EP0168880B1

EP0168880B1 - Process for the preparation of sulphurized overbased salicylates

Info

Publication number: EP0168880B1
Application number: EP85201083A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Rudolf Frank Heldeweg; Martin Booth; Eugène Marie Godfried Andre van Kruchten
Original assignee: Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij BV
Current assignee: Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij BV
Priority date: 1984-07-06
Filing date: 1985-07-04
Publication date: 1988-08-24
Also published as: SG7090G; JPH0580517B2; ZA855048B; DE3564570D1; BR8503201A; EP0168880A1; GB8417297D0; CA1253873A; JPS6124560A

Description

This invention relates to a process for the preparation of sulphurized overbased metal aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylates, to products thus prepared and to oil compositions containing them.
From British patent specification 1 287 812 such products and oil compositions containing them as detergents and wear inhibitors are already known. It disclosses the reaction of an aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acid, or a metal salt thereof, with elemental sulphur, an alkaline earth base, e.g. a hydroxide, and a solvent, such as ethylene glycol, at at least 150 °C, and optionally further reaction with carbon dioxide. A similar process is disclosed in British patent specification 1 194503.
However, it has been found that this known process shows the disadvantage of a substantial degree of decarboxylation during the reaction with sulphur.
It has now been found that a much lower degree of decarboxylation can be obtained by reaction of the same type of aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acid, or the metal salt thereof, with sulphur after overbasing with carbon dioxide, without loss of the excellent detergent and anti-wear properties.
This invention therefore relates to a process for the preparation of sulphurized overbased metal aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylates, characterized in that an aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acid is transformed into an overbased metal salicylate having a basicity index of at least 1.5 by means of a basic metal compound and with carbon dioxide, and subsequently the overbased metal salicylate is sulphurized by heating with elemental sulphur.
The invention furthermore relates to the products thus prepared and to oil compositions containing them.
Suitable metals are e.g. alkali metals, such as Li, Cs, Na and K, alkaline earth metals, such as Ca, Ba, Sr and Mg, and polyvalent metals, such as Zn and Cr.
Alkaline earth metals such as calcium, barium and magnesium are preferred.
Suitable aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acids are described in the above-mentioned British patent specifications. Preferred are C₈-₃₀- alkyl salicylic acids.
The overbasing step can be carried out by reacting the hydrocarbon substituted salicylic acid in a solvent, such as a hydrocarbon solvent, preferably an aromatic hydrocarbon solvent, such as xylene, with a basic metal compound, preferably a hydroxide, and carbon dioxide, as described in e.g. British patent specification 786 167.
To the resulting reaction mixture a light mineral oil may be added and then the hydrocarbon solvent, and any water formed may be removed by distillation.
The basicity index (BI) of the overbased salicylate, defined as the equivalent ratio of metal: salicylic acid, is at least 1.5, preferably at least 3. It has been found that this is of importance in order to avoid any substantial amount of decarboxylation in the sulphurization step.
The sulphurization step can be carried out by contacting the resulting oil solution of the overbased salt with elemental sulphur, preferably in the presence of a solvent, at a temperature in the range of 100-250 °C, preferably 150-225 °C, whereby the final temperature should be at least 175 °C and preferably at least 195 °C.
The resulting oil solution of the sulphurized product may be filtered, if desired, and then be added to an oil, such as a lubricating oil or a fuel oil, including gasoline.
The above-mentioned solvent of the sulphurization step preferably is an alkylene or polyalkylene glycol or a lower alkyl monoether thereof, as disclosed in the above-mentioned British patent specifications 1 287 812 and 1 194 503.
A promotor such as a carboxylic acid or a metal salt thereof, as described in British patent specification 1 194 503, may also be present in the sulphurization step.
The molar ratio of S: substituted salicylic acid is e.g. 0.25 to 3, preferably 0.5 to 2.
Before or after sulphurization the product may be reacted with a boron compound, such as boric acid, as described in the copending British patent application 83 30 441.
The reaction products of this invention including mixtures thereof can be incorporated in oil compositions, in particular lubricating oil compositions or concentrates or fuels, e.g., automotive crankcase oils, in concentrations within the range of 0.001 to 65, in particular 0.1 to 15%w based on the weight of the total compositions.
The lubricating oils to which the additives of the invention can be added include not only mineral lubricating oils, but synthetic oils also. Synthetic hydrocarbon lubricating oils may also be employed, as well as non-hydrocarbon synthetic oils including dibasic acid esters such as di-2-ethyl hexyl sebacate, carbonate esters, phosphate esters, halogenated hydrocarbons, polysilicones, polyglycols, glycol esters such as C₁₃ oxo acid diesters of tetraethylene glycol, etc. Mixtures of these oils, in particular of mineral lubricating oils, including hydrogenated oils, and synthetic lubricating oils, can also be used.
When used in gasoline or fuel oil, e.g., diesel fuel, etc., then usually 0.001 to 0.5%w, based on the weight of the total composition of the reaction product will be used. Usually concentrates comprising e.g. 15 to 65%w of said reaction product in a hydrocarbon diluent and 85 to 35%w mineral lubricating oil, are prepared for ease of handling.
In the above compositions other additives may also be present, including dyes, pour point depressants, anti-wear, e.g., tricresyl phosphate, zinc dithiophosphates, antioxidants such as phenyl-alpha-naphthyl-amine, bis-phenols such as 4,4'-methylene bis (3,6-di-tert-butylphenol), viscosity index improvers, such as hydrogenated (co)polymers of conjugated dienes and optionally styrene, ethylene-higher olefin copolymers, polymethylacrylates, polyisobutylene, and the like as well as ashless dispersants, such as reaction products of polyisobutylene, maleic anhydride and amines and/or polyols, or other metal-containing detergents, such as overbased metal salicylates.
Reaction products of amines, formaldehyde and alkyl phenols (Mannich bases) can also be present.
The invention is further illustrated by the following Examples.

Example 1

Overbased calcium C_14-18-alkyl salicylate, having a BI of 3 (Product A), was prepared from C₁₄-₁₈-alkyl salicylic acid by means of calcium hydroxide and carbon dioxide, and was taken up in a mineral lubricating oil.
A reaction vessel (5 litre) was charged with 2500 g (2530 meq acid) of a concentrate of 67%w of the overbased calcium C₁₄-₁₈-alkyl salicylate in 33%w of the mineral lubricating oil, 80 g (2500 meq) elemental sulphur and 20 g ethylene glycol. Under stirring this mixture was heated to 125 °C and kept at that temperature for one hour. The temperature was then raised to 150 °C and kept at that temperature for one hour at a pressure of about 0.73 Bar (550 mm Hg). Then the temperature was raised to 195 °C and the pressure lowered to 0.067-0.08 Bar 50-60 mm Hg), these conditions were maintained for two hours. The reaction product was then allowed to cool to about 100 °C before filtering through filter aid, to give a dark viscous product (yield: 2500 g, S: 1.6%w (Product B). It appeared that sulphurization at a lower temperature (175 °C) resulted in some dissolved unreacted sulphur, which is inclined to precipitate on standing.
It furthermore appeared that during the sulphurization only a small amount of decarboxylation occurred (9%; acid number of starting material 1.06 and of product 0.96; acid number in meq acid/g, determined after acidification with HCI, extraction with diethyl ether, phase separation and evaporation of the solvent) (same method in the following Examples).

Example 2

2500 g of a concentrate of 50%w overbased calcium C₁₄-₁₈-alkylsalicylate (1625 meq) prepared from the alkyl salicylic acids, calcium hydroxide and carbon dioxide and having a B.I. of 7.72, in 50%w mineral lubricating oil was sulphurised with 51.3 g of elemental sulphur (1603 meq) and 13 g of ethylene glycol according to the process described in example 1. Yield: 2453 g, S: 1.2%w.
It appeared that during sulphurisation 2% decarboxylation occurred (acid number of starting material 0.79 meq/g and of product 0.77 meq/g). Example 3
250 g of a concentrate of 62%w overbased magnesium C₁₄-₁₈-alkylsalicylate (213.5 meq) having a B.I. of 7.2 in 38%w mineral lubricating oil was sulphurised with 6.58 g of elemental sulphur (205.6 meq) and 1.7 g of ethylene glycol according to the process described in example 1. Yield: 243.6 g, S:0.94%w.
It appeared that during sulphurisation 3% decarboxylation occurred (acid number of starting material 1.02 meq/g and of product 1.00 meq/g).

Comparative Experiment 1

To 97.6 g (205 meq) of neat C₁₄-₁₈ alkyl salicylic acids were added 37.9 g (1025 meq) of Ca(OH)₂ and 69.5 g of a mineral lubricating oil, resulting in a 1.0 meq/g mixture of acids. 133.2 g of this mixture (133.2 meq), 4.26 g of S (133.2 meq) and 1.0 g of ethylene glycol were heated under stirring to 125 °C and kept at that temperature for one hour. The temperature was further raised to 150 °C (1 hour, pressure: 0.73 Bar (550 mm Hg) and 195°C (2 hours, 0.067-0.08 Bar 50-60 mm Hg). The reaction mixture was cooled, diluted with n-hexane, filtered through filter aid and finally evaporated to yield a very viscous, dark material. Yield: 112.3 g, S: 1.6%.
It appeared that during the sulphurisation 20% decarboxylation occurred (acid number of starting material 1.22 meq/g and of product 0.95 meq/g).

Comparative Experiment 2

2500 g of a concentrate of 58%w overbased calcium C₁₄-₁₈-alkylsalicylate (2300 meq) having a B.I. of 1.28 in 42%w mineral lubricating oil was sulphurised with 77 g elemental sulphur (2406 meq) and 19 g of ethylene glycol according to the proces decribed in example 1. Yield: 2496 g, S: 1.3%w. It appeared that during sulphurization 28% decarboxylation occured (acid number of starting material 0.92 meq/g and of product 0.66 meq/g).

Tests

In two 15W40 mineral lubricating oils (1 and 2), containing commercial dispersant, detergent and anti-oxidant additives, the products A and B (see Example 1) were tested.
Formulation I contained Product A in an amount of 0.14%w as Ca in lubricating oil 1. Formulation II contained lubricating oil 1 and 0.14%w (as Ca) of Product B. Formulations III and IV comprised lubricating oil 2 with 0.19%w as Ca of Product A and B, respectively.
Formulations I and II were tested in the CRC L38 test (ASTM STP 509A, part IV) in which the bearing weight loss is determined. The results are represented in Table I:
It appears that use of the sulphurized product results in a reduction of the bearing weight loss.
Formulations III and IV were tested in the MS Sequence IIID engine test in which the cam and lifter wear and cleanliness performance were determined.
The results are shown in Table I
It appears that use of the sulphurized products results in a reduction of the cam and lifter wear. The cleanliness rating remained about the same.

Claims

1. Process for the preparation of sulphurized overbased metal aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylates, characterised in that an aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acid is transformed into an overbased metal salicylate having a basicity index of at least 1.5 by means of a basic metal compound and carbon dioxide, and subsequently the overbased metal salicylate is sulphurized by heating with elemental sulphur.

2. Process according to claim 1, wherein the metal is an alkaline earth metal.

3. Process according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the aliphatic hydrocarbon-substituted salicylic acid is a C_$__3o-alkyl salicylic acid.

4. Process according to any one of claims 1-3, wherein the basicity index of the overbased salicylate is at least 3.

5. Process according to any one of claims 1-4, wherein the sulphurization is carried out at least 175 °C.

6. Process according to any one of claims 1-5, wherein the molar ratio of S: substituted salicylic acid is 0.25 to 3..

7. Process according to any one of claims 1-6, wherein the product before or after sulphurization is reacted with a boron compound.

8. Oil composition, in particular lubricating oil composition or concentrate or fuel, comprising an oil and 0.001-65%w of a product obtained according to the process of claim 1.