CN101478069B - Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning - Google Patents

Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN101478069B
CN101478069B CN 200910020953 CN200910020953A CN101478069B CN 101478069 B CN101478069 B CN 101478069B CN 200910020953 CN200910020953 CN 200910020953 CN 200910020953 A CN200910020953 A CN 200910020953A CN 101478069 B CN101478069 B CN 101478069B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
filter
delta
model
adjustment amount
coupling matrix
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Fee Related
Application number
CN 200910020953
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN101478069A (en
Inventor
周金柱
段宝岩
黄进
王一凡
唐波
熊长武
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Xidian University
Original Assignee
Xidian University
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Xidian University filed Critical Xidian University
Priority to CN 200910020953 priority Critical patent/CN101478069B/en
Publication of CN101478069A publication Critical patent/CN101478069A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN101478069B publication Critical patent/CN101478069B/en
Expired - Fee Related legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Feedback Control In General (AREA)
  • Monitoring And Testing Of Nuclear Reactors (AREA)

Abstract

The invention discloses a microwave filter auxiliary debugging method based on kernel machine study, which mainly solves the problem that the prior art that does not construct a relationship model between the bolt adjustment amount and variable quantities of a coupling matrix. The method comprises the following steps: extracting the coupling matrix and processing data according to parameters of a filter S in engineering measurement to obtain normalized data sample sets of the bolt adjustment amount and the variable quantities of the coupling matrix; constructing the model of the influences of the bolt adjustment amount on the variable quantities of the coupling matrix by using the kernel machine study algorithm according to the sample sets; constructing an optimal adjustment model of the bolt adjustment amount of the filter according to the study model of the machine; and solving the optimal adjustment model to obtain the adjustment amount of each adjusting bolt of the filter. The method can rapidly and accurately carry out auxiliary debugging of the filter, and can be used for auxiliary debugging of mass-produced filters.

Description

Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning
Technical field
The invention belongs to the art of microwave filters field, specifically a kind of microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning is used for the debugging of guidance or assisted microwave synthesis filter.
Background technology
Microwave filter is widely used in the communication system.In actual production, because the impact of machining accuracy and rigging error, the debugging of filter is indispensable.Yet, since the adjustment bolt of filter on electrical property to affect rule very complicated so that the debugging operational difficulties.At present all be to rely on artificial experience to debug in the engineering, more time-consuming, the effort of debug process, and need that the commissioning staff's is experienced; For new commissioning staff, be difficult to competent such work.If the production in enormous quantities filter will be engaged a lot of veteran commissioning staffs usually, so that the production cost of filter increases cycle stretch-out.Therefore, in order to alleviate the difficulty of filter debugging, shorten debug time and to reducing the requirement of commissioning staff's commissioning experience, study microwave filter assistant debugging method with the debugging of guidance and help filter, this is very important.
At present, at home and abroad disclosed microwave filter assistant debugging method mainly contains following several:
(1) Optimization Debugging of use equivalent-circuit model and coupling matrix.According to the actual measurement S parameter of filter, adopt optimization method to approach the coupling matrix that obtains time domain and frequency-domain equivalent circuit model, then compare with desirable (design) coupling matrix, instruct debugging according to the difference between them.This method only provides the difference between the coupling matrix, can not obtain filter and adjust the adjustment amount of bolt directly to instruct the engineering staff to debug.As at Masoud Kahrzi, Safieddin Safavi-Naeini, Sujeet K.Chaudhuri, et al.Computer Diagnosis and Tuning of RF and Microwave Filters Using Model-Based Parameter Estimation.IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems, vol.49, no.9 has adopted the equivalent model of frequency domain to obtain coupling matrix in 2002..In " space electronic technology " document of the 1st phase in 2004 " a kind of new method of the auxiliary debugging of machine of microwave filter " (Li Shengxian waits), adopted time domain approach to obtain its coupling matrix.
(2) method of adjustment of the extraction of use coupling matrix and sensitivity.The method extracts by the method for optimizing and obtains coupling matrix, and then the linearisation hypothesis is adopted in sensitivity, has set up the approximate model between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity.Because the relation between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity is nonlinear, linearizing restriction of assumption the range of application of the method.This method is at Peter Harscher, Rudiger Vahldieck, Smain Amari.Automated Filter Tuning Using Generalized Low-Pass Prototype Networks and Gradient-Based Parameter Extraction.IEEE Transaction on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.49, no.12 has report in 2001..
(3) the machine learning method of adjustment of Schema-based identification and Adaptive Signal Processing technology.The method adopts the clustering method in the pattern recognition that the S supplemental characteristic of actual measurement is extracted and obtains characteristic parameter, use the Adaptive Signal Processing technology set up bolt adjustment amount and characteristic parameter between relational model.The deficiency that the method is used is the accuracy of feature extracting.The method is at document Ahmad R.Mirzai, Colin F.N.Cowean, Tom M.Crawford.Intelligent Alignment of Waveguide Filters Using a Machine Learning Approach.IEEE Transaction on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.37, no.1 has report in 1989..
(4) based on the aided debugging method of fuzzy logic.The method is utilized the integrated approach of fuzzy logic, coupling matrix and the human expert info realization assistant adjustment that combines.Yet the method can only provide the difference between the coupling matrix, can not the amount of being adjusted directly instructing the engineering staff to debug, and exist and need more fuzzy rule base and the difficulty of data sample and acquirement of expert knowledge.The method is at document Vahid Miraftab, Raafat R.Computer-aided Tuning of Microwave Filters Using Fuzzy Logic, IEEE Transaction on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.50, no.12 has report in 2002..
There is following defective in the filter assistant debugging method that top document proposes: 1) extract coupling matrix from filter actual measurement S parameter, and with design coupling matrix contrast, the method can only provide the difference between the two, can not directly provide the adjustment amount of filter bolt, can't in the engineering of reality, use.2) adjustment amount adopts the linearisation hypothesis to the sensitivity of coupling matrix variable quantity impact, and this hypothesis does not conform to the actual conditions and closes, so that the debugging effect is restricted.3) there is the difficulty that needs the accurate extraction of more fuzzy rule base and data sample and characteristic parameter and acquirement of expert knowledge in the method for adjustment based on fuzzy logic and pattern recognition.
Summary of the invention
The objective of the invention is to avoid now methodical deficiency, a kind of microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning is provided, it can be used for the debugging of guidance or assisted microwave synthesis filter.It relatively is fit to shorten debug time, improve the debugging efficiency of filter in the microwave filter debugging of large-scale mass production.
The technical scheme that realizes the object of the invention is according to the filter S parameter of measuring in the engineering, by extracting its coupling matrix and carrying out data and process, to obtain the set of data samples of normalized bolt adjustment amount and coupling matrix variable quantity; According to these sample sets, use the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up the model of bolt adjustment amount on the impact of coupling matrix variable quantity, by revising desirable coupling matrix, obtained the machine learning model of bolt adjustment amount on the electrical property impact; According to this machine learning model, made up the optimum adjustment model of filter bolt adjustment amount at last; Find the solution this optimum adjustment model, each adjusts the adjustment amount of bolt to calculate filter.Detailed process comprises:
(1) presets benchmark D for one 0Filter, vow that by changing bolt adjustment amount Δ D, using net measures corresponding filter transformation parameter S 21With reflection parameters S 11
(2) according to the S that measures 21And S 11, extract corresponding coupling matrix, obtain bolt adjustment amount and the corresponding coupling matrix set of data samples Г of experiment;
(3) data sample set Г is carried out normalization, the data set Z of the coupling matrix variable quantity of the bolt adjustment amount that obtains testing and correspondence;
(4) according to resulting data set Z, utilize the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up nuclear machine learning model Δ M between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity:
4a) set of the data sample after normalization Z is divided into training sample T and test samples V two parts, wherein training sample T accounts for 4/5 of data sample sum, and remaining data sample is test samples V;
4b) according to training sample T, the least square support vector regression in the use nuclear machine learning algorithm is set up respectively the meta-model Δ m of each unit variation amount in bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix Ij:
4b1) according to training sample set T, use the least square support vector regression, in high-dimensional feature space, make up respectively the meta-model Δ m of each unit of coupling matrix and bolt adjustment amount Δ D Ij:
Figure GSB00000968030500031
ω is weight vectors in the formula, and b is bias term, Expression Nonlinear Mapping function;
4b2) regression model with above-mentioned high-dimensional feature space is converted into:
Min:
Figure GSB00000968030500033
s.t.
Figure GSB00000968030500034
Figure GSB00000968030500035
...,M
E in the formula kBe ij the error that the relative measured data of meta-model is calculated, C is the compromise of models fitting precision and model complexity, K data sample of ij unit in the expression coupling matrix, M represents the number of samples of training sample T, Δ D kRepresent k bolt adjustment amount data sample;
4b3) introduce Lagrange multiplier α=[α 1, α 2..., α M] T, structure LagrangianL (ω, b, e k, α) be:
Figure GSB00000968030500037
4b4) respectively to the variable ω in the above-mentioned formula, b, e k, α asks local derviation, obtains system of linear equations after the arrangement:
Ω + 1 C I I I T 0 α b = Δm 0
Each element in the formula among the matrix in block form Ω satisfies I is unit matrix,
Figure GSB000009680305000310
The vector that expression coupling matrix unit variable quantity forms;
4b5) find the solution above-mentioned system of linear equations, obtain And b;
4b6) introduce kernel function Finally obtain the meta-model in the ij unit variation amount in the coupling matrix:
Δ m ij = Σ k = 1 M α k K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) + b ,
K(ΔD,ΔD k)=exp(-σ -2||ΔD-ΔD k|| 2),
Or K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) = Π h = 1 n ( 1 - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 σ 2 ) exp ( - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 2 σ 2 ) ,
In the formula
Figure GSB00000968030500045
Represent h component of k data sample, σ represents nuclear parameter, and n represents the number of translation invariant Mexico hat wavelet function base;
4c) utilize all meta-model Δ m among the test samples V checking nuclear machine learning model Δ M IjAccuracy, if the accuracy of model the expectation scope in, then use these models; Otherwise, turn back to step 4b) again modeling, until the accuracy of model meets the demands, the Accuracy evaluation formula that uses in the checking is:
AAE = L - 1 Σ k = 1 L | ( Δ m ij k - Δ m ^ ij k ) | ,
MAE = max ( | Δ m ij 1 - Δ m ^ ij 1 | , . . . , | Δ m ij L - Δ m ^ ij L | ) ,
In the formula: AAE is the average absolute value error, and MAE is the maximum value error,
Figure GSB00000968030500048
Ij unit variation value in the coupling matrix that represents to measure for the k time,
Figure GSB00000968030500049
Be k the numerical value that sample calculates by ij meta-model, L represents the number of samples of test samples V;
4d) to verifying each correct meta-model, according to the structure composition form of filter, combination obtains the nuclear machine learning model Δ M of the actual adjustment amount of bolt and coupling matrix variable quantity:
ΔM=f(ΔD),
ΔL=ΔD Tr,
F represents above-mentioned meta-model Δ m in the formula IjAccording to the Nonlinear Mapping function that the combination of filter construction form obtains, r represents the bolt pitch that microwave filter uses, after Δ L represents that bolt has rotated Δ D circle when adjusting, and the variable quantity that the screw-in depth relative datum of bolt occurs;
(5) use Δ M to the coupling matrix correction, set up the bolt adjustment amount of experiment to the machine learning model of filter electrical property impact
Figure GSB000009680305000410
With
Figure GSB000009680305000411
5a) use machine learning model Δ M to revise desirable coupling matrix M 0, obtaining the bolt adjustment amount is actual coupling matrix M corresponding to Δ D:
M=M 0+ΔM;
5b) according to actual coupling matrix M, set up coupling matrix and filter electrical property
Figure GSB00000968030500051
With
Figure GSB00000968030500052
Relation:
S 21 mode l ( f ) = - 2 j R 1 R 2 [ A - 1 ] n 1
S 11 mode l ( f ) = 1 + 2 j R 1 [ A - 1 ] 11 ,
A = f 0 BW ( f f 0 - f 0 f ) I - jR + M
I is unit matrix in the formula, and BW represents the filter bandwidht that designs, f 0The filter center frequency of expression design, f represents the actual operating frequency of filter, R 1The coupling of expression filter input end mouth and adjacent resonators, R 2The coupling of expression filter output mouth and adjacent resonators, j represents the imaginary part of plural number, matrix A -1In subscript n 1 and 11 represent that respectively transmission characteristic and the reflection characteristic of n rank filter, R represent filter input and output and outside coupling matrix:
R = R 1 0 0 . . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0 0 . . . R 2 ;
(6) according to machine learning model
Figure GSB00000968030500057
With
Figure GSB00000968030500058
Off-line set up microwave filter experiment the bolt adjustment amount optimize and revise model:
6a) according to above-mentioned 5b) process foundation
Figure GSB00000968030500059
With
Figure GSB000009680305000510
Relation, corresponding off resonance adjustment amount Δ D before calculating filter is adjusted 1:
Find:ΔD 1
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 measure ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 measure ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] ,
s.t. Δ D 1 L ≤ Δ D 1 ≤ Δ D 1 U
In the formula
Figure GSB000009680305000513
With
Figure GSB000009680305000514
The lower bound and the upper bound that represent respectively the filter bolt adjustment amount of permission,
Figure GSB000009680305000515
With
Figure GSB000009680305000516
Be illustrated respectively in f iThe transformation parameter that individual Frequency point measures and reflection parameters numerical value,
Figure GSB000009680305000517
With
Figure GSB000009680305000518
Be illustrated respectively in f iTransformation parameter and reflection parameters numerical value that individual Frequency point utilizes machine learning model to calculate, Sfreq and Efreq represent respectively the sample initial frequency point that obtains and finish Frequency point of filter operating frequency;
6b) according to 5b) set up
Figure GSB000009680305000519
With
Figure GSB000009680305000520
Relation, the bolt adjustment amount Δ D that needs when calculating filter is transferred to target by current off resonance state 2
Find:ΔD 2
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 t arg et ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 t arg et ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] ,
s.t. Δ D 2 L ≤ Δ D 2 ≤ Δ D 2 U
In the formula With
Figure GSB00000968030500064
Be illustrated respectively in f iTarget debugging transformation parameter and the reflection parameters numerical value of individual Frequency point, it is given by design in advance,
Figure GSB00000968030500065
With Be illustrated respectively in f iTransformation parameter and reflection parameters numerical value that individual Frequency point utilizes machine learning model to calculate,
Figure GSB00000968030500067
With
Figure GSB00000968030500068
Respectively lower bound and the upper bound of the bolt adjustment amount of the filter that allows of expression; Sfreq and Efreq represent respectively the sample initial frequency point that obtains and finish Frequency point of filter operating frequency;
The as a result Δ D that 6c) obtains according to above-mentioned optimization 1With Δ D 2, the bolt adjustment amount that calculates filter is Δ D:
ΔD=ΔD 2-ΔD 1
(7) with described transformation parameter S 21With reflection parameters S 11Be input to above-mentioned optimizing and revising in the model, in line computation, obtain the actual adjustment amount of each bolt of filter by computer, ancillary works personnel carry out the filter debugging.
The present invention has following advantage:
(1) the present invention can directly obtain the adjustment amount of each bolt owing to the relational model of having set up between bolt adjustment amount and the filter electrical property when optimizing and revising, thereby uses step examination just can adjust to filter the target of expectation.
(2) the present invention assists adjustment model because off-line is set up the filter that contains the engineering debug experience, and adopts in line computation when using, and can obtain fast the concrete adjustment amount of bolt, has shortened debug time, has improved debugging efficiency.
(3) the present invention uses in the filter assistant adjustment of the same type that is suitable for producing in enormous quantities in engineering because the nuclear machine learning algorithm in the employing artificial intelligence is set up the assistant adjustment model of filter.
Description of drawings
Fig. 1 is the structural representation of existing microwave filter;
Fig. 2 is the equivalent circuit diagram of existing microwave filter;
Fig. 3 is aided debugging method flow chart of the present invention;
Fig. 4 is the bright flow charts of setting up bolt adjustment amount and electrical property relation of we;
Fig. 5 is the experimental system of existing four chamber spiral microwave filters;
Fig. 6 uses the filter bolt adjustment amount that the present invention obtains;
Fig. 7 uses filter that the present invention the obtains S21 performance comparison before and after adjusting;
Fig. 8 uses filter that the present invention the obtains S11 performance comparison before and after adjusting;
Fig. 9 uses filter that the present invention the obtains group delay performance comparison before and after adjusting.
Embodiment
Referring to accompanying drawing the present invention is described in further detail.
With reference to Fig. 1, assistant adjustment of the present invention uses existing microwave filter mainly by n resonant element, tuning bolt t iWith coupling bolt c iConsist of.In the aided debugging method of filter, its physical structure is converted into corresponding equivalent electric circuit, such as Fig. 2, m among Fig. 2 IjCoupling between expression resonant element i and the resonant element j, it is cell value in the filter coupled matrix M, ω iThe resonance frequency that represents i resonant element, R 1And R 2Be respectively the coupling of filter input end mouth and output port and adjacent resonant element.
With reference to Fig. 3, the implementation process of the inventive method is as follows:
The first step changes bolt adjustment amount Δ D, uses and vows that net measures corresponding filter transformation parameter S 21With reflection parameters S 11
For a concrete filter, before producing in enormous quantities, the Design of microwave filters personnel by specialty ask according to technique, at first filter are debugged optimum state, and are this setting state benchmark.This benchmark has been specified the initial position D of the filter bolt of producing in enormous quantities 0And corresponding target coupling matrix M 0Experiment according to design changes bolt adjustment amount Δ D at every turn, then obtains the transformation parameter S of filter from vector network analyzer 21With reflection parameters S 11
Second step is according to the S that measures 21And S 11, extract coupling matrix, obtain bolt adjustment amount and corresponding coupling matrix set of data samples Г.
In order to obtain coupling matrix M i, use the equivalent electric circuit of Fig. 2, and be optimized extraction with following objective function F:
F = Σ freq Σ i = 1 2 Σ j = 1 2 [ ( Re ( S ij m ) - Re ( S ij c ) ) 2 + ( Im ( S ij m ) - Im ( S ij c ) ) 2 ] - - - ( 1 )
In the formula
Figure GSB00000968030500072
With The S that represents respectively actual measurement IjThe S that parameter and equivalent-circuit model calculate IjParameter, Re and Im represent respectively S IjThe real part of parameter and imaginary part, freq represent the to sample frequency of the filter that obtains.
According to objective function F and microwave designing software ADS, the S that respectively vector network analyzer is recorded 21And S 11, extract corresponding coupling matrix M i, obtain N data sample Г={ (Δ D i, M i), i=1,2 ..., N}.
In the 3rd step, normalized data sample Г obtains the data set Z of bolt adjustment amount and corresponding coupling matrix variable quantity.
Before data sample normalization, at first calculate the variation delta M that corresponding coupling matrix produces i:
ΔM i=M i-M 0 (2)
Then, use the linear-scale method for normalizing to data set { (Δ D i, Δ M i), i=1,2 ..., N} processes, and obtains data sample set after the normalization
Figure GSB00000968030500074
Wherein With
Figure GSB00000968030500076
The variable quantity that represents respectively normalized bolt adjustment amount and coupling matrix.
In the 4th step, set up the bolt adjustment amount to the machine learning model of filter electrical property impact
Figure GSB00000968030500081
With
Figure GSB00000968030500082
According to the data sample set Z that obtains, at first utilize the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up nuclear machine learning model Δ M between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity, then use Δ M to the coupling matrix correction, set up at last the bolt adjustment amount of experiment to the machine learning model of filter electrical property impact
Figure GSB00000968030500083
With
Figure GSB00000968030500084
As shown in Figure 4.
With reference to Fig. 4, the specific implementation process is as follows:
1) set of the data sample after normalization Z is divided into training sample T and test samples V two parts, wherein training data sample T accounts for 4/5 of data sample sum, is used for setting up the nuclear machine learning model between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity; Check data sample V is used for the accuracy of verification model.
2) according to training sample T, use the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up respectively the meta-model Δ m of each unit variation amount in bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix Ij
At data acquisition system Z={ (Δ D i, Δ M i), i=1,2 ..., among the N}, according to the physical structure that filter adopts, the coupling matrix Δ M of filter iGenerally be expressed as:
Δ M i = Δ m 11 Δ m 12 . . . Δ m 1 n Δ m 21 Δ m 22 . . . Δ m 2 n . . . . . . . . . . . . Δ m n 1 Δ m n 2 . . . Δ m nn - - - ( 3 )
Δ m in the formula Ij=Δ m Ji, nonzero element Δ m IjThe variable quantity of the coupling value between expression resonant element i and the resonant element j, Δ m IiRepresent that the resonance frequency of each resonant element departs from the value of its centre frequency.
In data acquisition system Z, because the variable quantity of each unit belongs to many inputs to the relations of many outputs in bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix, and reasonable algorithm such as least square support vector regression can only be set up many inputs to the data models of single output in the nuclear machine learning.For this reason, the present invention proposes use least square support vector regression and set up respectively bolt adjustment amount Δ D to unit Δ m among the coupling matrix Δ M IjThe method of meta-model.
When making up ij meta-model, the input data are Δ D ∈ R n, the output data are Δ m IjThe M of ∈ R training data sample set
Figure GSB00000968030500086
Use the nonlinear mapping function
Figure GSB00000968030500087
Least square support vector regression model below making up:
Figure GSB00000968030500088
ω is weight vectors in the formula, and b is bias term.According to Statistical Learning Theory, the problems referred to above can be converted into following optimization problem:
Min:
Figure GSB00000968030500091
s.t.
Figure GSB00000968030500092
Figure GSB00000968030500093
...,M
E in the formula kBe model error, C is the compromise of models fitting precision and model complexity.
In order to find the solution this optimization problem, introduce Lagrange multiplier α=[α 1, α 2..., α M] T, LagrangianL (ω, b, e that structure is following; α):
Figure GSB00000968030500094
To the parameter ω in the formula (6), b, e, α ask respectively local derviation, and cancellation intermediate variable ω and e obtain system of linear equations after the arrangement:
Ω + 1 C I I I T 0 α b = Δm 0 - - - ( 7 )
Each element in the formula among the matrix in block form Ω satisfies
Figure GSB00000968030500096
Matrix in block form I is unit matrix,
Figure GSB00000968030500097
The vector that the unit variable quantity forms in the expression coupling matrix;
Find the solution this system of linear equations, obtain
Figure GSB00000968030500098
With b, and by introducing kernel function
Figure GSB00000968030500099
Obtain meta-model:
Δ m ij = Σ k = 1 M α k K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) + b - - - ( 8 )
K in the formula (Δ D, Δ D k) be the nonlinear mapping function
Figure GSB000009680305000911
Inner product in high-dimensional feature space, the use of kernel function have been avoided direct searching nonlinear mapping function
Figure GSB000009680305000912
Difficulty, kernel function is used Gaussian kernel or translation invariant Mexico hat wavelet kernel function, their mathematic(al) representation is as follows respectively:
K(ΔD,ΔD k)=exp(-σ -2||ΔD-ΔD k|| 2) (9)
K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) = Π h = 1 n ( 1 - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 σ 2 ) exp ( - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 2 σ 2 ) - - - ( 10 )
In the formula Represent h component of k data sample, σ represents nuclear parameter.When practical application, according to the requirement of model accuracy, select one of them kernel function to carry out modeling.
3) each meta-model Δ m that utilizes check data sample V checking to set up IiAccuracy.
If the accuracy of model is then used these models in the scope of expectation; Otherwise, turn back to process 2) in again modeling, the parameter that reselects model is carried out modeling, until the accuracy of model meets the demands.In the process of verification model accuracy, be the accuracy that index is come assessment models with average absolute value error AAE and maximum value error MAE:
AAE = L - 1 Σ k = 1 L | ( Δ m ij k - Δ m ^ ij k ) | - - - ( 11 )
MAE = max ( | Δ m ij 1 - Δ m ^ ij 1 | , . . . , | Δ m ij L - Δ m ^ ij L | ) - - - ( 12 )
In the formula
Figure GSB00000968030500103
Ij unit variation value in the coupling matrix that represents to measure for the k time, Be k the numerical value that sample calculates by ij meta-model, L represents the test samples number.
4) combination obtains the nuclear machine learning model Δ M of the actual adjustment amount of bolt and coupling matrix variable quantity.
According to process 2) in the meta-model modeling method, use respectively the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up bolt adjustment amount Δ D to each unit Δ m among the coupling matrix Δ M IjMeta-model; Then, according to the practical structures composition form of filter, each unit Δ m IjMeta-model be combined into coupling matrix, obtain the bolt adjustment amount to the model Δ M of coupling matrix variable quantity impact:
ΔM=f(ΔD) (13)
ΔL=ΔD Tr (14)
R represents the bolt pitch that microwave filter uses in the formula, when Δ L represents that bolt is adjusted because after having rotated Δ D circle, the screw-in depth relative datum D of bolt 0The variable quantity that occurs.
5) use machine learning model Δ M to revise desirable coupling matrix M 0, when acquisition bolt adjustment amount is Δ D, corresponding actual coupling matrix M.
M=M 0+ΔM (15)
6) according to actual coupling matrix M, set up coupling matrix and filter electrical property
Figure GSB00000968030500105
With
Figure GSB00000968030500106
Relation.
S 21 mode l ( f ) = - 2 j R 1 R 2 [ A - 1 ] n 1
S 11 mode l ( f ) = 1 + 2 j R 1 [ A - 1 ] 11 - - - ( 16 )
A = f 0 BW ( f f 0 - f 0 f ) I - jR + M
M is the actual coupling matrix of considering after bolt adjustment amount Δ D affects in the formula, M 0The target coupling matrix of expression expectation, Δ M represent because the coupling matrix variable quantity that the impact of bolt adjustment amount Δ D causes.I is unit matrix.BW represents the filter bandwidht that designs.f 0The centre frequency of expression filter, f represents the actual operating frequency of filter.R 1The coupling of expression filter input end mouth and adjacent resonators, R 2The coupling of expression filter output mouth and adjacent resonators, R represents the coupling matrix of filter input and output and outside, the R matrix notation is:
R = R 1 0 0 . . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0 0 . . . R 2 - - - ( 17 )
The 5th step, set up microwave filter experiment the bolt adjustment amount optimize and revise model, detailed process is as follows:
According to the filter off resonance state outcome of vowing that net measures With Then utilize process 6) the middle machine learning model of setting up
Figure GSB00000968030500114
Off resonance state with current measurement The principle of error sum of squares minimum, the Optimized model below making up:
Find:ΔD 1
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 measure ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 measure ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] - - - ( 18 )
s.t. Δ D 1 L ≤ Δ D 1 ≤ Δ D 1 U
In the formula With Represent respectively lower bound and the upper bound of the filter bolt adjustment amount of permission, their value is determined in advance by the designer;
Figure GSB000009680305001110
With
Figure GSB000009680305001111
Be illustrated respectively in f iThe off resonance state transfer parameter that individual Frequency point measures and off resonance attitudinal reflexes parameter values;
Figure GSB000009680305001112
With Be illustrated respectively in f iIndividual Frequency point utilizes process 6) in the machine learning model the set up transformation parameter and the reflection parameters numerical value that calculate, Sfeq and Efeq represent respectively initial frequency point and end Frequency point that the filter operating frequency is sampled and obtained.
Find the solution above-mentioned Optimized model, find and to approach current off resonance state
Figure GSB000009680305001114
With
Figure GSB000009680305001115
Optimum machine learning model
Figure GSB000009680305001116
With
Figure GSB000009680305001117
And corresponding bolt off resonance adjustment amount Δ D 1
The machine learning model of approaching with the current off resonance state of filter according to above-mentioned acquisition With
Figure GSB000009680305001119
Filter debug target with prior setting With
Figure GSB000009680305001121
Adopt the principle of the two error sum of squares minimum, the optimization formula below making up makes the machine learning model that is in the off resonance state
Figure GSB000009680305001122
With
Figure GSB000009680305001123
Adjust to the filter debug target of prior setting:
Find:ΔD 2
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 t arg et ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 t arg et ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] - - - ( 19 )
s.t. Δ D 2 L ≤ Δ D 2 ≤ Δ D 2 U
In the formula
Figure GSB000009680305001126
With
Figure GSB000009680305001127
Be illustrated respectively in f iThe target debugging transformation parameter of individual Frequency point and target debugging reflection parameters numerical value, they are given by design in advance;
Figure GSB000009680305001128
With
Figure GSB000009680305001129
Respectively lower bound and the upper bound of the filter bolt adjustment amount that allows of expression, their value also determined in advance by the designer, and Sfeq and Efeq represent respectively initial frequency point and end Frequency point that the filter operating frequency is sampled and obtained.
Find the solution the Optimized model of formula (19), obtain the bolt adjustment amount Δ D that needs when filter is adjusted to the debug target of prior setting by current off resonance state 2
At last, the as a result Δ D that obtains according to above-mentioned seismic responses calculated 1With Δ D 2, the bolt adjustment amount Δ D of calculating filter:
ΔD=ΔD 2-ΔD 1。(20)
In the 6th step, the optimizing application adjustment model obtains the actual adjustment amount of each bolt of filter, carries out the filter debugging.
When practical engineering application, at first should arrive predefined benchmark by the correcting filter bolt; Then in debugging, what measure from the arrow net
Figure GSB00000968030500121
With
Figure GSB00000968030500122
Data directly be sent to optimizing and revising in modular form (18) and (19) that off-line is set up in the 5th step, utilize computer in line computation, obtain filter bolt adjustment amount, according to this adjustment amount filter is debugged.
Advantage of the present invention can be used by the debugging of the filter in the following Practical Project and further specify:
Microwave filter assistant debugging method of the present invention is carried out experimental verification at four chamber screw-filters.The experimental system of this filter is seen accompanying drawing 5.The design objective of this filter is: centre frequency f 0For 397.7MHz, bandwidth are that return loss is 20dB in 8.31MHz, the band.According to the structure of filter shown in Figure 7, obtain its coupling matrix and be:
M = m 11 m 12 0 0 m 12 m 22 m 23 0 0 m 23 m 33 m 34 0 0 m 34 m 44 - - - ( 21 )
Use filter coupled matrix integrated approach, the R that obtains designing 1=R 2The no-load Q=540 of=1.0352, four cavitys, in the coupling matrix except m 12=0.9211, m 23=0.6999, m 34=0.9211, other unit is zero.
Collect in the experiment at data sample, as benchmark, measured corresponding S parameter by the vector network analyzer device this moment, then extracts coupling matrix when the inventive method was debugged the electrical property optimum take filter, acquisition target coupling matrix M 0, its each unit is respectively m 11=-0.0355, m 22=-0.0263, m 33=-0.0089, m 44=0.0034, m 12=0.969, m 23=0.7177, m 34=0.9043.
Take above-mentioned optimum debug results as benchmark, and the number of turns that turns clockwise of regulation bolt relative datum on the occasion of, instead then for negative.Adopted the uniform experiments method for designing.In each experiment, measure the S supplemental characteristic from the vector network analyzer device, then extract and obtain corresponding coupling matrix data.Again bolt is reset to benchmark, restart experiment next time.By experiment repeatedly, can obtain the set of data samples E={ Δ D that some bolts are adjusted variable quantity and coupling matrix i, M i), i=1,2 ..., N}.After the processing of data sample set, directly used the normalized bolt adjustment amount of modeling and data set Z={ (the Δ D of the coupling matrix variable quantity of correspondence i, Δ M i), i=1,2 ..., N}.
According to set of data samples Z, utilize the present invention to set up nuclear machine learning model between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity.Because coupling matrix is very responsive on the impact of electrical property, for accuracy set up bolt adjustment amount and coupling matrix variable quantity model, the nuclear machine learning algorithm such as RBF nuclear least square support vector regression RBFLSSVR, the Mexico hat wavelet nuclear least square support vector regression LSWSVR that have used respectively the present invention to propose, and traditional machine learning algorithm such as BP neural net are carried out modeling.For accuracy and the generalization that guarantees model, use parameter and BP network configuration that cross validation method is selected the least square support vector regression.
For the accuracy of verification model, come the accuracy of verification model with 5 test samples, and average absolute value error AAE and maximum value error MAE are the accuracy that index is come assessment models.Table 1 has provided the AAE of three kinds of modeling methods and the performance comparison result of MAE.
Table 1 model accuracy comparing result
Can see from table 1: LSWSVR is higher than accuracy and the generalization of RBFLSSVR, and the accuracy of BP network and generalization are the poorest.
According to the comparing result of table 1, the machine learning model of using above-mentioned Wavelet Kernel least square support vector regression LSWSVR to set up, and optimize and revise the adjustment amount that model is found the solution bolt in conjunction with what the present invention proposed.Obtain the concrete adjustment amount of each bolt of filter after finding the solution, see accompanying drawing 6.6 bolt adjustment amounts that provide with reference to the accompanying drawings, the commissioning staff adjusts the adjustment bolt of respective filter, only needs can finish adjustment once going on foot.
Before accompanying drawing 7, accompanying drawing 8 and accompanying drawing 9 have provided respectively the adjustment of this filter, adjust after and S21, the S11 of debug target and the comparing result of group delay.From these figure, can see: the adjustment amount that uses the present invention to calculate, only need step examination just the electrical property of filter to be adjusted near optimum state, satisfy the designing requirement of filter, having overcome needs repeatedly to debug filter, too much drawback of time in the engineering, improved the debugging efficiency of filter.
The experimental result of above-mentioned filter shows, adopt the present invention can be than more quickly, finish the debugging of filter exactly.

Claims (1)

1. microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning comprises following process:
(1) presets benchmark D for one 0Filter, vow that by changing bolt adjustment amount Δ D, using net measures corresponding filter transformation parameter S 21With reflection parameters S 11
(2) according to the S that measures 21And S 11, extract corresponding coupling matrix, obtain bolt adjustment amount and the corresponding coupling matrix set of data samples Г of experiment;
(3) data sample set Г is carried out normalization, the data set Z of the coupling matrix variable quantity of the bolt adjustment amount that obtains testing and correspondence;
(4) according to resulting data set Z, utilize the nuclear machine learning algorithm to set up nuclear machine learning model Δ M between bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix variable quantity:
4a) set of the data sample after normalization Z is divided into training sample T and test samples V two parts, wherein training sample T accounts for 4/5 of data sample sum, and remaining data sample is test samples V;
4b) according to training sample T, the least square support vector regression in the use nuclear machine learning algorithm is set up respectively the meta-model Δ m of each unit variation amount in bolt adjustment amount and the coupling matrix Ij:
4b1) according to training sample set T, use the least square support vector regression, in high-dimensional feature space, make up respectively the meta-model Δ m of each unit of coupling matrix and bolt adjustment amount Δ D Ij:
Figure FSB00000968030400011
ω is weight vectors in the formula, and b is bias term, Expression Nonlinear Mapping function;
4b2) regression model with above-mentioned high-dimensional feature space is converted into:
Min:
s.t.
Figure FSB00000968030400015
...,M
E in the formula kBe ij the error that the relative measured data of meta-model is calculated, C is the compromise of models fitting precision and model complexity,
Figure FSB00000968030400016
K data sample of ij unit in the expression coupling matrix, M represents the number of samples of training sample T, Δ D kRepresent k bolt adjustment amount data sample;
4b3) introduce Lagrange multiplier α=[α 1, α 2..., α M] T, structure LagrangianL (ω, b, e k, α) be:
Figure FSB00000968030400017
4b4) respectively to the variable ω in the above-mentioned formula, b, e k, α asks local derviation, obtains system of linear equations after the arrangement:
Ω + 1 C I I I T 0 α b = Δm 0
Each element in the formula among the matrix in block form Ω satisfies
Figure FSB00000968030400022
I is unit matrix,
Figure FSB00000968030400023
The vector that expression coupling matrix unit variable quantity forms;
4b5) find the solution above-mentioned system of linear equations, obtain
Figure FSB00000968030400024
And b;
4b6) introduce kernel function
Figure FSB00000968030400025
Finally obtain the meta-model in the ij unit variation amount in the coupling matrix:
Δ m ij = Σ k = 1 M α k K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) + b ,
K(ΔD,ΔD k)=exp(-σ -2||ΔD-ΔD k|| 2),
Or K ( ΔD , Δ D k ) = Π h = 1 n ( 1 - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 σ 2 ) exp ( - | | ΔD - Δ D k h | | 2 2 σ 2 ) ,
In the formula
Figure FSB00000968030400028
Represent h component of k data sample, σ represents nuclear parameter, and n represents the number of translation invariant Mexico hat wavelet function base;
4c) utilize all meta-model Δ m among the test samples V checking nuclear machine learning model Δ M IjAccuracy, if the accuracy of model the expectation scope in, then use these models; Otherwise, turn back to step 4b) again modeling, until the accuracy of model meets the demands, the Accuracy evaluation formula that uses in the checking is:
AAE = L - 1 Σ k = 1 L | ( Δ m ij k - Δ m ^ ij k ) | ,
MAE = max ( | Δ m ij 1 - Δ m ^ ij 1 | , . . . , | Δ m ij L - Δ m ^ ij L | ) ,
In the formula: AAE is the average absolute value error, and MAE is the maximum value error,
Figure FSB000009680304000211
Ij unit variation value in the coupling matrix that represents to measure for the k time,
Figure FSB000009680304000212
Be k the numerical value that sample calculates by ij meta-model, L represents the number of samples of test samples V;
4d) to verifying each correct meta-model, according to the structure composition form of filter, combination obtains the nuclear machine learning model Δ M of the actual adjustment amount of bolt and coupling matrix variable quantity:
ΔM=f(ΔD),
ΔL=ΔD Tr,
F represents above-mentioned meta-model Δ m in the formula IjAccording to the Nonlinear Mapping function that the combination of filter construction form obtains, r represents the bolt pitch that microwave filter uses, after Δ L represents that bolt has rotated Δ D circle when adjusting, and the variable quantity that the screw-in depth relative datum of bolt occurs;
(5) use Δ M to the coupling matrix correction, set up the bolt adjustment amount of experiment to the machine learning model of filter electrical property impact
Figure FSB00000968030400031
With
Figure FSB00000968030400032
5a) use machine learning model Δ M to revise desirable coupling matrix M 0, obtaining the bolt adjustment amount is actual coupling matrix M corresponding to Δ D:
M=M 0+ΔM;
5b) according to actual coupling matrix M, set up coupling matrix and filter electrical property
Figure FSB00000968030400033
With
Figure FSB00000968030400034
Relation:
S 21 mode l ( f ) = - 2 j R 1 R 2 [ A - 1 ] n 1
S 11 mode l ( f ) = 1 + 2 j R 1 [ A - 1 ] 11 ,
A = f 0 BW ( f f 0 - f 0 f ) I - jR + M
I is unit matrix in the formula, and BW represents the filter bandwidht that designs, f 0The filter center frequency of expression design, f represents the actual operating frequency of filter, R 1The coupling of expression filter input end mouth and adjacent resonators, R 2The coupling of expression filter output mouth and adjacent resonators, j represents the imaginary part of plural number, matrix A -1In subscript n 1 and 11 represent that respectively transmission characteristic and the reflection characteristic of n rank filter, R represent filter input and output and outside coupling matrix:
R = R 1 0 0 . . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 0 0 0 . . . 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0 0 . . . R 2 ;
(6) according to machine learning model
Figure FSB00000968030400039
With
Figure FSB000009680304000310
Off-line set up microwave filter experiment the bolt adjustment amount optimize and revise model:
6a) according to above-mentioned 5b) process foundation
Figure FSB000009680304000311
With
Figure FSB000009680304000312
Relation, corresponding off resonance adjustment amount Δ D before calculating filter is adjusted 1:
Find:ΔD 1
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 measure ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 measure ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] ,
s.t. Δ D 1 L ≤ Δ D 1 ≤ Δ D 1 U
In the formula With The lower bound and the upper bound that represent respectively the filter bolt adjustment amount of permission,
Figure FSB000009680304000317
With
Figure FSB00000968030400041
Be illustrated respectively in f iThe transformation parameter that individual Frequency point measures and reflection parameters numerical value,
Figure FSB00000968030400042
With
Figure FSB00000968030400043
Be illustrated respectively in f iTransformation parameter and reflection parameters numerical value that individual Frequency point utilizes machine learning model to calculate, Sfreq and Efreq represent respectively the sample initial frequency point that obtains and finish Frequency point of filter operating frequency;
6b) according to 5b) set up
Figure FSB00000968030400044
With
Figure FSB00000968030400045
Relation, the bolt adjustment amount Δ D that needs when calculating filter is transferred to target by current off resonance state 2
Find:ΔD 2
Min: Σ f i = Sfreq Efreq [ ( S 21 t arg et ( f i ) - S 21 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 + ( S 11 t arg et ( f i ) - S 11 mode l ( f i ) ) 2 ] ,
s.t. Δ D 2 L ≤ Δ D 2 ≤ Δ D 2 U
In the formula With
Figure FSB00000968030400049
Be illustrated respectively in f iTarget debugging transformation parameter and the reflection parameters numerical value of individual Frequency point, it is given by design in advance,
Figure FSB000009680304000410
With Be illustrated respectively in f iTransformation parameter and reflection parameters numerical value that individual Frequency point utilizes machine learning model to calculate,
Figure FSB000009680304000412
With
Figure FSB000009680304000413
Respectively lower bound and the upper bound of the bolt adjustment amount of the filter that allows of expression; Sfreq and Efreq represent respectively the sample initial frequency point that obtains and finish Frequency point of filter operating frequency;
The as a result Δ D that 6c) obtains according to above-mentioned optimization 1With Δ D 2, the bolt adjustment amount that calculates filter is Δ D:
ΔD=ΔD 2-ΔD 1
(7) with described transformation parameter S 21With reflection parameters S 11Be input to above-mentioned optimizing and revising in the model, in line computation, obtain the actual adjustment amount of each bolt of filter by computer, ancillary works personnel carry out the filter debugging.
CN 200910020953 2009-01-16 2009-01-16 Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning Expired - Fee Related CN101478069B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN 200910020953 CN101478069B (en) 2009-01-16 2009-01-16 Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN 200910020953 CN101478069B (en) 2009-01-16 2009-01-16 Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN101478069A CN101478069A (en) 2009-07-08
CN101478069B true CN101478069B (en) 2013-04-03

Family

ID=40838722

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN 200910020953 Expired - Fee Related CN101478069B (en) 2009-01-16 2009-01-16 Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN101478069B (en)

Families Citing this family (16)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN104659460B (en) * 2013-11-25 2018-01-09 中国科学院深圳先进技术研究院 The automated tuning method and system of cavity body filter
CN104462651B (en) * 2014-11-07 2017-05-10 西安电子科技大学 Method for quickly determining mounting position of microwave device bolts based on sparse array
CN105048040B (en) * 2015-07-10 2018-06-05 深圳市艾励美特科技有限公司 Automatic debugging method of cavity filter
CN105680827B (en) * 2015-12-31 2018-06-22 中国科学院深圳先进技术研究院 A kind of cavity body filter intelligent tuning algorithm and the tuning methods using the algorithm
CN107124150A (en) * 2016-02-24 2017-09-01 苏州尚迈智能科技有限公司 The adaptive approach that a kind of filter parameter is extracted
CN106602202B (en) * 2016-12-08 2019-03-12 中国科学院深圳先进技术研究院 A kind of adjustment method of radio-frequency devices
CN106814307B (en) * 2017-01-10 2020-05-12 深圳鼎缘电子科技有限公司 Automatic debugging method and system for cavity filter
CN107766646B (en) * 2017-10-13 2020-05-22 中国地质大学(武汉) Processing method and system of microwave filter constructed by poles and residue numbers of Y parameters
CN108170922B (en) * 2017-12-21 2021-05-14 中国地质大学(武汉) Auxiliary debugging method and device for microwave filter and storage device
CN108879047B (en) * 2018-07-17 2020-08-07 中国地质大学(武汉) Method and device for debugging microwave cavity filter and storage device
CN109783905B (en) * 2018-12-28 2020-09-25 中国地质大学(武汉) Intelligent microwave cavity filter debugging method based on particle swarm optimization algorithm
CN109696618A (en) * 2019-02-21 2019-04-30 徐晨阳 A kind of adjustment method of radio-frequency devices, device, equipment, storage medium and system
WO2021077291A1 (en) * 2019-10-22 2021-04-29 华为技术有限公司 Dielectric filter debugging method and device
CN114079131B (en) * 2020-08-11 2024-03-26 苏州畅恒通信科技有限公司 Cavity filter debugging method
CN113255222B (en) * 2021-06-01 2023-10-31 苏州芯迈智能科技有限公司 Intelligent auxiliary debugging method and device for cavity filter
CN113591541A (en) * 2021-06-02 2021-11-02 江汉大学 Processing method and device for debugging data of duplexer

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN101478069A (en) 2009-07-08

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN101478069B (en) Microwave filter assistant debugging method based on nuclear machine learning
CN106529090B (en) A kind of aerospace electron class Reliability Assessment method
CN108170922B (en) Auxiliary debugging method and device for microwave filter and storage device
CN105158723B (en) A kind of error evaluation system and method for digitalized electric energy metering system
CN102393864B (en) Method for optimizing reliability of harmonic gear used for space vehicle based on fault physics
WO2020258826A1 (en) Industrial equipment operation, maintenance and optimization method and system based on complex network model
CN107766646B (en) Processing method and system of microwave filter constructed by poles and residue numbers of Y parameters
CN110221237A (en) A kind of capacitance type potential transformer harmonic voltage measurement method and apparatus
CN102052233A (en) Water turbine regulating system module used for stability analysis of power system
CN104298809A (en) Non-linear modeling solving method based on matrix index electromagnetic transient simulation
CN110210687A (en) A kind of Nonlinear Dynamic production process product quality prediction technique returned based on local weighted slow feature
CN103106305A (en) Space grid structure model step-by-step correction method based on actual measurement mode
CN106055827A (en) Oil deposit numerical value simulation parameter sensibility analysis device and method
CN109284541A (en) A kind of more Method of Physical Modeling of neural network for microwave passive component
CN110378035A (en) It is a kind of that soft-measuring modeling method is hydrocracked based on deep learning
CN113255222B (en) Intelligent auxiliary debugging method and device for cavity filter
CN114004191A (en) Method, system, device and medium for extracting delay circuit macro model
CN105868918A (en) Similarity index computing method of harmonic current type monitoring sample
CN103279030A (en) Bayesian framework-based dynamic soft measurement modeling method and device
CN109886316B (en) Transformer state parameter combination prediction method based on cloud system similarity weight distribution
CN105354584A (en) Waveband dissimilarity based high-spectral data waveband representation selection method
CN111832213B (en) Filter coupling matrix decoupling transformation method based on hybrid optimization algorithm
CN104063539A (en) Band elimination filter diagnostic method
Michalski On linear mapping of filter characteristic to position of tuning elements in filter tuning algorithm
CN106021670A (en) Modeling method of millimeter waves FET

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
C10 Entry into substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
C14 Grant of patent or utility model
GR01 Patent grant
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee

Granted publication date: 20130403

CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee