EP1422488B2

EP1422488B2 - A heat exchanger with a silicon carbide set of tubes and double tube plates in enamelled steel

Info

Publication number: EP1422488B2
Application number: EP03005976.0A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Gianni Artusi; Nicola Barison
Original assignee: Pfaudler GmbH
Current assignee: Pfaudler GmbH
Priority date: 2002-11-19
Filing date: 2003-03-18
Publication date: 2017-01-25
Anticipated expiration: 2023-03-18
Also published as: EP2685201A2; ITMI20022449A1; EP2685201B1; EP1422488B1; EP1422488A2; EP2685201A3; EP1422488A3; ES2835223T3

Description

Field of the invention

The present invention relates to a heat exchanger with a set of tubes and tube plates and more particularly a heat exchanger suited for the treatment of highly corrosive fluids or the ones for which a high level of purity must be ensured.

State of the art

Heat exchangers are known for processing highly corrosive fluids or fluids with special purity requirements, wherein the tube plates are of a suitable material, such as solid PTFE. The tubes are sealed with the plate by means of threaded ring nuts, directly tightened in a threading provided in the PTFE. This solution presents drawbacks connected with the not satisfactory mechanical resistance of the plates, especially at high temperatures, which limits the possible applications of the exchanger and renders frequent maintenance necessary.
A possible alternative is the use of PTFE coated steel plates; the coating is necessarily thin, which renders it not always sufficiently impermeable, and unsuitable for providing a proper sealing for the tubes passing through the plate.
This requires complicated construction for properly fixing and sealing the tubes, and a relevant danger of seepage of the circulating fluid is anyway present.
DE 2326365 represents the closest prior art and relates to a heat exchanger consisting of ceramic tubes mounted between two double tube plates.

Summary of the invention

The above mentioned problems have been solved, according to the present invention as defined in claim 1.

Brief description of the drawings

In the attached figures are represented:

Figure 1: overall view of the exchanger according to the invention where (11) is the set of tubes with silicon carbide tubes, (12) are the tube plates in enamelled steel, (14) is the central shell in enamelled steel, and (13) are the end distributors;
Figure 2: a detail of the tube plate in PTFE according to the prior art, double O ring seal (24), threaded ring nut (22) with threading (23) on the PTFE;
Figure 3: a detail of the double tube plate according to the prior art, in PTFE coated steel, where (32) is the coating in PTFE, (33) O ring seal, (34) locking through screw, (35) through holes;
Figure 4: a detail of the single tube plate (41) according to an example not claimed, with O ring seal (42), threaded ring nut (43), and intermediate bushing (44);
Figure 5: a detail of the double tube plate according to an example not claimed, with O ring seal (51) on the inner plate and an O ring (52) on the outer plate, a single locking ring nut (53), intermediate bushing (54) hole (55) for the conveyance of possible fluid leakages;
Figure 6: a detail of the double tube plate according to the invention, with O ring seal (62) on the inner plate (61), O ring seal (67) on the outer plate (65) locking bushing (66), steel ring nut (63), intermediate bushing (64), elastic seal system support L-profile (68);
Figure 7: a detail of the double tube plate with locking screw (74) of the two plates with gasket (73) between the plates.

Detailed description of preferred embodiments

In Fig.1 is briefly represented a heat exchanger comprising a set of tubes in silicon carbide (SiC) (11) and tube plates in enamelled steel (12) as the essential members. Depending on the plates which may be enamelled indifferently on one or both the two faces, both the central shell (14) and the end distributors (13) may be provided in enamelled steel.
A characteristic and original aspect of the heat exchanger according to the invention is represented by the enamelled tube plates substituting the traditional ones in PTFE (PolyTetraFluoroEthylene) see Fig. 2 reference 21 or the ones in PFTE-coated steel (see Fig.3 reference31).
Another original aspect is represented by the seal systems between the end of the SiC tube and the tube plate (see. Fig. 6). These seal systems, especially studied for the various embodiments of enamelled tube plates (enamelling only on the distributor side face, only on that of the shell side which is not claimed or on both), can also be adopted for traditional tube plates with tubes in SiC or in glass and represent an improvement with respect to the traditional solutions.
The improvement achieved with the present invention overcomes the drawbacks of the above mentioned prior art exchangers and in particular (with reference to figure 2 for the plate in solid PTFE and figure 3 for the plate in PTFE-coated steel):

The plate in solid PTFE (Fig.2, reference21 ), normally of the glass fiber filled type, can be used up to a maximum temperature of 165°C, beyond which a rapid decline in the mechanical resistance values of this material is observed.

In addition, being PTFE essentially a plastic material, the tube plate may deform over time and bend under pressure, subjecting the ends of the SiC tubes (particularly the most exterior ones with respect to the set of tubes) to flexing stress beyond their ultimate stress. For this reason in practice they do not exceed φ 300 mm.

For sealing the tubes on the glass-filled solid PTFE tube plates threaded ring nuts (22) also in glass-filled PTFE are provided, which press a gasket generally of a double O ring type (24). The threading (23) on the PTFE (plastic material) tends to loosen with time the higher the temperature as well as the amplitude and the frequency of the thermal cycles. Accordingly, frequent inspections of the locking moment of the PTFE ring nuts are required to avoid leakages from the sealing.
The PTFE coated steel plates (Fig.3, reference 31) are not subjected to permanent progressive deformations. However, being the coating (32) necessarily thin, it has certain porosity and as a consequence is not completely impermeable. Furthermore, in this low thickness neither the threading required for the locking ring nuts of the O ring gasket nor the housings for the gaskets themselves can be formed, as it is however possible to do for the plates in solid PTFE. One must therefore resort to the solution represented by the double plate with O ring (33) in the intermediate area. To allow for the tightening of the O rings between the two plates through screws (34) passing through holes in the plate, are used and thus the PTFE coating is drilled accordingly. In correspondence of such holes (35) an appropriate seal system must be provided, which will however constitute a point of discontinuity in the coating with a danger of seepage of the circulating fluid.

With the enamelled tube plate the following advantages may be achieved:

The coating is not porous, but perfectly impermeable and cleanable like glass;
The high mechanical resistance of the steel plate allows the use of large-sized plates, well beyond 300 mm diameter;
It is suitable to be easily implemented in a double embodiment with enamelling on one or on both faces and with an intermediate circuit for leakage collection (see Fig.7 reference 71) delimited on the circumference of the O ring gasket reference 73 with a drainage hole (72) in the lower part, wherein an appropriate device for signalling the leakage itself may be screwed thereto (for example a manometer with min/max pressure contacts). In this way, the fluids are prevented from entering into contact with each other, an event to be avoided with chemically incompatible fluids or fluids which must not contaminate each another. The collected fluid allows for an immediate identification of whether the leakage is on the tube side or the shell side.
All the threaded couplings for the locking ring nuts are metallic and therefore much more reliable than those in PTFE.

With the new sealing systems between the end of the SiC tube and the tube plate the basic needs are considered, which are however met by the traditional seal systems (generally made with fluoro-elastomer O ring gaskets of Kalrez^R and Viton^R type or FEP-coated Silicone (C₂F₄/C₃F₆ copolymer), or other materials with high corrosion resistance), and that is:

accomplish the pressure seal between tube and tube plate,
prevent direct contact of the tube with the tube plate (both elements in rigid material) in such a way as to avoid breakage due to localised peaks of stress,
allow the sliding of the tube (in the hole of the tube plate) for the automatic compensation of the different expansion between set of tubes and shell of the exchanger,
prevent that the sum of subsequent translations of the tube, which may also occur always in the same direction, may cause the tube itself to unthread from the hole of the plate. This is achieved by a "translation limiter" consisting in the reduction in diameter of the ring nut head (reference 43, 53, 66), which prevents the tube from exiting beyond the ring nut itself.

Fig.4 shows an example of the exchanger with a single tube plate (41), with enamelling on the shell side, in which the O ring seal gaskets (42) are locked by the threaded ring nut (43) by means of the intermediate bushing (44).
The following new prerogatives for the double tube plates are further added.
For the double tube plate enamelled only on the inner face (shell side) Fig.5 which is not part of the claimed invention, the seal on the inner (by O ring reference 51 ) and the outer (by O ring reference 52) tube plate can be simultaneously achieved by a single locking of the threaded ring nut (53) by means of the intermediate bushing (54) in steel or in PEEK (phenylpolyetherketones of Du Pont), which is fitted with holes (55) for conveying possible fluid leakages to the outside.
For the double tube plate enamelled on both sides (Fig.6), the two seals on the tube are separate. For the inner plate (shell side) (61) the seal is implemented by means of a double O ring gasket (62) pressed by an intermediate bushing in steel or in PEEK (64) by the screwing of a steel ring nut (63) in the corresponding thread provided in the tube plate.
For the outer tube plate (distributor side) (65), the use of a ring nut for the locking of every single tube not being possible, the required pressure for pressing the O ring seals (67) has been provided by means of a special bushing in glass-filled PEEK or PTFE (66), being pressed by the tube plate. This pressure is applied during the coupling step of the two single plates by the locking of the screws located on an outer peripheral circumference of the enamelled area to avoid any point of discontinuity in the coating (see fig.7 reference 74). The type of seal is characterised by a high degree of elasticity in the axial direction made by means of a mechanical spring system or an adequate number of overlapping O ring gaskets (68), in addition to those provided for pressure seal.
An underlying L-profile ring (69) ensures support to this elastic system regardless of the position of the underlying seal ring nut on the inner plate.

Claims

A heat exchanger comprising a set of tubes consisting of SiC tubes (11) mounted between two double tube plates (61, 65) in steel by means of a pressure seal system at the end of, and on the outer surface of, each tube (11), in which the tube (11) can axially slide therein to compensate for thermal expansions, wherein
the distributor side surfaces of the distributer tube plates (65) of the double tube plates (61, 65) are enamelled, and
wherein the pressure seal system comprises a bushing (66) in glass-filled PEEK or PTFE which, includes a portion with a reduced diameter preventing the tube (11) from exiting beyond the bushing itself (66), wherein
the bushing (66) is located within an enamelled aperture passing through the enamelled distributer side tube plates (65) and which is pressed by a reduced diameter portion of said aperture against an O-ring seal (67), wherein further
the pressure is applied during a coupling step of the two tube plates of the double tube plates (61, 65) by locking screws (74) located on an outer peripheral surface of the enamelled area of the distributer side tube plates (65),
wherein the shell side tube plate (61) is enamelled on the shell side, and wherein the seal between the ends of the tubes (11) and the shell side tube plate (61) is obtained through double O ring gaskets (62, 67) pressed in such a way: the seal (62) on the shell side tube plate (61) is obtained by a double 0 ring gasket (62) pressed, by means of an intermediate bushing (64) in steel or in PEEK, by screwing of a steel ring nut (63) in the corresponding threading provided on the shell side tube plate (61).
The heat exchanger according to claim 1, in which the members of the seal system between tubes (11) and tube plate (61, 65) are adapted for chemically and thermally resisting the circulating fluids under the normal operating conditions of the exchanger.
The heat exchanger according to claim 1, wherein the seals between the ends of the tubes (11) and the distributer side plate (65) are ensured by an elastic system indifferently formed by a series of overlapping O ring gaskets (68) or a mechanical spring, which rest on an L-profile ring (69) which ensures pressing required for each single seal following the locking of the peripheral screws (74) which fix the two plates (61, 65) forming the double tube plate one to the other.