AU2005315789A1 - Method and device for continuous casting of metals - Google Patents

Method and device for continuous casting of metals Download PDF

Info

Publication number
AU2005315789A1
AU2005315789A1 AU2005315789A AU2005315789A AU2005315789A1 AU 2005315789 A1 AU2005315789 A1 AU 2005315789A1 AU 2005315789 A AU2005315789 A AU 2005315789A AU 2005315789 A AU2005315789 A AU 2005315789A AU 2005315789 A1 AU2005315789 A1 AU 2005315789A1
Authority
AU
Australia
Prior art keywords
accordance
conveyor belt
nozzles
nozzle segments
metal
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Abandoned
Application number
AU2005315789A
Inventor
Joerg Bausch
Udo Falkenreck
Hans-Juergen Schemeit
Walter Weischedel
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
SMS Siemag AG
Original Assignee
SMS Siemag AG
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by SMS Siemag AG filed Critical SMS Siemag AG
Publication of AU2005315789A1 publication Critical patent/AU2005315789A1/en
Assigned to SMS SIEMAG AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT reassignment SMS SIEMAG AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT Alteration of Name(s) of Applicant(s) under S113 Assignors: SMS DEMAG AG
Abandoned legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B22CASTING; POWDER METALLURGY
    • B22DCASTING OF METALS; CASTING OF OTHER SUBSTANCES BY THE SAME PROCESSES OR DEVICES
    • B22D11/00Continuous casting of metals, i.e. casting in indefinite lengths
    • B22D11/06Continuous casting of metals, i.e. casting in indefinite lengths into moulds with travelling walls, e.g. with rolls, plates, belts, caterpillars
    • B22D11/0637Accessories therefor
    • B22D11/068Accessories therefor for cooling the cast product during its passage through the mould surfaces
    • B22D11/0685Accessories therefor for cooling the cast product during its passage through the mould surfaces by cooling the casting belts
    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B22CASTING; POWDER METALLURGY
    • B22DCASTING OF METALS; CASTING OF OTHER SUBSTANCES BY THE SAME PROCESSES OR DEVICES
    • B22D11/00Continuous casting of metals, i.e. casting in indefinite lengths
    • B22D11/06Continuous casting of metals, i.e. casting in indefinite lengths into moulds with travelling walls, e.g. with rolls, plates, belts, caterpillars
    • B22D11/0631Continuous casting of metals, i.e. casting in indefinite lengths into moulds with travelling walls, e.g. with rolls, plates, belts, caterpillars formed by a travelling straight surface, e.g. through-like moulds, a belt

Abstract

The invention relates to a method for close-to-final-dimension casting of billets made of metal, particularly rectangular billets, wherein molten metal ( 2 ) is cast onto a circulating transport belt ( 3 ), followed by in-line rolling and cooling of said transport belt ( 3 ). The invention also relates to a device for carrying out the inventive method.

Description

VERIFICATION OF TRANSLATION RE: INTERNATIONAL APPLICATION NO. PCT/EP2005/013571 I, Paul J. Collins, c/o Frank C. Farnham Company, Inc., 210 W. Front St., Suite 5, Media, PA 19063-3101, am the translator of the specification of Patent Application No. PCT/EP2005/013571, as well as the replacement pages containing amendments made during the international phase, and I state that said translation is a true translation to the best of my knowledge and belief. Translator: Dated: TRANSLATION (HM-772PCT-original): WO 2006/063,847 Al PCT/EP2005/013,571 METHOD AND DEVICE FOR THE NEAR-NET-SHAPE STRIP CASTING OF METALS The invention concerns a method for the near-net-shape casting of metal strands, especially rectangular strands, where liquid metal is cast on a revolving conveyor belt with subsequent in-line rolling. The invention also concerns a device for carrying out this method. In near-net-shape strip casting, liquid metal is cast through an opening in the wall of a horizontally movable feed tank onto the upper side of a horizontally revolving belt, where it solidifies. After solidification has occurred, the strip that has been cast in this way is conveyed directly to a rolling stand or a rolling train. EP 1 077 782 B1 describes a method for the near-net-shape casting of rectangular strands of metal, especially steel, followed by in-line rolling out of the strand, with a material feed tank, through whose discharge nozzle the liquid metal is fed onto the carrying run of a conveyor belt, on which it solidifies and is transferred to a rolling stand, with the following steps: (a) before the start of casting: 1 (aa) the point at which the liquid metal is fed onto the conveyor belt is roughly predetermined, and (ab) the conveying speed of the conveyor belt is set as a function of a desired rolling thickness and rolling speed of the rolling stand. (b) during casting: (ba) the position of complete solidification of the metal strand on the conveyor belt is determined, (bb) the temperature of the rolling stock in the vicinity of the rolling stand is detected, and (bc) the position of complete solidification and the temperature of the rolling stock are used as control variables for the current position of the point at which the liquid metal leaving the material feed tank is fed onto the conveyor belt. The cited document also discloses a device for the near net-shape casting of rectangular strands of metal, especially steel, followed by in-line rolling out of the strand, which device comprises a material feed tank with a discharge nozzle, a horizontally arranged conveyor belt, and at least one rolling stand downstream of the conveyor belt, where the material feed tank is connected with motion control elements for moving it in the horizontal direction, coaxially with the principal axis of the conveyor belt in the same direction as 2 or in the opposite direction from the direction of conveyance of the strand, and where the material feed tank is connected to an actuator, which is automatically controlled by an automatic control system, which is connected to the actuator and to measuring elements for determining the position of the complete solidification of the strand and measuring elements for determining the temperature of the rolling stock. The prior art thus includes a method and a device in which the point at which the metal is fed onto the conveyor belt is locally fixed or locally variable. A disadvantage of a locally fixed metal feed point is that it greatly limits the production spectrum. Only products with small variations in dimensions or material properties can be produced. An improvement was realized with a variable liquid metal feed point onto the conveyor belt. However, a method or device of this type has the disadvantage that the cooling is not adapted to the variable boundary conditions. It was realized that the type of cooling and the position or spatial configuration of the cooling during the strip casting affect the heat dissipation, for example, in such a way that local heating of the conveyor belt occurs, which causes the conveyor belt to fail. Furthermore, the effective heat transfer can be so low that sufficient solidification of the cast strip is not achieved. 3 Therefore, the objective of the invention is to specify a method and a device in which the production window or production spectrum is widened. This includes the casting of different metals and grades, the casting of different production thicknesses and widths, and a wide variance of the casting speed in order to avoid the disadvantages specified above. In a method of the type specified in the introductory clause of Claim 1, the objective of the invention is achieved by cooling the conveyor belt. Further embodiments of the method are specified in the dependent claims concerning the method. The invention also concerns a device for carrying out the method of the invention. Further embodiments of the device are specified in the dependent claims concerning the device. The decisive advantage of the method of the invention is that the intensity of the cooling is designed according to the greatest heat transfer in such a way that the greatest cooling effect is realized at the point of first contact of the liquid metal with the conveyor belt and decreases downstream. A more flexible production spectrum is realized by local variation of the point at which the liquid metal is fed onto the conveyor belt in conjunction with optimally adapted cooling or cooling 4 configuration. The point at which the liquid metal comes into contact with the conveyor belt must be varied in the casting direction under certain boundary conditions, such as varying metal grades, mass flow rates and the like. To this end, the intensity of the cooling is adjusted by local variation of the cooling zone in the direction of conveyance. Therefore, the zone of the conveyor belt that has the greatest cooling intensity is correlated with the point of discharge of the liquid metal from the feed tank. The method of the invention and the device of the invention make the effective cooling length and heat dissipation more flexible to widen the production window. This makes it possible to cast materials that require more or less intense cooling in a wide range of flow rates. In a first embodiment, the nozzles are combined in several independent units. A separate, pressure-controlled water supply is assigned to each nozzle unit. In a device of this type, the pressure with which the coolant is sprayed against the underside of the carrying run of the conveyor belt is greatest in each case at the point at which the liquid metal is fed onto the upper side of the carrying run of the conveyor belt. In the direction of conveyance, the pressure in the following nozzle units is reduced, e.g., incrementally. 5 By applying the greatest pressure at the point at which the liquid metal is fed onto the conveyor belt, one achieves the greatest cooling effect at that point. In the first embodiment, the pressure in the individual nozzle units is varied. In a second embodiment, the pressure with which the individual nozzle units spray the coolant at the underside of the carrying run of the conveyor belt remains constant. In this embodiment, the individual nozzle units are arranged in such a way that the nozzle unit with the greatest cooling effect, i.e., the greatest coolant volume flow rate, is always positioned where the liquid metal is fed onto the conveyor belt. This is accomplished by local shifting or displacement of the nozzle units. Furthermore, to obtain a solidified strip at the end of the conveyor belt, the parameters of conveyor belt speed and amount of metal/time are varied. The effective cooling length necessary for solidification is adapted to the metallurgical length. This process is carried out as follows in various situations, and uniform feeding of the liquid metal to the conveyor belt is assumed. Shortening of the effective cooling length during the casting process 6 Case 1: The relative speed between the unit Z / I and the conveyor belt is held constant. The speed of the conveyor belt VTr must be raised by the amount of the horizontal speed of the unit Z / I: vTr new = vTr old + vunit z / I where vTr is the speed of the conveyor belt and vunit z / I is the speed of the unit Z / I. The mass flow rate m is held constant -- when the end position of the unit Z / I is reached, the conveyor belt speed vTr is reduced to its original value. Case 2: The conveyor belt speed vTr is held constant. The metal feed must be reduced by the amount m = d x b xrho xvunie z / I in (t/min) where m is the mass flow rate, d is the thickness of the strand, b is the width of the strand, rho is the density of the liquid metal, and v is the speed of the unit Z / I. When the end position of the unit Z / I is reached, the flow rate m is raised to its original value. Lengthening of the effective cooling length during the casting process Case 3: The relative speed between the unit Z / I and the conveyor belt is held constant. The speed of the conveyor belt vTr must be reduced by the amount of the horizontal speed of the unit Z / I: 7 VTr new = VTr old - vunit z / I The mass flow rate m is held constant. When the end position of the unit Z / I is reached, the conveyor belt speed VTr is raised to its original value. Case 4: The conveyor belt speed vTr is held constant. The metal feed must be raised by the amount m = d x b * rho x vuni z / (t/min) When the end position of the unit Z / I is reached, the flow rate m is reduced to its original value. The processes that have been explained are graphically represented below Example of a typical conveyor belt speed vTr: 40 m / min unit z / 1: 10 m / min Case 1: Tr = 50 m /min Case 3: vTr = 30 m /min Example of a typical flow rate of the plant: m = 0.012 m x 1.3 m x 7.6 t/m 3 x 40 m / min = 4.7 t/min vunit z / 1: 10 m / min - Am = 1.2 t/min Case 2: m = 3.5 t/min Case 4: m = 5.9 t/min Specific embodiments of the invention are described in greater detail below with reference to the highly schematic 8 drawings. -- Figure 1 shows a strip casting plant with pressure control of the nozzle segments, where a metal feed tank is located in different positions (la, lb, 1c). -- Figure 2 shows a strip casting plant with interchangeable nozzle segments, where a metal feed tank is located in different positions (2a, 2b, 2c). In Figures la, lb, 1c, a metal feed tank 1 for liquid metal 2 is located above a conveyor belt 3. The conveyor belt 3 runs around two rollers 4 and 5. Liquid metal 2 is fed from an opening 6 in the metal feed tank 1 onto the upper side 7 of the carrying run 8 of the conveyor belt 3. Rotary motion of the rollers 4 and 5 causes the liquid metal 2 to be conveyed in conveyance direction 9 to a rolling installation (not shown). In this regard, the liquid metal 2 must have formed a strand shell of sufficient strength when it leaves the conveyor belt 3 in the area of roller 5. To cool the conveyor belt 3 and thus the liquid metal 2, nozzles 11 are installed near the underside 10 of the carrying run 8 of the conveyor belt 3. A coolant, such as water or the like, is sprayed from the nozzles 11 towards the underside 10 of the carrying run 8. The nozzles 11 are arranged, for example, in four nozzle segments 12, 13, 14, 15. Each nozzle segment 12, 13, 14, 15 9 has a separate, pressure-controlled water supply (not shown). This makes it possible for each nozzle segment 12, 13, 14, 15 to be pressurized with a different pressure. The highest pressure of the cooling water or coolant is provided where the greatest amount of heat must be dissipated. This location corresponds to the point at which the liquid metal 2 is fed onto the upper side 7. In Figure la, this point is located on the left side. Therefore, the nozzle segment 12 is pressurized, for example, with a pressure of 8 bars. Since the amount of heat to be removed decreases in the direction of conveyance 8, nozzle segment 13 is pressurized with a reduced pressure of, for example, 6 bars, nozzle segment 14 with 4 bars, and nozzle segment 15 with 3 bars. The nozzle segment located upstream of the point at which the liquid metal 2 is fed onto the upper side 7 are also pressurized with a reduced pressure (nozzle segment in Figure 1b, and nozzle segments in Figure lc). The nozzle segment located upstream of the point at which the liquid metal 2 is fed onto the upper side 7 are also pressurized with a reduced pressure (nozzle segment in Figure 1b, and nozzle segments in Figure lc). The pressures can be individually adjusted at any time and are affected by the aforementioned boundary conditions, such as metal properties, mass flow rate, etc. 10 In the device of the invention which is illustrated in Figures 2a, 2b, 2c, the cooling water or coolant is supplied under constant pressure to the individual nozzle segments 16, 17, 18, 19, 20. All of the nozzle segments 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 can be supplied by a centralized system, or each individual nozzle segment can be supplied by a decentralized system. In this connection, the nozzles of the nozzle segments are designed in such a way that the nozzle segments 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 have different cooling effects. This can be achieved, for example, by different volume flows of the coolant. In accordance with the invention, the nozzle segment 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 with the greatest cooling effect is positioned where the liquid metal 2 is fed onto the conveyor belt 3. Since this place varies, the nozzle segments 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 can be interchanged or shifted. In Figure 2a, the greatest cooling effect is achieved in the left nozzle segment 16. The cooling effect decreases in the following nozzle segments 17, 18, 19, 20 in the direction of conveyance 9. In Figure 2b, the point of delivery of the liquid metal 2 is displaced in the direction of conveyance 9. To produce the greatest cooling effect here, the nozzle segment 16 described in connection with Figure 2a is likewise displaced in the direction of conveyance 9. To achieve a uniform gradient in the cooling effect, the 11 downstream nozzle segments 17, 18, 19, 20 are each displaced by one position to the right. A displacement by one additional position is shown in Figure 2c. When the parameters of conveyance speed and amount of metal per unit time are varied as described above, the effective cooling length is thus adapted to the metallurgical length. List of Reference Numbers 1 metal feed tank 2 liquid metal 3 conveyor belt 4 roller 5 roller 6 opening 7 upper side 8 carrying run 9 direction of conveyance 10 underside 11 nozzles 12-20 nozzle segment 12

Claims (18)

1. A method for the near-net-shape casting of metal strands, especially rectangular strands, where liquid metal (2) is cast on a revolving conveyor belt (3) with subsequent in-line rolling, wherein the conveyor belt (3) is cooled.
2. A method in accordance with Claim 1, wherein the conveyor belt (3) is cooled most intensely or the greatest amount of heat is removed from it at the point at which the liquid metal is fed onto the upper side (7) of the carrying run (8).
3. A method in accordance with Claim 1 or Claim 2, wherein the cooling is effected by spraying coolant or cooling water by nozzles (11) onto the underside (10) of the carrying run (8) of the conveyor belt (3).
4. A method in accordance with Claim 1, Claim 2, or Claim 3, wherein the nozzles (11) are combined to form nozzle segments (12-20).
5. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 4, wherein the nozzles (11) in the nozzle segments (12-15) have different pressures. 13
6. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 4, wherein the nozzles in the nozzle segments (16-20) have the same pressure.
7. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 4, wherein the volume flow rate of the coolant or cooling water in the individual nozzle segments (12-20) is varied.
8. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 4, wherein the volume flow rate of the coolant or cooling water in the individual nozzle segments (12-20) is set at a constant level.
9. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 8, wherein the mass flow rate m is held constant.
10. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 8, wherein the conveyance speed vTr is held constant.
11. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 8, wherein the metal feed is increased or decreased.
12. A method in accordance with any of Claims 1 to 8, wherein the conveyance speed vTr is increased or decreased.
13. A device for the near-net-shape casting of metal strands, especially rectangular strands, where liquid metal (2) is cast on a revolving conveyor belt (3), which runs around two rollers (4, 5), has a carrying run (8) with an upper side (7) and an underside (10), and is followed by a rolling mill, wherein nozzles (11) are installed below the 14 underside (10).
14. A device in accordance with Claim 13, wherein the nozzles (11) are arranged in nozzle segments (12-20).
15. A device in accordance with Claim 14, wherein the nozzles (11) in the individual nozzle segments (12-20) have different flow rates.
16. A device in accordance with Claim 13, wherein the nozzles (11) in the individual nozzle segments (12-20) are identical.
17. A device in accordance with any of Claims 12 to 16, wherein each nozzle segment (12-15) has a separate, pressure controlled coolant or cooling water supply.
18. A device in accordance with any of Claims 12 to 16, wherein the nozzle segments (16-20) are interchangeably arranged. 15
AU2005315789A 2004-12-18 2005-12-16 Method and device for continuous casting of metals Abandoned AU2005315789A1 (en)

Applications Claiming Priority (3)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
DE102004061080.0 2004-12-18
DE102004061080A DE102004061080A1 (en) 2004-12-18 2004-12-18 Method and device for strip casting of metals
PCT/EP2005/013571 WO2006063847A1 (en) 2004-12-18 2005-12-16 Method and device for continuous casting of metals

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
AU2005315789A1 true AU2005315789A1 (en) 2006-06-22

Family

ID=36011709

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2005315789A Abandoned AU2005315789A1 (en) 2004-12-18 2005-12-16 Method and device for continuous casting of metals

Country Status (9)

Country Link
US (1) US20080000612A1 (en)
EP (1) EP1827735B1 (en)
JP (1) JP4922945B2 (en)
AT (1) ATE414579T1 (en)
AU (1) AU2005315789A1 (en)
DE (2) DE102004061080A1 (en)
ES (1) ES2314751T3 (en)
PL (1) PL1827735T3 (en)
WO (1) WO2006063847A1 (en)

Families Citing this family (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2009102756A1 (en) 2008-02-13 2009-08-20 Andreas Rose Light delivery device that provides a radial light output pattern
DE102010005226C5 (en) 2010-01-21 2020-02-13 Fritz-Peter Pleschiutschnigg Band casting method and apparatus
DE102017221095A1 (en) * 2016-11-29 2018-05-30 Sms Group Gmbh Caster casting machine and method for producing a cast metal from liquid metal

Family Cites Families (15)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JPS6127149A (en) * 1984-07-17 1986-02-06 Sumitomo Metal Ind Ltd Horizontal and continuous casting device
CH671534A5 (en) * 1986-03-14 1989-09-15 Escher Wyss Ag
JPS63123552A (en) * 1986-11-12 1988-05-27 Kawasaki Steel Corp Cooling apparatus for belt in belt type continuous casting machine
JPS63126652A (en) * 1986-11-18 1988-05-30 Kawasaki Steel Corp Twin belt continuous casting method
JPH01254351A (en) * 1988-04-01 1989-10-11 Hitachi Ltd Cooling pad for belt type continuous casting machine
JPH084887B2 (en) * 1989-12-06 1996-01-24 株式会社日立製作所 High temperature cast carrier
JP2680470B2 (en) * 1990-09-14 1997-11-19 新日本製鐵株式会社 Belt cooling method of twin belt type continuous casting machine
JPH09141408A (en) * 1995-11-24 1997-06-03 Kawasaki Steel Corp Secondary cooling method in continuous casting
US5671801A (en) * 1996-01-11 1997-09-30 Larex A.G. Cooling system for a belt caster and associated methods
JPH09192791A (en) * 1996-01-22 1997-07-29 Kobe Steel Ltd Cooling pad in belt type continuous caster
US5967223A (en) * 1996-07-10 1999-10-19 Hazelett Strip-Casting Corporation Permanent-magnetic hydrodynamic methods and apparatus for stabilizing a casting belt in a continuous metal-casting machine
DE19823440C1 (en) * 1998-05-19 1999-12-09 Mannesmann Ag Method and device for the near-dimensional casting of metal
JP2000126848A (en) * 1998-10-27 2000-05-09 Ishikawajima Harima Heavy Ind Co Ltd Device and method for manufacturing quenched alloy foil band
US6755236B1 (en) * 2000-08-07 2004-06-29 Alcan International Limited Belt-cooling and guiding means for continuous belt casting of metal strip
US6453984B1 (en) * 2001-03-13 2002-09-24 Honeywell International Inc. Apparatus and method for casting amorphous metal alloys in an adjustable low density atmosphere

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
US20080000612A1 (en) 2008-01-03
JP4922945B2 (en) 2012-04-25
WO2006063847A1 (en) 2006-06-22
EP1827735A1 (en) 2007-09-05
DE102004061080A1 (en) 2006-06-22
JP2008531281A (en) 2008-08-14
ES2314751T3 (en) 2009-03-16
EP1827735B1 (en) 2008-11-19
DE502005006026D1 (en) 2009-01-02
ATE414579T1 (en) 2008-12-15
PL1827735T3 (en) 2009-04-30

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
TWI442982B (en) Device for influencing the widthwise temperature distribution
US4658882A (en) Machine for direct rolling of steel casting and producing steel product therefrom
TWI382888B (en) Method and means of continuous casting
JP2008515647A (en) Process and equipment for continuous production of thin metal strips
JP6236525B2 (en) Steel plant with multiple co-rolling lines and corresponding manufacturing method
CN109890525B (en) Method for operating a casting and rolling combined plant
US20020029865A1 (en) Method of and apparatus for continuous casting of steel strip
US4625788A (en) Apparatus and method for the continuous casting of metal
AU2005315789A1 (en) Method and device for continuous casting of metals
CA2200470A1 (en) Apparatus and method for the vertical casting of a metalbar
CA2332914C (en) Method and device for the casting of metal close to final dimensions
EP0515075B1 (en) Strip casting
US20160199905A1 (en) Caster
US6581675B1 (en) Method and apparatus for continuous casting of metals
RU2008140284A (en) TAPE LINEAR MACHINE HAVING AN ADJUSTABLE LENGTH OF CONTACT WITH MOLDABLE METAL PREPARATION
JP2008531281A5 (en)
US5427172A (en) Method and apparatus for the direct casting of metals to form elongated bodies
AU711139B2 (en) Method and device for guiding strands in a continuous casting installation
KR20030071890A (en) Installation for producing a hot-rolled strip
RU2741312C1 (en) Cooling method of metal article and cooling beam
US6565925B1 (en) Method and device for producing coated metal strands, especially steel strips
KR20100060243A (en) Cooling device for rolling roll
KR20050013576A (en) Method and casting roller plant for the semi-endless or endless rolling by casting of a metal in particular a steel strip which may be transversely separated as required after solidification

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
DA3 Amendments made section 104

Free format text: THE NATURE OF THE AMENDMENT IS: AMEND THE NAME OF THE INVENTOR TO READ FALKENRECK, UDO; WEISCHEDEL,WALTER; BAUSCH, JOERG AND SCHEMEIT, HANS-JUERGEN

MK5 Application lapsed section 142(2)(e) - patent request and compl. specification not accepted