JPS62108154A - Method for diagnosing weld zone in flash butt welding - Google Patents
Method for diagnosing weld zone in flash butt weldingInfo
- Publication number
- JPS62108154A JPS62108154A JP24937185A JP24937185A JPS62108154A JP S62108154 A JPS62108154 A JP S62108154A JP 24937185 A JP24937185 A JP 24937185A JP 24937185 A JP24937185 A JP 24937185A JP S62108154 A JPS62108154 A JP S62108154A
- Authority
- JP
- Japan
- Prior art keywords
- welding
- quantities
- weld zone
- butt welding
- amount
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Granted
Links
Landscapes
- Investigating Or Analyzing Materials By The Use Of Ultrasonic Waves (AREA)
Abstract
Description
【発明の詳細な説明】
〔産業上の利用分野〕
本発明は、火花突合せ溶接の溶接部診断方法に係わり、
特にアコースティックエミッション(Acoustic
Emission:以下AEと略称する)技術を利
用した診断方法に関する。[Detailed Description of the Invention] [Industrial Application Field] The present invention relates to a method for diagnosing a welded part of spark butt welding.
Especially acoustic emission (Acoustic
The present invention relates to a diagnostic method using AE (hereinafter abbreviated as AE) technology.
近年、火花突合せ溶接は、圧接の際に溶接金属が溶接面
から押出されて清浄な溶接部が得られる上、通常、短時
間で溶接作業が終了し極めて能率的であるため、航空機
、自動車等の車両工業分野あるいは建築分野に広く実用
化されている。In recent years, spark butt welding has been used in aircraft, automobiles, etc. because the weld metal is pushed out from the welding surface during pressure welding, resulting in a clean welded joint, and the welding process is usually completed in a short time, making it extremely efficient. It has been widely put into practical use in the vehicle industry and construction field.
第5図は火花突合せ溶接を説明するための口であって、
図中1はコントローラ、2はトランス、3a、3bおよ
び4a、4bは各々一対の電極。FIG. 5 is for explaining spark butt welding,
In the figure, 1 is a controller, 2 is a transformer, and 3a, 3b and 4a, 4b are each a pair of electrodes.
5は固定側の被溶接部材、6は可動側の被溶接部材であ
る。溶接を行なう場合には、両液溶接部材5.6の溶接
面を軽く接触させつつコン1〜ローラ1およびトランス
2の作用により大電流を流し、接触面に電気火花7を発
生させつつその熱で被溶接部材5,6を加熱し、その後
、溶接面が金屑蒸気と溶融金属とで覆われた状態におい
て、可動側被溶接部材6に急激な強圧力を加えて圧接す
る。5 is a member to be welded on the fixed side, and 6 is a member to be welded on the movable side. When welding, the welding surfaces of the two-liquid welding members 5.6 are brought into light contact and a large current is passed through the action of the controller 1 to the roller 1 and the transformer 2, generating electric sparks 7 on the contact surfaces and dissipating the heat. The members to be welded 5 and 6 are heated, and then, with the welding surfaces covered with metal scrap vapor and molten metal, a sudden strong pressure is applied to the movable member to be welded 6 to press them together.
こうすることにより、被溶接部材5と6との溶接が完了
する。By doing this, welding of the members to be welded 5 and 6 is completed.
(発明が解決しようとする問題点)
ところで、上記火花突合せ溶接の溶接部を診断する場合
、一般に、放射線透過試験法あるいは超音波探傷試験法
等の非破壊検査法が適用されているが、これら試験法は
実時間で診断できない上、被溶接部材の形状が複雑な場
合には診断が困難となることもあった。このため、フラ
ッシュ電圧。(Problems to be Solved by the Invention) By the way, when diagnosing the welded part of the above-mentioned spark butt welding, non-destructive testing methods such as radiographic testing or ultrasonic testing are generally applied. Testing methods cannot diagnose in real time, and diagnosis is sometimes difficult when the shape of the welded part is complex. Because of this, the flash voltage.
フラッシュ電流、フラッシュ量ならびにアプセット通電
時間、アプセット5等の各種溶接プロセスに対゛する制
mおよび監視を行なうことにより、溶接部の品質を評価
することもあったが、これでは溶接欠陥の有無を高信頼
度で判断することはできなかった。さらに、抜取りによ
る材料試験も行なわれていたが、信頼性の向上をはかり
得るものではなかった。The quality of welds was sometimes evaluated by controlling and monitoring various welding processes such as flash current, flash amount, upset energization time, upset 5, etc., but this method was not sufficient to check the presence or absence of weld defects. It was not possible to make a judgment with high reliability. Furthermore, material testing by sampling was also conducted, but this did not improve reliability.
そこで本発明は、火花突合せ溶接における溶接部を非破
壊的に実時間でかつ高信頼度で診断することができる火
花突合せ溶接の溶接部診断方法を提供することを目的と
する。SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a method for diagnosing a weld in spark butt welding, which can non-destructively diagnose a weld in spark butt welding in real time and with high reliability.
本発明は、上記問題点を解決し目的を達成するために、
火花突合せ溶接終了後の主として加圧量に比例するAE
Iと、主として入熱量に比例するAEIとを計数し、こ
れら両AEfflにより予め設定された良否識別線図に
基いて溶接部を診断するようにしたものである。In order to solve the above problems and achieve the objectives, the present invention has the following features:
AE after spark butt welding is mainly proportional to the amount of pressurization
I and AEI, which is mainly proportional to the amount of heat input, are counted, and the welded part is diagnosed based on a pass/fail identification diagram set in advance using both AEffl.
このような手段を講じたことにより、火花突合せ溶接時
に溶接部のAE発生曇が計数され、主として加圧量すな
わちアプセット世に比例するAEE数量と、主として入
熱量に比例するAE計計数色が予め設定された良否識別
線図における層領域を満足する場合は溶接部が良好であ
ると評価され、不良領域に含まれる場合には溶接不良で
あると評価される。By taking such measures, the AE fog generated in the welding part during spark butt welding is counted, and the AEE quantity, which is mainly proportional to the amount of pressurization, that is, the upset, and the AE counting color, which is mainly proportional to the amount of heat input, are preset. If the layer area in the pass/fail identification diagram is satisfied, the weld is evaluated to be good, and if it is included in the defective area, it is evaluated to be a weld defect.
以下、本発明方法の一実施例を図面を参照しながら説明
する。本実施例においては、溶接部近傍にAEセンサを
設け、これにより火花突合せ溶接終了後のAE倍信号検
出し、このAE信号発生最に基いて溶接部の良否識別を
行なうものとなっている。An embodiment of the method of the present invention will be described below with reference to the drawings. In this embodiment, an AE sensor is provided in the vicinity of the weld, and this detects an AE multiplied signal after spark butt welding is completed, and the quality of the weld is determined based on the occurrence of this AE signal.
第1図は一般的な火花突合せ溶接時における溶接部近傍
のAEE号発生パターンを示している。FIG. 1 shows the AEE generation pattern near the weld during general spark butt welding.
同図から明らかなように、時点t○にて突合せ溶接終了
後、AE倍信号発生し、時点t1にてAEE号発生量が
極小値となった後、再び時点t2に至るまでAE倍信号
発生する。ここで、時点t。As is clear from the figure, after the end of butt welding at time t○, the AE multiplied signal is generated, and after the AEE signal generation amount reaches the minimum value at time t1, the AE multiplied signal is generated again until time t2. do. Here, time t.
からtlまでの間に発生するAE倍信号発生量は、主と
して火花突合せ溶接時の加圧量(アプセット量)に比例
し、時点t1からt2までの間に発生するAE倍信号発
生量は、主として火花突合せ溶接時の入熱量に比例する
。すなわち、本実施例においては、この時点10からt
lまでのAEE生量と、時点t1からt2までのAE発
生Mとに基いて溶接部診断を行なう。The amount of AE multiplied signal generated between tl and tl is mainly proportional to the amount of pressure (upset amount) during spark butt welding, and the amount of AE multiplied signal generated between time t1 and t2 is mainly proportional to It is proportional to the amount of heat input during spark butt welding. That is, in this embodiment, from this time point 10, t
The weld zone diagnosis is performed based on the AEE yield up to 1 and the AE occurrence M from time t1 to t2.
なお、上記時点t1およびt2は被溶接部材の形状(棒
鋼、パイプ、レールなど)2寸法および材質等により異
なった値となるが、同一形状、同一寸法、同一材質であ
ればほぼ一定の値となる。Note that the above points t1 and t2 have different values depending on the shape (steel bar, pipe, rail, etc.) of the workpiece to be welded, its dimensions, material, etc., but if they are the same shape, same dimensions, and made of the same material, they are almost constant values. Become.
第2図は被溶接部材として丸棒鋼を選択し、フラッシュ
電圧、フラッシュl流、フラッシュ量。Figure 2 shows the flash voltage, flash current, and flash amount when a round steel bar is selected as the workpiece to be welded.
アプセット通電時間、アプセット量の各溶接プロセス値
を種々に変えて火花突合せ溶接を行なったときにおいて
、溶接終了時点から10秒後すなわち第1図中10から
tlまでのAE計数邑(横軸)と、それ以降すなわち第
1図中10
のAE計数fl(縦軸)とをグラフ化した良否認識線図
を示している。なお、溶接終了後の材料試験結果により
溶接部に欠陥等が存在し不良であると判定された場合は
図中「黒丸」で指示し、良好であると判定された場合に
は図中「白丸」で指示している。When spark butt welding was performed with various welding process values such as upset energization time and upset amount, the AE count value (horizontal axis) 10 seconds after the welding completion, that is, from 10 to tl in Fig. 1, , and thereafter, that is, the AE count fl (vertical axis) of 10 in FIG. 1 is shown as a quality recognition diagram. If the welded part is found to be defective due to the presence of defects in the material test results after welding is completed, it will be indicated by a "black circle" in the diagram, and if it is determined to be good, it will be indicated by a "white circle" in the diagram. ”.
同図に示すように、両AE計数量の関係が曲線A−Aよ
りも下側の領域に位置する場合の溶接部1ま全で不良と
なっており、曲IB−8よりも上側の領域に位置する場
合の溶接部は全て良好となっている。また、曲IA−A
と曲線B−Bとの間の領域は良・不良の境界領域となっ
ている。As shown in the figure, when the relationship between both AE counts is located in the region below curve A-A, the entire weld part 1 is defective, and the region above curve IB-8 is defective. All welds located in the area are in good condition. Also, the song IA-A
The area between and curve B-B is a boundary area between good and bad.
すなわち、火花突合せ溶接終了時点tQからtlまでの
AEE生量と、上記t1以降のAE発発生上を計数し、
これら両AE発生開の計数値を前記良否識別線図に当は
めることにより、非破壊釣力法でリアルタイムにかつ高
信頼度で溶接部を診断することができる。なお、第1図
中時点t2に相当する時間はせいぜい300〜400秒
であり、速やかに診断結果が得られることにかわりはな
い。That is, the amount of AEE generated from the spark butt welding end time tQ to tl and the occurrence of AE generation after the above t1 are counted,
By applying these counts of both AE occurrences to the pass/fail identification diagram, it is possible to diagnose the welded portion in real time and with high reliability using the non-destructive fishing force method. Note that the time corresponding to time t2 in FIG. 1 is at most 300 to 400 seconds, and the diagnostic result can still be obtained quickly.
第3図は本実施例を実現するためのシステム構成を示す
模式口である。第3図において、10a。FIG. 3 is a schematic diagram showing the system configuration for realizing this embodiment. In FIG. 3, 10a.
10bは被溶接部材としての丸棒鋼であって、火花突合
せ溶接により溶接部11の溶接が行なわれるものとなっ
ている。12a、12bは上記丸棒m10a、10bを
それぞれ保持するクランプ部であって、このクランプ部
12a、12bにはAEセンサ13a、13bがそれぞ
れ設けられている。これらAEセンサ13a、13bに
より検出されたAE倍信号、それぞれバンドパスフィル
タ14a、14bに与えられ、所定周波数帯域のAE倍
信号みが増幅器i5a、15bに出力される。そして、
これら増幅器15a、15bにて増幅された所定周波数
帯域のAE倍信号、各識別回路16a、16bにて所定
のしきい値レベルで識別され、しきい値レベル以上の信
号のみが時間差計測部17に供給される。この時間差計
測部17は、内入力信号に基いてAEセンサ12aと1
2bとにそれぞれ到達するAE倍信号到達時間差を求め
るものであって、この時間差計測部17にて求められた
到達時間差に基いてAEカウンタ18により溶接部11
近傍のAE発生農が計数される。Reference numeral 10b is a round steel bar serving as a member to be welded, and the welding portion 11 is welded by spark butt welding. Reference numerals 12a and 12b are clamp parts that hold the round bars m10a and 10b, respectively, and AE sensors 13a and 13b are provided on the clamp parts 12a and 12b, respectively. The AE multiplied signals detected by these AE sensors 13a and 13b are applied to band pass filters 14a and 14b, respectively, and only the AE multiplied signals in a predetermined frequency band are outputted to amplifiers i5a and 15b. and,
The AE multiplied signals in a predetermined frequency band amplified by these amplifiers 15a and 15b are identified at a predetermined threshold level by respective identification circuits 16a and 16b, and only signals above the threshold level are sent to the time difference measuring section 17. Supplied. This time difference measuring section 17 operates between the AE sensors 12a and 1 based on internal input signals.
2b and AE multiplied signal arrival time difference, and based on the arrival time difference determined by the time difference measurement unit 17, the AE counter 18 determines the arrival time difference of the AE multiplied signal reaching the welding part 11.
Farms with AE outbreaks in the vicinity are counted.
このAEカウンタ18のカウント出力は、良否判定回路
19に与えられ、この良否判定回路19にて溶接終了直
後の第1図toからtlに相当する時間内のAE計数量
と、第1図t1からt2に相当する時間内のAE計数量
とを求め、これら両AE計数農を、データテーブル20
に予め格納されている第2図に示す良否識別線図に当て
はめて溶接部11の良否を判定し、判定結果を出力する
。The count output of this AE counter 18 is given to a pass/fail judgment circuit 19, and the pass/fail judgment circuit 19 calculates the AE count within the time period corresponding to tl from to in Fig. 1 immediately after the completion of welding, and from t1 in Fig. 1. The AE counting amount within the time corresponding to t2 is calculated, and these two AE counting amounts are stored in the data table 20.
The quality of the welded portion 11 is determined by applying it to the quality identification diagram shown in FIG. 2, which is stored in advance, and the determination result is output.
上述したようなシステム構成により、丸棒鋼10a、1
0bの溶接部11の状態を非破壊的にリアルタイムで診
断することができる。また、丸棒!j110a、10b
を保持するクランプ部12a。With the system configuration as described above, the round steel bars 10a, 1
The state of the welded portion 11 of 0b can be diagnosed non-destructively in real time. Also, a round bar! j110a, 10b
A clamp portion 12a that holds the.
12bにAEセンサ13a、13bを設けるだけなので
、被溶接部材の形状に囚われず溶接部を診断することが
できる。Since only the AE sensors 13a and 13b are provided on the welding part 12b, the welded portion can be diagnosed regardless of the shape of the welded member.
なお、本発明は前記実施例に限定されるものではない。Note that the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments.
たとえば、前記実施例では被溶接部材として丸棒鋼の火
花突合せ溶接を行なった際の溶接部診断について説明し
たが、被溶接部材の寸法ならびに形状(レール、バイブ
など)に応じてそれぞれの良否識別線図を予め求めてお
(ことにより、様々な被溶接部材の火花突合せ溶接にお
ける溶接部診断を非破壊的にかつリアルタイムで行なう
ことができる。また、第3図においてAEセンサ13a
、13bをクランプ部12a、12bにそれぞれ設けた
場合を示したが、例えば第4図に示すようにクランプ部
12a、12bの外側の丸棒tg10a、10bに直接
AEセンサ13c、13dを設けると共に、溶接部11
の近傍にAEセンサ13eを設け、AEセンサ13c、
13dによりクランプ部12a、12bからの雑音を除
去するようにし、AEセンサ13eによって溶接部11
近傍のAE倍信号検出するようにしてもよい。For example, in the above embodiment, welding part diagnosis was explained when spark butt welding was performed on round steel bars as workpieces, but each pass/fail identification line is determined depending on the size and shape of the workpiece (rail, vibrator, etc.) By obtaining the diagram in advance (thereby, welding part diagnosis in spark butt welding of various workpieces can be performed nondestructively and in real time. Also, in Figure 3, AE sensor 13a
, 13b are provided on the clamp parts 12a, 12b, respectively. For example, as shown in FIG. Welding part 11
An AE sensor 13e is provided near the AE sensor 13c,
13d removes noise from the clamp parts 12a and 12b, and the AE sensor 13e removes noise from the welding part 11.
It is also possible to detect a nearby AE multiplied signal.
このほか、本発明の要旨を逸脱しない範囲で種々変形実
施可能であるのは勿論である。It goes without saying that various other modifications can be made without departing from the spirit of the invention.
以上詳述したように、本発明は、火花突合せ溶接終了後
の主として加圧量に比例するAE発生量と、主として入
熱量に比例するAE発生量とを計数し、これら両AE発
生量により予め設定された良否識別線図に基いて溶接部
を診断するようにしたものである。As described in detail above, the present invention counts the amount of AE generated which is mainly proportional to the amount of pressurization after the completion of spark butt welding, and the amount of AE generated which is mainly proportional to the amount of heat input, and calculates the amount of AE generated in advance based on these two amounts of AE generated. The welded part is diagnosed based on the set pass/fail identification diagram.
したがって、本発明によれば、火花突合せ溶接時に溶接
部のAE発生量が計数され、主として加圧量に比例する
AE計数量と、主として入熱量に比例するA E ff
t数量とが予め設定された良否識別線図における良領域
を満足する場合は溶接部が良好であると評価され、不良
領域に含まれる場合には溶接不良であると評価されるの
で、火花突合せ溶接における溶接部を非破壊的に実時間
でかつ高信頼度で診断することができる火花突合せ溶接
の溶接部診断方法を提供できる。Therefore, according to the present invention, the amount of AE generated in the welded part during spark butt welding is counted, and the AE counting amount is mainly proportional to the amount of pressurization, and the amount of AE generated is mainly proportional to the amount of heat input.
If the t quantity satisfies the good area in the preset pass/fail identification diagram, the weld is evaluated to be good, and if it is included in the bad area, it is evaluated to be a weld defect. It is possible to provide a weld part diagnosis method for spark butt welding that can nondestructively diagnose a weld part in welding in real time and with high reliability.
第1図ないし第3図は本発明の一実施例を説明するため
の図であって、第1図は一般的なAE信号発生パターン
を示す図、第2図は良否識別線図を示す図、第3図は本
実施例を実現するシステム構成を示す系統図、第4図は
AEセンサ取付は位置の変形例を示す模式図、第5図は
火花突合せ溶接を説明するための模式図である。
10a、10b・・・丸棒鋼(被溶接部材)、11・・
・溶接部、12a、12b・・・クランプ部、13a〜
13e・・・AEセンサ、14a、14b・・・バンド
パスフィルタ、15a、15b・・・信号増幅器、16
a、16b・・・識別回路、17・・・時間差計測部、
18・・・AEカウンタ、19・・・良否判定回路、2
0・・・データテーブル。
出願人代理人 弁理士 鈴江武彦
時間□
frX i図
u
第3図1 to 3 are diagrams for explaining one embodiment of the present invention, in which FIG. 1 is a diagram showing a general AE signal generation pattern, and FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a pass/fail identification diagram. , Fig. 3 is a system diagram showing the system configuration for realizing this embodiment, Fig. 4 is a schematic diagram showing a modified example of the mounting position of the AE sensor, and Fig. 5 is a schematic diagram for explaining spark butt welding. be. 10a, 10b... Round steel bar (member to be welded), 11...
・Welding part, 12a, 12b... Clamp part, 13a~
13e...AE sensor, 14a, 14b...Band pass filter, 15a, 15b...Signal amplifier, 16
a, 16b...Identification circuit, 17...Time difference measuring section,
18... AE counter, 19... Pass/fail judgment circuit, 2
0...Data table. Applicant's agent Patent attorney Takehiko Suzue Time□ frX iFigure u Figure 3
Claims (1)
ースティックエミッシヨン量と、主として入熱量に比例
するアコースティックエミッション量とを計数し、これ
ら両アコースティックエミッシヨン量により予め設定さ
れた良否識別線図に基いて溶接部を診断するようにした
ことを特徴とする火花突合せ溶接の溶接部診断方法。After spark butt welding is completed, the amount of acoustic emission, which is mainly proportional to the amount of pressure applied, and the amount of acoustic emission, which is mainly proportional to the amount of heat input, are counted, and based on a preset pass/fail identification diagram based on these two amounts of acoustic emission. A method for diagnosing a welded part of spark butt welding, characterized in that the welded part is diagnosed using the same method.
Priority Applications (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
JP24937185A JPH06100582B2 (en) | 1985-11-07 | 1985-11-07 | Weld diagnosis method for spark butt welding |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
JP24937185A JPH06100582B2 (en) | 1985-11-07 | 1985-11-07 | Weld diagnosis method for spark butt welding |
Publications (2)
Publication Number | Publication Date |
---|---|
JPS62108154A true JPS62108154A (en) | 1987-05-19 |
JPH06100582B2 JPH06100582B2 (en) | 1994-12-12 |
Family
ID=17192025
Family Applications (1)
Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
---|---|---|---|
JP24937185A Expired - Lifetime JPH06100582B2 (en) | 1985-11-07 | 1985-11-07 | Weld diagnosis method for spark butt welding |
Country Status (1)
Country | Link |
---|---|
JP (1) | JPH06100582B2 (en) |
Cited By (1)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN103487136A (en) * | 2013-10-15 | 2014-01-01 | 重庆理工大学 | Method for quantitatively detecting welding spatter by utilizing acoustic emission signal energy equivalent of resistance spot welding process |
Families Citing this family (1)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN103675103B (en) * | 2013-10-15 | 2015-10-07 | 重庆理工大学 | A kind of method utilizing resistance spot welding process Acoustic Emission Signal Energy equivalent quantitatively to detect nugget crackle |
-
1985
- 1985-11-07 JP JP24937185A patent/JPH06100582B2/en not_active Expired - Lifetime
Cited By (2)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN103487136A (en) * | 2013-10-15 | 2014-01-01 | 重庆理工大学 | Method for quantitatively detecting welding spatter by utilizing acoustic emission signal energy equivalent of resistance spot welding process |
CN103487136B (en) * | 2013-10-15 | 2016-01-20 | 重庆理工大学 | A kind of method utilizing resistance spot welding process Acoustic Emission Signal Energy equivalent quantitatively to detect welding splash |
Also Published As
Publication number | Publication date |
---|---|
JPH06100582B2 (en) | 1994-12-12 |
Similar Documents
Publication | Publication Date | Title |
---|---|---|
US4144766A (en) | Apparatus for the in-situ detection and location of flaws in welds | |
US5756967A (en) | Sensing ARC welding process characteristics for welding process control | |
US5474225A (en) | Automated method for butt weld inspection and defect diagnosis | |
US3986391A (en) | Method and apparatus for the real-time monitoring of a continuous weld using stress-wave emission techniques | |
US4480475A (en) | Real-time ultrasonic weld inspection method | |
EP0277467B1 (en) | Method and apparatus for the non-destructive checking of spotwelds between metal sheets,produced by electric welding | |
US20080237197A1 (en) | System and method for welding and real time monitoring of seam welded parts | |
JPS6243565A (en) | Real time monitoring of welding defect | |
JPH0763694A (en) | Nondestructive inspection apparatus for spot-welded part | |
JPS62108154A (en) | Method for diagnosing weld zone in flash butt welding | |
JP2725582B2 (en) | Nugget diameter measurement method for spot welding | |
JP2861649B2 (en) | Steel plate weld inspection method | |
JP2001191186A (en) | Quality evaluation system for weld zone | |
JPH1058170A (en) | Method and device for judging quality of laser beam welding | |
JPS5856830B2 (en) | Kanjiyoubuzaiohihakaiteki ni Kensasur Hohou Oyobi Souchi | |
JP2000046696A (en) | Quality inspection method for friction pressure welding part | |
JPH08215868A (en) | Method and device for monitoring welding | |
JPH0440359A (en) | Nondestructive inspecting method for spot weld zone | |
JPH05115903A (en) | Quality determining device for strip weld zone | |
JPS63165077A (en) | Method for deciding quality of stud welding | |
JP2786806B2 (en) | Evaluation method for thin plate welds | |
JP2000312976A (en) | Method and device for non-destructive inspection in projection welding, welding device, and producing method of welding processing article | |
JP3260477B2 (en) | Diagnosis method for welds of thin plates | |
JP2000111328A (en) | Method for inspecting welding part of welding pipe | |
Lee et al. | Measurement of weld bead defect for shock absorber using laser vision sensor |