EP0813585B1

EP0813585B1 - Cleaning compositions

Info

Publication number: EP0813585B1
Application number: EP96944872A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Balvinder Adat
Original assignee: SC Johnson and Son Inc
Current assignee: SC Johnson and Son Inc
Priority date: 1996-01-03
Filing date: 1996-12-19
Publication date: 2002-03-27
Anticipated expiration: 2016-12-19
Also published as: ES2170887T3; AU713065B2; AU1337497A; DK0813585T3; DE69620158D1; CN1181105A; GB9600030D0; ATE215121T1; BR9607812A; KR19980702727A; CA2214524A1; DE69620158T2; WO1997025401A1; EP0813585A1

Abstract

An aqueous liquid storage stable foamable limescale removing composition comprising a mixture of sulphamic acid and at least one organic carboxylic acid, a thickening agent and an amine oxide surfactant.

Description

Technical Field

This invention relates to foamable cleaning compositions for use in removing limescale stains from surfaces.

Background Art

Tap water always contains a certain amount of solubilized ions which eventually deposit as salts, on surfaces in contact with the water, as it evaporates. Such salts include calcium carbonate, commonly referred to as limescale. This phenomenon of limescale accumulation on surfaces which are often in contact with water may damage surfaces and affects the functioning of taps or appliances, such as irons. Also, the accumulation of limescale in the toilet bowl is aesthetically unpleasant and favors the deposition of further soil and the growth of microorganisms. It is therefore important to control this limescale accumulation.
Many limescale removing compositions are known in the art. For example, EP-A-0,589,761 discloses a thickened acidic aqueous cleaner for bathtubs and other hard surfaced items, which removes limescale, soap scum and greasy soil from surfaces of such items without damaging such surfaces.
One composition of the reference comprises:
(a) an anionic surfactant;
(b) a nonionic surfactant;
(c) a xanthan gum thickener having a molecular weight of about 1,000,000 to 10,000,000 such as Kelzan® T sold by Merck & Co.; and
(d) 2 to 8 percent of an acid mixture of succinic acid; glutaric acid and adipic acid of about 1:1:1; and
(e) balance being water, wherein the composition has a pH of about 1 to about 4, more preferably about 2.7 to about 3.3 and a Brookfield viscosity of about 200 to 1,000 cps at room temperature using a #2 spindle and 50 rpm. The composition of the reference does not include either sulfamic acid or amine oxide surfactants.
EP-A-0,606,712 discloses a thickened buffered aqueous acidic composition.
The composition of the reference comprises citric acid and sodium citrate, and in the composition suitable thickeners include conventional thickeners such as xanthan gum, polymers, alkyl amines, and surfactant based thickeners as well as nonionic and amine oxide surfactants. The composition of the reference does not include sulphamic acid.
EP-A-0,666,304 discloses compositions comprising as a first essential ingredient an organic acid such as maleic acid. It is preferred in the invention of the reference to use maleic acid either alone or together with sulfonic acids such as sulfamic acid.
The compositions according to the reference invention comprises as a second essential ingredient a surfactant or mixtures thereof. The compositions comprise said surfactant in an appropriate amount below 1% by weight of the total composition. The composition of the reference does not include amine oxide surfactants. Optionally, the compositions of the reference comprise thickeners.
WO-A-94 28108 concerns over cleaning compositions and does not deal with acidic limescale removing compositions.
EP-A-0130786 discloses an acidic cleaning composition comprising water, a mixture of a weak inorganic acid and a weak organic acid, an amine oxide surfactant, and a surface-tension-reducing co-solvent.
The subject invention is directed to a limescale removing composition which can be delivered as a foam.
In one embodiment, the subject invention provides an aqueous liquid storage-stable foamable limescale removing composition consisting of:
a. from 5% to 20% by weight of a mixture of sulphamic acid and at least one organic carboxylic acid;
b. from 0.001% to 5% by weight of a thickening agent selected from acrylic emulsion polymer thickeners, xanthan gums, rhamsan gums, welan gums and polyurethane;
c. from 2% to 8% by weight of an amine oxide surfactant,
d. optionally a dye;
e. optionally a fragrance; and
f. deionized water to balance
In another embodiment, the subject invention provides a method of removing limescale from a substrate comprising the steps of:
applying the composition of the present invention to a substrate containing limescale;
allowing the composition to remain in contact with the substrate for a sufficient amount of time to have a descaling effect; and
removing the composition from the substrate.

Disclosure of Invention

All amounts of components set out herein are given as percentages by weight of the limescale removing composition.
The composition of the invention comprises a mixture of sulphamic acid and at least one organic carboxylic acid. The sulphamic acid and the at least one other acid are preferably mixed in synergistically effective limescale removing amounts. Preferably, the organic carboxylic acid has a molecular weight of 60-250. More preferably, the carboxylic acid is lactic acid, citric acid, or another hydroxy acid where the hydroxy group is α to at least one of the acid moieties.
The mixture of acids is present in the range 5-20 weight percent of the aqueous cleaning composition and more preferably 10-20 weight percent.
The composition of the invention can be dispensed as a foam through a foam dispenser. The composition may tend to be difficult to dispense in this way if the composition in use has a final viscosity which is much above 300 cps. All viscosity measurements stated herein are taken using a Brookfield viscometer, at 20°C using #3 spindle at 30 rpm. Preferably, the final viscosity is in the range 200-300 cps. When the maximum viscosity of the composition of the invention is limited by the need for the composition to be dispensable through a foam dispenser, one aspect of particular importance is storage stability. The composition of the subject invention relies on a complex blend of components and inevitably the composition will be placed into its final package some long time before it comes into use in the hands of the ultimate consumer. It is important that the viscosity of the composition is maintained within parameters during storage to allow delivery through the foam dispenser. Long term stability of the viscosity is mainly determined by the optimized level and type of thickening agents. Thickeners which are effective in the composition of the subject invention are selected from the group consisting of acrylic emulsion polymer thickeners, xanthan gums, rhamsan gums, welan gums and polyurethanes. The preferred thickener is xanthan gum with altered rheology. The thickener is present in an amount of 0.001-5 weight percent based on the weight of the cleaning composition.
The storage stable composition of the subject invention will preferably be dispensable as a foam through a foam dispenser after storage at room temperature for 6 months, and more preferable after storage at room temperature for 1 year. Preferably, the storage stable composition of the subject invention will not show phase separation or precipitation after said storage, the viscosity of the composition remaining constant during said storage.
Typically, the foaminess index Σ is between 15-50 and more typically between 20-30.
While the amount of thickener is instrumental in allowing the composition to remain storage stable, it should also be noted that the presence of particular amounts of other components in the composition may effect viscosity. In particular, the amine oxide surfactant can be expected to have an effect on the viscosity of the composition.
Another important feature of the limescale removing composition of the invention is that the composition is dispensable as a foam.
Dispensing as a foam allows the composition to remain on the limescale stain for an effective time. The composition should be able to remain in contact with and be able to wet and penetrate the limescale stain for a sufficient time to have an effective descaling effect. Subsequently, the composition must be able to be washed away easily with water.
Of importance, therefore, in the effectiveness of the composition is the quality of the foam which is produced. At one extreme, foams can be loose airy type foams, while at the other extreme, foams can be tight mousse like type foams. The composition of the subject invention ideally produces a foam which is roughly halfway between a loose airy type foam and a tight mousse type foam in order to give maximum descaling and a good cling parameter. Cling is measured by spraying about 10g of product onto the underside of a preweighed suspended plate weighing about 200g. The plate is left to hang for 5 minutes and is then re-weighed. The cling is determined by the amount of product remaining on the plate after 5 minutes. Preferably, the cling parameter of the composition of the subject invention is 50 - 70% of product remaining on the surface after 5 minutes.
The nature and amount of the amine oxide surfactant present in the composition of the invention will generally determine the foam profile and cling parameter of the composition. Additionally, however, the cling parameter is dependent on the amount of thickener present in the composition. The amine oxide preferably has the formula RR' R"NO, where R is a substituted or unsubstituted alkyl or alkene group containing from 8 to 30, preferably from 10 to 20, more preferably 10 to 16 carbon atoms. Preferably, R is an unsubstituted alkyl group. Groups R' and R" are each substituted or unsubstituted alkyl or alkene groups containing from 1 to 18, preferably from 1 to 4, carbon atoms. More preferably, R' and R" are each methyl groups.
The amine oxide detergent surfactant can be prepared by known and conventional methods. One such method involves the oxidation of tertiary amines in the manner set forth in U.S. Patent No. 3,223,647 and British Patent 437,566. In general terms, amine oxides are prepared by the controlled oxidation of the corresponding tertiary amines.
Most preferably, the surfactant will be lauryl dimethyl amine oxide. The amine oxide surfactant is present in the amount of 2.0-8.0% by weight of the total composition.
The composition can contain other optional components appropriate to limescale removing compositions including dyes and fragrances.
The balance of the composition of the invention (to 100 weight percent) is deionized water.
The composition of the invention is dispensable through a conventional foam dispenser.

Modes for Carrying Out the Invention

Exemplary compositions of the invention are now set out below:

Example 1

Material	% w/w
Deionized Water	To balance
Xanthan gum with altered rheology (Kelco)	0.50
Sulphamic Acid (GelpKe and Bate Ltd.)	10.00
Citric Acid	4.00
Lauryl dimethyl amine oxide	2.00
1% Dye Solution - Blue	0.50
Fragrance	0.10

Example 2

Material	% w/w
Deionized Water	To balance
Xanthan gum with altered rheology (Kelco)	0.70
Sulphamic Acid (GelpKe and Bate Ltd.)	9.00
Lactic Acid (Purac®)	5.00
Lauryl dimethyl amine oxide	4.00
1% Dye Solution - Blue	0.30
Fragrance	0.20

Example 3

Material	% w/w
Deionized Water	To balance
Xanthan gum with altered rheology (Kelco)	0.60
Sulphamic Acid (GelpKe and Bate Ltd.)	13.00
Lactic Acid (Purac®)	1.00
Lauryl dimethyl amine oxide	5.00
1% Dye Solution Acid Blue 7	0.40
Fragrance	0.10

The composition of Example 3 had a viscosity of 250 cps and on dispensing through a conventional foam dispenser produced a foam with a cling parameter of 50 - 70% over a 5 minute period.
The composition was stable on storage at room temperature for one year.
The composition of Example 3 was tested for effectiveness by the marble cube test as follows:

Marble Cube Test

1) 3 marble cubes weighing approximately 20g were washed with distilled water and dried in an oven until their weight was constant at room temperature.
2) Each marble cube was weighed (W_o).
3) 150g of product being tested was weighed into a conical flask.
4) The pre-weighed marble cubes were placed into the test product.
5) The marble cubes were left on test for 18 hours.
6) After 18 hours, the marble cubes were removed from the test product and rinsed thoroughly with deionized water.
7) Each marble cube was dried in an oven for 12 hours and weighed at room temperature. (W₁)
The percentage descaling was calculated as follows: W0 - W1 x 100% = % weight loss.

Interpretation of Results

The higher the percentage weight loss the greater the limescale removal activity of the product.

Results of the above Marble Cube Test

For the composition of Example 3, the average % weight loss (for the 3 cubes) ranged from 35 - 40%.

Comparative Example 1

A commercially available maleic acid limescale removing composition was tested in the same way as above and the % weight loss ranged from 20 - 30%.

Industrial Applicability

The subject invention provides a limescale removing composition which may be produced using conventional manufacturing methods and packaging. The foamable limescale removing composition maintains its foaming and rheological properties after shelf storage at room temperature for 6 months, preferably one year. This shelf stability will allow a consumer to effectively utilize the descaling composition even though the composition may be placed into its final package a long time prior to its purchase and use.

Claims

An aqueous liquid storage-stable foamable limescale removing composition consisting of:

a. from 5% to 20% by weight of a mixture of sulphamic acid and an organic carboxylic acid;

b. from 0.001% to 5% by weight of a thickening agent selected from acrylic emulsion polymer thickeners, xanthan gums, rhamsan gums, welan gums and polyurethane;

c. from 2% to 8% by weight of an amine oxide surfactant;

d. optionally a dye;

e. optionally a fragrance; and

f. deionized water to balance;

wherein the viscosity of the composition is 300 cps or less, the viscosity being measured using a Brookfield viscometer at 20°C using #3 spindle at 30 rpm.
The composition of Claim 1 wherein the viscosity of the composition is in the range of 200 cps to 300 cps, the viscosity being measured using a Brookfield viscometer at 20°C using #3 spindle at 30 rpm..
The composition of Claim 1 wherein the composition has a cling parameter of 50% to 70%, wherein the cling parameter is determined by spraying an amount of the composition onto the underside of a suspended plate and after 5 minutes re-weighing the plate and the composition clinging to the plate.
The composition of Claim 1 wherein the organic carboxylic acid is selected from the group consisting of lactic acid, citric acid, hydroxy acids where the hydroxy group is alpha to at least one of the acid moieties, and mixtures thereof.
The composition of Claim 1 wherein the amine oxide surfactant is an alkyl amine oxide surfactant.
The composition of Claim 5 wherein the alkyl amine oxide surfactant is a C₁₀ to C₁₆ alkyl dimethyl amine oxide.
The composition of Claim 6 wherein the alkyl amine oxide surfactant is lauryl dimethyl amine oxide.
An aqueous liquid storage stable foamable limescale removing composition consisting of:

5% to 20% by weight of a mixture of sulphamic acid and an organic carboxylic acid selected from the group consisting of lactic acid, citric acid, hydroxy acids where the hydroxy group is alpha to at least one of the acid moieties, and mixtures thereof;

0.001% to 5% by weight of a thickening agent selected from the group consisting of acrylic emulsion polymers, xanthan gums, rhamsan gums, welan gums and polyurethane;

2% to 8% by weight of an amine oxide surfactant;

optionally a dye;

optionally a fragrance;

wherein the balance of the composition is deionized water, and
wherein the viscosity of the composition is 300 cps or less, the viscosity being measured using a Brookfield viscometer at 20°C using # 3 spindle et 30 rpm.
A method of removing limescale from a substrate comprising the steps of:

applying the composition of any of the preceding claims to a substrate containing limescale;

allowing the composition to remain in contact with the substrate for a sufficient amount of time to have a descaling effect; and

removing the composition from the substrate.