CN111391822A - A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions - Google Patents

A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN111391822A
CN111391822A CN202010228385.2A CN202010228385A CN111391822A CN 111391822 A CN111391822 A CN 111391822A CN 202010228385 A CN202010228385 A CN 202010228385A CN 111391822 A CN111391822 A CN 111391822A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
vehicle
longitudinal
slip
tire
lateral
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Granted
Application number
CN202010228385.2A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN111391822B (en
Inventor
王萍
李梓涵
张曦月
胡云峰
陈虹
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Jilin University
Original Assignee
Jilin University
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Jilin University filed Critical Jilin University
Priority to CN202010228385.2A priority Critical patent/CN111391822B/en
Publication of CN111391822A publication Critical patent/CN111391822A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN111391822B publication Critical patent/CN111391822B/en
Active legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Classifications

    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B60VEHICLES IN GENERAL
    • B60WCONJOINT CONTROL OF VEHICLE SUB-UNITS OF DIFFERENT TYPE OR DIFFERENT FUNCTION; CONTROL SYSTEMS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR HYBRID VEHICLES; ROAD VEHICLE DRIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR PURPOSES NOT RELATED TO THE CONTROL OF A PARTICULAR SUB-UNIT
    • B60W30/00Purposes of road vehicle drive control systems not related to the control of a particular sub-unit, e.g. of systems using conjoint control of vehicle sub-units
    • B60W30/02Control of vehicle driving stability
    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B60VEHICLES IN GENERAL
    • B60WCONJOINT CONTROL OF VEHICLE SUB-UNITS OF DIFFERENT TYPE OR DIFFERENT FUNCTION; CONTROL SYSTEMS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR HYBRID VEHICLES; ROAD VEHICLE DRIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR PURPOSES NOT RELATED TO THE CONTROL OF A PARTICULAR SUB-UNIT
    • B60W50/00Details of control systems for road vehicle drive control not related to the control of a particular sub-unit, e.g. process diagnostic or vehicle driver interfaces
    • B60W50/0098Details of control systems ensuring comfort, safety or stability not otherwise provided for
    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B60VEHICLES IN GENERAL
    • B60WCONJOINT CONTROL OF VEHICLE SUB-UNITS OF DIFFERENT TYPE OR DIFFERENT FUNCTION; CONTROL SYSTEMS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR HYBRID VEHICLES; ROAD VEHICLE DRIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR PURPOSES NOT RELATED TO THE CONTROL OF A PARTICULAR SUB-UNIT
    • B60W50/00Details of control systems for road vehicle drive control not related to the control of a particular sub-unit, e.g. process diagnostic or vehicle driver interfaces
    • B60W2050/0001Details of the control system
    • B60W2050/0019Control system elements or transfer functions
    • B60W2050/0028Mathematical models, e.g. for simulation
    • B60W2050/0031Mathematical model of the vehicle
    • BPERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
    • B60VEHICLES IN GENERAL
    • B60WCONJOINT CONTROL OF VEHICLE SUB-UNITS OF DIFFERENT TYPE OR DIFFERENT FUNCTION; CONTROL SYSTEMS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR HYBRID VEHICLES; ROAD VEHICLE DRIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR PURPOSES NOT RELATED TO THE CONTROL OF A PARTICULAR SUB-UNIT
    • B60W2520/00Input parameters relating to overall vehicle dynamics

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
  • Transportation (AREA)
  • Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
  • Human Computer Interaction (AREA)
  • Steering Control In Accordance With Driving Conditions (AREA)
  • Control Of Driving Devices And Active Controlling Of Vehicle (AREA)

Abstract

本发明公开了一种极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法,首先,利用仿真软件CarSim得到四轮轮毂电机驱动电动汽车模型;其次,设计二自由度参考模型,通过二自由度参考模型推导出车辆侧向速度和横摆角速度的期望值;然后,为降低求解复杂度采用双层控制结构,上层采用NMPC控制器,以保证车辆横纵向稳定为控制目标,并考虑横纵向安全约束进行优化求解,得到虚拟控制量——轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的期望值;最后,下层根据轮胎实际的滑移率和侧偏角与上层给出的期望值之间的偏差得到附加转矩作用于轮毂电机,从而保证车辆横纵向的稳定性。

Figure 202010228385

The invention discloses a coordinated control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions. First, a four-wheel hub motor-driven electric vehicle model is obtained by using the simulation software CarSim; secondly, a two-degree-of-freedom reference model is designed, and the two-degree-of-freedom reference model is The expected values of lateral speed and yaw angular velocity of the vehicle are deduced; then, a two-layer control structure is adopted to reduce the complexity of the solution, and the upper layer adopts an NMPC controller to ensure the lateral and longitudinal stability of the vehicle as the control objective, and consider the lateral and longitudinal safety constraints for optimization Solve to get the virtual control variable - the expected value of tire slip rate and side slip angle; finally, the lower layer obtains the additional torque acting on the hub according to the deviation between the actual slip rate and side slip angle of the tire and the expected value given by the upper layer The motor ensures the stability of the vehicle in the horizontal and vertical directions.

Figure 202010228385

Description

一种极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions

技术领域technical field

本发明涉及一种极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法,更具体地说,本发明针对四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车在极限工况下横纵向运动易失稳问题,在模型预测控制框架下,设计了一种具有低计算复杂度的横纵向稳定性的协同控制方法,属于车辆安全控制技术领域。The invention relates to a coordinated control method for the lateral and longitudinal stability of an automobile under extreme working conditions. Under the present invention, a collaborative control method for lateral and longitudinal stability with low computational complexity is designed, which belongs to the technical field of vehicle safety control.

背景技术Background technique

车辆在极限驾驶工况下,极易失稳引发交通事故,此时车辆的横纵向动力学系统呈现强耦合非线性特征,而目前已有的主动安全系统往往只是关注纵向或侧向运动的稳定,没有考虑其它系统的相互影响和耦合作用,在极限工况下由于控制目标冲突、执行器干涉等原因很难发挥功能,由此需要对车辆横纵向稳定性开展协同控制研究。对于四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车,利用其车轮独立可控的特点,可以对每个车轮分别附加驱动/制动转矩,从而更好地对车辆运动状态进行控制。目前极限工况下汽车的横纵向稳定性协同控制存在以下问题:Under extreme driving conditions, the vehicle is easily unstable and causes traffic accidents. At this time, the lateral and longitudinal dynamic systems of the vehicle exhibit strong coupling and nonlinear characteristics, and the existing active safety systems often only focus on the stability of longitudinal or lateral motion. , without considering the mutual influence and coupling effect of other systems, it is difficult to function under extreme conditions due to control target conflict, actuator interference and other reasons. Therefore, it is necessary to carry out collaborative control research on vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability. For a four-wheel-wheel-drive electric vehicle, with the independent controllability of its wheels, the driving/braking torque can be added to each wheel, so as to better control the motion state of the vehicle. At present, there are the following problems in the coordinated control of lateral and longitudinal stability of vehicles under extreme working conditions:

1.评价车辆侧向稳定性的指标主要为车辆侧向速度和横摆角速度,主要体现在对其期望值的跟踪。多数传统控制算法将侧向速度的期望值简单设置为零,或只对横摆角速度进行跟踪,使得参考模型的设计不完全合理而影响控制器控制性能。1. The indicators for evaluating the lateral stability of the vehicle are mainly the lateral speed and yaw angular velocity of the vehicle, which are mainly reflected in the tracking of its expected value. Most traditional control algorithms simply set the expected value of lateral velocity to zero, or only track the yaw angular velocity, which makes the design of the reference model not completely reasonable and affects the control performance of the controller.

2.极限工况下轮胎纵向力侧向力会互相影响,纵侧向力与滑移率和侧偏角之间呈耦合非线性关系。多数传统控制算法在利用轮胎模型计算轮胎纵侧向力时,没有考虑轮胎的复合滑移特性,使得轮胎力计算不准确从而影响预测模型精度。2. Under the extreme working conditions, the longitudinal and lateral forces of the tires will affect each other, and there is a coupled nonlinear relationship between the longitudinal and lateral forces, the slip rate and the slip angle. Most of the traditional control algorithms do not consider the composite slip characteristics of the tire when using the tire model to calculate the tire longitudinal and lateral force, which makes the tire force calculation inaccurate and affects the accuracy of the prediction model.

3.轮胎滑移率作为评价车辆纵向稳定的指标,多数控制方法将轮胎滑移率作为状态变量进行跟踪,虽然可以进行控制,但这种方法动力学模型复杂,并且难以设置合理的滑移率期望值。3. The tire slip rate is used as an index to evaluate the longitudinal stability of the vehicle. Most control methods track the tire slip rate as a state variable. Although it can be controlled, the dynamic model of this method is complex and it is difficult to set a reasonable slip rate. expected value.

4.附加转矩作为直接影响车辆运动状态的控制量,多数控制方法对其计算主要是通过将求解得到的总附加转矩对每个车轮进行分配,而忽视每个车轮可能处于不同的驱动/制动状态,这样得到的附加转矩不够准确;或者根据各个轮胎的状态量对每个车轮分别设计控制器得到附加转矩,这使得控制系统结构更为复杂。4. As a control quantity that directly affects the motion state of the vehicle, most control methods calculate the additional torque by distributing the total additional torque obtained by the solution to each wheel, ignoring that each wheel may be in different driving/ Braking state, the additional torque obtained in this way is not accurate; or the additional torque is obtained by designing a controller for each wheel separately according to the state quantity of each tire, which makes the control system structure more complicated.

发明内容SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

本发明针对极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制问题,采用双层控制结构,上层利用NMPC控制器使车辆横摆角速度和侧向速度跟踪其参考信号,并抑制车辆纵向的滑动,保证车辆横纵向的稳定性,求解得到虚拟控制量为轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的期望值;下层根据轮胎实际的滑移率和侧偏角与上层给出的期望值之间的偏差,利用轮胎纵向力与滑移率、侧偏角之间的动力学关系,基于纵向力的变化计算附加转矩作用于轮毂电机,从而保证车辆横纵向的稳定性。Aiming at the problem of coordinated control of the vehicle's lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions, the invention adopts a double-layer control structure. The upper layer uses an NMPC controller to make the vehicle yaw rate and lateral speed track its reference signal, and suppress the longitudinal sliding of the vehicle to ensure that the vehicle Transverse and longitudinal stability, the virtual control variables obtained are the expected values of tire slip rate and sideslip angle; the lower layer uses the tire longitudinal force according to the deviation between the actual tire slip rate and sideslip angle and the expected value given by the upper layer. Based on the dynamic relationship between the slip rate and the slip angle, the additional torque is calculated based on the change of the longitudinal force and acts on the in-wheel motor, thereby ensuring the stability of the vehicle in the lateral and longitudinal directions.

为解决上述技术问题,本发明是采用如下技术方案实现的:In order to solve the above-mentioned technical problems, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions to realize:

一种极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法,包括以下步骤:A coordinated control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions, comprising the following steps:

步骤一、利用仿真软件CarSim得到四轮轮毂电机驱动电动汽车模型,实时提供车辆的各状态信息;Step 1. Use the simulation software CarSim to obtain a model of an electric vehicle driven by a four-wheel in-wheel motor, and provide various status information of the vehicle in real time;

步骤二、二自由度参考模型设计,得到考虑路面附着系数限制的车辆横摆角速度和车辆侧向速度的期望值,确定车辆的理想运动状态;Step 2: Designing a two-degree-of-freedom reference model to obtain the expected values of the vehicle yaw angular velocity and the vehicle lateral velocity considering the limitation of the road adhesion coefficient, and determine the ideal motion state of the vehicle;

步骤三、上层NMPC控制器设计:基于三自由度车辆动力学模型,考虑轮胎的复合滑移特性建立复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型,设计预测模型,使车辆的横摆角速度和侧向速度能够跟踪其期望值,并抑制轮胎纵向的滑移,以轮胎滑移率和侧偏角为虚拟控制量,优化求解得到的虚拟控制量作为下层控制的期望值;Step 3. Design of the upper-layer NMPC controller: Based on the three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamics model, a compound-slip LuGre tire model is established considering the compound-slip characteristics of the tire, and a prediction model is designed, so that the yaw rate and lateral speed of the vehicle can track the tire. the expected value, and suppress the longitudinal slip of the tire, take the tire slip rate and the slip angle as the virtual control variables, and the virtual control variables obtained by the optimization solution are used as the expected value of the lower layer control;

步骤四、下层附加转矩计算:根据轮胎实际的滑移率和侧偏角与上层给出的期望值之间的偏差量,利用轮胎纵向力与滑移率、侧偏角之间的动力学关系,基于纵向力的变化计算轮毂电机的附加转矩,发送给电动汽车作为输入量。Step 4. Calculation of the additional torque of the lower layer: According to the deviation between the actual slip rate and slip angle of the tire and the expected value given by the upper layer, the dynamic relationship between the tire longitudinal force and the slip rate and the slip angle is used. , which calculates the additional torque of the in-wheel motor based on the change of the longitudinal force and sends it to the electric vehicle as an input.

与现有技术相比本发明的有益效果是:Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are:

1.本发明采用基于二自由度车辆模型推导出期望的车辆侧向速度和横摆角速度信号,在设计NMPC控制器时对二者同时进行跟踪。不同于传统的将侧向速度的期望值简单设置为零,或只对横摆角速度进行跟踪,而是将二者的理想轨迹分别进行设计,保证更好的车辆侧向稳定性。1. The present invention derives the desired lateral speed and yaw rate signals of the vehicle based on the two-degree-of-freedom vehicle model, and simultaneously tracks both when designing the NMPC controller. Instead of simply setting the expected value of the lateral velocity to zero, or only tracking the yaw angular velocity, the ideal trajectories of the two are designed separately to ensure better lateral stability of the vehicle.

2.多数传统控制算法没有考虑极限工况下轮胎纵向力侧向力之间的互相影响,忽略了纵侧向力与滑移率和侧偏角之间的耦合非线性关系。本发明在对轮胎纵侧向力进行拟合时,采用复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型,考虑轮胎的复合滑移特性,可以更好地计算极限工况下的轮胎力,从而提高了预测模型的精度。2. Most traditional control algorithms do not consider the interaction between longitudinal and lateral tire forces under extreme conditions, and ignore the coupled nonlinear relationship between longitudinal and lateral forces, slip rate and slip angle. When fitting the longitudinal and lateral force of the tire, the present invention adopts the compound slip LuGre tire model and considers the compound slip characteristic of the tire to better calculate the tire force under extreme working conditions, thereby improving the accuracy of the prediction model .

3.多数传统控制算法将轮胎滑移率作为状态变量进行跟踪以保证车辆纵向稳定,本发明采用双层控制结构,降低了预测模型的阶数,将轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的期望值作为NMPC控制器求解得到的虚拟控制量,对它们能够进行控制的同时降低了计算复杂度,提高了求解速度。3. Most traditional control algorithms track the tire slip rate as a state variable to ensure the longitudinal stability of the vehicle. The present invention adopts a double-layer control structure, which reduces the order of the prediction model, and takes the tire slip rate and the expected value of the side slip angle as the expected value. The virtual control variables obtained by the NMPC controller can control them while reducing the computational complexity and improving the solution speed.

4.本发明对附加转矩的计算是通过对期望的轮胎滑移率和侧偏角与实际值的偏差量进行转化得到的,相比于对每个车轮分别设计控制器得到附加转矩的传统控制算法,本发明的计算方式更能体现滑移率和侧偏角的变化对附加转矩的影响,更准确的计算附加转矩,并避免了多控制器的冗余。4. The calculation of the additional torque in the present invention is obtained by transforming the deviation between the expected tire slip rate and the slip angle and the actual value, compared with the calculation of the additional torque obtained by designing a controller for each wheel separately. Compared with the traditional control algorithm, the calculation method of the present invention can better reflect the influence of the change of the slip rate and the slip angle on the additional torque, calculate the additional torque more accurately, and avoid the redundancy of multiple controllers.

附图说明Description of drawings

下面结合附图对本发明的具体实施方式作进一步的说明,本发明的这些和/或其他方面将更清晰明白。其中:The specific embodiments of the present invention will be further described below with reference to the accompanying drawings, and these and/or other aspects of the present invention will be more clearly understood. in:

图1是本发明所述的四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法流程框图;Fig. 1 is the flow chart of the coordinated control method for lateral and longitudinal stability of a four-wheel hub-driven electric vehicle according to the present invention;

图2是本发明所述的车辆动力学模型的示意图;Fig. 2 is the schematic diagram of the vehicle dynamics model of the present invention;

图3是本发明所述的轮胎纵向力验证图,其中实线为利用复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型计算的纵向力,虚线代表CarSim端口输出的轮胎纵向力,纵坐标单位为N,横坐标为时间,单位为s;Fig. 3 is the tire longitudinal force verification diagram of the present invention, wherein the solid line is the longitudinal force calculated by using the compound slip LuGre tire model, the dotted line represents the tire longitudinal force output by the CarSim port, the ordinate unit is N, and the abscissa is time , the unit is s;

图4是本发明所述的轮胎侧向力验证图,其中实线为利用复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型计算的侧向力,虚线代表CarSim端口输出的轮胎侧向力,纵坐标单位为N,横坐标为时间,单位为s;Fig. 4 is the tire lateral force verification diagram of the present invention, wherein the solid line is the lateral force calculated by using the composite slip LuGre tire model, the dotted line represents the tire lateral force output by the CarSim port, the ordinate unit is N, the horizontal axis The coordinates are time, and the unit is s;

图5是本发明所述的双移线工况下车辆纵向速度仿真图,纵坐标单位为m/s,横坐标为时间,单位为s;Fig. 5 is a simulation diagram of the longitudinal speed of the vehicle under the double line shifting condition of the present invention, the unit of the ordinate is m/s, the unit of the abscissa is time, and the unit is s;

图6是本发明所述的双移线工况下横摆角速度仿真图,其中点划线、实线、虚线分别代表无控制器作用、有控制器作用,以及期望的横摆角速度,纵坐标单位为rad/s,横坐标为时间,单位为s;6 is a simulation diagram of the yaw angular velocity under the double line shifting condition of the present invention, wherein the dotted line, the solid line, and the dashed line represent respectively no controller function, controller function, and expected yaw angular velocity, ordinate The unit is rad/s, the abscissa is time, and the unit is s;

图7是本发明所述的双移线工况下车辆侧向速度仿真图,其中点划线、实线、虚线分别代表无控制器作用、有控制器作用,以及期望的侧向速度,纵坐标单位为m/s,横坐标为时间,单位为s;Fig. 7 is a simulation diagram of the lateral speed of the vehicle under the double line shifting condition of the present invention, wherein the dotted line, the solid line, and the dashed line respectively represent no controller function, a controller function, and the desired lateral speed, and the vertical The coordinate unit is m/s, the abscissa is time, and the unit is s;

图8是本发明所述的双移线工况下附加力矩仿真图,纵坐标单位为Nm,横坐标为时间,单位为s;Fig. 8 is a simulation diagram of additional torque under the double line shifting condition of the present invention, the unit of ordinate is Nm, the unit of abscissa is time, and the unit is s;

图9是本发明所述的双移线工况下轮胎滑移率仿真图,其中虚线为上层NMPC控制器计算得到的滑移率期望值,实线为实际的滑移率,横坐标为时间,单位为s。9 is a simulation diagram of the tire slip rate under the double-line shifting condition of the present invention, wherein the dotted line is the expected value of the slip rate calculated by the upper-layer NMPC controller, the solid line is the actual slip rate, and the abscissa is the time, The unit is s.

具体实施方式Detailed ways

为详细说明本发明的技术内容、构造特点、实现目的等,下面结合附图对本发明进行全面解释。In order to describe in detail the technical content, structural features, realization purpose, etc. of the present invention, the present invention will be fully explained below with reference to the accompanying drawings.

本发明协同控制方法流程如图1所示,图中上层NMPC控制器的输入是期望横摆角速度、期望车辆侧向速度和被控对象输出测量值,输出分别为四个轮胎期望的纵向滑移率和侧偏角;下层附加转矩的计算根据上层得到的期望值与被控对象输出的实际值,得到轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的偏差量,利用轮胎纵向力与滑移率、侧偏角之间的动力学关系,基于纵向力的变化计算附加电机转矩;上层NMPC控制器和下层附加转矩的计算模块均是在MATLAB/Simulink中搭建的;被控对象是利用CarSim构造的四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车模型。The flow of the collaborative control method of the present invention is shown in Figure 1. The input of the upper-layer NMPC controller in the figure is the expected yaw angular velocity, the expected lateral velocity of the vehicle, and the output measurement value of the controlled object, and the outputs are the expected longitudinal slip of the four tires respectively. The calculation of the additional torque of the lower layer is based on the expected value obtained by the upper layer and the actual value output by the controlled object, and the deviation of the tire slip rate and sideslip angle is obtained. The dynamic relationship between the angles, the additional motor torque is calculated based on the change of the longitudinal force; the upper-layer NMPC controller and the lower-layer additional torque calculation module are built in MATLAB/Simulink; the controlled object is a four-dimensional structure constructed by CarSim Wheel hub drive electric car model.

本发明的控制目标是,控制系统根据实时反馈信号,利用上层控制器得到的期望轮胎滑移率、侧偏角与实际值之间的偏差,考虑轮胎纵向力与滑移率、侧偏角之间的动力学关系,基于纵向力的变化得到作用于四个轮毂电机的附加转矩,来控制车辆的横纵向稳定,使实际横摆角速度和实际车辆侧向速度跟踪分别跟踪其期望值,抑制轮胎的纵向滑移率,并对车辆滑移率和后轮侧偏角进行限制约束限制,保证车辆的行驶安全性。The control objective of the present invention is that, according to the real-time feedback signal, the control system uses the deviation between the expected tire slip rate, the side slip angle and the actual value obtained by the upper controller, and considers the relationship between the tire longitudinal force and the slip rate and the side slip angle. Based on the change of the longitudinal force, the additional torque acting on the four in-wheel motors is obtained to control the lateral and longitudinal stability of the vehicle, so that the actual yaw angular velocity and the actual lateral velocity of the vehicle track their expected values respectively, restraining the tires. The longitudinal slip rate of the vehicle is limited, and the vehicle slip rate and rear wheel slip angle are limited and restricted to ensure the driving safety of the vehicle.

本发明提供了一套基于以上运行原理和运行过程的联合仿真模型,其搭建以及运行过程如下:The present invention provides a set of co-simulation models based on the above operating principles and operating processes, and the building and operating processes are as follows:

1、软件选择1. Software selection

该控制系统的控制器和被控对象的仿真模型分别通过软件MATLAB/Simulink和CarSim进行搭建,软件版本分别为MATLAB R2016a和CarSim 2016.1,仿真步长为0.001s。其中CarSim软件是一个商用的专门针对车辆动力学的仿真软件,它在本发明中的主要作用是提供高保真的车辆动力学模型,在仿真实验中代替真实的四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车作为控制方法的实施对象,并提供极限工况的仿真环境;MATLAB/Simulink则是用于控制器的仿真模型搭建,即通过Simulink编程来完成该控制系统中控制器的运算。The simulation models of the controller and the controlled object of the control system are built by the software MATLAB/Simulink and CarSim respectively. The software versions are MATLAB R2016a and CarSim 2016.1 respectively, and the simulation step size is 0.001s. Among them, CarSim software is a commercial simulation software specially aimed at vehicle dynamics. Its main function in the present invention is to provide a high-fidelity vehicle dynamics model and replace the real four-wheel hub-driven electric vehicle as a control method in the simulation experiment. MATLAB/Simulink is used to build the simulation model of the controller, that is, the operation of the controller in the control system is completed through Simulink programming.

2、联合仿真设置2. Co-simulation settings

要实现MATLAB/Simulink和CarSim的联合仿真,首先要把CarSim的工作路径设为指定的Simulink Model,然后将在CarSim中把设置好的车辆模型添加到Simulink中,运行Simulink从而实现两者的联合仿真与通信。如果对CarSim中的模型结构或者参数设置进行了修改,则需要重新发送。To realize the co-simulation of MATLAB/Simulink and CarSim, first set the working path of CarSim to the specified Simulink Model, then add the set vehicle model in CarSim to Simulink, and run Simulink to realize the co-simulation of the two with communication. If the model structure or parameter settings in CarSim are modified, it needs to be resent.

3、联合仿真软件中四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车模型搭建3. Construction of four-wheel hub-driven electric vehicle model in co-simulation software

CarSim电动汽车整车模型主要由车身、传动系、转向系、制动系、轮胎、悬架、空气动力学、工况配置等系统构成。选用四轮驱动车辆,其动力装置是四个轮毂电机,其附加转矩输入选用IMP_MYUSM_L1、IMP_MYUSM_L2、IMP_MYUSM_R1、IMP_MYUSM_R2,电动汽车参数如表1所示。CarSim electric vehicle model is mainly composed of body, drive train, steering system, braking system, tires, suspension, aerodynamics, working condition configuration and other systems. A four-wheel drive vehicle is selected, and its power unit is four in-wheel motors, and its additional torque input selects IMP_MYUSM_L1, IMP_MYUSM_L2, IMP_MYUSM_R1, and IMP_MYUSM_R2. The parameters of the electric vehicle are shown in Table 1.

表1电动汽车参数表Table 1 Electric vehicle parameter table

Figure BDA0002428434130000041
Figure BDA0002428434130000041

Figure BDA0002428434130000051
Figure BDA0002428434130000051

4、本发明极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性控制原理4. The control principle of vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions of the present invention

本发明的被控对象是四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车,控制目标是提高其在极限工况下的横纵向稳定性。控制方法的主要设计过程描述如下:首先,利用仿真软件CarSim得到四轮轮毂电机驱动电动汽车模型;其次,设计二自由度参考模型,通过二自由度参考模型推导出车辆侧向速度和横摆角速度的期望值;然后,为降低求解复杂度采用双层控制结构,上层采用NMPC控制器,以保证车辆横纵向稳定为控制目标,并考虑横纵向安全约束进行优化求解,得到虚拟控制量——轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的期望值;最后,下层根据轮胎实际的滑移率和侧偏角与上层给出的期望值之间的偏差得到附加转矩作用于轮毂电机,从而保证车辆横纵向的稳定性。The controlled object of the present invention is a four-wheel hub-driven electric vehicle, and the control objective is to improve its lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions. The main design process of the control method is described as follows: First, the four-wheel in-wheel motor-driven electric vehicle model is obtained by using the simulation software CarSim; secondly, the two-degree-of-freedom reference model is designed, and the vehicle lateral speed and yaw angular velocity are derived from the two-degree-of-freedom reference model. Then, in order to reduce the complexity of the solution, a double-layer control structure is adopted, and the upper layer adopts an NMPC controller to ensure the lateral and longitudinal stability of the vehicle as the control goal, and consider the lateral and longitudinal safety constraints to optimize the solution to obtain a virtual control variable - tire slippage The expected value of slip rate and slip angle; finally, the lower layer obtains additional torque to act on the in-wheel motor according to the deviation between the actual slip rate and slip angle of the tire and the expected value given by the upper layer, so as to ensure the stability of the vehicle in the lateral and longitudinal directions .

以下介绍本发明控制方法的具体步骤:The specific steps of the control method of the present invention are introduced below:

一种极限工况下汽车横纵向稳定性协同控制方法,包括以下步骤:A coordinated control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions, comprising the following steps:

步骤一、利用仿真软件CarSim得到四轮轮毂电机驱动电动汽车模型:四轮轮毂电机驱动电动汽车模型模拟真实的被控对象,主要作用是能够实时提供车辆的各状态信息,并且能够以电机附加转矩作为输入量来改变车辆运动状态。Step 1. Use the simulation software CarSim to obtain the four-wheel in-wheel motor-driven electric vehicle model: The four-wheel in-wheel motor-driven electric vehicle model simulates the real controlled object. The moment is used as the input quantity to change the vehicle motion state.

步骤二、二自由度参考模型设计:得到考虑路面附着系数限制的车辆横摆角速度和车辆侧向速度的期望值,确定车辆的理想运动状态。Step 2: Design of a two-degree-of-freedom reference model: obtain the expected values of the vehicle yaw angular velocity and the vehicle lateral velocity considering the limitation of the road adhesion coefficient, and determine the ideal motion state of the vehicle.

为了得到车辆理想的横摆及侧向运动状态,建立了二自由度参考模型,它是一个忽略了轮胎力非线性特性的线性车辆模型。其方程如下:In order to obtain the ideal yaw and lateral motion states of the vehicle, a two-degree-of-freedom reference model is established, which is a linear vehicle model that ignores the nonlinear characteristics of tire forces. Its equation is as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000052
Figure BDA0002428434130000052

其中,β为车辆质心侧偏角,γ为横摆角速度,δ是驾驶员给出的方向盘转角,Vx代表车辆纵向速度。将该模型得到的瞬态响应作为期望,根据频率响应分析,可以得到由δ到质心侧偏角和横摆角速度的期望响应β*和γ*Among them, β is the sideslip angle of the center of mass of the vehicle, γ is the yaw rate, δ is the steering wheel angle given by the driver, and V x represents the longitudinal speed of the vehicle. Taking the transient response obtained by this model as the expectation, according to the frequency response analysis, the expected responses β * and γ * from δ to the center of mass slip angle and yaw rate can be obtained:

Figure BDA0002428434130000061
Figure BDA0002428434130000061

其中,Kβ,Kγ分别代表质心侧偏角稳态增益及横摆角速度稳态增益,τβγ分别为两式的微分系数,ωn表示系统的振荡频率,ξ表示阻尼系数。它们的计算公式如下:Among them, K β , K γ represent the steady-state gain of the center of mass slip angle and the steady-state gain of the yaw rate, respectively, τ β , τ γ are the differential coefficients of the two formulas, respectively, ω n represents the oscillation frequency of the system, and ξ represents the damping coefficient. Their calculation formulas are as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000062
Figure BDA0002428434130000062

Figure BDA0002428434130000063
Figure BDA0002428434130000063

式中,L=Lf+Lr代表前轴到后轴的距离,

Figure BDA0002428434130000064
为车辆系统稳定数。而期望的质心侧偏角β*和横摆角速度γ*都会受到有关路面附着系数的限制,它们的上限值分别为:In the formula, L=L f +L r represents the distance from the front axle to the rear axle,
Figure BDA0002428434130000064
is the vehicle system stability number. The expected center of mass slip angle β * and yaw rate γ * will be limited by the relevant road adhesion coefficient, and their upper limits are:

Figure BDA0002428434130000065
Figure BDA0002428434130000065

Figure BDA0002428434130000066
Figure BDA0002428434130000066

其中,μ代表路面附着系数,重力系数g=9.8m/s2。于是可得到参考质心侧偏角和参考横摆角速度如下:Among them, μ represents the road adhesion coefficient, and the gravity coefficient g=9.8m/s 2 . Then the reference centroid sideslip angle and reference yaw rate can be obtained as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000067
Figure BDA0002428434130000067

在质心侧偏角较小时,其值可看作是车辆侧向速度与纵向速度的比值,故根据βref可得到侧向速度的参考值Vyref如下:When the center of mass slip angle is small, its value can be regarded as the ratio of the lateral speed of the vehicle to the longitudinal speed, so the reference value V yref of the lateral speed can be obtained according to β ref as follows:

Vyref=sgn(δ)Vx·min{|β*|,βlim} (6)V yref =sgn(δ)V x ·min{|β * |,β lim } (6)

步骤三、上层NMPC控制器设计:基于三自由度车辆动力学模型,考虑轮胎的复合滑移特性建立复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型,设计预测模型,使车辆的横摆角速度和侧向速度能够跟踪其期望值,并抑制轮胎纵向的滑移,以轮胎滑移率和侧偏角为虚拟控制量,优化求解得到的虚拟控制量作为下层控制的期望值。Step 3. Design of the upper-layer NMPC controller: Based on the three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamics model, a compound-slip LuGre tire model is established considering the compound-slip characteristics of the tire, and a prediction model is designed, so that the yaw rate and lateral speed of the vehicle can track the tire. The expected value is obtained, and the longitudinal slip of the tire is suppressed. The tire slip rate and the slip angle are used as virtual control variables, and the virtual control variables obtained by the optimization solution are used as the expected value of the lower layer control.

①三自由度车辆动力学模型①Three degrees of freedom vehicle dynamics model

本发明所述的车辆动力学模型示意图如图2所示,考虑车辆的纵向,侧向及横摆运动,得到三自由度车辆动力学模型:The schematic diagram of the vehicle dynamics model of the present invention is shown in Figure 2, considering the longitudinal, lateral and yaw motions of the vehicle, the three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamics model is obtained:

Figure BDA0002428434130000071
Figure BDA0002428434130000071

其中,Vy为车辆侧向速度,Fx和Fy分别代表轮胎的纵向力和侧向力,下标fl,fr,rl,rr分别代表左前、右前、左后和右后车轮。轮胎的侧偏角α的计算如下:Among them, V y is the lateral speed of the vehicle, F x and F y represent the longitudinal force and lateral force of the tire, respectively, and the subscripts fl, fr, rl, rr represent the front left, front right, rear left, and rear right wheels, respectively. The tire slip angle α is calculated as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000072
Figure BDA0002428434130000072

轮胎的纵向滑移率

Figure BDA0002428434130000073
其中ω代表车轮转速。Longitudinal slip rate of tires
Figure BDA0002428434130000073
where ω represents the wheel speed.

②轮胎模型②Tire model

在极限工况下,轮胎的纵向力侧向力之间互相影响,轮胎纵向力不只是通过纵向滑移率计算得到,同理侧向力也不只与轮胎侧偏角有关,因此轮胎的纵向力侧向力都与滑移率和侧偏角呈耦合非线性关系。于是,利用复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型来描述轮胎的纵向力和侧向力。Under the extreme conditions, the longitudinal force and lateral force of the tire affect each other. The longitudinal force of the tire is not only calculated by the longitudinal slip rate. Similarly, the lateral force is not only related to the tire slip angle. Both the thrust forces are coupled nonlinearly with slip rate and slip angle. Therefore, the composite slip LuGre tire model is used to describe the longitudinal and lateral forces of the tire.

当车辆处于稳态时,复合滑移LuGre轮胎模型对纵向力Fx和侧向力Fy的描述如下:When the vehicle is in steady state, the composite slip LuGre tire model describes the longitudinal force F x and the lateral force F y as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000081
Figure BDA0002428434130000081

其中,σ0x和σ0y分别代表纵向、侧向刚度系数,σ2x和σ2y分别代表纵向、侧向粘滞阻尼,κx和κy分别为纵向、侧向载荷分布系数;

Figure BDA0002428434130000082
为合成滑移率;g(sres)是关于滑移率和侧偏角的斯特里贝克方程,可近似计算为g(sres)≈C1-C2λ-C3α,其中C1=1,C2=0.64,C3=0.1;Fz为轮胎的垂向载荷。Among them, σ 0x and σ 0y represent longitudinal and lateral stiffness coefficients, respectively, σ 2x and σ 2y represent longitudinal and lateral viscous damping, respectively, and κ x and κ y are longitudinal and lateral load distribution coefficients, respectively;
Figure BDA0002428434130000082
is the synthetic slip rate; g(s res ) is the Strybeck equation for slip rate and slip angle, which can be approximately calculated as g(s res )≈C 1 -C 2 λ-C 3 α, where C 1 = 1, C 2 =0.64, C 3 =0.1; F z is the vertical load of the tire.

根据公式(9),对该轮胎模型计算得到的纵向、侧向力与CarSim在同一低附着双移线工况下端口输出的纵向、侧向力进行对比如图3、图4所示,从图3、图4中可以看出,该轮胎模型可以较准确地计算出在极限工况下轮胎的纵向、侧向力,也可描述出转向时轮胎的非线性特性。According to formula (9), the longitudinal and lateral forces calculated by the tire model are compared with the longitudinal and lateral forces output by the CarSim port under the same low-adhesion double-line shift condition, as shown in Figures 3 and 4. It can be seen from Figure 3 and Figure 4 that the tire model can more accurately calculate the longitudinal and lateral forces of the tire under extreme conditions, and can also describe the nonlinear characteristics of the tire during steering.

③预测模型③Prediction model

由三自由度车辆动力学模型(7)与轮胎模型(9)可得到面向控制器设计的预测模型,其状态量x由车辆纵向速度、侧向速度和横摆角速度组成,将它们进行归一化处理,即

Figure BDA0002428434130000083
其中Vxmax,Vymaxmax分别为车辆纵向速度,侧向速度,横摆角速度的上限值,Vymax=Vx·βlim,γmax=γlim;控制量u为轮胎期望的滑移率和侧偏角,由于进行了归一化,求解得到的虚拟控制量
Figure BDA0002428434130000084
其中λmaxfmaxrmax分别为车轮滑移率、前轮侧偏角和后轮侧偏角的上限值。综上预测方程可描述为From the three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamics model (7) and the tire model (9), a prediction model for controller design can be obtained, and its state quantity x is composed of vehicle longitudinal velocity, lateral velocity and yaw angular velocity. processing, i.e.
Figure BDA0002428434130000083
Wherein V xmax , V ymax , γ max are the upper limit values of vehicle longitudinal speed, lateral speed and yaw angular velocity respectively, V ymax =V x ·β lim , γ maxlim ; the control variable u is the expected slippage of the tire The shift rate and the slip angle, due to the normalization, the virtual control quantity obtained by the solution
Figure BDA0002428434130000084
Where λ max , α fmax , α rmax are the upper limit values of wheel slip ratio, front wheel slip angle and rear wheel slip angle, respectively. In summary, the prediction equation can be described as

Figure BDA0002428434130000085
Figure BDA0002428434130000085

④目标函数及约束④ Objective function and constraints

为了保证车辆在极限工况下的侧向稳定性,NMPC控制器的主要控制目标为横摆角速度和侧向速度对其参考值的跟踪,于是有以下控制目标In order to ensure the lateral stability of the vehicle under extreme working conditions, the main control objective of the NMPC controller is the tracking of the yaw rate and lateral velocity to its reference value, so there are the following control objectives

Figure BDA0002428434130000091
Figure BDA0002428434130000091

其中,tk代表当前时刻,tp为预测时域,x2(t)是侧向速度的预测输出,x3(t)是横摆角速度的预测输出。另外对于控制量,定义

Figure BDA0002428434130000092
为了保证车辆的纵向稳定,抑制车轮纵向滑动保证驾驶安全,设计下面控制目标:Among them, t k represents the current moment, t p is the prediction time domain, x 2 (t) is the predicted output of the lateral velocity, and x 3 (t) is the predicted output of the yaw rate. In addition, for the control quantity, define
Figure BDA0002428434130000092
In order to ensure the longitudinal stability of the vehicle and suppress the longitudinal sliding of the wheels to ensure driving safety, the following control objectives are designed:

Figure BDA0002428434130000093
Figure BDA0002428434130000093

车辆在极限工况行驶过程中应受到安全性约束,对于车辆纵向安全,对轮胎纵向滑移率约束如下:Vehicles should be subject to safety constraints during driving under extreme conditions. For vehicle longitudinal safety, the longitudinal tire slip rate constraints are as follows:

ux(t)∈[-I4×1 I4×1] (13)u x (t)∈[-I 4×1 I 4×1 ] (13)

定义

Figure BDA0002428434130000094
根据式(8)可计算后轮侧偏角,已知质心侧偏角
Figure BDA0002428434130000095
后轮侧偏角可通过下式计算:definition
Figure BDA0002428434130000094
According to formula (8), the rear wheel slip angle can be calculated, and the center of mass slip angle is known
Figure BDA0002428434130000095
The rear wheel slip angle can be calculated by the following formula:

Figure BDA0002428434130000096
Figure BDA0002428434130000096

于是有

Figure BDA0002428434130000097
β和γ都是评价车辆侧向稳定性的指标,为了更好地保证车辆侧向安全,对后轮侧偏角进行约束如下:So there is
Figure BDA0002428434130000097
β and γ are both indicators for evaluating the lateral stability of the vehicle. In order to better ensure the lateral safety of the vehicle, the rear wheel slip angle is constrained as follows:

uy(t)∈[-I2×1 I2×1] (15)u y (t)∈[-I 2×1 I 2×1 ] (15)

综上得到目标函数如下:In summary, the objective function is obtained as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000098
Figure BDA0002428434130000098

其中,Γvx为权重系数。利用GRAMPC工具箱优化求解上述目标函数,得到虚拟控制量为期望的轮胎的滑移率和侧偏角。Among them, Γ v , Γ x are weight coefficients. Using the GRAMPC toolbox to optimize and solve the above objective function, the virtual control variables are obtained as the expected slip rate and slip angle of the tire.

步骤四、下层附加转矩计算:根据轮胎实际的滑移率和侧偏角与上层给出的期望值之间的偏差量,利用轮胎纵向力与滑移率、侧偏角之间的动力学关系,基于纵向力的变化计算轮毂电机的附加转矩,发送给电动汽车作为输入量。Step 4. Calculation of the additional torque of the lower layer: According to the deviation between the actual slip rate and slip angle of the tire and the expected value given by the upper layer, the dynamic relationship between the tire longitudinal force and the slip rate and the slip angle is used. , which calculates the additional torque of the in-wheel motor based on the change of the longitudinal force and sends it to the electric vehicle as an input.

由上层NMPC控制器优化求解得到的虚拟控制量需要转化为可实际作用于车辆的输入量,将其变换为作用于每个轮毂电机的附加转矩。根据之前对极限工况下轮胎力的分析可知,轮胎的纵向力的计算与滑移率和侧偏角均有关,故轮胎纵向力的变化ΔFx也与滑移率的变化Δλ和侧偏角的变化Δα有关,它们之间的关系可表示为:The virtual control quantity obtained by the optimization solution of the upper-layer NMPC controller needs to be converted into the input quantity that can actually act on the vehicle, and it is transformed into the additional torque acting on each in-wheel motor. According to the previous analysis of tire force under extreme conditions, the calculation of tire longitudinal force is related to slip rate and sideslip angle, so the change of tire longitudinal force ΔF x is also related to the change of slip rate Δλ and sideslip angle The change Δα is related to the relationship between them can be expressed as:

Figure BDA0002428434130000101
Figure BDA0002428434130000101

根据LuGre复合滑移轮胎模型(9),可得到轮胎纵向力对滑移率和侧偏角的偏导如下:According to the LuGre composite-slip tire model (9), the deflection of the tire longitudinal force to the slip rate and slip angle can be obtained as follows:

Figure BDA0002428434130000102
Figure BDA0002428434130000102

式中我们定义

Figure BDA0002428434130000103
where we define
Figure BDA0002428434130000103

上层NMPC控制器得到的期望的滑移率

Figure BDA0002428434130000104
和侧偏角
Figure BDA0002428434130000105
与车辆实际的滑移率λ和侧偏角α之间存在的偏差量,可看作为滑移率和侧偏角在想要满足控制器控制目标及约束时所产生的变化,于是有下列关系:Desired slip rate obtained by the upper-level NMPC controller
Figure BDA0002428434130000104
and slip angle
Figure BDA0002428434130000105
The deviation from the actual slip rate λ and the sideslip angle α of the vehicle can be regarded as the change of the slip rate and sideslip angle when trying to meet the control objectives and constraints of the controller, so there is the following relationship :

Figure BDA0002428434130000106
Figure BDA0002428434130000106

根据式(14)将偏差量转换为所需的纵向力变化ΔFx,然后计算得到作用于每个轮毂电机上的附加力矩ΔT如下,并考虑执行器的饱和对其进行限制:According to formula (14), the deviation is converted into the required longitudinal force change ΔF x , and then the additional torque ΔT acting on each in-wheel motor is calculated as follows, and the saturation of the actuator is considered to limit it:

ΔT=sgn(ΔFx)min{|ΔFxRe|,Tmax} (20)ΔT=sgn(ΔF x )min{|ΔF x Re |,T max } (20)

式中Tmax为可作用于轮毂电机的附加转矩的上限值。where T max is the upper limit of the additional torque that can act on the in-wheel motor.

以下通过实施例仿真实验验证本发明控制方法的有效性:The validity of the control method of the present invention is verified by the following simulation experiments:

为了验证本发明所述的控制方法的有效性,在CarSim和MATLAB/Simulink联合仿真环境下设计了仿真实验。设置仿真测试工况为双移线工况,路面摩擦系数μ=0.35,车速保持在60km·h-1附近如图5所示,设置采样时间为5ms,预测时域tp=10,仿真实验中使用的参数和权重系数见表2。In order to verify the effectiveness of the control method described in the present invention, a simulation experiment is designed under the co-simulation environment of CarSim and MATLAB/Simulink. The simulation test condition is set as the double-line shift condition, the road friction coefficient μ=0.35, the vehicle speed is kept around 60km·h -1 as shown in Figure 5, the sampling time is set to 5ms, the prediction time domain tp =10, the simulation experiment The parameters and weight coefficients used in Table 2.

表2仿真实验参数表Table 2 Simulation experiment parameter table

符号symbol 定义definition 数值/单位value/unit V<sub>xmax</sub>V<sub>xmax</sub> 车辆纵向速度上限值Vehicle longitudinal speed upper limit 120/km·h<sup>-1</sup>120/km·h<sup>-1</sup> λ<sub>max</sub>λ<sub>max</sub> 轮胎滑移率上限值Upper limit of tire slip ratio 0.10.1 α<sub>fmax</sub>α<sub>fmax</sub> 前轮侧偏角上限值Front wheel slip angle upper limit 0.4/rad0.4/rad α<sub>rmax</sub>α<sub>rmax</sub> 轮胎侧偏角上限值Tire slip angle upper limit 0.1/rad0.1/rad T<sub>max</sub>T<sub>max</sub> 轮毂电机附加转矩上限值In-wheel motor additional torque upper limit 800/N·m<sup>-1</sup>800/N m<sup>-1</sup> Γ<sub>v</sub>Γ<sub>v</sub> NMPC中侧向速度跟踪权重Lateral velocity tracking weights in NMPC 0.050.05 Γ<sub>u</sub>Γ<sub>u</sub> NMPC中轮胎滑移率抑制权重Tire Slip Suppression Weights in NMPC 0.250.25

图6和图7分别为车辆在低附着双移线工况下横摆角速度和侧向速度的仿真曲线,可以看出相较于无控制器介入的系统,在NMPC控制器作用下,车辆的横摆角速度可以跟踪其期望值,侧向速度也有效被抑制,从而保证了车辆的侧向稳定性。Figures 6 and 7 are the simulation curves of the yaw angular velocity and the lateral velocity of the vehicle under the low-adhesion double lane-shifting condition, respectively. It can be seen that compared with the system without the intervention of the controller, under the action of the NMPC controller, the vehicle's The yaw rate can track its desired value, and the lateral velocity is effectively suppressed, thereby ensuring the lateral stability of the vehicle.

下层利用轮胎滑移率和侧偏角的偏差量计算得到的附加转矩如图8所示,在前1s内,由于车辆处于加速状态,为了保证车速,需要对四个轮毂电机附加驱动力矩,在速度保持平稳后,附加转矩趋近于零,在4s时车辆开始转弯,本发明所述的控制结构可以为四个轮毂电机附加合理的驱动/制动转矩以保证车辆稳定,并考虑执行器的饱和。The additional torque calculated by the lower layer using the deviation of the tire slip rate and the slip angle is shown in Figure 8. In the first 1s, since the vehicle is in the acceleration state, in order to ensure the vehicle speed, it is necessary to add additional driving torque to the four in-wheel motors. After the speed remains stable, the additional torque tends to zero, and the vehicle starts to turn at 4s. The control structure of the present invention can add a reasonable driving/braking torque to the four in-wheel motors to ensure the stability of the vehicle, and consider Saturation of the actuator.

轮胎的实际滑移率以及由上层NMPC控制器求得的期望滑移率如图9所示,在前1s时,四个轮胎的滑移率在车辆加速、保持平稳的过程中也会逐渐减小趋近于零,在整个双移线过程中,轮胎的滑移率都能够被限制在很小的范围内,车辆在低附着路面上的纵向滑动被有效抑制,从而保证了车辆的纵向稳定性。通过仿真实验的验证,本发明所述的横纵向稳定性协同控制方法可以有效地提高四轮轮毂驱动电动汽车在极限工况下的横纵向稳定性,保证驾驶安全。The actual slip rate of the tires and the expected slip rate obtained by the upper-layer NMPC controller are shown in Figure 9. In the first 1s, the slip rates of the four tires will gradually decrease as the vehicle accelerates and remains stable. Small approaching zero, the tire slip rate can be limited to a small range during the entire double line shifting process, and the longitudinal sliding of the vehicle on the low-adhesion road surface is effectively suppressed, thereby ensuring the longitudinal stability of the vehicle sex. Through the verification of simulation experiments, the lateral and longitudinal stability cooperative control method of the present invention can effectively improve the lateral and longitudinal stability of the four-wheel hub-driven electric vehicle under extreme working conditions, and ensure driving safety.

Claims (4)

1. A method for cooperatively controlling the transverse and longitudinal stability of an automobile under a limit working condition is characterized by comprising the following steps:
the method comprises the following steps of firstly, obtaining a four-wheel hub motor driven electric automobile model by using simulation software CarSim, and providing each state information of a vehicle in real time;
designing a two-degree-of-freedom reference model to obtain expected values of the yaw velocity and the lateral velocity of the vehicle, which are limited by considering the road adhesion coefficient, and determining an ideal motion state of the vehicle;
thirdly, designing an upper-layer NMPC controller, namely establishing a composite slip L uGre tire model by considering the composite slip characteristic of a tire based on a three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamic model, designing a prediction model, enabling the yaw velocity and the lateral velocity of the vehicle to track the expected values of the yaw velocity and the lateral velocity of the vehicle, inhibiting the longitudinal slip of the tire, and taking the tire slip rate and the slip angle as virtual control quantities, and optimally solving the obtained virtual control quantity as the expected value of lower-layer control;
step four, calculating the lower additional torque: according to the actual slip ratio and deviation amount between the slip angle and the expected value given by the upper layer, the dynamic relation between the longitudinal force of the tire, the slip ratio and the slip angle is utilized, the additional torque of the hub motor is calculated based on the change of the longitudinal force, and the additional torque is sent to the electric automobile as the input amount.
2. The cooperative control method for the transverse and longitudinal stability of the automobile under the limit condition as claimed in claim 1, wherein in the second step, a two-degree-of-freedom reference model is designed, and the equation is as follows:
Figure FDA0002428434120000011
Figure FDA0002428434120000012
where β is the vehicle centroid slip angle, γ is the yaw rate, is the driver-given steering wheel angle, VxRepresenting the vehicle longitudinal speed;
taking the transient response obtained by the son's finite reference model as the expectation, the expected response β from the centroid yaw angle and yaw rate is obtained*And gamma*
Figure FDA0002428434120000013
Figure FDA0002428434120000014
Wherein, Kβ,KγRespectively representing the steady-state gain of the centroid slip angle and the steady-state gain of the yaw angular velocity, tauβγDifferential coefficients, ω, of two types respectivelynRepresenting the oscillation frequency of the system, ξ representing the damping coefficient;
desired centroid slip angle β*And yaw rate γ*Are limited by the road adhesion coefficient, and their upper limits are:
Figure FDA0002428434120000021
Figure FDA0002428434120000022
wherein mu represents the road adhesion coefficient, and g is 9.8m/s2(ii) a The reference centroid slip angle and the reference yaw rate are obtained as follows:
βref=sgn()min{|β*|,βlim}
γref=sgn()min{|γ*|,γlim}
when the centroid slip angle is small, the value can be considered as the ratio of the vehicle lateral velocity to the longitudinal velocity, so according to βrefThe reference value V of the lateral speed can be obtainedyrefThe following were used:
Vyref=sgn()Vx·min{|β*|,βlim}。
3. the cooperative control method for the transverse and longitudinal stability of the automobile under the limit condition as claimed in claim 1, wherein the third step comprises the following steps:
① the vehicle dynamics model is obtained by considering the longitudinal, lateral and yaw movement of the vehicle:
Figure FDA0002428434120000023
Figure FDA0002428434120000024
Figure FDA0002428434120000025
wherein, VyAs the lateral speed of the vehicle, FxAnd FyThe subscripts fl, fr, rl, rr represent the left front, right front, left rear and right rear wheels, respectively;
longitudinal slip ratio of tire
Figure FDA0002428434120000031
Wherein ω represents wheel speed;
② tire longitudinal force F using compound slip L uGre tire modelxAnd a lateral force FyThe description of (A) is as follows:
Figure FDA0002428434120000032
Figure FDA0002428434120000033
wherein σ0xAnd σ0yRespectively representing longitudinal and lateral stiffness coefficients, σ2xAnd σ2yRespectively representing longitudinal and lateral viscous damping, kxAnd kappayLongitudinal and lateral load distribution coefficients respectively;
Figure FDA0002428434120000034
the synthetic slip ratio; g(s)res) Is a Sterbek equation for slip ratio and slip angle, and can be approximated as g(s)res)≈C1-C2λ-C3α, wherein C1=1,C2=0.64,C3=0.1;FzIs the vertical load of the tire;
③ A predictive model for controller design is obtained from the three-degree-of-freedom vehicle dynamics model and the tire model:
Figure FDA0002428434120000035
the state quantity x is composed of the longitudinal speed, the lateral speed and the yaw rate of the vehicle, and the state quantity x is subjected to normalization processing, namely:
Figure FDA0002428434120000036
wherein Vxmax,VymaxmaxUpper limit values V of the longitudinal speed, lateral speed and yaw rate of the vehicleymax=Vx·βlim,γmax=γlim(ii) a The control quantity u is a virtual control quantity obtained by solving the slip rate and the slip angle expected by the tire
Figure FDA0002428434120000037
Wherein λmaxfmaxrmaxThe upper limit values of the wheel slip rate, the front wheel side deflection angle and the rear wheel side deflection angle are respectively;
④ objective function and constraints:
the NMPC controller mainly controls the tracking of the yaw velocity and the lateral velocity on the reference value thereof, and the control targets are as follows:
Figure FDA0002428434120000038
Figure FDA0002428434120000039
wherein, tkRepresenting the current time, tpTo predict the time domain, x2(t) is the predicted output of lateral velocity, x3(t) is the predicted output of yaw rate;
for the controlled quantity, define
Figure FDA0002428434120000041
Designing a control target:
Figure FDA0002428434120000042
the tire longitudinal slip ratio is constrained as follows:
ux(t)∈[-I4×1I4×1]
definition of
Figure FDA0002428434120000043
Centroid slip angle
Figure FDA0002428434120000044
The rear wheel side slip angle is calculated by the following equation:
Figure FDA0002428434120000045
then there are
Figure FDA0002428434120000046
The rear wheel side slip angle is constrained as follows:
uy(t)∈[-I2×1I2×1]
the objective function is obtained as follows:
Figure FDA0002428434120000047
s.t.
Figure FDA0002428434120000048
ux(t)∈[-I4×1I4×1]
uy(t)∈[-I2×1I2×1]
wherein,v,xis a weight coefficient;
and optimally solving the objective function to obtain the slip rate and the slip angle of the tire with the virtual control quantity as expected.
4. The method for cooperatively controlling the transverse and longitudinal stability of the automobile under the limit condition of claim 1, wherein the step four of lower-layer additional torque comprises the following steps of:
change of tire longitudinal force Δ FxThe relationship between the change in slip ratio Δ λ and the change in slip angle Δ α can be expressed as:
Figure FDA0002428434120000049
the partial derivatives of the tire longitudinal force on the slip ratio and the slip angle are as follows:
Figure FDA0002428434120000051
Figure FDA0002428434120000052
in the formula (II)
Figure FDA0002428434120000053
Desired slip ratio by upper NMPC controller
Figure FDA0002428434120000054
And slip angle
Figure FDA0002428434120000055
The following relationship is present with respect to the actual slip ratio λ and slip angle α of the vehicle:
Figure FDA0002428434120000056
Figure FDA0002428434120000057
converting the deviation into the desired longitudinal force change Δ FxThen, the additional torque Δ T acting on each in-wheel motor is calculated as follows:
ΔT=sgn(ΔFx)min{|ΔFxRe|,Tmax}
in the formula, TmaxIs an upper limit value of the additional torque acting on the in-wheel motor.
CN202010228385.2A 2020-03-27 2020-03-27 A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions Active CN111391822B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202010228385.2A CN111391822B (en) 2020-03-27 2020-03-27 A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202010228385.2A CN111391822B (en) 2020-03-27 2020-03-27 A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN111391822A true CN111391822A (en) 2020-07-10
CN111391822B CN111391822B (en) 2022-06-24

Family

ID=71424944

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN202010228385.2A Active CN111391822B (en) 2020-03-27 2020-03-27 A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN111391822B (en)

Cited By (11)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN111890951A (en) * 2020-08-07 2020-11-06 吉林大学 Intelligent electric vehicle trajectory tracking and motion control method
CN111942399A (en) * 2020-07-17 2020-11-17 东风汽车集团有限公司 Vehicle speed estimation method and system based on unscented Kalman filtering
CN111965977A (en) * 2020-08-06 2020-11-20 长春工业大学 Automobile stability control method based on tire equal backup capability
CN111959500A (en) * 2020-08-07 2020-11-20 长春工业大学 Automobile path tracking performance improving method based on tire force distribution
CN112277929A (en) * 2020-11-05 2021-01-29 中国第一汽车股份有限公司 Vehicle wheel slip rate control method and device, vehicle and storage medium
CN113221257A (en) * 2021-06-11 2021-08-06 吉林大学 Vehicle transverse and longitudinal stability control method under extreme working condition considering control area
CN113753054A (en) * 2021-09-23 2021-12-07 扬州亚星客车股份有限公司 Vehicle line control chassis control method and device, electronic equipment and medium
CN113815650A (en) * 2021-10-29 2021-12-21 吉林大学 A vehicle drift control method based on backstepping method
CN114312749A (en) * 2021-11-24 2022-04-12 中国煤炭科工集团太原研究院有限公司 Anti-skid yaw torque control method and device for multi-point independent wheel side driving mining vehicle
CN114722493A (en) * 2022-03-25 2022-07-08 江铃汽车股份有限公司 Simulation method and system based on ADAMS vehicle double-line-shifting test
CN115649135A (en) * 2022-10-12 2023-01-31 吉林大学 Transverse and longitudinal cooperative control method for emergency braking of split-road automobile

Citations (22)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US20030093190A1 (en) * 2001-11-15 2003-05-15 Honda Giken Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha Method of estimating quantities that represent state of vehicle
EP1433682A1 (en) * 2002-12-27 2004-06-30 Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha Vehicular brake system and method of controlling same brake system
CA2633315A1 (en) * 2005-12-27 2007-07-05 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Vehicle control device
CA2631433A1 (en) * 2005-12-27 2007-07-05 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Controller of vehicle
CN101574979A (en) * 2009-06-11 2009-11-11 重庆大学 Electric motor car differential steeling control method based on slip rate control
WO2011039039A1 (en) * 2009-10-01 2011-04-07 Robert Bosch Gmbh Method for operating a drive device and drive device
US20130030601A1 (en) * 2011-07-28 2013-01-31 Hyundai Motor Company Control system and method of vehicle using in-wheel motor
CN103124663A (en) * 2010-08-30 2013-05-29 E-Aam传动系统公司 Method of controlling a torque vectoring mechanism and torque vectoring system
EP2729337A1 (en) * 2011-07-05 2014-05-14 WABCO GmbH Device and method for controlling the driving dynamics of a vehicle and vehicle having such a device
CN104029677A (en) * 2014-05-26 2014-09-10 北京理工大学 Control method of distributed drive electric cars
CN104554255A (en) * 2013-10-22 2015-04-29 沈阳工业大学 Dynamic decoupling method for active safety integrated control system of four-wheel drive electric automobile chassis
CN104670204A (en) * 2013-11-28 2015-06-03 现代摩比斯株式会社 Wheel driving system using acceleration sensor, and vehicle with the said system
EP2927065A1 (en) * 2014-04-03 2015-10-07 The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company Road surface friction and surface type estimation system and method
CN107000755A (en) * 2014-08-04 2017-08-01 模道威有限责任公司 Method and corresponding virtual-sensor for the variable of estimation influence dynamics of vehicle
CN107512262A (en) * 2017-08-14 2017-12-26 吉林大学 A kind of vehicle stability control system tire force distribution method for performing during driving limited space
CN108107731A (en) * 2017-12-18 2018-06-01 长春工业大学 A kind of Vehicle Stability Control method based on Tire nonlinearity characteristic
CN108437978A (en) * 2018-05-14 2018-08-24 武汉理工大学 Four wheel hub electricity drive vehicle running surface automatic identification and stability integrated control method
CN108482363A (en) * 2018-04-09 2018-09-04 吉林大学 vehicle yaw stability prediction model control method
CN108944866A (en) * 2018-07-06 2018-12-07 长春工业大学 It is a kind of to improve the adaptive model predictive control algorithm turned to braking Collaborative Control
CN109204317A (en) * 2018-07-24 2019-01-15 吉林大学 Wheel hub drives electric car longitudinal and transverse and vertical force integrated control optimization method
CN110194064A (en) * 2019-06-26 2019-09-03 重庆大学 Bi-motor integration pure electric vehicle passenger car power allocation strategy optimization method
CN110228462A (en) * 2019-05-17 2019-09-13 吉林大学 Four-wheel hub motor driven electric vehicle Yaw stability control method

Patent Citations (22)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US20030093190A1 (en) * 2001-11-15 2003-05-15 Honda Giken Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha Method of estimating quantities that represent state of vehicle
EP1433682A1 (en) * 2002-12-27 2004-06-30 Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha Vehicular brake system and method of controlling same brake system
CA2633315A1 (en) * 2005-12-27 2007-07-05 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Vehicle control device
CA2631433A1 (en) * 2005-12-27 2007-07-05 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Controller of vehicle
CN101574979A (en) * 2009-06-11 2009-11-11 重庆大学 Electric motor car differential steeling control method based on slip rate control
WO2011039039A1 (en) * 2009-10-01 2011-04-07 Robert Bosch Gmbh Method for operating a drive device and drive device
CN103124663A (en) * 2010-08-30 2013-05-29 E-Aam传动系统公司 Method of controlling a torque vectoring mechanism and torque vectoring system
EP2729337A1 (en) * 2011-07-05 2014-05-14 WABCO GmbH Device and method for controlling the driving dynamics of a vehicle and vehicle having such a device
US20130030601A1 (en) * 2011-07-28 2013-01-31 Hyundai Motor Company Control system and method of vehicle using in-wheel motor
CN104554255A (en) * 2013-10-22 2015-04-29 沈阳工业大学 Dynamic decoupling method for active safety integrated control system of four-wheel drive electric automobile chassis
CN104670204A (en) * 2013-11-28 2015-06-03 现代摩比斯株式会社 Wheel driving system using acceleration sensor, and vehicle with the said system
EP2927065A1 (en) * 2014-04-03 2015-10-07 The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company Road surface friction and surface type estimation system and method
CN104029677A (en) * 2014-05-26 2014-09-10 北京理工大学 Control method of distributed drive electric cars
CN107000755A (en) * 2014-08-04 2017-08-01 模道威有限责任公司 Method and corresponding virtual-sensor for the variable of estimation influence dynamics of vehicle
CN107512262A (en) * 2017-08-14 2017-12-26 吉林大学 A kind of vehicle stability control system tire force distribution method for performing during driving limited space
CN108107731A (en) * 2017-12-18 2018-06-01 长春工业大学 A kind of Vehicle Stability Control method based on Tire nonlinearity characteristic
CN108482363A (en) * 2018-04-09 2018-09-04 吉林大学 vehicle yaw stability prediction model control method
CN108437978A (en) * 2018-05-14 2018-08-24 武汉理工大学 Four wheel hub electricity drive vehicle running surface automatic identification and stability integrated control method
CN108944866A (en) * 2018-07-06 2018-12-07 长春工业大学 It is a kind of to improve the adaptive model predictive control algorithm turned to braking Collaborative Control
CN109204317A (en) * 2018-07-24 2019-01-15 吉林大学 Wheel hub drives electric car longitudinal and transverse and vertical force integrated control optimization method
CN110228462A (en) * 2019-05-17 2019-09-13 吉林大学 Four-wheel hub motor driven electric vehicle Yaw stability control method
CN110194064A (en) * 2019-06-26 2019-09-03 重庆大学 Bi-motor integration pure electric vehicle passenger car power allocation strategy optimization method

Non-Patent Citations (6)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
RONGRONG WANG;HUI ZHANG;JUNMIN WANG: "Linear Parameter-Varying Controller Design for Four-Wheel Independently Actuated Electric Ground Vehicles With Active Steering Systems", 《IEEE/IEE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY (IEL)》 *
刘秋生等: "4WID轮毂电机式电动汽车横摆稳定性滑模控制研究", 《广西大学学报(自然科学版)》 *
刘震涛等: "基于车辆稳定性的轮胎力优化分配研究", 《机电工程》 *
李梓涵等: "基于复合滑移轮胎模型的车辆横纵协同优化控制", 《同济大学学报(自然科学版)》 *
童树林: "四轮轮毂电机驱动电动车稳定性控制研究", 《中国优秀硕士学位论文全文数据库电子期刊工程科技Ⅱ辑》 *
谭洪亮等: "轮毂电机驱动汽车直接横摆力矩控制研究", 《车辆与动力技术》 *

Cited By (17)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN111942399A (en) * 2020-07-17 2020-11-17 东风汽车集团有限公司 Vehicle speed estimation method and system based on unscented Kalman filtering
CN111965977A (en) * 2020-08-06 2020-11-20 长春工业大学 Automobile stability control method based on tire equal backup capability
CN111965977B (en) * 2020-08-06 2023-01-10 长春工业大学 Automobile stability control method based on equal backup capacity of tire
CN111890951B (en) * 2020-08-07 2022-08-05 吉林大学 Intelligent electric vehicle trajectory tracking and motion control method
CN111959500A (en) * 2020-08-07 2020-11-20 长春工业大学 Automobile path tracking performance improving method based on tire force distribution
CN111890951A (en) * 2020-08-07 2020-11-06 吉林大学 Intelligent electric vehicle trajectory tracking and motion control method
CN112277929A (en) * 2020-11-05 2021-01-29 中国第一汽车股份有限公司 Vehicle wheel slip rate control method and device, vehicle and storage medium
CN113221257B (en) * 2021-06-11 2022-05-31 吉林大学 Vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability control method under extreme conditions considering control area
CN113221257A (en) * 2021-06-11 2021-08-06 吉林大学 Vehicle transverse and longitudinal stability control method under extreme working condition considering control area
CN113753054A (en) * 2021-09-23 2021-12-07 扬州亚星客车股份有限公司 Vehicle line control chassis control method and device, electronic equipment and medium
CN113815650A (en) * 2021-10-29 2021-12-21 吉林大学 A vehicle drift control method based on backstepping method
CN113815650B (en) * 2021-10-29 2023-12-29 吉林大学 Vehicle drift control method based on back stepping method
CN114312749A (en) * 2021-11-24 2022-04-12 中国煤炭科工集团太原研究院有限公司 Anti-skid yaw torque control method and device for multi-point independent wheel side driving mining vehicle
CN114312749B (en) * 2021-11-24 2024-05-07 中国煤炭科工集团太原研究院有限公司 Multi-point independent wheel edge driving mining vehicle anti-skid yaw torque control method and equipment
CN114722493A (en) * 2022-03-25 2022-07-08 江铃汽车股份有限公司 Simulation method and system based on ADAMS vehicle double-line-shifting test
CN115649135A (en) * 2022-10-12 2023-01-31 吉林大学 Transverse and longitudinal cooperative control method for emergency braking of split-road automobile
CN115649135B (en) * 2022-10-12 2025-01-03 吉林大学 Transverse and longitudinal cooperative control method for emergency braking of split road automobile

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN111391822B (en) 2022-06-24

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN111391822B (en) A collaborative control method for vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability under extreme working conditions
CN110228462B (en) Yaw stability control method for four-wheel hub motor-driven electric automobile
CN109204317B (en) Wheel hub drive electric automobile longitudinal, transverse and vertical force integrated control optimization method
CN107791773B (en) Whole vehicle active suspension system vibration control method based on specified performance function
CN103921786B (en) A kind of nonlinear model predictive control method of electric vehicle process of regenerative braking
CN108482363B (en) Vehicle yaw stability prediction model control method
Zha et al. A survey of intelligent driving vehicle trajectory tracking based on vehicle dynamics
CN111890951A (en) Intelligent electric vehicle trajectory tracking and motion control method
CN107253453A (en) A kind of distributed electric automobile lateral stability adaptive control system and method
CN110422052B (en) Distributed drive electric vehicle stability and energy-saving control system
CN113221257B (en) Vehicle lateral and longitudinal stability control method under extreme conditions considering control area
CN109606378A (en) A Vehicle Driving State Estimation Method for Non-Gaussian Noise Environment
CN113002528A (en) Four-wheel hub motor driven electric vehicle stability coordination control method and system
CN113147422A (en) Direct yaw moment control system and method for distributed driving electric automobile
CN112026533A (en) Traction control method for four-wheel independent drive electric automobile under limit working condition
CN109094644A (en) Active rear steer and direct yaw moment control method under limiting condition
Li et al. Adaptive sliding mode control of lateral stability of four wheel hub electric vehicles
CN112346337A (en) Vehicle stability control method based on active rear wheel steering under extreme conditions
Raji et al. A tricycle model to accurately control an autonomous racecar with locked differential
CN112622875A (en) Lower-layer torque distribution control method and comprehensive control method for four-hub motor driven vehicle
CN111444577A (en) A kind of automatic avoidance method of electric bus
CN115214697A (en) Adaptive second-order sliding mode control intelligent automobile transverse control method
CN114889446A (en) An off-road vehicle two-direction torque vector distribution method, device and storage medium
CN113830094A (en) An adaptive fusion and compensation method for vehicle centroid sideslip angle considering multi-source input information
CN113602278B (en) Distributed model predictive path tracking control method for four-wheel independent drive electric vehicles

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
GR01 Patent grant
GR01 Patent grant