WO2021026810A1 - Method for assessing risk of thermal runaway in chemical process - Google Patents

Method for assessing risk of thermal runaway in chemical process Download PDF

Info

Publication number
WO2021026810A1
WO2021026810A1 PCT/CN2019/100569 CN2019100569W WO2021026810A1 WO 2021026810 A1 WO2021026810 A1 WO 2021026810A1 CN 2019100569 W CN2019100569 W CN 2019100569W WO 2021026810 A1 WO2021026810 A1 WO 2021026810A1
Authority
WO
WIPO (PCT)
Prior art keywords
reaction
coefficient
risk
value
thermal runaway
Prior art date
Application number
PCT/CN2019/100569
Other languages
French (fr)
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
蒋军成
魏丹
倪磊
潘勇
Original Assignee
南京工业大学
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by 南京工业大学 filed Critical 南京工业大学
Priority to ZA2020/05471A priority Critical patent/ZA202005471B/en
Publication of WO2021026810A1 publication Critical patent/WO2021026810A1/en

Links

Images

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06QINFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
    • G06Q10/00Administration; Management
    • G06Q10/06Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling
    • G06Q10/063Operations research, analysis or management
    • G06Q10/0635Risk analysis of enterprise or organisation activities
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06QINFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
    • G06Q50/00Information and communication technology [ICT] specially adapted for implementation of business processes of specific business sectors, e.g. utilities or tourism
    • G06Q50/04Manufacturing
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02PCLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THE PRODUCTION OR PROCESSING OF GOODS
    • Y02P90/00Enabling technologies with a potential contribution to greenhouse gas [GHG] emissions mitigation
    • Y02P90/30Computing systems specially adapted for manufacturing

Definitions

  • the invention belongs to the field of risk assessment of chemical processes, and relates to a method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process.
  • Exothermic reaction is a very common type of reaction in the chemical and pharmaceutical industry. If the energy released during the reaction is not effectively controlled, it may cause thermal runaway accidents in the process. The correct recognition of hazards is the prerequisite for controlling hazards. Therefore, pre-assessing the risk of thermal runaway in the process is an important means to understand and take corresponding measures to control hazards. How to comprehensively and accurately assess the risk of thermal runaway in the process is an important issue that needs to be resolved urgently in the chemical industry.
  • the current research on the risk of thermal runaway mostly focuses on the experiments and simulation studies of the thermal runaway risk of substances and reactions, but little attention has been paid to the evaluation methods of the thermal runaway risk of the process.
  • the existing thermal runaway risk assessment methods mostly focus on the thermal risk of substances or reactions, but do not combine substances and reactions to assess the thermal runaway risk of the process, which may lead to deviations in the perception of the actual thermal runaway risk of the process.
  • the current methods used to assess the risk of thermal runaway are mostly only applicable to substances or reactions, and rarely combine the risk of thermal decomposition of reactive substances with the risk of runaway in the reaction stage.
  • the risk of thermal runaway in the process of evaluating the risk of thermal runaway that combines substances and reaction processes is of great significance for improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the assessment results.
  • the purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in the chemical process in response to the current demand for the risk of thermal runaway in the chemical process, combining the thermal risk of substances with the risk of reaction runaway to form a chemical process thermal runaway
  • a quantitative risk assessment method which comprehensively reflects the influence of substances and reactions on the risk of thermal runaway in the process.
  • the method for determining the material coefficient MF in the step (2) is to test the thermal stability of all raw materials, and select the material with the worst thermal stability to determine the MF, which specifically includes the following steps:
  • I Tonset represents the initial decomposition temperature coefficient
  • I MPD represents the maximum heat release power coefficient
  • I Tonset is correspondingly determined by the value range of Tonset in Table 1; the value of I MPD is correspondingly determined by the value range of MPD in Table 1.
  • the I Tonset coefficient is 0; when the value of Tonset is in the interval (200°C, 300°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 1; when the value of Tonset is In the interval of (100°C, 200°C), the coefficient of I Tonset is 2; when the value of Tonset is in the interval of (50°C, 100°C], the coefficient of I Tonset is 3; when the value of Tonset is not greater than 50°C (ie When the temperature is less than or equal to 50°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 4.
  • the I MPD coefficient When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is less than 0.01W/ml, the I MPD coefficient is 0; when the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [0.01W/ml, 10W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 1; When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [10W/ml, 100W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 2; when the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [100W/ml, 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is not less than 1000W/ml (that is, greater than or equal to 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 4.
  • the material coefficient MF is determined by the material’s initial decomposition temperature Tonset and the maximum exothermic power MPD, reflecting the risk of thermal decomposition of the material; among them, Tonset refers to the temperature at which a material begins to decompose. The lower the temperature, the description The higher the possibility of thermal decomposition of the substance; MPD is an indicator reflecting the heat release and rate of heat release during the thermal decomposition of a substance. The larger the value, the more serious the consequences of the thermal decomposition of the substance.
  • the material coefficient MF corrects the risk of thermal runaway in the entire process, and its value range is limited to [1, 2]; if the substances involved in the reaction are thermally stable, the material coefficient MF is 1, and the material coefficient cannot be corrected.
  • the intrinsic thermal runaway risk of the process only depends on the thermal runaway risk of the reaction process; if the material coefficient is greater than 1, the thermal risk of the material will increase the thermal runaway risk of the entire process.
  • step (3) the specific method for determining the reaction heat runaway risk index RI includes the following steps:
  • reaction heat and adiabatic temperature rise are selected as the out-of-control severity indicators for mutual verification, and the greater value of the two is used to determine the severity of the out-of-control consequences S;
  • the specific method is to obtain the severity coefficient S rx of the target reaction and the severity coefficient S dec of the secondary reaction respectively, and finally obtain the severity coefficient S of the reaction out of control.
  • the calculation formula is as follows:
  • I H,rx represents the reaction heat coefficient of the target reaction
  • I ⁇ Tad,rx represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the target reaction, and the maximum value of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient S rx of the target reaction
  • I H,dec means two The reaction heat coefficient of the secondary reaction, I ⁇ Tad,dec represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the secondary reaction, and the maximum of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient of the secondary reaction S dec .
  • the values of the severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction refer to Table 2; where I H represents the heat coefficient of reaction, I ⁇ Tad represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient, and ⁇ T ad represents the adiabatic temperature rise of the reaction.
  • the specific corresponding rules are: when the reaction heat is not greater than 100kJ/kg, the I H coefficient takes the value 1; when the reaction heat is in the interval of (100kJ/kg, 400kJ/kg), the I H coefficient takes the value 2. When the heat is in the range of (400kJ/kg, 800kJ/kg), the I H coefficient takes the value 3; when the reaction heat is greater than 800 kJ/kg, the I H coefficient takes the value 4.
  • the target reaction and the second The reaction heat of the reaction is evaluated according to Table 2, and the reaction heat coefficient I H,rx of the corresponding target reaction and the reaction heat coefficient I H,dec of the secondary reaction are obtained.
  • the I ⁇ Tad coefficient takes the value 1; when the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ⁇ T ad is in the (50°C, 200°C) interval, the I ⁇ Tad coefficient takes the value 2; when the reaction is adiabatic When the temperature rise ⁇ T ad is in the interval of (200°C,400°C), the I ⁇ Tad coefficient takes the value 3; when the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ⁇ T ad is greater than 400°C, the I ⁇ Tad coefficient takes the value 4.
  • the target The adiabatic temperature rise of the reaction and the secondary reaction is evaluated according to Table 2, and the corresponding adiabatic temperature rise coefficient I ⁇ Tad,rx of the target reaction and the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient I ⁇ Tad,dec of the secondary reaction are obtained.
  • the severity of the consequences of out-of-control reaction is determined by the severity of the target reaction and the out-of-control of the secondary reaction; using the reaction heat criterion and adiabatic temperature rise criterion for the same process may result in different coefficient levels. In order to obtain a conservative estimation result, both are selected in the present invention
  • the heat of reaction and adiabatic temperature rise are used as indicators of the severity of the runaway to verify each other, and the larger value of the two is used to determine S.
  • TMR ad represents the time required for the secondary decomposition reaction to occur and is an indicator of the time dimension. The larger the value, the greater the occurrence. The longer the time required for the secondary reaction, the more sufficient time the operator has to take emergency measures to control the reaction, and the lower the possibility of a secondary reaction eventually; the risk level of out-of-control scenarios is inferred from the temperature scale. The criterion for the possibility of loss of control.
  • the possibility of reaction out of control P is the sum of the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR and the risk level coefficient I CC .
  • the calculation formula is as shown in the following formula 5. The greater the possibility P of an out of control reaction, the higher the possibility of an out of control reaction.
  • Table 3 is a value table for the possibility of reaction out of control P.
  • Table 3 determines the value range of the relationship between the risk of out-of-control scenarios, and obtains the corresponding risk level coefficient I CC ; thereby calculating the possibility of reaction out of control P.
  • the specific rule is that when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is greater than 50h, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 1; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is in the (24h, 50h) interval, the maximum The reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 2; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is in the (8h, 24h) interval, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 3; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value In the interval (1h, 8h), the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 4; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is not greater than 1h (that is, less than or equal to 1h), the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 5; Among them, h means hour.
  • the risk level coefficient I CC is 1; when Tp ⁇ MTSR ⁇ T D24 ⁇ MTT, the risk level coefficient I CC is 2; when Tp ⁇ MTT ⁇ MTSR ⁇ T D24 , the risk level The grade coefficient I CC is 3; when Tp ⁇ MTT ⁇ T D24 ⁇ MTSR, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 4; when Tp ⁇ T D24 ⁇ MTSR ⁇ MTT, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 5.
  • step (4) calculates the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determines the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard.
  • the specific method includes the following steps:
  • the ITHI value is obtained by multiplying the substance coefficient MF and the reaction out of control risk index RI;
  • the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards in step (4-2) are as follows:
  • ITHI thermal runaway risk index
  • the present invention separately establishes the thermal runaway risk coefficient of the raw materials and the thermal runaway risk coefficient of the reaction process, and combines the two to evaluate the thermal runaway risk of the process, thereby improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the evaluation results;
  • the thermal runaway hazards of different processes are more distinguished, and the recognition of the thermal runaway hazard assessment results is improved, which is conducive to the realization of process optimization and intrinsic safety.
  • the assessment method is simple and easy to understand.
  • the data required for the assessment is in It can be obtained through experiments in the early stage and has strong operability, so it can be used for the risk assessment of thermal runaway in the initial stage of design.
  • Fig. 1 is a flowchart of a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to the present invention.
  • the method of the present invention includes the following steps:
  • Step 1 Collect thermal hazard data of raw materials, products and reaction process
  • Step 2 Determine the material factor MF
  • the material coefficient MF is determined by the initial decomposition temperature (T onset ) of the material and the maximum exothermic power (MPD), which reflects the risk of thermal decomposition of the material.
  • Tonset refers to the temperature at which a substance begins to decompose. The lower the temperature, the higher the possibility of thermal decomposition of the substance.
  • MPD is an indicator reflecting the heat release and rate of heat release during the thermal decomposition of a substance. The larger the value, the more serious the consequences of the thermal decomposition of the substance.
  • MF can correct the risk of thermal runaway in the whole process, and its value range is limited to [1,2]. If the substances involved in the reaction are all thermally stable, the material coefficient MF is 1, and the material coefficient has no corrective effect.
  • the intrinsic thermal runaway risk of the process only depends on the thermal runaway risk of the reaction process. If the material coefficient is greater than 1, the thermal risk of the material will increase the risk of thermal runaway in the entire process. In the actual evaluation process, the thermal stability of all raw materials needs to be tested, and the material with the worst thermal stability is selected to determine the MF.
  • the calculation formula is as follows:
  • Step 3 Determine the risk index RI for out-of-control reaction
  • the reaction out-of-control risk index is the product of the consequence severity (S) and the probability (P) of the out-of-control reaction, and S and P are determined in sequence according to steps 3-1 and 3-2;
  • Step 3-1 Determine the severity S of the consequences of losing control
  • the severity of the consequences of a reaction out of control is determined by the severity of the target reaction and the second reaction out of control.
  • Using the reaction heat criterion and adiabatic temperature rise criterion for the same process may result in different coefficient levels.
  • the present invention simultaneously selects reaction heat and adiabatic temperature rise as indicators of the out-of-control severity for mutual verification, and the two The larger value determines S.
  • the severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction are obtained respectively, and the severity coefficient S of the reaction out of control is finally obtained.
  • the value of the severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction is referred to Table 2.
  • the calculation formula is as follows:
  • Step 3-2 Determine the possibility P of the reaction out of control
  • TMR ad The possibility of reaction out of control is determined by the time to reach the maximum reaction rate (TMR ad ) and the criticality classes of the out-of-control scenario.
  • TMR ad characterizes the time required for the secondary decomposition reaction and is an indicator of the time dimension. The larger the value, the longer the time required for the secondary reaction to occur, and the operator has more time to take emergency measures. Control the reaction, the lower the possibility of a secondary reaction eventually.
  • the risk level of out-of-control scenarios is a criterion for inferring the possibility of out-of-control from the temperature scale.
  • the relative magnitude of the four temperature relationships will be divided into out-of-control scenarios.
  • the risk level of out-of-control scenarios describes the conditions under which out-of-control occurs. The higher the level, the higher the possibility of secondary reactions.
  • the possibility of out-of-control reaction P is the sum of the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient and the out-of-control risk level coefficient. The greater the P, the higher the possibility of an out-of-control reaction.
  • Table 3 below is the value table of possibility P.
  • Step 3-3 After determining the severity S and the possibility P of the reaction out of control, the thermal runaway risk index RI of the chemical process is determined by the following formula.
  • Step 4 Calculate the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determine the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard.
  • Step 4-1 Multiply the substance coefficient MF and the reaction out of control risk index RI to obtain the ITHI value
  • Step 4-2. According to ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard, classify and analyze the thermal runaway risk of the process.
  • ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards are as follows:
  • the raw material for the reaction of cyclohexanone peroxidation is 210g cyclohexanone, 60g of a mixed solution of hydrogen peroxide and nitric acid with a concentration of ⁇ 30%, the reaction condition is a temperature of 12°C, a stirring blade speed of 250r/min, and the product is cyclohexanone peroxide;
  • the reaction formula is as follows:
  • the severity S and the probability P of the out-of-control are 5 and 8, respectively, as shown in the following table.
  • ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard in step 4-2 it is considered that the thermal runaway risk of cyclohexanone peroxidation process is extremely high. Accepted.
  • the invention proposes a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process, which is composed of a material coefficient (MF) and a reaction runaway risk index (RI).
  • the material coefficient MF is determined by the initial decomposition temperature of the material and the maximum power density.
  • the reaction out-of-control risk index RI is determined by the possibility and severity of out-of-control.
  • the time to reach the maximum reaction rate under adiabatic conditions and the out-of-control risk level are used to determine the possibility of out-of-control in the process.
  • the severity of the runaway reaction is determined by the adiabatic temperature rise of the target reaction and the secondary reaction. Finally, use pre-defined hazard levels to grade and analyze the ITHI assessment results.
  • the present invention combines the thermal runaway risk of substances and reactions to evaluate the thermal runaway risk of the technological process, thereby improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the evaluation result.
  • the evaluation from the two aspects of material and reaction makes the risk of thermal runaway of different processes more distinguishable, improves the recognition of the evaluation results of thermal runaway risk, and is conducive to the realization of process optimization and intrinsic safety.
  • the present invention is simple and easy to understand, the data required for evaluation can be obtained through experiments in the early stage, and the operability is strong. Therefore, it can be used for the evaluation of the risk of thermal runaway in the initial stage of design, and provides a reference basis for process optimization and hazard identification.

Landscapes

  • Business, Economics & Management (AREA)
  • Human Resources & Organizations (AREA)
  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Economics (AREA)
  • Strategic Management (AREA)
  • Tourism & Hospitality (AREA)
  • Theoretical Computer Science (AREA)
  • Entrepreneurship & Innovation (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Marketing (AREA)
  • General Business, Economics & Management (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Educational Administration (AREA)
  • Quality & Reliability (AREA)
  • Operations Research (AREA)
  • Game Theory and Decision Science (AREA)
  • Development Economics (AREA)
  • Manufacturing & Machinery (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Primary Health Care (AREA)
  • Investigating Or Analyzing Materials Using Thermal Means (AREA)

Abstract

A method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process, relating to the field of chemical process risk assessment. Comprising the steps: 1) collecting thermal risk data of raw materials, products, and reaction processes; 2) determining a material factor MF, the material factor MF being determined by the initial decomposition temperature Tonset and the maximum exothermic power MPD of a material; 3) determining a reaction thermal runaway risk index RI, RI being the product of the consequence severity S and probability P of a runaway reaction; and 4) calculating a thermal runaway risk index ITHI of a process and, on the basis of an ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard, determining the thermal runaway risk level of the process. Material thermal risk is combined with reaction runaway risk to provide a method for quantitatively assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process.

Description

一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法A method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in chemical process 技术领域Technical field
本发明属于化工工艺过程风险评估领域,涉及的是一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法。The invention belongs to the field of risk assessment of chemical processes, and relates to a method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process.
背景技术Background technique
放热反应是化工制药行业中是非常常见的反应类型,如果反应过程释放的能量未得到有效控制,就可能引发工艺过程热失控事故。正确认知危险是控制危险的前提,因此预先对工艺过程进行热失控危险评估,是了解从而采取相应措施控制危险的重要手段。如何全面准确地评估工艺过程热失控危险度是化工行业安全亟需解决的一个重要问题。Exothermic reaction is a very common type of reaction in the chemical and pharmaceutical industry. If the energy released during the reaction is not effectively controlled, it may cause thermal runaway accidents in the process. The correct recognition of hazards is the prerequisite for controlling hazards. Therefore, pre-assessing the risk of thermal runaway in the process is an important means to understand and take corresponding measures to control hazards. How to comprehensively and accurately assess the risk of thermal runaway in the process is an important issue that needs to be resolved urgently in the chemical industry.
目前的热失控危险相关研究重点多集中于物质、反应的热失控危险实验及模拟研究,但对工艺过程热失控危险的评估方法的关注不多。现有的热失控危险评估方法多针对物质或反应的热危险,而未结合物质与反应来评估过程的热失控危险,这可能导致对工艺过程实际的热失控危险的认知产生偏差。The current research on the risk of thermal runaway mostly focuses on the experiments and simulation studies of the thermal runaway risk of substances and reactions, but little attention has been paid to the evaluation methods of the thermal runaway risk of the process. The existing thermal runaway risk assessment methods mostly focus on the thermal risk of substances or reactions, but do not combine substances and reactions to assess the thermal runaway risk of the process, which may lead to deviations in the perception of the actual thermal runaway risk of the process.
目前用于评估热失控风险的方法多为仅适用于物质或反应,而较少将反应物质的热分解危险与反应阶段的失控风险结合评估。结合物质及反应过程的热失控风险评估工艺过程热失控危险度对于提升评估结果全面性及准确性具有重要意义。The current methods used to assess the risk of thermal runaway are mostly only applicable to substances or reactions, and rarely combine the risk of thermal decomposition of reactive substances with the risk of runaway in the reaction stage. The risk of thermal runaway in the process of evaluating the risk of thermal runaway that combines substances and reaction processes is of great significance for improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the assessment results.
发明内容Summary of the invention
本发明的目的是针对目前针对化工工艺过程热失控危险度的需求,提供一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,将物质热危险与反应失控风险结合,形成一种化工工艺过程热失控危险定量评估方法,从而综合体现物质与反应对工艺过程热失控危险的影响。The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in the chemical process in response to the current demand for the risk of thermal runaway in the chemical process, combining the thermal risk of substances with the risk of reaction runaway to form a chemical process thermal runaway A quantitative risk assessment method, which comprehensively reflects the influence of substances and reactions on the risk of thermal runaway in the process.
本发明是采取以下技术方案实现的:The present invention is realized by adopting the following technical solutions:
一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,具体步骤如下:A method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process. The specific steps are as follows:
1)收集原料、产物及反应过程的热危险性数据;1) Collect thermal hazard data of raw materials, products and reaction processes;
通过实验测试或查阅文献资料获取工艺所涉及的原料、产物热分解数据,以及反应过程的热失控风险特征数据,为后续评估提供数据支撑;Obtain the thermal decomposition data of the raw materials and products involved in the process through experimental tests or consulting literature, as well as the thermal runaway risk characteristic data of the reaction process, and provide data support for subsequent evaluation;
2)确定物质系数MF,所述物质系数MF由物质的起始分解温度T onset和最大放热功率MPD确定; 2) Determine the material coefficient MF, which is determined by the initial decomposition temperature Tonset of the material and the maximum exothermic power MPD;
3)确定反应热失控风险指数RI,RI为发生失控反应的后果严重度S和可能性P的乘积;3) Determine the reaction heat runaway risk index RI, which is the product of the consequence severity S and the possibility P of the runaway reaction;
4)计算工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI,并根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准确定工艺过程热失控危险度。4) Calculate the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determine the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard.
进一步的,所述步骤(2)确定物质系数MF的方法是测试所有原料的热稳定性,选择其中热稳定性最差的物质确定MF,具体包括如下步骤:Further, the method for determining the material coefficient MF in the step (2) is to test the thermal stability of all raw materials, and select the material with the worst thermal stability to determine the MF, which specifically includes the following steps:
2-1)确定热稳定性最差的物质的起始分解温度T onset2-1) Determine the initial decomposition temperature T onset of the material with the worst thermal stability;
2-2)确定热稳定性最差的物质的最大放热功率MPD;2-2) Determine the maximum heat release power MPD of the material with the worst thermal stability;
2-3)按照如下公式1计算得到物质系数MF;2-3) Calculate the material coefficient MF according to the following formula 1;
MF=1+I Tonset×I MPD/16      公式1; MF=1+I Tonset ×I MPD /16 formula 1;
I Tonset表示起始分解温度系数,I MPD表示最大放热功率系数; I Tonset represents the initial decomposition temperature coefficient, and I MPD represents the maximum heat release power coefficient;
所述I Tonset的数值通过T onset在表1中所属的数值范围对应确定;I MPD的数值通过MPD在表1中所属的数值范围对应确定。 The value of I Tonset is correspondingly determined by the value range of Tonset in Table 1; the value of I MPD is correspondingly determined by the value range of MPD in Table 1.
表1、物质系数MF取值表Table 1. Material coefficient MF value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000001
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000001
具体的规则是,当起始分解温度T onset大于300℃时,I Tonset系数为0;当T onset的数值在(200℃,300℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为1;当T onset的数值在(100℃,200℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为2;当T onset的数值在(50℃,100℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为3;当T onset的数值不大于50℃(即小于等于50℃)时,I Tonset系数为4。 The specific rule is that when the initial decomposition temperature Tonset is greater than 300°C, the I Tonset coefficient is 0; when the value of Tonset is in the interval (200°C, 300°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 1; when the value of Tonset is In the interval of (100℃, 200℃), the coefficient of I Tonset is 2; when the value of Tonset is in the interval of (50℃, 100℃], the coefficient of I Tonset is 3; when the value of Tonset is not greater than 50℃ (ie When the temperature is less than or equal to 50°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 4.
当最大放热功率MPD的数值小于0.01W/ml时,I MPD系数为0;当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[0.01W/ml,10W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为1;当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[10W/ml,100W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为2;当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[100W/ml,1000W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为3;当最大放热功率MPD的数值不小于1000W/ml(即大于等于1000W/ml)时,I MPD系数为4。 When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is less than 0.01W/ml, the I MPD coefficient is 0; when the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [0.01W/ml, 10W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 1; When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [10W/ml, 100W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 2; when the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [100W/ml, 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is not less than 1000W/ml (that is, greater than or equal to 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 4.
物质系数MF由物质的起始分解温度T onset和最大放热功率MPD确定,反映了物质发生热分解的危险大小;其中,T onset是指某物质开始发生分解的温度,该温度越低,说明该物质发生热分解的可能性越高;MPD是反映物质热分解过程的放热量和放热速率的指标,其值越大,表明物质热分解的后果越严重。 The material coefficient MF is determined by the material’s initial decomposition temperature Tonset and the maximum exothermic power MPD, reflecting the risk of thermal decomposition of the material; among them, Tonset refers to the temperature at which a material begins to decompose. The lower the temperature, the description The higher the possibility of thermal decomposition of the substance; MPD is an indicator reflecting the heat release and rate of heat release during the thermal decomposition of a substance. The larger the value, the more serious the consequences of the thermal decomposition of the substance.
物质系数MF对整个过程热失控危险度起修正作用,其取值范围限制在[1,2];如果参与反应的物质均为热稳定的,则物质系数MF就为1,物质系数不起修正作用,过程的本质热失控危险度只取决于反应过程的热失控危险;如果物质系数大于1,则物质的热危险性会增加整个过程的热失控危险性。The material coefficient MF corrects the risk of thermal runaway in the entire process, and its value range is limited to [1, 2]; if the substances involved in the reaction are thermally stable, the material coefficient MF is 1, and the material coefficient cannot be corrected. Function, the intrinsic thermal runaway risk of the process only depends on the thermal runaway risk of the reaction process; if the material coefficient is greater than 1, the thermal risk of the material will increase the thermal runaway risk of the entire process.
进一步的,所述步骤(3)确定反应热失控风险指数RI的具体方法,包括如下步骤:Further, the step (3) the specific method for determining the reaction heat runaway risk index RI includes the following steps:
3-1)确定失控后果严重度S;3-1) Determine the severity of the consequences of loss of control S;
同时选取反应热和绝热温升作为失控严重度指标以相互验证,并且以两者较大值确定失控后果严重度S;At the same time, the reaction heat and adiabatic temperature rise are selected as the out-of-control severity indicators for mutual verification, and the greater value of the two is used to determine the severity of the out-of-control consequences S;
具体方法为,分别求得目标反应的严重度系数S rx和二次反应的严重度系数S dec,最终得到反应失控的严重度系数S,计算公式如下, The specific method is to obtain the severity coefficient S rx of the target reaction and the severity coefficient S dec of the secondary reaction respectively, and finally obtain the severity coefficient S of the reaction out of control. The calculation formula is as follows:
S rx=max(I H,rx,I ΔTad,rx)   公式2; S rx =max(I H,rx ,I ΔTad,rx ) formula 2;
S dec=max(I H,dec,I ΔTad,dec)  公式3; S dec =max(I H,dec ,I ΔTad,dec ) Formula 3;
S=S rx+S dec     公式4; S = S rx + S dec formula 4;
式中I H,rx表示目标反应的反应热系数,I ΔTad,rx表示目标反应的绝热温升系数,取两者中的最大值确定目标反应的严重度系数S rx;I H,dec表示二次反应的反应热系数,I ΔTad,dec表示二次反应的绝热温升系数,取两者中的最大值确定二次反应的严重度系 数S decIn the formula, I H,rx represents the reaction heat coefficient of the target reaction, I ΔTad,rx represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the target reaction, and the maximum value of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient S rx of the target reaction; I H,dec means two The reaction heat coefficient of the secondary reaction, I ΔTad,dec represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the secondary reaction, and the maximum of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient of the secondary reaction S dec .
其中,目标反应和二次反应的严重度系数S rx和S dec的取值参照表2;其中I H表示反应热系数,I ΔTad表示绝热温升系数,ΔT ad表示反应绝热温升。 Among them, the values of the severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction refer to Table 2; where I H represents the heat coefficient of reaction, I ΔTad represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient, and ΔT ad represents the adiabatic temperature rise of the reaction.
表2、严重度S取值表Table 2. Severity S value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000002
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000002
具体的对应规则是:当反应热不大于100kJ/kg时,I H系数取值为1;当反应热在(100kJ/kg,400kJ/kg]区间时,I H系数取值为2;当反应热在(400kJ/kg,800kJ/kg]区间时,I H系数取值为3;当反应热大于800kJ/kg时,I H系数取值为4。根据上述规则,分别对目标反应和二次反应的反应热按照表2进行评估,得到相应的目标反应的反应热系数I H,rx和二次反应的反应热系数I H,decThe specific corresponding rules are: when the reaction heat is not greater than 100kJ/kg, the I H coefficient takes the value 1; when the reaction heat is in the interval of (100kJ/kg, 400kJ/kg), the I H coefficient takes the value 2. When the heat is in the range of (400kJ/kg, 800kJ/kg), the I H coefficient takes the value 3; when the reaction heat is greater than 800 kJ/kg, the I H coefficient takes the value 4. According to the above rules, the target reaction and the second The reaction heat of the reaction is evaluated according to Table 2, and the reaction heat coefficient I H,rx of the corresponding target reaction and the reaction heat coefficient I H,dec of the secondary reaction are obtained.
当反应绝热温升ΔT ad不大于50℃时,I ΔTad系数取值为1;当反应绝热温升ΔT ad在(50℃,200℃]区间时,I ΔTad系数取值为2;当反应绝热温升ΔT ad在(200℃,400℃]区间时,I ΔTad系数取值为3;当反应绝热温升ΔT ad大于400℃时,I ΔTad系数取值为4。根据上述规则,分别对目标反应和二次反应的绝热温升按照表2进行评估,得到相应的 目标反应的绝热温升系数I ΔTad,rx和二次反应的绝热温升系数I ΔTad,dec。 When the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad is not greater than 50°C, the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 1; when the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad is in the (50°C, 200°C) interval, the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 2; when the reaction is adiabatic When the temperature rise ΔT ad is in the interval of (200℃,400℃), the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 3; when the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad is greater than 400℃, the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 4. According to the above rules, the target The adiabatic temperature rise of the reaction and the secondary reaction is evaluated according to Table 2, and the corresponding adiabatic temperature rise coefficient I ΔTad,rx of the target reaction and the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient I ΔTad,dec of the secondary reaction are obtained.
反应失控后果严重度由目标反应和二次反应失控的严重度决定;对同一过程使用反应热判据和绝热温升判据可能得到不同的系数等级,为得到保守估计结果,本发明中同时选取反应热和绝热温升作为失控严重度指标以相互验证,并且以两者较大值确定S。实验中测试二次分解反应的放热数据时,尽量用含产物的反应体系混合物测试,更能反映实际过程的热失控危险度。The severity of the consequences of out-of-control reaction is determined by the severity of the target reaction and the out-of-control of the secondary reaction; using the reaction heat criterion and adiabatic temperature rise criterion for the same process may result in different coefficient levels. In order to obtain a conservative estimation result, both are selected in the present invention The heat of reaction and adiabatic temperature rise are used as indicators of the severity of the runaway to verify each other, and the larger value of the two is used to determine S. When testing the exothermic data of the secondary decomposition reaction in the experiment, try to use the reaction system mixture containing the product to test, which can better reflect the risk of thermal runaway in the actual process.
3-2)确定反应失控可能性P;3-2) Determine the possibility P of the reaction out of control;
反应失控可能性由最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad和失控情景危险度等级(criticalityclasses)确定;TMR ad表征了发生二次分解反应所需的时间,是时间维度的指标,其值越大,说明发生二次反应所需的时间越长,那么操作人员就有更充分的时间采取应急处置措施控制反应,最终引发二次反应的可能性就越低;失控情景危险度等级是从温度尺度上推断发生失控可能性的判据。 The possibility of reaction out of control is determined by the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad and the criticality classes of the out-of-control scenario; TMR ad represents the time required for the secondary decomposition reaction to occur and is an indicator of the time dimension. The larger the value, the greater the occurrence. The longer the time required for the secondary reaction, the more sufficient time the operator has to take emergency measures to control the reaction, and the lower the possibility of a secondary reaction eventually; the risk level of out-of-control scenarios is inferred from the temperature scale. The criterion for the possibility of loss of control.
以工艺操作温度T P、合成反应的最高温度MTSR、最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad为24小时对应的温度T D24和技术原因的最高温度MTT,这四个温度的相对大小关系将失控情景分为5类,失控情景危险度描述了失控发生的条件,级别越高发生二次反应的可能性越高。 Taking the process operating temperature T P , the maximum temperature of the synthesis reaction MTSR, the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad as 24 hours, the corresponding temperature T D24 and the maximum temperature MTT for technical reasons, the relative magnitude relationship of these four temperatures divides the out-of-control scenarios into Category 5, the risk of out-of-control scenarios describes the conditions under which out-of-control occurs. The higher the level, the higher the possibility of secondary reactions.
反应失控可能性P为最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR和危险度等级系数I CC之和,计算公式如下面的公式5。反应失控可能性P越大,发生失控反应的可能性越高。 The possibility of reaction out of control P is the sum of the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR and the risk level coefficient I CC . The calculation formula is as shown in the following formula 5. The greater the possibility P of an out of control reaction, the higher the possibility of an out of control reaction.
P=I TMR+I CC      公式5。 P=I TMR +I CC Formula 5.
下面的表3为反应失控可能性P取值表,在该表中,通过表3确定最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的数值所属取值范围,取得对应的最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR;通过表3确定失控情景危险度的关系所属取值范围,取得对应的危险度等级系数I CC;从而计算得到反应失控可能性P。 The following Table 3 is a value table for the possibility of reaction out of control P. In this table, determine the value range of the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad from Table 3, and obtain the corresponding maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR ; Table 3 determines the value range of the relationship between the risk of out-of-control scenarios, and obtains the corresponding risk level coefficient I CC ; thereby calculating the possibility of reaction out of control P.
表3、可能性P取值表Table 3. Possibility P value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000003
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000003
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000004
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000004
具体的规则是,当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值大于50h时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为1;当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(24h,50h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为2;当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(8h,24h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为3;当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(1h,8h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为4;当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值不大于1h(即小于等于1h)时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为5;其中,h表示小时。 The specific rule is that when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is greater than 50h, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 1; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is in the (24h, 50h) interval, the maximum The reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 2; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value is in the (8h, 24h) interval, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 3; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad value In the interval (1h, 8h), the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 4; when the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is not greater than 1h (that is, less than or equal to 1h), the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 5; Among them, h means hour.
当Tp<MTSR<MTT<T D24,危险度等级系数I CC为1;当Tp<MTSR<T D24<MTT,危险度等级系数I CC为2;当Tp<MTT<MTSR<T D24,危险度等级系数I CC为3;当Tp<MTT<T D24<MTSR,危险度等级系数I CC为4;当Tp<T D24<MTSR<MTT,危险度等级系数I CC为5。 When Tp<MTSR<MTT<T D24 , the risk level coefficient I CC is 1; when Tp<MTSR<T D24 <MTT, the risk level coefficient I CC is 2; when Tp<MTT<MTSR<T D24 , the risk level The grade coefficient I CC is 3; when Tp<MTT<T D24 <MTSR, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 4; when Tp<T D24 <MTSR<MTT, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 5.
3-3)根据所述步骤(3-1)确定的反应失控的严重度S和步骤(3-2)确定的可能性P后,通过公式6确定化工工艺过程热失控风险指数RI;3-3) After the severity S of the reaction out of control determined in step (3-1) and the possibility P determined in step (3-2), the thermal runaway risk index RI of the chemical process is determined by formula 6;
RI=S×P    公式6;RI=S×P Formula 6;
进一步的,步骤(4)计算工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI,并根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准确定工艺过程热失控危险度,其具体方法包括以下步骤:Further, step (4) calculates the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determines the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard. The specific method includes the following steps:
4-1)如公式7所示,将物质系数MF与反应失控风险指数RI的相乘得到ITHI值;4-1) As shown in formula 7, the ITHI value is obtained by multiplying the substance coefficient MF and the reaction out of control risk index RI;
ITHI=MF×RI       公式7;ITHI=MF×RI Formula 7;
4-2)根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准,对工艺过程热失控危险度进行分级并分析。4-2) According to ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard, classify and analyze the thermal runaway risk of the process.
步骤(4-2)中的ITHI热失控危险度分级标准如下表4:The ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards in step (4-2) are as follows:
表4、ITHI热失控危险度分级标准Table 4. ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards
范围range 等级grade 危险度Risk
<16<16 II 很低Very low
[16,32)[16,32) IIII 较低Lower
[32,48)[32,48) IIIIII 中等medium
[48,64)[48,64) IVIV 较高Higher
>64>64 VV 很高Very high
上述表4的含义是,当工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI(后面简称ITHI)值小于16时,属于第I危险等级,危险度很低;当ITHI值在[16,32)的区间时,属于第II危险等级,危险度较低;当ITHI值在[32,48)的区间时,属于第III危险等级,危险度中等;当ITHI值在[48,64)的区间时,属于第IV危险等级,危险度较高;当ITHI值不小于64时,属于第V危险等级,危险度很高。The meaning of Table 4 above is that when the thermal runaway risk index ITHI (hereinafter referred to as ITHI) value of the process is less than 16, it belongs to the first danger level and the risk is very low; when the ITHI value is in the interval of [16,32), It belongs to the second hazard level and the degree of risk is low; when the ITHI value is in the interval of [32,48), it belongs to the third hazard level and the degree of danger is medium; when the ITHI value is in the interval of [48,64), it belongs to the IV The danger level is high; when the ITHI value is not less than 64, it belongs to the V danger level and the danger level is very high.
本发明优点:Advantages of the invention:
本发明分别建立了原料的热失控危险系数及反应过程的热失控风险系数,并将两者结合评估工艺过程的热失控危险度,提升了评估结果的全面性与准确性;从物质与反应两方面评估,使不同工艺过程的热失控危险更具区分度,提升了热失控危险评估结果的辨识度,有利于实现工艺优选及本质安全化;本评估方法简单易理解,评估所需的数据在早期可通过实验获得,具有较强的可操作性,因此可用于设计初期阶段的热失控危险评估。The present invention separately establishes the thermal runaway risk coefficient of the raw materials and the thermal runaway risk coefficient of the reaction process, and combines the two to evaluate the thermal runaway risk of the process, thereby improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the evaluation results; In terms of evaluation, the thermal runaway hazards of different processes are more distinguished, and the recognition of the thermal runaway hazard assessment results is improved, which is conducive to the realization of process optimization and intrinsic safety. The assessment method is simple and easy to understand. The data required for the assessment is in It can be obtained through experiments in the early stage and has strong operability, so it can be used for the risk assessment of thermal runaway in the initial stage of design.
附图说明Description of the drawings
以下将结合附图对本发明作进一步说明:The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with the drawings:
图1是本发明一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法的流程图。Fig. 1 is a flowchart of a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to the present invention.
具体实施方式detailed description
下面结合附图1和具体实施例,对本发明方法做详细的说明。The method of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to FIG. 1 and specific embodiments.
参照附图1,本发明方法包括如下步骤:Referring to Figure 1, the method of the present invention includes the following steps:
步骤1、收集原料、产物及反应过程的热危险性数据;Step 1. Collect thermal hazard data of raw materials, products and reaction process;
通过实验测试或查阅文献资料获取工艺所涉及的原料、产物热分解数据,以及反应过程的热失控危险特征数据,为后续评估提供数据支撑;Obtain data on the thermal decomposition of raw materials and products involved in the process through experimental tests or consulting literature, as well as data on the thermal runaway hazard characteristics of the reaction process, and provide data support for subsequent evaluation;
步骤2、确定物质系数MF;Step 2. Determine the material factor MF;
物质系数MF由物质的起始分解温度(T onset)和最大放热功率(MPD)确定,反映了物质发生热分解的危险大小。T onset是指某物质开始发生分解的温度,该温度越低,说明该物质发生热分解的可能性越高。MPD是反映物质热分解过程的放热量和放热速率的指标,其值越大,表明物质热分解的后果越严重。MF对整个过程热失控危险度起修正作用,其取值范围限制在[1,2]。如果参与反应的物质均为热稳定的,则物质系数MF就为1,物质系数不起修正作用,过程的本质热失控危险度只取决于反应过程的热失控风险。如果物质系数大于1,则物质的热危险性会增加整个过程的热失控危险性。实际评估过程中需测试所有原料的热稳定性,选择其中热稳定性最差的物质确定MF,其计算公式如下; The material coefficient MF is determined by the initial decomposition temperature (T onset ) of the material and the maximum exothermic power (MPD), which reflects the risk of thermal decomposition of the material. Tonset refers to the temperature at which a substance begins to decompose. The lower the temperature, the higher the possibility of thermal decomposition of the substance. MPD is an indicator reflecting the heat release and rate of heat release during the thermal decomposition of a substance. The larger the value, the more serious the consequences of the thermal decomposition of the substance. MF can correct the risk of thermal runaway in the whole process, and its value range is limited to [1,2]. If the substances involved in the reaction are all thermally stable, the material coefficient MF is 1, and the material coefficient has no corrective effect. The intrinsic thermal runaway risk of the process only depends on the thermal runaway risk of the reaction process. If the material coefficient is greater than 1, the thermal risk of the material will increase the risk of thermal runaway in the entire process. In the actual evaluation process, the thermal stability of all raw materials needs to be tested, and the material with the worst thermal stability is selected to determine the MF. The calculation formula is as follows:
MF=1+I Tonset×I MPD/16      (1) MF=1+I Tonset ×I MPD /16 (1)
通过下表1确定物质系数MF:Determine the material factor MF by following Table 1:
表1、物质系数MF取值表Table 1. Material coefficient MF value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000005
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000005
步骤3、确定反应失控风险指数RI;Step 3. Determine the risk index RI for out-of-control reaction;
反应失控风险指数为发生失控反应的后果严重度(S)和可能性(P)的乘积,根据步骤3-1、3-2依次确定S和P;The reaction out-of-control risk index is the product of the consequence severity (S) and the probability (P) of the out-of-control reaction, and S and P are determined in sequence according to steps 3-1 and 3-2;
步骤3-1、确定失控后果严重度S;Step 3-1: Determine the severity S of the consequences of losing control;
反应失控后果严重度由目标反应和二次反应失控的严重度决定。对同一过程使用反应热判据和绝热温升判据可能得到不同的系数等级,为得到保守估计结果,本发明中同时选取反应热和绝热温升作为失控严重度指标以相互验证,并且以两者较大值确定S。实验中测试二次分解反应的放热数据时,尽量用含产物的反应体系混合物测试,更能反映实际过程的热失控危险度。分别求得目标反应和二次反应的严重度系数S rx和S dec,最终得到反应失控的严重度系数S,其中,目标反应和二次反应的严重度系数S rx和S dec的取值参照表2。其计算公式如下: The severity of the consequences of a reaction out of control is determined by the severity of the target reaction and the second reaction out of control. Using the reaction heat criterion and adiabatic temperature rise criterion for the same process may result in different coefficient levels. In order to obtain a conservative estimation result, the present invention simultaneously selects reaction heat and adiabatic temperature rise as indicators of the out-of-control severity for mutual verification, and the two The larger value determines S. When testing the exothermic data of the secondary decomposition reaction in the experiment, try to use the reaction system mixture containing the product to test, which can better reflect the risk of thermal runaway in the actual process. The severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction are obtained respectively, and the severity coefficient S of the reaction out of control is finally obtained. The value of the severity coefficients S rx and S dec of the target reaction and the secondary reaction is referred to Table 2. The calculation formula is as follows:
S rx=max(I H,rx,I ΔTad,rx)  (2) S rx =max(I H,rx ,I ΔTad,rx ) (2)
S dec=max(I H,dec,I ΔTad,dec)  (3) S dec =max(I H,dec ,I ΔTad,dec ) (3)
S=S rx+S dec    (4) S=S rx +S dec (4)
表2、严重度S取值表Table 2. Severity S value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000006
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000006
步骤3-2、确定反应失控可能性P;Step 3-2. Determine the possibility P of the reaction out of control;
反应失控可能性由最大反应速率到达时间(TMR ad)和失控情景危险度等级(criticality classes)确定。TMR ad表征了发生二次分解反应所需的时间,是时间维度的指标,其值越大,说明发生二次反应所需的时间越长,那么操作人员就有更充分的时间采取应急处置措施控制反应,最终引发二次反应的可能性就越低。失控情景危险度等级是从温度尺度上推断发生失控可能性的判据。以工艺操作温度(T P)、合成反应的最高温度(MTSR)、TMR ad为24小时对应的温度(T D24)和技术原因的最高温度(MTT)四个温度的相对大小关系将失控情景分为5类,失控情景危险度等级描述了失控发生的条件,级别越高发生二次反应的可能性越高。反应失控可能性P为最大反应速率到达时间系数和失控危险度等级系数之和,P越大,发生失控反应的可能性越高。 The possibility of reaction out of control is determined by the time to reach the maximum reaction rate (TMR ad ) and the criticality classes of the out-of-control scenario. TMR ad characterizes the time required for the secondary decomposition reaction and is an indicator of the time dimension. The larger the value, the longer the time required for the secondary reaction to occur, and the operator has more time to take emergency measures. Control the reaction, the lower the possibility of a secondary reaction eventually. The risk level of out-of-control scenarios is a criterion for inferring the possibility of out-of-control from the temperature scale. Based on the process operating temperature ( TP ), the maximum temperature of the synthesis reaction (MTSR), the temperature corresponding to 24 hours of TMR ad (T D24 ), and the maximum temperature (MTT) for technical reasons, the relative magnitude of the four temperature relationships will be divided into out-of-control scenarios. There are five categories. The risk level of out-of-control scenarios describes the conditions under which out-of-control occurs. The higher the level, the higher the possibility of secondary reactions. The possibility of out-of-control reaction P is the sum of the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient and the out-of-control risk level coefficient. The greater the P, the higher the possibility of an out-of-control reaction.
反应失控可能性P的计算公式如下公式5:The calculation formula for the possibility of reaction out of control P is as follows:
P=I TMR+I CC     (5) P=I TMR +I CC (5)
下表3为可能性P取值表,在该表中,通过表3确定最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的数值所属取值范围,取得对应的最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR;通过表3确定失控情景危险度的关系所属取值范围,取得对应的危险度等级系数I CC;从而计算得到反应失控可能性P。 Table 3 below is the value table of possibility P. In this table, determine the value range of the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad from Table 3, and obtain the corresponding maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR ; determine it from Table 3 The value range of the relationship between the risk of out-of-control scenarios belongs to, and the corresponding risk level coefficient I CC is obtained; thus, the possibility of reaction out of control P is calculated.
表3、可能性P取值表Table 3. Possibility P value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000007
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000007
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000008
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000008
步骤3-3、确定了反应失控的严重度S和可能性P之后,通过下式确定化工工艺过程热失控风险指数RI。Step 3-3. After determining the severity S and the possibility P of the reaction out of control, the thermal runaway risk index RI of the chemical process is determined by the following formula.
RI=S×P     (6)RI=S×P (6)
步骤4、计算工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI,并根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准确定工艺过程热失控危险度。Step 4. Calculate the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determine the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard.
步骤4-1、将物质系数MF与反应失控风险指数RI的相乘得到ITHI值;Step 4-1: Multiply the substance coefficient MF and the reaction out of control risk index RI to obtain the ITHI value;
ITHI=MF×RI          (7)ITHI=MF×RI (7)
步骤4-2、根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准,对工艺过程热失控危险度进行分级并分析。ITHI热失控危险度分级标准如下表4:Step 4-2. According to ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard, classify and analyze the thermal runaway risk of the process. The ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards are as follows:
表4、ITHI热失控危险度分级标准Table 4. ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standards
范围range 等级grade 危险度Risk
<16<16 II 很低Very low
[16,32)[16,32) IIII 较低Lower
[32,48)[32,48) IIIIII 中等medium
[48,64)[48,64) IVIV 较高Higher
≥64≥64 VV 很高Very high
下面结合实例对本发明作进一步详细的阐述。The present invention will be further elaborated below in conjunction with examples.
环己酮过氧化的反应原料是环己酮210g,浓度≥30%的过氧化氢与硝酸混合溶液60g,反应条件为温度12℃,搅拌桨转速250r/min,产物为过氧化环己酮;其反应公式如下:The raw material for the reaction of cyclohexanone peroxidation is 210g cyclohexanone, 60g of a mixed solution of hydrogen peroxide and nitric acid with a concentration of ≥30%, the reaction condition is a temperature of 12°C, a stirring blade speed of 250r/min, and the product is cyclohexanone peroxide; The reaction formula is as follows:
2C 6H 10O+2H 2O 2→C 12H 22O 5+H 2O。 2C 6 H 10 O+2H 2 O 2 →C 12 H 22 O 5 +H 2 O.
1)通过实验测试或查阅文献资料获取环己酮过氧化工艺过程所涉及的原料、产物热分解数据,以及反应过程的热失控风险特征数据,1) Obtain the thermal decomposition data of the raw materials and products involved in the cyclohexanone peroxidation process, as well as the thermal runaway risk characteristic data of the reaction process through experimental tests or consulting literature.
2)确定环己酮过氧化工艺过程的物质系数MF。通过实验和文献获取反应原料环己酮、过氧化氢溶液的热分解数据,如下如环己酮过氧化工艺物质系数MF取值表。过氧 化氢溶液的热危险性高于环己酮,故以过氧化氢溶液的热分解数据确定物质系数,最后根据步骤2中公式(1)确定MF为1.75。2) Determine the material factor MF of the cyclohexanone peroxidation process. Obtain the thermal decomposition data of the reaction raw material cyclohexanone and hydrogen peroxide solution through experiments and literature, as shown in the following table for the material coefficient MF value table of cyclohexanone peroxide process. The thermal hazard of hydrogen peroxide solution is higher than that of cyclohexanone, so the material coefficient is determined by the thermal decomposition data of hydrogen peroxide solution. Finally, the MF is determined to be 1.75 according to formula (1) in step 2.
环己酮过氧化工艺物质系数MF取值表Cyclohexanone peroxidation process material coefficient MF value table
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000009
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000009
3)确定反应失控风险指数RI3) Determine the RI
依次将环己酮过氧化反应的热危险参数代入,得到失控的严重度S、可能性P分别为5、8,如下表。Substituting the thermal hazard parameters of the cyclohexanone peroxidation reaction in turn, the severity S and the probability P of the out-of-control are 5 and 8, respectively, as shown in the following table.
环己酮过氧化工艺失控严重度SCyclohexanone peroxidation process out of control severity S
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000010
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000010
环己酮过氧化工艺失控可能性PThe possibility of out-of-control cyclohexanone peroxidation process P
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000011
Figure PCTCN2019100569-appb-000011
根据步骤3-3中公式(6)得到环己酮过氧化失控的风险系数为RI=S×P=40。According to formula (6) in step 3-3, the risk coefficient of cyclohexanone peroxidation out of control is RI=S×P=40.
4)最后根据公式(7)得到ITHI=MF×RI=70,按照步骤4-2的ITHI热失控危险度分级标准,认为环己酮过氧化工艺过程的热失控危险度是极高的,不可接受的。4) Finally, according to formula (7), ITHI=MF×RI=70 is obtained. According to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard in step 4-2, it is considered that the thermal runaway risk of cyclohexanone peroxidation process is extremely high. Accepted.
本发明提出了一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,由物质系数(MF)与反应失控风险指数(RI)构成。物质系数MF由物质的起始分解温度和最大功率密度确定。反应失控风险指数RI通过失控可能性和严重度确定。绝热条件下的最大反应速率到达时间和失控危险度等级用于确定该工艺过程的失控可能性。失控反应的严重程度由目标反应和二次反应的绝热温升确定。最后,使用预先定义的危险等级对ITHI评估结果进行定级和分析。本发明将物质与反应的热失控风险结合评估工艺过程的热失控危险度,提升了评估结果的全面性与准确性。并且从物质与反应两方面评估,使不同工艺过程的热失控危险度更具区分性,提升了热失控危险度评估结果的辨识度,有利于实现工艺优选及本质安全化。此外,本发明简单易理解,评估所需的数据在早期均可通过实验获得,可操作性较强,因此可用于设计初期阶段的热失控危险度评估,为工艺优选及危害辨识提供参照依据。The invention proposes a method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process, which is composed of a material coefficient (MF) and a reaction runaway risk index (RI). The material coefficient MF is determined by the initial decomposition temperature of the material and the maximum power density. The reaction out-of-control risk index RI is determined by the possibility and severity of out-of-control. The time to reach the maximum reaction rate under adiabatic conditions and the out-of-control risk level are used to determine the possibility of out-of-control in the process. The severity of the runaway reaction is determined by the adiabatic temperature rise of the target reaction and the secondary reaction. Finally, use pre-defined hazard levels to grade and analyze the ITHI assessment results. The present invention combines the thermal runaway risk of substances and reactions to evaluate the thermal runaway risk of the technological process, thereby improving the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the evaluation result. In addition, the evaluation from the two aspects of material and reaction makes the risk of thermal runaway of different processes more distinguishable, improves the recognition of the evaluation results of thermal runaway risk, and is conducive to the realization of process optimization and intrinsic safety. In addition, the present invention is simple and easy to understand, the data required for evaluation can be obtained through experiments in the early stage, and the operability is strong. Therefore, it can be used for the evaluation of the risk of thermal runaway in the initial stage of design, and provides a reference basis for process optimization and hazard identification.

Claims (8)

  1. 一种评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,包括如下步骤:A method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process is characterized by comprising the following steps:
    1)收集原料、产物及反应过程的热危险性数据;1) Collect thermal hazard data of raw materials, products and reaction processes;
    通过实验测试或查阅文献资料获取工艺所涉及的原料、产物热分解数据,以及反应过程的热失控风险特征数据,为后续评估提供数据支撑;Obtain the thermal decomposition data of the raw materials and products involved in the process through experimental tests or consulting literature, as well as the thermal runaway risk characteristic data of the reaction process, and provide data support for subsequent evaluation;
    2)确定物质系数MF,所述物质系数MF由物质的起始分解温度T onset和最大放热功率MPD确定; 2) Determine the material coefficient MF, which is determined by the initial decomposition temperature Tonset of the material and the maximum exothermic power MPD;
    3)确定反应热失控风险指数RI,RI为发生失控反应的后果严重度S和可能性P的乘积;3) Determine the reaction heat runaway risk index RI, which is the product of the consequence severity S and the possibility P of the runaway reaction;
    4)计算工艺过程的热失控危险度指数ITHI,并根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准确定工艺过程热失控危险度。4) Calculate the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determine the thermal runaway risk of the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard.
  2. 根据权利要求1所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,所述步骤(2)确定物质系数MF的方法是测试所有原料的热稳定性,选择其中热稳定性最差的物质确定MF,具体包括如下步骤:The method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 1, wherein the method for determining the material coefficient MF in step (2) is to test the thermal stability of all raw materials, and select the worst thermal stability To determine the MF of the substance, it includes the following steps:
    2-1)确定热稳定性最差的物质的起始分解温度T onset2-1) Determine the initial decomposition temperature T onset of the material with the worst thermal stability;
    2-2)确定热稳定性最差的物质的最大放热功率MPD;2-2) Determine the maximum heat release power MPD of the material with the worst thermal stability;
    2-3)按照如下公式1计算得到物质系数MF;2-3) Calculate the material coefficient MF according to the following formula 1;
    MF=1+I Tonset×I MPD/16    公式1; MF=1+I Tonset ×I MPD /16 formula 1;
    其中,I Tonset表示起始分解温度系数,I MPD表示最大放热功率系数。 Among them, I Tonset represents the initial decomposition temperature coefficient, and I MPD represents the maximum heat release power coefficient.
  3. 根据权利要求2所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,确定所述起始分解温度系数I Tonset和最大放热功率系数I MPD的规则如下: The method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 2, wherein the rules for determining the initial decomposition temperature coefficient I Tonset and the maximum heat release power coefficient I MPD are as follows:
    当起始分解温度T onset大于300℃时,I Tonset系数为0; When the initial decomposition temperature Tonset is greater than 300°C, the I Tonset coefficient is 0;
    当T onset的数值在(200℃,300℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为1; When the value of Tonset is in the interval of (200℃, 300℃), the coefficient of I Tonset is 1;
    当T onset的数值在(100℃,200℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为2; When the value of Tonset is in the interval of (100°C, 200°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 2;
    当T onset的数值在(50℃,100℃]区间时,I Tonset系数为3; When the value of Tonset is in the interval of (50°C, 100°C), the I Tonset coefficient is 3;
    当T onset的数值不大于50℃,即小于等于50℃时,I Tonset系数为4; When the value of Tonset is not greater than 50°C, that is, less than or equal to 50°C, the I Tonset coefficient is 4;
    当最大放热功率MPD的数值小于0.01W/ml时,I MPD系数为0; When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is less than 0.01W/ml, the I MPD coefficient is 0;
    当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[0.01W/ml,10W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为1; When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [0.01W/ml, 10W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 1;
    当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[10W/ml,100W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为2; When the maximum heat release power MPD value is in the range of [10W/ml, 100W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 2;
    当最大放热功率MPD的数值在[100W/ml,1000W/ml)区间时,I MPD系数为3; When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is in the range of [100W/ml, 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 3;
    当最大放热功率MPD的数值不小于1000W/ml(即大于等于1000W/ml)时,I MPD系数为4。 When the value of the maximum heat release power MPD is not less than 1000W/ml (that is, greater than or equal to 1000W/ml), the I MPD coefficient is 4.
  4. 根据权利要求1所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,所述步骤(3)确定反应热失控风险指数RI的具体方法,包括如下步骤:The method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 1, wherein the step (3) determines the specific method for the risk index RI of thermal runaway of reaction, comprising the following steps:
    3-1)确定失控后果严重度S;3-1) Determine the severity of the consequences of loss of control S;
    同时选取反应热和绝热温升作为失控严重度指标以相互验证,并且以两者较大值确定失控后果严重度S;At the same time, the reaction heat and adiabatic temperature rise are selected as the out-of-control severity indicators for mutual verification, and the greater value of the two is used to determine the severity of the out-of-control consequences S;
    3-2)确定反应失控可能性P;3-2) Determine the possibility P of the reaction out of control;
    反应失控可能性P为最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR和危险度等级系数I CC之和,计算公式如下面的公式5;反应失控可能性P越大,发生 失控反应的可能性越高; The reaction out-of-control possibility P is the sum of the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR and the risk level coefficient I CC , calculated as the following formula 5; the greater the reaction out-of-control possibility P, the higher the possibility of an out-of-control reaction;
    P=I TMR+I CC     公式5; P = I TMR + I CC formula 5;
    3-3)根据所述步骤(3-1)确定的反应失控的严重度S和步骤(3-2)确定的可能性P后,通过公式6确定化工工艺过程热失控风险指数RI;3-3) After the severity S of the reaction out of control determined in step (3-1) and the possibility P determined in step (3-2), the thermal runaway risk index RI of the chemical process is determined by formula 6;
    RI=S×P    公式6。RI=S×P Formula 6.
  5. 根据权利要求4所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,所述步骤(3-1)中,确定失控后果严重度S的具体方法为,分别求得目标反应的严重度系数S rx和二次反应的严重度系数S dec,最终得到反应失控的严重度系数S,计算公式如下, The method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 4, characterized in that, in the step (3-1), the specific method for determining the severity S of the runaway consequences is to obtain the severity of the target reaction respectively. The degree coefficient S rx and the severity coefficient of the secondary reaction S dec , finally get the severity coefficient S of the reaction out of control. The calculation formula is as follows:
    S rx=max(I H,rx,I ΔTad,rx)   公式2; S rx =max(I H,rx ,I ΔTad,rx ) formula 2;
    S dec=max(I H,dec,I ΔTad,dec)   公式3; S dec =max(I H,dec ,I ΔTad,dec ) Formula 3;
    S=S rx+S dec        公式4; S = S rx + S dec formula 4;
    式中I H,rx表示目标反应的反应热系数,I ΔTad,rx表示目标反应的绝热温升系数,取两者中的最大值确定目标反应的严重度系数S rx;I H,dec表示二次反应的反应热系数,I ΔTad,dec表示二次反应的绝热温升系数,取两者中的最大值确定二次反应的严重度系数S decIn the formula, I H,rx represents the reaction heat coefficient of the target reaction, I ΔTad,rx represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the target reaction, and the maximum value of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient S rx of the target reaction; I H,dec means two The reaction heat coefficient of the secondary reaction, I ΔTad,dec represents the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the secondary reaction, and the maximum of the two is used to determine the severity coefficient of the secondary reaction S dec ;
    目标反应的严重度系数S rx和二次反应的严重度系数S dec的具体取值规则如下: The specific value rules for the severity coefficient of the target reaction S rx and the severity coefficient of the secondary reaction S dec are as follows:
    当反应热不大于100kJ/kg时,I H系数取值为1; When the reaction heat is not more than 100kJ/kg, the I H coefficient is set to 1;
    当反应热在(100kJ/kg,400kJ/kg]区间时,I H系数取值为2; When the reaction heat is in the range of (100kJ/kg, 400kJ/kg), the I H coefficient is set to 2;
    当反应热在(400kJ/kg,800kJ/kg]区间时,I H系数取值为3; When the reaction heat is in the range of (400kJ/kg, 800kJ/kg), the I H coefficient is set to 3;
    当反应热大于800kJ/kg时,I H系数取值为4; When the reaction heat is greater than 800kJ/kg, the I H coefficient is set to 4;
    根据上述规则,分别对目标反应和二次反应的反应热进行评估,得到 相应的目标反应的反应热系数I H,rx和二次反应的反应热系数I H,decAccording to the above rules, the reaction heats of the target reaction and the secondary reaction are evaluated respectively, and the corresponding reaction heat coefficients I H,rx of the target reaction and the reaction heat coefficients I H,dec of the secondary reaction are obtained;
    当反应绝热温升ΔT ad不大于50℃时,I ΔTad系数取值为1; When the adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad of the reaction is not greater than 50°C, the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 1;
    当反应绝热温升ΔT ad在(50℃,200℃]区间时,I ΔTad系数取值为2; When the adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad of the reaction is in the interval of (50℃,200℃), the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 2;
    当反应绝热温升ΔT ad在(200℃,400℃]区间时,I ΔTad系数取值为3; When the reaction adiabatic temperature rise ΔT ad is in the interval of (200℃,400℃), the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 3;
    当反应绝热温升ΔT ad大于400℃时,I ΔTad系数取值为4;根据上述规则,分别对目标反应和二次反应的绝热温升进行评估,得到相应的目标反应的绝热温升系数I ΔTad,rx和二次反应的绝热温升系数I ΔTad,decWhen the adiabatic temperature rise of the reaction ΔT ad is greater than 400°C, the I ΔTad coefficient takes the value 4; according to the above rules, the adiabatic temperature rise of the target reaction and the secondary reaction are evaluated separately to obtain the corresponding adiabatic temperature rise coefficient I of the target reaction ΔTad,rx and the adiabatic temperature rise coefficient of the secondary reaction I ΔTad,dec .
  6. 根据权利要求4所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,所述步骤(3-2)中,反应失控可能性由最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad和失控情景危险度等级确定;TMR ad表征了发生二次分解反应所需的时间,是时间维度的指标,其值越大,说明发生二次反应所需的时间越长,那么操作人员就有更充分的时间采取应急处置措施控制反应,最终引发二次反应的可能性就越低;失控情景危险度等级是从温度尺度上推断发生失控可能性的判据; The method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 4, characterized in that, in the step (3-2), the possibility of reaction runaway is determined from the maximum reaction rate reaching time TMR ad and the risk level of the runaway scenario Confirm; TMR ad characterizes the time required for the secondary decomposition reaction and is an indicator of the time dimension. The larger the value, the longer the time required for the secondary reaction to occur, and the operator has more time to take emergency response Disposal measures control the reaction, the lower the possibility of a secondary reaction will eventually be triggered; the risk level of out-of-control scenarios is the criterion for inferring the possibility of out-of-control from the temperature scale;
    以工艺操作温度T P、合成反应的最高温度MTSR、最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad为24小时对应的温度T D24和技术原因的最高温度MTT,这四个温度的相对大小关系将失控情景分为5类,失控情景危险度描述了失控发生的条件,级别越高发生二次反应的可能性越高; Taking the process operating temperature T P , the maximum temperature of the synthesis reaction MTSR, the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad as 24 hours, the corresponding temperature T D24 and the maximum temperature MTT for technical reasons, the relative magnitude relationship of these four temperatures divides the out-of-control scenarios into Category 5: The risk of out-of-control scenarios describes the conditions under which out-of-control occurs. The higher the level, the higher the possibility of secondary reactions;
    最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR的取值规则包括: The value rules for the maximum response rate arrival time coefficient I TMR include:
    当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值大于50h时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为1; When the value of the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is greater than 50h, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 1;
    当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(24h,50h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为2; When the maximum response rate arrival time TMR ad is in the (24h, 50h) interval, the maximum response rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 2;
    当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(8h,24h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为3; When the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is in the interval (8h, 24h), the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 3;
    当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值在(1h,8h]区间时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为4; When the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is in the (1h, 8h) interval, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 4;
    当最大反应速率到达时间TMR ad的值不大于1h,即小于等于1h时,最大反应速率到达时间系数I TMR为5; When the value of the maximum reaction rate arrival time TMR ad is not greater than 1h, that is, less than or equal to 1h, the maximum reaction rate arrival time coefficient I TMR is 5;
    危险度等级系数I CC的取值规则包括: The value rules for the risk level coefficient I CC include:
    当Tp<MTSR<MTT<T D24,危险度等级系数I CC为1;当Tp<MTSR<T D24<MTT,危险度等级系数I CC为2;当Tp<MTT<MTSR<T D24,危险度等级系数I CC为3;当Tp<MTT<T D24<MTSR,危险度等级系数I CC为4;当Tp<T D24<MTSR<MTT,危险度等级系数I CC为5。 When Tp<MTSR<MTT<T D24 , the risk level coefficient I CC is 1; when Tp<MTSR<T D24 <MTT, the risk level coefficient I CC is 2; when Tp<MTT<MTSR<T D24 , the risk level The grade coefficient I CC is 3; when Tp<MTT<T D24 <MTSR, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 4; when Tp<T D24 <MTSR<MTT, the risk grade coefficient I CC is 5.
  7. 根据权利要求1所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,所述步骤(4)计算工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI,并根据ITHI热失控危险度分级标准确定工艺过程热失控危险度,其具体方法包括以下步骤:The method for evaluating the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 1, wherein the step (4) calculates the thermal runaway risk index ITHI of the process, and determines the process according to the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard The specific method for the risk of thermal runaway includes the following steps:
    4-1)如公式7所示,将物质系数MF与反应失控风险指数RI的相乘得到ITHI值;4-1) As shown in formula 7, the ITHI value is obtained by multiplying the substance coefficient MF and the reaction out of control risk index RI;
    ITHI=MF×RI     公式7;ITHI=MF×RI Formula 7;
    4-2)根据ITHI热失控风险度分级标准,对工艺过程热失控危险度进行分级并分析。4-2) According to ITHI's thermal runaway risk grading standard, classify and analyze the thermal runaway risk of the process.
  8. 根据权利要求1所述的评估化工工艺过程热失控危险度的方法,其特征在于,步骤(4-2)中所述的ITHI热失控危险度分级标准如下:当工艺过程的热失控危险指数ITHI值小于16时,属于第I危险等级,危险度很低; 当ITHI值在[16,32)的区间时,属于第II危险等级,危险度较低;当ITHI值在[32,48)的区间时,属于第III危险等级,危险度中等;当ITHI值在[48,64)的区间时,属于第IV危险等级,危险度较高;当ITHI值不小于64时,属于第V危险等级,危险度很高。The method for assessing the risk of thermal runaway in a chemical process according to claim 1, characterized in that the ITHI thermal runaway risk classification standard in step (4-2) is as follows: When the thermal runaway risk index of the process is ITHI When the value is less than 16, it belongs to the first hazard level and the degree of danger is very low; when the ITHI value is in the interval of [16,32), it belongs to the second hazard level, and the degree of danger is low; when the ITHI value is in [32,48) In the interval, it belongs to the third hazard level and the degree of danger is medium; when the ITHI value is in the interval of [48,64), it belongs to the IV hazard level and the degree of danger is high; when the ITHI value is not less than 64, it belongs to the V hazard level , The risk is high.
PCT/CN2019/100569 2019-08-13 2019-08-14 Method for assessing risk of thermal runaway in chemical process WO2021026810A1 (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
ZA2020/05471A ZA202005471B (en) 2019-08-13 2020-09-02 Thermal runaway hazard evaluation method of chemical process

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201910743160.8A CN110414868B (en) 2019-08-13 2019-08-13 Method for evaluating thermal runaway risk degree in chemical process
CN201910743160.8 2019-08-13

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
WO2021026810A1 true WO2021026810A1 (en) 2021-02-18

Family

ID=68367197

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
PCT/CN2019/100569 WO2021026810A1 (en) 2019-08-13 2019-08-14 Method for assessing risk of thermal runaway in chemical process

Country Status (3)

Country Link
CN (1) CN110414868B (en)
WO (1) WO2021026810A1 (en)
ZA (1) ZA202005471B (en)

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN117314167A (en) * 2023-10-17 2023-12-29 山东润博安全科技有限公司 Continuous flow gas phase reaction safety risk assessment method in tubular reactor

Families Citing this family (8)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN111382502B (en) * 2020-02-25 2023-05-02 智慧航海(青岛)科技有限公司 Ship simulation platform motion protection method and mechanism
CN113724794A (en) * 2020-05-25 2021-11-30 中国石油化工股份有限公司 Method and system for monitoring and early warning out of control of chemical reaction
CN112102892B (en) * 2020-08-17 2023-05-09 西安近代化学研究所 Method for determining temperature correction coefficient of energetic material combination process
CN112033997B (en) * 2020-08-17 2023-02-14 西安近代化学研究所 Explosive thermal stability grading method based on differential scanning calorimetry
CN112033998B (en) * 2020-08-17 2023-04-18 西安近代化学研究所 Thermal insulation acceleration calorimetry-based explosive material thermal stability grading method
CN113283070B (en) * 2021-05-20 2021-12-17 中国安全生产科学研究院 Intelligent diagnosis method and system for intrinsic safety of technological process
CN115273998B (en) * 2022-08-17 2023-07-28 沈阳化工研究院有限公司 Chemical reaction risk analysis method
CN116882328B (en) * 2023-09-08 2023-12-05 中国特种设备检测研究院 Early warning and multistage intelligent emergency response method for reactive hot air danger

Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
KR20130003848A (en) * 2011-07-01 2013-01-09 부경대학교 산학협력단 System and method for heat wave monitoring using time dependent function on heat stress
CN104504293A (en) * 2015-01-14 2015-04-08 南京理工大学 Method for evaluating thermal explosion risk of material by fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method
CN106875126A (en) * 2017-03-07 2017-06-20 中国石油化工股份有限公司 A kind of physical hazard serialization natural hazard risk appraisal procedure
CN108345986A (en) * 2018-01-19 2018-07-31 杭州电子科技大学 A kind of chemical industry danger source dynamic quantization appraisal procedure
CN109389256A (en) * 2017-08-02 2019-02-26 南京理工大学 Utilize the method for polynary dust explosion parametric synthesis assessment combustible dust explosion danger grade
CN109949874A (en) * 2019-04-16 2019-06-28 南京工业大学 A kind of risk stratification method of fine chemistry industry production process security evaluation
EP3505832A1 (en) * 2017-12-27 2019-07-03 Brunnshög Energi AB Method for controlling a thermal distribution system

Family Cites Families (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
SG151122A1 (en) * 2007-09-12 2009-04-30 Natarajan Krishnamurthy System and method for risk assessment and management
CN102980972B (en) * 2012-11-06 2015-06-03 南京工业大学 Method for determining hot dangerousness of self-reactive chemical substance

Patent Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
KR20130003848A (en) * 2011-07-01 2013-01-09 부경대학교 산학협력단 System and method for heat wave monitoring using time dependent function on heat stress
CN104504293A (en) * 2015-01-14 2015-04-08 南京理工大学 Method for evaluating thermal explosion risk of material by fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method
CN106875126A (en) * 2017-03-07 2017-06-20 中国石油化工股份有限公司 A kind of physical hazard serialization natural hazard risk appraisal procedure
CN109389256A (en) * 2017-08-02 2019-02-26 南京理工大学 Utilize the method for polynary dust explosion parametric synthesis assessment combustible dust explosion danger grade
EP3505832A1 (en) * 2017-12-27 2019-07-03 Brunnshög Energi AB Method for controlling a thermal distribution system
CN108345986A (en) * 2018-01-19 2018-07-31 杭州电子科技大学 A kind of chemical industry danger source dynamic quantization appraisal procedure
CN109949874A (en) * 2019-04-16 2019-06-28 南京工业大学 A kind of risk stratification method of fine chemistry industry production process security evaluation

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN117314167A (en) * 2023-10-17 2023-12-29 山东润博安全科技有限公司 Continuous flow gas phase reaction safety risk assessment method in tubular reactor

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
ZA202005471B (en) 2021-07-28
CN110414868A (en) 2019-11-05
CN110414868B (en) 2022-12-13

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
WO2021026810A1 (en) Method for assessing risk of thermal runaway in chemical process
CN109949874B (en) Risk grading method for safety assessment in fine chemical production process
Faraway Distribution of the admixture test for the detection of linkage under heterogeneity
Shen et al. Process safety evaluation of the synthesis of tert-butyl peracetate
Wang et al. Thermal research on the uncontrolled behavior of styrene bulk polymerization
US11846675B2 (en) Battery temperature estimation method and apparatus, electronic device, and storage medium
Liu et al. Applications of thermal hazard analyses on process safety assessments
CN109406726A (en) A kind of polyolefin catalyst kinetic assay device and method
CN105844478A (en) Product quality sampling method used for cross-border electronic commerce
CN109752292A (en) A kind of test method of the particle size and its distribution of three aluminum hydrides
CN110531276B (en) Battery condition detection method and device
Chicoma et al. In‐Line Monitoring of Particle Size during Emulsion Polymerization under Different Operational Conditions using NIR Spectroscopy
Maria et al. Comparative evaluation of critical operating conditions for a tubular catalytic reactor using thermal sensitivity and loss-of-stability criteria
US20240060919A1 (en) Chemical reaction hazard analysis method
Biernath et al. Model-based zero emission safety concept for reactors with exothermal reactions for chemical plants
Yang et al. A new method for assessing the thermal hazard of reactive substances
Li et al. Thermal stability and decomposition mechanism analysis of 1, 1’-Azobis (cyclohexanecarbonitrile) by STA, DSC, ARC and TG-FTIR
Bind et al. Effect of hydrogen isotopes on tensile and fracture properties of Zr–2.5 Nb pressure tube material
CN110457721A (en) Method is determined based on the chemical industry safety operation domain of global parameter sensitivity analysis
Gloor et al. Developing feed policies to maximize productivity in emulsion polymerization processes
Roduit et al. Estimation of time to maximum rate under adiabatic conditions (TMRad) using kinetic parameters derived from DSC-investigation of thermal behavior of 3-methyl-4-nitrophenol
WO2014129125A1 (en) Reliability design assistance device, reliability design assistance method, and reliability design assistance program
Sofekun et al. A random particle model for catalyst dilution
Kossoy et al. Methodological aspects of the application of adiabatic calorimetry for thermal safety investigation
CN112033997B (en) Explosive thermal stability grading method based on differential scanning calorimetry

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
121 Ep: the epo has been informed by wipo that ep was designated in this application

Ref document number: 19941303

Country of ref document: EP

Kind code of ref document: A1

NENP Non-entry into the national phase

Ref country code: DE

122 Ep: pct application non-entry in european phase

Ref document number: 19941303

Country of ref document: EP

Kind code of ref document: A1