EP3612654B1

EP3612654B1 - Production method for scandium metal and al-sc alloys via electrolysis of fluorinated scandium salts obtained by the calcination of scandium compound in the form of (nh4)2nascf6

Info

Publication number: EP3612654B1
Application number: EP18849073.4A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Ali Safder IPLIKÇIOGLU; Serif KAYA
Original assignee: Minertek Mineral Teknolojileri Madencilik Sanayi Ve Ticaret AS
Current assignee: Minertek Mineral Teknolojileri Madencilik Sanayi Ve Ticaret AS
Priority date: 2017-03-20
Filing date: 2018-03-06
Publication date: 2021-09-08
Anticipated expiration: 2038-03-06
Also published as: WO2019040016A3; WO2019040016A2; EP3612654A2; EP3612654A4

Description

Technical Field

The invention relates to scandium metal in its pure or alloy form obtained by removing the NH₄ form present in the scandium compound which is initially in its (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, by calcination first and then with molten salt electrolysis of fluorinated scandium compounds in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms that resulted after the calcination process.

State of the Art

Scandium is one of the transition metals, which belongs to the 3B group of the periodic table, and known as one of the rare earth elements, which is rarely enriched in nature. Scarcity of the ores which has sufficient grade of scandium for feasible processing, constitutes a great obstacle against production and the usage of this metal in various industries. Until today, scandium has been found in trace amounts among uranium, tin, iron, tungsten, tantalum, zirconium, titanium and other rare earth element ores that are economically processed, within the content of more than 100 minerals; it has been obtained as a byproduct during the production of these metals. Other than this, the presence of substantial amounts of scandium element in lateritic nickel-cobalt ores have brought the possibility of producing scandium as a byproduct during the processing of these resources and consequently various studies about this subject have recently been conducted. An example of these studies is provided by patent application no. TR201308682 titled 'High pressure acid leaching of refractory lateritic ores containing nickel, cobalt and scandium and recovery of scandium from the pregnant leach solution loaded with metals and purification precipitates' claimed by 'Meta Nikel Kobalt Madencilik Sanayi ve Ticaret Anonim
irketi'. Another one is the patent application titled 'Recovering scandium and its derivatives from leach solutions loaded with metals, which are obtained by leaching lateritic ores containing nickel, cobalt and scandium, and secondary sources containing scandium', claimed by 'Meta Nikel Kobalt Madencilik Sanayi ve Ticaret Anonim
irketi' as well. The aforementioned applications are related to scandium recovery which is present in lateritic nickel-cobalt ores.
Another of them is given by the US application no. US3111467 . Mentioned application requires pure NaF, ScF3 and Sc2O3 salts in order to conduct the electrolysis process. First, NaF and ScF3 salts are mixed and melted at 800 °C, and then Sc2O3 salt is dissolved inside this melt.
Patent application no. CN1410599 relates to the method for producing the alloy of aluminium and scandium by using oxides of aluminium and scandium as the raw materials. Fused salt electrolysis process is adopted to electrolyze and separate out aluminium and scandium so as to form the alloy. The weight ratio of the electrolyte of fused cryolite is as following: alumina 1%-10%, scandium oxide 0.1%-10%, cryolite as the rest and the unavoidable impurities. The ratio between sodium fluoride and aluminium fluoride is 2-3. The relevant parameters are as following: temperature of electrolysis 900-990 deg.C, operating voltage of the electrobath 3.0V-6.5V and the electrode distance 2.0cm-7.0 cm.
In a publication titled "Production of scandium and Al-Sc alloy by metallothermic reduction" (M. HARATA ET AL, 2013), a fundamental study was conducted by on a new process for producing scandium (Sc) metal or aluminium-scandium (Al-Sc) alloy by the calciothermic reduction of scandium oxide (Sc2O3). In this study, aluminium (Al) and calcium chloride (CaCl2) were used as the collector metal and flux for the reduction respectively. A mixture of Sc2O3, Al and CaCl2 in a tantalum crucible was placed inside a stainless steel reaction container, and the feed mixture was reacted with calcium (Ca) vapour at 1273 K for 6 h. After the reduction experiment, the reaction product (CaO), CaCl2 flux and excess Ca reductant were removed from the obtained alloy sample by leaching with an aqueous solution. The formation of AI3Sc in the Al matrix phase of the alloy was confirmed by X-ray diffraction and electron microprobe analysis. This result indicates that Sc2O3 was successfully reduced to metallic Sc and alloyed in situ to form liquid Al-Sc alloy during the reduction. When Al was not used in the reduction experiment, a complex oxide (CaSc2O4) was formed, and the reduction was incomplete. This study demonstrates that the Al-Sc alloy can be directly produced by calciothermic reduction using CaCl2 flux and Al collector metal.
In another publication titled "Electrochemical production of Al-Sc alloy in CaCI2-Sc2O3 molten salt" (HARATA M ET AL,2008), to develop a new production process for Al-Sc alloys, a fundamental study on the electrolysis in CaCl2-Sc2O3 melts was conducted using a small-scale laboratory cell. Al-Sc alloys were electrochemically produced by cathodically polarizing an Al liquid electrode in CaCl2-Sc2O3 melts at 1173 K. Metallic-colored spherical samples were produced by the electrolysis and were analyzed by XRD, EPMA, XRF, and ICP-AES. The electrolyzed samples consisted of Al and AI3Sc phases. The purity of the obtained Al-Sc alloys was greater than 99 mass%, and the calcium content was less than 0.65 mass%. This study demonstrates the feasibility of Al-Sc alloy production directly from Sc2O3 by electrochemical methods.
One of the most important areas of scandium element usage is in aluminum-scandium alloys which is obtained by adding 0.2-0.8% scandium into aluminum for applications which require high strength, corrosion resistance and weldability. These alloys are generally obtained via adding pure scandium metal or master alloy containing 1-20% scandium, into molten aluminum metal.
One of the methods used for obtaining pure scandium metal is based on metallothermic reduction of pure Sc₂O₃ compound with gaseous calcium metal at high temperature. However, since the compound is a highly stable compound during the reduction, the reduction process may not be complete and some amount of scandium metal is lost in the form of CaSc₂O₄.
Another method for obtaining pure scandium metal is that converting Sc₂O₃ compound into relatively less stable ScF₃ form via using HF gas at high temperature and metallothermic reduction with calcium metal at high temperature. However, HF gas used in converting the Sc₂O₃ compound into ScF₃ form, is an extremely environmentally hazardous and corrosive compound, thus technically it makes the process very difficult. At the end of the reaction CaF₂ compound is produced along with the scandium metal, leading into the problem of separating scandium from this compound. Furthermore, impurity problem is caused by the tantalum pots where the reduction process takes place during the applied process, and the calcium metal used in the reaction, thus additional operational costs occur because of the vacuum distillation method used in order to overcome the impurity problem. In order to overcome these problems, it has been proposed to perform the reduction process of pure Sc₂O₃ or ScF₃ compound with calcium in the presence of aluminum metal, so recovering scandium aluminum alloy instead of pure scandium metal is proposed. The reduction process has been claimed to become easier and more efficient by dissolving the scandium metal, which has been reduced to metallic form, in molten aluminum metal.
However on the other hand; impurity problems during the reduction process at high temperatures due to tantalum pots and calcium metal, generation of Al₄Ca phase in processes where Sc₂O₃ compound is used as the initial compound, and the requirement of using HF gas in processes where ScF₃ compound is used as the initial compound still constitute the technical problems which should be overcome during these processes.
It has been proposed that it may be possible to obtain scandium metal alternatively by using molten salt electrolysis method in order to overcome the problems encountered during metallothermic reduction methods realized at high temperatures with calcium metal [1]. The basic principle of the molten salt method is to dissolve the compound of the desired metal, inside an appropriate salt mixture at high temperature and separate it into its ions, and during the process, reduction of the desired element ions and selectively collect it at the cathode may be achieved by applying electric current to the molten salt mixture. Salts that may be used in this process, are fluoride, chloride, bromide and iodide and among them fluoride, chloride and mixtures thereof have been the most preferred alternatives [2]. Molten salts containing chloride and fluoride, fluoride containing salts are the most preferred ones due to having higher stability at high temperatures, absence of humidity absorption problem (not being hydroscopic) in contrast to chloride, and having high current efficiency [3].
As a result, aforementioned disadvantages and lack of adequate solutions in the background art have made it necessary to make a development in the technical field related to scandium metal production.

Objectives of the Invention

The present invention relates to a production method for scandium metal and Al-Sc alloys from scandium compounds obtained by the calcination of scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, via molten salt electrolysis method, which meets the aforementioned requirements while overcoming all disadvantages and providing further advantages.
The primary objective of the invention is the production of pure scandium metal, directly obtaining aluminum-scandium alloys containing 0.2-0.8% scandium and obtaining aluminum-scandium master alloys containing 1-20% scandium.
Another objective of the invention is to obtain scandium metal by using molten salt method, in order to overcome the technical problems associated with metallothermic reduction method. It is also obtaining fluoride containing salts in order to achieve this.
Another objective of the invention is the calcination of the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆, form at a temperature between 350-400 °C; and after the calcination process, by removing the (NH₄) form from the structure, obtaining fluorinated scandium salts having the forms of NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆, in order to be used in molten salt electrolysis method.
A similar objective of the invention is to prevent the use of various high purity salts required to form the molten salt mixture.
In order to achieve aforementioned objectives, the invention relates to a production method of pure scandium metal, comprising process steps of;

a) obtaining fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms from the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form via calcination process, wherein the calcination process of the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, is conducted at 350-400 °C for a duration of 1-3 hours;
b) electrolysis process of the obtained fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms via molten salt electrolysis method, wherein the electrolysis process comprises
- heating the fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, until it is molten to the temperature of 600-1100 °C,
- applying an electrical current to the obtained molten salt bath through the anode and the cathode in order to maintain 2-8 volts of potential difference,
- obtaining pure scandium metal at the bottom of the electrolysis cell by reducing and separating the Sc⁺³ ions from the molten salt mixture via this applied electrical current and potential.

In order to achieve aforementioned objectives, the invention relates to a production method for an aluminum-scandium alloy containing 0.2-0.8% scandium or an aluminum-scandium master alloy containing 1-20% scandium; comprising process steps of:

a) obtaining fluorinated salt mixture of scandium in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms from the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form via calcination process, wherein the calcination process of the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, is conducted at 350-400 °C for a duration of 1-3 hours;
b) electrolysis process of the obtained fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms via molten salt electrolysis method, wherein the electrolysis process comprises:
- adding aluminum to the bottom of the electrolysis cell,
- adding fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, on top of the aluminum metal,
- heating the aluminum metal and the fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms until it is molten, to the temperature of 700-1100°C,
- applying an electrical current to the obtained molten salt bath through the anode and the cathode in order to maintain 2-8 volts of potential difference,
- obtaining aluminum-scandium alloy by separating from the molten fluoride salt mixture after the electrolysis process.

Structural and characteristic features of the invention with all its advantages shall become apparent with the detailed description given below and the appended drawings, therefore, assessment should be based on these drawings and the detailed description.

Brief Description of the Drawings

Figure 1:: View of the cell system that is used to obtain pure scandium metal
Figure 2:: View of the cell system that is used to obtain aluminum-scandium metal
Figure 3:: Graphical representation of DTA/TGA analysis results which is conducted to determine the calcination temperature of (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ compound
Figure 4:: XRD graph of (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ compound which has been calcined between 350-400 °C for 1 hour
Figure 5:: XRD graph of the Al-Sc alloy obtained by electrolysis
Figure 6:: Optical microscope image of the Al-Sc alloy obtained by electrolysis (x190 magnification)
Figure 7:: Optical microscope image of the Al-Sc alloy obtained by electrolysis (x190 magnification) and micro-hardness measurement of Al and Al₃Sc phases

Drawings may not be scaled and the details that are not essential for understanding the present invention may have been omitted. Moreover, at least substantially identical elements or elements with at least substantially identical functions are denoted with same numbers.

Explanation of the Parts Presented in the Drawings

1.: Gas inlet
2.: Gas outlet
3.: Quartz Tube
4.: Graphite anode
5.: Graphite cathode
6.: Alumina Casing
7.: Graphite pot
8.: Molten salt
9.: Reduced metallic scandium powder (solid)
10.: Liquid aluminum

Detailed Description of the Invention

In this detailed description, the preferred embodiments of the production method for scandium metal and Al-Sc alloys from scandium compounds obtained via calcination of a scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, via molten salt electrolysis method, are described without any limiting effect for a better understanding of the subject.
The invention relates to production method for scandium metal in its pure or alloy form. The scandium production method of the invention comprises two steps. In the first step; removing the (NH₄) form by applying calcination process to scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form for a duration of 1-3 hours (preferably 1 hour) at 350-400 °C temperature, after the calcination process obtaining a fluorinated scandium salt mixture in the forms of NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆. The second step is the use of fluorinated scandium salt mixture in the NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, in molten salt electrolysis method in order to obtain pure scandium metal.
In Figure 1, a cell system that is used to obtain pure scandium metal is shown. The calcined fluorinated salt mixture is used directly in order to obtain pure scandium metal. It is desired to maintain the salts, which are used in molten salt electrolysis, in molten phase during the process. Therefore, the obtained salt mixture is desired to have a relatively lower melting temperature. It has been observed that the fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, obtained by calcination, melts at about 600 °C. Therefore, in this process the temperature duri ng the molten salt electrolysis method should be over 600 °C.
Over this temperature Na, Sc and F elements are in ionic states, generally in Na⁺, Sc⁺³ and F^- forms. Therefore, when an electric current is applied through the molten mixture at a certain potential, positively charged Na⁺, Sc⁺³ ions will be attracted by the cathode, while negatively charged F^- ions will be attracted by the anode. Depending on the relative stability of these ions with respect to each other, the applied potential will result in electrochemical oxidation and reduction reactions at the anode and the cathode regions.
Mentioned salt mixture is heated until it reaches 600-1100 °C as shown in the example drawing of Figure 1. Depending on the composition of the salt mixture, the preferred temperature should be 10-15 °C above the melting te mperature of the salt.
The circuit is supplied with electric current to maintain 2-8 volts of potential difference. The current density applied to the circuit should be stabilized preferentially between 0.5-1.0 A/cm². Due to the relatively lower applied potential, Na⁺ ions are prevented to react, while only Sc³⁺ ions are reduced at the cathode (5) and collected on the electrolysis cell in a metallic form. Therefore, limiting the potential applied to the circuit below 3 volts will prevent the Na contamination problem. Whereas, due to the oxidation reactions at the anode, F^- ions will react with the graphite anode (4) and leave the cell as various fluorocarbon gases. These gases leaving the anode are environmentally undesired and hence may be collected and neutralized later. The scope of this study does not cover disposal of these gases. If preferred, in order to provide easier disposal of these gases, instead of the graphite anode (4) more stable anode materials which does not react with fluorine may be used, resulting only fluorine gas output at the anode. These residual gases may be converted into more stable and less hazardous fluoride compounds using a gas collector unit. When fluorine gas outlet (2) is not preferred in the circuit after the reduction reactions, Sc₂O₃ compound may be added to the system no more than 10% by weight in the total salt bath and this compound may be dissolved into Sc⁺³ and O^-2 ions inside the molten salt (8) phase. Since O^-2 ions are oxidized with lower potentials in comparison to F^- ions, F^- ions may be prevented to react by adjusting the potential difference applied to the circuit. In order to meet this criterion, the potential difference applied to the circuit should not exceed 6 volts. Thereby, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide gases, which are environmentally easier to dispose of, may be the gas outlet (2) as a result of the carbon and oxygen reactions at the graphite anode (4). Alternatively, oxygen gas which does not possess any environmental risks may be obtained at by using more stable anode materials which does not react with oxygen, When the oxidation and reduction reactions at the anode and the cathode terminate, the Sc⁺³ ions inside the molten salt is reduced and separated from the salt mixture so pure scandium metal (9) can be obtained at the bottom of the cell.
If it is desired to obtain an aluminum-scandium alloy containing 0.2-0.8% scandium or an aluminum-scandium master alloy containing 1-20% scandium via molten salt electrolysis method; then pure aluminum metal is added to the bottom of the cell before the reaction as shown in Figure 2. Subsequently, fluoride salt mixture of NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ obtained from the calcination process is added on top of the Al metal. Thereafter, both phases are melted by increasing the temperature of the cell over a value where the aluminum and the fluoride salt mixtures are in their molten states (preferably 700-1100 °C). When melting is completed, liquid aluminum (10) is collected at the bottom of the cell due to the density difference, while fluoride salt mixture (8) is collected on top of the liquid aluminum (10).
A current may be applied to the circuit in order to create a potential difference between 2 and 8 volts. Applying relatively lower potentials preferably not exceeding 3 volts prevents Na⁺ ions to react, ensuring only Sc³⁺ ions to be reduced at the cathode (5) and to be dissolved in the liquid aluminum (10), collected at the bottom of the electrolysis cell in molten state. Due to oxidation reactions occurred at anode, by reacting with the graphite anode (4), F^- ions may leave the cell in the form of various fluorocarbon gases. Since these gases emitted at the anode are environmentally undesired, these gases may be collected and disposed of later. If it is preferred, more stable anode materials which does not react with fluorine gas may be used instead of the graphite anode (4), resulting in only fluorine gas output (2) at the anode, in order to provide easier disposal of these gases. These residual gases may be converted into more stable and less hazardous fluoride compounds via using a gas collector unit. When fluorine gas outlet (2) is not preferred in the circuit during the reduction reactions, Sc₂O₃ or Al₂O₃ compounds may be added to the system no more than 10% by weight in the salt mixture and scandium oxide may be dissolved into Sc⁺³ and O^-2 ions, or the aluminum oxide may be dissolved into Al⁺³ and O^-2 ions, inside the molten salt (8) phase. Since O^-2 ions are oxidized with lower potentials in comparison to F^- ions, F^- ions may be prevented to react by adjusting the potential difference applied to the circuit. In order to meet this criterion, the potential difference applied to the circuit should not exceed 6 volts. Thereby, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide gases, which are environmentally more easily disposable, may be emitted as a result of the carbon and oxygen reactions at the graphite anode (4). Alternatively, instead of graphite by using more stable anode materials which does not react with oxygen, only oxygen gas, which does not possess any environmental risks, may be emitted at the anode. While potential difference between 2-8 volts is applied, Sc³⁺ and Al⁺³ ions may be reduced simultaneously and dissolved in the liquid aluminum (10), collected at the bottom of the electrolysis cell in molten state. Applying 2-8 volts of potential difference to the cell in this way while the process is maintained until the desired scandium concentration; an aluminum-scandium alloy containing 0.2-0.8% scandium or, with longer electrolysis durations, an aluminum-scandium master alloy with 1-20% scandium may be obtained. After the electrolysis process, the aluminum-scandium alloy at the bottom of the cell in liquid state again, may be separated from the molten fluoride salt phase and an aluminum-scandium alloy may be obtained via this way.

REFERENCES

1. Xiao Y. Yan and D.J. Fray, Molten salt electrolysis for sustainable metals extraction and materials processing - A review, in Electrolysis: Theory, Types and Applications, Shing Kuai and Ji Meng, Editors. 2010, Nova Science: New York. p. 255-302.
2. Zhu, H., Rare Earth Metal Production by Molten Salt Electrolysis, in Encyclopedia of Applied Electrochemistry, G. Kreysa, K.-i. Ota, and R. Savinell, Editors. 2014, Springer New York. p. 1765-1772.
3. Yuriy Shtefanyuk, et al. Production of Al-Sc alloy by electrolysis of cryolite-scandium oxide melts. in TMS (The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society). 2015. Florida: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
4. M. HARATA ET AL, "Production of scandium and Al-Sc alloy by metallothermic reduction", TRANSACTIONS - INSTITUTION OF MINING AND METALLURGY. SECTION C.MINERAL PROCESSING AND EXTRACTIVE METALLURGY, GB, (20130701), vol. 117, no. 2, doi:10.1179/174328508X290876, ISSN 0371-9553, pages 95 - 99.
5. HARATA M ET AL, "Electrochemical production of Al-Sc alloy in CaCl"2-Sc"2O"3 molten salt", JOURNAL OF ALLOYS AND COMPOUNDS, ELSEVIER SEQUOIA, LAUSANNE, CH, vol. 474, no. 1-2, doi:10.1016/J.JALLCOM.2008.06.110, ISSN 0925-8388, (20090417), pages 124 - 130.

Claims

A production method for pure scandium comprising process steps of:
a) obtaining fluorinated salt mixture of scandium in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms from the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form via calcination process, wherein the calcination process of the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, is conducted at 350-400 °C for a duration of 1-3 hours;

b) electrolysis process of the obtained fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms via molten salt electrolysis method, wherein the electrolysis process comprises:
• heating the fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, until it is molten to the temperature of 600-1100 °C,

• applying an electrical current to the obtained molten salt bath through the anode and the cathode in order to maintain 2-8 volts of potential difference,

• obtaining pure scandium metal at the bottom of the electrolysis cell by reducing and separating the Sc⁺³ ions from the molten salt mixture via this applied electrical current and potential.
A production method for an aluminum-scandium alloy containing 0.2-0.8% scandium or an aluminum-scandium master alloy containing 1-20% scandium; comprising process steps of:
a) obtaining fluorinated salt mixture of scandium in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms from the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form via calcination process, wherein the calcination process of the scandium compound in (NH₄)₂NaScF₆ form, is conducted at 350-400 °C for a duration of 1-3 hours;

b) electrolysis process of the obtained fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms via molten salt electrolysis method, wherein the electrolysis process comprises:
• adding aluminum to the bottom of the electrolysis cell,

• adding fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms, on top of the aluminum metal,

• heating the aluminum metal and the fluorinated scandium salt mixture in NaScF₄ and Na₃ScF₆ forms until it is molten, to the temperature of 700-1100°C,

• applying an electrical current to the obtained molten salt bath through the anode and the cathode in order to maintain 2-8 volts of potential difference,

• obtaining aluminum-scandium alloy by separating from the molten fluoride salt mixture after the electrolysis process.
The production method according to claim 2, wherein; when the mentioned anode material is graphite; fluorocarbon gas or carbon monoxide-carbon dioxide gases may be emitted.
The production method according to claim 3, wherein; when carbon monoxide-carbon dioxide gas emission is preferred; the method further comprises the process steps of:
• adding Sc₂O₃ or Al₂O₃ compound no more than 10% by weight to the salt mixture and dissolving scandium oxide into Sc⁺³ and O^-2 ions, or dissolving the aluminum oxide into Al⁺³ and O^-2 ions, inside the molten salt phase,

• adjusting the potential difference applied to the circuit without exceeding 6 volts, in order to oxidize only O^-2 ions.
The production method according to claim 2, wherein; when the mentioned anode material is a stable anode material which does not react with F^-, F₂ gas is emitted; and when it is a stable anode material which does not react with O^-, O₂ gas is emitted.
The production method according to claim 5, wherein; when emission of O₂ gas is preferred; the method further comprises the process steps of:
• adding Sc₂O₃ or Al₂O₃ compound no more than 10% by weight to the salt mixture and dissolving scandium oxide into Sc⁺³ and O^-2 ions, or dissolving the aluminum oxide into Al⁺³ and O^-2 ions, inside the molten salt phase,

• adjusting the potential difference applied to the circuit without exceeding 6 volts, in order to oxidize only O^-2 ions.