CA1151513A - Process for annealing steels - Google Patents

Process for annealing steels

Info

Publication number
CA1151513A
CA1151513A CA000364167A CA364167A CA1151513A CA 1151513 A CA1151513 A CA 1151513A CA 000364167 A CA000364167 A CA 000364167A CA 364167 A CA364167 A CA 364167A CA 1151513 A CA1151513 A CA 1151513A
Authority
CA
Canada
Prior art keywords
steel
annealed
heating
carbides
austenite
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired
Application number
CA000364167A
Other languages
French (fr)
Inventor
Gerald W. Wilks
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Lasalle Steel Co
Original Assignee
Lasalle Steel Co
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Lasalle Steel Co filed Critical Lasalle Steel Co
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CA1151513A publication Critical patent/CA1151513A/en
Expired legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • CCHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
    • C21METALLURGY OF IRON
    • C21DMODIFYING THE PHYSICAL STRUCTURE OF FERROUS METALS; GENERAL DEVICES FOR HEAT TREATMENT OF FERROUS OR NON-FERROUS METALS OR ALLOYS; MAKING METAL MALLEABLE, e.g. BY DECARBURISATION OR TEMPERING
    • C21D1/00General methods or devices for heat treatment, e.g. annealing, hardening, quenching or tempering
    • C21D1/26Methods of annealing

Landscapes

  • Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Thermal Sciences (AREA)
  • Crystallography & Structural Chemistry (AREA)
  • Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
  • Materials Engineering (AREA)
  • Metallurgy (AREA)
  • Organic Chemistry (AREA)
  • Heat Treatment Of Strip Materials And Filament Materials (AREA)
  • Heat Treatment Of Articles (AREA)
  • Heat Treatment Of Steel (AREA)

Abstract

PROCESS FOR ANNEALING STEELS

ABSTRACT OF THE DISCLOSURE

A process for the annealing of hypoeutectoid steels wherein a steel is rapidly heated to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to convert the steel to austenite and carbides, followed by cooling of the steel. The rate of heating of the steel is such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite thus formed, thereby leaving small particles of undissolved carbide in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products on cooling. Steels processed in accordance with the process of this invention are characterized by improved ductility and toughness as well as good machinability characteristics.

Description

5~3 S P E C I F I C A T I O N

This invention relates to the annealing of steels, and more particularly to a process for the annealing of steels to improve the forming and machining characteristics of the steel.

Annealing is a well-known process in the treatment of steels, and is used primarily to soften the steel so that it can be machined or formed into a part having ~he desired configuration in an economical manner. In general, annealing is carried out by heating the steel in a furnace maintained at the austenitizing temperature, from which the steel is removed and cooled in a controlled manner. The steel is heated to a temperature above the austenitizing temperature (i - ' the A3 temperature) and then cooled so that the micro-structure of the steel contains the so-called upper trans-formation products, namely pearlite, blocky ferrite, spheroidal carbides and combinations thereof. The upper transformation products are to be distinguished from the equally well-known lower transformation products, namely bainite, acicular ferrite and martensite, in that the upper transformation products are softer and more ductile than the lower transformation products.
Thus, for annealing to improve machinability, the goal in the annealing process is to form upper transformation products to the substantial exclusion of lower transformation products.

Annealing is frequently carried out with respect to hot rolled steel, using large annealing furnaces. Just the size of the furnaces required in terms of space requirements and capital investment represents a significant drawback to 3 5~3 their use. As is well known to those skilled in the art, there are several further disadvantages associated with the use of such annealing furnaces. In the first place, furnace heating efficiency ls generally quite low, with the result that increasing fuel costs make it desirable to provide a more efficient means of heating the steel. In addition, furnace heating takes place by radiation, conduction and by convection as the mechanism for heat transfer, thus necessitating long cycles to insure that a load of steel in the furnace has been subjected to uniform processing in a given heating cycle.
Such long cycles are themselves disadvantageous, for the elevated temperatures used require the use of a known non-o~idizing atmosphere (i.e., a protective atmosphere or vacuum), which requires additional energy to produce.

It is thus desirable to avoid the use of such large annealing furnaces provided that the physical properties of the annealed steel fall within acceptable limits. It has been proposed, as described in U. S. Patent Nos. 3,908,431, 4,040,872 and 4,088,511 to treat steels using various thermal cycles by use of electrical resistance heating techniques.
Those techniques have the adva-ntage of providing very rapid ~eating of steel workpieces with high efficiencies, including uniform heating over the entire cross section of the steel workpiece.

Electrical resistance heating has been used in annealing processes, as described in U.S. Patent No. 3,855,013.
In that process, a cold worked steel is rapidly heated by electrical resistance heating to a temperature above the A
temperature, in which the ferrite present in the steel is 5~
converted to austenite. The carbides present do not dissolve in the austenite thus formed, but remain as a separate phase. The steel is then quenched to room temperature to convert the austenite back to ferrite, in essence resul-ting in elimination of the cold work in the steel leaving the carbides unchanged.
It has now been found that annealing of steels can be significantly modified to provide steels having improved ductility and toughness when the heating to a temperature above the austenitizing temperature is rapidly carried out at a rate such that most of the carbides dissolve in the austenite thus formed, while leaving small particles of carbide in undissolved form. The small carbide particles which remain are of sufficient quantity to serve as nuclei for the growth of upper transformation products during cooling, thereby resulting in an overall acceleration of the annealing process.
The present invention is directed to providing an improved process for the annealing of steels.
This invention also is directed to providing improved steels which have been annealed to yield high ductility, formability and toughness characteristics.
According to the present invention therefore, there is provided a process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) rapidly heating a hypoeutectoid steel to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the rate of heating being such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite, leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbide in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the s-teel to precipitate said upper trans-formation products and form an annealed steel having improved ductility, formability and toughness.

L5~3 The heating of the hypoeutectoid steel may be far less than ten minutes and may be effected by passing an electrical current through the steel.
More specifically, the present invention may be defined as a process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) heating a hypoeutectoid steel uniformly across its cross section to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the rate of heating being such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite, leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbides to serve as nuclei for the preci-pitation of upper transformation products, and, (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper trans-formation products.
Figure 1 is a graph of temperature versus time, representing the heating and cooling of two steel specimens to show the temperature dependence of accelerated annealing in accordance with the present invention;
Figure 2 is a graph of temperature versus time, representing the heating and cooling of several steel specimens to show the time dependence of accelerated annealing in accordance with the present invention;
Figure 3A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4142 steel prior to processing in accordance with the present invention (Heat A);
Figure 3B is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4142 steel after heating to 1415F followed by quenching (Heat A);
Figure 3C is a photomicrograph showing the micro-30 structure of 4142 steel after heating to 1415F and air cooling (Heat A);
Figure 4 is a graph of mechanical properties (hardness S~L3 ~ and tensile strength~ versus austenitizing temperature of 8640 steel (Heat B);
Figure 5 is a schematic illustration of apparatus used for annealing in accordance with the concepts of this invention;
Figure 6A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4140 steel prior to treatment in accordance with the present invention (Heat C);

- 4a ~

` ?
~ ~, 5~L3 Figure 6B is a photo~icrograph showing the micro-structure of 4140 steel after furnace annealing (Heat C);

Figure 6Cis a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4140 steel whicll has been annealed in accordance with the process of this inven~ion (Hea~ C);

Figure 7 is a graph of Charpy impact energy versus temperature for 4140 steel which has been furnace annealed and annealed by the process of this invention (Heat C);

Figure 8 illustrates the results of machinability testing (in the form of a plot of part growth versus parts produced in running time)for 4140 steels which have been furnace annealed and annealed in the process of tnis invention(Heat C) Figure 9A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4140 steel prior to processing in accordance with the present invention(Heat D);

Figure 9B is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 4140 steel after furnace annealing(Heat D);

Figure 9C is a photomicrograph of 4140 steel as annealed by the process of this invention (Heat D);

Figure lQ is a plot of Charpy impact energy versus temperature for 4140 steel which has been furnace annealed and annealed by the process of this invention(Heat D);

Fi~ure 11 is a graph (in the form of time versus speed as determined by a modified Taylor life test) of 4140 steel which has been furnace annealed and annealed by the process of this invention (Heat D);

r 51~

Figure 12A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 8640 steel prior to processing in accordance with the present invention (Heat B);

Figure 12B is a photo~licrograph showing the micro-s~ructu-.e OI ~6~u Sl~i which nas be~n Iurn~c~ anneaieu ~-nea B);

Figure 12C is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 8640 steel which has been annealed in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat B);

Figure 13 is a graph of Charpy impact energy versus temperature for 8~40 steel which has been furnace annealed and annealed by the process of this invention (Heat B);

Figure 14A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 6150 steel prior to treatment in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat G);

Figure 14~ is a photomicrograph showing the micro~
structure of 6150 steel which has been furnace annealed (Heat G);

Figure 14C is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of 6150 steel ~hich has been annealed by the process of this invention (Heat G);

Figure 15 is a graph of Charpy impact energy versus testing temperature for 6150 steel which has been annealed in a furnace and 6150 steel which has been annealed in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat G);

Figure 16A is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of a 1144 steel prior to processing in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat H);

5~3 ~ igure 16B is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of the 1144 steel shown in Figure 16A after annealing in a furnace (Heat H);

Figure 16C is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of the 1144 steel after it has been annealed in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat H);

Figure 17A is a pnotomicrograph showing the micro-structure of an 86L20 steel prior to processing (Heat I);

Figure 17B is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of the 86L20 steel of Figure 17A after it has been furnace annealed (Heat I); and, Figure 17C is a photomicrograph showing the micro-structure of the 86L20 steel of Figure 17A after it-has been annealed in accordance with the process of this invention (Heat I).

` The concepts of the present invention reside in the discovery that high levels of ductility and toughness can be achieved with hypoeutectoid steels by annealing where the steel is rapidly heated to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature to form austenite and retained iron carbides, with the rate of heating being sufficiently rapid such that most of the carbides are dissolved in the austenite leaving small particles, usually spheroidal in form, 3 of carbide in an undissolved state. Following that heating, the steel is cooled at a rate such that the small particles of retained carbide which are undissolved in the austenite serve as nucle:i for the growth of upper transformation products, notably including pearlite and blocky ferrite as well as fine spheroids of iron carbide. It has been found that carbides thus formed on cooling are characterized by particle sizes which are much finer than those formed during furnace annealing, with the result that the refined microstructure of the annealed steel provides improved ductility, formability and toughness when compared to steel subjected to furnace annealing.

The concepts of the present invention are applicable to the processing of hypoeutectoid steels having a carbon content ranging up to 0.7% by weight, and preferably containing between 0.1 to 0.7% carbon by weight. Such steels may contain relatively small quantities of the common alloying elements such as chromium, molybdenu~, nickel and manganese. By a widely used convention, a steel containing less than 5% by weight of such alloying elements is referred to in the art as a "low alloy steel".
Representative hypoeutectoid steels which can be used in accordance with the present invention are shown in the following table:

- ~I r ~ 15~3 ~ o U , ~1 I ~ ~t~t ~ ~t ~r ~1 ¢ O o oo o o o ~ o O o oo o o O I O
u~ oo OCO O
O ~ ~ l ~ O O ~
o o o o o o o o o 1~ C~ ~oC~ o~ ~ o Ln C~
I o oo ~ o o o o o æ ~ ~t ~ l o o O o oo o O O I O

U~
O o oo o o o o o U~ O o oo o o o ~ o ~ .
I O O O O O O O O ~
. I
~;
E~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~
P~ O o o o o o o o o O o o o o o o O o O ~ CS~
O ~i o o o o O ~1 0 ~ -I c~ ~1 ~t O ~t O
t ~ ~ ~t ~t ~ Lf) ~t C~
O o oo O o o o O

S~
~ J ~ C~ J o C~
t~S ~ ~ ~ l ~ O ~ ~O 1 O o o~ o o o O
~ ~ ~ ~~,~

- a~ c~lo o o oc~l o ~t O
~t ~t ~~t~ ~ u~
,~
~0 ~t~t ~t ~~D
C~ oO

Q) X

~lS~L3 In the preferred practice of this invention~ the steel is in the form of a workpiece which can be heated separately so that the heating process can be precisely controlled. For that purpose, it is frequently preferred to employ workpieces in a form having a repeating cross section such as bars, rods, tubes and the like.
In accordance with the preferred embodiment~ the individual workpieces are rapidly heated by direct electrical resistance heating or by electrical induction heating, preferably while the temperature of the workpiece is monitored by a suitable sensing device. The rapidity of the heating process, while permitting the economic processing of large quantities of workpieces, causes the austenitizing trans-formation to proceed very rapidly. The most preferred method for rapid heating in accordance with the present invention is by direct electrical resistance heating. That technique, described in detail by Jones et al, in United States Patent No. 3,90~,431 involves a procedure whereby an electri-cal current is passed through the steel workpiece; the electri-cal resistance of the workpiece to the flow of electrical cur-rent causes rapid heating of the workpiece uniformly throughout its entire cross section.
In heating according to the technique of Jones et al., the workpiece is connected to a source of electrlcal current, with the connection being made at both ends of the workpiece so t~at the current flows completely through the workpiece. Because of the uniform flow of the current through the workpiece, the temperature of the workpiece, r~s r ~5~S~

usually in the form of a bar or rod, increases uniformly, both axially and radially. Thus, the interior as well as the exterior of the workpiece are heated simultaneously, without introducing thermal strains. In contrast, in a conventional furnace, the exterior of the furnace load is heated much more rapidly than the interior, with the result that the steel near the exterior of the load is completely transformed to austenite while the interior of the load may not have, at the same point in time, undergone transformation to austenite. Such furnace techniques thus involve a significant disadvantage since it is difficult, if not impossible, to control the rate of heating such that austenitic transformation along with dissolution of only part of the carbides is achieved. In other words, there is a tendency, when heating in a furnace, to dissolve all of the carbide, and hence fine particles of retained carbides are not available to serve as nuclei for the formation of the upper transformation products on cooling.

Ir the practice of this invention, the steel work~
piece is heated to a temperature above the A3 or upper transformation temperature at a very rapid rate, usually within the range of one second to ten minutes. The control of the heating step may be effected within relatively narrow limits by making use of the well-known endothermic character of austenite transformation. As is now well established, the temperature of the workpiece at the onset of austenitic transformation remains constant, or even decreases slightly for a period ranging from a few seconds to several minutes, depending somewhat on the heating rate. A typical heating curve for the austenitizing step used in the practice of s~

this invention is shown in Figure 1 of the drawing, which is a plot of temperature versus time for heat A of 4142 steel. (The chemistry for that particular heat is shown in Table 1, supra.) As can be seen from that figure, two steel workpieces were rapidly heated in less than five minutes to austenitizing temperatures of 1412F for sample (1) and 1550F for sample (2). The heating curve indicates that carbide dissolution is taking place when the rate of temperature increase remains constant, that is at the so-called heating arrest point. Care must be taken when that point is reached to insure that all of the carbides do not dissolve in the austenite thus formed. It is an important concept of this invention that sufficient quantities of carbide be retained in undissolved state to serve as nuclei for precipitation of the upper transformation products on cooling of the workpiece.

Thus, heating to the austenitization temperature is continued for a short time above the heating arrest point.
During this time, austenitization of most of the structure is completed, and the structure which exists at the point of maximum temperature consists essentially of austenite and undissolved carbide particles. Following the austeni-tizing, the workpieces are allowed to air cool at their own rate.

As shown in Figure 1, the steels exhibit a cooling arrest (1220F for sample (1) and 880F for sample (2)) at which point precipitation of transformation products begins.

3L5~3 The cooling arrest point is thus determined by the austenitizing temperature employed. In the case of sample (1), the austenitizing temperature was such that the sample cooled to for~ upper transformation products, while sample (2), austenitized at the higher temperature, cooled to form lower transformation products.

The complete data on this phenomenon is shown in the following table:

~L~EC~NICAL PROPERTIES OF 4142 -AUSTENITIZED AND AIR COOLED SPECI~ENS
. . _ . . _ SPECIMEN Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
-~~ (~hn) (ksi)- (ksi) As Received Steel 311 153.0 77.3 14.1 37.2 Austenitized at 1412F (Time: 212 110.4 63.9 24.0 59.7 3 min.-36 sec.) Austenitized at 1430F (Time: 235 127.1 70.4 18.5 41.6 3 min.-58 sec.) Austenitized at 1480F (Time: 266 135.2 74.3 17.9 40.2 4 min.-26 sec.) Austenitized at 1550F (Time: 2~2 147.3 95.9 16.1 42.2 5 min.-2 sec.) The data show that the hardness of the steel increased (accompanied by a decrease in ductility) as the austenitizing temperature increased.

The foregoing data demonstrate that accelerated annealing in accordance with the present invention is dependent on austenitization temperature. If the temperature is too high, all of the carbide dissolves, and hence no nuclei ~515~3 are available to accelerate the rate of precipitation of upper transformation products.

It has also been found tha-t time affects the annealing process of this invention as well, with longer heatin~ ~i~es resuLting in ~3s~u~an ~ al? o th~ c~rbi~
particles present. This effect is shown in Figure 2, which is another plot of temperature versus time for a series of samples held for varying lengths of time prior to air cooling. (The heating and cooling portions of this curve have been cut off at 1100F so that only the temperature where upper transformation products form are shown. The hardness values for each sample are also shown in the graph.) As shown in Figure 2, as the time at which the various samples are held at the austenitizing temperature is increased, the cooling arrest point decreases; as a result, there is a tendency for lower transformation products to form instead of the upper transformation products in accordance with the practice of this invention. Thus, the hardness values increase as the austenitizing time increased.
Indeed, after 12 minutes at the austenitizing temperature, there is no cooling arrest within the temperature range shown in Figure 2, and the hardest air-cooled specimens are produced.

The :Eoregoing tests with 4142 specimens demonstrated that the accelerated annealing phenomenon of this invention is dependent upon both austenitizing temperature and austenitizing time. To demonstrate how the accelerated annealing phenomenon occurs, the microstructures of the steel prior to austenitization, at the austenitizing temperature, ~515~L3 and after air cooling, were e~amined. The as received structure and the air cooled structure could be examined using standard metallographic techniques. To observe the condition of the austenite at the austenitizing temperature, a classical metallurgical quenching technique was used. A
specimen from Heat A was rapidly heated to 1415F and quenched in agitated water. The parts of the structure tha-t were austenite prior to the quench were converted to martensite.
Consequently, the austenitized structure could be observed at room temperature with standard metallographic techniques by using an etchant thaL would not reveal the martensite.

Figures 3A, 3B and 3C show the as received structure, the austenitized-quenched structure, and the austenitized-air cooled structure of samples from Heat A. The scanning electron microscope (SE~I) was used for these photomicrographs due to the fine nature of these structures.

This technique clearly revealed the structure o~
the steel beforç austenitizing, at the austenitizing temperature and after air cooling.

It can be clearly seen from these photomicrographs that the as received structure (before processing) was austenitized during the rapid heating cycle, but some particles of carbide remained undissolved in the austenite.
Since nuclei already existed in the austenitized structure, there was no time required at the annealing temperature for nucleation oE upper transformation products. The retained carbide particles simply began to grow as the temperature dropped below the Al temperature, and eventually pearlite began to ~15~3 grow from the carbide nuclei. Consequently, the time required to anneal the steel was shortened considerably. Several other grades of steel were tested in a similar manner, and, in each case, it was discovered that the austenitized structure consisted of austenite with fine spheroidal carbides. This retention of carbide in the austenitized structure due to rapid heating is believed to be the basis of the accelerated annealing phenomenon of this invention.

The retention of carbide in the austenitized structure of steel has been noted in the literature. However, with slower heating, the amount of carbide retained in the austenitized structure is small. Consequently, a steel which is slowly heated to the austenitizing temperature is less likely to display the accelerated annealing phenomenon.
Comparison tests with furnace austenitizing treatments and rapid austenitizing treatments revealed that the accelerated annealing phenomenon did not occur with furnace treatments.

In one of these tests, bars of 8640 from Heat B
were austenitized at various temperatures in a furnace and allowed to air cool. Then another set of bars from the same heat was austenitized with electric resistance heating and allowed to air cool. The mechanical properties which resulted from this treatment are sho~ in Figure 4. All of the furnace treated specimens cooled to a relatively high hardness. However, the rapidly heated specimens show a noti-ceable transition between hard and soft air cooled specimens. Table 3 shows the mechanical properties of one set of specimens from this test. The furnace austenitized specimen had mechanical properties very similar to those of -16- .

~ ~ 5~ S~ ~

the as received steel while the rapidly austenitized specimen was significantly softer. It is clear from that data that 8640 responded to the rapid austenitization in the same manner as the 4142 had responded. However, the accelerated annealing phenomenon is more apparent in ~640 because ~his steel has lower hardenability than 4142.

.~CH~ICAL PROPERTIES OF 8640 -AUSTE~ITI~ED AND AIR COOLED SPECIMENS

S~ECI~iE~ Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
(Bhn) ~ksi) (ksi) As Received 8640 256 132.7 94.3 15.1 39.1 Furnace Austenitized at 1500F, Air 254 132.1 96.2 15.5 47.0 Cooled (Time: 1 ltr~) Rapidly Austenitized at 1500F, Air 205 111.1 71.1 20.0 50.3 Cooled (Time: 4 min.) The tests demonstrate that the accelerated annealing phenomenon is sensitive to austenitizing temperature because the specimens which were rapidly austenitized above 1550F
did not self-anneal. These tests also demonstrate that the accelerated annealing phenomenon is dependent upon austenitizing time as well because none of the furnace austenitized specimens annealed during air cooling regardless of the austenitizing temperature. Furnace treatments are simply too slow to permit the accelerated annealing phenomenon to occur. The relatively long time at the austenitizing temperature permits the retained carbide to be dissolved or reduced in size to the point where there is not enough carbide left to be effective as nuclei for carbide growth during cooling.

r ~ 5~ 3 In accordance with one variation in the prac~ice of this invention, it is sometimes desirable to insure uniformity in cooling rates in large batches of workpieces being processed. If, for example, steel bars were simply heated and piled in a rack to cool, the first bar might cool at a much faster rate than the last, and hence lack of uniformity withln a batch of steel processed at one time might develop. Accordingly, to avoid lack of uniformity of batches, use can be made of an insulated cooling queue of the sort illustrated in Figure 5 of the drawing. When using this type of equipment, it is possible to pass bars through the queue with a dwell or residence time of, for example, lO minutes. No external source of heat need be used in equipment of that type,and hence no energy is consumed.
Tests with respect to uniformity of mechanical properties have demonstrated that the insula~ed cooling queue is effective.

Having described the basic concepts of the present invention, reference is now made to the following examples, which are provided by way of illustration and not by way of limitation, of the practice of the present invention in the annealing of steel bars having a length of 7 feet. In each example, the steel was examined in three conditions, namely as received or prior to any treatment, after furnace annealing, and after annealing by the process of this-invention, with comparisons having been made between the furnace annealed steel and steel annealed by way of this invention.

EX~PEE 1 This example illustrates the annealing of a 4140 r ~5~S1L3 steel from heat C as shown in Table 1.

Twenty bars of 4140 from Heat C were furnace annealed using a roller hearth :Eurnace. The furnace austenitizing temperature was 1550F, and the annealing cvcle was a total of 16 hours long.

Twenty bars from the same heat were also annealed by the process of this invention. Tlte austenitizing temperature was 1450F, and each bar was austenitized in 33 seconds. The total annealing time for all 20 bars was less than one hour.

Both lots of steel were cleaned, cold drawn and straightened after annealing. Then the two lots were e~tensively tested, and the steel that remained after testing was used for a machinability test. Table 4 shows the mechanical properties of the steel used in these tests. The mechanical properties of the as received steel and`the as annealed steel are sho~t for comparison purposes.

The steel annealed by the process of this invention has a better combination of properties than the furnace annealed steel. The hardness of the steel annealed by the present process is slightly higher, but the significant difference between the two products is the improved ductility of the steel annealed by the process of the invention. The elongation was 13.3% for the furnace annealed steel after complete processing, and the elongation for the steel annealed by this process was 17.0%. This is an improvement of 28%.
The reduction of area for the furnace annealed steel was 39.0% and the reduction of area for the steel annealed by the ~ 1513 ~resen~ 2rocess ~as ,9.~/O~ T;~is is an i~rovement oi 52%.
The elongation and reduction of area are a basis for estimating tl~e ductility of a steel, and these improvements over the furnace annealed steel indicate a dramatic i~provement in ductility and formability.

?.`IEC~ ICAL PROPE~TIES OF Ll 40 - HEAT C
Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
SPECI.EI~ (Bhn) (ksi)(ksi) As ~eceived 4140315 151.0120.5 13.0 39. 4 Furnace ~nnealed197 99.746 . 6 21.5 40 . 8 Annealed by the Present Process 217 108.058.7 23.5 60.9 Furnace Annealed `~
& Cold Drawn 226 111.581.2 13.3 39.0 Annealed by the Present Process & Cold Drat~n 23~ 119.493.9 17.0 59.3 The reason for the improved ductility of the product annealed by the present process can be clearly seen in the microstructure of these steel samples. Figures 6A, 6B, and 6C show the microstructures of samples from this heat of 4140 in three conditions: as received, furnace annealed, and annealed by the process. The as received structure consists of lower transformation products: upper bainite and acicular ferrite.
The furnace annealed structure consists of pearlite and ferrite.
The steel annealed by the present process has a structure which consists essentially of ferrite, pearlite and fine carbide spheroids. Ferrite areas are not distinct, and the ferrite contains spheroidal carbides. Also, the grain size is finer for the steel annealed by the present process. It is the fine nature of this structure which gives the steel its improved ductility and formability over the coarse furnace annealed structure.

5~L;3 The fine microstructure also gives the annealed product improved toughness. Figure 7 shows the Charpy impact curves for bars taken from the two lots of annealed steel. The steel annealed by the present process has a lower transitlon ,emperature, and an upper shelf energy which is almost three times that of the furnace annealed steel. Improved toughness is valuable for applications where the par~ is machined or formed, and then only surface hardened. In such applications, improved core toughness would give the part higher resistance to rracture.

To demonstrate that the improved toughness and ductility of steel annealed by the instant process did not adversely affect its machinability as compared to that of furnace annealed steel, a comprehensive machinability test was carried out. The screw machine test was selected because it tests the machinability of the steel with several different types of tools. Figure 8 shows the results of machinability testing of the two annealed lots of 4140 from Heat C. ln this type of test> part growth is ~easured and plotted against time or the number of parts produced. Steels which machine well have part growth curves which are relatively flat and near the time axis. Steels which machine poorly have curves which have steep slopes.
The part growth curves shown in Figure 8 indicate that the two annealed steels machined about the same. The steel annealed by the present process was slightly better than the furnace amlealed steel, but the difference is not considered significant.

- r ~

~5:L5~;~

This example illustrates the annealing at a 4140 steel from neat D.

~ Jenty bars from Heat D were furnace annealed using a 16 hour cycle with an austenitization temperature of 1550F.
Then 20 additional bars from the same heat were annealed by the present process. For this treatment each bar was austenitized at 1500F in approximately 36 seconds, and the entire lot was annealed in less than one hour.

Both lots were then descaled, cold drawn and straightened.
Extensive testing was conducted on each lot, and the steel -that remained after this testing was used for a machinability test. The mechanical properties of the as received steel, the furnace annealed steel and the steel annealed by the new process are shown in Table 5. Once again, the steel annealed by the present process had greater ductility and was slightly harder than the furnace annealed steel. Figures 9A, 9B and gC show the microstructure of this heat of steel in three conditions: as received, furnace annealed, and annealed by the present invention, respectively. Just as before, the steel annealed by the present process has a microstructure which is much finer than the furnace annealed steel.

~ECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF 4140 ~ HEAT D
. _ .... .. . . _ SPECI~EN Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
~E~- (ksi)--- (ksi~ (%) ~
As Received 4140 311 151.4 109.6 13.3 41.9 Furnace Annealed and Cold Drawn 231 119.1 lQ2.312.1 42.8 Annealed by the Present Process and Cold Drawn 241 127.4 105.913.8 53.1 .'' - . :

r ~r ~L~S~LS13 Figure 10 shows the Charpy impact curves for the furnace annealed steel and -the steel annealed by the present process. The superiority of the steel annealed by the present ?rocess is again obvious. The transition temperature is lower and the upper shelf energy is higher for the steel annealed by ~he present process.

Machinability testing of the two annealed lots of steel was accomplished using a Modified Taylor Life test.
In this type of machinability test, the bar is turned at various speeds and feeds until the machining tool fails. Then the data points representing the time to failure at various speeds are plotted on log-log paper. The result is a straight line which represents the relationship between machining speed and time to tool failure. Figure 11 shows the results of this type of machinability testing on the two annealed lots produced from Heat D. The two lines cross, indicating that there is some difference between the way these two annealed steels machined. However, at the lower machining speeds, where alloy steels are usually machined, the steel annealed by the present process is slightly better. ~nce again, even though the steel annealed by the present process was harder, tougher, and more ductile, it machined better than the furnace annealed steel. These differences in ductility, toughness and machinability are in the aggregate, a significant inprovement in the mechanical properties of this steel.

Ten bars of 4140 steel from Heat E were furnace annealed using a 16 hour cycle with an austenitization temperature of 1550F. Then ten bars from the same heat were ~ ~ 5~ ~3 annealed by the present process using an austenitization temperature of 1450F. The bars were each austenitized in 35 seconds, and the entire annealing cycle was 45 minutes long. Table 6 shows the results of this processing. The specimens made in this test were not cold drawn after annealing. This heat responded to annealing by the present process almost exactly as the other heats had responded.
The superior ductility of the steel annealed by the process of this invention is apparent from the data in Table 6.

~ECHA~ICAL PROPERTIES OF 4140 - HEAT E

SPECI~EN Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
(Bhn) (ksi) (ksi) (%) (%) As Received 4140 269 141.6 99.2 15.7 50.2 Furnace Annealed Steel 186 103.7 49.6 19.7 42.6 Annealed by the process of this invention 194 104.5 97.1 24.6 60.5 EXA~PLE 4 15 bars of 4142 from Heat F were annealed using a furnace. The austenitizing temperature for the furnace treatment was 1550~F and the cycle was 16 hours long. Then 15 more bars from the same heat were annealed by the process of this invention. An austenitizing temperature of 1450F
was used, and each bar was austenitized in 60 seconds. The entire cycle was less than one hour long. Table 7 shows the mechanical properties of the steel in three conditions: as received, furnace annealed, and annealed by the process of ~51513 this invention. ~nce again, the steel annealed by the present process had superior ductility as compared to that of the furnace annealed steel.

SPECI~IEN Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
(Bhn) (~si) (ksi)~ /O) As received 4142 268 141.0 99.115.5 46.5 Furnace Annealed Steel 194 101.8 50.3 20.846.6 Annealed by the present process196 102.3 66.2 25.068.3 EXA~lPLE 5 Ten bars of 8640 from Heat ~ were annealed using the roller hearth furnace. The furnace austenitizing temper-ature was 1550F and the furnace cycle was a total of 16 hours.
Then ten bars from the same heat were annealed using the p.esent process. The austenitizing temperature was 1450F, and each bar was austenitized in 35 seconds. The total annealing cycle with the process of this invention was approximately 30 minutes. Table 8 shows the mechanical properties of the steel in three conditions: as received, furnace annealed and annealed by the instant process. Once again, the steel annealed by the process of this invention had significantly better ductility than the furnace annealed steel.

f ~5~s~ 3 ~EC~NICAL PROP~RTIES OF 8640 - HEAT B

SPECI~`~N Hardness Tensile Yield EL 7~A
(Bhn)~ksi) (ksi~ (%~ (~/o) As P~eceived 8640 258 132.1 102.8 16.7 46.9 Fu~nace .~nnea~ed Steel 176 98.9 49.3 22.8 47.0 Ar.nealed by the ?resent process180 9~.9 60.4 28.1 64.6 The microstructures of the as received steel, the furnace annealed steel, and the steel annealed by the process of this invention are shown in Figures 12A, 12B and 12C. The steel annealed by the present process had a more spheroidal st-ucture than the furnace annealed steel, and it was somewhat finer. This difference in microstructure is similar to what was observed in the 4140 tests. The 8640 was also tested for toughness using the Charpy impact test. The results of impact testing of the two annealed lots is shown in Figure 13.
Once again the steel annealed by the present process had far su?erior toughness. (It should be noted that the annealed ~6~0 was not cold drawn prior to testing. Consequently, it was some~.7hat softer and tougher than the 4140 heats that were mentioned earlier.) EX.~PLE 6 Twenty bars of 6150 from Heat G were annealed using a roller hearth furnace. The furnace austenitizing temperature was 1550F and the cycle was 16 hours.

Then twenty bars from the same heat were annealed with the process of this invention using an austenitizing ~515~L3 te~perature of 1500F. Each bar was austenitized in 34 seconds, and the total annealing time was approximately one hour. Table 9 shows the mechanical properties of the as received steel, furnace annealed steel, and steel annealed by the present process.

The two annealed lots were then cold drawn and straightened to duplicate one type of typical commercial processing. The cold drawn and straightened properties are also given in Table 9. For this particular grade, the steel treated with the present process was slightly harder than the furnace annealed steel, but it was still more ductile.
This superior ductility is evident both before and after cold drawing.

SPECIMEN Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
(Bhn) (ksi) (ksi) ~ (%) As Received 6150 299151.0 111.6 12.0 37.8 Furnace Annealed Steel 195 100.853.0 20.7 44.1 Annealed by the present process 225 109.881.2 25.5 66.4 Furnace annealed cold dra~
straightened 240 120.486.0 9.6 3-l.3 Annealed by the present process cold drawn straightened 263 130.9103.8 13.0 48.3 The microstructures of the as received steel, the furnace annealed steel, and the steel annealed by the present ~5~L5~L3 process are shown in Figures 14A, 14B and 14C, respectively.
The steel annealed by the present process has a finer carbide structure than the furnace annealed steel. Charpy impact testing was also accomplished on the two annealed samples and the results are shown in Figure 15. The curves shown are for the 6150 after cold drawing. Once again the steel annealed by the present process had a finer microstructure, improved ductility and improved toughness as compared to the furnace annealed steel.

Several bars of 1144 from Heat H were furnace annealed using a five hour cycle. The austenitization temperature was 1550F for the furnace treatment.

Then five bars from the same heat were annealed using the present process. The austenitization temperature was 1450F and the annealing time for the five bars was 20 minutes. Each bar was austenitized in 30 seconds.

Table 10 shows the mechanical properties of the as received steel, the furnace annealed steel and the steel annealed by the process of the invention. In this case, the hardness of the steel annealed by the present process was very near that of the furnace annealed steel. As with the previous examples, the steel annealed by the present process has superior ductility. Figures 16A, 16B and 16C
show the microstructure of this steel in three conditions:
as received, furnace annealed, and annealed by the present process, respectively.

S~L3 `i~ECI~NICAL PROPERTIES OF 1144 - HEAT H
-S.~'IPLE Hardness Tensile Yield EL RA
~n) ~ksi)- (ksi~ (~,') (v/O) As Received Steel Hot Rolled l144 190 99.0 60.9 19.5 41.4 Furnace Annealed 162 ~9.5 51.3 23.1 41.1 ~nnealed by the present process 165 89.1 57.4 25.0 48.5 EXA~PLE ~

Several bars of 86L20 from Heat I were furnace annealed using a five hour cycle. The austenitizing temperature used for the furnace anneal was 1625F.

Then 15 bars from the same heat were annealed using the present annealing process. The austenitizing temperature used was 1600F, and each bar was austenitized in 31 seconds.
The total annealing cycle was 47 minutes.

Table 11 shows the mechanical properties of the as received steel, the furnace annealed steel, and the steel annealed by the present process. For this grade of steel, the improvement in ductility for the steel annealed by the present process is relatively small. Also, the hardness of the steel annealed by the present process was rather high.
The reason for these differences is clear from the photo-micrographs of the structures of this heat of ste~l (Figures 17A, 17B and 17C). The grain size of the steel annealed by the present process is much finer tnan the grain size of the ~l151513 furnace annealed steel. In a low carbon steel like 86L20, the fine grain si~e which results from the new annealing process is the dominant factor. There is not enou~h carbon in the steel 'or the carbides to play a dominant role, and the grain si7e effect makes the steel annealed by the present ~rocess so~ewhat harder than the furnace annealed product. Consequently, only marginal impovements in ductility were achieved with the present annealing process.

~ECH~iICAL PROPE~TIES OF 86L20 - HEAT I

S~IPLE Hardness Tensile Yield EL P~A
(~hn) (ksi) (ksi) ~ (%) As Received 86L20 172 83.2 53.3 25.2 62.4 Furnace Annealed 141 74.9 49.5 29.7 62.1 Annealed by tne present process 160 81.9 60.1 30.0 65.2 The foregoing examples demonstrate that the present annealing process is applicable to a wide variety of carbon and alloy steels. Each grade that was tested responded to the present annealing process in about the same way. For each alloy, a finer carbide morphology was produced which gave the steel improved ductility, formability and toughness.
It is important to note that these improved properties were achieved with no loss of strength or loss of machinability.
This combinaLion of improved ductility, formability and toughness with no loss of machinability is an unexpected phenomenon. Usually when ductility and toughness increase at a given harclness level, the machinability decreases.
However, the new annealing process creates a structure which does not follow this general trend.

r r ~5~5~3 It will be apparent from the foregoing that the present invention provides a significant improvement in the annealing of hypoeutectoid steel. It affords improved energy efficiency through the use of direct electrical resistance heating, and,at the same time, eliminates the need for long controlled cooling cycles of the sort that have been required in the furnace annealing of steels. In addition, the process of this invention eliminates the need for protective or non-oxidizing atmospheres of the sort required with furnace annealing procedures heretofore used by the prior art.

It will be apparent that various changes and modifications can be made in the procedures of carrying out the present invention as well as the equipment employed without departing from the spirit of the invention, especially as defined in the foIlowing claims.

Claims (16)

C L A I M S
1. A process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) rapidly heating a hypoeutectoid steel to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the rate of heating being such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite, leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbide in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper transformation products and form an annealed steel having improved ductility, formability and toughness.
2. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the hypoeutectoid steel contains up to 0.7% carbon by weight.
3. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the steel contains between 0.1 to 0.7% carbon by weight.
4. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the steel contains less than 5% by weight of an alloying element.
5. A process as defined in claim 4 wherein the alloying element is selected from the group consisting of chromium, molybdenum, nickel, manganese and combinations thereof.
6. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the steel is heated to the upper transformation temperature in less than ten minutes.
7. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the steel is heated by direct electrical resistance heating.
8. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the steel is in the form of a workpiece having a repeating cross section.
9. A process as defined in claim 1 wherein the heating of the steel takes place in the absence of an inert atmosphere.
10. A process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) heating a hypoeutectoid steel to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the rate of heating being less than ten minutes to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite while leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbide present in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the steel at a rate sufficient to precipitate upper transformation products and form an annealed steel having improved ductility, formability and toughness.
11. A process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) heating a hypoeutectoid steel uniformly across its cross section to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the rate of heating being such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite, leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbides to serve as nuclei for the preci-pitation of upper transformation products, and, (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper transformation products.
12. A thermally efficient process for the annealing of steel comprising the steps of:
(a) heating a hypoeutectoid steel by passing an electrical current through the steel to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to form austenite and carbides, with the heating taking place in less than ten minutes to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite, leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbide present in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper transformation products.
13. A process as defined in claim 12 wherein the steel is air cooled.
14. A process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) rapidly heating a hypoeutectoid steel containing ferrite and carbides to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to convert the ferrite to austenite, with the rate of heating being such as to cause dissolution of most of the carbides in the austenite thus formed while leaving in undissolved form small particles of carbide present in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper transformation products and form an annealed steel.
15. A process as defined in claim 14 wherein the annealed steel contains pearlite, ferrite and spheroidal carbides.
16. A process for annealing steel comprising the steps of:
(a) rapidly heating a hypoeutectoid steel containing ferrite and carbides to a temperature above the upper transformation temperature of the steel to convert the ferrite to austenite, with the heating being carried out at a rate to form small particles of carbide dissolved in austenite whereby the carbides are present in an amount sufficient to serve as nuclei for the precipitation of upper transformation products, and (b) cooling the steel to precipitate said upper transformation products.
CA000364167A 1979-11-09 1980-11-06 Process for annealing steels Expired CA1151513A (en)

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US9300779A 1979-11-09 1979-11-09
US93,007 1979-11-09

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CA1151513A true CA1151513A (en) 1983-08-09

Family

ID=22236273

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CA000364167A Expired CA1151513A (en) 1979-11-09 1980-11-06 Process for annealing steels

Country Status (14)

Country Link
JP (1) JPS56139618A (en)
AU (1) AU537333B2 (en)
BE (1) BE886095A (en)
BR (1) BR8007075A (en)
CA (1) CA1151513A (en)
CH (1) CH649313A5 (en)
DE (1) DE3042067A1 (en)
DK (1) DK154229C (en)
ES (1) ES8202867A1 (en)
FR (1) FR2469460A1 (en)
GB (1) GB2066850B (en)
IT (1) IT1134136B (en)
MX (1) MX154795A (en)
SE (1) SE449008B (en)

Families Citing this family (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US4673433A (en) * 1986-05-28 1987-06-16 Uddeholm Tooling Aktiebolag Low-alloy steel material, die blocks and other heavy forgings made thereof and a method to manufacture the material
DE102004023579B4 (en) * 2004-05-13 2014-04-03 GM Global Technology Operations LLC (n. d. Ges. d. Staates Delaware) Process for the heat treatment of a joining part made of high-strength steel

Family Cites Families (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US3692591A (en) * 1970-08-31 1972-09-19 United States Steel Corp Method for effecting the rapid heat-treatment of steel plate
SE396769B (en) * 1972-03-07 1977-10-03 Licencia Talalmanyokat QUICK HEAT TREATMENT OF STEEL
JPS4894618A (en) * 1972-03-15 1973-12-05
US4040872A (en) * 1976-04-16 1977-08-09 Lasalle Steel Company Process for strengthening of carbon steels

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
DK473080A (en) 1981-05-10
DK154229C (en) 1989-03-20
BE886095A (en) 1981-03-02
FR2469460A1 (en) 1981-05-22
AU537333B2 (en) 1984-06-21
JPS56139618A (en) 1981-10-31
GB2066850B (en) 1983-09-21
SE8007767L (en) 1981-05-10
SE449008B (en) 1987-03-30
MX154795A (en) 1987-12-15
DE3042067A1 (en) 1981-05-21
ES496654A0 (en) 1982-02-16
BR8007075A (en) 1981-05-12
IT1134136B (en) 1986-07-24
AU6351780A (en) 1981-05-14
FR2469460B1 (en) 1985-01-18
GB2066850A (en) 1981-07-15
DK154229B (en) 1988-10-24
CH649313A5 (en) 1985-05-15
ES8202867A1 (en) 1982-02-16
IT8025723A0 (en) 1980-10-31

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
EP0372465B1 (en) Method for manufacture of a metallic material having ultrafine grain structure
US3413166A (en) Fine grained steel and process for preparation thereof
US4457789A (en) Process for annealing steels
Wada et al. Effect of trace elements, molybdenum, and intercritical heat treatment on temper embrittlement of 2-1/4Cr-1 Mo steel
CA1092861A (en) Steels combining toughness and machinability
JPH05320749A (en) Production of ultrahigh strength steel
CA1151513A (en) Process for annealing steels
JPS6128742B2 (en)
US3502514A (en) Method of processing steel
USRE27505E (en) Method for producing ultrafine grained steel
CA2004336C (en) High strength non-magnetic alloy
JPH036981B2 (en)
JPH1025521A (en) Method to spheroidizing wire rod
JPS63161117A (en) Production of hot rolled steel products having high strength and high toughness
US3922181A (en) Thermal treatment of steel
RU2086667C1 (en) Method of treating aging austenite invar alloys
US3892602A (en) As-worked, heat treated cold-workable hypoeutectoid steel
JPH0576522B2 (en)
JPH0310046A (en) Fine-grained bainite steel
RU2020163C1 (en) Process of thermomechanical treatment of products of austenite steel
Pradhan Annealing of cold-rolled rephosphorized steels containing Si and Cb
Snape The effects of experimental rolling on microstructure and mechanical properties of a Ni-Cu-Cb steel
Jahazi The influence of thermomechanical treatment on the microstructure and mechanical properties of aisi 4130 steel
JPS61227129A (en) Manufacture of high strength steel having superior resistance to sulfide stress corrosion cracking
JPH04355A (en) Production of titanium alloy

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
MKEX Expiry