CA1048164A - Method and apparatus for improved focusing of ion currents in quadrupole mass filters - Google Patents

Abstract

Abstract of the Disclosure Application of dc potentials of values other than ground to materials which appear as conductors to dc and low frequency ac electric fields and as dielectrics to high frequency ac electric fields in order to compensate for changes of potential due to ion and electron currents reaching the material and/or to provide for improved focusing of the ions, particular-ly with large ion curents, into a quadrupole mass filter.

Description

L6~
The quadrupole mass filter of W. Paul et al described in United States Patent No. 2,939,952, issued June 7, 1960, consists of four sub-stantially parallel hyperbolic sheet electrodes (or cylindrical rods~, symmetrically disposed about an axis. Opposite rods are electrically connected. On one pair of electrically connec~ed oppositely disposed electrodes a dc voltage, U~ and an ac voltage of amplitude, V, are placed.
On the other pair of electrically connected oppositely disposed electrodes identical voltages, except having an electrical polarity opposite to the first pair, are placed. With proper settings of the dc voltage and the amplitude of the ac voltages, ions of a given charge-to-mass ratio have stable trajectories and oscillate about the axis whereby they do not collide with the eleckrodes; ions of other than the given charge-to-mass ratio are on unstable trajectories whereby they strike the electrodes. If ions are injected along the axis of the electrode structure, those with the given charge-to-mass ratio do not strike the electrodes and emerge from the opposite end of the electrode structure; however~ ions with other than the given charge-to-mass ratio are accelerated in the transverse directions so that they collide with the electrodes and therefore do not emerge from the opposite end of the electrode structure. In this manner~ the electrode structure functions as an ion "mass filter."
As no~ed in United States Patent No. 3,129,327 to W.M. Brubaker of April 14, 1964, an ion entering the electrode structure must pass through fringe fields near and beyond the end o-f the electrode struckure. The ions must also pass through a similar fringe field in emerging from the opposite end of khe electrode structure. As pointed out in the aforesaid patent of W.M. Brubaker, the ratio of the dc field strengths to ac field strength in the fringe fields is the same as in the electrode structure itself. Also, .
as disclosed in the aforesaid patent, an ion of the given charge-to-mass ratio, which is stable within the electrode structure proper, is on an unstable .- ~

.6fl~
trajectory when it is in the fringe fields. Thus, although an ion would be stable within the electrode structure proper, it may not be received in the electrode structure proper due to its unstable trajectory in the fringe fields. This greatly reduces the transmission of ions of a given charge-to-mass ratio due to their rejection while within the fringe fields.
Patent No. 3,129,327 further teaches that the ion trajectories can be stabilized on passage through the fringe fields provided that the ratio of the dc voltage (U) to the ac voltage amplitude (V) is reduced to a lower value than appropriate for use within the electrode structure proper.
The aforesaid patent indicates several ways in which this can be accomplished in the case of quadrupole mass filters which have conventional metal electrodes. But the patent does not address itself to the broader problem of spatial separation of ac and dc fields emanating from the same metallic electrodes.
~q~ ,c, t~
The copending Canadian patent application Serial No. 234,491~filed -August 29, 1975 teaches that separation of the high frequency ac fringe fields from the low frequency (including dc) fringe fields, is possible by placement of a tube or other appropriate geometrical configuration near an end or ends of a quadrupole mass filter wherein the tube is composed of a material which appears as a dielectric to the high frequency ac fringe fields and as a conductor to the low frequency (including dc) fringe fields. A required characteristic of such material is that the parameter 4~/f~ be much less than unity in value, where a is the dc electrical conductivity of the material and is the material's dielectric constant. The angular frequency, G~ is equal to 2~f where f is the frequency of the high-frequency ac fields.
-.:
Materials having the necessary physical characteristics exist and are readily available. Among such materials is a Nickel-zinc type ferrite manufactured by StackpoleCarbon Company of St. Mary's, Pennsylvania, known as " ~erramag C/12," which has a volume resis-tivity at 25 C. of about 3 x 10 ~f~Q~

-2-. . .
, . . . . .
, :
. , .' ' ~ ' ' ' ' ,: '' ~8~6~
ohm-cm and a dielectric constant at l.OMHz of about 10. When ions or electrons or both pass inside and along the length of a tube of such mate-rial, some of said ions or electrons or both strike the tube's walls producing effectively dc electrical currents within the material which may affect the dc potential of the tube. I'he dc potential of the tube can thus be changed through the IR drop of such currents, so that trajectories of ions which do not strike the tube's walls but pass on into the quadrupole mass filter are affected adversely. Another nickel-zinc ferrite manufactured by Stackpole Carbon Company which may be utilized in the invention, Cerramag C/ll, has a resistivity of 2 x 10 ohm-cm. A still further substance which ~- has been tested and found operable is slate, the test sample having a resistivity of 1.0 x 106 ohm-cm along two axes and 2.2 x 106 ohm-cm along the third axis. The dielectric constant of slate is 6.0 - 7.5. The basic - formula for the ferrites, Cerramag C/12 and Cerramag C/ll, may be found in the patent of Zerbes No. 3,036,009 wherein other characteristics of the ferrite not important to the instant invention are discussed.
It is essential that the shield in the instant invention must appear to high-frequency ac fields as a dielectric and to low frequency, including direct current, fields as a conductor. Thus, for frequencies on the order of one megahertz, the resistivity must be substantially greater than 105 ohm-cm. However, the materials utilized for the shielding effect are to be contrasted with good dielectrics which have resistivities of 10 2 ohm-cm and higher. It is important that the resistivity of the material be not so high as to be unable effectively to conduct away current caused by ions or electrons which may strike the material during their transmission or receipt thereinq Also, there are practical upper limits on the resistivity which basically relate to the sweep rate 'which may be utilized in the quadrupole mass filter. In this connection, it is to 'be understood ~ that the substantially dc fields may be fields in a mass filter up to about ; -3-loss llz because this is about the limit of the sweep rate of thc quadrupole mass filter. Thus, it is desirable that the material act like a conductor at a frequency up to 1000 Hz but as a dielectric at one million Hz. As a practical matter, materials having resistivities up to about 108 ohm-cm are operable even at the maximum sweeping rate. By reducing the sweep rate and in many applications a sweep rate of about 10 Hz is all that is desirable, materials with resistivities up to about 101 ohm-cm are operable. Still further, there are bona fide applications wherein resistivities up to about 1011 ohm-cm. However, a resistivity up to roughly 108 ohm-cm offers improve-ment in every application of a quadrupole mass filter. From the foregoingit will be understood by those skilled in the art that the upper limit of resistivity of the shielding material varies depending upon the sweep rate desired in the mass filter, the configuration of the shield a~l the total ion current necessary for the shield to carry off.
The present invention relates to an improved spatial separation of fields emanating from electrodes wherein such fields are produced from superpositions of the dc or low-frequency ac and high frequency voltages placed on the electrodes, such fringe fields being produced in the vicinity of the ends of the electrode structure of a quadrupole mass filter. More particularly, the invention involves the biasing of tha material affecting the spatial separation in a dc fashion away from ground potential whereby the effects of dc currents produced within the material are overcome to ; permit a free passage of ions into the quadrupole mass filter.
In accordance with this invention there is provided a me~thod of mass analysis which utilizes a quadrupole mass filter and comprises the steps of producing positive ions with an initial kinetic energy Ei rom an ion source having an electrical potential Us, introducing said ions into the space between the poles of the quadrupole mass filter wherein the electric potential along the axis of said poles is U , causing the transmission of only those ions of a selected mass-to-charge ratio through the space between said poles, providing a selective shielding at least one end of said poles which functions substantially as a conductor to the substantially dc fields ~ -4-.

and substantially as a dielectric to ac fields, said shielding having an ~ electric connection at a potential of UE, and maintaining said potential UE
less than said potential U , and said potential U less than said potential of Us plus Ei/e where e is the charge of the ion.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention there is provided a device for improving the efficiency of injection and/or transmission of ions passing through a quadrupole mass filter, said device comprising an ion source having an electric potential Us, means for producing ions from said ion source having an initial kinetic energy of Ei, a selective shielding at at least one end of the poles of the quadrupole mass filter adapted to receive said ions therethrough, said shielding functioni.ng substantially as a con-ductor to the substantially dc fields and substantially as a dielectric to the ac fields produced by said poles, said shielding having electric connec-tion to a potential of UE, means for causing the transmission of said ions through said quadrupole mass filter, means for maintaining an electric potential along the axis of said poles of Up, and biasing means in said quadrupole mass filter for maintaining said potential UE less than said potential Up and said potential Up less than said potential Us ~ Ei/e wherein e is the charge on the ion.
Other adaptabilities and capabilities of the invention will be ~ appreciated by those skilled in the art with reference to the following - description and the drawing wherein a schematic representation of the invention is shown.
: With reference to the Figure, a selective electric field shielding means composed of a material which is a conductor to dc and low-frequency -4a-`~ ~
, .

.
;:; .

electrical ac fields and a dielectric to high-frequency electric ac fields, is shown as tube 17, one end of which protrudes a short distance into the space between the four rods, or hyperbolic sheets, of a quadrupole mass filter, the forward two of which are designated 11+ and 12-, and the more rearwardly two as seen in the Figure are designated 1~ and 1~-. The other end of tube 17 is mounted in an end plate 18 which is electrically conducting and in dc electrical contact with tube 17 at their juncture.
Ions produced from an ion source 21 are drawn from source 21, pass through the opening 20 in end plate 18 and enter the interior of tube 17.
With tube 17 composed of material having the proper ratio o-f electrical conductivity to dielectric constant, as described in the aforesaid copending patent application Serial No. 234,491, some ions follow trajectories such as l9a and enter the massfilter. mese ions are those having masses greater than about 0.77 times the mass of the ions to be transmitted through the mass filter at any given setting of its fields. Ions with masses less than about 0.77 times the mass of the ions to be transmitted by the mass filter (and any electrons that might accompany the ions) are caused by the ac fields within the interior of tube 17 to strike its interior walls. Such trajectories are designated by reference characters l9b and 19c.
Inasmuch as tube 17 is constructed of a material with high resistivity within a range of above 6 x 10 to less than 109 ohm-cm~
typically of the order of 10 ohm-cm, tube 17 has an electrical resistance.
Thus the ions or electrons or both striking the interior walls of tube 17 produce electric currents which are of necessity, conducted to the circuit common 30 or ground through the tube material itself. Typical dimensions of tube 17 are about one or two centimeters in length, an interior diameter ; of from two to six millimeters and wall thicknesses of two or three millimeters; the total resistance of the tube is several tens of megaohms :
and reaches values of the order of 10 ohms. Thus, with currents reaching ~5--. .

-8~64 the interior walls being as high as a few times 10 amperes, voltages along tube 17 of in the range of several volts result.
Referring to the electrical portions of the Figure, when positive ions are produced inside an ion source 21 at a potential Us with respect to the circuit common 30 potential, they have a kinetic energy of eUs ~ Ei, e being the value of the charge of the ion and Ei the kinetic energy with which the ion is initially produced, at any point where the existing potential is that of the circuit common 30. In particular, if the value of UE, provided by a dc voltage supply, is zero, the ions have a kinetic energy of eUs + Ei in passing through opening 20 in end plate 18. Under these circumstances, positive ions striking the interior walls of tube 17 cause positive dc voltages to build up along the length of the tube extending into the mass filter. These voltages, if small, cause the tube to act as an unwanted lens which defocuses the ion beam in unwanted ways. Moreover, if the ion currents become sufficiently large, potentials within the tube 17 may increase to the value of Us, in which case ions that would normally follow a trajectory such as l9a lose their kinetic energy within the tube and are not transmitted. The possibility exists that this situation may develop when end plate 18 is grounded as taught by copending Patent Application Serial No. 3~6,250.
A solution to the problem lies in increasing the value of Us to where the ion's kinetic energy is necessarily greater than the product of the maximum current from the ion source times the resistance of tube 17 divided by the charge on the ions. However, for ion sources which produce ion currents in excess of 10 amperes, this solution has serious drawbacks as will be discussed.
It is customary to operate the quadrupole mass filter by applying .
thereto a combination of radio frequency ac voltages generated by source V
of the Figure and dc voltages represented by the battery symbols in the ., .
, .
.

~48~6~

Figure and designated U therein. Blocking condensers, Cl and C2, and radio frequency chokes RFCl and RFC2 prevent the ac and dc voltage sources from shorting each other out and permit application of both the ac and dc voltages to the four poles 11 +~12 -, 13 + and 14 -.
It is also usual to include two voltage sources of equal values, sources U on either side of a point 31. By this means, the dc potential at the axis of the mass filter is the same as the potential, U31 at point 31.
The kinetic energy of the ions during their passage through the - mass filter is given by Ei plus the ion charge, e times (Us ~ U31), both o potentials Us and U31 being measured with respect to the circuit common. If US is increased to excessively high values, the ion kinetic energy during passage through the mass filter is increased to the point where the ion executes too few oscillations at the ac frequency within the mass filter to permit the mass filter to provide good mass resolution. Raising the potential US to the values required to overcome the voltages on tube 17 in the case of large ion currents leads to having excessive ion energy within ~he massfilter under these normal operating conditions.
With an understanding of the foregoing two improved solutions are presented:
The first is to place end plate 18 not at the circuit common potential but at a lower dc potential UE as represented by the battery symbol in Figure 1. Because it is only the potential difference Us ~ UE
which determines whether ions pass through the tube 17, the difference can - be made large by increasing UE while holding Us at a low enough value to give the required low energy of the ions in passing through the mass filter.
Referring to the Figure, this solution is appropriate to having the pole potential U be ~ero, so that the potential of the mass filter axis, which is equal to U31, is at the potential of the circuit common.
A second solution is to let the potential of the end plate 18 be '' ;' ' , ' . ,' , ~4~L6~

the same as the circuit common, by letting the value of UE be zero. This requires that the value of Us be relatively high in order to have ions be able to be transmitted through the tube 17. However~ by placing potential U at a value slightly less than the value of Us, the ions are slowed down to a low energy, e(Us - U ), for their passage through the mass fi]ter, which may be sufficiently low to obtain good resolution in the mass filter.
Either solution or both in combination have been used with success.
Where negative ions rather than positive ions are involved, the same solutions to the problem are applicable by merely reversing the signs of the potentials Us, UE, and U .
Tests have been conducted using an Extranuclear Laboratories quadrupole mass filter, Model 324-9, which has poles 3/4~' diameter. A tube 17 of Ceramag C/12, of length 1.5 cm, outside diameter of 1.2 cm and inside diameter 0.6 cm, and with an end-to-end resistance of 6 x 10 ohms, was mounted on a stainless steel end plate 18 by means of pressing tube 17 into a recess that was cut into the end plate. An electron impac~ ioni~ation source, Extranuclear Laboratories, Model 041-1, was used to make both positive and negative ions. The positive ion currents produced by this ionizer are in excess of 10 milliamperes per torr of gas being ionized, so that when operating in a vacuum of 10 torr, a current of 10 amperes is caused to pass through tube 17. ~fost of this current is from ions of low mass ranging from twelve through eighteen amu (carbon ions through water ions) and from twenty-eight through ~orty-four amu (nitrogen carbon dioxide).
When the mass filter is set to examine ions at higher masses, such as mercury ions at 200 amu, the ac fields within tube 17 cause the lighter ions, which constitute almost all of the 10 amps of ions coming from the ionizer to strike the interior walls of tube 17. This current, being carried to the .
end plate through the tube material, theoretically caused the potential within the tube to increase to about 6 x 10 ohms times 10 amps, or 6 volts.

.

6~

In the first test, both the potentials of the end plate 18 and of the mass filter axis were placed at ground potential by grounding the circuit common and setting UE = Up = 0. It was found that to cause any ions to pass through the mass filter, it was necessary to set the ion source potential Us in excess of eight volts. By reducing the total ion current coming from the source through using a reduced electron current, and thus ; reducing the total current of ions reaching the interior of tube 17, it was found that Us could be reduced to as low as one volt, and still cause ions to pass through the mass filter. Under the first circumstances it is calculated that of the minimum eight volts required, some two ~olts were ~ required to compensate for electron space charge within the ionizer and the ;~ remaining SiY volts are attributed to voltages built up in the tube 17 by ion currents reaching its interior wallsO
It was also found that at the eight volts value of Us the shape of the mass peaks and their resolution showed the typical effects of having an excessive ion energy for transmission through the mass filter.
~ wo further tests were then performed. In the first the potential of the axis of the mass filter was increased by application of positive voltage U . It was found that U could be increased to approximately six volts without appreciable loss of ion current and that such increases improved the shapes of the mass peaks and the resolution.
In the second test the mass filter axis was again placed at ground potential, by making U = 0, and the ion source potential placed at Us was two volts. ~ negative potential UE was then applied to the end plate 19.
It was found that to cause ion current to pass through the mass filter, it was necessary that the value of U~ be at least six volts negative. Under these conditions the mass peaks showed both good shape and good resolution .
as expected for the low energy of the ions during transmission through the mass filter. Making the magnitude of UE less than six volts away from ground _g_ ., , .

~4~ 4 seriously reduced the transmitted ion current. Making the magnitude of UE
greater than six rolts away from ground has only minor effects on the ion current and virtually no effect on the peak shape and resolution of the mass filter. These observations are interpreted as confirming the theory described abovc.
In a second set of tests, negative ions were produced in the source. The negative ion examined was 0 produced by dissociative attach-ment of electrons of 2 molecules. This process has its maximum cross-section at an electron energy of about 6.5 eV, and this was the energy of the electrons used in the tests. At this low energy, the accelerating fields of the ion source used to extract the negative ions also cause some of the electrons to be extracted so that the ion beam presented to the mass filter is a mixture of negative ions and electrons with the vast majority of the particles being electrons.
It was found that with the axis of the mass filter at ground ~ potential and with the end plate 18 grounded, under certain ion optics - tuning conditions it was necessary to raise the potential Us of the ion source to a value of negative twenty volts in order to observe ions transmitted by the mass filter. At this potential, the peak shapes and mass resolution of the emerging ions were seriously distorted in a manner characteristic of excess ion energy. It was found that placing a bias voltage at Up of a negative fifteen volts considerably improved the peak shapes and resolution without engendering a loss of 0 ion current in accordance with the theory.

~; .

Claims (22)

THE EMBODIMENTS OF THE INVENTION IN WHICH AN EXCLUSIVE
PROPERTY OR PRIVILEGE IS CLAIMED ARE DEFINED AS FOLLOWS:

1. In a method of mass analysis which utilizes a quadrupole mass filter and comprises the steps of producing positive ions with an initial kinetic energy Ei from an ion source having an electrical potential US, introducing said ions into the space between the poles of the quadrupole mass filter wherein the electric potential along the axis of said poles is Up, causing the transmission of only those ions of a selected mass-to-charge ratio through the space between said poles, providing a selective shielding at least one end of said poles which functions substantially as a conductor to the substantially dc fields and substantially as a dielectric to ac fields, said shielding having an electric connection at a potential of UE, and maintaining said potential UE less than said potential Up, and said potential Up less than said potential of US plus Ei/e where e is the charge of the ion.

2. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein said potential UE
is maintained at a ground potential and both said potentials US + Ei/e and Up are maintained positive with respect to ground.

3. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein said potential of the mass filter axis Up is set to ground potential and said potential UE is maintained negative and said potential US + Ei/e is maintained positive with respect to ground potential.

4. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein the ions are produced initially at rest whereby Ei = 0.

5. A method in accordance with claim 4, wherein the ions are produced by electron impact ionization.

6. A method in accordance with claim 4, wherein the ions are produced by photo-ionization.

7. In a method of mass analysis which utilizes a quadrupole mass filter and comprises the steps of producing negative ions with an initial kinetic energy Ei from an ion source having an electric potential US, introducing said ions into the space between the poles of the quadrupole mass filter wherein the electric potential along the axis of said poles is Up, causing the transmission of only those ions of a selected mass-to-charge ratio through the space between said poles, providing a selective shielding of at least one end of said poles which functions substantially as a conductor to the substantially dc fields and substantially as a dielectric to the ac fields, said shielding having electric connection at a potential of a UE, and maintaining in the negative charge sense said potential UE less than said potential Up, and Up less than said potential US + Ei/e where e is the charge on the ion.

8. A method in accordance with claim 7, wherein said potential UE
is maintained at ground potential and both said potentials US + Ei/e and Up are maintained negative with respect to ground.

9. A method in accordance with claim 7, wherein the potential of the mass filter axis Up is set to ground potential and said potential UE is maintained positive and said potential US + Ei/e is maintained negative with respect to ground potential.

10. A method in accordance with claim 7, wherein the ions are produced initially at rest whereby Ei = 0.

11. A method in accordance with claim 10, wherein the ions are produced by electron impact ionization.

12. A method in accordance with claim 10, wherein the ions are produced by photo-ionization.

13. A device for improving the efficiency of injection and/or transmission of ions passing through a quadrupole mass filter, said device comprising an ion source having an electric potential US, means for producing ions from said ion source having an initial kinetic energy of Ei, a selective shielding at at least one end of the poles of the quadrupole mass filter adapted to receive said ions therethrough, said shielding functioning substantially as a conductor to the substantially dc fields and substantially as a dielectric to the ac fields produced by said poles, said shielding having electric connection to a potential of UE, means for causing the transmission of said ions through said quadrupole mass filter, means for maintaining an electric potential along the axis of said poles of Up, and biasing means in said quadrupole mass filter for maintaining said potential UE less than said potential Up and said potential Up less than said potential US + Ei/e wherein e is the charge on the ion.

14. A device in accordance with claim 13, wherein said ion source produces positive ions and said potential UE is maintained less than said potential Up and said potential Up is maintained less than said potential US + Ei/e in the positive sense.

15. A device in accordance with claim 14, wherein said biasing means is adapted to maintain said potential UE at ground potential and both said potentials US + Ei/e and Up at positive potential with respect to the ground.

16. A device in accordance with claim 14, wherein said means for establishing said potential Up is set to ground potential and said biasing means maintains said potential UE negative and said potential US + Ei/e positive with respect to ground potential.

17. A device in accordance with claim 13, wherein said means for producing ions produces said ions at rest whereby Ei = 0.

18. A device in accordance with claim 17, which includes electron impact ionization means for producing said ions.

19. A device in accordance with claim 17, including photo-ionization means wherein said ions are produced by photo-ionization.

20. A device in accordance with claim 13, wherein said ions source produces negative ions and said biasing means maintains said potential UE
less than said potential Up and said potential Up less than said potential US + Ei/e in the negative sense.

21. A device in accordance with claim 20, wherein said biasing means maintains said potential UE at ground potential and both said potentials US + Ei/e and Up are maintained negative with respect to the ground.

22. A device in accordance with claim 20, wherein said means for establishing the potential for the mass filter axis Up maintains such potential at ground potential and said biasing means is adapted to maintain said potentials UE and US + Ei/e negative with respect to ground potential.