CA1076655A

CA1076655A - Underwater cutting rod

Info

Publication number: CA1076655A
Application number: CA279,349A
Authority: CA
Inventors: Jerome S. Brower
Original assignee: Individual
Current assignee: Individual
Priority date: 1977-02-04
Filing date: 1977-05-27
Publication date: 1980-04-29
Also published as: DE2725643A1; NO771282L; MX144360A; DK269877A; FR2379347A1; DE2725643C2; BE854976A; FR2379347B1; IT1079644B; NL7704360A; NO147941B; NO147941C

Abstract

Abstract of the Disclosure A torch for cutting metals and non-metals under water includes an electrode having a tube and a plurality of rods within the tube. Some of the rods are ferrous metal and smaller number of them are a non-ferrous metal selected from the group consisting of Al, Mg, Ti, or alloys thereof Oxygen and electrical power are supplied through the electrode at least to start the cutting with an ionized gaseous cone. The cone persists when power is removed and is terminated by stopping oxygen flow An independently portable apparatus using the torch is disclosed.

Description

107~i5~j This invention relates to a torch for cutting under water.
Electric arc cutting and welding torches are well known in the art.
Such devices as commonly used on the surface are adapted for underwater use in the salvaging of sunken vessels and drill platforms, repairing ships and in the construction and maintenance of subsea structures.
Cutting torches as presently used under water have particularly severe problems in cutting non-ferrous metals, stainless steels and non-con-ductive substances such as cement, concrete, bitumens, barnacles, and other marine growth. Maintaining an arc under water, at any depth, is impossible when the material to be cut is non-conductive. The present generation of arc cutting rods will not penetrate or cut through non-conductive materials, Present arc-oxygen systems cannot function without a power source. Where the power is removed, the arc extinguishes itself, and the rod will not sustain itself in burning. Available arc-oxygen units cannot cut through non-con-ductive materials.
The arc-oxygen method of cutting metals is based on the same prin-ciple as that employed in oxyacetylene cutting. In the latter, the metal is first locally preheated to incandescence by means of the oxyacetylene flame.
When incandescence is reached, a high velocity of oxygen is impinged upon the preheated spot. The oxygen jet performs the double duty of oxidizing or burning the core of the preheated portion and removing the products of combustion. The oxyacetylene flame continuously advances the incandescent spot in preparation for the action of the oxygen stream. In arc-oxygen cut-ting, preheating is performed by the electric arc maintained between the material being cut and the electrode. Since the heat energy available in an arc is much greater than that of an oxyacetylene flame, preheating with the - arc-oxygen method is practically instantaneous. Therefore, the instant the arc is struck, the high velocity oxygen stream is admitted to impinge upon the preheated spot where the same phenomena occur as given for the oxyacetylene cutting. Advancing the electrode along the intended line of cut while the .
: .

107~ 55 electric arc is continuously maintained results in the uninterrupted succession of preheat, oxidation and removal of the burned metal.
An object of this invention is to effectively provide an underwater cutting rod which will solve the problems described above.
A further object of this invention is to provide a cutting electrode and system which is far superior to any previously used in the art. In addi-tion, it is an object to provide an electrode which is lightweight, readily adaptable to most standard rod holders, easy to handle and use, which develops an arc under any non-explosive atmosphere, including water, which ignites the tip of the rod to produce progressive burning, and develops temperatures high enough to melt any known metal, mineral or combination of metals and minerals.
It is a further object of this invention to provide an underwater cutting electrode which will maintain ultrahigh temperatures and continue to burn under water without the continuous presence of an electrical current.
Thus, in accordance with one aspect of the invention there is pro-vided a cutting torch primarily for underwater use comprising an electrode comprising a metallic tube; a plurality of ferrous metal rods within said tube; at least one rod made of a metal selected from the group consisting of aluminum, magnesium, titanium and alloys thereof disposed within said tube; and a layer of insulating material substantially covering the exterior surface of said tube; means for connecting a source of electrical current to said tube; and means for connecting a supply of reactive gas to said tube.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention there is pro-vided a portable cutting torch system primarily for underwater use comprising a portable supply of reactive gas; a portable power supply unit; a cutting torch including a handle portion and an electrode replaceably held in said handle portion; electrical conductor means for interconnecting said power supply unit and said electrode through said handle portion; and conduit means : 30 for conducting gas from said supply to said electrode through said handle ~(~7ti~5S

portion; and wherein said electrode comprises a metallic tube; a plurality of ferrous metal rods within said tube; and at least one rod made of a metal selected from the group consisting of aluminum, magnesium, titanium, and alloys thereof disposed within said tube.
In order that the manner in which the foregoing and other objects are attained in accordance with the invention can be understood in detail, particularly advantageous embodiments thereof will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, which form a part of this specification and wherein:
Figure 1 is a partial side elevation, in partial section, of a torch handle and electrode rod in accordance with the invention;
Figure 2 is an end elevation of the rod of Figure l;
Figure 3 is an enlarged foreshortened side elevation of the rod of Figures 1 and 2, in p~rtial section;
Figure 4 is an enlarged sectional end elevation along lines 4-4 of Figure 3;
Figure 5 is an enlarged sectional end elevation similar to Figure 4 of a second embodiment of a rod in accordance with the invention;
Figure 6 is a schematic drawing of a portable system according to the invention; and Figure 7 is a schematic block diagram of an ignition power supply usable in the system of figure 6.
Referring first to Figure 4, the sectional view of that figure shows an outer shell 10 which comprises a relatively thin-walled lightweight steel tube to provide the outer casing of the cut~ing rod, this tube actingJ
in major part, to conduct electrical current through the rod as will be des-cribed. Tube 10 is supplied with an exterior coating 12 of an electrically non-conductive material which is preferably a plastic such as epoxy, vinyl, acrylic or urethane which acts as an insulative and protective coating for 3Q tube lO. This coating can b~ provided in a simple manner by simply wrapping - ~ , 107f~655 the exterior of the tube with an electrically non-conductive tape. The coating, being an insulator, prevents inadvertant ignition at the side of the rod should the rod be touched against an electrically conductive grounded member accidentally. It thus prevents side-rod sticking as well as side-rod arcing and blowout.
Located inside tube 10 is a plurality of rods 14, each of which is metallic. Some of the rods are made of a ferrous metal, such as steel, and some of the rods are made of a non-ferrous metal or alloys thereof. A typical combination, which has been found to be particularly satisfactory, is steel rods and aluminum rods, the preferred ratio of steel rods to aluminum rods clustered together within the tube being approximately seven steel to one aluminum. However, the cutting rod electrode will operate satisfactorily with a range of ratios between about 3:1 steel to aluminum and about 10:1 steel to aluminum It has been found that the highest temperatures and best burning results are obtained with a ratio of 5-7:1, steel to aluminum. It should also be noted that the aluminum can be replaced by a metal selected from the group consisting of magnesium, titanium, or alloys of two or more of the metals from the group magnesium, aluminum and titanium. Aluminum, however, is preferred.
Figure 1 illustrates a torch handle assembly with which the rod can be used. As shown therein, an electrode rod holder 16 has a central passage which receives rod 10 in a conventional fashion as shown in United States Patent 2,417,650, Kandel, issued March 18, 1947, the holder being connected to a handle 18. The holder and handle have connected passages through which gas can pass, the gas being delivered into a gas inlet tube 20. The gas is usually oxygen although other gases may be used for certain results. A gas flow control handle 22 regulates the volume of gas passing through the handle and into the electrode tube, the flow of gas being controlled by the person handling the torch. An electrical power input cable 24 is connected to a 3~ source of power and provides means for bringing electrical energy to tube 10.

1~76~55 The gas passes through the control valve on the handle and flows through a perforated tube and out of the torch which is held in place in the holder 16 by a collet 26 and a washer 27, the gas passing under pressure between metal rods 14 which are encased in tube 10, the gas igniting the outer distal end of tube 10 adjacent the work point. The oxygen is passed through tube 10 longitudinally at pressures varying from 30 psig to 200 psig along the axis of the cluster of rods 14, passing through the spaces therebetween.
The purpose of this gas medium is twofold. One purpose is to pro-vide an oxidizing envelope at the tip of the tube 10 and to aid in the com-plete combustion at the tip, as well as blowing away the slag. The second purpose is to initiate and maintain a continuous thermitic process at the tip. Provision of the oxygen elevates the temperature at the tip to the white heat range and provides a gaseous cone for the ionized arc to form.
Methods for providing the introduction of oxygen to the rods through the tube, using devices such as the handle and holder generally illustrated, are well known in the art.
An electrical current of from 1.5 to 600 amperes, for example, pro-vided by a conventional generator, and passing through the torch head and collet, is introduced to the cutting tube through conductor cable 24. This current is used to strike an arc at the end of the tube 10 by grounding the end of the rod against the work itself, if the work is conductive, or against a grounded conductive plate if the work is non-conductive. The arc, in conjunction with the flow of oxygen, ignites the cutting rod and establishes the gaseous cone simultaneously. The melting of the binary metallic system of rods within tube 10 occurs at the introduction of the arc, whereupon a eutectic is formed. Oxygen passing into the melt causes an exchange and reformation of A1203-Fe in the proper ratio. Continuous burning occurs so long as the oxygen is present. At this point, temperatures are developed which are high enough to melt metals, alloys, minerals in their natural state, and concrete. The rod will melt these materials underwater at any working 1076~55 depth and on dry land at all altitudes. The electrical current may be applied to the tube 10 and the individual rods 14 on a continuing basis during operation of the torch, or can be shut off once the tube 10 ignites. The ; thermitic process with elevated temperatures will sustain burning with or without the current. However, maintaining the supply of current to maintain the arc when cutting conductive materials increasesthe burning rate by be-tween lS and 20 percent. The tube 10 in conjunction with the feedthrough oxygen burns at about 5,432F, as measured using an optical pyrometer. The burning tip is not quenched by the water. The tube 10 as set forth is this invention, will easily cut, burn or melt through concrete, steel, brass or cast iron under water.
When used to burn through coral, concrete, pipe covering or any marine growth, a conductive starter plate is required. It is a simple grounded contact plate which is placed on, next to, or near the subject target to com-plete the circuit when power is supplied to the torch head. When the arc is struck, it ignites the tube at the tip and the burning is sustained by the ` continuous flow of oxygen. The end of the tube is then moved to the target and melting, burning or cutting begins. Removing the rod from the starter plate does not extinguish the flame at the tip of the rod. This unusual characteristic allows for melting and/or cutting through non-conductive substances. This invention provides a continuous process which consumes the rod from and at the point of contact which results in the super-elevated temperature The transfer of this heat from the tube to the subject results in a lava-like melt and subsequent flow of molten materials away from the point of contact.
Electric arcs, the region where a sharply focused energy beam heats a solid surface, and the impact region on a solid surface of a high-intensity, high-energy particle beam, all have one important feature in common. This ` is the concentration of energy per particle, in a small region, much higher than the conventional equipartition energy at normally obtainable temperatures.

107~;655 This is achieved by utilizing the method of concentrating energy in the re-gion at a rate far greater than it can be removed by the ordinary processes of heat removal such as conduction, convection or radiation. The result is the creation of a highly excited region which can be viewed in many cases of interest as a dense super-heated plasmic cone.
In addition, this invention provides a continuous thermitic reaction cone at the point of work. As stated, the temperature within the apparent plasmic cone is approximately 5,432F.
The classic thermite reaction consists of eight moles of aluminum plus three moles of magnetic iron oxide. The reaction to completion produces four moles of aluminum oxide plus nine moles of molten iron as illustrated by the following; 8A1 1 3Fe304 ---~ 4A12O3 ~ 9Fe. When ignited this mixture produces an enormous quantity of heat, i.e., 758,000 calories per gram molecular weight. This heat is sufficient to raise the temperature of the region to 5,432F.
The rod of the present invention is completely consumed during the operation; thus, no waste product is developed which would cause environmental problems in the use of the device.
When a chemical reaction is subjected to an electric current, or conducted within an electric field, different results are observed and can be attained, depending on the nature of the substances, than normally observed.
The extent of chemical change is dependent, in each case, upon the amount of current which passes.
It has been noted and recorded that the application of current during the cutting operation increases the efficiency of the system by as much as 20~. When the current is removed, the tube continues to burn under water with sufficient energy to cut or me~t all of the materials stated above. Variations of cur~ent from 30 amperes to 600 amperes appear to be the most efficient range of operation depending upon the thickness and thermal conductivity of the target material.
. , The tube 10 and rods 14 of this invention are completely consumed during its operation. The rods of the present invention 14, contained within the tube 10, are used in a diameter of approximately 0.094 inches, although diameters of 0.031 through 0.25 inches may be utilized. However, diameters of approximately 0.094 inches are considered best. There is no flux contained within the rods or tube of the present invention, and there is no packing between the steel and aluminum rods.
The tube 10 may range from about .18 inches in diameter to about .75 inches in diameter with a diameter of about .375 inches considered best.
The thickness of the plastic coating 12 is not critical and thicknesses of about .01 to about .1 inches is normal, and is enough to limit external side wall conductivity, although thicker coatings can be used.
Referring now to Figure 2, there is shown an end view of the tube 10 with the rods 14 and the plastic coating 12.
Figure 3 shows the tube 10 with the rods 14 clustered within. The ends 28 and 30 of rod 10 are crimped to hold the rods in the tube 10.
Various tests were made with rods of the present invention to determine cutting time and performance characteristics. A chart showing the results follows, The tests were done by cutting anchor, chain or steel plate at a 20 to 60 foot depth of water.
:

~076655 o o ~ o _, ~ oo _1 ~ ~ .,1 r~
D ~:: D ~ _~~: ~ ~ _~
¢ .,1 ~ ~ _ .,1 X ~ ~ _ ~ _ ~ ~ _ ~ _ ~ ~ .,1 U~ U~

_~ t_~ h ~ _ ~ c~ _ h ~ ~ 7 E~ O ~ ~ ~
:~ ~ ~ O

~ ~ _ _ _ _ ~ ~ _ _ 8~
;,' ~ ~ U~ U~ U~ U~ U~ V~ U~ .~ U~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ P~ ~ ~ P~ ~
X f~ o o u~ u~ n u~ u~ O O
0~ oo `O I~ t~ I~ t` ~ ~0 X
~, ' ~ h U~ ~
e u~ O O o _, o O o o o o ~0 o o o ~ o o o o o o N ~ O ~I ~I ~I ~I tt~ t~

a~ f, ,, -~ ~ O ~,U~

~ b4 ~ t~ O
3 3 h ~ 3 o ~
F O X-~ o a~ ~

.
g - ~ . . ..

~_ ~ o ~ o~ o . _ ,~ .~ ~ ~ oo o ~o ~
~_ _ _ _ _ _ ~o a~ ~ u, ~
C ,, o . V~ rl ~ ~ g ~C 1~0 O C h .Q O ~ O C h 0 3 ~ t~ h ~ O ~ X
rl ~,C~ tdr~ C
,D O ~ h m ,1 4-1 ~1 ¢ æ~c~ ~C30h t~O ~:) 3 : _ U) 41 ~1 0 ~ C ~
~D oo ~r~ O h h ~ v~ ~ 8 o o g ~ ~ ~O~ : : ~ O :

~.
~ E o ~o C ~ ~ ~
~, , Ul o ~rl h ~ ~
~od ~ ~ ~ ~d ~Oo ~ ¢ : : m ~ ~ _ : ~ :
_ a~ a~ a~
~ ~ ~d v) ~O
~ ~ ~ rO
a>
~ ~ ~ : ~
;~; ~ _l ~n : oo _ ~n : _ :

~ ~ .~1 .,1 .,1 .,1 .,1 ., a~ ~ ul v) v~ v~ v~ u~
:~ ~ ~ ~ ~ P- ~
X h O ul u~ u~ ".~ u~ Il~
0~ o~ ~ O~ ~ O) ~ g g g g g g O
¢ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

'~ ~ C~ O
C ~ h ~
,C O h :~ h H ~ C~
_ It was finally ascertained that 150 amps and 60 to 90 psi over bottom pressure produced the best results at all depths.
It has been found that operation of the above-described apparatus can be improved by concentrating the flow of reactive gas through the electrode, and that such increased concentration can be attained using an electrode made in accordance with the embodiment of Figure 5. As shown therein, the overall structure is similar to that shown in Figures 1 - 4, the difference being in the electrode itself. That electrode includes a tube 40 having an insulating coating or covering 41 on the exterior thereof, as with the embodi-ment of Figure 4. Within tube 40 is a plurality of metal rods including a number of ferrous rods 42 and a non-ferrous rod 43 which can be aluminum or one of the other materials previously mentioned. Again, the ratio of ferrous to non-ferrous materials can be in the range of 3:1 to 10:1 with 7:1 being preferred.
Of particular significance to the embodiment of Figure 5 is the central opening 44 within the cluster of rods. The opening can be formed by placing a central plug (not shown) having a diameter equal to the inside dia-meter of tube 40 less twice the diameter of one of rods 42 or 43 (the diameters of which are substantially equal to each other) inside the tube surrounded by the accompanying rods 42 and 43. The plug can be removed during the crimping operation. This suggested assembly technique is only for purposes of illustration and example and forms no specific part of the invention.
With the electrode having the central opening 44, a concentrated beam of oxygen is created without increasing the pr0ssure. This impinging beam or column of gas allows for increased oxidation and effective slag removal and is easily obtained with the structure of Figure 5. The cutting speed of the torch is thus greatly increased without increasing the current supply or gas structure.
An embodiment of a cutting torch system incorporating an electrode of the type previcusly discussed is shown in Figures 6 and 7, this system being ~(~76655 a portable one which permits cutting to be accomplished at great depths, on the order of 1,000 feet below the surface of the water, without reliance upon cables, umbilicals or other interconnections with a surface vessel. As shown in Figure 6, the components of the system are an electrode 50 which is replace-ably retained in a handle structure 51 having a grip portion indicated gen-erally at 52 with a valve, substantially as shown in Figure 1. An electrical ; conductor 53 interconnects the electrode, through the handle, with a portable power supply unit 54 which is sealed to prevent ingress of water and which is supplied with a carrying strap 55. Finally, the system includes a portable oxygen tank 56 which can also be supplied with carrying straps to be carried on the back of a diver. Oxygen tank 56 is provided with a valve and coupling apparatus indicated generally at 57, the valve and control thereof being conventional in nature. A hose 58 interconnects the valve with the manually operable valve 52 in the handle portion of the device.
The advantage of this portable system is that the power supply can provide sufficient electrical energy to the electrode so that, when the elec-trode is brought into contact with a grounded striker plate, ignition is initiated. Oxygen flow is then commenced, permitting the electrode to continue burning as previously described. The power supply can then be disconnected and no longer used. In this form of the system, the power supply can be relatively small since it need not provide continuous electrical current to assist in the cutting operation. A manually operated switch 59 can be supplied on the power supply unit, which switch can be operated manually and momentarily when ignition is to be started.
; A block diagram of a suitable power supply unit is shown in Figure 7 wherein a battery 60 is connected to an oscillator circuit 61 to supply electrical energy thereto. The oscillator circuit can be of any conventional free-running type to produce an output signal which is approximately sinusoidal in nature. An ON-OFF switch indicated generall~at 62 can be provided to dis-connect the battery from the oscillator circuit when the apparatus is not in :

1071~6S5 use.
The output of the oscillator circuit is connected to the input of a conventional capacitive voltage multiplier circuit 63 which operates to multiply the amplitude of the oscillator circuit and to store the multiplied voltage in a capacitive output circuit. Circuits of this general category are well known and are therefore not described herein in detail. One terminal of the voltage multiplier circuit output is connected to ground and the other, high voltage, terminal thereof is connec~ed through a normally open switch indicated generally at 64 to the conductor 53 which leads to the handle por-tion of the torch assembly. Switch 64 is mechanically interconnected to the switch operator 59 on the exterior of the unit so that depression thereof momentarily closes the switch, permitting the output of the capacitive voltage multiplier to be applied to the electrode through the handle.
A striker plate, which can also be a grounded workpiece, is indi-cated generally at 65. When the exposed end of electrode 50 is brought into contact with plate 65 and when switch operator 59 is depressed to close ; switch 54, the output of the voltage ~ultiplier circuit is applied through the electrode to ground to cause an arc at the end of the electrode to ini-tiate ignition as previously described. Switch 64 can then be permitted to ~0 open and the cutting can be continued with the oxygen flow supplied to the electrode.
Although it is not essential for the exterior surface of electrode 50 to be insulated with a system of this type, such insulation is advantageous in that it prevents inadvertent ignition at an intermediate point along the length of the electrode.
While certain advantageous embodiments have been chosen to illustrate the invention, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications can be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention as defined in the appended claims.

,

Claims

THE EMBODIMENTS OF THE INVENTION IN WHICH AN EXCLUSIVE
PROPERTY OR PRIVILEGE IS CLAIMED ARE DEFINED AS FOLLOWS:

1. A cutting torch primarily for underwater use comprising an electrode comprising a metallic tube; a plurality of ferrous metal rods within said tube; at least one rod made of a metal selected from the group consisting of aluminum, magnesium, titanium, and alloys thereof disposed within said tube;
and a layer of insulating material substantially covering the exterior sur-face of said tube; means for connecting a source of electrical current to said tube; and means for connecting a supply of reactive gas to said tube.

2. A torch according to claim 1 wherein the ratio of steel rods to aluminum rods is between about 3 to 1 and about 10 to 1.

3. A torch according to claim 1 wherein the ratio of steel rods to aluminum rods is 7 to 1.

4. A torch according to claim 1 wherein said tube is crimped at each end to hold the rods disposed therein.

5. A torch according to claim 1 wherein the gas supplied is oxygen at a pressure between about 55 psig and about 200 psig.

6. A torch according to claim 1 wherein the electrical current supplied is between about 30 and about 600 amperes.

7. A cutting torch according to claim 1 wherein said ferrous rods and said at least one rod are arranged in said tube against the inner surface thereof with the centers of said rods lying substantially on a circle having as its center the central axis of said tube, the arrangement of said rods defining a central channel along the axis of said tube.

8. A cutting torch primarily for underwater use comprising an electrode comprising a metallic tube; a plurality of ferrous metal rods within said tube; at least one rod made of a metal selected from the group consisting of aluminum, magnesium, titanium, and alloys thereof disposed within said tube;
and a layer of insulating material substantially covering the exterior sur-face of said tube; means for connecting a source of electrical current to said tube and for supplying electrical current thereto; and means for con-necting a supply of reactive gas to said tube, said ferrous rods and said at least one rod being arranged in said tube against the inner surface there-of with the centers of said rods lying substantially on a circle having as its center the central axis of said tube, the arrangement of said rods de-fining a central channel along the axis of said tube.

9. A portable cutting torch system primarily for underwater use com-prising a portable supply of reactive gas; a portable power supply unit; a cutting torch including a handle portion and an electrode replaceably held in said handle portion; electrical conductor means for interconnecting said power supply unit and said electrode through said handle portion; and conduit means for conducting gas from said supply to said electrode through said handle portion; and wherein said electrode comprises a metallic tube; a plurality of ferrous metal rods within said tube; and at least one rod made of a metal selected from the group consisting of aluminum, magnesium, titanium and alloys thereof disposed within said tube.

10. A system according to claim 9 wherein said handle portion includes manually operable means for controlling the flow of said gas to said electrode.

11. A system according to claim 9 wherein said power supply unit in-cludes a battery; and circuit means connected to said battery for producing an output voltage which is a multiple of the battery terminal voltage and for supplying said output voltage to said conductor means.

12. A system according to claim 11 wherein said circuit means in said power supply unit includes manually operable switch means for controlling the connection of said output voltage to said conductor means.

13. A system according to claim 12 wherein said circuit means further includes an oscillator connected to said battery, and a capacitive voltage multiplying circuit connected to said oscillator and to said switch means.