JP2021089768A - Presentation evaluation device, presentation evaluation system, presentation evaluation program, and control method for the presentation evaluation device - Google Patents

Abstract

To provide a presentation evaluation device capable of quickly and objectively evaluating a presentation of an explainer conducting the presentation, and a presentation evaluation system, a presentation evaluation program, and a control method for the presentation evaluation device thereof.SOLUTION: In a presentation education complementary system, a management server 40 includes a server side control unit 41. The server side control unit 41 controls a server side communication device 42 for communication with a terminal, a server side display 43 for displaying various kinds of information, and a server side input device 44 for inputting the various kinds of information. The presentation education complementary system transmits, to a terminal of an evaluating person, slide information for displaying object items to be explained as the presentation, photographed information obtained by photographing an evaluation object person himself/herself, voice information of the evaluation object person, and other slide information stored in association with evaluation information, and stores the evaluation information input to the terminal of the evaluating person.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 3

Description

The present invention relates to a presentation evaluation device for evaluating a presentation, a presentation evaluation system, a presentation evaluation program, and a control method for the presentation evaluation device.

Conventionally, various proposals for supporting a presentation for explaining a specific content to a target person using slides or the like have been made (for example, Patent Document 1 and the like).
Then, the explainer who gives the presentation usually practices to explain the same content before actually giving the presentation.
Even if such presentation practice is performed only by the explainer, the points to be improved cannot be clarified, and if possible, the instructor who can accurately point out the points to be improved in the explanation content of the presentation should judge and evaluate. desirable.

Japanese Unexamined Patent Publication No. 2005-243027

However, when requesting an evaluator such as an instructor to evaluate a presentation, there is a problem that it is difficult to coordinate the schedules of both parties. In addition, when the evaluator evaluates the presentation, the evaluation is biased toward the subjective evaluation and it is difficult to make an objective evaluation.

Therefore, the present invention can easily and quickly request the evaluator to evaluate the evaluation without adjusting the schedules of both the evaluated person such as the explainer who gives the presentation and the evaluator, and the evaluation is also quick. Another object of the present invention is to provide a presentation evaluation device, a presentation evaluation system, a presentation evaluation program, and a control method of the presentation evaluation device that can be objectively performed.

According to the present invention, the object is to store a storage unit for storing slide information for displaying an object to be described as a presentation, and at least to store imaging information obtained by imaging the evaluated person himself / herself who is explaining the object. A storage unit, a storage unit that stores voice information uttered regarding the explanation content of the evaluated person, and a storage unit that stores other slide information related to the target item and already stored in association with the evaluation information. The slide information, the imaging information, the audio information, and the other slide information stored in the storage unit are transmitted to the evaluator terminal device, which is the evaluator's terminal device, and the evaluator. The evaluation information input via the terminal device is stored, and the appearance information of a predetermined important word included in the voice information is stored in association with the corresponding time information, and the important word is stored. Achieved by a presentation evaluation device characterized in that the validity of the development of the explanation content is judged based on the degree of appearance frequency and the explanation content development validity information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device. Will be done.

According to the above configuration, slide information for displaying target items (for example, in-house products, etc.) to be explained as a presentation, and a figure in which an evaluated person such as an explainer explains the target items (for example, in-house products, etc.) on slides, etc. The imaged information and the audio information thereof are transmitted to the evaluator terminal of the evaluator such as the boss of the explainer.
Therefore, it is possible to request the evaluator to evaluate the evaluation easily and quickly without adjusting the schedules of both the evaluator who gives the presentation and the evaluator such as the boss.
In addition, the evaluator such as the boss shall evaluate the presentation while visually recognizing the captured information such as the video in which the evaluated person such as the explainer is actually practicing the presentation and listening to the audio information at the same time. Can be done. Therefore, the judgment can be made more accurately.

Further, according to the above configuration, not only slide information, imaging information and audio information but also other slide information related to the target item and already stored in association with the evaluation information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal. It has become.
Therefore, when the evaluator evaluates the presentation of the evaluated person, other related slides and the evaluation thereof can be referred to, so that a more objective evaluation can be performed quickly.
According to the above configuration, the evaluation information (comments, etc.) of the evaluator is also stored, so that the evaluator can not only know his / her own evaluation at any time, but also evaluate the presentations of other evaluators. The evaluation information can also be used as an objective evaluation material.
Further, according to the above configuration, the validity of the development of the explanation content is determined based on the frequency of appearance of important words. That is, for example, when the frequency of occurrence of important words becomes extremely low in the latter half of the explanation, it is judged that the theme of the explanation is inappropriate and the development of the explanation content is not appropriate, and this explanation content development validity information is evaluated. It is configured to be transmitted to the personal terminal device. Therefore, the evaluator can easily judge the validity of the development of the explanation content.

Preferably, based on the imaging information, the eye-gaze angle information of the imaged person to be evaluated is generated, the suitability of the line-of-sight angle information is determined, and the determination result information is used as the slide information, the imaging information, and the above. It is characterized in that it is configured to be transmitted to the evaluator terminal device together with the voice information and the other slide information.

According to the above configuration, the suitability of the line-of-sight angle information of the evaluated person in the presentation is determined, and the determination result information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal.
Therefore, the evaluator can judge whether or not the evaluated person maintains an appropriate line of sight during the presentation, and thereby judge the appropriateness of the way of speaking.

Preferably, it is configured to store the instruction portion information which is a portion pointed by the pointer forming tool with respect to the slide information and transmit the instruction portion information to the evaluator terminal device. It is a feature.

According to the above configuration, since the instruction portion information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device, the evaluator can easily and appropriately determine whether or not the evaluated person points to an appropriate portion with the mark forming tool. You can judge.

Preferably, the ambiguity of the sentence is determined based on the appearance rate information of the specific phrase indicating the existence of the subject included in the voice information within a predetermined time, and the determination information of the ambiguity is used as the evaluator terminal device. It is characterized in that it is configured to be transmitted to.

According to the above structure, the ambiguity of a sentence (for example, the subject) is based on the appearance rate information of a specific word / phrase (for example, a phrase related to a subject such as "ha" or "ga") included in the voice information within a predetermined time. Is insufficient, etc.), and the judgment information of such ambiguity (unclear explanation information) is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device.
Therefore, the evaluator can easily determine whether or not the explanation is unclear as a sentence or the like due to lack of the subject or the like.

Preferably, the evaluator terminal device, which is a terminal operated by the evaluator, and the evaluator terminal device are included, and the evaluator terminal device and the evaluator terminal device are communicably connected to each other. A presentation evaluation system comprising the presentation evaluation device according to any one of claims 1 to 5.

According to the present invention, the object is slide information for displaying an object to be described as a presentation, at least imaging information obtained by imaging the evaluated person who is explaining the object, and explanation of the evaluated person. The slide information, the imaging information, the audio information, and the presentation evaluation device that stores the audio information uttered regarding the content and other slide information that is related to the target item and is already stored in association with the evaluation information. A function of transmitting the other slide information to the evaluator terminal device, which is the evaluator's terminal device, and storing the evaluation information input via the evaluator terminal device, a predetermined importance included in the voice information. The appearance information of the word and the corresponding time information are stored in association with each other, the validity of the development of the explanation content is determined based on the degree of appearance frequency of the important word, and the evaluation of the explanation content development validity information. It is achieved by the function of transmitting to the personal terminal device and the presentation evaluation program for executing the function.

According to the present invention, the object is to store slide information for displaying an object to be described as a presentation in a storage unit, and at least to store imaged information obtained by imaging the evaluated person who is explaining the object. The voice information uttered regarding the explanation content of the evaluated person is stored in the storage unit, and other slide information related to the target item and already stored in association with the evaluation information is stored in the storage unit. Then, the slide information, the imaging information, the audio information, and the other slide information are transmitted to the evaluator terminal device which is the evaluator's terminal device, and the evaluation information input via the evaluator terminal device is transmitted. Is memorized, the appearance information of the important word included in the voice information and the corresponding time information are memorized in association with each other, and the validity of the development of the explanation content is appropriate based on the degree of appearance frequency of the important word. Is achieved by the control method of the presentation evaluation device, which is characterized in that the above-mentioned explanation content expansion validity information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device.

INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY The present invention can easily and quickly request the evaluator to evaluate the evaluation without adjusting the schedules of both the evaluator such as the explainer who gives the presentation and the evaluator, and the evaluation is also quick and objective. There is an advantage that a presentation evaluation device, a presentation evaluation system, a presentation evaluation program, and a control method of the presentation evaluation device can be provided.

It is the schematic which shows the main structure of the presentation education supplement system, for example, which is the presentation evaluation system of this invention. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main structure of the 001 terminal of FIG. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main configuration of the management server of FIG. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the 1st server-side various information storage part. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the 2nd server-side various information storage part. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the 3rd server-side various information storage part. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the 4th server-side information storage part. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the 5th server-side information storage part. It is a schematic flowchart which shows the main operation example of this system. It is another schematic flowchart which shows the main operation example of this system. It is another schematic flowchart which shows the main operation example of this system. It is another schematic flowchart which shows the main operation example of this system. It is another schematic flowchart which shows the main operation example of this system.

Hereinafter, preferred embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings and the like.
Since the embodiments described below are suitable specific examples of the present invention, various technically preferable limitations are attached, but the scope of the present invention particularly limits the present invention in the following description. Unless otherwise stated, the present invention is not limited to these aspects.

FIG. 1 is a schematic view showing a main configuration of, for example, a presentation education supplementary system 1 which is a presentation evaluation system of the present invention.
As shown in FIG. 1, in this system 1, for example, W Pharmaceutical Company has a presentation evaluation device, for example, a management server 40.
In addition, this system 1 is an example of "001 terminal" 10a ("evaluated person terminal device") which is a terminal of Mr. Z of MR (Medical Representive) who is a medical representative employed by W Pharmaceutical Company. ), MR Z's boss Y's terminal "002 terminal" 10b (an example of "evaluator terminal device") and MR Z's colleague MR X's terminal "003" It has a "terminal" 10c.
Further, in the present embodiment, MR will be described as an example, but the present invention is not limited to this, and MSL (Medical Science Liaison), MA (Medical Assistant) and the like are also used. included.

The management servers 40, 001 terminals 10a, 002 terminals 10b, and 003 terminals 10c are connected to each other so as to be able to communicate with each other via the Internet network 2, base stations 3a, 3b, 3c, and the like.

The 001 terminal 10a, the 002 terminal 10b, and the 003 terminal 10c (since the configurations of these terminals are the same, when the configuration and the like are described below, only the 001 terminal 10a will be described) are as shown in FIG. , MR has a small shape that can be carried around, "terminal side display 12a" that displays various information, "terminal side input device 14a" that inputs various information, video (video), photos, etc. It has, for example, a "camera 13a" or the like, which is an imaging device for imaging the image.

The 001 terminal 10a, the 002 terminal 10b, the 003 terminal 10c, and the management device 40 shown in FIG. 1 have a computer, and the computer includes a CPU (Central Processing Unit), a RAM (Random Access Memory), and a ROM (Read Only) (not shown). It has Memory) and the like, and these are connected via a bus or the like.

FIG. 2 is a schematic block diagram showing a main configuration of the 001 terminal 10a of FIG.
As shown in FIG. 2, the 001 terminal 10a has a "terminal side control unit 11a", and the terminal side control unit 11a includes a "terminal side communication device 15a" for communicating with the management server 40 and the like shown in FIG. It controls the terminal-side display 12a, the terminal-side input device 14a, and the camera 13a described above.
The terminal-side control unit 11a also controls the "microphone 16a" that acquires MR voice information and the like, and the "speaker 17a" that outputs voice and the like.
Further, the "terminal-side various information storage units 18a" shown in FIG. 2 are also controlled.

FIG. 3 is a schematic block diagram showing a main configuration of the management server 40 of FIG.
As shown in FIG. 3, the management server 40 has a "server-side control unit 41", and the server-side control unit 41 stores various information such as a "server-side communication device 42" for communicating with the 001 terminal 10a and the like. It controls the "server-side display 43" to be displayed, the "server-side input device 44" for inputting various information, and the like.
Further, the server-side control unit 41 includes "first server-side various information storage units 50", "second server-side various information storage units 60", and "third server-side various information storage units 70" shown in FIG. , "Fourth server-side various information storage units 80" and "fifth server-side various information storage units 90" are controlled.

4 to 8 show "first server-side various information storage units 50", "second server-side various information storage units 60", "third server-side various information storage units 70", and "fourth", respectively. It is a schematic block diagram which shows the main contents of the "server-side various information storage units 80" and "fifth server-side various information storage units 90". These contents will be described later.

9 to 13 are schematic flowcharts showing a main operation example of the system 1.
In this embodiment, Mr. Z, who is an MR of W Pharmaceutical Company, practices the presentation in advance when giving a presentation about his company's product (α antihypertensive drug (an example in "Target items") at his hospital. The situation is imaged by the camera 13a of the 001 terminal 10a of FIG. 1, and at the same time, the sound is also recorded via the microphone 16a. Then, the state of these presentations is shown to Mr. Y, who is Mr. Z's boss, and the evaluation is evaluated. The following will be described with reference to the receiving example.
In this embodiment, Mr. Z's presentation is provided as a reference to his colleague, Mr. X.

First, in step 1 of FIG. 9 (hereinafter referred to as “ST”) 1, Mr. Z, who is an MR, transfers the data of the slide group for his / her practice from his / her own terminal 001 terminal 10a of FIG. 1 to the management server 40. Send to.
In this slide group, for example, MR (Mr. Z) has selected a slide group prepared by W Pharmaceutical Company for presenting its product.

For example, the following slide group.
1) Slide 1: Development history of antihypertensive drugs (Summary: 1952: sympathomimetics, 1960: diuretics, 1978: β-blockers, 1982 Ca antagonists, ACE inhibitors, 1998 ARBs).
2) Slide 2: Side effects after long-term use of antihypertensive drugs (Summary: Diuretics have an effect on glucose / lipid metabolism, ACE inhibitors have a cough, and Ca antagonists have a gingival overgrowth effect).
3) Slide 3: A drug that causes fewer side effects even after long-term use is eagerly desired.
4) Slide 4: "α antihypertensive drug" has fewer side effects than before.

Then, the process proceeds to ST2. In ST2, the management server 40 stores the data of the practice slide group received from the 001 terminal 10a in the “practice slide group storage unit 51” of FIG. 4 of the management server 40.
Then, the process proceeds to ST3. In ST3, MR (Mr. Z) transmits, for example, a “keyword”, which is an important word of the practice slide group, from his / her own terminal (001 terminal 10a) to the management server 40.

For example, the following keywords are sent.
1) For slide 1, "medicine".
2) For slide 2, "long-term use" and "side effects".
3) For slide 3, "long-term use" and "side effects".
4) For slide 4, "α antihypertensive drug".
5) For slide 5, "α antihypertensive drug" and "clinical trial".
6) For slide 6, "α antihypertensive drug" and "prescription example".

Then, the process proceeds to ST4. In ST4, the “keyword” of the practice slide group received from the 001 terminal 10a is stored in the “keyword storage unit 52” of FIG. 4 of the management server 40.

Further, when the MR (Mr. Z) further registers an additional slide 7 after the keyword registration for the slides 1 to 6 is completed, the slide 7 is referred to as the “practice slide group storage unit 61”. To be registered in.
At that time, when the "keyword" for slides 1 to 6 is already stored in the "keyword storage unit 52", the "keyword" of the new slide 7 is inferred and the "keyword" is estimated as follows. It is stored in the storage unit 52.

That is, it is determined whether or not the registered "keyword" of slides 1 to 6 exists on slide 7. Then, when it exists, information such as the appearance frequency of the "keyword" on slides 1 to 6 is acquired.
From this information, the keyword of slide 7 is inferred, and the keyword candidate of slide 7 is displayed on the terminal side display 12a of the 001 terminal 10a.
Then, the MR (Mr. Z) can identify the “keyword” on the slide 7 and store it in the “keyword storage unit 52” while referring to the keyword candidate.
Therefore, MR (Mr. Z) can greatly reduce the trouble of inputting the keyword for the additional slide 7, and can quickly and easily register the keyword of the slide.

Then, the process proceeds to ST5. In ST5, the “related checked practice slide search processing unit (program) 61” of FIG. 5 operates, and based on the keyword of the “keyword storage unit 52” of FIG. 4, the “checked practice slide group storage” of FIG. 4 is stored. Search the slide of "Part 53".

In this "checked practice slide group storage unit 53", other MRs have practiced presentations using slides in the past, and related information such as comments from their superiors, etc., which is the evaluation information, is associated with the "checked practice slide group storage unit 53". Checked practice slide group (an example of "other slide information") "is stored.
This "checked practice slide group" will be described later.

Then, the program 61 determines whether or not there are slide groups or slides of the "checked practice slide group" including the same "keyword" in a predetermined number or more.

Then, when it is determined in ST6 that there are slide groups or slides of the "checked practice slide group" including the same "keyword" in a predetermined number or more, the process proceeds to ST7.
In ST7, the identification number, slide number, etc. of the slide group of the "checked practice slide group" containing the same "keyword" in a predetermined number or more are stored in the "related checked practice slide group storage unit 62" of FIG. ..

As described above, in the present embodiment, the slide group having the content similar to the slide group practiced by MR (Mr. Z) this time, and the slide group already evaluated by the boss or the like is acquired as reference information. Can be done.

Next, Mr. Z of MR practices the presentation using the above-mentioned practice slide group, images the state with the camera 13a of the 001 terminal 10a, and acquires the sound with the microphone 16a.
Then, proceed to ST8. In ST8, the "video data with audio" acquired by the camera 13a and the microphone 16a of the 001 terminal 10a and the slide information displayed on the terminal side display 12a are transmitted to the management server 40.
Therefore, this video data with audio is an example of "imaging information" and "audio information".

Then, the process proceeds to ST9. In ST9, the "video data with audio" and the slide information received by the management server 40 are stored in the "video information storage unit 63 with audio" of FIG. 5 of the management server 40.
Then, the process proceeds to ST10. In ST10, the “line-of-sight angle estimation processing unit (program) 64” of FIG. 5 operates, cuts out the “eye image” in the video information of the “memory unit 63 for video information with sound, etc.”, and the “line-of-sight angle” of FIG. It is compared with the "line-of-sight angle reference information" of the reference information storage unit 65.
In this line-of-sight angle reference information, the correspondence information between the "eye image" and the "line-of-sight angle" is stored. That is, the structure is such that it is possible to determine what kind of line-of-sight angle the explainer had at that time from the image state of the eyes.

Then, the line-of-sight angle of the explainer is estimated from this "line-of-sight angle reference information" and stored in the "line-of-sight angle information storage unit 71" of FIG. 6 as the line-of-sight angle information together with the time information (time information in the entire explanation). ..
Then, the process proceeds to ST11. In ST11, the “line-of-sight angle abnormality state determination processing unit (program) 72” of FIG. 6 operates, and the “line-of-sight angle information” of the “line-of-sight angle information storage unit 71” of FIG. It is determined whether or not it is included in the "line-of-sight angle abnormality reference information" of the storage unit 73.

That is, the "line-of-sight angle abnormality reference information" stores the reference information when the line-of-sight angle of the explainer is unfavorable, and when it is included in this line-of-sight angle, it is estimated that the line-of-sight of the explainer is unfavorable. Will be.

Next, when it is determined in ST12 that the "line-of-sight angle information" is included in the "line-of-sight angle abnormality reference information", the process proceeds to ST13.
In ST13, the "line-of-sight angle information" is stored as "abnormal line-of-sight angle information" in the "abnormal line-of-sight angle information storage unit 74" of FIG. 6 together with "time information".

Therefore, when MR (Mr. Z), who is the explainer, does not like the line of sight in the presentation and speaks poorly, he / she can easily provide reference information on such facts.

Then, the process proceeds to ST14. In ST14, the "pointer mark processing unit (program) 75" of FIG. 6 operates, and the slide information of the "storage unit 63 for video information with audio" of FIG. 5 is used as a "pointer (an example of a" mark forming tool ")". Determine if there is an image showing the slide.

If there is an image showing the slide with the pointer in ST15, the process proceeds to ST16.
In ST16, it is referred to as "ponter information", and the coordinate axis information of the slide portion pointed by the pointer is associated with the time information in the entire explanation time, and the time information and the coordinate axis information are stored in the "pointer information storage unit 81" of FIG. Let me.
That is, this "pointer information" is an example of the indicated partial information.

In this way, in the present embodiment, the slide portion (slide information, coordinate axis information, time information, etc.) pointed out by the MR (Mr. Z) who is the explainer is memorized, and the reference material is used for the evaluation described later. It is a configuration that can be provided.

Then, the process proceeds to ST17. In ST17, the “keyword appearance state determination processing unit (program) 82” of FIG. 7 operates, and the “audio information” of the “video information storage unit 63 with audio” of FIG. 5 is replaced with the “keyword storage unit 52” of FIG. It is determined whether or not the "keyword" of the above, for example, the keyword "medicine" of slide 1 is included.

Next, when it is determined in ST18 that the "voice information" includes the "keyword", the process proceeds to ST19. In ST19, the appearance of the keyword is stored in the “keyword appearance information storage unit 83” together with the time information as “keyword appearance information”.

Then, the process proceeds to ST20. In ST20, the "keyword appearance frequency information generation processing unit (program) 84" of FIG. 7 operates, and the explanation of the slide is described from the time information in the entire explanation time of the "keyword appearance information" of the "keyword appearance information storage unit 83". It is determined whether or not the frequency of appearance of keywords in the "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage" falls within a predetermined range.

That is, if the keyword is within the predetermined range and the explanation changes to "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage", it is judged that the theme of the explanation does not deviate significantly, and conversely, the frequency of appearance of the keyword is high. If it does not fall within the specified range in any of the "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage", and if it drops significantly, for example, it is judged that the theme of the explanation may have deviated significantly at that time. ..

Further, the distinction between "early stage", "middle stage", "late stage" and the like in the explanation of the slide can be judged not only from the time information in the entire explanation time but also from the wording of the audio information and the slide data.
For example, if there is a wording such as "This indicates ..." in the voice information, it is judged as "early stage".
Further, if the slide data is, for example, the content of the "PowerPoint note portion", it is determined to be the content of the slide, and this is defined as the "middle stage".
Furthermore, when there is a word such as "that is ..." in the voice information, it is judged as "the final stage".

Further, in the present embodiment, if the keyword has a frequency of falling within a predetermined range and the explanation changes to "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage", it is judged that the theme of the explanation does not deviate significantly, and vice versa. If the frequency of appearance of keywords is either "early stage", "middle stage", or "late stage" and does not fall within the specified range, for example, if it drops significantly, then the theme of the explanation may deviate significantly. However, the present invention is not limited to this, and may be determined as follows.

That is, referring to the "related checked practice slide group storage unit 62", the "early stage", "middle stage", and "middle stage" in the highly evaluated "checked practice slide group storage unit 53" of the "checked practice slide group storage unit 53". Get the appearance rate of the keyword "late stage".
Then, the appearance rate of the keywords in each "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage" is compared with the appearance rate of the keywords on the slide of MR (Mr. Z), and it is judged whether or not the theme of the explanation deviates significantly. It may be configured to be used.

In ST21, when it is determined that the frequency of appearance of the keywords is "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage" and is not within the predetermined range, the process proceeds to ST22.
In ST22, MR (Mr. Z) judges that "the flow of explanation is inappropriate", and sets the slide (for example, slide 1) number or the like as "inappropriate explanation slide", and sets the slide (for example, slide 1) number as "inappropriate explanation slide" in FIG. It is stored in the storage unit 85 ”.

That is, when it is judged that the frequency of appearance of keywords is "early stage", "middle stage", and "late stage" and does not fall within the predetermined range, the theme of explanation is not consistent and "the flow of explanation is inconsistent". It will be judged as "appropriate".
Therefore, "inappropriate flow of explanation" is an example of "validity information of expansion of explanation contents".

As described above, in the present embodiment, when there is a possibility that the theme of the explanation of the explainer may be off the middle, the slide is memorized as "inappropriate flow of explanation" and evaluated by the boss or the like. It is structured to provide reference materials.

Then, the process proceeds to ST23. In ST23, the "unclear explanation information judgment processing unit (program) 91" of FIG. 8 operates, and a specific phrase indicating the existence of a subject or the like in the "audio information" of the "audio information storage unit 63 with audio" of FIG. For example, it is determined whether or not the appearance rate of words such as "ga" and "ha" within a predetermined time is equal to or less than a predetermined value.
That is, for example, when the appearance rate of words such as "ga" and "ha" within a predetermined time is less than or equal to a predetermined value, it is judged that the explanation is significantly lacking in the subject, and the explanation is likely to be unclear. It will be judged.

Next, in ST24, if the appearance rate of the words "ga", "ha", etc. within the predetermined time is equal to or less than the predetermined value, the process proceeds to ST25.
In ST25, it is determined that the explanation of the slide, etc. (for example, slide 1) is unclear due to lack of subject, etc., and the slide number, etc. is used as "unclear explanation information", and the "unclear explanation information" in FIG. It is stored in the storage unit 92.
This "unclear explanation information" is an example of "unclear judgment information".

Therefore, in the present embodiment, when the explanation of the explainer is likely to be unclear due to lack of the subject or the like, the slide number or the like is memorized and the reference material for the evaluation of the boss or the like is provided. ing.
In the present embodiment, the subject is used as an example as a specific phrase, but the present invention is not limited to this, and the object, the so-called "5W1H", and the like can be similarly determined.

Then, the process proceeds to ST26. In ST26, the “practice slide-related information generation processing unit (program) 93” in FIG. 8 operates, the “practice slide group storage unit 51” in FIG. 4, and the “related checked practice slide group storage unit” in FIG. 61 ”,“ Video information storage unit 63 with audio ”in FIG. 5,“ Abnormal line-of-sight angle information storage unit 74 ”in FIG. 6,“ Pointer information storage unit 81 ”in FIG. 7, and“ Inappropriate explanation slide storage ”in FIG. Refer to “Part 85” and “Unclear explanatory information storage unit 92” in FIG.

Then, the process proceeds to ST27. In ST27, "video information with audio" and "slide information" of "memory unit 63 for video information with audio" and "identification number and slide number of slide group" of "related checked practice slide group storage unit 61" , "Abnormal line-of-sight angle information" with "time information" of "abnormal line-of-sight angle information storage unit 74", "coordinate axis information with time information" of "pointer information storage unit 81", "inappropriate explanation slide storage unit 85" "Slide (for example, slide 1) number, etc." and "the slide number" of the "unclear explanation information storage unit 92" are associated and stored in the "practice slide-related information storage unit 94" as "practice slide-related information".

Therefore, the following information is associated with the "video information with audio" and "slide information (slide information explained by MR (Mr. Z))" of the presentation given by MR (Mr. Z) as a practice, and "practice slides". Related information ".
1) "Related checked practice slides" related to "Practice slides".
2) "Abnormal line-of-sight angle information" in which the line of sight of MR (Mr. Z) is not preferable during the explanation.
3) "Pointer information" that is the part pointed by the pointer to the slide of MR (Mr. Z).
4) "Inappropriate explanation slide" information such as slide numbers for which "the flow of explanation is inappropriate" by MR (Mr. Z).
5) "Unclear explanatory information" such as slide numbers that are likely to be unclear due to lack of the subject of MR (Mr. Z).

Then, the process proceeds to ST28. In ST28, the "destination terminal 1 (002 terminal 0b (boss (Mr. Y)) terminal" corresponding to the source terminal (001 terminal 10a (MR (Mr. Z))) of the "destination terminal information storage unit 54" in FIG. 4 ) ”And“ the terminal of the destination terminal 2 (003 terminal 10c (colleague MR (Mr. X)) ”, the“ practice slide-related information ”of the“ practice slide-related information storage unit 94 ”in FIG. 8 is transmitted.

Then, the process proceeds to ST29. In ST29, in the center of the terminal side displays 12b and 13b of the terminal 002 (the terminal of the boss (Mr. Y)) and the terminal 003 (the terminal of the colleague MR (Mr. X)), the "audio-attached video information storage unit""withaudio""Videoinformation" and "slide information" are displayed, and audio is output from the speakers 17b and 17c.
Then, "slide group identification number, slide number, etc." of "related checked practice slide group storage unit 62", "abnormal line-of-sight angle information with time information", and "pointer information" of "abnormal line-of-sight angle information storage unit 74". "Coordinate axis information with time information" of "storage unit 81", "slide (for example, slide 1) number etc." of "inappropriate explanation slide storage unit 85" and "slide number" of "unclear explanation information storage unit 92" When data exists, "icons" indicating the respective information are displayed outside the video display portion of the "video information with audio" and "slide information".

Then, when each icon is clicked, the corresponding data is displayed in a separate window on the terminals 12b and 12c.
Therefore, Mr. Y, the boss who evaluates the presentation of MR (Mr. Z), operates each "icon" displayed outside the display part of the video of "video information with audio" and "slide information", respectively. For example, a comment or the like, which is evaluation information of the presentation of MR (Mr. Z), is input while referring to the information of.

Next, in ST30, it is determined whether or not a comment has been input, and if it is determined that a comment has been input, the process proceeds to ST31.
In ST31, the “checked practice slide group information generation processing unit (program) 95” of FIG. 8 operates, and the “practice slide group” of the “practice slide group storage unit 51” is displayed together with the input comment. It is stored in the "checked practice slide group storage unit 53" of FIG. 4 as "checked practice slide group information".

Therefore, MR (Mr. Z) can know the comment of the presentation by accessing the management server 40 via his / her own 001 terminal 10a without adjusting the schedule with his / her boss Y. ..
Similarly, comments from a colleague, Mr. X, can also be obtained.

Furthermore, the boss (Mr. Y) who inputs a comment can refer to the above-mentioned various reference information while watching the video and audio of the presentation of MR (Mr. Z) while operating the icons, so that the comment is more objective. Etc. can be given.

The slide group of MR (Mr. Z) with a comment given by this boss (Mr. Y) is stored as "checked practice slide group information", so this comment will also be used as a reference for future evaluation. This will improve the accuracy of comments.

The present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and may be as follows.
Before MR (Mr. Z) finishes the explanation of the slide and transmits "video data with audio" or the like to the server, for example, the following question is output from the 001 terminal 10a.
For example, "I am using the therapeutic drug α, what is the difference?" And "I found the incidence of the main side effects in the package insert, but which one is earlier in the onset?"
Then, video data with audio such as the answer contents and explanatory attitude of MR (Mr. Z) to these questions is transmitted to the management server 40, and these are analyzed by the management server 40, and the analysis result information is 001 terminal 10b or the like. Will be sent to.
For these question information, for example, the management server 40 extracts the terms and the like of the practice slide group of the "practice slide group storage unit 51" and selects the question information associated with these terms and the like in advance. , 001 The configuration is such that transmission is performed to the terminal 10a or the like.
Further, the function such as question selection may be exhibited not by the management server 40 but by the 001 terminal 10a.
Further, in the present embodiment, the main processing is executed on the management server 40 side, but the present invention is not limited to this, and for example, even if the processing of the management server 40 is executed on the 001 terminal 10a or the like. I do not care.

1 ... Presentation education complementary system, 2 ... Internet network, 3a, 3b, 3c ... Base station, 10a ... 001 terminal, 10b ... 002 terminal, 10c ... 003 terminal, 11a ... .. Terminal side control unit, 12a ... Terminal side display, 13a ... Camera, 14a ... Terminal side input device, 15a ... Terminal side communication device, 16a ... Microphone, 17a ... Speaker, 18a ... Various information storage units on the terminal side, 40 ... Management server, 41 ... Server side control unit, 42 ... Server side communication device, 43 ... Server side display, 44 ... Server side input device, 50 ... 1st server side various information storage unit, 51 ... practice slide group storage unit, 52 ... keyword storage unit, 53 ... checked practice slide group storage unit , 54 ... Destination terminal information storage unit, 60 ... Various information storage units on the second server side, 61 ... Related checked Practice slide search processing unit (program), 62 ... Related checked Practice slide group storage unit, 63 ... Video information storage unit with audio, 64 ... Line-of-sight angle estimation processing unit (program), 65 ... Line-of-sight angle reference information storage unit, 70 ... Third Various information storage units on the server side, 71 ... Line-of-sight angle information storage unit, 72 ... Line-of-sight angle abnormality state determination processing unit (program), 73 ... Line-of-sight angle abnormality reference information storage unit, 74 ... Abnormal line of sight Angle information storage unit, 75 ... pointer mark processing unit (program), 80 ... various information storage units on the fourth server side, 81 ... pointer information storage unit, 82 ... keyword appearance state determination processing unit (Program), 83 ... Keyword appearance information storage unit, 84 ... Keyword appearance frequency information generation processing unit (program), 85 ... Inappropriate explanation slide storage unit, 90 ... Various types on the fifth server side Information storage unit, 91 ... Unclear explanation information judgment processing unit (program), 92 ... Unclear explanation information storage unit, 93 ... Practice slide-related information generation processing unit (program), 94 ...・ Practice slide related information storage unit, 95 ・ ・ ・ Checked practice slide group information generation processing unit (program)

Claims (7)

A storage unit that stores slide information that displays the target items to be explained as a presentation,
A storage unit that stores voice information uttered regarding the content of the explanation of the evaluated person, and a storage unit.
It has a storage unit that stores other slide information that is related to the target item and is already stored in association with the evaluation information, and the slide information, the audio information, and the other other that are stored in the storage unit. The slide information is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device, which is the evaluator's terminal device, and the evaluation information input via the evaluator terminal device is stored.
Predetermined appearance information of important words included in the voice information is stored, the validity of the development of the explanation content is determined based on the degree of appearance frequency of the important word, and the explanation content development validity information is used as described above. A presentation evaluation device characterized in that it is configured to be transmitted to an evaluator terminal device. The presentation evaluation device according to claim 1, wherein the slide information is a practice slide. The feature is that the evaluator stores the instruction portion information which is a portion pointed to by the pointer forming tool with respect to the slide information, and transmits the instruction portion information to the evaluator terminal device. The presentation evaluation device according to claim 1 or 2. The ambiguity of the sentence is determined based on the appearance rate information of the specific phrase indicating the existence of the subject included in the voice information within a predetermined time, and the determination information of the ambiguity is transmitted to the evaluator terminal device. The presentation evaluation device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the presentation evaluation device has a configuration. The evaluated person terminal device, which is a terminal operated by the evaluated person,
With the evaluator terminal device,
The presentation evaluation system according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the evaluator terminal device is communicably connected to the evaluator terminal device. Slide information that displays the subject matter to be explained as a presentation,
The voice information uttered regarding the explanation content of the evaluated person and
In a presentation evaluation device that stores other slide information that is already stored in association with the evaluation information in relation to the target item.
A function of transmitting the slide information, the voice information, and the other slide information to the evaluator terminal device, which is the evaluator's terminal device, and storing the evaluation information input via the evaluator terminal device.
Predetermined appearance information of important words included in the voice information is stored, the validity of the development of the explanation content is determined based on the degree of appearance frequency of the important word, and the explanation content development validity information is used as described above. Evaluator A presentation evaluation program for executing the function of sending to the terminal device. Slide information that displays the target items to be explained as a presentation is stored in the storage unit, and
The voice information uttered regarding the explanation content of the evaluated person is stored in the storage unit, and the voice information is stored in the storage unit.
Other slide information related to the target item and already stored in association with the evaluation information is stored in the storage unit.
The slide information, the voice information, and the other slide information are transmitted to the evaluator terminal device, which is the evaluator's terminal device, and the evaluation information input via the evaluator terminal device is stored.
Predetermined appearance information of important words included in the voice information is stored, the validity of the development of the explanation content is determined based on the degree of appearance frequency of the important word, and the explanation content development validity information is used as described above. A control method for a presentation evaluation device, which is configured to transmit information to an evaluator terminal device.

Images