JP3028438B2 - Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength - Google Patents

Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength

Info

Publication number
JP3028438B2
JP3028438B2 JP22626992A JP22626992A JP3028438B2 JP 3028438 B2 JP3028438 B2 JP 3028438B2 JP 22626992 A JP22626992 A JP 22626992A JP 22626992 A JP22626992 A JP 22626992A JP 3028438 B2 JP3028438 B2 JP 3028438B2
Authority
JP
Japan
Prior art keywords
coil spring
spring
fatigue strength
shot peening
residual stress
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Lifetime
Application number
JP22626992A
Other languages
Japanese (ja)
Other versions
JPH0674274A (en
Inventor
道昭 舘山
武司 三木
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Nippon Steel Corp
Original Assignee
Nippon Steel Corp
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Nippon Steel Corp filed Critical Nippon Steel Corp
Priority to JP22626992A priority Critical patent/JP3028438B2/en
Publication of JPH0674274A publication Critical patent/JPH0674274A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of JP3028438B2 publication Critical patent/JP3028438B2/en
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical
Expired - Lifetime legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02PCLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THE PRODUCTION OR PROCESSING OF GOODS
    • Y02P10/00Technologies related to metal processing
    • Y02P10/20Recycling

Landscapes

  • Springs (AREA)
  • Wire Processing (AREA)

Description

【発明の詳細な説明】DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

【0001】[0001]

【産業上の利用分野】本発明は、自動車エンジンにおけ
る弁ばね、あるいは懸架ばね等、高度の疲労特性が要求
されている分野に用いられる、母材硬さHvが700以
上の高強度コイルばねに関するものである。
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 1. Field of the Invention The present invention relates to a high-strength coil spring having a base material hardness Hv of 700 or more, which is used in fields requiring a high degree of fatigue characteristics, such as a valve spring or a suspension spring in an automobile engine. Things.

【0002】[0002]

【従来の技術】一般にばねは、JIS−G3502、3
506あるいは4801に規定されている鋼材などを用
い、単に焼入れ焼戻しをしたものが多い。しかし、最
近、自動車関連のコイルばね類は、高強度化の方向にあ
り、エンジンの弁ばねの一部には特公昭36−9406
号公報にあるように、500℃近傍の低温で浸炭窒化し
たものさえある。一方、ばねの強度が高くなると、現状
の製造工程能力からも、不可避と思われるほど微小な表
面欠陥によってばねの疲労特性を阻害するようになる。
2. Description of the Related Art Generally, springs are JIS-G3502, 3
In many cases, steel materials specified in 506 or 4801 are simply quenched and tempered. However, recently, coil springs related to automobiles have been increasing in strength, and some of engine valve springs have been disclosed in Japanese Patent Publication No. 36-9406.
As described in the publication, there is even a carbonitrided material at a low temperature of around 500 ° C. On the other hand, when the strength of the spring increases, the fatigue characteristics of the spring are impaired by minute surface defects that seem inevitable from the current manufacturing process capability.

【0003】そのために、「ばね技術研究会会報」N
o.203(AUG.1988−P7)や特開昭63−
52729号公報「耐疲れ性にすぐれたばねおよびその
製造方法」さらには特開平2−129421号公報「高
強度コイルばねおよびその製造方法」と特開平2−12
9422号公報「高強度コイルばねおよびその製造方
法」にあるように、ばねを電解研磨仕上げすることによ
り、表面欠陥やショットピーニングにより生じた圧痕を
低減して疲労寿命を向上させることが報告されている。
このばねの電解研磨仕上げ方法は、ばねの疲労強度向上
の今後の一方法と考えられるが、コイルばねの場合、ば
ねの全表面を一様に仕上げることに問題があり、且つコ
イルばねの内側に陰極をその都度配置する必要があるた
め極めて効率が悪い。
[0003] For that purpose, "Spring Technology Research Society Bulletin" N
o. 203 (AUG. 1988-P7) and JP-A-63-1988.
JP-A-52729, "Spring with excellent fatigue resistance and method of manufacturing the same", and JP-A-2-129421, "High-strength coil spring and method of manufacturing the same", and JP-A-2-12.
As described in Japanese Patent No. 9422, “High-strength coil spring and manufacturing method thereof”, it has been reported that by subjecting the spring to electrolytic polishing, the indentation caused by surface defects and shot peening is reduced to improve the fatigue life. I have.
This method of electropolishing the spring is considered to be one of the future methods for improving the fatigue strength of the spring. However, in the case of the coil spring, there is a problem in that the entire surface of the spring is uniformly finished, and the inside of the coil spring has a problem. Since the cathode needs to be arranged each time, the efficiency is extremely low.

【0004】また、タンブリング(バレルの中に被加工
物を入れて回転させ、被加工物同士の衝突によって、被
加工物表面の油やスケールを除去する)や液体ホーニン
グもばねの表面仕上げ法として検討されていることが、
「ばね技術研究会偏;ばね、第3版」(1982−P4
37)に記載されているが、これらはいずれもショット
ピーニング類似の処理、即ち圧縮残留応力という観点か
ら検討されたものであって、以下にいう本発明の表面疵
対策とは全く関係のないものである。
[0004] Tumbling (putting a work in a barrel and rotating it to remove oil and scale on the work surface by collision of the work) and liquid honing are also methods of spring surface finishing. What is being considered,
"Spring Technology Research Association, Spring, Third Edition" (1982-P4)
37), all of which have been examined from the viewpoint of treatment similar to shot peening, that is, compressive residual stress, and have nothing to do with the following surface flaw countermeasures of the present invention. It is.

【0005】[0005]

【発明が解決しようとする課題】例えば、自動車の高性
能化に伴い、疲労強度の高いばねが強く望まれている。
このような要望に応えるためには、ばねの強度、特に表
面硬さを高くする必要がある。而して、現状では完全に
なくすことが不可能であると思われるほどの微小な表面
欠陥が問題となる。本発明は、かかる表面欠陥のない疲
労強度に優れた高強度コイルばねを提供することを目的
とする。
For example, with the advancement of the performance of automobiles, springs having high fatigue strength are strongly desired.
In order to meet such a demand, it is necessary to increase the strength of the spring, particularly the surface hardness. Thus, there is a problem with minute surface defects that are considered impossible to completely eliminate at present. An object of the present invention is to provide a high-strength coil spring having no such surface defects and excellent in fatigue strength.

【0006】[0006]

【課題を解決するための手段】本発明の要旨とするとこ
ろは、炭素鋼線あるいは合金鋼線を用いたコイルばねで
あって、90±10kgf/mm2 の圧縮残留応力が表
層から150μm深さの内部まで分布し、最大粗さRm
axで1.0μm以下の表面粗さを有する母材硬さHv
が700以上である疲労強度に優れたコイルばねにあ
る。
The gist of the present invention is to provide a coil spring using a carbon steel wire or an alloy steel wire.
There are 90 distributed from the compression residual stress of ± 10 kgf / mm 2 is the surface to the interior of 150μm depth, maximum roughness Rm
Base material hardness Hv having a surface roughness of 1.0 μm or less in ax
Is a coil spring having excellent fatigue strength of 700 or more.

【0007】[0007]

【作用】以下、本発明の詳細について、説明する。近
年、コイルばね素材の疵検査技術も高まっており、深さ
60μm以上の表面疵はほぼ検出できる。母材硬さHv
が500未満の一般のコイルばねでは、この程度の表面
疵が問題になることは少ない。しかし、母材硬度Hvが
500以上、700未満の炭素鋼線または合金鋼線を用
いたコイルばねで、疲労試験の剪断応力τ=60±50
kgf/mm2 で繰返し回数が5×107 以上を保証す
る場合には、深さ60μm以上の表面疵はもちろん、深
さ10乃至30μmのものでも、表面疵を起点として疲
労破損することがある。特に窒化処理をして表面硬さH
vを700以上にもしたコイルばねになると、上記のよ
うな表面疵保証では必ず表面疵を起点として疲労破壊す
るので、信頼できる疲労強度を保証することはできな
い。
Hereinafter, the present invention will be described in detail. In recent years, techniques for inspecting flaws in coil spring materials have been increasing, and surface flaws having a depth of 60 μm or more can be almost detected. Base material hardness Hv
Is less than 500, there is little problem with such a surface flaw. However, in a coil spring using a carbon steel wire or an alloy steel wire having a base material hardness Hv of 500 or more and less than 700, the shear stress τ = 60 ± 50 in the fatigue test was used.
In the case where the number of repetitions is 5 × 10 7 or more at kgf / mm 2 , fatigue damage may occur from the surface flaw even if the depth is 10 to 30 μm as well as the surface flaw having a depth of 60 μm or more. . In particular, the surface hardness H
In the case of a coil spring having a v of 700 or more, the above-mentioned surface flaw guarantee always causes fatigue fracture starting from the surface flaw, so that reliable fatigue strength cannot be guaranteed.

【0008】コイルばねの疲労強度を高めるために、ば
ねの表面硬さを高くするわけであるが、表面疵が保証で
きない限り、その効果は望めない。そこで、本発明者ら
は、母材硬さHvが700以上の炭素鋼線または合金鋼
線を用いてコイルばねの表面疵を保証するために、現状
のコイルばね製造工程におけるショットピーニングの直
後にバレル研磨仕上げを施すことにより、前記の効果が
得られることを見出した。バレル研磨仕上げは、6〜8
角形断面の筒状容器の中に被加工物(コイルばね)と適
当な粒度のアランダムやカーボランダムなどの砥粒、少
量の水およびコンパウンドと称されている種々の研磨促
進剤をそれぞれ適当量一緒に入れて、数時間回転あるい
は振動させて行う。
In order to increase the fatigue strength of the coil spring, the surface hardness of the spring is increased, but the effect cannot be expected unless surface defects can be guaranteed. Therefore, the present inventors, in order to guarantee the surface flaw of the coil spring using a carbon steel wire or alloy steel wire having a base metal hardness Hv of 700 or more, immediately after shot peening in the current coil spring manufacturing process. It has been found that the above effects can be obtained by performing barrel polishing. Barrel polishing finish is 6-8
Workpiece (coil spring), abrasive grains such as alundum and carborundum of appropriate particle size, a small amount of water, and various polishing accelerators called compounds are placed in an appropriate amount in a cylindrical container having a square cross section. Put together and rotate or shake for several hours.

【0009】本発明では、バレル研磨による表面粗さ条
件を規定することが、重要な要件である。即ち、母材硬
さHvが700以上の炭素鋼線または合金鋼線を用い
て、コイルばねを得る製造工程において、コイルばね成
形後行われるショットピーニング処理に続いてバレル研
磨を施すことによって、表面粗さを最大粗さRmaxで
1.0μm以下に仕上げる。最大粗さRmaxが1.0
μmを超えると、母材硬さの高いばね、特にHvが70
0以上ともなると切欠感受性が高くなるため疲労強度が
低下する。母材硬さHvを700以上とするには、例え
ばJIS−G3502、G3506、G4801に規定
されている鋼線や、あるいは合金線を用いて焼入れ焼戻
しを行い、その際、焼入れあるいは焼戻し温度を調整す
ることによって可能である。
In the present invention, it is an important requirement to define surface roughness conditions by barrel polishing. That is, in a manufacturing process of obtaining a coil spring using a carbon steel wire or an alloy steel wire having a base material hardness Hv of 700 or more, barrel polishing is performed following a shot peening process performed after the coil spring is formed, so that the surface is polished. Finish the roughness to a maximum roughness Rmax of 1.0 μm or less. Maximum roughness Rmax is 1.0
If it exceeds μm, a spring having a high base material hardness, especially Hv of 70
If the value is 0 or more, the notch sensitivity increases, and the fatigue strength decreases. To make the base metal hardness Hv 700 or more, for example,
Stipulated in JIS-G3502, G3506, G4801
Quenching and tempering using steel wire or alloy wire
And then adjust the quenching or tempering temperature.
It is possible by doing.

【0010】圧縮残留応力は、外力による引張応力を相
殺するために付加するが、上限を超えて付加してもショ
ットピーニング処理が非能率的となり、下限を下回る
と、特に表面近傍で外力の引張応力を相殺することが困
難になるため、その範囲を90±10kgf/mm2
する。また、その深さを表面から150μmまでとした
のは、通常の製造方法では鋼中に最大の大きさで20μ
mの非金属介在物が存在し、これが外力の引張応力によ
って疲労亀裂発生の起点となるため、外力の引張応力を
内部深さ150μmまで相殺すれば、現状の鋼中非金属
介在物の大きさ最大20μmによる疲労亀裂発生が抑制
可能となるためであり、150μmを超えて分布しても
特性の上では問題がないが、ショットピーニング処理の
面で経済的制約を考慮して、圧縮残留応力の及ぶ範囲を
表層から150μmとする。残留応力の付与には、カッ
トワイヤなどを用いたショットピーニングを適用するこ
とができる。その際、ショットの投射強度と投射時間を
調整して残留応力の大きさとその深さを調整することが
できる。
The compressive residual stress is added to offset the tensile stress due to external force. However, even if the compressive residual stress is added beyond the upper limit, the shot peening treatment becomes inefficient. Since it is difficult to cancel the stress, the range is set to 90 ± 10 kgf / mm 2 . The reason why the depth is set to 150 μm from the surface is that the maximum size in steel is 20 μm in a normal manufacturing method.
m of non-metallic inclusions, which are caused by external tensile stress
Therefore, if the tensile stress of the external force is offset to an internal depth of 150 μm , the occurrence of fatigue cracks due to the current maximum non-metallic inclusion size of 20 μm in steel can be suppressed. Although there is no problem in characteristics even if the distribution exceeds 150 μm, the range of the compressive residual stress is set to 150 μm from the surface layer in consideration of economic restrictions in the shot peening process. To apply residual stress,
Apply shot peening with wire
Can be. At that time, adjust the shot projection intensity and projection time
To adjust the magnitude and depth of residual stress
it can.

【0011】このバレル研磨仕上げは、現状のコイルば
ね製造工程におけるショットピーニングの直後に行うの
が良い。即ち、ショットピーニングによりコイルばね表
面に凹凸が生じ、これが疲労強度低下の原因の一つにも
なっていることを考えると、ショットピーニングの直後
が好ましい。しかしながら、表面疵がショットピーニン
グによって叩き込まれることもあるので、好ましくはシ
ョットピーニング前でも軽度のバレル研磨をすればその
効果はさらに向上する。
The barrel polishing is preferably performed immediately after shot peening in the current coil spring manufacturing process. That is, considering that the surface of the coil spring becomes uneven due to the shot peening, which is one of the causes of the decrease in the fatigue strength, it is preferable to immediately after the shot peening. However, since surface flaws may be hammered by shot peening, the effect is further improved by light barrel polishing, preferably before shot peening.

【0012】コイルばねは、へたり特性を向上させるた
めにセッチングが必要であるため、本発明においても、
ショットピーニング、バレル研磨仕上げを施した後セッ
チングを行う。本発明が対象とするコイルばね材として
は、例えば、JIS−G3502、G3506、G48
01等に規定されている成分を有するピアノ線材、硬鋼
線材、あるいはばね鋼鋼材、その他の合金線材を用いる
ことができる。これらのばね材は、これらの規格に規定
されている製造方法によって溶製後、熱間圧延され、必
要に応じて冷間引き抜き、切削、研磨あるいはこれらを
組み合わせた冷間加工を施して製造することができる。
これらのばね鋼材は、例えば、JIS−G4801に記
されているような適切な温度にて焼入れ焼戻しなどの熱
処理を施すことにより、所要の母材硬さにすることがで
きる。これらの処理によって得られたコイルばねを上述
のようにショットピーニング、バレル研磨等を施すこと
によって所要の残留応力、表面粗さを得ることができ
る。
[0012] Since the coil spring needs to be set in order to improve the set characteristic, in the present invention also,
After performing shot peening and barrel polishing, setting is performed. As a coil spring material targeted by the present invention
Is, for example, JIS-G3502, G3506, G48
Piano wires and hard steels with components specified in 01 etc.
Use wire, spring steel, or other alloy wire
be able to. These spring materials are specified in these standards.
Hot-rolled after melting by the
Cold drawing, cutting, polishing or
It can be manufactured by performing a combination of cold working.
These spring steel materials are described in, for example, JIS-G4801.
Heat such as quenching and tempering at an appropriate temperature
By processing, the required base metal hardness can be obtained.
Wear. The coil spring obtained by these processes is described above.
Subject to shot peening, barrel polishing, etc.
Required residual stress and surface roughness
You.

【0013】[0013]

【実施例】以下に、本発明の効果を実施例により、さら
に具体的に示す。母材硬さHvを730〜870まで熱
処理条件によって変化させたφ3.0mmの弁ばね用シ
リコンクロム鋼オイルテンパー線を用い、ばね平均径2
4.2mm、ばね高さ52mm、総巻数6.5巻、有効
巻数4.5巻のコイルばねを成形した。その後、0.8
mm径のカットワイヤによりショットピーニングをして
圧縮残留応力を付与し、直ちに6角回転バレル内にコイ
ルばねを各5個入れ、砥粒、コンパウンド、水などを適
当量配合して、粗研磨と仕上げ研磨のバレル研磨時間を
それぞれ変えてコイルばねの表面粗さを変化させ、その
後セッチングした。
EXAMPLES The effects of the present invention will be more specifically described below with reference to examples. A spring average diameter of 2 was used using a φ3.0 mm silicon chrome steel oil-tempered wire for a valve spring in which the base metal hardness Hv was changed according to heat treatment conditions from 730 to 870.
A coil spring having 4.2 mm, a spring height of 52 mm, a total number of turns of 6.5, and an effective number of turns of 4.5 was formed. Then 0.8
Immediate shot peening with a cut wire of mm diameter to give compressive residual stress, immediately put 5 coil springs each in a hexagonal rotating barrel, mix appropriate amounts of abrasive grains, compound, water, etc. The surface roughness of the coil spring was changed by respectively changing the barrel polishing time of the final polishing, and thereafter, the setting was performed.

【0014】ここで本発明の効果を明瞭にするために、
これら全てのコイルばね表面の粗さおよび圧縮残留応力
を測定した。残留応力は表層および表層から20μmピ
ッチで150μmまで測定し、その平均値を残留応力分
布の値として示し、また平均値の±10kgf/mm2
の範囲で分布している深さを表1に示した。また、比較
材は上記と同様の硬度を得てからコイルばね成形後、シ
ョットピーニングを行い、その後バレル研磨処理したも
のは表面粗さを変化させ、バレル研磨処理しなかったも
のはそのままセッチングを行った。
Here, in order to clarify the effects of the present invention,
The surface roughness and compressive residual stress of all these coil springs were measured. The residual stress was measured from the surface layer and from the surface layer to 150 μm at a pitch of 20 μm, the average value was shown as the value of the residual stress distribution, and ± 10 kgf / mm 2 of the average value.
Table 1 shows the depths distributed in the range. In addition, the comparative material obtained the same hardness as above, after forming a coil spring, performed shot peening, then changed the surface roughness of the barrel-polished one, and set it as it was without the barrel-polishing. Was.

【0015】このようにして製造したコイルばねについ
て、ばね形状から計算される剪断応力(τm=65±5
0kgf/mm2 )になる圧縮荷重を繰返し負荷して疲
労寿命を5×107 回を限度に求めた。これらの結果を
表2に示す。その結果、本発明のショットピーニング直
後にバレル研磨仕上げを施したコイルばねは高寿命を示
すものであったが、特に母材硬度を考慮した最適な表面
粗さとし、且つ内部深く圧縮残留応力が分布したコイル
ばねは、保証疲労寿命を確保している。一方、比較例と
したものは、大半が表面疵による破損発生であった。
For the coil spring thus manufactured, the shear stress calculated from the spring shape (τm = 65 ± 5)
0 kgf / mm 2 ) was repeatedly applied with a compressive load, and the fatigue life was determined up to 5 × 10 7 times. Table 2 shows the results. As a result, the coil spring of the present invention, which was subjected to barrel polishing immediately after shot peening, exhibited a long service life, but had an optimum surface roughness, especially considering the base metal hardness, and a compressive residual stress distributed deep inside. The coil spring has a guaranteed fatigue life. On the other hand, in the case of the comparative example, most of the damage was caused by surface flaws.

【0016】[0016]

【表1】 [Table 1]

【0017】[0017]

【表2】 [Table 2]

【0018】[0018]

【発明の効果】以上述べた如く、本発明によれば、自動
車用エンジンの弁ばねあるいは懸架ばねの疲労強度を大
幅に向上させることができるので、産業上極めて有用で
ある。
As described above, according to the present invention, the fatigue strength of a valve spring or a suspension spring of an automobile engine can be greatly improved, which is extremely useful in industry.

───────────────────────────────────────────────────── フロントページの続き (56)参考文献 特開 平4−272524(JP,A) 特開 平5−86418(JP,A) 実開 平1−127634(JP,U) ────────────────────────────────────────────────── ─── Continuation of the front page (56) References JP-A-4-272524 (JP, A) JP-A-5-86418 (JP, A) JP-A-1-127634 (JP, U)

Claims (1)

(57)【特許請求の範囲】(57) [Claims] 【請求項1】 炭素鋼線あるいは合金鋼線を用いたコイ
ルばねであって、90±10kgf/mm2 の圧縮残留
応力が表層から150μm深さの内部まで分布し、最大
粗さRmaxで1.0μm以下の表面粗さを有する母材
硬さHvが700以上である疲労強度に優れたコイルば
ね。
1. A coil using a carbon steel wire or an alloy steel wire.
A base material having a compressive residual stress of 90 ± 10 kgf / mm 2 distributed from the surface layer to a depth of 150 μm and having a maximum roughness Rmax of not more than 1.0 μm has a base material hardness Hv of 700. A coil spring excellent in fatigue strength as described above.
JP22626992A 1992-08-25 1992-08-25 Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength Expired - Lifetime JP3028438B2 (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP22626992A JP3028438B2 (en) 1992-08-25 1992-08-25 Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP22626992A JP3028438B2 (en) 1992-08-25 1992-08-25 Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
JPH0674274A JPH0674274A (en) 1994-03-15
JP3028438B2 true JP3028438B2 (en) 2000-04-04

Family

ID=16842561

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
JP22626992A Expired - Lifetime JP3028438B2 (en) 1992-08-25 1992-08-25 Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength

Country Status (1)

Country Link
JP (1) JP3028438B2 (en)

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
JPH0674274A (en) 1994-03-15

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US7699943B2 (en) Method for manufacturing high-strength spring
KR101170248B1 (en) Material for projecting material for shot-peening, finished wire, production process, and projecting material for shot-peening
JP6241136B2 (en) Case-hardened steel
WO2012018144A1 (en) Spring and manufacture method thereof
JP5711539B2 (en) Spring with excellent corrosion fatigue strength
JP5184935B2 (en) Oil tempered wire manufacturing method and spring
JP2003105498A (en) High strength spring, and production method therefor
WO2012133885A1 (en) Spring and method for producing same
EP0614994B1 (en) Spring steel wires and process for producing the same
EP3336206A1 (en) Method for manufacturing product member, and product member
WO2020230880A1 (en) Steel wire and hot-rolled wire material
JP3028438B2 (en) Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength
JP6477129B2 (en) Product member manufacturing method and product member
JP5540433B2 (en) Spring excellent in sag resistance and durability and method for manufacturing the same
JP2001082518A (en) Coil spring and its manufacturing method
JP2001079766A (en) Projection material for shot peening
JPH0674273A (en) Coil spring with excellent fatigue strength
JP2803915B2 (en) Method of improving fatigue strength of high strength coil spring
JP3301088B2 (en) Spring with excellent fatigue resistance
JP2009270150A (en) Method for manufacturing coil spring
JP2001049337A (en) Production of high strength spring excellent in fatigue strength
JP5523241B2 (en) Spring and manufacturing method thereof
JPH05156351A (en) Manufacture of coil spring with oil tempered wire
JP7163770B2 (en) Rolling bearing component and manufacturing method thereof
JPH04371333A (en) Manufacture of spring superior in fatigue strength

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
A02 Decision of refusal

Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A02

Effective date: 19980317

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20080204

Year of fee payment: 8

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20090204

Year of fee payment: 9

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20090204

Year of fee payment: 9

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20100204

Year of fee payment: 10

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20100204

Year of fee payment: 10

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20110204

Year of fee payment: 11

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20110204

Year of fee payment: 11

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20120204

Year of fee payment: 12

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20120204

Year of fee payment: 12

FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20130204

Year of fee payment: 13

EXPY Cancellation because of completion of term
FPAY Renewal fee payment (event date is renewal date of database)

Free format text: PAYMENT UNTIL: 20130204

Year of fee payment: 13