EP0762472B1

EP0762472B1 - Charged particle detectors and mass spectrometers employing the same

Info

Publication number: EP0762472B1
Application number: EP96306426A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Patrick James Turner; Raymond Clive Haines
Original assignee: Micromass UK Ltd
Current assignee: Micromass UK Ltd
Priority date: 1995-09-07
Filing date: 1996-09-05
Publication date: 2000-04-05
Anticipated expiration: 2016-09-05
Also published as: EP0762472A1; DE69607543T2; CA2184963C; JPH09171083A; DE69607543D1; GB9518258D0; US5757012A; JP2886508B2; US5903002A; ATE191585T1; CA2184963A1

Abstract

A Faraday Cup charged-particle detector (1) for use e.g. in an isotopic ratio mass spectrometer is provided with a charged-particle collector substrate (12) being at least partially composed of carbon produced by burning wood or other grained or cellular organic material so that the substrate surface has an open cellular structure and wherein the cells are of elongated tubular form. The detector is economic to manufacture, reliable and has an increased lifetime. <IMAGE>

Description

The invention relates to a Faraday cup detector for detecting charged-particles, and to a mass spectrometer employing one or more of the said detectors. The invention relates further to a method of detecting charged particles with such a detector. More specifically, the invention relates to charged-particle detectors having an improved lifetime compared to known charged-particle detectors, to charged-particle collector substrates for such detectors, and to mass spectrometers employing one or more of the said detectors.
The invention is particularly relevant to the type of charged-particle detector known as the Faraday Cup. Faraday Cups, also known as Faraday Detectors or Faraday Buckets, have been used to detect both electrons and charged particles from the nineteenth century onwards. A typical Faraday Cup comprises an electrostatically shielded enclosure of electrically conducting material. The enclosure has a first aperture through which charged particles can enter, these charged particles striking a collector plate within the enclosure and generating an electrical current that is detected by a meter or counter connected to the collector. The electrostatic shielding is provided by an electrically conducting frame or cage surrounding the internal enclosure and electrically isolated from it.
Faraday Cups may be used to detect either electrons or ions, but the following discussion will be limited to ion detection. It will be apparent to the skilled person, however, that many of the same or similar considerations apply to the detection of electrons.
Since the currents involved are extremely low, any detector used must be very sensitive. Furthermore, in order that the current detected by a Faraday Cup be truly representative of the charged particles desired to be detected, it is important both to suppress stray ions from being scattered into the cup and to stop secondary electrons being emitted out of the cup, as either of these events will affect the detected current. An apertured, positively biased suppressor plate may be provided at the cup entrance to suppress the entry of spurious charged particles, and the emission of secondary electrons from within the cup may be suppressed by providing a further, negatively biased suppressor plate.
The suppression of secondary particles has been further achieved in various ways, one of which is to coat the inside of the Faraday Cup with secondary-particle-absorbing material. Among materials that have been suggested are soot, solid carbon, meshes of various forms, gold or platinum black and "electron velvet" which is a complex structure formed of thousands of gold-plated copper tubes [Marmet and Kerwin, Can. J. Phys. Vol. 38 (1960) pp 787 - 796]. Some of these suggestions, along with other Faraday Cup designs, are reviewed by C. E. Kuyatt ["Methods of Experimental Physics" (1968) Vol. 7a, pp 1-43, chapter entitled 'Electron-Atom Interaction'].
A further study of Faraday Cup design has been undertaken by Seamans and Kimura [Rev. Sci. Instrum., Vol. 64(2), February 1993, pp 460 - 469]. Seamans and Kimura propose the use of a collector substrate within the Faraday Cup that consists of a carbon plate, the surface of which has been textured with 3.8mm wide V-section grooves. This type of regularly machined structure may, however, show periodic reflectivity changes at a microscopic level as an ion beam is scanned across the entrance of the collector.
Further work on the primary- and secondary-emission characteristics of carbon surfaces has been performed at NASA in the context of Travelling-Wave-Tube Amplifiers [e.g. Wintucky et al, Thin Solid Films, Vol. 84, (1981) pp 161 - 169 and Curren, IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev. (Nov. 1986) Vol. ED-33 (11), pp 1902 - 1914]. The optimum surface in this regard suggested by the NASA studies is Ion-sputter-textured pyrolytic graphite, which is obtained by exposing a carbon or carbon-coated surface to an ion beam for a number of hours until a surface is formed which consists of "a dense array of tall thin spires".
The manufacture of the collector surfaces suggested by Seamans et al and Wintucky et al is however time-consuming and costly, and would increase cost markedly.
Typically, Faraday cups in common use are coated internally with carbon (e.g. colloidal graphite) to prevent the generation of secondary ions. However, over a period of time the lining of the Faraday cup gradually builds a deposit of impacted ions that will change the physical characteristic of the cup lining and consequently increase the likelihood of secondary ion production. The efficiency of the Faraday cup will therefore become degraded and the peak shape will be affected.
Faraday Cups have many applications in detecting charged particles. An application in which Faraday Cups are particularly useful is Isotopic Ratio Mass Spectrometry, in which a sample is ionized and the ions representative of a particular constituent of the sample are separated according to their mass (e.g. by a magnetic field) so that ions representative of different isotopes follow different paths. An Isotopic Ratio Mass Spectrometer may contain a plurality of Faraday Cups positioned so that ions representative of a particular isotope are detected by a particular cup. Such a Mass Spectrometer is shown, for example, in EP-A-0587448.
When an Isotopic Ratio Mass Spectrometer is operating in static mode, ions representative of a particular isotope are always detected by the same detector. It is therefore important that the detectors are stable in their operation, as the degradation of one detector will lead to inaccurate measurements of isotopic ratio. Furthermore, peak shape is particularly crucial in Isotopic Ratio measurements, so that the degradation in performance of a Carbon-coated Faraday Cup over time is particularly undesirable in Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometers, and the previously mentioned periodic reflectivity changes which may be introduced by a regularly grooved collector plate would show up as undesirable artefacts at the ppm level in such measurements.
Typically, each detector will last in the region of one year before replacement is necessary. In an Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometer, which typically operates at a vacuum of 133,3 · 10^-8 - 133,3 · 10^-9 Pa (10^-8 or 10^-9 Torr), replacement of the detectors is extremely costly and inconvenient, as the vacuum must be broken, the detector assembly removed and replaced, the vacuum reattained and the new detector assembly calibrated. This procedure can take up to four days, which can cause great inconvenience. Furthermore, since an Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometer may contain up to seven or more detectors, the good performance and reliability of the detectors is particularly crucial.
An object of the present invention is to overcome the above-mentioned disadvantages. In particular, an object of the present invention is to provide a charged-particle detector having an increased lifetime. A further object of the invention is to provide a charged-particle detector which is reliable and economic to manufacture. A still further object of the invention is to provide a charged-particle collector substrate for a charged-particle detector which enhances the lifetime-of the detector and is reliable and economic. A still further object of the invention is to provide a mass spectrometer having one or more charged-particle detectors having the aforementioned advantages.
According to the present invention there is provided a Faraday cup detector as claimed in claim 1, a mass spectrometer as claimed in claim 11, a method of detecting charged-particles as claimed in claim 14, and a method of mass spectrometry as claimed in claim 18.
Advantageously, the cells forming said open cellular structure are long and thin and extend generally in the direction of the incoming particles. Preferably the cells are roughly tubular in form. Preferably the surface of the collector substrate presented to the charged particles is roughly transverse to the grain or axial direction of the tubular structure. Advantageously the collector substrate is formed of charcoal. Further advantageously the charcoal consists of wood or other grained or cellular organic material which has been burnt so as to become charcoal.
Preferably, when charcoal made from a grained material is used, the charcoal is arranged so that the surface presented to the charged particles to be detected is formed across the grain of the material. Further preferably, the charcoal is cut along a plane which is across the grain of the material and the said cut plane is presented to the charged particles. Advantageously, when charcoal made from a cellular material is used, the charcoal is cut across a plane which transects at least some of the cells so that the said cut plane is presented to the charged particles, thereby providing an exposed open cellular structure.
Certain preferred embodiments of the invention will now be described in detail by way of example only and with reference to the figures, which are not to scale and wherein:-

Figure 1 is a partially exploded and simplified diagram of a charged-particle detector according to the invention;
Figure 2 shows a cross-sectional view of the detector of Figure 1 when assembled;
Figure 3 shows the collector substrate; and
Figure 4 is a schematic diagram of a mass spectrometer including detectors according to the invention.

Figure 1 is a partially exploded and simplified diagram of a Faraday Cup detector, shown generally as 1. The detector consists of an inner cup surrounded by and electrically insulated from an electrostatically shielding outer enclosure. The inner cup includes internal cup frame 3 which is attached, e.g. by spot welding, to side walls 6. Aperture plate 10, which is attached to the inner frame, forms the mouth of the cup.
The outer enclosure includes an outer frame 2 which is connected to inner frame 3 at the rear of the frames by electrically insulating bolt 14. Defining slit 4, having side walls as shown, fits around the frames when assembled and forms the front and sides of the outer frame. The side walls of the outer frame are insulated from those of the inner frame by Kapton foils 5. The defining slit is attached to the outer frame by bolts 13 and to the inner frame by electrically-insulating screws 15. The screws 15 also pass through a number of further apertured plates 7,8 and 9 which are positioned in front of plate 10, screws 15 serving to hold the apertured plates in place. These plates are spaced apart by electrically insulating spacers 11 (Fig. 2). Apertured plate 7 is connected via a wire 17 (Fig. 2) to a positive potential of approximately +10 Volts. This acts to repel unwanted positively charged ions from entering the cup. Apertured plate 8 is connected via wire 18 to a negative potential of approximately -200 Volts which acts to stop secondary electrons from leaving the cup. Apertured plate 9 is connected to the earthed outer frame 2 by a stub 9a and forms an earthed guard plate.
The frame 3 of the inner cup is connected via a signal wire 20, which passes through an insulating feedthrough 16, to an electrical circuit 34 comprising signal measuring means 19 which may be a counter or amplifier. Signal measuring means 19 measures the current due to charged particles which impinge on the substrate 12, as discussed below. At the base of the inner cup a rebate is formed in which sits a charged-particle collector substrate 12. The collector substrate 12 is shown in more detail in Figure 3. It consists in this example of a piece of charcoal approximately 15mm in height by 1.7mm in width by 4mm in depth. The charcoal has been formed by burning a suitable organic material, in this case wood, and has been cut across the grain of the wood so that the surface presented to the charged particles entering the cup is in a plane approximately transverse to the grain direction, thereby presenting to the charged particles an exposed open cellular structure, the open cells being of generally elongated tubular form and extending generally in the direction of the incoming particles. The approximate direction of the charged particles approaching the substrate is shown by the arrow.
Figure 4 shows a mass spectrometer incorporating detectors according to the invention. The mass spectrometer includes an evacuated housing 33 containing a source 21 for generating ions representative of a particular sample, a mass analyzer 22 and three Faraday Cup detectors (23, 24, 25). The example shown is an isotopic ratio mass spectrometer having three Faraday Cups according to the invention. However, in practice more or fewer Faraday Cups may be used, and according to the design of the spectrometer, detectors of other types may be used in addition to the Faraday Cups of the present invention. Furthermore, only one Faraday Cup may be provided.
Operation of the mass spectrometer shown in Figure 4 is as follows; ions are generated in source 21 and a beam of ions 29 representative of the sample to be analyzed is directed towards the input of a mass analyzer 22, typically a magnet. The incident ions pass through the mass analyzer with varying trajectories according to their mass-to-charge ratios, and exit the mass analyzer in different directions as beams 30, 31, 32. Faraday Cup detectors 23, 24, 25 are each positioned to detect ions of a particular mass-to-charge ratio, and the outputs of the detectors are connected to counters or amplifiers 26, 27, 28. Conveniently the mass spectrometer may be controlled by a computer (not shown).
A mass spectrometer of the type shown in Figure 4 is typically used for the determination of isotopic ratios, in which case at least two of the amplifiers or counters 26, 27 and 28 will operate simultaneously so that simultaneous measurements of the ion flux on each detector can be made to reduce errors in the isotopic ratio measurement mode using these amplifiers and counters.
To test the performance of Faraday Cups constructed according to the invention they were exposed to very high ion currents to simulate normal usage over a period of years. Peak flatness, cup efficiency and dynamic multicollection analyses were made at intervals during the exposure experiment. It was found that even after 8 x 10¹⁵ ions were impacted into the cups there was no degradation in the peak shape. Furthermore there was no appreciable change in cup efficiency over the exposure period, confirming the robustness of the cups. In fact, cup lifetime was estimated to be at least 5 years, and since no failure point was reached during the experiments, this is thought to be a conservative estimate.
An advantage of the use of a collector substrate formed of wood charcoal cut across the grain, for example, is that the structure so formed consists of long thin "tunnels" of carbon. Energetic ions can therefore penetrate deep into the substrate so that an increased depth of the secondary-particle-absorbing substrate is used. Charcoal also has a low reflectivity, reducing scattering effects. Furthermore, the random nature of charcoal formed from burnt organic matter results in a non-periodic structure which decreases artefact formation. The high resistivity of the material used is not relevant, as the currents involved are so low (typically 3 x 10^-11 A over 10mm².)

Claims

A Faraday cup detector (1) for detecting charged particles comprising:
an electrostatically shielded enclosure (2); and

an aperture plate (10) through which charged particles in use enter said enclosure (2);
characterized in that:
a charged-particle collector substrate (12) at least partially composed of carbon having an open cellular structure is disposed within said enclosure (2).
A detector as claimed in claim 1, wherein in use charged particles impinge to cause a current to flow in an electrical circuit connected to said substrate (12), said detector further comprising signal measuring means (19) for measuring said current.
A detector as claimed in claim 1 or 2, wherein said substrate (12) is disposed so that the cells forming said open cellular structure are of open tubular form.
A detector as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein said substrate (12) has a surface on which charged-particles in use impinge, said surface being generally transverse to the grain or axial direction of the cells comprising said open cellular structure.
A detector as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein said substrate (12) is at least partially formed of charcoal.
A detector as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein said substrate (12) is at least partially made from wood or other grained or cellular organic material which has been burnt so as to become charcoal.
A detector as claimed in claim 6, wherein the charcoal is cut along a plane which is across the grain of the material so as to form a surface on which charged particles may impinge.
A detector as claimed in claim 7, wherein said plane intersects at least some of the cells forming said open cellular structure thereby providing said surface with an exposed cellular structure.
A detector as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein said charged-particle collector substrate (12) is disposed so that the cells forming said open cellular structure extend generally in the direction of travel of said charged particles entering said detector (1).
A detector as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein the surface of said substrate (12) on which at least some of said charged particles impinge is disposed generally transverse to the direction of entry of charged particles entering said charged-particle detector (1).
A mass spectrometer comprising:
ionizing means (21) for ionizing a sample to form ions representative of the constituents of the sample;

analyzing means (22) for analyzing the ions according to their mass-to-charge ratios; and

one or more detectors (23; 24; 25) according to any preceding claim for detecting at least some of said ions after they leave said analyzing means (22).
A mass spectrometer as claimed in claim 11, wherein said analyzing means (22) comprises a magnetic sector mass analyzer (22) from which ions of different mass-to-charge ratios exit in different directions and said mass spectrometer comprises a plurality of said detectors (23; 24; 25) disposed so that each of said detectors (23; 24; 25) receives only ions of one particular mass-to-charge ratio.
A mass spectrometer as claimed in claim 12 for the determination of isotopic ratios, wherein signal measuring means (26; 27; 28) are provided for simultaneously measuring the current generated by ions entering at least two of said plurality of detectors (23; 24; 25).
A method of detecting charged-particles comprising:
allowing said particles to impinge on a charged-particle collector substrate (12) so as to generate a current flow in an electrical circuit (34) connected to said substrate (12); and

measuring the current so generated;

said method characterized in that for said collector substrate a substrate is used (12) comprising carbon having an open cellular structure.
A method as claimed in claim 14, wherein the surface of the substrate (12) on which the charged particles to be detected impinge has an open cellular structure in which the cells comprising said structure are of elongated tubular form and wherein said surface is generally transverse to the grain or axial direction of said cells.
A method as claimed in either claim 14 or 15, wherein said substrate (12) is at least partially composed of charcoal made from burning wood or other grained or cellular organic material.
A method as claimed in any of claims 14-16, wherein at least some of said particles are allowed to enter a Faraday cup detector (1) comprising an electrostatically shielded enclosure (2) and an apertured plate (10) through which charged particles may enter said enclosure (2) and impinge on a said charged-particle collector substrate (12) disposed in said enclosure (2).
A method of mass spectrometry comprising:
generating ions from a sample;

analysing said ions according to their mass-to-charge ratio; and

detecting at least some of said ions so analyzed by a method as claimed in any of claims 14-17.
A method of mass spectrometry as claimed in claim 18, wherein the step of analyzing said ions comprises dispersing said ions according to their mass-to-charge ratio in a magnetic sector mass analyzer (22) so that ions of different mass-to-charge ratios exit from said analyzer (22) in different directions, and the step of detecting at least some of the ions so analyzed comprises detecting in each one of a plurality of charged-particle detectors (12; 24; 25) substantially only ions of a given mass-to-charge ratio.
A method of mass spectrometry as claimed in claim 19 for determining isotopic ratios, further comprising simultaneously measuring signals generated by ions entering at least two of said plurality of charged-particle detectors (23; 24; 25).