CONDUCTIVELY HEATING A s~B~ERRANEaN OIL SHALE TO
CRE~TE PE~E~BILITY AND SUBSEOUENTLY PRODUCE OIL
This invention relates to recovering oil frcm a subterranean oil shale by means of a conductive heat drive process. More particularly, the invention relates to treating a relatively thick and substantially ccmpletely imperll~able subterranean oil shale by means of a conductive heating process which both creates a permeable zone within a selected portion of the oil shale and subsequently produces shale oil hydrocarbons.
A permeability-aided type of conductive heat drive for producing oil from a subterranean oil shale was invented in Sweden lo by F.Ljungstroem. That process, which was invented about 40 years ago, was ccmmercially used on a small scale in the 1950s. It is described in Swedish Patents Nos. 121,737; 123,136; 123,137;
123,138; 125,712 and 126,674, in United States Patent No.
2,732,195, and in journal articles such as: "Underground Shale Oil Pyrolysis According to the Ljungstroem Method", IVA Volume 24 (1953) No. 3, pages 118 to 123, and "Net Energy Recoveries For The In Situ Dielectric Heating of Oil Shale", Oil Shale Symposium Proceedings 11, page 311 to 330 (1978). In the Swedish process, heat injection wells and fluid producing wells were ccmpleted within a permeable near-surface oil shale formation so that there was less than a three-metre separation between the boreholes. m e heat injection wells were equipped with electrical or other heating elements which were surrounded by a mass of material, such as sand or cement, arranged to transmit heat into the oil shale while preventing any inflowing or outflowing of fluid. In the oil shale for which the Swedish process was designed and tested, the permeability was such that, due to a continuous inflowing of ~round water, a continuous pumping-out of water was needed to avoid wasting energy by evaporating that water.
With respect to substantially ccmpletely impermeable, ~k J ~ 3 relatively deep and relatively thick oil shale deposits, such as those in the Piceance Basin in the United States, the possibility of utilizing a conductive heating process for producing oil was previously considered to be -- according to prior teachings and beliefs -- economically unfeasible. For example, in the above-identified Oil Shale Symposium, the Ljungstroem process is characterized as a process which "...successfully recovered shale oil by embedding tubular electrical heating elements within high-grade shale deposits. This method relied on ordinary thermal 1o diffusion for shale heating, which, of course, requires large temperature gradients. Thus, heating was very non-uniform; mo~ths were required to fully retort small room-size blocks of shale.
Also, much heat energy was wasted in underheating the shale regions beyond the periphery of the retorting zone and overheating the shale closest to the heat source. m e latter problem is especially important in the case of Western shales, since thermal energy in overheated zones, cannot be fully recovered by diffusion due to endothermic reactions which take place above about 600 C." (page 313).
In substantially impermeable types of relatively thick subterranean oil shale formations, the creating and maintaining of a permeable zone through which the pyrolysis products can be flowed has been found to be a severe problem. In US Patent No. 3,468,376, it is stated (in cols. l and 2) that "There are two mechanisms involved in the transport of heat through the oil shale. Heat is transferred through the solid mass of oil shale by conduction. The heat is also transferred by convection through the solid mass of oil shale. m e transfer of heat by conduction is a relatively slow process. The average thermal conductivity and average thermal diffusivity of oil shale are about those of a firebrick. The matrix of solid oil shale has an extremely low permeability much like unglazed porcelain. As a result, the convective transfer of heat is limited to heating by fluid flows obtained in open channels which traverse the oil shale. These flow channels may be natural and 35 artificially induced fractures. On heating, a layer of ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ t~
pyrolyzed oil shale builds adjacent the channel. This layer is an inorganic mineral matrix which contains varying degrees of carbon.
The layer is an ever-expanding barrier to heat flow from the heating fluid in the channel." The patent is directed to a process for circulating heated oil shale-pyrolyzing fluid through a flow channel while adding abrasive particles to the circulating fluid to erode the layer of pyrolyzed oil shale being formed adjacent to the channel.
Although the thermal conductivity and thermal diffusivity of l many subterranean oil shales are, in fact, relatively similar to those of unglazed porcelain and firebrick, US Patent No 3,237,689 postulates that "a rapid advance of a heat front" (Col. 3, line 7) can be obtained by exchanging heat between the oil shale and a nuclear reactor cooling fluid and describes systems for using such reactors either located on the earth's surface or in the oil shale deposit.
US Patent No. 3,284,281 says (at Col. 1, lines 3-21), "The production of oil from oil shale, by heating the shale by various means such as ... an electrical resistance heater ... has been 20 attempted with little success. Fracturing of the shale oil prior to the application of heat thereto by in situ combustion or other means has been practised with little suc oe ss because the shale swells upon heating with consequent partial or complete closure of the fracture". The patent describes a process of sequentially heating (and thus swelling) the oil shale, then injecting fluid to hydraulically fracture the swollen shale, then repeating those steps until a heat-stable fracture has been propagated into a production well.
US Patent No. 3,455,383 describes the accumulation of partially depleted oil shale fragments within a flow channel such as a horizontal fracture being held open by the pressure of the fluid within the channel. The patent discloses that if the channel roof is lifted to maintain a flow path above such a layer of depleted shale, the overlying formations must be bent and, without precautions, will bend to an extent causing fractures to extend up ~ ?8~ 43 to the surface of the earth. The patent is directed to a process of intermittently reducing the pressure on the fluid within such as fracture to allow the weight of the overburden to crush and compact the layer of depleted shale.
In a significant portion of substantially impermeable and relatively thick oil shale deposits, such as those in the Piceance Basin, a valuable resource of aluminium is present in the form of dawsonite. In US Patent No. 3,389,975, directed to recovering aluminium values from retorted oil shales which have been mined out from such deposits, it is pointed out that, in a substantial absence of water, at temperatures of about 1300 F the dawsonite is converted to crystalline sodium aluminate. Such a water-free retorting can decompose dolomite in the shale to produce carbon dioxide, calcite, and magnesium oxide so that magnesium oxide combines with part of the silicon dioxide in the shale, in a manner permitting a higher recovery of the aluminium values by a leaching process. VS Patent No. 3,502,372, directed to utilizing solution mining to recover dawsonite, indicates that where the pyrolysis is effected bv an aqueous fluid, such as steam or the products of underground combustion, it must be conducted at a low temperature and thus relatively slowly, to avoid converting the dawsonite and other soluble aluminium compounds to an insoluble material such as analcite. In US Patent No. 3,572,838, a similar relatively low temperature pyrolysis is alternated with injections of an aqueous alkaline fluid containing an acid-insoluble chelating agent to aid in leaching dawsonite without forming such insoluble materials.
m e present invention relates to a process for conductively heating a subterranean oil shale formation in a manner arranged for producing oil from a subterranean oil shale formation which is, initially, substantially impermeable. In accordance with this invention, the portion of oil shale deposit to be treated is selected, on the basis of the variations with depth in the cQmposition an properties of its components, to have properties capable of interacting in a manner which enhances the uniformity of the heat fronts to an extent limiting the time and energy , . ..
-5- ~32g3-2743 expenditures producing the oil to values equivalent to less than the value of the oil which is produced. The selection of the treatment interval is based on the grade and thickness of the portion of oil shale deposit to be treated and the enhancement it provides amounts to reducing the amount of heat energy lost due to exothermic side reactions and increasing the amount of oil recovered from a given grade of oil shale.
In accordance with this invention at least two wells are completed into a subterranean oil shale treatment interval which is substantially impermeable, contains substantially no mobile water, is at least about 30 m thick, is capable of confining fluid at process pressure, at least substantially within the treatment interval, and contains a grade and thickness of oil shale such that the average grade in gallons of oil plus gas equivalent per ton by Fischer Assay is at least about 10 and the product of the grade times the thickness in metres of the oil shale is at least about 900.
Thus, the present invention provides in a process in which oil is produced from a subterranean oil shale deposit by extending at least one each of heat-in~ecting and fluid-producing wells into the deposit, establishing a heat-conductive fluid-impermeable barrier between the interior of each heat-injecting well and the adjacent deposit, and then heating the interior of each heat-injecting well at a temperature sufficient to conductively heat oil shale kerogen and cause pyrolysis products to form fractures within the oil shale deposit through which the pyrolysis prod~cts are displaced into at least one production well, an improvement for enhancing the uniformity of the heat ~1 ~
~ ~ 12~ 43 -5a- 63293-27~3 fronts moving through the oil shale deposit, which comprises:
- determinin~ variations with depth in the compositlon and properties of the oil shale deposit;
- completing said heat-injecting and fluid-producing wells selectively into a treatment interval of oil shale in which the oil shale deposit (a) is at least about 30 m thick, (b) is substantially impermeable and free of mobile water, (c) has a compositlon and thickness such that the product of the average Fischer Assay grade time~ the thickness of the treatment interval is at least about 900, and (d) thereby contains components capable of interacting in a manner enhancing the uniformity of a front of conductively transmitted heat, with said wells being arranged so that, at least substantially throughout said treatment interval, the well boreholes are substantially parallel and are separated by substantially equal distances of at least about 6 m; and - within the interior of each heat-injecting well maintaining an average temperature which, selectively along said treatment interval, is at least about 600C, but is not high enough to thermally damage eguipment within the well, while heat is being transmitted away from the well at a rate n~t significantly faster than that permitted by the thermal conductivities of the earth formations adjacent to the heated interval within the well.
In a location in which a subterranean oil shale may contain portions which are generally æuitable for use as a ``` J ~S8043 -5b- 63293-2743 treatment interval (as described above) but are apt to be permeated by substantially disconnected natural fractures and/or planes of weakness as well as being located near boundaries of the oil recovery pattern and~or near a potentially active aquifer, the operation of the present process can advantageously be combined with a use of "guard wells" located near the periphery of the oil recovery pattern and/or between a production well and an aquifer.
Such guard wells are extended at least substantlally throughout the vertical extent of the treatment intervals and the ad~acent formations are initially heated by thermal conduction in a manner similar to that employed in the heat-injectin~ wells, except that the guard wells are heated at temperatures which are too low to gasify significant proportion of the oil shale organic components but are high enough to cause a signi~icant thermal expansion of the rock matrix of the oil shale deposlt.
In ~ome instances, it may be desirable to maintain such a L~
~ ~8~0~.3 relatively low temperature guard well heating throughout at least a substantial portion of the shale oil recovery process. In other instan oe s, after an initial relatively low temperature heating of the guard wells, it may be advantageous to heat guard wells at about the temperature selected for the heat-in~ecting wells, in order to expand the pattern of wells from which oil is displaced by thermal conduction.
As used herein regarding the grade of the portion of oil shale to be treated, the "average grade in gallons per ton by Fischer Assay" refers to the following: m e determlnation is or is equivalent to a determination conducted substantially as described in the ASTM Standard Test Method D 3904-80. Crushed raw shale is sampled by riffle-splitting. m e determination of the amount of oil plus gas equivalent available frcm oil shale is made by heating the raw shale from ambient temperature to 500 C in cast aluminium-alloy retorts. m e vapours distilled from the sample are cooled and the condensed fraction is collected. m e oil and water fractions are separated, the water volume (converted to weight equivalent) is measured and subtracted from the oil plus water weight. m e weight of uncondensable gases evolved (gas-plus-loss) is then calculated by difference. m e grade, as used in the "grade times thickness in metres of oil shale" product, is the gallons of oil plus hydrocarbon gas equivalent corresponding to the total weight of oil plus hydrocarbon gas evolved by the heating.
The wells are completed into the treatment interval and are arranged to provide at least one each of heat-injecting and fluid-producing wells having boreholes which, substantially throughout the treatment interval, are substantially parallel and are separated by substantially equal distances of at least about 6 m.
In each heat-injecting well, substantially throughout the treatment interval, the well-surrounding face of the oil shale formation is sealed with a solid material and/or cement which is relatively heat conductive and substantially fluid impermeable. In each fluid-producing well, substantially throughout the treatment interval, fluid ccmmNnication is established between the well borehole and ~8~043 the oil shale formation and the well is arranged for producing fluid from the oil shale formation. The interior of each heat-injecting well is heated, at least substantially throughout the treatment interval, at a rate or rates capable of (a) increasing the temperature within the borehole interior to at least about 600 C and (b) maintaining a borehole interior temperature of at least about 600 C without causing it to become high enough to thermally damage equipment within the borehole while the rate at which heat is generated in the borehole is substantially equal to that permitted by the heat conductivity of the oil shale formation.
In a preferred ~mbodiment of the present process, the material for sealing the face of the oil shale formation along the borehole of at least one heat-injecting well is a closed bottom casing grouted by cement arranged to fill substantially all of the space between each outermost metallic element present within the interior of the borehole and the adjacent fa oe of the oil shale formation, with said cement having a thermal conductivity at least substantially as high as that of the oil shale formation.
Determ m ations are made of variations with depth in the composition and properties of the oil shale deposit and, in a particularly preferred procedure, based on the variation with depth in the heat conductivity of the oil shale deposit, the heat-injecting wells are heated so that relatively higher temperatures are applied at depths adjacent to portions of the oil shale deposit in which the heat conductivity is relatively low. In addition, or alternatively, in various situations, the effective radius of at least one heat-injecting well is increased by creating an expanded portion of the well borehole and extending heat-conducting metal elements from within the heated well interior to near the wall of the expanded portion of the borehole.
The present process is valuable for use within a treatment interval of oil shale which contains other valuable minerals such as dawsonite and/or nahcolite. In such a situation the present process creates a permeable zone which i5 selectively located, within the treatment interval and substantially within the boundaries of the well pattern used for the oil production. The resultant permeable zone is a zone from which such other minerals can be solution-mined.
In general, the present invention is applicable to substantially any subterranean oil shale deposit containing an interval of substantially impermeable oil shale which is substantially free of mobile water, is more than about 30 m thick, and has an adequate average grade in gallons per ton tFischer Assay) to give a grade-thickness product of about 900 or greater.
The average grade of the heated interval should be greater than about 10 gallons per ton (Fischer Assay). Within these limitatio~s, a higher grade-thickness product is increasingly desirable if other conditions such as depth remain the same.
m e invention will now be explained in greater detail with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
Figure 1 shows a plot of relative rate of return tRR) for 1982 US dollars invested in installing and operating the process of the present invention, as a function of oil shale grade-thickness (GxTH) product, to produce shale oil at its 1982 value.
Figure 2 illustrates a plot of thermal profiles at an observation well regarding temperatures measured at different depths (D) and times within that well.
Figure 3 is a plot of the radial thermal profiles at the middle of a heated zone after different times of heating.
Figure 4 is a plot of thermal conductivities parallel and perpendicular to the bedding planes of an oil shale as a function of temperature.
Fig~re 5 is a graph of Fischer Assay yield with depth (D) in and above a heated portion of subterranean oil shale.
Figures 6 and 7 are plots of horizontal and vertical temperature profiles within a heated portion of subterranean oil shale formation.
Figure 8 is a schematic illustration of a portion of a well completion arrangement suitable for practising the present invention.
'~ Z~1~3 g As far as Applicants are aware, the most similar prior process ccmprises the above-described Swedish process. The Swedish process was designed for and used in a permeable oil shale formation in which the rate of the transmission of heat away from the heat-injecting wells and toward fluid-producing wells was increased by the flow of fluid through a permeable oil shale formation. In that oil shale, as soon as a portion of fluid (such as the ground water and/or kerogen pyrolysis products) became hotter and was thermally pressurized to attain a volume greater than that of a more remote portion of the same fluid, the increasing pressure and volume began to displace the heated fluid away from the heat-injecting well. This caused heat to be transmitted by convection, and thus caused heat to be transmitted at a rate significantly greater than the rate that would be permitted by the heat conductivity of an impermeable oil shale formation in which all of the components are i D bile. In spite of (or because of) the fact that the heat transmission involved such a flow of fluid and in spite of the fact that the wellbores were separated by less than 2.7 m, the Swedisch process was found to be economically unfeasible and was terminated.
As indicated by the above-mentioned patents relating to producing oil from substantially impermeable deposits of oil shale, the forming and maintaining of fluid permeable paths between injection and production wells was found to be extremely difficult and expensive. Accordingly, the possibility of applying a process based on the conductive heating of the formation to an Impermeable oil shale was considered to be hopeless. Conductive heating was indicated to be too slow and too inefficient to be econcmically useful, even in the permeable oil shale formation from which some production had been obtained. It appears that a simil æ opinion may have been shared by the inventor of the Swedish process. His belief that there was a need for a pre-existing permeable zone or channel is exemplified by US Patent No. 2,780,450. In describing how his previously tested in situ process for pyrolyzing oil shale should be applied to a fluid-impermeable material, such as the Athabasca ~ ~8fiO43 tar sand, Ljungstroem teaches that the in situ heatins and pyrolyzing should be done in a portion of the impermeable formation which is vertically contiguous to a well-interconnecting fracture or a layer which has different geological character and is permeable to flow of the fluid products of the heating or pyrolysis.
Contrary to the implications of such prior teachings and beliefs, applicants discovered that the presently described conductive heating process is economically feasible for use in a substantially impermeable subterranean oil shale. This is not obvious, particularly in view of the fact that the present process uses a much larger well spacing than that used in the Swedish process and the present process is conducted by heating the injection wells to temperatures of at least about 600 C (although 600 C has been said to be conducive to an economically untenable, heat-wasting, endothermic reaction; see the Oil Shale Symposium Proceedings mentioned above).
By means of laboratory and field test measurements and mathematical models of the present process, applicants have found that when the wells are spaced, completed, and operated as presently described, the only region in which heat energy is utilized in an endothermic reaction amounts to less than about 1 of the area to be heated, and the energy lost in that fashion is insignificant. Applicants have measured the rate at which substantially impermeable oil shale formations are heated by conductivity, and have determined the amount of heat required for pyrolyzing kerogen and thermally pressurizing the pyrolysis products to pressures capable of fracturing a relatively deep oil shale formation and thermally displacing pyrolysis products through the so-created permeability.
The data obtained by such measurements in the field and in the laboratory have been employed in calculations of power require-ments, econcmics, time to start production, project duration, amount of production, etc., in mathematical simulations that correlate with the field and laboratory data and indicate the magnitudes of such factors in respect to a full scale process.
~ 2~0~'t3 Those calculations indicate that the presently defined process is the only shale oil production process of which applicants are aware which is capable of economically obtaining oil from a relatively low grade oil shale formation, such as one in which the Fischer Assay is only 15 gallons or less per ton. This capability can increase the petroleum reserves of a significant proportion of the oil shale lands by a factor of six. In addition, with respect to processes for underground mining and modified in situ retorting of oil shale, the present process significantly increases the amount of available resources by eliminating the need for support pillars and interburden between mining zones and by providing a means for treating substantially all of a very thick interval of oil shale.
The present process can advantageously be applied to an oil shale formation in which there is significant concentration of a mineral such as dawsonite or nahcolite. In such a formation the process provides a permeable zone from which such a mineral can be recovered. In addition, the present process is particularly advantageous in converting dawsonite to water-soluble compounds of aluminium (probably rho-alumina) which have been tboth chemically and physically) made available for solution-mining to produce the aluminium -- an essential material which is in short supply within the United States. In contrast to many previously proposed processes, the process of the present invention requires sub-stantially no water, involves minimal land disruption, and can be conducted with minimal atmospheric pollution.
Figure 1 shows the relative rate of return for 1982 US dollars invested in installing and operating the present process in field applications that have been mathamatically modelled from data obtained by field and laboratory measurements.
A series of injection and production wells is drilled into an oil shale formation 48 m in thickness with 120 m of overburden. The average oil grade of the interval is 20 gallo~s per ton as deter-mined by Fischer Assay.
The well pattern is a seven-spot with each heat injector at ~ ~38~3 the corner of a regular hexagon surrounding a central producing well. The spacing is 22.5 m between producers and injectors. The pattern repeats with producers sharing the injectors in each direction and continues to form a field-wide pattern capable of producing a large quantity of oil. m e injector-to-producer ratio approaches 2 to 1 in a large field. In Example 1 the total oil production is 25,000 barrels per day throughout the life of the project.
The injection wells electrical heaters are cemented into the formation and connected to a power source on the surface. The production wells are equipped with standard oil field pumps for lifting the produced oil to the surface. The electrical injection rate is 3.23 x 106 BTU/well per day. The temperature of the injectors attains 750 C. m e production wells reach a terminal temperature of 300 C after 33-34 years of operation. Production over this period averages 5-6 barrelstday per well, with the average number of active producing wells being from about 4000 to 5000. Heat consumption is 1.1 x 106 BTU/barrel of liquid oil production.
Gaseous products collected from the production wells may be used for on-site generation of electricity or other purposes. m e oil-phase petroleum which is so produced is superior to con-ventionally retorted shale oil. m e relative rate of return which can be expected from the Example 1 situation is illustrated by the "Ex. 1" situation designation on Figure 1.
EXAMæLE 2 A series of injection and production wells are drilled into an oil shale formation 225 m in thickness with 300 m of overburden.
The average grade of the oil shale interval is 26 gallons per ton as detenmined by Fischer assay.
The well pattern is the same seven-spot described in Example 1 except the spacing is 13.5 m between walls instead of 22.5 m. Total production is 25,000 barrels/day troughout the life of the project.
The injector to producer ratio still approaches 2 to 1. In the wells, the heaters and production equipment are similar to those described in Example 1.
~ ~)fiO43 The electrical injection rate is 10.55 x 106 BTU/well per day.
The injection well temperatures reach 750 C and the production wells reach a final temperature of 300 C after a production life of 9-lO years. Production over this period averages 42-43 barrels/day per well, with the average number of active producing wells being about 600. The heat consumption is 5.6 x 105 BTU/barrel of liquid oil produced.
As in Example I, gaseous products can be used for on-site power generation or other purposes and the liquid product will be higher in quality than conventionally retorted shale oil. The relative rate of return which can be expected is illustrated by the "Ex. 2" situation designation on Figure l.
Table 1 lists combinations of oil, shale grades, thicknesses and grade-thickness products which are generally suitable for use in the present process. The relative positions of such grade thickness products with respect to the relative rates of financial return are illustrated by the designations "Preferred Range"(P.R.) and "Especially Preferred Range" (E.P.R.) on Figure 1.
Grade (gallons/ton)Thickness (m) Grade x Thickness goo More desirable grade thickness examples are shcwn as follows:
Grade (gallons/ton)Thickness (m) Grade x Thickness In general, the higher the grade thickness product the mDre desirable. The practical application is limited only by the ability to heat the desired interval.
Field Test ~qeasurements Tests were conducted in an outcropping of an oil shale formation which is typical of substantially impermeable and relatively thick oil shale deposits. Thirteen boreholes were drilled to depths between 6 and 12 m and were arranged to provide a pattern of heat-injection, observation and fluid-production wells, with the boreholes being spaced about 0.6 m apart in order to provide a relatively rapid acquisition of data. Heat was injected at a rate of about 1000 watts per metre for five days. After the heat-injection well temperature had reached 450 C, a temperature fall-off test was run for one day.
Figure 2 shows the vertical thermal profiles in an observation well, as a function of time. The data was fitted to a mathematical solution describing the temperature distribution around a finite-length line source inside a medium of thermal conductivity (parallel to bedding) 3.25 mcal/cm-sec-C and thermal conductivity (perpendicular) 3.25 mcal/cm-sec-C. The specific heat capacity utilized in the calculations was com~uted from the thermal conductivity, thermal diffusivity, and average bulk density of cores recovered during drilling of the wells. The therm~physical properties for the the oil shale in which the tests were conducted are summarized in Table 2.
Initial Reservoir Temperature 9.8 C
Fischer Assay: 20 gallon/ton Bulk Density: 2.20 gm/cm Thermal Diffusivity: 6.6 x 10 3 cm2/sec Specific Heat Capacity: 0.224 cal/gm C
Figure 3 shcws radial profiles ccmputed for the middle of the heated zone for various heating times (t). At the end of a temperature build-up test of 140.5 hours, the average formation temperature between the heater and observation well was 120 C.
~ ~8043 Figure 4 shows a comparison of laboratory values and field data relative to the thermal conductivity parallel to and perpendicular to the bedding planes of the oil shale formation, as a function of temperature. The laboratory conductivity measurements were made on adjacent samples of cores from the observation well, using some cores cut parallel to and some cut perpendicular to the bedding planes. A nitrogen-atm~sphere was used to eliminate oxidation reaction. The samples were constrained in the vertical direction but were free to expand radially. After the samples were heated to 800 C, the radial exFansion averaged 1.45%. As shown in the figures, the laboratory values are in excellent agreement with the values computed from the field data The tests indicate that the thermal conductivity is lower in the direction perpendicular to the bedding plane, because kerogen layers have a lower conductivity than the dolcmite matrix. At temperatures below 100 C, the thermal conductivity is essentially isotropic, as observed in the field tests. But, that conductivity beccmes increasingly anisotropic, as the kerogen is remDved (at temperatures between 300 and 400 C) and gas begins to occupy the spaces between the layers. Abcve 700 C, both the parallel and perpendicular conductivity decrease sharply due to the decomposition of the dolcmite and evolution of CO2.
When a subterranean oil shale formation is heated the oil shale expands as the temperature increases. When the oil shale temperature reaches a kerogen pyrolyzing temperature (for example, from about 275-325 C) additional expansion for oe s are generated.
The kerogen is converted to fluids capable of occupying a larger volume than the kerogen, and such fluids became increasingly pressurized when the temperature is increased. As mDre fluid is formed and mDre fluid is heated, hydraulically induced fractures fonm within the oil shale formation.
Fractures which are hydraulically induced within subterranean earth formations form along planes perpendicular to the least of the three principal compressive stresses (i.e., one vertical and two mutually perpendicular horizontal compressive stresses) which exist within any subterranean earth formation. However, where the ~ 288~43 hydraulic fractures tend to be vertical, horizontal fractures can be formed by injecting heated fluids so that the walls of the vertical fractures are heated until they swell shut. men, by increasing the fluid injection pressure to greater than overburden pressure, a horizontal fracture can be formed. Such processes for thermally inducing the formation of horizontal fractures by injecting externally heated and pressurized fluids are described in patents such as the above-mentioned US Patent No. 3,284,281; US
Patent No. 3,455,391 by C.S. Matthews, P. Vanmeurs and C.W. Volek, and US Patent No. 3,613,785 by P.J. Closmann.
Applicants have llOW discovered that when substantially impermeable subterranean oil shales having the presently specified combination of grade and thickness were conductively heated as presently specified, a zone of permeability was developed between ]S wells within the oil shale. Although the present invention is not premised on any particular mechanism, in the course of such a treatment the heated oil shale behaved as though it was subjected to the above-described type of process for thermally inducing the formation of horizontal fractures. Such a behaviour was not predictable, since the present process is operated without any injection of any fluid. It appears that when the present process is operated within an impermeable oil shale, the in situ generation and displacement of heated and highly pressurized fluids occurs at the times and to the extents needed to successively extend and horizontally fracture through successive portions of the oil shale, when those portions become conductively heated. The zone being heated appears to undergo a relatively uniform, horizontal, radial expansion through the oil shale, at the rate set by the thermal conductivity of the oil shale. In each successive location in which a kerogen pyrolyzing temperature is reached, fluids appear to be formed, heated and pressurized so that substantially any vertical fractures which are formed within the heated zone are subsequently converted to horizontal fractures.
Applicants' tests indicated that substantially all of the fluid pyrolysis products of the oil shale tended to remain in or ., .:
0~3 near the locations in which they were formed until they were displaced, through substantially horizontal fractures, into wells adjoining the heat-injecting wells. In addition, the fracture-inducing pressure of fluids in the horizontal fractures appears to have been reduced as those fluids expanded and were ccoled as they moved away frcm the hottest portions of the heated zone.
Thus, the present process seems to induce the moving of a zone of kerogen-pyrolyzing temperatures through the oil shale immediately behind a zone of localized fracturing in which the fractures are, or soon become, horizontal fractures. The heating and fracturing zones seem to undergo a substantially uniform, horizontal, radial exFansion through the oil shale, until the zone of fracturing reaches a location (such as the borehole of a production well) from which the oil shale pyrolysis products are IS withdrawn.
In addition, applicants have discovered that, at least where the overburden pressure is small, the zone of permeability that is created between adjacent wells retains a significantly high degree of permeability after the formations have cooled. mus it appears that, even if the overburden pressure is high, an application of the present process is capable of forming a well-interconnecting zone in which the permeability remains high or can be readily restored by an injection of fluid after some or all of the heat has dissipated. And, the degree and location of that permeability can be controlled by controlling the rate of removing fluid frcm the producing wells.
The data obtained by measurements in field tests of the type described above were inclusive of: the thermal conductivity of the oil shale formation, the amount of oil recoverable by Fischer analysis at various depths within heated intervals of the oil shale before and after heating, the measurement of the am~Nnt of pyrolysis products recovered, and the like. While no communication existed between heat injectors and producers at test start-up, injections at the end of the test demonstrated that permeable channels had formed. The results of standard engineering , . .
fi~3~3 calculations were indicative of the applicability of a concept of the t~e described above to the results obtained by the tests.
Figure 5 is a graph of Fischer Assay yields, from the target zone in the field test, as a function of depth D. m e heated interval extended from 4.2 to 6 m. The solid curve shows the yields before the heating treatment and the dashed curve shows the yields after retorting was campleted. The yields before and after were essentially the same outside the heated interval. m e measurements were made on cores from the centre of the pattern before heating and on cores about 15 cm away after heating. The variations which are apparent in those yields are within the normal limits of accuracy for the measuring of such values.
Within the heated interval the Fischer Assay yield drops from an average of 20 gallons/ton-before the test to less than 2 gallons/ton after heating. The retorting efficiency within the process zone was thus better than 90~ of Fischer Assay.
The pattern and extent of the recovery confirms the fact that little oil was lost over the producing horizon through vertical fractures. In addition, the uniformity in retorting efficiency through the heated zone, indicates that thermal fronts were approximately uniform over most of the heated interval.
The uniformity of the thermal fronts is even more apparent in Fig~res 6 and 7. m ey shaw horizontal and vertical temperature profiles calculated for a set of vertical heaters in a five-spot square pattern. m e set used in the calculations included four heat injectors and one centre producer (not shawn, but centered between the heaters shawn on the figures). Each heater was assumed to be 24 m long and heated at the rate of 814 W/m.
The profiles in Figure 6 (graphs of temperature variations with distances from the heaters) were calculated along a horizontal segment IlI3 which extends through the mid-points of heaters at opposite corners of the square. Figure 7 is a similar graph of profiles along a vertical segment I5I6 on the axis of symmetry of the pattern.
Such calculations indicate that by the time retorting 0~3 temperatures (275-325 C) are reached at the centre of the pattern, m~re than 87% of its volume has been converted while only about 14%
of the converted volume was heated to more than 325 C. Furtherm~re, the calculations indicate that if the power is turned off or reduced before the centre reaches a target temperature such as 325 C, the levelling off of the thermal fronts will still heat the centre of the pattern to retorting temperatures and will also reduce the temperature rise at the heaters. This mode of operation can ensure that less than 10% of the heated volume is heated to more than 325 C, and thus can increase the thermal efficiency of the process.
In view of the above test results and the calculations based on those results, it appears that, contra to the prior teachings and beliefs, the initial impermeability of an oil shale deposit can be utilized as an advantage. The initial impermeability confines the fluids and fractures within the well pattern, since no permeability exists until the zone between the heat-injecting and fluid-producing wells become permeated by a pattern of heat-induced horizontal fractures.
In the present process, the rate at which heat is transmitted into the oil shale deposit is strongly affected by the temperature gradient between a heat-injecting well and the surrounding earth formation. In a preferred procedure, the determinations of variations with depth in the composition and prcperties of the oil shale deposit include a determination of the pattern of heat conductivity with depth within the earth formations adjacent to the heat-injecting well. Based on such determinations the temperatures to which at least one heat-injecting well is heated are arranged to be relatively high at the depths at which the heat conductivities of the adjacent earth formations are relatively low. m is tends to cause the rate at which heat is transmitted through the earth formations to be substantially unifonm along the axis of the heat-injecting well. Kncwn procedures can be utilized in order to provide higher temperatures in portions of heat injecting wells adjacent to earth formations of relatively low heat conductivity.
)43 For example, in wells which are being heated by electrical resistances, additional resistant elements can be positioned at the location at which extra heating is required, preferably with precautions being taken to avoid the creation of "run-away hot-spots" due to increasing temperature further increasing the resistance and thus further increasing the heating, for example, as described in the commonly asslgned Canadian patent application Serial No. 495,854 filed November 21, 1985, by P. VanMeurs and C.F. Van Egmond. In wells being heated by combustion, more, or larger, or more heavily fired, burner elements can be positioned in such locations.
Suitable determinations of compositions and properties of the minerals and/or organic components of an oil shale deposit and the variatlons with depth in such properties can be made by means of known well logging, reservolr sampling, and the like analytical procedures. The determinations can utilize previously measured geophysical or geochemical data or laboratory or core analyses, etc. For example, the variations with depth in the heat conductivity of the adjacent formations can be determined by calculations based on the kinds and amounts of materials present, and/or by thermal conductivity logging measurements, etc. US
Patent No. 3,807,227 describes a logging tool containing a constant output heat source and three temperature sensors for obtaining a log of relative thermal conductivity with depth. US
Patent No. 3,892,128 describes logging cased or open boreholes for temperature, specific heat and thermal conductivity, employing a constant output heat source and three temperature sensors. US
,t~)4.~3 -20a- 63293-~743 Patent No. 3,864,969 describes a logger for making station measurements of thermal conductivity by heating a formation for a ti.me then measuring the rate at which the temperature decays back to the ambient temperature. US Patent No. 3,981,187 describes logging thermal conductivity of a cased well by measuring the temperature of the casing wall before and after passing a heated probe along the wall.
As indicated above, even with respect to a five-spot pattern in which a single fluid-producing well is surrounded by four heat-injecting wells, substantlally all of the intervening oil ;,r; ~
., . .. -shale can be both retorted and made permeable. Hcwever, the present invention is preferably employed in a series of contiguous seven-or thirteen-spot patterns -- in either of which patterns (particularly in the thirteen-spot pattern) the retorting rate is significantly increased by having each fluid-producing well surrounded by six or twelve heat-injecting wells.
m e wells used in the present process can be completed by substantially any method for drilling a borehole into and/or opening a pre-existing borehole into fluid comm~nication with the subterranean oil shale formation to be used as an oil shale treatment interval. In addition to having the specified absence of significant amounts of mobile water, thickness, and grade of oil shale, the interval to which the present process is applied should be capable of confining fluid at least substantially within the treatment interval~ at least in respect to allowing no significant leakage into overlying locations when the pressure of the fluid reaches process pressuret and fractures the formation within the treatment interval. The boreholes of wells completed for use in the present process should be substantially parallel and separated by substantially equal distances of at least about 6 m. Borehole separation distances between injectors and producers of from about 9 to 30 m are particularly suitable. Boreholes free of deviations from parallel which cause variations of more than about 20 per cent of the well distances are particularly suitable.
In the heat-injecting wells used in the present process, the cement or cement-like material which is used to seal along the face of the oil shale formation is preferably relatively heat-conductive and substantially fluid-impermeable. Particularly preferred cements are stable at temperatures of at least about 800 C, have a relatively high thermal conductivities, relatively low permeability, little or no shrinkage, an adequate ease of pumpability and good chemical resistance, etc. m e permeability and disposition of the sealing material should provide a seal capabl~ of preventing any significant amount of fluid flow between the interior of the borehole and the face of the oil shale formation, so that the ~ 2~3~04~
transfer of heat from the well to the formation is substantially entirely by conduction. Where portions of the heat-injecting well borehole are effectively increased in diameter near upper and lower extremities of the treatment interval, for example, by under-s reaming, the diameters of the increased portions are preferably at least about 110% of the nominal borehole diameter. Calcium aluminate-bonded concretes and/or cements containing alumina-silicate aggregates (or fine particles) are particularly suitable for use as such formation face-sealing materials. Examples of suitable cements and concretes include those described in US
patents such as 3,379,252; 3,507,332 and 3,595,642.
Figure 8 shows a portion of a heat-injecting well borehole, borehole 1, which is suitable for use in the present invention and is located within a treatment interval of subterranean oil shale deposit. Borehole 1 contains enlarged portions, such as portions 2 and 3, which can be formed by conventional procedures such as underreaming during drilling, etc. A casing 4 is shown positioned within the borehole and cemented into place with a fluid-impermeable, heat-conductive material, such as cement.
Within each enlarged borehole portion, the casing 4 is equipped with at least one heat-conductive metal element, such as collar 6, containing radially extensive elements or portions, such as flexible metal members 7. Such heat-conductive materials fonm relatively highly conductive paths for conducting heat from within the interior of a borehole to substantially the wall of an enlarged portion of the borehole. Examples of suitable heat-conductive metal elements include metal wall scratchers, turbulence inducers, centralizers and the like such as a Hammer-Lok Turbcbonder, or Boltlok Turbobonder, available from Bakerline division of Baker Oil Tools or a 101 Bar S centralizer available from Antelope Oil Tbol and Manufacturing Ccmpany, etc.
With an arangement of the type shown in Fig~re 8, at least to some extent, the front of heat transmitted away from a heat-injecting well can be made m~re uniform along a vertical line traversing a layer of relatively low heat conductivity without the necessity of maintaining a higher temperature in the portion of the well adjacent to that layer. When a uniform temperature is maintained within the interior of the borehole, the earth formation face along such an enlarged portion of the borehole becomes heated to substantially the same temperature as the formation face along narrower portions of the borehole. Since the fa oe of the formation adjoining the borehole is heated to the highest temperature of any portion in the formation, the temperature gradient extending radially away from the enlarged portion of the bore-hole is shifted radially away from the borehole.
In general, the heating of the interior of the heat-injecting well can be accomplished by substantially any type of heating device, such as combustion and/or electrical type of heating elements, or the like. The heating element should extend substantially throughout the treatment interval (preferably throughout at least about 80 per cent of that interval). Where a combustion type heating element is used, a gas-fired heater is preferred. The fuel and oxidants for a combustion heater (such as methane and oxygen) are preferably supplied trough separate conduits leading through a heat exchanger in which the inccming fluids are heated by the outflowing combustion products. The burner housing and fluid conduits of a combustion heater are preferably installed within a well conduit which is surrounded by an annular space that is filled by the cement for sealing the face of the oil shale. Generally suitable types of combustion heaters which could be arranged for use in the present process are described in US
Patents such as 2,670,802; 2,780,450 and 2,902,270.
An electrical resistance heater is particularly suitable for heating the interior of a heat-injecting well in the present process. A plurality of resistance elements are preferably used.
The resistance elements can be mDunted within or external to an internal conduit or rod, or simply extended into the borehole. When the resistances are external to, or are free of a supporting element, such as a conduit or rod, they are preferably embedded in the cement which seals the face of the oil shale along the treatment interval. Generally suitable types of electrical heaters which could be arranged for use in the present process are described in US Patents such as 2,472,445; 2,484,063; 2,670,802;
2,732,195 and 2,954,826.
In various reservoir situations, portions of an oil shale deposit ~hich would, in general, be suitable for use as a treatment interval, as described in our parent application, may be permeated by natural fractures and/or planes of weakness. Such relatively weak rocks may undergo relatively long extensions of vertical fractures when pressurized fluids being displaced away from an injection well move into them. mis may result in extending fluid passageways beyond the openings into production wells and/or into adjacent aquifers capable of causing an inflow of water to an extent detrimental to the oil recovery process.
We have now discovered that such premature fracture extensions can be avoided by drilling and heating "guard wells" within such relatively weak oil shale zones in locations surrounding a pattern of heat injecting and fluid producing wells and/or in locations intermittent between a heat injecting or fluid producing well and an adjacent aquifer. Such guard wells are used for conductively heating the adjoining formations substantially throughout the oil shale interval to be treated to a temperature which is too low to gasify significant proportions of the oil shale organic co~ponents but is high enough to cause a significant thermal expansion of the rocks. When those rocks are heated the natural fractures are kept closed and the fracturing caused by the approaching pressurized fluids (displaced away from heat-injecting wells) tends to be limited to horizontal fractures concentrated along the sides nearest to the heat-injecting wells. Where fluid producing wells are located substantially between the heat-injecting wells and the guard wells, the fractures are preferentially extended into those wells, where the high fluid pressures are quickly reduced by the pmduction of the inflowing fluid.
The encountering of such relatively weak reservoir rocks is apt to be indicated by an inflow of water into wells drilled into 304~
- ~.5 -such rocks. In general, the natural fractures creating a relative weaXness and/or water inflow can be thermally closed by a relatively mlld heating, as long as the fracture porosity is not more than about 5 per cent.