CN108335004A - A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed - Google Patents

A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN108335004A
CN108335004A CN201710801950.8A CN201710801950A CN108335004A CN 108335004 A CN108335004 A CN 108335004A CN 201710801950 A CN201710801950 A CN 201710801950A CN 108335004 A CN108335004 A CN 108335004A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
wind
reliability
failure
state
string
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN201710801950.8A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
刘利民
刘俊勇
谢曼
张里
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology
Original Assignee
Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology filed Critical Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology
Priority to CN201710801950.8A priority Critical patent/CN108335004A/en
Publication of CN108335004A publication Critical patent/CN108335004A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06QINFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
    • G06Q10/00Administration; Management
    • G06Q10/06Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling
    • G06Q10/063Operations research, analysis or management
    • G06Q10/0639Performance analysis of employees; Performance analysis of enterprise or organisation operations
    • H02J3/386
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02EREDUCTION OF GREENHOUSE GAS [GHG] EMISSIONS, RELATED TO ENERGY GENERATION, TRANSMISSION OR DISTRIBUTION
    • Y02E10/00Energy generation through renewable energy sources
    • Y02E10/70Wind energy
    • Y02E10/76Power conversion electric or electronic aspects
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02PCLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THE PRODUCTION OR PROCESSING OF GOODS
    • Y02P90/00Enabling technologies with a potential contribution to greenhouse gas [GHG] emissions mitigation
    • Y02P90/80Management or planning
    • Y02P90/82Energy audits or management systems therefor
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y04INFORMATION OR COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES HAVING AN IMPACT ON OTHER TECHNOLOGY AREAS
    • Y04SSYSTEMS INTEGRATING TECHNOLOGIES RELATED TO POWER NETWORK OPERATION, COMMUNICATION OR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES FOR IMPROVING THE ELECTRICAL POWER GENERATION, TRANSMISSION, DISTRIBUTION, MANAGEMENT OR USAGE, i.e. SMART GRIDS
    • Y04S10/00Systems supporting electrical power generation, transmission or distribution
    • Y04S10/50Systems or methods supporting the power network operation or management, involving a certain degree of interaction with the load-side end user applications

Abstract

The invention discloses a kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed, the method for evaluating reliability include:N platform Wind turbines are connected into one " string ", while m string unit parallel connections access an inverter, the wind power generating set for each group being connected into " string " is equivalent to the generating set of an identical capacity;Multistate reliability is analyzed according to wind-resources feature and wind powered generator system fault characteristic;The division of reliability state, establishes reliability index system, finally by sample calculation analysis, verifies the division of reliability state and the correctness of index system, assesses the reliability of wind generator system actual motion.The present invention proposes desired failure and is obstructed the equal method of electric energy, system reliability state is divided, and establish reliability index system, finally use currently running data, the correctness for demonstrating model and index system shows that the system can accurately assess the reliability of wind generator system.

Description

A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed
Technical field
The invention belongs to wind generator system method for evaluating reliability fields, more particularly to one kind is based on electric energy phase of being obstructed Deng wind generator system method for evaluating reliability.
Background technology
Wind generating technology is grown rapidly, and due to the decline of its cost of electricity-generating, installed capacity is significantly increased, and is allowed to have become For one of the generation technology for developing most ripe in regenerative resource.Due to the intermittence of wind-resources, the spy of fluctuation and randomness Point so that bring uncertain factor to power grid after wind power integration, therefore assess reliability containing wind generator system to seem non- It is often important.
Have some scholars both at home and abroad from different perspectives to study the reliability assessment of wind generator system.Have Problem of System Reliability after literature research wind-electricity integration, to system reserve capacity after selective analysis wind power integration power grid Demand;Also document establishes wind power plant reliability model and wake effect model, can to electric system for research wind power plant Influence and determining wind power plant confidence level by property lay the first stone;Other documents simulate actual wind speed with probability sampling method, The random output power of wind-driven generator is calculated, finally use that sequential Monte-Carlo simulation method analyzes wind-power electricity generation can By property;Also wind power plant reliability model is combined by document with composite power systems, to the generating and transmitting system containing wind power plant Carry out reliability assessment.
Invention content
The purpose of the present invention is to provide a kind of wind generator system reliability evaluation side equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed Method, it is intended to the characteristics of solving the intermittence of wind-resources, fluctuation and randomness so that brought not to power grid after wind power integration Determining factor assesses the inapt problem of reliability containing wind generator system.
The invention is realized in this way a kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed, This approach includes the following steps:
N platform Wind turbines are connected into one " string ", while m string unit parallel connections access an inverter, K is arranged in inverter Platform, K platform inverter parallels access on busbar, in the case where maintaining identical reliability standard, the wind-force that connects into " string " by each group Generating set is equivalent to the generating set of an identical capacity;
Multistate reliability is analyzed according to wind-resources feature and wind powered generator system fault characteristic;
The division of reliability state:According to wind-resources and unit failure feature by the reliability state of wind generator system Divide a variety of situations;
Establish reliability index system:According to the division of reliability state wind-force is corresponded to from time, output, system aspects Generation System Reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in the characteristic of each state, and then reflects system performance;
It finally uses currently running data, by sample calculation analysis, verifies division and the index system of reliability state Correctness assesses the reliability of wind generator system actual motion.
Further, the wind powered generator system fault characteristic multistate reliability, which is analyzed, includes:
A, single wind generator group failure calculates the equivalent outage rate of separate unit Wind turbines, separate unit using series connection formula The stoppage in transit probability of Wind turbines is:
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 1, which is located at the end of string, passes through Cable L is connected with other wind turbines, and outage rate is
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of Wind turbines;For the outage rate of cable L;For separate unit wind turbine The element of groupStoppage in transit probability;
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 2, that is, connect front and back 2 Fans, wind turbine it Between by on-load switch and cable series connection, be obstructed the constant principle of electric power according to desired failure, take the probability of each operating status with Itself divided by " equivalent capacity " are obtained equivalent fault probability, i.e., by the sum of products of output power
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of n-1 typhoon power generator group cascaded structures;For n platform wind power generating sets The equivalent outage rate of cascaded structure, byIterative calculation obtains, as n=1,It can be calculated by formula (2);
B, according to series-parallel system Calculation of Reliability formula, the probability of malfunction after m string Wind turbines parallel connections can be obtainedFor:
After the series-parallel Wind turbines of m " string " are connected with inverter, the probability of malfunction of wind-powered electricity generation-inverter group is obtained For:
C, wind generator system failure is divided into complete system failure and components of system as directed failure:
K groups wind turbine-inverter group parallel power generating system complete failure probabilityFor:
Components of system as directed failure includes:Wind-driven generator string formation failure and fault of converter;
Wind-driven generator string formation probability of malfunction obeys bi-distribution, probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
Fault of converter probabilityIt is calculated as follows:
Components of system as directed probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
Further, a variety of situations of the division of the reliability state include:
Operating status in full:When wind speed is very fast, the output of wind generator system reaches 60% of installed capacity or more, The operating status of such system is classified as operating status in full, using the 60% of installed capacity as delimitation standard;
Resource constraint derating operating status:It is influenced by wind speed factor, the output level of wind generator system is less than 60% The system mode of installed capacity is all classified as resource constraint derating operating status;
Failure derating operating status:It causes wind generator system part to contribute since equipment component failure is out of service to damage Mistake state;
Failure stoppage in transit state:Forced outage occurs for wind generator system or plan repair stoppage in transit causes wind-power electricity generation system The state of the whole output losses of system;
The too fast stoppage in transit state of calm or wind speed:System is less than incision wind velocity or more than cut-out wind speed since wind speed is in It spends and is in the state stopped transport.
Further, the incision wind velocity and cut-out wind speed degree
Further, the division according to reliability state is corresponding in terms of time index, output index, system index Wind generator system reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in time index in the characteristic of each state and is:
Run time FRH in full:System is in the cumulative time of operating status in full;
Resource constraint derating run time RDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to resource constraint;
Failure derating run time FDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to partial fault;Failure Idle time FOH:System occurs complete failure and causes the cumulative time stopped transport, and the failure idle time FOH is by FOH= PHQCIt calculates;
The too fast idle time NH of calm or wind speed (not use hour):System is under the too fast state of calm or wind speed Cumulative time;
Annual utilization hours UH:Power generation under the conditions of system generated energy conversion to this all installation oepration at full load is small When number;
Derating run time DH:System is in the cumulative time of derating operating status, DH=FDH+RDH;
Run time RH:System cumulative time in operating status, RH=FRH+DH;
Idle time OH:System is in the cumulative time of stoppage in transit state, OH=FOH+NH;
Cycle time PH:Year is 8760h.
Further, the sample calculation analysis includes:System trouble analysis and indicator-specific statistics and calculating;
The indicator-specific statistics and calculating:
The definition that a variety of situations of division of the force data according to reliability state will actually be gone out carries out statistic of classification, calculates And analyze time index, output index, the system index established in reliability index system.
Further, the wind generator system includes unit, the m that the n platform separate unit Wind turbines being serially connected are constituted String unit, inverter and busbar;The m string units parallel connection accesses an inverter, and K platforms, K platform inversions is arranged in inverter Device parallel connection accesses busbar.System total installation of generating capacity is 30MW, and the distance between adjacent two Wind turbines is 500m, 5 typhoon motors Group one " string " of composition accesses inverter, shares 3 groups of wind-driven generator string formations.
Further, the separate unit Wind turbines include wind-driven generator, lv contactor, tower inner cable, fan outlet Box type transformer, medium voltage breaker, on-load switch are simultaneously sequentially connected.
Further, the wind-resources feature is:When wind speed is less than incision wind speed, wind speed is equal to incision wind speed or specified wind Speed and cut-out wind speed, wind speed are more than rated wind speed and are less than cut-out wind speed.
The present invention has studied the influence to wind generator system reliability, this hair based on unit failure and abundant resource degree Bright detailed analysis wind generator system structure failure feature, desirably failure be obstructed electric energy equal method by wind turbine Group " string " is equivalent to the generator of 1 identical capacity, and establishes the system mode for considering unit failure and resource constraint, together When by time, output, index system, wind generator system reliability is assessed;Sample calculation analysis shows to be based on The reliability model of unit failure and resource constraint can reflect real system reliability of operation
The present invention mainly on the basis of existing research, analyze first relationship that wind speed is contributed with Wind turbines and Wind generator system design feature, it is proposed that it is expected that failure is obstructed the equal method of electric energy, sent out according to wind-resources situation and wind-force The characteristic of electric system unit failure has divided system reliability state, and establishes reliability index system, finally uses existing Operation data demonstrates the correctness of model and index system, to assess wind generator system;
In each state of wind generator system of the present invention, complete failure idle time is minimum;Idle time is about 1200h, is accounted for Annual 13.7%;Run time illustrates local wind-resources compared with horn of plenty far more than idle time;Run time in full is only The 13% of whole service time is accounted for, derating run time accounts for run time overwhelming majority ratio up to 87%, illustrates local wind money Source fluctuation is larger;Annual utilization hours are only 1882h, and it is relatively low to reflect wind energy resources utilization ratio;
Fully equivalent output accounts for about the 68.8% of installed capacity in the present invention, and the equivalent output of derating accounts for caused by resource 11%, the equivalent output of derating caused by failure accounts for 41.9%, illustrate the limitation of resource on the output of wind generator system influence compared with Greatly.The equivalent output of system only accounts for the 21.5% of installed capacity, in system year maximum output 24.485MW, accounts for installed capacity 81.6%;
Present system only considers that the design availability of failure stoppage in transit situation reaches 99.5%, and operating factor reaches 86.3%, illustrate that the availability of wind generator system is higher;The operation ratio of unit failure reaches 42.59%, and which reflects wind-force The probability of malfunction of generating set and inverter is higher, wherein with the larger practical feelings of possibility that Wind turbines break down Condition, therefore, failure derating operation probability can be reduced by improving the reliability of component, improve reliability.Year generating equipment utilization rate It is 21.48%, exposure 24.89%, the limitation for reflecting wind energy resources causes system to be reduced using the efficiency of the energy, such as Fruit is using variable speed HAWT group or uses active wind flow intelligence control system, then can effectively improve wind power plant exposure Rate further increases system reliability.
Description of the drawings
Fig. 1 is the wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed provided in an embodiment of the present invention Flow chart;
Fig. 2 is Wind turbines output power curve provided in an embodiment of the present invention;
Fig. 3 is wind generator system basic boom figure provided in an embodiment of the present invention;
Fig. 4 is single wind generator group schematic diagram provided in an embodiment of the present invention;
In figure:1, wind-driven generator;2, lv contactor;3, tower inner cable;4, fan outlet box type transformer;5、 Medium voltage breaker;6, on-load switch.
Fig. 5 be on-load switch number provided in an embodiment of the present invention be 1 when Wind turbines connection figure;
Fig. 6 be on-load switch number provided in an embodiment of the present invention be 2 when Wind turbines connection figure;
Fig. 7 is that time index provided in an embodiment of the present invention carries out division figure.
Specific implementation mode
In order to make the purpose , technical scheme and advantage of the present invention be clearer, with reference to embodiments, to this hair It is bright to be further elaborated.It should be appreciated that the specific embodiments described herein are merely illustrative of the present invention, not For limiting the present invention.
Below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiment is further described the application principle of the present invention.
A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed, this approach includes the following steps:
S101:N platform Wind turbines are connected into one " string ", while m string unit parallel connections access an inverter, inverter K platforms are set, and K platform inverter parallels access on busbar, and in the case where maintaining identical reliability standard, each group is connected into " string " Wind power generating set be equivalent to the generating set of an identical capacity;
S102:Multistate reliability is analyzed according to wind-resources feature and wind powered generator system fault characteristic;
S103:The division of reliability state:According to wind-resources and unit failure feature by the reliability of wind generator system The a variety of situations of state demarcation;
S104:Establish reliability index system:It is corresponded to from time, output, system aspects according to the division of reliability state Wind generator system reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in the characteristic of each state, and then reflects system performance;
S105:Division and the index of reliability state are finally verified by sample calculation analysis with currently running data The correctness of system assesses the reliability of wind generator system actual motion.
The wind powered generator system fault characteristic multistate reliability is analyzed:
A, single wind generator group failure calculates the equivalent outage rate of separate unit Wind turbines, separate unit using series connection formula The stoppage in transit probability of Wind turbines is:
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 1, which is located at the end of string, passes through Cable L is connected with other wind turbines, and outage rate is
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of Wind turbines;For the outage rate of cable L;For separate unit wind turbine The element of groupStoppage in transit probability;
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 2, that is, connect front and back 2 Fans, wind turbine it Between by on-load switch and cable series connection, be obstructed the constant principle of electric power according to desired failure, take the probability of each operating status with Itself divided by " equivalent capacity " are obtained equivalent fault probability, i.e., by the sum of products of output power
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of n-1 typhoon power generator group cascaded structures;For n platform wind power generating sets The equivalent outage rate of cascaded structure, byIterative calculation obtains, as n=1,It can be calculated by formula (2);
B, according to series-parallel system Calculation of Reliability formula, the probability of malfunction after m string Wind turbines parallel connections can be obtainedFor:
After the series-parallel Wind turbines of m " string " are connected with inverter, the probability of malfunction of wind-powered electricity generation-inverter group is obtained For:
C, wind generator system failure is divided into complete system failure and components of system as directed failure:
K groups wind turbine-inverter group parallel power generating system complete failure probabilityFor:
Components of system as directed failure includes:Wind-driven generator string formation failure and fault of converter;
Wind-driven generator string formation probability of malfunction obeys bi-distribution, probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
Fault of converter probabilityIt is calculated as follows:
Components of system as directed probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
A variety of situations of the division of the reliability state include:
Operating status in full:When wind speed is very fast, the output of wind generator system reaches 60% of installed capacity or more, The operating status of such system is classified as operating status in full, using the 60% of installed capacity as delimitation standard;
Resource constraint derating operating status:It is influenced by wind speed factor, the output level of wind generator system is less than 60% The system mode of installed capacity is all classified as resource constraint derating operating status;
Failure derating operating status:It causes wind generator system part to contribute since equipment component failure is out of service to damage Mistake state;
Failure stoppage in transit state:Forced outage occurs for wind generator system or plan repair stoppage in transit causes wind-power electricity generation system The state of the whole output losses of system;
The too fast stoppage in transit state of calm or wind speed:System is less than incision wind velocity or more than cut-out wind speed since wind speed is in It spends and is in the state stopped transport.
The incision wind velocity and cut-out wind speed degree
The division according to reliability state corresponds to wind-power electricity generation in terms of time index, output index, system index System reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in time index in the characteristic of each state and is:
Run time FRH in full:System is in the cumulative time of operating status in full;
Resource constraint derating run time RDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to resource constraint;
Failure derating run time FDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to partial fault;Failure Idle time FOH:System occurs complete failure and causes the cumulative time stopped transport, and the failure idle time FOH is by FOH= PHQCIt calculates;
The too fast idle time NH of calm or wind speed (not use hour):System is under the too fast state of calm or wind speed Cumulative time;
Annual utilization hours UH:Power generation under the conditions of system generated energy conversion to this all installation oepration at full load is small When number;
Derating run time DH:System is in the cumulative time of derating operating status, DH=FDH+RDH;
Run time RH:System cumulative time in operating status, RH=FRH+DH;
Idle time OH:System is in the cumulative time of stoppage in transit state, OH=FOH+NH;
Cycle time PH:Year is 8760h.
Further, the sample calculation analysis includes:System trouble analysis and indicator-specific statistics and calculating;
The indicator-specific statistics and calculating:
The definition that a variety of situations of division of the force data according to reliability state will actually be gone out carries out statistic of classification, calculates And analyze time index, output index, the system index established in reliability index system.
The wind generator system includes a unit, the m string machines that the n platform separate unit Wind turbines being serially connected are constituted Group, inverter and busbar;The m string units parallel connection accesses an inverter, and K platforms, K platform inverter parallels is arranged in inverter Access busbar.System total installation of generating capacity is 30MW, and the distance between adjacent two Wind turbines is 500m, 5 Wind turbines compositions One " string " accesses inverter, shares 3 groups of wind-driven generator string formations.
The separate unit Wind turbines include that wind-driven generator 1, lv contactor 2, tower inner cable 3, fan outlet are box Transformer 4, medium voltage breaker 5, on-load switch 6 are simultaneously sequentially connected.
The wind-resources feature is:When wind speed is less than incision wind speed, wind speed is equal to incision wind speed or rated wind speed and cuts Go out wind speed, wind speed is more than rated wind speed and is less than cut-out wind speed.
The application principle of the present invention is further described with reference to specific embodiment.
1, the characteristics of wind generator system
The unstability of wind speed and the intermittent output for determining Wind turbines also have fluctuation and intermittent spy Point, while part reliability and system structure determine the output situation of wind generator system.
1.1 wind turbine output analysis of Influential Factors
Since its energy conversion principle limits, output is mainly influenced by seasonal climate and wind speed wind turbine.
1) influence of time in season
China land wind-resources are concentrated mainly on the areas such as northeast, North China, northwest.In general, spring and winter in 1 year Monsoon resource is relatively abundant, and summer wind-resources are leaner weary;For in one day, daytime, wind-resources were poorer, and night wind-resources compared with It is abundant.
2) influence of wind speed size
Whether the output of Wind turbines changes with wind speed and is changed, both depended in generating state and output size The situation of wind speed.Fig. 2 gives the relation curve of Wind turbines output power and wind speed.
It can be seen from the figure that when wind speed is less than incision wind speed, generated output is zero;It is equal to incision wind in wind speed When speed, rated wind speed and cut-out wind speed, all there is apparent turning point in power characteristic;It is more than specified wind in wind speed Speed and less than cut-out wind speed when, generated output is certain value;Only when wind speed is more than incision wind speed and is less than rated wind speed, Generated output and wind speed are approximately just linear relationship.Therefore, we according to resource abundant intensity by system mode be divided into it is in full, Resource constraint derating and these three states of stopping transport.
1.2 system structure characteristic analysis
The typical structure of wind generator system is as shown in Figure 3.
The radial connection type of generally use, i.e., sent out wind-force with cable and on-load switch between wind power generating set Motor group connects, and then passes through cable connection to inverter.N platforms Wind turbines connect into one " string " in figure, while m goes here and there Unit parallel connection accesses an inverter, has on K platform inverter parallels access busbar.It, can in the case where maintaining identical reliability standard The wind power generating set for each group being connected into " string " is equivalent to the generating set of an identical capacity.
According to these design features, it is known that when some Wind turbines failure, Wind turbines " string " are contributed not where causing Completely, it is believed that unit " string " is in part stoppage in transit state;But the failure of inverter can lead to place wind turbine-inverter Group is stopped transport.System mode can be divided into operation, the operation of failure derating and failure in full according to different fault conditions and stop transport this Three state.System structure failure will specifically be analyzed below.
The specific connection type of wind power generating set is as shown in figure 4, figure 4, it is seen that when wind-driven generator, wind When machine exports one lv contactor, box type transformer, medium voltage breaker and middle pressure disconnecting switch any of which element stoppage in transit, This Wind turbines will stop transport.But due to buffer action, above-mentioned Wind turbines stoppage in transit will not influence the other wind being connected with it Electric unit operation.Therefore, the element 1~4 in Fig. 4 can be considered as element group outage model, which is calculated using series connection formula The equivalent outage rate of unit.The stoppage in transit probability of the Wind turbines is:
The stoppage in transit of medium voltage breaker and on-load switch will also cause the stoppage in transit of the Wind turbines in Fig. 4.When on wind turbine pedestal On-load switch quantity when being more than 1, medium voltage breaker or any one on-load switch are stopped transport, and also be will be enlarged by stoppage in transit range, are caused The stoppage in transit for the other units being attached thereto.Therefore, the influence of medium voltage breaker and on-load switch to reliability can be mainly divided into 2 kinds of situations below:
1) on-load switch quantity is 1, i.e. the wind turbine is located at the end of string, is connected with other wind turbines by cable L, at this time The stoppage in transit of element 5,6 or cable L will cause the stoppage in transit of Wind turbines, as shown in Figure 5.Therefore, it is regarded as element group stoppage in transit mould Formula.Its outage rate is
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of Wind turbines;For the outage rate of cable L;For element in Fig. 5Stoppage in transit probability.
2) on-load switch quantity is 2, that is, connects front and back 2 Fans.Pass through on-load switch and cable series connection between wind turbine. Fig. 6 is shown in Wind turbines connection when on-load switch number is 2.From fig. 6, it can be seen that working as Wind turbinesMedium voltage breaker B, On-load switchOr when the L stoppages in transit of fan outlet cable, entire Wind turbines will stop transport.It is obstructed electric power according to desired failure Constant principle takes the probability of each operating status and the sum of products of output power, itself divided by " equivalent capacity " can be obtained Equivalent fault probability, i.e.,
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of n-1 typhoons power generator group cascaded structure shown in fig. 6;For n typhoon power The equivalent outage rate of generating set cascaded structure, byIterative calculation obtains, as n=1,It can be calculated by formula 2 It arrives.
According to series-parallel system Calculation of Reliability formula, the probability of malfunction after m string Wind turbines parallel connections can be obtainedFor:
After the series-parallel Wind turbines of m " string " are connected with inverter, the probability of malfunction of wind-powered electricity generation-inverter group is obtained For:
According to above-mentioned analysis, wind generator system failure is divided into complete system failure and components of system as directed failure two by us Class;(1) K groups wind turbine-inverter group parallel power generating system complete failure probabilityFor:
(2) in real process, since wind turbine-inverter group is more so complete failure occurs in wind generator system Probability and little, be more often the components of system as directed failure caused by Wind turbines or inverter.
1) wind-driven generator string formation failure
Due to mutual indepedent between each wind power generating set " string ", and system fault probability obeys bi-distribution, and failure is general RateIt can be calculated as follows:
2) fault of converter
The analysis of similar wind-driven generator string formation failure, can obtain part inverter probability of malfunction
Since the failure of wind-driven generator string formation and inverter is relatively independent, so obtaining components of system as directed probability of malfunction
The above analysis can obtain, due to being influenced by wind-resources constraint and system structure feature, it is necessary to consider money Source feature and system failure feature establish multi state reliability model.
The division of 2 reliability states
The reliability state of wind generator system can be divided into following several feelings according to wind-resources and unit failure Condition:
1) operating status in full:When wind speed is very fast, systematically contributes and be located at higher level, installed capacity can be reached 60% or more.The operating status of such system is classified as operating status in full, is marked using the 60% of installed capacity as delimitation It is accurate.
2) resource constraint derating operating status:It is influenced, will be contributed horizontal less than 60% installed capacity by factors such as wind speed System mode be all classified as resource constraint derating operating status.
3) failure derating operating status:Components of system as directed output loss state is caused since equipment component failure is out of service.
4) failure stoppage in transit state:Forced outage occurs for system or plan repair stoppage in transit causes system whole output loss State.
5) the too fast stoppage in transit state of calm or wind speed:System is in due to wind speed less than cutting speed or more than excision speed And in the state stopped transport.
3. reliability index system
For the reliability state in 2.2 sections, the present invention corresponds to wind generator system from time, output, system etc. Reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in the characteristic of each state, and then reflects system performance.
3.1 time index
According to thinking is divided, in conjunction with 5 states that the present invention defines, time index is carried out to division as shown in Figure 7.
In conjunction with system mode, state for time index is as follows.1) run time FRH (full run hour) in full:System Resource constraint derating run time RDH (resource deduction hour) when accumulative in operating status in full:2) system System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to resource constraint;3) failure derating run time FDH (fault deduction hour):System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to partial fault;4) failure idle time FOH (fault outage hour):System occurs complete failure and causes the cumulative time stopped transport.By FOH=PHQCIt calculates;5) nothing Wind or the too fast idle time NH of wind speed (not use hour):System is in the cumulative time under the too fast state of calm or wind speed; 6) annual utilization hours UH (utilization hours):This all installation oepration at full load items are arrived in the conversion of system generated energy Power generation hourage under part;7) derating run time DH (deduction hour):System is in the tired of derating operating status Between timing, DH=FDH+RDH;8) run time RH (run hour):The system cumulative time in operating status.RH=FRH +DH;9) idle time OH (outage hour):System is in the cumulative time of stoppage in transit state.OH=FOH+NH;10) period Time PH (period hour):Year is about 8760h.
3.2 output state indexs
1) equivalent output FEP (full equivalent power) in full:System is equivalent under operating status in full It contributes;
2) the equivalent output RDEP of derating (resource deduction equivalent power) under resource constraint:System Equivalent output of the system under resource constraint derating operating status;
3) the equivalent output FDEP of failure derating (fault deduction equivalent power):System is in failure Equivalent output under derating operating status;
4) the equivalent output EDP of derating (equivalent deduction power):System is in derating operating status Equivalent output;
5) equivalent output EP (equivalent power):System equivalent constant output in timing statistics;
6) equivalent power factor ECF (equivalent coefficient factor):Equivalent output in actual power With the ratio ECF=EP/RP of nominal output;
7) maximum output MP (maximum power):Maximum output in system actual power;
8) maximum output coefficient MPF (Maximum power factor):Maximum output and nominal output in actual power Ratio MPF=MP/RP;
3.3 system overall objectives
To reflect that system total breakdown situation, fault indices are as follows
1) design availability DU (Design usability):Design is calculated according to system failure rate and repair time On system availability, DU=1-QC
2) operating factor OF (Operating factor):Wind generator system is practically in the probability of operating status, OF =RH/PH;
3) year generating equipment utilization rate EUR (The annual power generation equipment utilization rate):The probability that wind generator system generating equipment utilizes, EUR=UH/PH;
4) operation ratio FRR (Full run rate) in full:Wind generator system is in the probability fully run, FRR= FRH/PH;
5) resource constraint derating operation ratio RDR (Resource the deduction rate of operation):Wind Force generating system is in practice since resource constraint leads to the probability of derating operating status, RDR=RDH/PH;
6) equipment fault derating operation ratio EFDR (Equipment fault deduction rate of operation):Wind generator system, which is practically in the system failure, leads to the probability of derating operating status, EFDR=FDH/PH;
7) exposure EXR (Exposure rate):Wind generator system utilizes the efficiency of wind energy.Annual utilization hours can be used The description of the ratio between number and run time.EXR=UH/RH;
4 examples
The present invention is using miniature wind power generation system as Example Verification reliability model proposed in this paper and index system Feasibility.System total installation of generating capacity is 30MW, and the distance between adjacent two Wind turbines is 500m, 5 Wind turbines compositions One " string " accesses inverter, shares 3 groups of wind-driven generator string formations.
Example system component failure data use the statistical data in relation to document, and practical power curve is according to Zhangjiakou Wind-powered electricity generation field data (2009 on September 1, to 2010 on August 31) obtain, and are provided respectively in table 1.
Each part reliability parameter of 1 wind generator system of table
4.1 system trouble analysis
Analysis system fault condition, n=5, m=1, k=3, according to formula (1),
When on-load switch number is 1, equivalent fault probability
By the equivalent fault probability of " string " that 5 typhoon power generators form
The probability of malfunction of wind-powered electricity generation-inverter group
When complete system failure,
If timing statistics PH takes 8760h, failure idle time can be obtained by formula
FOH=PHQC≈ 44h,
When components of system as directed failure, due to m=1, k=3, the partial fault of system can be divided into 1 rank and 2 ranks, failure Probability calculation is as follows:
It is as follows that components of system as directed fault parameter can then be obtained:
ByFailure, which can be calculated, and stop transport causes the time of derating operation to be about 3731h.
The ratio contributed under output and normal condition under failure derating can also be calculated according to the above analysis
4.2 indicator-specific statistics and calculating
Force data will actually be gone out and carry out statistic of classification according to the definition in the division of reliability state, calculate analysis system Time index, output index in overall objective, system index result.
In each state of wind generator system of the present invention, complete failure idle time is minimum;Idle time is about 1200h, is accounted for Annual 13.7%;Run time illustrates local wind-resources compared with horn of plenty far more than idle time;Run time in full is only The 13% of whole service time is accounted for, derating run time accounts for run time overwhelming majority ratio up to 87%, illustrates local wind money Source fluctuation is larger;Annual utilization hours are only 1882h, and it is relatively low to reflect wind energy resources utilization ratio.
The present invention equivalent output in full accounts for about the 68.8% of installed capacity, and the equivalent output of derating accounts for 11% caused by resource, The equivalent output of derating caused by failure accounts for 41.9%, illustrates that the limitation of resource is affected to the output of wind generator system.System Equivalent output of uniting only accounts for the 21.5% of installed capacity, in system year maximum output 24.485MW, accounts for the 81.6% of installed capacity.
The system of the present invention only considers that the design availability of failure stoppage in transit situation reaches 99.5%, and operating factor reaches 86.3%, illustrate that the availability of wind generator system is higher;The operation ratio of unit failure reaches 42.59%, and which reflects wind-force The probability of malfunction of generating set and inverter is higher, wherein with the larger practical feelings of possibility that Wind turbines break down Condition, therefore, failure derating operation probability can be reduced by improving the reliability of component, improve reliability.Year generating equipment utilization rate It is 21.48%, exposure 24.89%, the limitation for reflecting wind energy resources causes system to be reduced using the efficiency of the energy, such as Fruit is using variable speed HAWT group or uses active wind flow intelligence control system, then can effectively improve wind power plant exposure Rate further increases system reliability.
With the progress of wind power technology, the reduction of cost of electricity-generating, the advantage and economy of wind-power electricity generation will constantly be shown Come, it is detailed that the present invention has studied the influence to wind generator system reliability, the present invention based on unit failure and abundant resource degree Wind generator system structure failure feature is analyzed, desirably failure is obstructed the equal method of electric energy by Wind turbines " string " It is equivalent to the generator of 1 identical capacity, and establishes the system mode for considering unit failure and resource constraint, is passed through simultaneously Time, output, index system assess wind generator system reliability;Sample calculation analysis shows based on component event The reliability model of barrier and resource constraint, can reflect real system reliability of operation.
The foregoing is merely illustrative of the preferred embodiments of the present invention, is not intended to limit the invention, all essences in the present invention All any modification, equivalent and improvement etc., should all be included in the protection scope of the present invention made by within refreshing and principle.

Claims (8)

1. a kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed, which is characterized in that should be based on being obstructed The equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of electric energy includes the following steps:
N platform Wind turbines are connected into one " string ", while m string unit parallel connections access an inverter, K platforms, K platforms is arranged in inverter Inverter parallel accesses on busbar, in the case where maintaining identical reliability standard, the wind-driven generator that connects into " string " by each group Group is equivalent to the generating set of an identical capacity;
Multistate reliability is analyzed according to wind-resources feature and wind powered generator system fault characteristic;
The division of reliability state:It is according to wind-resources and unit failure feature that the reliability state division of wind generator system is more Kind situation;
Establish reliability index system:According to the division of reliability state wind-power electricity generation system is corresponded to from time, output, system aspects System reliability is assessed and reflects that system is in the characteristic of each state, and then reflects system performance;
Finally use currently running data, by sample calculation analysis, verify reliability state division and index system it is correct Property, the reliability of wind generator system actual motion is assessed.
2. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In the wind powered generator system fault characteristic multistate reliability analysis includes:
A, single wind generator group failure calculates the equivalent outage rate of separate unit Wind turbines, separate unit wind-powered electricity generation using series connection formula The stoppage in transit probability of unit is:
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 1, which is located at the end of string, passes through cable L It is connected with other wind turbines, outage rate is
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of Wind turbines;For the outage rate of cable L;For the member of separate unit Wind turbines PartStoppage in transit probability;
When the on-load switch quantity on the wind turbine pedestal of separate unit Wind turbines is 2, that is, front and back 2 Fans are connected, are led between wind turbine Overload switch and cable series connection are obstructed the constant principle of electric power according to desired failure, take probability and the output of each operating status Itself divided by " equivalent capacity " are obtained equivalent fault probability, i.e., by the sum of products of power
Wherein:For the equivalent outage rate of n-1 typhoon power generator group cascaded structures;For n typhoon power generator group tandem junctions The equivalent outage rate of structure, byIterative calculation obtains, as n=1,It can be calculated by formula (2);
B, according to series-parallel system Calculation of Reliability formula, the probability of malfunction after m string Wind turbines parallel connections can be obtainedFor:
After the series-parallel Wind turbines of m " string " are connected with inverter, the probability of malfunction of wind-powered electricity generation-inverter group is obtainedFor:
C, wind generator system failure is divided into complete system failure and components of system as directed failure:
K groups wind turbine-inverter group parallel power generating system complete failure probabilityFor:
Components of system as directed failure includes:Wind-driven generator string formation failure and fault of converter;
Wind-driven generator string formation probability of malfunction obeys bi-distribution, probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
Fault of converter probabilityIt is calculated as follows:
Components of system as directed probability of malfunctionIt is calculated as follows:
3. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In a variety of situations of the division of the reliability state include:
Operating status in full:When wind speed is very fast, the output of wind generator system reaches 60% of installed capacity or more, will be such The operating status of system is classified as operating status in full, using the 60% of installed capacity as delimitation standard;
Resource constraint derating operating status:It is influenced by wind speed factor, the output level of wind generator system is less than 60% installation The system mode of capacity is all classified as resource constraint derating operating status;
Failure derating operating status:Output loss shape in wind generator system part is caused since equipment component failure is out of service State;
Failure stoppage in transit state:Forced outage occurs for wind generator system or plan repair stoppage in transit causes wind generator system whole The state of output loss;
The too fast stoppage in transit state of calm or wind speed:System is in less than incision wind velocity due to wind speed or is located more than cut-out wind speed degree In the state of stoppage in transit.
4. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In the division according to reliability state corresponds to wind generator system in terms of time index, output index, system index can It is assessed by property and reflects that system is in time index in the characteristic of each state and is:
Run time FRH in full:System is in the cumulative time of operating status in full;
Resource constraint derating run time RDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to resource constraint;
Failure derating run time FDH:System is in the accumulated time of derating operating status due to partial fault;When failure is stopped transport Between FOH:System occurs complete failure and causes the cumulative time stopped transport, and the failure idle time FOH is by FOH=PHQCIt calculates;
The too fast idle time NH of calm or wind speed (not use hour):System is in accumulative under the too fast state of calm or wind speed Time;
Annual utilization hours UH:Power generation hourage under the conditions of system generated energy conversion to this all installation oepration at full load;
Derating run time DH:System is in the cumulative time of derating operating status, DH=FDH+RDH;
Run time RH:System cumulative time in operating status, RH=FRH+DH;
Idle time OH:System is in the cumulative time of stoppage in transit state, OH=FOH+NH;
Cycle time PH:Year is 8760h.
5. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In the sample calculation analysis includes:System trouble analysis and indicator-specific statistics and calculating;
The indicator-specific statistics and calculating:
The definition that a variety of situations of division of the force data according to reliability state will actually be gone out carries out statistic of classification, calculates and analyzes Establish time index, output index, the system index in reliability index system.
6. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In the wind generator system includes a unit, m string unit, the inversion that the n platform separate unit Wind turbines being serially connected are constituted Device and busbar;The m string units parallel connection accesses an inverter, and K platforms are arranged in inverter, and K platform inverter parallels access busbar. System total installation of generating capacity is 30MW, and the distance between adjacent two Wind turbines is 500m, and 5 Wind turbines form one " string " access Inverter shares 3 groups of wind-driven generator string formations.
7. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In, separate unit Wind turbines include wind-driven generator, lv contactor, tower inner cable, fan outlet box type transformer, in Voltage breaker, on-load switch are simultaneously sequentially connected.
8. as described in claim 1 based on the equal wind generator system method for evaluating reliability of the electric energy that is obstructed, feature exists In the wind-resources feature is:When wind speed is less than incision wind speed, wind speed is equal to incision wind speed or rated wind speed and cuts out wind Speed, wind speed are more than rated wind speed and are less than cut-out wind speed.
CN201710801950.8A 2017-09-07 2017-09-07 A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed Pending CN108335004A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201710801950.8A CN108335004A (en) 2017-09-07 2017-09-07 A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201710801950.8A CN108335004A (en) 2017-09-07 2017-09-07 A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN108335004A true CN108335004A (en) 2018-07-27

Family

ID=62921902

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN201710801950.8A Pending CN108335004A (en) 2017-09-07 2017-09-07 A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN108335004A (en)

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN110852544A (en) * 2018-08-21 2020-02-28 新疆金风科技股份有限公司 Reliability evaluation method and device for wind generating set
CN112736963A (en) * 2020-12-15 2021-04-30 国网江苏省电力有限公司盐城供电分公司 Power dispatching control method based on distributed power supply access
CN112736964A (en) * 2020-12-15 2021-04-30 国网江苏省电力有限公司盐城供电分公司 Regional power grid control method based on distributed power supply access
CN116523349A (en) * 2023-05-19 2023-08-01 北京协合运维风电技术有限公司 Wind power station reliability analysis method and system

Citations (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN103489132A (en) * 2013-09-03 2014-01-01 吉林省电力科学研究院有限公司 Wind power plant reliability evaluating system
CN103701120A (en) * 2013-12-23 2014-04-02 华北电力大学 Method for evaluating reliability of large power grid comprising wind power station
CN103746370A (en) * 2013-12-20 2014-04-23 河海大学 Wind-power-plant reliability modeling method
JP5989732B2 (en) * 2014-10-01 2016-09-07 中国電力株式会社 Power generation amount prediction device, power generation amount prediction method, and program
CN106355517A (en) * 2016-11-07 2017-01-25 国网重庆市电力公司经济技术研究院 Method for calculating reliability of current collection system of wind power plant

Patent Citations (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN103489132A (en) * 2013-09-03 2014-01-01 吉林省电力科学研究院有限公司 Wind power plant reliability evaluating system
CN103746370A (en) * 2013-12-20 2014-04-23 河海大学 Wind-power-plant reliability modeling method
CN103701120A (en) * 2013-12-23 2014-04-02 华北电力大学 Method for evaluating reliability of large power grid comprising wind power station
JP5989732B2 (en) * 2014-10-01 2016-09-07 中国電力株式会社 Power generation amount prediction device, power generation amount prediction method, and program
CN106355517A (en) * 2016-11-07 2017-01-25 国网重庆市电力公司经济技术研究院 Method for calculating reliability of current collection system of wind power plant

Cited By (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN110852544A (en) * 2018-08-21 2020-02-28 新疆金风科技股份有限公司 Reliability evaluation method and device for wind generating set
CN112736963A (en) * 2020-12-15 2021-04-30 国网江苏省电力有限公司盐城供电分公司 Power dispatching control method based on distributed power supply access
CN112736964A (en) * 2020-12-15 2021-04-30 国网江苏省电力有限公司盐城供电分公司 Regional power grid control method based on distributed power supply access
CN112736963B (en) * 2020-12-15 2022-08-19 国网江苏省电力有限公司盐城供电分公司 Power dispatching control method based on distributed power supply access
CN116523349A (en) * 2023-05-19 2023-08-01 北京协合运维风电技术有限公司 Wind power station reliability analysis method and system

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN103020462B (en) Take into account the wind energy turbine set probability output power calculation algorithms of complicated wake effect model
Keyhani Smart power grids
CN108335004A (en) A kind of wind generator system method for evaluating reliability equal based on the electric energy that is obstructed
CN103606913B (en) Distributed hybrid power system power source planning method
CN102915471A (en) Wind power disturbance online safety precaution method
CN104319785B (en) Source flow path electrical subdivision-based wind power system key node identification method
Abul’Wafa Matching wind turbine generators with wind regime in Egypt
Liu et al. Reliability evaluation of tidal and wind power generation system with battery energy storage
CN105305488A (en) Evaluation method considering influence of new energy grid connection on utilization rate of transmission network
Cheng et al. A multi-state model for wind farms considering operational outage probability
Zhang et al. Boosting the power grid resilience under typhoon disasters by coordinated scheduling of wind energy and conventional generators
CN104680243B (en) Count and turn the marine wind electric field main transformer capacity optimization method for ability
Karki et al. Reliability assessment of a wind integrated hydro-thermal power system
CN105552880A (en) Electric power system typical fault set determination method based on state enumeration method
CN109149636A (en) Wind power integration point transient stability based on Dynamic Security Region influences research method
Li et al. Reliability evaluation of distribution network considering distributed intermittent renewable energy access
CN107886227A (en) Method for assessing power distribution network anti-disaster capability improving degree
Panumpabi Large wind farm aggregation and model validation
Wei et al. Electrical System Planning of Large-scale Offshore Wind Farm Based on N+ Design Considering Optimization of Upper Power Limits of Wind Turbines
Huo et al. Reliability of distribution systems considering photovoltaic-wind power generation systems' complementary characteristics
Paul et al. Optimal placement of wind power plant in a radial distribution network considering plant reliability
Cao et al. Study on reliability assessment of composite generation and transmission system integrated wind farm
Abdellatif et al. Hybrid distributed generation system modeling for smart self-healing electric microgrid
Yin et al. Optimization Method of power grid data fusion for High Proportion New Energy System
Negra et al. Windfarm generation assessment for reliability analysis of power systems

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication
RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication

Application publication date: 20180727