IE85210B1

IE85210B1 - Methods and systems for diagnosing projection device failure

Info

Publication number: IE85210B1
Application number: IE2007/0264A
Authority: IE
Inventors: Sakai Masayoshi; Jayaram Subramanian; Mishra Satchidananda
Original assignee: Dell Products Lp
Filing date: 2005-08-04
Publication date: 2009-04-29

Abstract

ABSTRACT This invention relates generally to projection devices, and more particularly to methods and systems for diagnosing projection device failure.

Description

Methods and Systems for Diagnosing Projection Device Failure Dell Products LP METHODS AND SYSTEMS FOR DIAGNOSING PROJECTION DEVICE FAILURE BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION . Field oi the invention This invention relates generally to projection devices, and more particularly to methods and systems for diagnosing projection device failure.

. Description of the Related Art Projection devices include projectors that use projection lamps to display images on a wall or other suitable viewing surface. Such projectors may be conﬁgured to display‘ images provided by analog and digital connections that are compatible with PC, television and video standards. Projectors may be provided with a lamp sensor that monitors lamp current and triggers a lamp failure light if the projector lamp fails to ignite when powered on (e.g., after four ignition attempts). When other power indicators of the projector are illuminated and the projector fan is running, the illuminated lamp failure light indicates to the user that the projector lamp has failed and needs to be replaced. A replacement lamp may then be ordered by the user or may be shipped to the user by the manufacturer, e. g., when still covered under warranty. Projectors may also be provided with an end of life indicator that notiﬁes a user when the lamp has reached its end of life.

A projector lamp failure light does not distinguish between a failed projector lamp and a failed ignitor circuit. Thus, a failure in the ignitor circuit will be viewed by a user as a lamp failure, and may result in a failed attempt to restore projector operation by purchasing and installing a new replacement lamp. For projector products still covered under warranty, a new projector lamp may be shipped to the user in a wasted attempt to restore operation of a projector with a failed i gnitor circuit. .521‘ 0 SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION According to one aspect of the present invention, a projection device comprises: a projection lamp; a lamp failure indicator system; and an ignitor failure indicator system, wherein the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprise a multi-state indicator.

According to a further aspect of the present invention, a system for detecting a failure in a projection device comprises: a lamp failure indicator system for a lamp of the projection device. and an ignitor failure indicator system for an ignitor of the lamp of the projection device, wherein the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprise a multi-state indicator.

According to a still further aspect of the present invention, a method for indicating a failure of a projection device comprises: determining, whether a lamp of the projection device has successfully ignited; determining, whether there is a failure of an ignitor circuit, if the lamp of the projection device did not successfully ignite; and, indicating a failure of the lamp or ignitor circuit by a respective lamp failure indicator system and ignitor failure indicator system, the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprising a multi- stage indicator.

Disclosed herein are methods and systems for diagnosing projection device failure and for preventing incorrect projection lamp failure notiﬁcation by sensing improper operation of projection lamp ignitor circuitry and providing an indication of the same. Such incorrect lamp failure notiﬁcation may occur when a lamp failure light is activated due to a failure in the ignitor circuitry (ballast circuit), rather than due to a defective or burned out projection lamp. in one embodiment, the disclosed methods and systems may be implemented using a separate indicator circuit that monitors the input to the projector lamp by sensing the ignition voltage to the projector lamp. if the ignition voltage is below a specified value, an ignitor failure indicator is activated by the indicator circuit. e.g., a light emitting diode ("LED") indicator light that turns on and stays on.

In a case where only the projector lamp fails (i.e., the ignitor circuitry is functioning properly), the lamp failure indicator is activated. while the ignitor failure indicator remains off. Activation of only the lamp failure indicator allows for easy identiﬁcation that the projector lamp has encountered a failure and needs to be replaced, However, in a case where the ignitor circuitry supplies insufﬁcient voltage (or no voltage) for projector lamp ignition, both the ignitor failure indicator and lamp failure indicators are activated. Activation of both lamp failure and ignitor failure indicators is an indication that a projector failure is due to an electronics failure in the ignitor circuitry, and that the projector needs to be repaired. lNth the advantage of this indication of ignitor circuitry failure, wasted time and efforts associated with unsuccessful attempts to replace the projector lamp may be avoided.

The step of sensing operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry may include measuring lamp ignitor voltage provided by the lamp ignitor circuitry to a projector lamp of the projection device; and the method may include activating an ignitor failure indicator based on a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage. The method may further include comparing a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage to a speciﬁed voltage magnitude; and activating the ignitor failure indicator if the measured voltage magnitude is less than the speciﬁed voltage magnitude. The method may further include the steps of: attempting to ignite the projector lamp; sensing whether the projector lamp is ignited; and activating a lamp failure indicator if the projector lamp fails to ignite. in one embodiment of this method, the ignitor failure indicator may only be activated if the lamp failure indicator is activated. In another embodiment, the step of sensing operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry may be performed after the step of activating the lamp failure indicator. The method may be implemented with a projection device that is configured to display information based on signals received from an information handling system.

In one embodiment of a system for sensing lamp ignitor circuitry failure in a projection device, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to sense operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry by measuring lamp ignitor voltage provided by the lamp ignitor circuitry to a projector lamp of the projection device; and to activate the ignitor failure indicator based on a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage. In this regard, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to compare a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage to a speciﬁed voltage magnitude; and to activate the ignitor failure indicator if the measured voltage magnitude is less than the speciﬁed voltage magnitude. In one embodiment. the system may include: lamp ignition detection circuitry conﬁgured to sense whether the projector lamp is ignited; and a lamp failure indicator coupled to the lamp ignition detection circuitry. In one embodiment, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to only activate the ignitor failure indicator if the lamp failure indicator is activated. In another embodiment, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to sense operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry after the lamp failure indicator is activated. The system may be implemented with a projection device conﬁgured to display information based on signals received from an information handling system.

In one embodiment of a projection device, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to sense operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry by measuring lamp ignitor voltage provided by the lamp ignitor circuitry to the projector lamp of the projection device; and to activate the ignitor failure indicator based on a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage. In this regard, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to compare a magnitude of the measured lamp ignitor voltage to a speciﬁed voltage magnitude; and to activate the ignitor failure indicator if the measured voltage magnitude is less than the speciﬁed voltage magnitude. In one embodiment. the projection device may further include: lamp ignition detection circuitry configured to sense whether the projector lamp is ignited; and a lamp failure indicator coupled to the lamp ignition detection circuitry. In one embodiment, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to only activate the ignitor failure indicator if the lamp failure indicator is activated. in another embodiment, the ignitor detection circuitry may be conﬁgured to sense operation of the lamp ignitor circuitry after the lamp failure indicator is activated. The projection device may be conﬁgured to display information based on signals received from an information handling system.

FIG. I is a ﬂow diagram illustrating methodology according to one embodiment of the disclosed methods and systems.

FIG. 2 is a ﬂow diagram illustrating methodology according to another embodiment of the disclosed methods and systems.

FIG. 3 is a simpliﬁed block diagram of a projection device according to one embodiment of the disclosed methods and system DESCRIPTIQN OF ILLUSTRATIVE EMBODIMENTS Figure I is a ﬂow diagram illustrating methodology that may be implemented to diagnose projector failure in one exemplary embodiment of the disclosed methods and systems. The projector is turned on in step 110, and the ignition circuitry attempts to light the projector lamp (e.g., mercury vapor lamp) in step 112. Lamp ignition detection circuitry determines whether the projector lamp was successfully ignited in step 114, e.g., by sensing lamp current. If the projector lamp ignites , then the projector is powered on successfully as indicated in step 116. However, if it is detennined in step 114 that the projector lamp was not successfully ignited. then one or more additional attempts (e.g., for a total of four attempts) may be optionally made to ignite the projector lamp as indicated by optional return ﬂow path 119 from step 118 to step 112. If the projector lamp ignites during any one of these additional attempts, then the projector is powered on as indicated in step 116.

After a specified number of one or more unsuccessful attempts to ignite the projector lamp have been made, then a lamp failure indicator (e.g. a ﬁrst state of a tri-state LED light) may be activated in step 120.

Still referring to Figure 1, ignitor circuitry (ballast circuit) voltage may be monitored in step 122, e.g.j by a voltage detector circuit in one exemplary embodiment. If the ignitor voltage supplied by the ignitor circuitry is less than a speciﬁed voltage (e.g., the voltage required to successfully ignite the projector lamp), then an ignitor failure indicator (e.g., a second state of a tri- state LED light) may be activated in step 124, and the projector power may be optionally turned off (e.g., automatically or manually by the projector operator) in step 126. At this point, both the lamp failure and ignitor failure indicators will be activated, indicating a failure has occurred in the ignition circuitry and that the projector needs to be repaired.

However, if the ignitor voltage is found to be equal to or greater than the speciﬁed voltage in step 122, then the ignitor failure indicator is not activated and the projector power optionally turned off (e.g., automatically by automatic shut-down circuitry or manually by the projector operator) in step 126. At this point, only the lamp failure indicator is activated, indicating that the projector lamp has failed or is defective and needs to be replaced.

Figure 2 illustrates an optional embodiment in which the ignitor circuitry is optionally shutoff (e.g.. in addition to the perfonnance of steps 122 to 124 of Figure 1 as indicated in outline by dashed line 150) to prevent further ignition tries. in this embodiment, ignitor circuitry voltage may be monitored in step 122 in a manner as previously described. If the ignitor voltage supplied by the ignitor circuitry is less than the speciﬁed voltage and the ignitor failure indicator is activated in step 124, then the ignitor circuitry is shut off to prevent further ignition tries as indicated by step 125 of Figure 2.

Figure 1 illustrates one exemplary embodiment in which the methodology of steps 122 to 126 follows the methodology of steps 110 to 120. In this regard, it will be understood that in another embodiment the methodology of steps 122 to 126 may be implemented separately. simultaneously and/or independently to the methodology of steps 110 to 120. According to the present invention, lamp failure and ignitor failure indicators comprise a single multi-state indicator such as multi-state LED capable of displaying a different- respective color to reﬂect each of lamp failure or ignitor circuit failure.

Furthermore, although one embodiment for sensing operation of ignitor circuitry is described herein in which a separate indicator circuit is employed to monitor the input to a projector lamp by sensing the ignition voltage to the projector lamp, it will be understood that any other methodology and/or conﬁguration of one or more circuits that is suitable for sensing proper operation of ignitor circuitry may be employed.

Figure 3 is a simpliﬁed block diagram of projection device 300 conﬁgured according to one exemplary embodiment of the disclosed methods and systems, e.g. to implement the methodology of Figure 1 andlor 2. As shown in Figure 3, projection device 300 is coupled to receive image signals 315 from an image source 301. for example, an infonnation handling system such as described further herein. In the illustrated exemplary embodiment, projection device 300 includes lamp ignitor circuitry 303 that is coupled via lamp power connection 309 to projector tamp 302 which may be, for example, a mercury vapor lamp.

In the exemplary embodiment of Figure 3, ignitor detection circuitry 304 is 10 conﬁgured to sense operation of lamp ignitor circuitry 303, e.g., by measuring lamp ignitor voltage provided by lamp ignitor circuitry 303 to projector lamp 302 via lamp power connection 309. An ignitor failure indicator 307 (e.g., LED light or other suitable indicator) is shown coupled to display an indication of lamp ignitor circuitry failure upon receipt of ignitor failure signal 313 provided by ignitor detection circuitry 304 upon detection of failure of lamp ignitor circuitry 303. Optional ignitor shutdown circuitry 310 is also shown present for receiving ignitor failure signal 308 and for in turn providing an ignitor shutdown signal 312 to shut down lamp ignitor circuitry 303. In this regard, it will be understood that an ignitor failure signal may be a separate signal 308 as shown. or may alternatively be the same signal as signal 313.

Still referring to Figure 3, lamp ignition detection circuitry 305 may be provided that is conﬁgured to sense whether projector lamp 302 is ignited e.g., by measuring current provided by lamp ignitor circuitry 303 to projector lamp 302 via lamp power connection 309. A lamp failure indicator 306 (e.g., LED light or other suitable indicator) is shown coupled to display an indication of projector lamp failure upon receipt of lamp failure signal 311 from lamp ignition detection circuitry 305.

In the practice of the disclosed methods and systems. features of ignitor defection circuitry 304, lamp ignition detection circuitry 305 and/or optional ignitor shutdown circuitry 310 may be implemented using any suitable conﬁguration of one or more circuits. For example, in one embodiment, one or more features of circuitry 304, 305 and 3l0 may be implemented using a controller (e.g., microprocessor and associated ﬁrmware) that is integral to projector 300 or using any other suitable conﬁguration of microprocessor, ﬁrmware and/or software that interfaces with projection device circuitry/components. Discrete circuit devices may also be employed, e.g., ignitor detection circuitry 304 may be implemented using a comparator circuit or other suitable discrete circuit configuration.

The disclosed methods and systems may be implemented with any type of projection device that utilizes one or more projector lamps, e.g., table top projectors, projection televisions, etc. in one exemplary embodiment, the disclosed methods and systems may be implemented with projection devices that are conﬁgured to display images based on signals received from an information handling system. For purposes of this disclosure, an information handling system may include any instrumentality or aggregate of instrumentalities operable to compute, classify, process, transmit, receive, retrieve, originate, switch, store, display, manifest, detect, record, reproduce, handle, or utilize any form of information, intelligence, or data for business, scientiﬁc, control, or other purposes. For example, an information handling system may be a personal computer, a network storage device, or any other suitable device and may vary in size, shape, performance, functionality, and price. The information handling system may include random access memory (RAM), one or more processing resources such as a central processing unit (CPU) or hardware or software control logic, ROM, and/or other types of nonvolatile memory. Additional components of the information handling system may include one or more disk drives, one or more network ports for communicating with external devices as well as various input and output (I/O) devices, such as a keyboard, a mouse, and a video display. The information handling system may also include one or more buses operable to transmit communications between the various hardware components.

While the invention may be adaptable to various modiﬁcations and alternative forms, speciﬁc embodiments have been shown by way of example and described herein.

However, it should be understood that the invention is not intended to be limited to the particular forms disclosed. Rather, the invention is to cover all modiﬁcations, equivalents, and alternatives falling within the scope of the invention as deﬁned by the appended claims. Moreover. the different aspects of the disclosed methods and systems may be utilized in various combinations and/or independently. Thus the invention is not limited to only those combinations shown herein, but rather may include other combinations.

Claims

1. A projection device. comprising: a projection lamp; a lamp failure indicator system; and an ignitor failure indicator system, wherein the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprise a multi-state indicator.

2. The projection device according to claim 1, wherein the lamp failure indicator system is adapted to be activated in case of a failure of the lamp and no failure of the ignitor.

3. The projection device according to claim 2, wherein the ignitor failure indicator system and the lamp failure indicator system are adapted to be both activated in case of a failure of the ignitor of the projection device.

4. The projection device according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the ignitor failure indicator system is conﬁgured to be activated based on a magnitude of a -measured lamp ignitor voltage.

5. The projection device according to claim 4. wherein the lamp failure indicator system is configured to be activated based on the lamp current.

6. A system for detecting a failure in a projection device comprising: a lamp failure indicator system for a lamp of the projection device, and an ignitor failure indicator system for an ignitor of the lamp of the projection device, wherein the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprise a multi-state indicator.

7. The system of claim 6,’ wherein the ramp failure indicator system is adapted to be activated in case of a failure of the lamp and no failure of the ignitor.

8. The system of claim 6 or claim 7. wherein the ignitor failure indicator system and the lamp failure indicator system are adapted to be both activated in case of a failure of the ignitor of the projection device.

9. The system of any one of claims 6 to 8. wherein the ignitor failure indicator system is conﬁgured to be activated based on a magnitude of a measured lamp ignitor voltage.

10. The system of any one of claims 6 to 9, wherein the lamp failure indicator system is conﬁgured to be activated based on the lamp current.

11. A method for indicating a failure of a projection device comprising the steps of: detennining, whether a lamp of the projection device has successfully ignited; detennining,_ whether there is a failure of an ignitor circuit, if the lamp of the projection device did not successfully ignite; and, indicating a failure of the lamp or ignitor circuit by a respective lamp failure indicator system and ignitor failure indicator system, the lamp failure indicator system and the ignitor failure indicator system comprising a multi- stage indicator.

12. The method of claim 11, wherein the step of determining, whether a lamp of the projection device is successfully ignited, comprises measuring a lamp current.

13. The method of claim ll or claim 12, wherein the step of determining, whether there is a failure of an ignitor circuit, comprises measuring an ignitor vohage.

14. The method of any one of claims 11 to 13, wherein only a lamp failure indicator is activated, if it is detennined that there is a failure of the lamp and no failure of the ignitor circuit.

15. The method of any one of claims 11 to 14, wherein a lamp failure indicator and an ignitor failure indicator are activated. if it is detennined that there is a failure of the ignitor circuit.