EP0636068B1

EP0636068B1 - Foam grip

Info

Publication number: EP0636068B1
Application number: EP93905052A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Mingchic M. Tseng; Nan Jae Lin; Michael J. Kwiecien
Original assignee: Gillette Co LLC
Current assignee: Gillette Co LLC
Priority date: 1992-02-14
Filing date: 1993-02-12
Publication date: 1999-04-21
Anticipated expiration: 2013-02-12
Also published as: CA2130109C; EP0636068A1; JPH07504131A; ES2130254T3; JP3454431B2; AU3619393A; EP0636068A4; CA2130109A1; DE69324577T2; WO1993015917A1; DE69324577D1; MY130433A; MX9300762A

Description

Background of the Invention

This invention relates to foam grips.
It is known in the art to provide articles which are to be gripped with the fingers with resilient or cushioned grips in order to improve the comfort of the user of the article. In particular, finger manipulated articles, such as writing instruments, have been provided with devices designed to provide a comfortable gripping area, as disclosed in, e.g., U.S. Patent No. 4,932,800. Conventional finger gripping devices typically provide a sleeve of resilient compressible material, extending about or covering a portion of the gripping area. This compressible material is intended to deform on application of gripping pressure, and at least partially conform to the shape of the fingers during manipulation of the article. After removal of gripping pressure, the compressible material returns to its original shape.
For additional information, see the following references: U.S Patent US-A-4 474 276 which discloses a sealing composition for preventing or inhibiting leaks; German Patent DE-A-1 511 325 which discloses the use of a sleeve on a writing instrument; U.S. Patent US-A-4 158 087 which discloses polyurethane foam compositions; U.S. Patent US-A-4 725 627 which discloses a hand-squeezable toy with dimensional memory; Japanese Patent J-A-56 081 345 which discloses a plastic foam with uniform and fine open cells; U.S. Patent US-A-4 098 506 a removable hand grip for use on a tennis racket and the like; U.S. Patent US-A-4 932 800 which discloses a compressible finger-gripping device for finger-manipulated articles; and British Patent GB-A-1 093 173 which discloses flexible polyurethane foams.

Summary of the Invention

In one aspect, the invention features a finger manipulated article having a handle with a gripping surface including a foam having a recovery rate of less than 10 cm per minute, preferably less than 5 cm per minute, more preferably less than 3 cm per minute.
In another aspect, the invention features a finger manipulated article having a handle with a gripping surface including a foam having a spring rate of between 250 and 20,000 grams per cm, preferably between 500 and 16,000 grams per cm.
In another aspect, the invention features a finger manipulated article having a handle with a gripping surface including a foam having a percent peak force of less than 95%, preferably of less than 85%.
In another aspect, the invention features a finger manipulated article having a handle with a gripping surface including a polyurethane foam that was made from a mixture including a latex or a filler, or both. The mixture also includes a polyurethane foam precursor, which can be, e.g., a foamable polyurethane prepolymer or the combination of a polyisocyanate and polyol that when mixed together react to provide a polyurethane foam.
In another aspect, the invention features a method of manufacturing a finger manipulated article having a foam gripping surface. The method includes mixing the chemical precursor (e.g., polyol and isocyanate, or polyurethane prepolymer) used to form the foam, and a latex or a filler, or both, to induce foaming; molding the foam to a desired shape; and applying the foam to the gripping surface of the article. The mixing, molding, and applying steps (or any two of the three steps) may occur simultaneously, for example, by conventional insert molding.
The foam preferably extends circumferential around the gripping surface of the article. Alternatively, the foam can be disposed on a portion of the surface in the form of a discontinuous surface (e.g., strips, dots), or can be disposed within, e.g., a hollow razor handle that has openings in its surface through which the foam extends. In the latter alternative, the fingers of the user will contact the foam extending through the holes. The foam alternatively can be the major component of the handle of the finger-manipulated device.
"Finger-manipulated article", as used herein, means an article having a handle that can be easily maneuvered by the fingers of a user's hand. Typically, the handle of such an article will have a maximum diameter of less than 3.5 cm. Examples of finger manipulated articles include writing instruments like pens and pencils; razors; and toothbrushes.
"Foam", as used herein, is a cellular polymer consisting of two phases, a fluid (liquid or gas) and a solid. The fluid phase in a cellular polymer is distributed in voids or pockets called cells. These cells can be interconnected to form an open-cell foam, or the cells can be discrete and independent of other cells to form a closed cell foam.
The foams of the invention have sufficient rigidity that they can be used in a thin layer on a handle without the underlying handle causing discomfort for the user. Further, the foam has slow recovery, such that it is easily deformed by the user, does not exert significant force against the user's fingers, and returns slowly to its original shape when compressive force is removed. These properties provide comfort to the user of the article, and reduces user fatigue, particularly on writing instruments.
Another aspect of the invention is the preferred foams themselves, which can be used in other applications (e.g., on hand grips for tennis rackets).
Other features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the description of the preferred embodiment thereof, and from the claims.

Description of the Preferred Embodiments

The figure is a perspective view of a pen having a preferred gripping surface.
Referring to the figure, the writing end of pen 10 has a cylindrical body 12 that includes a foam gripping surface 14 extending around the circumference of the instrument in the finger gripping area. The foam layer is less than 1.5 cm thick (more preferably 0.05-0.5 cm thick).
The preferred foam is a polyurethane. Some of the significant properties of the foam are spring rate, recovery rate, and percent peak force. These properties are measured as described subsequently, in the Examples. The preferred foam may be any cured polyurethane prepolymer having a spring rate of from 250 to 20,000 grams/cm, a recovery rate of less than 5 cm per minute, and a percent peak force of less than 95%.
Suitable polyurethane foams include those prepared from compositions having two components: a foamable, curable polyurethane prepolymer, and an aqueous phase containing a latex and a surfactant. One of the two phases (or both) also includes a filler. Either phase can also include a conventional catalyst (or other reaction rate modifier) to either speed up or slow down the reaction.
The preferred foamable polyurethane prepolymers are polyisocyanate capped polyoxyethylene polyols, for example the TREPOL® prepolymers described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,828,542, which is owned by Twin Rivers Engineering of Boothbay, Maine and is hereby incorporated by reference. Other preferred polymers are sold by W.R. Grace & Co. and include HYPOL® FHP 2000 and Hydrogel®, which are derived from toluene diisocyanate, and the FHP 4000 series, which are derived from methylene diisocyanate.
Preferred latexes include styrene-butadienes, polystyrenes, nitriles, acrylics, polyvinyl acetates, and polyvinyl chlorides. Acrylic latexes generally are produced as copolymer of methyl or ethyl methacrylate and an other monomer like styrene and vinyl acetate. The preferred latexes are stable aqueous dispersion of a polymeric substance having a particle size in the range of about 500 Å to 50,000 Å (0.05 µm to 5 µm). Particularly preferred latexes are those having low resilience properties, e.g. UCAR 154, UCAR 123, and UCAR 163 (all commercially available from Union Carbide) and Hycar Acrylic 2671 and Nitrile 1562, available from BF Goodrich. The latex provides the composition with reduced resiliency. Preferably, the starting mixture used to produce the foam should include between 15% and 80% of the latex by weight, where the latex includes 30% to 60% solids by weight.
Any inert filler may be used. Preferred fillers include barium sulfate, calcium carbonate, diatomaceous earth, carbon black, silica, clay, TiO₂, fibers, and other inorganic compounds. The filler helps provide the foam with good mechanical properties, including rigidity, density, and other viscoelastic properties. Preferably, the final foam includes up to 30% of filler by weight. Too little filler in the composition may provide a foam that is not rigid enough, resulting in discomfort to the user because the fingers may feel the body of the pen through the grip. Too much filler results in a foam that may be too viscous to process. Sufficient filler is added to the composition to provide a composition density of from 0.32 to 1.5 g/cm³.
The amounts of the polyurethane prepolymer (and thus the polyurethane resin in the cured foam), latex and filler can be varied in order to provide a desired balance of properties. The properties of the composition will also be affected by the specific polyurethane prepolymer, latex, and filler selected. The percentage of open cells and the degree of openness of cells in a flexible foam are related to resiliency.
The surfactant can be e.g., Pluronic-62, Brij 72, and DC 190. Other suitable surfactants are described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,158,087, which is hereby incorporated by reference. The surfactants help to control the cell size and surface properties of the foam. They also make the latex more compatible with the resin during mixing.
The composition may also comprise other conventional additives, e.g., colorants, catalysts, and foaming agents.

Examples

1. A series of foam grips were prepared from an aqueous phase that included 16 parts (by weight) of diatomaceous earth filler, 34 parts water, and 50 parts Geon HYCAR 2671 latex available from B.F. Goodrich, and a prepolymer phase that included the TREPOL prepolymer described in U.S. Patent No. 4,828,542. The two phases were mixed at a weight ratio of 2:1 until the mix was uniform, causing the composition to foam as carbon dioxide gas is generated. The reacting foam mixtures were molded in a single cavity mold, to form a foam grip having approximately a 0.9 cm outer diameter, a thickness of 0.22 cm, and a length of 4.2 cm. The mechanical properties spring-rate, percent peak force, and recovery rate for the grips, were measured (as described below); the results are presented in the Table.
2. A foam grip having approximately a 1.0 cm diameter, a thickness of 0.22 cm, and a length of 4.2 cm was prepared by injecting a reacting foam mixture into a single-cavity mold into which a pen barrel assembly was inserted. The foam mixture was obtained by mixing an aqueous phase (35 parts by weight of UCAR 154 acrylic latex emulsion available from Union Carbide, and 5 parts of 3% water emulsion of Brij 72 surfactant available from ICI America) and a prepolymer phase comprised of 25 parts Hydrogel polyurethane prepolymer obtained from W.R. Grace Company, 10 parts CaCO₃ filler, and 0.05 parts carbon black pigment. The mechanical properties of the resulting slow recovery foam grip on a finished pen barrel are presented in the Table.
3. Foam grips (having the same dimensions as those prepared in example 2) were insert-molded on pen barrel assemblies by injecting a reacting polyurethane foam mixture into a single cavity mold as in Example 2. The mixtures were identical to Example 2, with the exception of the prepolymer phase which was comprised of 25 part HYPOL FHP 2000 polyurethane prepolymer (W.R. Grace Company) instead of the Hydrogel resin. The mechanical properties for the resulting foam grips are presented in the Table.

Mechanical Properties for Molded Grip Components
Example #	Spring Rate g/cm	Percent Peak Force	Recovery Rate cm/min
1	1,480	74	0.21
2	1,301	79	0.53
3	427	79	0.35

Test Procedures:

Spring Rate

The spring rate of the grip is measured on a standard Instron (e.g., Model 1122) compression tester. When the foam portion of the gripping surface is disposed on the outside of a rigid body (e.g., as shown in the figure), the procedure involves fixedly positioning the grip in alignment with a probe which consists of a cylindrical aluminum rod having a radius of 0.8 cm; the end of the rod has a curvature with a tip radius of 0.6 cm and a chamber radius of 0.2 cm. The probe is arranged for reciprocal movement through a vertical distance after the bottom surface of the probe contacts the grip. The probe is moved downward at 0.13 cm/min to a distance corresponding to approximately 70% of the thickness of the grip before returning to its original position. During this process, the force of compression versus distance of compression is recorded on an X-Y graph. The spring rate value corresponds to the slope of the force/compression distance curve at a compression distance of 0.025 cm.
When the foam portion of the gripping surface is not disposed on the outside of a rigid body, the beginning of the test procedure is modified slightly. A 0.2 cm thick piece of the foam is cut from the foam portion, and attached to the outside of a rigid body having an outer circumference of approximately the same size of any common pen. The remainder of the procedure remains the same.

Percent Peak Force

Peak force is the maximum force of compression resulting from the spring rate measurement. The instron probe is held at the point of maximum grip compression (for the spring rate measurement) for sixty seconds. The force at this time, divided by the peak force, expressed as a percentage, is the percent peak force.

Recovery Rate

The recovery rate is measured concurrently with the spring rate measurement. The probe is held at the point of maximum grip compression for sixty seconds, and is then lifted instantly to a position which is below the original probe-grip contact position by approximately 20% of the thickness of the foam. The time for the grip to recover to reach the probe is recorded by the Instron. The recovery rate is defined as the time for the grip to recover to reach the probe divided by the grip recovery distance.
Other embodiments are within the claims. For example a foam gripping surface may also be utilized on other finger manipulated articles, besides pens and pencils, such as razors (typically having an elongate handle with a cutting edge at one end), toothbrushes (typically having an elongate handle with an array of bristles disposed at one end), and other similar personal care items. The surfactant, like the filler, can be included in either the prepolymer or aqueous phase. Although in the preferred embodiment the polyurethane foam precursor is a foamable polyurethane prepolymer, alternatively the foam may be produced from the reaction of a polyol (polyester-type or polyether-type) with an isocyanate (such as TDI (toluene diisocyanate), MDI (methylene bis (4-phenyl isocyanate), or H-MDI (dicyclohexylmethane-4,4'-diisocyanate)). Foams produced from isocyanates and polyols generally require a catalyst, surfactant and a blowing agent.

Claims

A finger manipulated article (10) having a handle that can be easily maneuvered by the fingers, said handle having a body (12) and a gripping surface comprising a foam layer on an outer surface of the body (12), said foam characterized by having a density from 0.32 to 1.5 g/cm³ and being deformable by the fingers of the user of the article.
The article of claim 1, which is a pen, a razor, or a toothbrush.
The article of claim 1 or 2, wherein said foam has one or more of the following features:

(a) has a recovery rate of less than 5 and less than 3 cm per minute;

(b) comprises a polyurethane resin;

(c) is produced from a mixture comprising a foamable polyurethane resin and a latex and the latex is selected from the group consisting of styrene-butadienes, polystyrenes, nitriles, acrylics, polyvinyl acetates, and polyvinyl chlorides;

(d) further comprising a filler and said filler is selected from the group consisting of diatomaceous earth, carbon black, silica, fibers, and inorganic compounds;

(e) has an average thickness of less than 1.5 cm;

(f) has a spring rate of between 250 and 20,000 grams/cm; and

(g) has a percent peak force of less than 95%.
The finger manipulated article of claim 1 or 2, wherein said foam has a percent peak force of less than 95%.
The article of claim 4, wherein said article is a pen, and said foam has one or more of the following features:

(a) has a recovery rate of less than 5 cm per minute;

(b) is made from a mixture comprising a foamable polyurethane resin and a latex;

(c) further comprises a filler; and

(d) has a spring rate of between 250 and 20,000 grams per cm.
The finger manipulated article of claim 1 or 2, wherein said foam has a spring rate of between 250 and 20,000 grams per cm.
The article of claim 6, wherein said article is a writing instrument and said foam has one or more of the following features:

(a) a recovery rate of less than 10 cm per minute;l

(b) a percent peak force of less than 95%;

(c) is produced from a foamable polyurethane resin;

(d) is produced from a mixture including a foamable polyurethane resin and a latex; or

(e) further comprises a filler.
The finger manipulated article of claim 1 or 2, wherein said foam is produced from a mixture comprising a polyurethane resin and a latex.
The article of claim 8, having one or more of the following features:

(a) said latex is selected from the group consisting of styrene-butadienes, polystyrenes, nitriles, acrylics, polyvinyl acetates, and polyvinyl chlorides;

(b) said foam further comprises a filler;

(c) said article is a pen; and

(d) said foam has a thickness of less than 1.5 cm.
The finger manipulated article or claim 1 or 2, wherein said foam includes a filler.
The article of claim 10, wherein said filler consists of diatomaceous earth, carbon black, silica, fibers, and/or inorganic compounds.
A method for manufacturing a finger-manipulated article according to claim 1 comprising:

(a) mixing a polyurethane foam precursor, a latex, or a filler, of both, to cause foaming to occur, whereby the occured foam has a density from 0.32 to 1.5 g/cm³;

(b) molding the foam to a desired shape; and

(c) applying the molded foam to the body of said article.
The method of claim 12, wherein:

(a) a latex is mixed with said polyurethane foam precursor;

(b) said latex is selected from the group consisting of styrene-butadienes, polystyrenes, nitrites, acrylics, polyvinyl acetates, and polyvinyl chlorides;

(c) a filler is mixed with said polyurethane foam precursor;

(d) said filler is selected from the group consisting of diatomaceous earth, carbon black, silica, fibers, and inorganic compounds;

(e) said precursor comprises a polyol and an isocyanate;

(g) said article is a writing instrument;

(h) all three steps are performed simultaneously; or

(i) said steps are performed by insert molding.
A method of producing the foam of claim 1 comprising mixing a latex, a filler, and a polyurethane foam precursor, said mixing causing foaming to provide said foam.