EP0422920A2

EP0422920A2 - Sensitivity indicator for a radio receiver

Info

Publication number: EP0422920A2
Application number: EP90311108A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Robert John Schwendeman
Original assignee: Motorola Inc
Current assignee: Motorola Solutions Inc
Priority date: 1989-10-10
Filing date: 1990-10-10
Publication date: 1991-04-17
Anticipated expiration: 2010-10-10
Also published as: EP0422920A3; EP0422920B1; DE69021820D1; HK1000481A1; DE69021820T2; ATE126949T1

Abstract

This invention provides an indication of quality of signal reception in a selection call system such as a paging system, by comparing received data with preprogrammed data and indicating the degree of discrepancy therebetween.

Description

Background of the Invention

This invention relates to an indicator for a radio receiver, such as a pager or other selective call receiver, for indicating quality of reception and/or out of range probability.

Summary of the Prior Art

Some pagers have an out-of-range indicator, which provides to the pager user an indication of the out-of-range condition when a specific signature signal available within the signaling protocol (such as POCSAG) does not appear for a specified length of time. This indication disappears upon a single occurrence of the signature signal until the time again elapses. An out-of-range indicator of the type described will show a pager to be within range, even when the true probability of message reception may be very low, e.g. only 10 or 20%.
It is known generally in the art of selective call receivers that other methods for measuring out-of-range conditions also exist, such as using analog methods to provide an indication of received signal strength. However, received signal strength alone does not always give an accurate indication of probability of message reception. This is particularly true at the lower end of received signal strength levels.
It is an object of the present invention to provide an improved out-of-range indicator for a radio receiver, such as a pager, which provides feedback to a pager user on the actual operation of a pager in the actual pager environment.
According to a first embodiment of the present invention, there is provided a selective call system comprising a transmitter and at least one selective call receiver, the transmitter comprising means for transmitting a predetermined sequence of data, and the receiver comprising means for storing the same predetermined sequence of data, means for receiving the sequence of data transmitted by the transmitter and means for comparing the data received with the data stored and for providing a displayed indication of the comparison, indicative of the quality of reception.
The receiver may comprise control means for initiating a test mode of operation which, when initiated, causes the reception of the predetermined data, the comparison of the received and stored data and the displaying of the reception quality indication. At times other than during the control mode, the control means allows the receiver to receive other data, characteristic of normal pager operation.
The transmitter preferably comprises means for transmitting the predetermined data preceded by a predetermined identification code and the receiver comprises means for identifying said code and initiating reception of the predetermined data, comparison of the received and stored data and displaying of the reception quality indication on receipt thereof.
In another embodiment of the present invention, the receiver comprises first and second counters, the first counter being arranged to count at the rate of receipt of received data and the second counter being arranged to count correct correlations between the received and the stored data. The receiver further comprises means for dividing a count value of the second counter by a count value of the first counter to provide a relative figure of merit or a percentage indication of quality of reception.
In accordance with the present invention, a reception indicator is provided for a radio receiver which receives messages having recognizable signals extending over a period of time, e.g. over the length of one POCSAG synchronization word. The reception indicator comprises: timing means (e.g. a shift register) for providing a time interval smaller than the said period of time, detecting means for detecting the number of recognizable signals received during said time interval, whereby the detected number represents the quality of reception; and indicating means for displaying the quality of reception.
Since the synchronization word is repeated at consecutive frame periods, the indicator is provided with second timing means for providing a second time interval greater than a frame period and means for freezing the indicating means for said second period of time after the end of said first period of time. In this manner a continuous indication of quality of reception is displayable from frame to frame.
Thus, an advantage of the present invention is that it gives a qualitative indication of the actual probability of message reception in the actual environment which can be regularly updated.

Brief Description of the Drawings

Fig. 1 is a diagram of a paging system in accordance with a first embodiment of the invention.
Fig. 2 is a flow diagram showing the operation of a pager in the system of Fig. 1.
Fig. 3 is a diagram of a pager in accordance with a second embodiment of the invention.
Fig. 4 is a flow diagram showing the operation of the pager of Fig. 3.
Fig. 5 is a timing diagram illustrating the operation of the pager of Fig. 3 in accordance with the flow diagram of Fig. 4.
Fig. 6 is a flow diagram showing the operation of the pager of Fig. 3 in accordance with a third embodiment of the invention.

Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments

Referring to Fig. 1, there is shown a paging system comprising a paging terminal 10, a paging transmitter 11 and a pager 12. Each of these elements is structurally identical to known elements in the art. In particular the pager 12 is a numeric or alphanumeric display pager, with certain additional programs and features as are now explained. The pager comprises receiver circuitry as shown in the inset of Fig. 1, as well as a microprocessor 13 and a display 14. The microprocessor 13 comprises a central processing unit 15, an arithmetic and logic unit 16 and at least two counters 17 and 18.
In one embodiment of the present invention, the pager 12 is capable of being placed in a test mode. The manner of entering a test mode is by way of a unique button sequence, such as by depressing the read switch and the reset switch simultaneously while the pager 12 is being turned on. The test mode may alternately be entered by means of a menu displayed on the pager display. The pager of the present invention has an additional test mode, over and above existing test modes, such as described in U.S. Patents Nos. 4,599,615 and 4,649,538, and U.K. Patent Application No. 2 124 001 A. This additional test mode may be referred to as a page sensitivity utility.
The paging terminal 10 causes a specific series of data words to be transmitted by the transmitter 11 at predetermined intervals at a desired baud rate, such as 300, 600, or 1200 bits per second which may be representative of the actual paging data bit rate currently in service, or to be placed into service. The predetermined data words are illustrated in Fig. 1 and comprise a unique ID followed by 100 data words. The ID corresponds to a unique address to which the pager 12 is responsive when the pager has been placed in the test mode. This ID and the data words D1-D100 are preprogrammed in the pager 12. When the pager 12 is in the page sensitivity utility mode it receives and identifies this ID in a manner well known in the art, and compares the 100 received data words with the corresponding data words stored in memory. When the transmission is complete and the pager 12 has carried out the comparison, the pager 12 displays the number of data words correctly received. This number provides a "figure of merit" having no units, but which can be interpreted as representing the effective paging probability, or probability of receiving a page, expressed as a percentage. It can be used for comparison against other readings from different locations using the pager 12, or with different pagers, assuming such a comparison can be readily made with the other pagers. When a comparison of readings is to be made, the service engineer or operator simply moves to a new location, and when at that location, the pager receives a retransmission of the predetermined sequence of words, and a new reception quality indication is displayed. The tests can also be repeated at different transmitter powers, different antennas etc, and provide the service operator an indication of the actual area of coverage provided being provided by the system under the different measurement conditions.
Fig. 2 shows a flow diagram illustrating the operation of the above described embodiment. The operation of the flow diagram calls for two counters 17 and 18, as shown in Fig. 1, embodied in the pager 12. After the test mode has been entered by the user, the pager begins searching for the ID start code. When the ID start code is detected in step 20, counter 17 is incremented in step 21. Thereafter, counter 17 is incremented each time the program executes loop 22. This loop is executed once for each period of time a data word is expected to be thereafter received, such as every eight bits for an eight bit data word. If one of the data words D1-D100 is correctly detected in step 23, counter 18 is incremented in step 24. Once counter 17 reaches a count of 100, the figure of merit is calculated in step 25 and this figure is displayed on the radio display 14 of Fig. 1 in step 26.
It will be appreciated that modifications of detail can be made. For example, in the above method, there is a high degree or redundancy in the predetermined sequence of words transmitted. For example, if each word is eight bits in length, any number of errors within a word from 1-8 will degrade the quality indication by only one point. Thus, other methods of comparison could be used whereby the received data and the data stored in the pager 12 are compared on a bit-by-bit basis and an indication is given of the percentage of correct bits overall.
Referring now to Fig. 3, a pager in accordance with a second embodiment of the present invention is shown, comprising receiver circuitry 30 as for Fig. 1. The recovered data bit stream from the receiver circuitry 30 is coupled to a microprocessor 31. The microprocessor 31 performs a number of functions, the relevant ones of which are represented by boxes on the diagram. These elements do not necessarily form identifiable elements of hardware. The recovered data bit stream from the receiver circuitry 30 is first fed to a pattern detector means 32, which detects the synchronization codeword, such as when the POCSAG signaling format is being transmitted, or any other representative bit pattern within the received protocol. Each time the synchronization codeword is successfully detected by the pattern detector 32, the output of pattern detector 34 is set to a logic 1 state, remaining in that state until reset to a logic 0 state by a clock pulse generated by clock 43. A logic 1 pulse is also provided to the input of shift register 34 at the time the clock pulse is generated. Should the synchronization codeword fail to be subsequently detected, the output of pattern detector 34 would then remain in the logic 0 state, and a logic 0 pulse will also be provided to the input of shift register 34. This operation allows a synchronous detection of the synchronization codewords. The detections are then loaded into a software shift register 34 each time the clock pulse is generated. Means are provided for reading the first stage of this shift register 34 and the last stage (or some other stage), as will be explained shortly. Two timers 36 and 37, hereafter referred to as timer A and timer B respectively are provided in the microprocessor 31 together with a display interrupt unit 38 and an display driver 39. The display driver drives a display 40, which includes a visual indicator, which in the preferred embodiment of the present invention is in the form of a bar indicator 41. The display interrupt unit 38 causes the display to momentarily blink each time the expected pattern, such as the synchronization codeword, is successfully detected, thereby providing positive feedback that measurements are being made. Failure of the display to periodically blink for an extended length of time, such as a thirty second time interval, would indicate such circumstances, as the absence of channel activity or an out-of-range condition.
The operation of the pager of Fig. 3 will be described with reference to the flow chart of Fig. 4. This flow chart shows two programs which run consecutively. On the left hand side, there is shown a program which receives the pulses generated at the output of pattern detector 34 for each successful detection of the synchronization codeword (step 100). These pulses are loaded into the shift register 34 as previously described. For each successfully detected synchronization codeword, a logic 1 pulse is loaded into the shift register 34 and timer A 36 is reset in step 102. For each non-successful detection of the synchronization codeword, a logic 0 pulse is passed to the shift register 34, which results in the timer A count being advanced one clock time interval by clock 43. In summary, timer A is reset each time a synchronization codeword is detected, and advanced each time a synchronization codeword is not detected in the allotted time interval.
On the right hand side, there is shown a timing program for reading the shift register 34 and for calculating the percentage detection rate based on the output of shift register 34. By way of preliminary explanation of this diagram, the shift register 34 has a length Y, the period of timer B is less than the period of timer A and is greater than the time length of the period between the pattern codewords to be measured. In the preferred embodiment of the present invention, timer B is sufficiently long to enable detection of at least ten pattern codewords.
For each pulse received from the clock 43, timers A and B are advanced in step 110, and a pulse is loaded into the shift register as previously described at step 112. If timer A has expired, the program passes from step 114 to step 116 at which the shift register 34 stages are cleared and a zero indication is displayed on the display 41. From this, and from step 102, it can be seen that timer A only expires if a series of zeros are received into the shift register, indicating no match with the synchronization codeword for a predetermined period of time. If timer A has not expired at step 114, the program passes to decision 117 and, because in the first instance timer B has expired as a result of a previous cycle, the program passes to step 118 and the last stage of the shift register is read. If, upon reading the last stage of the register, the bit stored is a zero, this is determined in decision 120 and no action is taken, the program returning to steps 100 and 108. When a logic 1, indicating the first detected pulse has propagated through shift register 34, appears in the last stage of the register, all the stages of the shift register which contain 1's are summed, to give a value X. This operation is carried out in step 124. After step 124, timer B is reset at step 125 so that on the next execution of decision 117, step 130 will be reached. Until such time as the first detect appears in the last stage of the register, the program waits for the next pulse.
The first detection percentage for the desired pattern is calculated in step 126 as 100X/Y for codewords in which the probability of detection of the desired pattern equals the probability of detection of an address (this is approximately true for POCSAG). The result is then displayed on display 41 by a graph number or other suitable means. For a more complex code, X or 100X/Y may be used to provide an address for a ROM (read-only memory) which stores a tabulation of the address detection percentage corresponding for the detection percentage derived by the measurement of the desired patterns. The display changes upon each execution of step 126, i.e. after each count.
Once the first detection percentage calculation has been made, further calculations are triggered by successful synchronization codeword detections read from the first stage of shift register at step 130. Simultaneously step 126 causes display interrupt unit 38 to blink the display 41 for a short blank period, such as a 1/10 second time interval.
In summary, as pulses are generated indicating the successful reception of the synchronization codeword, or other pattern, logic 1's are clocked into shift register 34. In the event the synchronization codeword was not successfully received, a logic 0 is clocked into the shift register 34. When the first logic 1 has propagated through to the last stage of shift register 34, timer B is started, and a computation of the detection percentage is made and displayed. Thereafter, the detection percentage is updated and displayed for each new detection determined by a logic 1 being shifted into the first stage of shift register 34, and counter B is reset. The detection percentage continues to be updated as long as timer B is reset prior to its timing out. When timer B times out, the last detection percentage remains displayed without any further update until timer A times out, indicating the absence of transmissions of the synchronization codeword on the channel for an extended period of time. The cycle would repeat the next time a logic 1 has propagated through to the last stage of shift register 34.
The operation of the pager of the second embodiment of the present invention, as described with reference to Figs. 3 and 4 is further described with reference to Fig. 5. Fig. 5 illustrates the operation of the present invention using a shift register having a length of ten bits.
Fig. 5 shows a typical data pattern 150 transmitted by a transmitter such as transmitter 11 of Fig. 1. The data pattern comprises a sequence of message batches 151 such as would be transmitted using the POCSAG signaling format. Within each of the message batches the unique pattern codeword, in this instance, the POCSAG synchronization codeword is transmitted at the beginning of each batch. The synchronization codeword is repeated periodically as additional message batches are transmitted on the channel. The data pattern 150 also illustrates the fact that there may be time interval 152 during which no transmissions are being made, or during which time other signaling formats may be transmitted on the channel. The output from the pattern detector 32 is shown as signal 154, each pulse indicating a successful detection of the synchronization codeword. As shown, there are also instances where the synchronization codeword was not successfully detected. Each time a successful detect is indicated, timer A is reset, as shown at 155. The contents of shift register 34 is represented in Fig 5 by pattern 156 which shows the changes in the contents of the register over a period of time. Point C on the figure represents the contents of the last stage of the shift register which in this case is a logic 1. As previously explained, this triggers the first detection percentage calculation. Thereafter, as shown at point D, the first stage of the shift register is read for the purposes of determining when to make the next detection percentage calculation. An updated detection percentage calculation is made each time a successful synchronization codeword detection is made. From the contents of shift register 34, Fig. 5 illustrates by example six successful detections occurred, or X = 6, giving rise to a page detection percentage of 60%. When the transmissions of message batches 151 have ceased, no further successful synchronization codeword detections are obtained allowing timer B to time out. The process is repeated when the next synchronization codeword is received, and since timer B timed out, the first calculation of detection percentages again keys on the last stage of the shift register. The last stage of the shift register is use to key the calculation of the detection probabilities after the expiration of timer B because it provides the advantage of preventing false counts which often occur at the beginning of the transmission.
Timer A has a period substantially greater than timer B and acts as a fail safe. If no additional synchronization codewords are received during the period before timer A expires, the display will continue to read the last calculated detection percentage count. When timer A expires, it indicates no additional successful synchronization detections have been made for a substantial period of time and consequently the display is set to zero. In contrast, timer B maintains the last percentage detection reading on the display for long enough for the next synchronization codeword to be received.
An alternate embodiment of the present invention will now be described with reference to Fig. 6. In this embodiment, the data is transmitted in a single signaling format, such as POCSAG. There are no periods of data in other signaling formats, and there are no periods wherein data is absent, such as periods 152 in Fig. 5. Such a condition would exist on a fully loaded system which does not share the channel with other signaling formats. In this embodiment, timer A is not required, making the flow diagram somewhat more simplified. Step 200 corresponds to step 100 of Fig. 4, with the received pulses passing directly from the pattern detector to the shift register 34. Step 208 corresponds to step 108. If a new pulse is received, the shift register is loaded in step 212 and all the ones in the shift register are counted in step 214, whereupon in step 216 the display is blinked and a new value of 100 X/Y is calculated and displayed. In step 212, the shift register is stepped regardless of whether a detect is received or not. While the shift register length has been described as ten bits in length, it will be appreciated that the length of the shift register can be changed, to provide greater or lesser resolution to the calculation of the detection percentages. A longer shift register is particularly applicable to the embodiment described in Fig. 6, since the shift register is not regularly reset.
It will also be appreciated that modifications of detail can be made. For example, in the above method, there is a high degree or redundancy in the predetermined sequence of words transmitted. For example, since the length of the synchronization codeword is thirty-two bits in length, any number of errors within the codeword from 1-32 will degrade the quality indication by only one point. Thus, other methods of comparison could be used whereby the received synchronization codeword and the synchronization codeword stored in the pager 12 are compared on a bit-by-bit basis and an indication is given of the percentage of correct bits overall.
While specific embodiments of this invention have been shown and described, further modifications and improvements will occur to those skilled in the art. All modifications which retain the basic underlying principles disclosed and claimed herein are within the scope and spirit of the present invention.

Claims

1. A selective call receiver comprising means for receiving a sequence of data, means for storing a predetermined sequence of data, means for comparing the sequence of data as received with the sequence of data stored and measuring the degree of discrepancy therebetween and means for providing a displayed indication of the discrepancy, indicative of the quality of reception.

2. The selective call receiver of claim 1, wherein the predetermined sequence of data stored comprises a synchronization word and means are provided for receiving said synchronization word followed by message data and for identifying the message data by said synchronization word, whereby the quality of reception is discernable as message data is being received.

3. The selective call receiver of claim 1, comprising:
timing means for providing a predetermined time interval;
detecting means for detecting the number of recognizable signals received during said time interval, whereby the detected number represents the quality of reception; and
indicating means for displaying the quality of reception.

4. The selective call receiver of claim 3, arranged to receive messages having recognizable signals extending over a first period of time, which are repeated at consecutive frame periods, the receiver further comprising means for freezing the indicating means after the end of said first period of time, whereby a continuous indication of quality of reception is displayable from detection to detection.

5. The selective call receiver of claim 3, wherein said detecting means comprises a shift register, having a predetermined number of stages, for storing a count for each recognizable signal detection, and controller means for detecting when a first count has shifted to the last stage of said shift register, and for subsequently generating a first number of detections representing the quality of reception.

6. The selective call receiver of claim 5, wherein said controller means further includes means for generating the number of detections representing signal quality for each subsequent count detected in the first stage of said shift register, after the first count has shifted into the last stage of said shift register.

7. The selective call receiver of claim 4, further comprising third timing means for providing a time interval substantially greater than said second time interval, wherein means are provided for displaying an indication of no reception if no such signals are detected during said third time interval.

8. The selective call receiver of claim 1 further comprising means for blinking the indicating means each time a new quality of reception indication is displayed.

9. The selective call receiver of claim 1 further comprising means for indicating each reception of the predetermined data sequence.

10. The selective call receiver of claim 9 wherein said means for indicating each reception of the predetermined data sequence blinks when the predetermined data sequence is detected.