration of stain-producing ions using hydrogen under pressure as the reducing agent. According to the method of the present invention, large substrates are placed in a large pressure vessel which is filled with an inert liquid saturated with hydrogen under pressure. The reduction and agglomeration of stain-produc-ing ions may be efficiently carried out at moderate temperatures, below 300°C and preferably below 200°C, at pressures up to about ten atmospheres.

Glass compositions useful for photomask substrates in accordance with the present invention are those containing mobile cations capable of being electromigrated at moderate voltages to provide sites into which the stain-producing cations may be injected. Alkali metal ions such as sodium, potassium and lithium have relatively high mobility in glass. Thus, glasses having at least minor amounts of alkali metal oxides are particularly useful. For example, conventional soda-lime-silica glass compositions typically contain about ten to thirteen percent by weight sodium oxide and a trace of potassium oxide, which represents a more than adequate supply of mobile cations. Other glass compositions having lower alkali metal oxide concentrations may also be used with the present invention, limited only by the ability to develop a stain pattern with sufficient density to mask the actinic radiation to be used in a subsequent photofabrication process.

Photoresist materials useful in accordance with the present invention are defined as polymeric materials which upon exposure to

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

4

GB2163 274A 4

actinic radiation, typically ultraviolet light, develop areas which are soluble in a particular solvent and other areas which are insoluble. When exposed to the particular solvent, the 5 soluble areas are removed, leaving a pattern of apertures in the photoresist layer through which stain-producing ions may be migrated. Specific examples of commercially available photoresists which may be used in accordance 10 with the present invention include LSI-195 Photoresist sold by Philip A. Hunt Company, KPR and KFTR Photoresists sold by Eastman Kodak Company, and AZ-111 and AZ-1350J sold by the Shipley Company.

15 The layer of stain-producing ions may be applied as a compound of one or more of the stain-producing cations having relatively low electrical conductivity or as a metallic film by employing conventional coating techniques 20 such as evaporation, sputtering, wet chemical deposition and other known techniques.

Preferably, migration of the stain-producing ions into the glass surface is carried out by applying electrically conductive layers over 25 both sides of the substrate and applying an electrical potential therethrough. The electrically conductive layers preferably comprise colloidal graphite, which may be applied to the substrate in aqueous or alcoholic slurry 30 form or as an aerosol spray.

Application of an electric field between the electrode layers drives mobile alkali metal cations deeper into the glass substrate while causing the stain-producing ions to be in-35 jected into the glass into the spaces vacated by the displaced alkali metal cations. The rate of ion migration is determined by the applied voltage and the temperature. At ambient temperatures the rate of ion migration is relatively 40 slow; therefore, elevated temperatures preferably above about 100°C are preferred in order to obtain reasonable ion migration times at an electric potential of a few hundred volts.

After the stain-producing ions have been 45 electromigrated into the glass to the desired depth, preferably one micron or less, development of optical density in the ion-migration zones is obtained by heating the glass substrate in the presence of a reducing agent to 50 reduce the stain-producing ions to their elemental state, and then to agglomerate the metallic atoms into a submicroscopic crystalline form. These steps are carried out with small substrates in accordance with the pre-55 sent invention in an atmosphere of pure hydrogen at relatively low temperatures, preferably less than 300°C and more preferably less than 200°C, at pressures above atmospheric, preferably on the order of ten to 100 atmos-60 pheres. These steps are carried out with large substrates in accordance with the present invention in the presence of an inert liquid saturated with hydrogen at relatively low temperatures, preferably less than 300°C and 65 more preferably less than 200°C, at pressures above atmospheric, preferably on the order of two to ten atmospheres.

Numerous configurations of stain-producing ions and photoresist materials are useful in accordance with the present invention. For example, a photoresist material may be applied directly onto the glass substrate, a pattern developed in the photoresist, then a layer of stain-producing ions applied over the photoresist material. Alternatively, a layer of stain-producing ions may be deposited onto the glass surface and a photoresist material pattern developed thereover. Various configurations are discussed in detail in U.S. Patent No. 4,155,735, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.

In a preferred embodiment of the present invention a high resolution stained glass photomask is made by developing a silver-con-taining photographic emulsion on a glass substrate and migrating silver from the developed photographic emulsion into the glass. Silver ions migrate into the glass, displacing mobile cations which migrate deeper into the glass substrate. The migrated silver ions are then reduced to the elemental state and agglomerated into submicroscopic crystals within the glass to produce a stain pattern by heating in the presence of hydrogen under pressure in accordane with the present invention. Photographic emulsions useful in producing stained glass photomask patterns in this embodiment of the invention are those capable of being developed to produce a residual layer of emulsion and silver halide, which has sufficient electrical conductivity to permit electromigration of silver ions from the emulsion into the glass substrate. The emulsion should also have high resolution capability in order to produce a high resolution photomask pattern.

Standard photographic techniques are em-polyed to expose and develop the photographic emulsion. The glass substrate bearing a film of photographic emulsion is exposed to actinic radiation through a master pattern in order to form a latent image, which is subsequently developed in the photographic emulsion by exposure to appropriate developing solutions. Either a positive image or a negative image may be developed on the substrate depending on the type of photographic emulsion employed in the developing process.

The electric field employed to migrate the silver ions from the developed photographic emulsion into the subjacent glass surface is prefereably high enough to migrate the necessary quantity of silver ions within a reasonable time but low enough to avoid arcing around the edges of the glass substrate between the anode and cathode layers. Typically voltages of 50 to 1000 volts, preferably 200 to 700 volts, are sufficient at temperatures of about 100 to 300°C. In order to maximize the resolution of the pattern in accordance with the present invention, the depth of silver ion

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

5

GB2163 274A 5

migration is preferably limited to one micron or less, which is sufficient in view of the efficiency of reduction and agglomeration of the stain-producing ions in the presence of 5 pure hydrogen or an inert liquid saturated with hydrogen under pressure in accordance with the present invention. The inert liquid, i.e. chemically inert to molecular hydrogen under the temperature and pressure condi-10 tions of the present invention, is preferably a hydrocarbon or fluorocarbon having a vapour pressure less than one atmosphere at the reduction and agglomeration temperatures of the present invention.

1 5 Once a sufficient quantity of ionic silver has been electromigrated into the glass substrate to the desired depth, the stain pattern is developed by reduction of the silver ions to the elemental state and agglomeration into 20 submicroscopic crystals by heating in the presence of pure hydrogen under pressure. While temperatures above about 400°C are generally required for the reduction and agglomeration steps to proceed in an ambient 25 atmosphere, and temperatures of about 350 to 400°C are required for the reduction and agglomeration steps to proceed in a forming gas atmosphere, the use of pure hydrogen under pressure as the reducing agent in accor-30 dance with the present invention allows the reduction and agglomeration of silver to proceed at temperatures below 300°C and preferably below 200°C in order to maximize the resolution of the stained photomask pattern. 35 At the temperatures and pressures in accordance with the present invention, a density of at least 2.0 with respect to ultraviolet radiation may be obtained in about two to twelve hours. For large substrates the presence of an 40 inert liquid saturated with hydrogen under pressure as the reducing agent in accordance with the present invention allows the reduction and agglomeration of silver to proceed at temperatures below 300°C and preferably be-45 low 200°C in order to maximize the resolution of the stained photomask pattern. At the temperatures and pressures in accordance with the present invention, a density of at least 2.0 with respect to ultraviolet radiation may be 50 obtained in about four to sixteen hours.

The present invention will be further understood from the descriptions of specific examples which follow.

55 EXAMPLE I

A commercially-produced photomask generated on a Kodak High Resolution emulsion plate 2.5 inches (about 6.35 centimeters) square and 0.060 inches (about 1.5 millimet-60 ers) thick was dip-coated in a seven percent solids suspension of Acheson DAG® 11 5 (a colloidal graphite in 1,1,1 trichloroethane), and baked for five hours at 260°C. The front and back coatings were separated electrically 65 by removing the coatings from the four edges.

and the plate was placed in a forced-circulation air oven at 181 °C. With the coating on the patterned surface connected as anode and the opposite surface coating connected as cathode, electrical treatment was carried out with the applied voltage beginning at 200 volts and rising at a constant rate, reaching 290 volts at the termination of the treatment 70 minutes later. The coatings were stripped from the plate with warm dilute aqueous alkali solution. Stain was developed by treating the plate in a pressure vessel filled to 600 pounds per square inch (at ambient temperature) with pure hydrogen for 14 hours at 182°C. Optical density of the resulting pattern was 2.84 to 2.94 as measured with a Macbeth TD504 microdensitometer using an M18 (Corning Glass Works) ultraviolet filter. Edge acuity was such that the smallest elements in the pattern, lines and spaces eight micrometres wide, were resolved with no roll-off region perceptible at 200X optical magnification (resolution of approximately one micron).

EXAMPLE II

A pattern is developed in a layer of photoresist material on a glass substrate. The photoresist coated surface of the glass substrate is contacted at a temperature of about 160°C with a pool of molten salt which is a eutectic mixture of silver nitrate and potassium nitrate. About 0.04 milligrams of silver ion per square centimetre of glass surface is injected to a depth of about 0.4 microns by electromigration. The silver ions are reduced and agglomerated to form a stained pattern within the glass surface by treatment in pure hydrogen at 800 pounds per square inch for four hours at 160°C. The stained pattern has an optical density of about 2.5 with respect to ultraviolet radiation of about 400 nanometres wavelength. The stained pattern is reddish amber, a colour characteristic of a narrow absorption band associated with small particles of silver (less than 100 Angstroms).

EXAMPLE III

A test sample cut from a production photomask 22 X 28 X 0.190 inches (about 56 X 71 X 0.5 centimetres) after electromigration treatment but before reduction, is placed in a four ounce wide-mouth glass bottle and Gulf DXE® fluid (a commercial heat transfer fluid, di-orthoxylyl ethane) is added until half the length of the sample is immersed in the liquid. The open bottle containing the sample and the liquid is placed in a one litre pressure vessel (Parr Instrument Company, No.4611). Air is purged from the vessel by filling twice to 500 pounds per square inch with forming gas and twice releasing the pressure to ambient; then the vessel is pressurized to 360 pounds per square inch with pure hydrogen and sealed. The vessel is then heated to 180°C for 14 hours. The pressure inside the

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

6

GB2 163 274A 6

vessel increases to 460 pounds per square inch as a consequence of the heating. Measurements on the sample after the conclusion of this treatment show an ultraviolet optical 5 density of 3.21 in the portion of the surface that was submerged in oil, and 3.05 in the portion contacted only by gaseous hydrogen. Optical density in the visual region of the spectrum (defined by Wratten 106 filter) is 10 0.95 in the submerged portion and 0.90 in the remainder. The colour is a deep reddish amber. Microscopic examination of the stain pattern at 200X, with a resolution of about one micron, reveals no observable roll-off re-15 gion. Properties of the fluid are unchanged. An identical sample, processed in forming gas for three hours at 343°C, has an ultraviolet optical density of only 2.30, and an olive-green visual appearance. An examination of 20 complete absorption spectra for both stains shows that both have an absorption maximum in the region around 400 nanometres, but the absorption band for the stain produced at higher temperature is broader, consistent with 25 the fact that a wide variety of silver particle sizes is present.

EXAMPLE IV.

Glass substrates containing a latent image 30 formed by electromigration of silver ions are placed in an autoclave welded from ordinary mild steel. Most of the remaining space in the autoclave is filled with paraffin oil. Hydrogen is added to produce a pressure of about ten 35 atmospheres at 180°C. After twelve hours the glass photomask bears a stained image with a density above 2.0 with respect to ultraviolet radiation. This density is comparable to that obtained after three hours of reduction and 40 agglomeration in forming gas at 400°C, at which temperature edge definition is comprised by lateral diffusion of the silver staining ions.

The above examples are offered to illustrate 45 the present invention. Various stain-producing ions, photoresist materials, temperatures and pressures may be employed. Various other inert liquids such as 1,1-di(orthoxylyl) ethane, mineral oil and fluorocarbons may be em-50 ployed. Other stain-producing ions and a wide range of treatment times, temperatures and pressures may be employed limited only by the strength of the pressure vessel and the required resolution of the stain pattern. The 55 scope of the present invention is defined by the following claims.

Claims (4)

1. An article of manufacture comprising a 60 transparent glass substrate and within said glass substrate a pattern of stain-producing metal wherein the roll-off region of the pattern edges is not more than one micron wide.

2. An article according to claim 1, wherein 65 the stain-producing metal is silver and the depth of silver penetration from the nearest glass surface is not more than one micron.

3. An article according to claim 2, wherein the optical density of the silver is at least 2.0

70 with respect to ultraviolet radiation.

4. An article of manufacture comprising a transparent glass substrate and within the glass substrate a pattern of stain-producing metal substantially as herein described with

75 reference to and as illustrated in any of the Examples.

Printed in the United Kingdom for

Her Majesty's Stationery Office, Dd 8818935, 1986, 4235. Published at The Patent Office, 25 Southampton Buildings,

London, WC2A 1AY, from which copies may be obtained.