JPS63302397A - Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel - Google Patents

Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel

Info

Publication number
JPS63302397A
JPS63302397A JP62138654A JP13865487A JPS63302397A JP S63302397 A JPS63302397 A JP S63302397A JP 62138654 A JP62138654 A JP 62138654A JP 13865487 A JP13865487 A JP 13865487A JP S63302397 A JPS63302397 A JP S63302397A
Authority
JP
Japan
Prior art keywords
abnormality
data signal
operating
steady
signal
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
JP62138654A
Other languages
Japanese (ja)
Inventor
Hideaki Aoki
秀明 青木
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Toshiba Corp
Original Assignee
Toshiba Corp
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Toshiba Corp filed Critical Toshiba Corp
Priority to JP62138654A priority Critical patent/JPS63302397A/en
Publication of JPS63302397A publication Critical patent/JPS63302397A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02EREDUCTION OF GREENHOUSE GAS [GHG] EMISSIONS, RELATED TO ENERGY GENERATION, TRANSMISSION OR DISTRIBUTION
    • Y02E30/00Energy generation of nuclear origin
    • Y02E30/30Nuclear fission reactors

Abstract

PURPOSE:To diagnose malfunctions quickly by estimating abnormal causes from the data base corresponding to various abnormal causes by the use of the signal of an abnormality judgement device when an appointed deviation is produced between operating and normal data signals. CONSTITUTION:Changes of process parameters are transmitted in operating data input device 2 as an operating data signal 11, and the operating data signals are compared with the normal data signal 12 from the normal data storage device 3 by the use of an abnormality judgment device 4. For an example, leak of reactor water and the like occurs in a reactor containment vessel, a deviation produces between an operating data signal 11 and a normal data signal 12 as the leakage increases and a switch 6 is actuated by an abnormality detecting signal 5 from the judgment device 4. In this phase the normal data signal 12 and the operating data signal 11 which represents abnormality from the judgment device 4 are output in an operating condition abnormality estimation device 7, a chemical condition abnormality estimation device 8 and an operating pattern estimation device 9. The estimated results from the above estimation devices 7, 8, 9 are shown on a display 10. Therefore, malfunction can be diagnosed quickly without need of assembling experts and trying to find the cause on each accident, 2 operating data input device 3 normal data storage device 4 abnormality judgment device 7 operating condition abnormality estimation device 8 chemical condition abnormality estimation device 9 operating pattern abnormality estimation device 10 display.

Description

【発明の詳細な説明】 〔発明の目的〕 (産業上の利用分野) 本発明は原子炉格納容器内の雰囲気異常を診断する異常
診断装置に係り、とりわけ確実かつ迅速に診断すること
ができる原子炉格納容器の異常診断装置に関する。
[Detailed Description of the Invention] [Object of the Invention] (Industrial Application Field) The present invention relates to an abnormality diagnosis device for diagnosing atmospheric abnormalities in a nuclear reactor containment vessel, and in particular, to an abnormality diagnosis device that can diagnose an atmospheric abnormality in a nuclear reactor containment vessel, and in particular, an atomic abnormality that can be diagnosed reliably and quickly. The present invention relates to an abnormality diagnosis device for a reactor containment vessel.

(従来の技術) 原子炉格納容器(以下PCVという)内には、原子炉圧
力容器、再循環ポンプ等の重要機器および配管が多数配
置されている。このPCM内の諸機器または配管等に異
常が発生すると、この異常原因によっては直ちに原子力
発電所の運転を停止する必要がある。
(Prior Art) A large number of important equipment and piping, such as a reactor pressure vessel and a recirculation pump, are arranged inside a nuclear reactor containment vessel (hereinafter referred to as PCV). When an abnormality occurs in various equipment or piping within the PCM, depending on the cause of the abnormality, it is necessary to immediately stop the operation of the nuclear power plant.

しかしながら、PCM内には常時N2ガスが封入されて
いるため、異常が発生してもPCM内に入って点検する
ことはできず、PCM内の各種運転データをPCVの外
側で入手して異常原因を究明しなければならない。
However, since N2 gas is always sealed inside the PCM, even if an abnormality occurs, it is not possible to enter the PCM and inspect it, and various operating data inside the PCM can be obtained outside the PCV to determine the cause of the abnormality. must be investigated.

この原因究明には、専門的な知識や経験が必要であり、
各分野の専門技術者が集まって各種運転データを分析・
評価して原因究明を行なっているのが実情である。
Investigating the cause requires specialized knowledge and experience.
Expert engineers from various fields gather to analyze and analyze various operational data.
The reality is that we are evaluating and investigating the cause.

(発明が解決しようとする問題点) 」二連のように、PCV内の異常原因の究明にあたって
は、各分野の専門技術者が集まってPCV内の各種運転
データを分析・評価しているが、このような専門技術者
を必要な時期に確実に集めることは困難である。このた
め、PCV内に異常が発生しても原因究明に時間がかか
ったり、また適切な診断ができないという問題がある。
(Problems to be Solved by the Invention) As mentioned above, in order to investigate the causes of abnormalities within the PCV, specialized engineers from various fields come together to analyze and evaluate various operational data within the PCV. However, it is difficult to reliably gather such specialized engineers at the required time. For this reason, even if an abnormality occurs in the PCV, there is a problem that it takes time to investigate the cause or that an appropriate diagnosis cannot be made.

本発明はこのような点を考慮してなされたものであり、
迅速かつ確実にPCV内の異常を診断できる原子力発電
所格納容器の異常診断装置を提供することを目的とする
The present invention has been made in consideration of these points,
It is an object of the present invention to provide an abnormality diagnosis device for a nuclear power plant containment vessel that can quickly and reliably diagnose abnormalities in a PCV.

〔発明の構成〕[Structure of the invention]

(問題点を解決するための手段) 本発明は、原子炉格納容器内の運転データ信号が入力さ
れる運転データ入力装置と、運転データ信号が所定時間
継続して安定した場合の定常データ信号を適宜記憶する
定常データ記憶装置と、前記運転データ入力装置からの
運転データ信号と前記定常データ記憶装置からの定常デ
ータ信号とを比較して運転データの変化から原子炉格納
容器の異常発生を判定する異常判定器と、運転データ信
号と定常データ信号との間に所定の偏差が発生した場合
、前記異常判定器から運転データ信号および定常データ
信号が入力されるとともに、あらかじめ各種異常原因と
それに対応する運転データの変化を記憶したデータベー
スから異常原因を推論する異常推論装置と、この異常推
論装置からの推論結果を表示する表示装置とを備えた原
子力発電所格納容器の異常診断装置である。
(Means for Solving the Problems) The present invention provides an operation data input device into which an operation data signal in a reactor containment vessel is input, and a steady data signal when the operation data signal continues for a predetermined period of time and becomes stable. A steady data storage device stores appropriate data, and the operating data signal from the operating data input device is compared with the steady data signal from the steady data storage device to determine whether an abnormality has occurred in the reactor containment vessel based on a change in the operating data. When a predetermined deviation occurs between the abnormality determination device, the operation data signal, and the steady data signal, the operation data signal and the steady data signal are input from the abnormality determination device, and various causes of the abnormality and countermeasures are determined in advance. This is an abnormality diagnosis device for a nuclear power plant containment vessel, which includes an abnormality inference device that infers the cause of an abnormality from a database that stores changes in operating data, and a display device that displays the inference results from this abnormality inference device.

(作 用) PCV内で雰囲気異常が発生すると、運転データ入力装
置からの運転データ信号と、定常データ記憶装置からの
定常データ信号とが異常判定器で比較され、この異常判
定器からさらに運転データ信号および定常データ信号が
異常推論装置に入力され、異常推論装置であらかじめ記
憶したデータベースから異常原因が推論され、この推論
結果が表示装置に表示される。
(Function) When an atmospheric abnormality occurs in the PCV, the operating data signal from the operating data input device and the steady data signal from the steady data storage device are compared in the abnormality determiner, and further operating data is output from the abnormality determiner. The signal and the steady data signal are input to the abnormality inference device, the cause of the abnormality is inferred from a database stored in advance by the abnormality inference device, and the result of this inference is displayed on the display device.

(実施例) 以下、図面を参照して本発明の実施例について説明する
。図は本発明による原子力発電所格納容器の異常診断装
置の一実施例を示す図である。
(Example) Hereinafter, an example of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. The figure is a diagram showing an embodiment of an abnormality diagnosis device for a nuclear power plant containment vessel according to the present invention.

図において、PCV (図示せず)内の運転データ信号
11が入力される運転データ入力装置2と、同じく運転
データ信号11が入力される定常データ入力装置3が設
けられている。この定常データ入力装置3は運転データ
信号11が所定時間(α時間)継続して安定した場合、
この運転データ信号11を定常データ信号12として適
時記憶するものである。また運転データ入力装置2およ
び定常データ記憶装置3には異常判定器4が接続され、
この異常判定器4には運転データ入力装置2から運転デ
ータ信号11が、定常データ記憶装置3から定常データ
信号12がそれぞれ入力される。
In the figure, an operating data input device 2 to which an operating data signal 11 in a PCV (not shown) is input, and a steady data input device 3 to which the operating data signal 11 is also input are provided. This steady data input device 3 operates when the operation data signal 11 continues to be stable for a predetermined period of time (α time).
This operation data signal 11 is stored as a steady data signal 12 at appropriate times. Further, an abnormality determination device 4 is connected to the operation data input device 2 and the steady data storage device 3.
An operating data signal 11 is inputted to the abnormality determination device 4 from the operating data input device 2, and a steady data signal 12 is inputted from the steady data storage device 3.

この異常判定器4は運転データ信号11と定常データ信
号12とを比較し、両者の信号11゜12の間に所定の
偏差(β)が発生した場合、異常判定器4に接続された
切替器6に異常検出信号5を出力するものである。切替
器6に異常検出信号5が入力されると切替器6は開作動
し、異常判定器4から運転データ信号11および定常デ
ータ信号12が運転状態異常推論装置7、化学状態異常
推論装置8および運転パターン異常推論装置9に入力C
る。
This abnormality determination device 4 compares the operating data signal 11 and the steady data signal 12, and if a predetermined deviation (β) occurs between the two signals 11°12, a switching device connected to the abnormality determination device 4 The abnormality detection signal 5 is output to the terminal 6. When the abnormality detection signal 5 is input to the switching device 6, the switching device 6 is opened, and the operating data signal 11 and steady data signal 12 are transmitted from the abnormality determining device 4 to the operating state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and Input C to driving pattern abnormality inference device 9
Ru.

運転状態異常推論装置7、化学状態異常推論装置8およ
び運転パターン異常推論装置9は、それぞれPCV内の
各種異常原因とそれに対応する運転データの変化を記憶
したデータベースを有している。データベースに記憶さ
れる各種異常原因と対応する運転データ変化は、専門家
の知識や経験または各種実験結果や理論式等をもとにし
て定められる。また運転状態異常推論装置7、化学状態
異常推論装置8および運転パターン異常推論装置9は、
それぞれデータベースにもとずいて運転データ信号11
および定常データ信号12からPCv内の異常原因を推
論し、その推論結果を表示装置10に入力する。
The operating state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and the operating pattern abnormality inference device 9 each have a database that stores various causes of abnormalities in the PCV and changes in operating data corresponding thereto. Changes in operating data that correspond to various causes of abnormalities stored in the database are determined based on the knowledge and experience of experts, various experimental results, theoretical formulas, and the like. Further, the driving state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and the driving pattern abnormality inference device 9,
Each operation data signal 11 is based on a database.
The cause of the abnormality in the PCv is inferred from the steady data signal 12 and the inference result is input to the display device 10.

次にこのような構成からなる本実施例の作用について説
明する。
Next, the operation of this embodiment having such a configuration will be explained.

PCvからの運転データ信号11には、一般的に温度、
圧力、ドレン量、放射能、ダスト量等の情報があり、こ
れらの情報が常時運転データ入力装置2および定常デー
タ記憶装置3に入力される。
The operation data signal 11 from the PCv generally includes temperature,
There is information such as pressure, drain amount, radioactivity, dust amount, etc., and this information is input into the constant operation data input device 2 and the steady data storage device 3.

そして定常データ記憶装置3では定常データ12が記憶
される。
In the steady data storage device 3, steady data 12 is stored.

例えば、PCv内で炉水または主蒸気の漏洩が発生する
と、ドライウェルローカルクーラドレン量や床ドレンサ
ンプ(HCW)のドレン量等のプロセスパラメータが定
常状態から徐々に上昇する。
For example, when a reactor water or main steam leak occurs in the PCv, process parameters such as the drywell local cooler drain rate and the floor condensate sump (HCW) drain rate gradually increase from a steady state.

、 これらのプロセスパラメータの変化は、運転データ
信号11として運転データ入力装置2に送られ、異常判
定器4にて定常データ記憶装置3からの定常データ信号
12と比較される。漏洩量の増加に伴ない、運転データ
入力装置2から運転データ信号11と定常データ記憶装
置3からの定常データ信号12との間にβ以上の偏差が
発生すると、異常判定器4からの異常検出信号5により
切替器6が作動する。
, Changes in these process parameters are sent to the operation data input device 2 as an operation data signal 11, and compared with the steady data signal 12 from the steady data storage device 3 in the abnormality determiner 4. When a deviation of β or more occurs between the operation data signal 11 from the operation data input device 2 and the steady data signal 12 from the steady data storage device 3 due to an increase in the amount of leakage, the abnormality determination unit 4 detects an abnormality. The signal 5 activates the switch 6.

この段階で異常判定器4からは異常となっている運転デ
ータ信号11および定常データ信号12が、運転状態異
常推論装置7、化学状態異常推論装置8および運転パタ
ーン異常推論装置9に出力される。
At this stage, the abnormal operation data signal 11 and steady data signal 12 that are abnormal are outputted from the abnormality determination device 4 to the operational state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and the driving pattern abnormality inference device 9.

運転データ信号11および定常データ信号12に含まれ
る情報のうち、例えばドライウェルローカルクーラドレ
ン量、HCWのドレン量、再循環ポンプメカシール圧力
等の運転状態データは運転状態異常推論装置7に入力さ
れる。運転状態異常推論装置7では、あらかじめ備えた
データベースをもとにして、例えばドライウェルローカ
ルクーラドレン量の変化からPCv内での炉水または主
蒸気の漏洩の発生およびその場所を推論する〇また、化
学状態異常推論装置8には、例えばサンプドレンの分析
結果等の化学状態データが入力される。そして、あらか
じめ備えたデータベースをもとに、例えば放射能の変化
から原子炉団りの漏洩を推論したり、補機の防錆材に用
いる亜硫酸濃度の変化から補機からの漏洩を推論する。
Among the information included in the operating data signal 11 and the steady data signal 12, operating state data such as dry well local cooler drain amount, HCW drain amount, recirculation pump mechanical seal pressure, etc. are input to the operating state abnormality inference device 7. . The operating state abnormality inference device 7 infers the occurrence and location of leakage of reactor water or main steam in the PCv from changes in the dry well local cooler drain amount, for example, based on a pre-prepared database. Chemical state data such as sump drain analysis results are input to the chemical state abnormality inference device 8 . Then, based on a pre-prepared database, for example, leaks from the reactor complex can be inferred from changes in radioactivity, or leaks from auxiliary equipment can be inferred from changes in the concentration of sulfite used in the rust preventive material for auxiliary equipment.

さらに、運転パターン異常推論装置9には、日々のドレ
ン量の変化等の運転パターンデータが入力される。例え
ばドレン漏洩箇所によっては日々のドレン量の変化に特
徴あることが知られており、この特徴を記憶したデータ
ベースをもとにドレン量の変化から、弁グランド部から
の漏洩や弁シートリーク部からの漏洩等を推論する。
Further, the driving pattern abnormality inference device 9 receives driving pattern data such as daily changes in drain amount. For example, it is known that there are characteristics in daily changes in the amount of condensate depending on the location of the condensate leakage, and based on a database that stores these characteristics, it is possible to detect changes in the amount of condensate from leaks from the valve gland, leaks from the valve seat, etc. Infer leakage, etc.

これら異常推論装置7,8.9からの推論結果は表示装
置10に表示される。
The inference results from these abnormality inference devices 7, 8.9 are displayed on the display device 10.

このように本実施例によれば、PCv内で雰囲気異常が
発生した場合、運転状態異常推論装置7、化学状態異常
推論装置8および運転パターン異常推論装置9によって
、それぞれあらかじめ記憶されたデータベースをもとに
して、PCv内での雰囲気異常を確実かつ迅速に推論す
ることができる。
According to this embodiment, when an atmospheric abnormality occurs in the PCv, the operating state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and the operational pattern abnormality inference device 9 each use a database stored in advance. Therefore, it is possible to reliably and quickly infer an abnormality in the atmosphere within the PCv.

なお、上記実施例において運転状態異常推論装置7、化
学状態異常推論装置8および運転パターン異常推論装置
9を別個に設けた例を示したが、これら3つの機能を有
する異常推論装置を単独で設けてもよい。
In the above embodiment, an example was shown in which the operating state abnormality inference device 7, the chemical state abnormality inference device 8, and the driving pattern abnormality inference device 9 were provided separately, but it is also possible to provide an abnormality inference device having these three functions independently. It's okay.

〔発明の効果〕〔Effect of the invention〕

本発明によれば、PCv内で雰囲気異常が発生した場合
、異常推論装置によってあらかじめ記憶されたデータベ
ースをもとにして、PCv内での雰囲気異常が推論され
、表示装置に表示される。
According to the present invention, when an abnormality in the atmosphere occurs in the PCv, the abnormality in the atmosphere in the PCv is inferred based on a database stored in advance by the abnormality inference device and displayed on the display device.

このため、従来のように異常発生毎に専門家を集める必
要はなく、確実かつ迅速にPCv内の異常を診断でき、
このことにより安全な原子力発電所の運転を確保できる
Therefore, there is no need to gather experts every time an abnormality occurs as in the past, and abnormalities within the PCv can be reliably and quickly diagnosed.
This ensures safe operation of nuclear power plants.

【図面の簡単な説明】[Brief explanation of the drawing]

図面は本発明による原子力発電所格納容器の異常診断装
置の一実施例を示す概略図である。 2・・・運転データ入力装置、3・・・定常データ記憶
装置、4・・・異常判定器、6・・・切替器、7・・・
運転状態異常推論装置、8・・・化学状態異常推論装置
、9・・・運転パターン異常推論装置、10・・・表示
装置、11・・・運転データ信号、12・・・定常デー
タ信号。
The drawing is a schematic diagram showing an embodiment of an abnormality diagnosis device for a nuclear power plant containment vessel according to the present invention. 2... Operating data input device, 3... Steady data storage device, 4... Abnormality determiner, 6... Switching device, 7...
Operating state abnormality inference device, 8... Chemical state abnormality inference device, 9... Operating pattern abnormality inference device, 10... Display device, 11... Operating data signal, 12... Steady data signal.

Claims (1)

【特許請求の範囲】[Claims] 原子炉格納容器内の運転データ信号が入力される運転デ
ータ入力装置と、運転データ信号が所定時間継続して安
定した場合の定常データ信号を適宜記憶する定常データ
記憶装置と、前記運転データ入力装置からの運転データ
信号と前記定常データ記憶装置からの定常データ信号と
を比較して運転データの変化から原子炉格納容器の異常
発生を判定する異常判定器と、運転データ信号と定常デ
ータ信号との間に所定の偏差が発生した場合、前記異常
判定器から運転データ信号および定常データ信号が入力
されるとともに、あらかじめ各種異常原因とそれに対応
する運転データの変化を記憶したデータベースから異常
原因を推論する異常推論装置と、この異常推論装置から
の推論結果を表示する表示装置とを備えた原子炉格納容
器の異常診断装置。
an operation data input device into which an operation data signal in the reactor containment vessel is input; a steady data storage device that appropriately stores a steady data signal when the operation data signal continues for a predetermined period of time and becomes stable; and the operation data input device. an abnormality determination device that compares the operating data signal from the operating data signal with the steady data signal from the steady data storage device and determines the occurrence of an abnormality in the reactor containment vessel from a change in the operating data; If a predetermined deviation occurs between the two, the operating data signal and steady data signal are input from the abnormality determiner, and the cause of the abnormality is inferred from a database that stores various abnormality causes and corresponding changes in operational data. An abnormality diagnosis device for a nuclear reactor containment vessel, comprising an abnormality inference device and a display device that displays the inference results from the abnormality inference device.
JP62138654A 1987-06-02 1987-06-02 Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel Pending JPS63302397A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP62138654A JPS63302397A (en) 1987-06-02 1987-06-02 Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP62138654A JPS63302397A (en) 1987-06-02 1987-06-02 Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
JPS63302397A true JPS63302397A (en) 1988-12-09

Family

ID=15227031

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
JP62138654A Pending JPS63302397A (en) 1987-06-02 1987-06-02 Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel

Country Status (1)

Country Link
JP (1) JPS63302397A (en)

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN105810262A (en) * 2014-12-30 2016-07-27 中核武汉核电运行技术股份有限公司 Nuclear power station pressure vessel automatic detection device control system

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN105810262A (en) * 2014-12-30 2016-07-27 中核武汉核电运行技术股份有限公司 Nuclear power station pressure vessel automatic detection device control system

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
EP0170516B1 (en) Diagnostic apparatus
KR920006411B1 (en) Intelligent chemistry management system
RU2154853C2 (en) Method for analysis of process data of production equipment
RU2160921C2 (en) Monitoring system for industrial plant
Papadopoulos et al. Automated safety monitoring: A review and classification of methods
Dahlstrand Consequence analysis theory for alarm analysis
Herbert et al. An initial evaluation of the detection and diagnosis of power plant faults using a deep knowledge representation of physical behaviour
Yamada et al. A Diagnosis Method of Dynamic System Using the Knowledge on System Description.
JPS63302397A (en) Device for malfunction diagnosis of reactor containment vessel
Zhang et al. Fault diagnosis of a mixing process using deep qualitative knowledge representation of physical behaviour
Bouamama et al. Bond-graph analysis of structural FDI properties in mechatronics system
JPH063637B2 (en) Abnormal time plan support device for process plant
Vinson et al. Fault detection and diagnosis using qualitative modelling and interpretation
JP2521326B2 (en) Plant failure diagnosis device
Kim et al. MOAS: A real-time operator advisory system
Larsson Avoiding human error
JPS621061A (en) Diagnosis and back-up device for fault of device
JPH01237344A (en) Self-diagnostic unit with inferential function in co-generation system
Van Niekerk et al. COMOS-an online system for problem-orientated vibration monitoring
Bjørlo et al. Early detection and diagnosis of disturbances in nuclear power plants
JPH08304125A (en) Plant diagnosing apparatus
Heino et al. Monitoring and analysis of hazards using HAZOP-based plant safety model
Larsson Support Tools for Situation Assessment
Kim et al. Integrated Approach for On-line Condition Monitoring on Process Components and Piping
JPH0353570B2 (en)