WO2000072079A2

WO2000072079A2 - Electro-optic devices

Info

Publication number: WO2000072079A2
Application number: PCT/GB2000/001979
Authority: WO
Inventors: Simon Howard Spencer; William Philip Pritchard
Original assignee: Marconi Applied Technologies Limited
Priority date: 1999-05-24
Filing date: 2000-05-24
Publication date: 2000-11-30
Also published as: EP1185899A2; WO2000072079A3; JP2003500693A; GB2351356A; GB9912072D0; GB0012655D0

Abstract

An electro-optic device includes a polarising beam splitter (1) wihch sends a polarised component along a first path via birefringent cells (C1 and C2) and a differently polarised component via a second path through cells (C3 and C4). The two components are combined at 8 and the output directed onto a CCD sensor (9). The modulator has high transmission characteristic and allows faster switching. In one embodiment, the device is used to view differently polarised light from a scene.

Description

ELECTRO-OPTIC DEVICES

This invention relates to electro-optic devices such as, for example, modulators or shutters which use birefringent material.

In these types of electro-optic devices, the application of an electrical field to the material causes its effective birefringence to change, resulting in rotation of its optic axis. This effect may be used to modulate incident optical radiation. Figure 1 illustrates a known simple electro-optic shutter configuration which comprises three elements, an input polariser PI, a birefringent cell Cl and an output analyser P2 (usually a second polariser). The birefringent cell Cl includes electrodes on its major surfaces to enable an electrical field to be produced in the cell Cl when a potential difference is applied across the electrodes. The shutter as illustrated in Figure 1 is subjected to unpolarised input radiation U which is incident on the input polariser PI. The light transmitted by input polariser PI is linearly polarised and is incident on the cell Cl. For zero field conditions, the state of the linearly polarised light is not altered as it passes through the electro-optic element and the light is absorbed by the second polariser P2 which is crossed relative to the input polariser PI. When a voltage is applied across the cell Cl, it acts as an optical retarder, shifting the relative phases of light polarised parallel and perpendicular to the applied electric field. Thus linearly polarised light received at cell Cl is changed to elliptically polarised light at its output, a portion of which will pass through the second polariser P2. The transmissivity in the on-state may be maximized by adjusting the electric field such that the birefringent cell Cl behaves as a half-wave retardation plate, such that light is linearly polarised at the output of the cell Cl with the plane of polarisation being

rotated by 90°.

The performance of a shutter can be characterized by a number of performance parameters and the most suitable selected for a particular application. These parameters include the transmission (T_ON), extinction (T_OFF), response time (t_r), repetition rate (f_r), acceptance angle, power consumption and the spectral range over which the shutter is effective.

Figure 2 illustrates another optical shutter which has improved extinction, acceptance angle and power consumption compared to the shutter shown in Figure 1. In the Figure 2 device, two birefringent cells Cl and C2 are spatially arranged alternately along the optical path with three polarisers PI, P2 and P3. If the two cells Cl and C2 are each identical with the single cell Cl of the Figure 1 device, the same effect can be achieved at the output using approximately half the voltage applied across each of the cells. Thus, if say in the Figure 1 device, voltage pulses of 600V were applied across the cell Cl to switch it between states, in the device of Figure 2 each cell Cl and C2 is subjected to pulses of 300V, leading to a faster response time and increased repetition rate. Other improvements may be achieved by including coatings on the surfaces of the optical elements and by appropriate selection of the chemical composition of the birefringent material.

According to the invention there is provided an electro-optic device comprising: a polarising beam splitter which produces first and second differently polarised components from applied unpolarised optical radiation; first and second optical paths along which the first and second components respectively are directed; and birefringent cell means in the first and second paths.

A device in accordance with the invention may have a significantly higher transmission characteristic than previously known devices. By sending the first and second components along what are effectively parallel optical paths, both of these components obtained from the original unpolarised incident radiation are utilized in the device. In the devices as illustrated in Figures 1 and 2, the initial polariser cuts down transmission through the system as a whole by 50% at least, with other components in the optical path adding to the reduction in transmission. The significantly improved transmission obtainable by making use of the invention means that devices based on the electro-optic effect become practicable in applications for which previously they would not have been considered. A device in accordance with the invention does not require a collimated, polarised or monochromatic illuminant source in order to work.

For a typical device, a prior art arrangement such as that shown in Figure 1 may have a transmission of approximately 42% whereas in a comparable device in accordance with the invention, transmissions of 80% may be achieved.

The term "optical" as used in this specification is intended to cover not only the visible parts of the spectrum but also the ultra-violet and far infra-red ranges also. For a particular device, the components included must be optimised for the parts of the spectrum at which it is intended to operate.

A device in accordance with the invention may be used as a shutter in applications such as for example gated TV cameras (which may use CCD or other solid state sensors), laser gated TV cameras, multicolour cameras and displays, holographic displays, mid-infra-red range thermal cameras (operating at wavelengths of 3 to 5 microns for example), and thermal modulators for thermal cameras.

A device according to the present invention may be used as a voltage controlled attenuator. A varying voltage may be applied to the birefringent cell means to control transmission through the device. Thus where the output of the device is directed onto a sensor, the transmission may be controlled such that the sensor is operated at its optimum level of incident light. The transmission may be controlled using a separate circuit but in one advantageous embodiment, a control signal is derived from a sensor receiving the output from the device. For example, a CCD sensor output may be used to provide a feedback signal for the birefringent cell means. The device may be used to control light transmission where the output is to be received in turn by different sensors having different characteristics and/or where the input optical radiation to the device has changing characteristics, for example to view a scene under daylight conditions and also at night when illuminated by a laser source.

Where the device is used to deliver light from a scene to a sensor, such as a CCD sensor, there may be occasions where a bright point source in the scene causes an undesirable voltage spike at the output of the sensor during frame intervals. By controlling transmission through the device, this may be avoided by ensuring that the device is non-transmissive during the frame intervals. This may be done for all frame intervals during normal operation as a precaution or only when conditions are such that a voltage spike is generated.

The invention is applicable to any device which uses the birefringence effect. For example, the birefringent cell means may comprise a Pockel cell or cells, Kerr cell or cells or LCD cells.

A particularly suitable material for use in a birefringent cell means is lanthanum- modified lead zirconate titanate (PLZT). Such materials may be tailored so as to control the magnitude of the birefringence for example by adjusting the percentage of lanthanum included in the material.

In a preferred embodiment, the cell means comprises a first cell in the first path and a second different cell in the second path. However, in an alternative embodiment, the cell means may comprise a single cell which is included in the both the first and second paths, the first and second components being applied to different regions of the single cell.

The polarising beam splitter may comprise a polarising separator such as a polarising beam splitter cube. In a preferred device, the polarising separator is such that it produces a transmitted component in one direction and a reflected component at 90° to the transmitted component, with the first and second components being linearly polarised in different directions. Other cubes are available which produce transmitted and reflected components separated by other angles, for example 45°. For example a

Glan-Thompson polarizer gives 40°.

In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the cell means includes a plurality of birefringent cells in the first path and a plurality of birefringent cells in the second

path. By cascading the cells in each path, increased transmission, repetition rate and switching speeds are achievable.

In one embodiment the optical outputs of the first and second optical paths are kept separate. These outputs may be separately processed subsequently or may be combined following conversion from optical form into, say, electrical signals. For example, a first CCD sensor may receive the optical component from the first path and a second CCD sensor the component from the second path and the electrical outputs of the CCDs combined to give an output video signal. In another embodiment, the optical outputs of the first and second paths are optically combined. In a shutter, for example, this combined output may then be applied to a single optical sensor, such as a single CCD sensor or camera tube. The optical paths must be adjusted such that when the outputs are combined, they are in register with one another. It may be useful for some devices to include a moveable reflective surface, such as a prism , within the device for adjustment of the paths relative to one another to permit correct registration to be obtained.

In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the polarising beam splitter and birefringent cell means form part of a single component. The component may also incorporate an optical combiner in those embodiments where the optical outputs are combined. This is particularly advantageous as it enables the geometry of the device and the properties of the components to be selected during assembly and subsequently the single component may be handled, for example, for shipping or when assembling it into a larger arrangement whilst maintaining the correct alignments, removing the need for subsequent adjustments. The optical combiner may be a cube or a prism, for example. Where the device is included within, say, a camera in which a focussing lens system is used to focus the image onto the camera, the device may be incorporated in the focussing system, for example, being located between elements of the focussing system itself.

A device in accordance with the invention may be used as a switch which modulates the applied input radiation between on and off states only, or in other arrangements, the cell means may be controlled to produce an intermediate state or states, or a continuous gradient between states. Thus, in one advantageous embodiment, the cell means may be controlled so as to switch between a transmissive state, an off state and a single intermediate state. This is particularly suitable for those applications in which it is important to be able to switch from a fully transmissive state to a state in which a significant proportion of incoming radiation is blocked in a very short time, for example in a system which uses a laser to illuminate a scene, where it is necessary to protect an optical sensor from scattered laser radiation occurring in its close vicinity immediately subsequent to the generation of a laser pulse. In a preferred embodiment, the optic axis or axes of the birefringent cell means are rotated in one path relative to those in the other path, permitting a wider acceptance

angle for the device and also reducing or eliminating aliasing effects which might otherwise occur in those systems where the outputs are re-combined.

A device in accordance with the invention may be used to extract from a viewed scene details of either vertically or horizontally polarised components which occur in that scene.

Some ways in which the invention may be performed are now described by way of example with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:

Figure 3 schematically illustrates an optical arrangement incorporating a device in accordance with the invention and having two CCD sensors; Figure 4 schematically illustrates a cascaded parallel shutter in accordance with the invention;

Figure 5 schematically shows another arrangement in accordance with the invention having a single output;

Figure 6 schematically illustrates another device in accordance with the invention;

Figures 7, 8 and 9 are explanatory diagrams relating to the device of Figure 6; and Figures 10, 11, 12 13 and 14 schematically show other devices in accordance with the invention.

With reference to Figure 3, a shutter arrangement includes a polarising beam splitter cube 1 at which unpolarised input radiation is received in the direction shown by the arrow. The cube 1 acts to split randomly polarised input light into two components, one being transmitted straight through the cube 1 to give a beam 2 which is linearly polarised with P-polarisation, and the other component being reflected through 90 ° to give an output beam 3 which is also highly polarised having a linear S-polarisation. The reflected beam 3 is applied to a prism 4 where it is redirected onto a first birefringent cell Cl, the output of which is directed to an analyser, in this case an output polariser P2. This first optical path also includes a CCD sensor 5 arranged to receive the output from polariser P2. There is a second optical path through the system parallel to the first path which includes a second birefringent cell C2, a second output polariser P4 and a second CCD sensor 6. Any light incident on the CCD sensors 5 and 6 produces a charge pattern representative of the amount of radiation incident thereon which can be electronically read out and combined at combiner 7 to give a video output signal at 8.

When no optical field is applied to either of the cells Cl and C2, there is no change in the direction of polarisation of light transmitted therethrough and subsequently incident on output polarisers P2 and P4. Thus, substantially no optical radiation is incident on the CCD sensors 5 and 6. When an electrical field is applied to both cells Cl and C2, the resultant rotation of the linearly polarised output light is transmitted through polarisers P2 and P4 to reach the CCD sensors 5 and 6. The outputs of the CCD sensors 5 and 6 are controlled to add inregistration so as to give a combined video output signal at 8. By using two parallel optical paths through the shutter, the transmission is effectively doubled compare to the simple optical shutter shown in Figure 1. In the arrangement shown in Figure 3, the transmission

T_0N= (Ux PI x Cl x P2) + (U x PI x C2 x P4) which is approximately PI x Cl x P2 giving a transmission of approximately 80%, U being 0.5 (being the conversion of unpolarised light to polarised light), PI and P2 are both approximately 0.9 and the transmission of Cl is approximately 0.9.

The material used in the birefringent cells Cl and C2 is PLZT which is commercially available. The first and second cells Cl and C2 could be replaced by a single cell which is extensive across both optical paths.

With reference to Figure 4, a shutter in accordance with the invention includes the components of the device shown in Figure 3 and having the same reference numerals for clarity. In addition, the first optical path also includes a second birefringent cell C2 which uses PLZT and a second polariser P3 interposed between the first polariser P2 and the CCD sensor 5. The second optical path, which is parallel to the first, includes an additional birefringent cell C4, again of PLZT, and a second polariser P5 located in front of the CCD sensor 6. Again, the outputs of the CCDs 5 and 6 are combined at 7 to give a video output at 8. As in the Figure 3 embodiment, the polarising beam splitter cube 1 produces a transmitted beam of one polarisation and a reflected beam of another polarisation. Thus, again, instead of the transmission being reduced by 50% at the first polariser, both beam components contribute to the final output signal. By using two cells in each of the parallel optical paths, the transmission, power requirements and speed of switching are improved compared to

the Figure 3 device. In a variation of this configuration, the cells Cl and C3 are replaced by a larger single cell, and cells C2 and C4 are replaced by a second larger single cell.

With reference to Figure 5, a shutter in accordance with the invention has an input polarising beam splitter 1. Linearly polarised light reflected at 1 is transmitted along a first path via prism 4 to a first birefringent cell C, and passes via a combiner 8 to a CCD sensor 9. Light transmitted by the beam splitter 1 and polarised orthogonal to that in the first path is transmitted to a second cell C₃ and is then directed onto the combiner 8 by a second prism 10 where it is reflected and combined with light from the first path to give a single output to the CCD 9.

With reference to Figure 6 this shows another shutter in accordance with the invention which includes two parallel optical paths each of which incorporates cascaded birefringent cells. Input radiation is applied to the polarising beam splitter 1. The reflected component is transmitted via a first cell C, and onto a reflecting polariser P2 from whence it is directed onto a second C₂ and to a combiner 8 which includes a polariser 11, which acts as the analyser. The light is then incident on a single CCD camera 9. The transmitted component from beam splitter 1 is similarly directed via a cell C₃ ,a reflecting polariser P4 and a second cell C₄, being finally incident on a second reflecting polariser 11 where it is combined with the originally reflected component to give a single output.

The device offers improved transmission enabling a TV camera to be used, for example, for pulsed laser viewing under total darkness conditions. In addition, the cells C_1; C₂, C₃ and C₄ may be operated so as to give a three-state transmission path

between the input and the CCD display output. This is particularly useful for active laser cameras. When the laser is pulsed, there may be scattering close to the sensor from, say, the surrounding atmosphere. It is thus essential to effectively shield the sensor from outgoing laser emission. After a finite delay, useful image information must be extracted from a scene being viewed but this requires the transmission to be extremely good. Thus switching is achieved between maximum extinction of 10^"4 during which time the laser fires, an intermediate extinction level of 10^"2 and a maximum transmission state of approximately 70% during which received imagery is extracted. By controlling when voltages are applied to the cells C, to C₄, these three states may be achieved.

Figure 7 is an explanatory diagram concerning the generation of the three transmission states. Figure 7a shows the PLZT transfer function, giving the transmission achieved for a particular applied voltage, the three voltage levels being 400 volts, 500 volts and 700 volts. Figure 7b illustrates the temporal function of the PLZT material, showing transmission against response time.

For a particular situation where it is wished to block transmission during emission of a laser pulse but permit the laser return from the illuminated scene to pass through the device, the transmissive sfates are as illustrated in Figures 8a, 8b and 8c. The laser pulse is emitted at time tl shown at Figure 8a and the return received at time t2.

Figure 8b shows the state of the shutter, which during time period a the shutter is fully

off, at time c the shutter is fully on, being at maximum transmission, and at other times, the shutter is partially off, shown at d. The pulses shown in Figure 8b are ideal and those achievable using the device of Figure 6 and a three state drive are illustrated in Figure 8c, where it can be seen the rise and fall of the transmission level during laser emission tl is about 5 microseconds duration and the fully on state occurs for approximately 1 microsecond.

Figure 9 schematically shows two cells Cl and C2 in series connected so as to achieve the three state drive. This is repeated for the other two cells C3 and C4 in the other optical path through the device.

In the arrangement shown in Figure 6, the digital electrodes laid down on the surfaces of the cells C, to C₄ are arranged so such that they are angled with respect to each other to avoid aliasing. In the Figure 6 arrangement, the angles of the electrodes of C, are + 22%, for C₂ + 45%, for C₃ - 22% and C₄- 45%.

In the device of Figure 6, a control signal from the ccD 9 may be applied to the cells Cl, C2, C3 and C4 to adjust transmission to ensure that the CCD 9 operates at optimum illumination levels. This may act, for example, to adjust for slowly varying ambient light conditions in a viewed scene. The cells Cl, C2, C3 and C4 may also be controlled so as to block transmission to the

CCD 9 during frame intervals.

For each of the devices shown in Figures 3 to 6, it is possible to distinguish between vertically and horizontally polarised components of a viewed scene. For example, in the Figure 6 device, the vertical and horizontal polarised components in a scene may be separately viewed by firstly switching off C₃ and C₄ and viewing the scene transmitted via C, and C₂ and then switching off C, and C₂ and viewing via C₃ and

C₄,

The device of Figure 6 may be modified by incorporating, for example, a blue pass filter in the first path and a red pass filter in the second path. For example, P2 may be a blue pass filter and P4 a red pass filter. Thus when the combined output is viewed, the colour present in the display will indicate the polarised states.

Colour separation may be achieved using a standard dichroic prism in which, say, blue light is reflected and red/green light is transmitted, or a triple colour dichroic arrangement in which light is separated into blue, red and green components.

The device shown in Figure 4 may also be used for polar viewing without the

inclusion of optical colour filters. Colour can then be introduced by electrical processing.

Another embodiment of the invention is illustrated in Figure 10. This has an input polar splitter 1 followed by a birefringent cell Cl and C2 in the respective reflected and transmitted paths. The light transmitted via cell Cl is reflected at P2 and is incident on a first CCD sensor 12. The transmitted light passes via cell C2 to a second CCD sensor 13. This arrangement avoids lateral inversion but involves unequal first and second path lengths.

Another device is illustrated in Figure 11 and includes a polar splitter 1 which divides the incident radiation. Light reflected at PI is transmitted via a birefringent cell Cl to a reflective surface P2 followed by another surface P3 to a polar combiner 14 where it is combined with light transmitted via polar splitter 1 and a second birefringent cell C2, the combined output being received by a single CCD sensor 15.

With reference to Figure 12, another device includes a polar splitter 1 following which in each path is located a birefringent cell Cl and C2 the output of which is directed towards prisms 16 and 17, the light then being recombined at polar combiner 18 and the output directed towards a CCD sensor 19. The prism 17 is adjustable in position so as to enable precise adjustment of the light paths to be achieved. Thus, registration may be adjusted by moving one prism only. This device requires a single CCD only and also presents equal path lengths on both the first and second paths through the device.

With reference to Figure 13, another device includes two polarising cubes and two polarisers. One cube acts as a polar splitter 1 and the second cube as a combiner 20. Two prisms 21 and 22 are located in the first and second optical paths and birefringent cells Cl, C2, C3 and C4 are located between the cubes and prisms. In addition, two polarisers PI and P2 are incorporated in the first and second optical paths.

With reference to Figure 14a, a device 23 similar to that shown in Figure 13 is located as a shutter between an input lens 24 and a CCD 25. The insertion of device 23 results in a longer system compared to an arrangement in which the device 23 is absent as illustrated in Figure 14b. In this arrangement the entry cube 1 of the device 23 is longer than the exit cube 20 because of the acceptance angle which is aperture and focal length dependent.

Claims

1. An electro-optic device comprising: a polarising beam splitter which produces first and second differently polarised components from applied unpolarised optical radiation; first and second optical paths along which the first and second components

respectively are directed; and birefringent cell means in the first and second paths.

2. A device as claimed in Claim 1 wherein the cell means comprises a first cell in the first path and a second different cell in the second path.

3. A device as claimed in Claim 1 or 2 wherein the cell means comprises a single cell which is included in both the first and second paths, the first and second components being applied to different regions of the single cell.

4. A device as claimed in Claim 1, 2 or 3 wherein the cell means is independently controllable in the first and second paths.

5. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the cell means includes a plurality of birefringent cells in the first path and plurality of birefringent cells in the second path.

6. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the optical outputs of the first and second paths are kept separate.

7. A device as claimed in any of Claims 1 to 5 wherein the optical outputs of the first

and second paths are combined.

8. A device as claimed in any preceding claim and including optical sensor means arranged to receive the components after they have travelled along the first and second

paths.

9. A device as claimed in Claim 8 wherein the optical sensor means includes CCD

means.

10. A device as claimed in Claim 8 or 9 when dependent on Claim 6, wherein the outputs of the first and second optical paths are applied to respective different optical sensors and the outputs of the sensors subsequently combined.

11. A device as claimed in any preceding claim and including analyser means to receive the output of the birefringent cell means.

12. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the beam splitter comprises a polarising beam splitter cube.

13. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the birefringent cell means includes PLZT.

14. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein electrodes incorporated in the cell means in one optical path are offset with respect to electrodes in the cell means in the other optical path.

15. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the cell means is operable such as to produce three or more degrees of transmission through the device.

16. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the birefringent cell means is controlled to maintain the optical output of the device within a pre-determined range during transmission.

17. a device as claimed in claim 16 and including a sensor for monitoring the output and means for deriving a control signal dependent on the monitored output and applying it to the birefringent cell means.

18. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein the birefringent cell means is controlled to prevent transmission during frame intervals of a sensor which receives the optical output.

19. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein at least the beam splitter and birefringent cell means are parts of a single component.

20. A device as claimed in Claim 19 when dependant on Claim 7 wherein an optical combiner for combining first and second components after transmission through the cell means forms part of the single component.

21. A device as claimed in any preceding claim wherein first and second polarised

components are output in respective different colours.

22. A device as claimed im any preceding claim wherein the optic axis of the birefringent cell means in one path is rotated relative to that in the other path.

23. Camera apparatus including a device as claimed in any preceding claim.

24. Camera apparatus as claimed in Claim 23 wherein the device is included within the focussing system of the camera.

25. An electro-optic device substantially as illustrated in and described with reference to any one of Figures 3 to 14 of the accompanying drawings.

26. A shutter arrangement substantially as illustrated in and described with reference to any one of Figures 3 to 14 of the accompanying drawings.