AU773425B2 - Methods for sedating and anaesthetising aquatic organisms - Google Patents

Description

AUSTRALIA

Patents Act COMPLETE SPECIFICATION

(ORIGINAL)

Class Int. Class Application Number: Lodged: Complete Specification Lodged: Accepted: Published: Priority Related Art: Name of Applicant: New Zealand Institute for Crop Food Research Limited Actual Inventor(s): Alistair Renfrew Jerrett Address for Service: PHILLIPS ORMONDE FITZPATRICK Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys 367 Collins Street Melbourne 3000 AUSTRALIA Invention Title: METHODS FOR SEDATING AND ANAESTHETISING AQUATIC ORGANISMS Our Ref: 668685 POF Code: 96334/283670 The following statement is a full description of this invention, including the best method of performing it known to applicant(s): la METHODS FOR SEDATING AND ANAESTHETISING AQUATIC ORGANISMS The present application is a divisional application from Australian patent application 18385/99 which in turn is a divisional of Australian patent application 13286/95, the entire disclosure of both applications is incorporated herein by reference.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION This invention relates to improved methods for sedating and/or anaesthetising aquatic organisms and to compositions for use in such methods.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION The practice of catching fish or other aquatic organisms usually involves the organisms undergoing some stress. The organisms commonly associate capture with predation and therefore struggle to escape immobilization. This struggle can have a major impact on the post-mortem quality of the tissue of the organism depending upon its duration and at the pre-mortem physical condition of the organism (Lowe, Ryder, Carragher, Wells, R.M.G. 1993: Flesh quality in snapper, Pagrus auratus, affected by capture stress. Journal of Food Science 58: 770-773).

In aquaculture, the cultured organisms are usually individually handled during their life cycle. With excitable fish species such as Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha), great care must be taken to ensure that the animals are not bruised, scaled or in any way disfigured or damaged during handling. A natural, undamaged appearance is often a critical factor in determining the final sale price of the fish.

To achieve optimum product quality during harvesting, the organisms must be maintained in a calm state. One approach which has been investigated is the use of anaesthetics during harvesting. Commonly used anaesthetics such as MS-222, 2-phenoxyethanol, benzocaine and more recently, the sedatives etomidate and metomidate (Kreiberg, H. 1992: Metomidate Sedation Minimises Handling Stress in Chinook Salmon. Bulletin of the Aquacultural Association of Canada 92-3: 52-54) have been used to minimise damage during handling but their potential residual toxicity to (or misuse by) humans prevents their use during harvesting.

W:\ciska~n speciesUDiv of 18385-99.doc -2- Non-toxic non-chemical anaesthesia has also been investigated. Commonly used nontoxic alternatives such as cold anaesthesia (Mittal, A.K. and Whitear, M. 1978: A note on cold anaesthesia of poikilotherms. Journal of Fish Biology: 519-520) or carbonic acid anaesthesia (Post, G. 1979: Carbonic Acid Anaesthesia for Aquatic Organisms. The Progressive Fish Culturist 41(3): 142-144) do induce anaesthesia but can also cause considerable trauma in the process. They are accordingly not appropriate for use in harvesting if the quality of the post-mortem flesh is to be maintained as near pre-mortem as is possible.

It is therefore apparent that a need exists for a readily available non-toxic anaesthetic suitable for use inter alia in the harvesting of aquatic organisms. The ideal chemical anaesthesia for harvesting would be cost-effective, have low irritant qualities and be suitable for use with animals intended for human consumption.

JP 46-23256 discloses a general class of aromatic compounds having the formula s'

R

where R' and R 2 are H, OH or an alkoxy group or R' and R 2 are the same lower alkylenedioxy group and R 3 is an alkenyl group. These compounds are disclosed as being effective as sedatives/anaesthetics for fish, with some compounds of the class being toxic and others non-toxic.

Two of the compounds covered by the general formula above are 4-allyl-2-methoxyphenol and 4-hydroxy-3-methoxy- 1-propenylbenzene which are known as eugenol and isoeugenol respectively. These compounds are non-toxic food grade additives which are approved for human consumption. They are however known irritants (Martindale, the Extra Pharmacopoeia, 29th Edition, Pharmaceutical Press, London) which means that they could be expected to be unsuitable for use as aquatic anaesthetics during harvesting due 3 to the tendency of irritants to induce the organisms to struggle, which in turn reduces post-mortem flesh quality.

JP 46-23256 discloses that eugenol and isoeugenol are effective as aquatic anaesthetics/sedatives at different concentrations. In particular, Table 1 of JP 46- 23256 teaches that eugenol is 100% effective as a fish anaesthetic/sedative at concentrations of 25 mg 1-1 (equivalent to ppm) or above, but totally ineffective at a concentration of 12.5 mg 1-1 and that isoeugenol is 100% effective at concentrations of or above 25 mg I' 1 partially effective at a concentration of 12.5 mg 1-1 and totally ineffective at a concentration of 6.25 mg 1-1.

It has now surprisingly been found by the applicants that both eugenol and isoeugenol are effective aquatic anaesthetics when employed at concentrations which are disclosed in IP 46-23256 as being totally ineffective. It has also been 15 found that at such concentrations the compounds are substantially non-irritants. It is upon these unexpected findings that the present invention is based.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of 20 anaesthetising a plurality of aquatic organisms comprising the step of contacting ~said organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, and wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg 1-1.

According to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of harvesting a plurality of aquatic organisms while substantially retaining their Y:\MarykKI NO DELETE MR\38264-02.doc 4 pre-mortem flesh quality, comprising the step of anaesthetising said organisms by contacting said organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, and wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg 1-'1.

According to a still further aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of transporting a plurality of live aquatic organisms comprising the steps of: anaesthetising said organisms to be transported by contacting the organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg 1'1; and transporting said organisms while anaesthetised.

:i 15 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING While the present invention is broadly defined above, it will of course be appreciated by those persons skilled in the art that it is not limited thereto but that it also includes embodiments of which the following description provides examples.

In addition, the invention will be better understood by reference to the accompanying Figure 1 which shows the response of king salmon to nominal concentrations of eugenol and isoeugenol.

Y:\M)arNKI NO DELETE MR\38264-02.doc DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION As summarised above, the present invention is based upon the applicants' surprising finding that the food grade additive isoeugenol can be utilised as aquatic sedatives and/or anaesthetics at concentrations which were previously thought to be totally ineffective. This finding has important consequences for the aquaculture industry, in terms of both the transporting and harvesting of aquatic organisms.

The aquatic organisms to which the methods of the present invention are applied are the so-called primary aquatic organisms which are cold blooded animals living in water and respiring dissolved oxygen. The methods of the present invention are preferably applied to very valuable high grade marketable organisms from an economic point of view. Examples of such organisms include those belonging to S.the class Pisces such as salmon, trout, char, ayu, carp, crucian carp, goldfish, 15 roach, whitebait, eel, conger eel, sardine, flying fish, sea bass, sea bream, parrot bass, snapper, mackerel, horse mackerel, tuna, bonito, yellowtail, rockfish, fluke, sole, flounder, blowfish, filefish, etc.; those belonging to the class Cephalopoda such as squid, cuttlefish, octopus, etc.; those belonging to the class Pelecypoda such as clam, scallop, ark shell, oyster, etc.; those belonging to the class 20 Gastropoda such as turban shell, abalone, etc.; and those belonging to the class Crustacea such as lobster, prawn, shrimp, crab, squilla, etc.

For use in the present invention, the active compound isoeugenol can be readily obtained from commercial sources. Alternatively, isoeugenol prepared from eugenol by heating with a caustic potash (West, J Soc Chem Ind, 59, 275 (1940)).

Y:\May\NK1 NO DELETE MR\38264-O2.do.

6 In the present invention, the active compound (isoeugenol) can be used in pure form or in a mixture. Such a mixture can be a suspension or emulsion of the active compound(s) in water or can be a mixture in which the active compound(s) are dissolved in an appropriate alcohol such as ethanol.

Alternatively, the active compound be used in the form of a composition which includes a surfactant as described below. Such, a composition is preferred.

Subject always to the upper limit of 12.5 mg 1, the amount of active compound employed in the methods of the invention may vary, depending on whether the active compound is eugenol or isoeugenol.

Where the compound employed is isoeugenol, it is preferred that the amount of isoeugenol used is from 1-10 mg 1-1, more preferably from 3-9 mg 1-1, most 15 preferably from 5-8.5 mg 11.

a 0 As stated above, it is the applicants preference that the active compound form part of an active composition which includes a surfactant. For use in the methods of the invention, this surfactant could in theory be any commercially available surfactant having suitable properties but is preferably polyethylene oxide sorbitan mono-oleate. The surfactant polyethylene oxide sorbitan mono-oleate is commercially available under the trade name Polysorbate 80, with it being particularly preferred that the form of Polysorbate 80 sold as Liposorb-0-20 (Lipochemicals, Inc., USA) be used.

Y:\MaryNK NO DELETE MR\38264-02.doc 7 The applicants have surprisingly found that the use of Liposorb-0-20 results in a composition having superior properties in terms of solubility in water and in terms of stability in aqueous solution over time as compared to compositions including other surfactants (such as Tween 60, Tween 65, Tween 80 and Span 80 (all ICI) and Triton X).

While various proportions of active compound and surfactant can be employed in forming the composition, it is presently preferred that each be included as 50% of the volume of the final composition. The most preferred composition is 50% by volume of isoeugenol.

**o 1 *2 Y:\MarlNKI NO DELETE MR\38264-02.doc -8- (Naarden International, Bussem, The Netherlands) and 50% by volume Liposorb-0-20 (Lipochemicals Inc, USA).

The invention will now be illustrated with reference to the following Examples.

EXAMPLE 1 MATERIALS AND METHODS Experimental animals Thirty-nine female king salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) with a mean wet weight of 365g 78) were used in this experiment. These animals were sampled from a tank population of 299 animals which had been reared indoors in a 28m 3 oval tank from smoltification. The rearing tank was supplied with filtered seawater on a flow-through basis with a typical turnover of one tank volume per 3.5 hours. Auxiliary aeration maintained the dissolved oxygen concentration typically between 85 to 95% of saturation.

The salmon were fed ad libitum a 3mm proprietary salmon diet (NRM New Zealand Ltd, Nelson, New Zealand) at a rate up to but not exceeding 2% of body weight per day. For two months prior to the experiment, the food had been distributed into the bubble stream of an air stone positioned immediately adjacent to the tank wall. This facilitated capture and reduced the likelihood of learned net avoidance behaviour.

Animal sampling and test conditions Each animal was caught in a shallow dip net as it came to the surface adjacent to the tank wall to feed. Once caught, each animal was transferred to an insulated 700 litre tank located within 1 metre of the rearing tank. A lid was then placed on the tank for 5 minutes to allow the fish to settle slightly before the anaesthetic doses were added.

Prior to each trial, the tank was thoroughly cleaned and rinsed with fresh water. It was then filled to a depth of 490mm with 500 251 of sand-filtered 34% seawater at a temperature of 14.4 0.5 0 C. Auxiliary aeration was used to ensure dissolved oxygen saturation at the beginning of each trial. A YSI Model 57 dissolved oxygen meter was used to confirm that dissolved oxygen concentrations remained above 90% saturation during each trial.

A Minolta CR-200B Chroma Meter was used to characterise the grey tank colour according to the L*a'b' International Colour System (CIE, 1976) as L* 55.4; a' 0/9 and b' 1.7. Light intensity (400 to 700nm) at the physical centre of the tank was measured using a Licor LI-1000 logger fitted with LI-192SA Underwater Quantum Sensor. The light intensity ranged between 1.2 and 2.3 umol s' m- 2 with the tank lid removed.

Dose-response trials Five fish were used in seven of the eight dose-response trials with the remaining trial using four (Figure la). For each trial eugenol (4-allyl-2-methoxyphenol) or isoeugenol (4-hydroxy-3-methoxy-l-propenylbenzene) were dissolved in 200 mis 99.7% ethanol to aid dispersion in seawater. Five trials were undertaken for eugenol with nominal concentrations of 25.0, 12.5, 8.0, 6.3 and 3.0 0.5 mg I-1 seawater. Three trials were undertaken for isoeugenol with nominal concentrations of 25.0, 8.0 and 3.0 0.5 mg 1-1 seawater. Experimental timing was initiated from the addition of the anaesthetic-ethanol mixture. Mixing of the anaesthetic-ethanol solution and the seawater was achieved by aeration. After 15 seconds mixing, the aeration was stopped to avoid accelerated airstripping of anaesthetics. Care was taken to disturb the fish as little as possible during the mixing procedure.

Dose-response criteria The responses of the fish to the nominal anaesthetic concentrations were judged against two criteria. The time taken from the addition of the anaesthetic dose to the point where the fish failed to avoid a hand placed in their path gave an empirical estimation of a sedative effect. Animals in this state could be removed from the water but would rouse themselves and slightly struggle if they were not returned to the water within 5 to seconds. Ventilation was often exaggerated and the fish would tend to swim slightly "nose up" near the tank surface. Fish in this stage were characterised as "handleable" for the purposes of this experiment.

The time taken from the addition of the anaesthetic dose to the point where the animals were insensible to forced extension of the operculum and contact with the gill lamellae 10 gave an indication of an anaesthetic effect. In this state the fish exhibited a loss of equilibrium but weak swimming motions were often present. Ventilation was often erratic and exaggerated at this stage. Fish that had not reached this state would respond within 30 seconds of contact with the gill lamellae with a reflexive "cough".

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION At all of the concentrations tested, the two anaesthetic formulations generated very similar patterns of behaviour when first introduced into the seawater. Some initial "coughing" was observed and was particularly pronounced with the higher concentrations indicating a transitory period of gill irritation in some of the animals.

In both anaesthetic formulations, increasing sedation was characterised by a slight increase in swimming speed, moderate ventilation and a progressive decrease in the distance at which the tank walls and water surface were perceived. At the point of "handleability", the animals were often unaware of the tank walls until contact was made.

A loud noise could elicit a transient startle response at this level of sedation.

Progression from the point of "handleability" to the loss of the "coughing" reflex is characterised by a progressive loss of equilibrium and effective swimming motions. The fish were insensitive to loud noises and physical restraint. The erratic ventilation observed at this stage slowed and eventually ceased as anaesthesia deepened leaving the fish inert and apparently unresponsive to physical stimuli.

Where the two formulations differ is in the nominal concentration and rate at which the abolition of the "coughing" reflex occurs. Figures l(a) and illustrate this result. There appears to be no effective or statistical difference between the formulations at a' nominal concentration of 25 mg (t-test, P<0.05). At a nominal concentration of 8.0 mg I 1 1 the mean time to elimination of the "coughing" reflex was approximately 2.5 times shorter for the isoeugenol formulation. At 3.0 rrg 1" 1 the eugenol formulation did not produce sufficient depth of anaesthesia to depress the "cough" reflex however the sedated, "handleable", state was easily achieved. At 3.0 mg 1- 1 nominal concentration isoeugenol produced a loss of equilibrium and weak ineffectual swimming motions but did not 11produce full suppression of the "cough" reflex. Eugenol produced a similar effect at a nominal concentration of 6.3 mg 1 The reason for the apparent differences in activity between the two formulations is likely to be attributable to differences in the solubility of the active ingredients. In practice, there appears to be little gained from nominal dosages above 12.5 mg 1 for eugenol and approximately 8.0 mg 1I' for isoeugenol.

General observations in relation to recovering from the anaesthetics suggest that recovery is rapid when the fish are placed in clean, well aerated water. Typically, when anaesthetized using low to medium concentrations to the point of suppression of the "coughing" reflex, the fish will regain orientation and coordinated swimming within approximately 5 to 15 minutes. In one incidence, approximately 171 (mean weight 578g) king salmon resumed apparently normal feeding within approximately two hours of exposure to 8 mg isoeugenol for approximately 10 to 30 minutes (Jerrett, Holland and Cleaver, unpublished results).

EXAMPLE 2 This example reports the applicants observations when 50% by volume isoeugenol is admixed with 50% by volume of various surfactants.

ICI Tween Very viscous solution which solidifies in cold weather (below about 15 0 Gentle heating will liquefy the solid material, ie. placing the container in a water bath Surfactant mixes well with isoeugenol but will solidify again if mixing does not take place quickly. Generally forms the composition as a very viscous mixture. Forms a cloudy white solution in water. A white precipitate forms after 10 minutes and by 20 minutes an emulsion has formed on the bottom of the container with some formation of isoeugenol globules. Will resuspend on shaking.

12 ICI Tween Solid needing direct heating, ie. on a hot plate to liquefy. Mixes well with isoeugenol but does need to be mixed quickly to stop the surfactant solidifying. Forms the composition as a very viscous solution. Mixes with water to form a cloudy solution but does not appear to mix totally. Separation takes place almost immediately. Globules formed on the sides of the bottle. Separates out into two distinct layers, one yellow (isoeugenol) and the other a white precipitate formed after two minutes. Isoeugenol globules form at the top and the bottom of the solution. Some resuspension will occur with prolonged shaking.

ICI Tween Isoeugenol and Tween 80 do not mix together easily. Will eventually (10 mins) blend with gentle mixing. Mixes well on addition to water. After 5 minutes precipitate forms.

Some emulsion formed at ten minutes. Will resuspend with a good shake although some globules appear to be left on the side of the container.

ICI Span Mixes well with isoeugenol but separates out immediately on addition to water.

Triton X Solid at room temperature. When melted mixes well with isoeugenol and immediately forms a cloudy solution. Mixes well on addition to water. Separation occurs as very fine precipitate within 10 minutes. Isoeugenol globules formed after 3 hours. Appeared after hours that both the surfactant and isoeugenol had separated out. Resuspension will occur but some globules are left on the side of the container.

Liposorb-0-20 Surfactant is less viscous and mixes relatively easily with isoeugenol. Will mix with a good shake.

Mixture goes into solution well on addition to water. No deposit is left on the side of the bottle. A fine precipitate is formed on the bottom of the container after about 13 minutes but this resuspends very easily once disturbed. Three hours before any emulsion is seen on the bottom of the flask. It appeared the isoeugenol did not separate out from the surfactant even when the mixture was left overnight. Total resuspension occurred on shaking.

It can therefore be seen that Liposorb-0-20 confers superior properties upon the ultimate composition in terms of mixability, solubility in water and stability. These advantages are surprising given that Tween 80 (also a polysorbate 80) is not nearly so effective.

EXAMPLE 3 This example demonstrates the effect of the applicants preferred composition (50% by volume isoeugenol and 50% by volume Lipsorb-0-20) on a range of aquatic organisms.

In this example, the composition is referred to as AQUI-S and the amount of isoeugenol with which the organisms are contacted is one-half of the AQUI-S dosage.

Rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) Dosage Temperature Time for sedation Time for anaesthesia Recovery 17mg 1- 1 AQUI-S (8.5 mg 1- 1 isoeugenol) 12.5 0

C

12 to 16 minutes 30 to 40 minutes. More mature fish were the ones that took longer.

Similar to salmon, as reported in Example 1.

(ii) Rock Lobster (Jasus edwardsii) Dosage Temperature pH Dissolved Oxygen Salinity Reaction to Introduction Time to Sedation Time to anaesthesia 17 mg 1- 1 AQUI-S (8.5 mg 1- 1 isoeugenol) 5.6 0

C

8.2 Saturated 32.84 No apparent awareness Juvenile 8 to 10 minutes Adult 10 to 12 minutes Juvenile 12 to 15 minutes Adult 15 to 20 minutes Equilibrium regained and walking/swimming motions regained within 5 minutes of introduction to fresh water. Tail curl was noticeable after 15 minutes of introduction to fresh water. Lobster still remained calm with no avoidance of handling for a further Recovery 14 minutes. At about 1 hour after being removed from the anaesthetic the aggressive behaviour was returning. Examination the next day showed full regaining of aggressive behaviour. Adults and juveniles responded in a similar fashion.

Sedation in this case is defined as the point at which equilibrium is lost and there is no aggression to being handled although the animal is definitely still aware of being handled.

Anaesthesia is defined as reaction from the animal.

reflexive curling in of the fully extended.

the point at which the lobster can be handled with no In this state, the tail fans are spread out and there is no tail. When the animal is placed on its back the tail is (iii) Paua (Haliotis iris) Dosage Temperature pH Dissolved Oxygen Salinity Reaction to Introduction Time to Sedation Time to anaesthesia 17 mg AQUI-S (8.5 mg 1-1 isoeugenol) 5.6 0

C

8.2 Saturated 32.84 Awareness of substance but no apparent adverse reaction. ie. no avoidance.

Juvenile 8 to 10 minutes Adult 13 to 20 minutes Juvenile 12 Adult 30 minutes Appeared to be fully recovered by 6 to minutes after removal from the anaesthetic.

Recovery Sedation in this case is defined as the point at which the animal is very slow to right itself after being placed on its back.

Anaesthesia is defined as the point at which the animal has released its hold on the substrate and usually fails completely to right itself after being placed on its back.

(iv) Long Finned Eels (Anguillea dieffenbachi) Dosage Temperature 17mg AQUI-S (8.5mg isoeugenol) Initial temperature 13°C Final temperature 4°C Saturated 10 to 15 minutes 10 to 12 minutes Dissolved oxygen Time to anaesthesia Recovery 15 Anaesthesia is defined as the point at which the eel lost equilibrium and turned over onto its back. No reaction to being handled.

Snapper (Pagrus auratus) Dosage 12mg 1.1 AQUI-S (6mg isoeugenol) Temperature 18 0

C

Dissolved oxygen 7.4 mg 1' 1 Time to sedation 20 to 30 minutes Time to anaesthesia 40 to 50 minutes Recovery 10 to 20 minutes Sedation is defined as the point at which equilibrium is lost and anaesthesia is the point at which there is no reaction from the snapper upon removal from the water.

This is for juvenile snapper weighing approximately 12 grams.

(vi) Yellow Eyed Mullet (Aldrichetta forsteri) Dosage 17 mg AQUI-S (8.5 mg 1-1 isoeugenol) Temperature 10 0

C

Time to sedation 9 to 10 minutes Time to anaesthesia 14 to 15 minutes Recovery 5 minutes Flounder (Paralichthys lethostigma) and spotty's (Pseudolabrus celidotus) in the same tank as the mullett appeared to respond in much the same manner within the same time frame.

Thus, in accordance with the present invention there are provided methods and compositions for sedating/anaesthetising aquatic organisms. Further, and most importantly, the active agents which are responsible for producing the sedating/anaesthetising effect are food grade additives which are non-carcinogenic (Finding of the WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives reported in Martindale, The Extra Pharmacopoeia, 29th Edition), and which are non-irritating to the organism at the concentrations employed.

Those persons skilled in the art will therefore appreciate the advantages of the present invention as well as the many applications to which the methods and compositions of the present invention can be put. As a first example, the methods and compositions can be employed in the harvesting of aquatic organisms for ultimate human consumption. This is particularly so in the case of organisms such as fish which otherwise struggle violently 16 to avoid capture, having a major impact on the post-mortem quality of the tissue.

However, when sedated and/or anaesthetised in accordance with the present methods this struggling is at least much reduced, if not eliminated. Further, any residual concentration of eugenol or isoeugenol in the tissue of the organism following harvesting does not detract from the suitability of the flesh for human consumption.

Additionally, where the aquatic organism is a shellfish, sedation/anaesthetisation of the shellfish greatly eases the extraction of the flesh from the shell.

A further application of the sedation and/or anaesthetic methods and compositions is in the transportation of live aquatic organisms. This is once again particularly the case with fish which are to be transported live to overseas markets and where the natural undamaged appearance of the fish is critical to the market price obtained.

Still a further application of the invention is in the transport of aquatic organisms to a market where the organism is to be sold in a pre-rigor state. By "pre-rigor" it is meant a state in which the tissue of the organism remains alive for a prolonged period following administration of the eugenol/isoeugenol but in which the organism is no longer capable of control of its musculature and from which the organism will not recover. The organism is therefore in a state of "living death".

The advantage of transporting the organism in this pre-rigor state is that the organism need not be transported in its aquatic environment. Instead, the organism can be transported "dry", which represents a considerable reduction in expense over that associated with the transportation of live organisms in their aquatic environment.

Additionally, as the tissue of the organism remains alive until the organism has reached its market, the flesh remains "fresh" and able to command a market premium over flesh from organisms euthanised before transport.

Other applications of the present methods and compositions will be readily apparent to the skilled worker in this art.

-17- In addition, the use of lesser amounts of eugenol and isoeugenol as compared to the amounts previously disclosed as being effective has significant advantages.

In particular, the applicants have found that, while effective in sedating/anaesthetising the organisms, the higher concentrations of eugenol and isoeugenol disclosed in JP 46-23256, do tend to irritate the organism and cause it to exercise more vigorously until such time as the sedaiive/anaesthetic effect takes hold. This is undesirable in terms of the effect this activity can have on the post-harvest flesh quality of the organism.

Equally, with the higher concentrations, the risk of the flesh becoming "tainted" by the residual levels of eugenol and isoeugenol is much increased. Again, this is undesirable, particularly where the flesh is to be consumed raw.

Finally, as a matter of simple economics, it is preferable to use lesser amounts of the active compounds to reduce overheads. In a large scale aquaculture operation, this can lead to considerable savings.

It will be appreciated that the above description is provided by way of example only and that the present invention is limited only by the lawful scope of the appended claims.

Throughout the description and claims of the specification the word "comprise" and variations of the word, such as "comprising" and "comprises", is not intended to exclude other additives, components, integers or steps.

Claims (8)

1. A method of anaesthetising a plurality of aquatic organisms comprising the step of contacting said organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, and wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg 11.

2. A method of harvesting a plurality of aquatic organisms while substantially retaining their pre-mortem flesh quality, comprising the step of anaesthetising said organisms by contacting said organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, and wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg 1

3. A method of transporting a plurality of live aquatic organisms comprising 15 the steps of: anaesthetising said organisms to be transported by contacting the organisms with a solution containing isoeugenol in an amount effective to anaesthetise each organism, wherein the amount of isoeugenol is up to but less than 12.5 mg I-1; and transporting said organisms while anaesthetised.

4. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein said solution contains isoeugenol in an amount from 1 to 10 mg 1 Y:\Mary\NKI NO DELETE MR\38264-02.doc 19 A method according to claim 4 wherein said solution contains isoeugenol in an amount of from 3 to 9 mg I 1

6. A method according to claim 4 wherein said solution contains isoeugenol in an amount of from 5 to 8.5 mg 1 1

7. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 6 wherein said solution further includes a suitable surfactant.

8. A method according to claim 7 wherein the surfactant is a polyethylene oxide sorbitan mono-oleate surfactant.

9. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 8 substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any of the examples. DATED: 9 March 2004 PHILLIPS ORMONDE FITZPATRICK Attorneys for: NEW ZEALAND INSTITUTE FOR CROP AND FOOD RESEARCH LIMITED Y:\Mar.NI NO DELETE MR\8264-02.doc