AU716124B2 - Cytoplasmic male sterile brassica oleracea plants which contain the polima CMS cytoplasm and are male sterile at high and low temperatures - Google Patents

Description

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -1- CYTOPLASMIC MALE STERILE BRASSICA OLERACE PLANTS WHICH CONTAIN THE POLIMA CMS CYTOPLASM AND ARE MALE STERILE AT HIGH AND LOW TEMPERATURES FIELD OF THE INVENTION The present invention involves cytoplasmic male sterile Brassicaoleracea plants that contain polima CMS cytoplasm, are male sterile at high and low temperatures, and exhibit good female fertility.

BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION In an effort to increase the productivity of plants and food crops, plant breeders generally develop cultivars that contain certain desirable characteristics such as increased height, growth rate, higher yields, etc. One of the ways in which this may be accomplished is by infusing desirable characteristics into a plant to form a superior plant line. Superior lines are then combined to form an F, hybrid that contains the desirable characteristics. Such superior hybrids can be developed in numerous ways.

One popular way of producing superior hybrids is by using male sterility in one of the plants for which hybridization is desired. Male sterile lines allow the breeder to produce hybrid seed more economically by controlling cross-fertilization in the flower of a plant. Cross-fertilization can be controlled by preventing the female parent from self fertilizing.

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -2- Self-fertilization is eliminated by making the plant male sterile. If the plant is male sterile, then no pollen can be produced for fertilization. Once rendered male sterile, the plant may then be hybridized with a gene donor plant possessing the desired characteristics.

One way to effectuate male sterility is through the use of cytoplasmic male sterility. Present belief is that genetic factors controlling cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) are found in the cytoplasm, particularly in the genes of the mitochondrial

DNA.

Three of the most common cytoplasmic male sterilities in the Brassica species are: 1) Ogura male sterile cytoplasm of Raphanussativu; 2) Polima male sterile cytoplasm of Brassicanapus; and 3) Nap male sterile cytoplasm of Brassicanapus.

In Brassica, cytoplasmic male sterility can be transmitted by crossing. The female (egg) parent contributes the cytoplasm, therefore, crossing to CMS females produces CMS progeny. The nuclear genes however are heterozygous. Therefore, six to eight generations of "backcrossing" are necessary to produce a CMS line breeding homozygous for nuclear characters. As an alternative, cytoplasmic male sterile lines can also be produced by protoplast fusion. In protoplast fusion, a WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -3protoplast from a plant having commercially desirable traits is combined with a protoplast of a CMS line. The nuclear material of the CMS line is either removed or inactivated prior to fusion so it donates only the cytoplasm. The resulting cytoplasmic hybrid (or cybrid) possesses the CMS cytoplasm and is male sterile. For example, U.S. Patent 5,254,802 discloses B. oleracea plants that contain the Ogura CMS cytoplasm. These plants were obtained by protoplast fusion.

Polima CMS cytoplasm has been used to produce CMS in varieties such as winter-type oil seed rape (Brassica napus) (See Barsby et al., Plant Science, 53: 243-248 (1987)). However, one significant problem with the expression of cytoplasmic male sterility by the polima CMS cytoplasm is that the polima cytoplasm is influenced by environmental conditions. Fan, Z et al. Can. J.

Plant Sci. 66:221-227 (1985). More specifically, male sterile plants containing polima CMS cytoplasm are known to become fertile under high temperatures in the field.

Id. See also Fu, Encarpia Cruciferea Newsletter 6: 6-7 (1981).

The present invention involves Brassicaoleracea plants that contain Polima CMS cytoplasm which remain male sterile at high and low temperatures and exhibit good WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -4female fertility. The Brassicaoleracea plants of the present invention can be produced by traditional breeding methods. Different Brassica types can then be developed by further crossings or backcrossings or by protoplast fusion.

To obtain the Brassicaoleracea plants of this invention by traditional breeding techniques, an interspecific cross was made between Brasicacampestris cultivar 87110 and Brassicaoleracea cultivar 87101. The seeds resulting from the cross are collected, planted and regenerated. The resulting plants are Brassicanapus and contain a haploid set of chromosomes. The chromosomal content of said Brassica napus must be doubled by treating the plants with colchicine.

A second interspecific cross is performed by crossing Brassicanapus cultivar 87118 with Brassicaoleracea cultivar 87101. The seeds resulting from the cross are collected, planted and regenerated. As in the previous cross, the resulting plants are Brassicanapus and contain a haploid set of chromosomes. The plants are treated with colchicine to double their chromosome content.

The Brassicanapus plants produced as a result of the second interspecific cross are next crossed with a Brassica napuscultivar 87102, which contains polima CMS cytoplasm WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 and is male sterile. The seeds resulting from the cross are collected, planted and regenerated. The regenerated plants are Brassicanapus and contained the polima CMS cytoplasm.

The resulting plants are subsequently crossed with the Brassicanapus plants produced as a result of the first interspecific cross. The seeds resulting from the cross are collected, planted and regenerated. The regenerated plants are Brassicanapus, contain the Polima CMS cytoplasm and are male sterile.

The resulting plants are then crossed with a normal Brassicaoleracea. As a result of the cross, siliques are produced, collected and examined for seeds. The seeds are collected for embryo rescue, because typically, embryos produced from such interspecific hybridization abort prior to maturation. However, by employing embryo rescue techniques, interspecific hybrid plants can be produced. The resulting F, plants contain the polima CMS cytoplasm from the female Brassicanapus, however; the nuclear DNA content is a combination of the Brassicanapus (N=19) and the Brassica oleracea The resulting plants are then backcrossed with a Brassicaoleracea. Siliques are again produced, collected and 6 examined for seeds. The seeds are collected for embryo rescue. The embryos are then regenerated as in the previous cross. The resulting plants are intermediate for chromosome number and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm. The nuclear content of the plants is a combination of Brassica napus and Brassica oleracea.

The resulting plants are then backcrossed with Brassica oleracea. Siliques are again produced, collected and examined for seeds. The seeds are sown. The resulting plants are Brassica oleracea which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm.

Thus in one embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for producing 0o cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and which contain polima CMS cytoplasm, the method comprising the steps of: a) crossing Brassica campeslris cultivar 87110 having ATCC Accession Number 97246 with Brassica oleracea cultivar 87101 and collecting the seeds resulting Is from said cross; *:so b) regenerating said seeds into Brassica napus plants which contain a haploid set of chromosomes; c) doubling the chromosomes of the plants of step b to provide Brassica napus plants containing a diploid set of chromosomes; 20 d) crossing Brassica campestris cultivar 87118 having ATCC Accession Number 97247 with Brassica oleracea cultivar 87101 and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; e) regenerating said seeds from step d into Brassica napus plants which contain a haploid set of chromosomes; 25 f) doubling the chromosomes of the plants of step e to provide Brassica napus plants containing a diploid set of chromosomes; g) crossing the plants of step f with Brassica napus cultivar 87102 which is male sterile and contains polima CMS cytoplasm and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; h) regenerating said seeds of step g into Brassica napus plants containing the polima CMS cytoplasm; i) crossing the plants of step c with the plants of step h and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; [R:\LIBVV]02102.doc:SSD j) regenerating said seeds of step i into Brassica napus plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; k) crossing the plants of step j with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; 1) removing the embryos from the seeds of step k and regenerating said embryos into F, plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; m) backcrossing the plants from step 1 with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and collecting the seeds resulting from said backcrossing; n) removing the embryos from the seeds of step m and regenerating said I0 embryos into plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; o) backcrossing the plants from step n with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and o* collecting the seeds resulting from said backcrossing; and p) regenerating said seeds of step o into Brassica oleracea plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm.

Optionally, the male sterile Brassica oleracea plants may be further crossed or backcrossed to produce different Brassica types. Siliques will again be produced, collected and examined for seeds. The seeds are sown. The resulting plants are Brassica oleracea which contain the polima cytoplasm and are male sterile.

Different Brassica types can also be produced by protoplast fusion. A protoplast S* 20 from a male sterile Brassica oleracea containing the polima CMS cytoplasm and inactivated nuclei is fused with a protoplast of a Brassica having commercially desirable characteristics. After the fusion, the allogenic cells are regenerated into CMS Brassica plants. The resulting plants are male sterile and contain the polima cytoplasm. The regenerated CMS Brassica plants contain the polima cytoplasm and can be employed in 25 crossings with other Brassica types containing commercially desirable characteristics.

In preferred aspects of the invention, the resulting plants are plants selected from the group consisting of: cauliflower oleracea L. convar. botrytis Alef. var.

hotrylis brussel sprouts oleracea L. convar. oleracea var. gemmifera white cabbage oleracea L. convar. capilata Alef. var. alba DC), oxheart cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitala Alef. var. alba red cabbage oleracea L.

convar. capilata Alef. var. rubra DC.) savoye cabbage oleracea L. convar.

capilata Alef. var. sabauda turnip cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica portugese cabbage oleracea. var. tronchuda syn.

Scoslata), curly kale cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica [R:\LBVV021 02.doc:SSD 4 7a kohlrabi (Brassica oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. gongylodes and broccoli oleracea L. convar. botrytis Alef. var. cymosa Duch.).

Description of the Figures Figure 1 shows the different hybridization patterns of BGL I digested DNA with probe E5 in an endonuclease digest containing nuclear DNA of a polima CMS donor, SBrassica oleracea 904005-1, and Brassica oleracea breeding lines used as acceptors for the CMS trait. Lane 1 shows Phage 2 Hind III digested DNA Fragments (MW Standards). Lanes 2 and 3 show Polima CMA Brassica oleracea 904005-1

DNA.

Lanes 4 and 5 show Brassica oleracea acceptor Line K14. Lanes 6 and 7 show Brassica 1o oleracea acceptor line Figure 2 shows the different hybridization patterns of BGLII digested DNA with probe CMS BRAS 4 in an endonuclease digest containing mitochondrial DNA of a polima CMS plant and mitochondrial DNA from an acceptor breeding line plant. Lanes 8 and 18 show Phage k Hind III digested DNA fragments. Lanes 1 to 7 show Polima CMS 15 Brassica oleracea 904005-1 DNA. Lanes 9 to 17 show Brassica oleracea acceptor Line K14. Lanes 19 to 24 show Brassica oleracea acceptor Line Description of the Invention Cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica napus plants containing polima cytoplasm are known to "leak". Leakiness refers to the fact that the plants tend to lose their sterility 20 under certain temperature conditions. For example, 0 O

OO*

[R:\LIBVV]02102.doc:SSD WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -8studies have shown that CMS Brassicanapus containing polima cytoplasm plants are only partially sterile at high temperatures. See Fan, Z et al., Can. J. Plant Sci. 66: 221-227 (1985).

The present invention involves CMS Brassicaoleracea plants that contain the polima cytoplasm. The plants are male sterile at high and low temperatures and exhibit good female fertility. Different Brassica CMS types can then be developed by employing further crossings and backcrossings or protoplast fusion.

The Breeding Program Traditional breeding techniques were used to develop the Brassicaoleracea plants of the present invention.

The inventors herewith describe the breeding program used to create the Brassicaoleracea plants of this invention.

The breeding program was undertaken by making an interspecific cross between a Brassicacampestris (=Brassicarapa) entry 87110 (n=10) and a Brassicaoleracea entry 87101 (N=19).

Entry 87110 was obtained from the Centre for Plant Research (CPRO), P.O. Box 16, 6700 AA, Wageningen, The Netherlands as entry IVT 86007 paar 3MS and was genetically male sterile. 87110 has been deposited under the Budapest Treaty with the American Type Culture WO 97/09873 PCTIUS95/11497 -9- Collection (ATCC), 12301 Parklawn Drive, Rockville, Maryland, 20852. 87110 was deposited on August 23, 1995 and received ATCC Accession Number 97246. Entry 87101 is available from the Crucifer Genetics Cooperative (CrGC) at the Department of Plant Pathology, 1630 Linden Drive, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin as CrGC #3-3 (Ccc) and is a rapid cycling Brassicaoleracea.

After the crossing, siliques (seeds) developed. The siliques are collected, examined for seeds and planted.

The resulting plants were haploid Brassicanapus ac (N=19) and were subjected to colchicine treatment to double chromosomes to the diploid number aacc (2n=38). The resulting plants were "artificial" Brassicanapus with an aacc genome. These were labelled 87116.

A second Brassicacamperis, 87118, having the same characteristics as 87110, was also crossed with 87101.

87118 was received from the CPRO as IVT 86017 paar 3MS.

87118 has been deposited under the Budapest Treaty with the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC), 12301 Parklawn Drive, Rockville, Maryland, 20852. 87118 was deposited on August 23, 1995 and received ATCC Accession Number 97247. As in the previous cross, the seeds were collected and planted. The resulting plants were subjected to colchicine treatment to double the WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 chromosomes. The resulting plants were an "artificial" Brassicanapus with an aacc genome. The resulting plants were labeled 87119.

Plants of 87119 were then crossed with a male sterile Brassicanapus (aacc) containing the polima CMS cytoplasm (labeled 87102). 87102 is available from the Crucifer Genetics Cooperative as CrGC #5-4 (AClaacc) which is a rapid cycling Brassica napus with "Polima" CMS cytoplasm. Siliques were produced, collected and examined for seeds. The seeds were planted and the resulting plants labeled 88102. These plants were Brassica napus, had an aacc genome and contained the polima CMS cytoplasm.

A cross was then made between 87116 and 88102.

Siliques were produced, collected and examined for seeds. The seeds were planted. The resulting plants were Brassicanapus (aacc) and were labeled 88125. Brassica napus (aacc) is an amphidiploid species between Brassicaoleracea N=9 (cc genome) and Brassica rapa N=10 (aa genome). 88125 are Brassicanapus (aacc) and contains polima CMS cytoplasm and are male sterile.

An interspecific cross was made between 88125 (aacc) and a normal male fertile broccoli plant, Brasica oleracea One skilled in the art would recongize that WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -11any male fertile Brassicaoleracea plant could be used for this cross. Siliques developed. The siliques were then collected and examined for seeds. If seeds were present, then the embryo(s) is/were rescued. The embryo(s) is/were rescued because typically, embryos produced from such an interspecific hybridization abort prior to maturation. However, by employing embryo rescue, interspecific hybrids can be produced.

Embryo rescue involves removing the embryo from the silique. It is preferred that the embryo rescue be conducted when the embryo is as large as possible.

Generally, 18-19 days after the cross is a good time to conduct embryo rescue. However, one skilled in the art would recognize that the embryo rescue could take place earlier or later, so long as the seed coat has not yet hardened.

In embryo rescue, the siliques are first disinfected for about 20 minutes in a 10% hypochlorate solution (such as sodium or potassium hypochlorate) and rinsed three times in sterile water at 2.5 and minutes.

Next, the siliques are cut in a longitudinal direction. Young seeds are removed and embryos taken out of the seed under a microscope. The embryos are then placed on a suitable medium to facilitate growth, WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -12such as a BLKC medium which is described in Example 11.

However, any medium that facilitates growth can be used.

The embryos are grown at 20'C in 16 hours of 4500 LUX light for at least two weeks. After the roots develop, the seedlings are placed into soil as soon as possible.

The resulting Fi plants were assigned the numbers 88132-1 through 88132-84. These plants contained the polima CMS cytoplasm from the female Brassicanapus plant, however; the nuclear DNA content was a combination of the Brassicanapus (N=19) and the Brassicaoleracea Essentially, the plants had mixed genomes. Because of their mixed nature, the plants were male sterile and partially female sterile. The plants were male sterile because they contained the polima CMS cytoplasm from the female (egg) parent, Brassicanapus, 88125.

Phenotypical selection was used to select the plants from 88132-1 through 88132-84 that have near normal DNA content (aacc or cc). Phenotypic selection allows the breeder to select plants most similar to Brassicaoleracea (cc genome). Plants with an abnormal DNA content are visually different than plants with a normal DNA content. The plants selected were backcrossed (BC1) with a normal broccoli or cauliflower, Brassica oleracea (cc).

However, one skilled in the art would recognize that any WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -13- Brassicaoleracea could be used. After the cross, embryo rescue was again employed. The plants that developed were assigned the numbers 89015 through 89040 and 89046 through 89056. These plants were intermediate for chromosome number and contained the polima CMS cytoplasm. Again, the nuclear DNA content was a combination of the Brassicanapus and the Brassicaoleracea. The plants were male sterile (polima CMS) and partially female sterile (chromosome number).

Phenotypical selection was employed to select plants from 89015 through 89040 and 89046 through 89056 having near normal DNA content. The plants selected were backcrossed (BC2) with a normal broccoli or cauliflower, Brassicaoleracea However, one skilled in the art would recognize that any Brassicaoleracea could be used. Siliques again developed, however, some seeds did not require embryo rescue. These seeds were collected and planted. The plants resulting from this cross were assigned the numbers 89070 through 89141. Most of these plants had the normal Brassicaoleracea set of chromosomes (2N=18), contained the polima cytoplasm and were male sterile. The flowers of these plants had reduced anthers and petals. The plants remained sterile WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -14at high and low temperatures and exhibited normal female fertility.

These resulting plants can be crossed with other Brassica types such as broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage (red, white, savoy), brussels sprouts, kohlrabi, kale, etc. to produce CMS lines. For example, different Brassica types can be produced by backcrossing to the CMS "polima" plants or by protoplast fusion.

Subsequent Crosses and Selection Process for Male Sterility. Female Fertility and Flower Morphology Plants of 89015 through 89640 and 89046 through 89056 and 89070 through 89141 were subsequently backcrossed with a normal broccoli and/or cauliflower and planted in the field. Siliques developed, were collected and examined for seeds. The seeds were collected and then sown. Rows of polima steriles were alternated with broccoli maintainer rows. A maintainer line is understood by those of ordinary skill in the art to denote a line that is used in crosses to produce progeny that maintain the sterility of the male sterile material parent. The maintainer plants are fertile but otherwise genetically identical counterparts to the CMS plants with which they are grown, typically in alternating strips, to produce seed from a male-sterile WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 line. After a period of growth, natural selection (by bees/flies, etc.) was employed to choose the plants exhibiting male sterility, good female fertility and the best flowers morphology, i.e. good petal size. The plants selected were assigned numbers CPO-1, etc.

These plants were Brassica oeracea, contained the polima CMS cytoplasm were male sterile and exhibited good female fertility.

After a period of growth, the CPO numbered plants exhibiting male sterility, good female fertility were cloned and put in a cage with a typical maintainer.

Cage production involves erecting a mesh tent (insect screening) or a cage around the plants. This is done to prevent cross pollination by insects with other plants in the field. A beehive or other insect colony is typically put inside with the plants. Siliques that developed were collected and the seeds sown. The resulting plants were Brassicaoleracea which contained the polima CMS cytoplasm, were male sterile and exhibited good female fertility.

Protoplast Fusion Different CMS Brassica types can also be prepared by protoplast fusion. The protoplasts can be obtained from a Brassicaoleracea plant that contains the CMS polima WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -16cytoplasm and is male sterile. For example, Brassicaoleracea plants obtained by the previously described breeding program can be used, such as plants of 89070 through 89111 and plants of the CPO series. The protoplast fusion may be accomplished by employing polyethylene glycol (PEG) causing agglutination, in the presence of a fusion buffer, i.e. a high pH solution to let the membranes fuse. Such somatic hybridization may be effected under the conditions disclosed by Sundberg et al. (Plant Science 43 (1986) 155), hereby incorporated by reference, for the production of interspecific hybrids or modifications thereof. However, one skilled in the art would recognize that the protoplast fusion can be accomplished in other ways other than using polyethylene glycol (PEG). For example, the protoplasts can be fused by using electric field-induced fusion techniques as described by Koop et al. "Electric Field- Induced Fusion and Cell Reconstruction-with Preselected Single Protoplasts and Subprotoplasts of Higher Plants" in Electroporation and Electrofusion in Cell Biology, Neuman et al. editors, pgs 355-365 (1989), herewith incorporated by reference. Additionally, protoplast fusion can be accomplished with dextran and polyvinyl alcohol as described by Hauptmann et al., "Carrot x Tobacco Somatic Cell Hybrids Selected by Amino Acid WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -17- Analog Resistance Complementation", 6th International Protoplast Symposium, Basel, August 12-16, 1983, herewith incorporated by reference.

If protoplast fusion is to be accomplished with polyethylene glycol, the procedure described below can be used.

The protoplast fusion is conveniently effected in a washing solution described below, containing an osmoticum e.g. a carbohydrate such as mannitol, sorbitol, glucose, or sucrose and potassium and calcium salts. The pH can range from 5.2 to 10 and is preferably about 5.7. The protoplasts of different origin are mixed and concentrated, conveniently to a final density of 105 and 108 protoplasm per ml.

The protoplast mixture should then be left undisturbed for at least 10 minutes to allow the protoplasts to settle at the bottom of the petri dish.

The mixture is then treated with polyethylene glycol (PEG), preferably having a molecular weight of 1500 to 6000. In general, good results are obtained when employing an aqueous solution (PFS) comprising 18.8% by weight of PEG at a volume ratio W5' to PFS of 10:1 to 1:1. PFS comprises conveniently an osmoticum and a calcium salt. The protoplasts are included in PFS for WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -18to 20 minutes depending on the fragility of the cells.

The fusion is accomplished by washing the protoplasts, for example, three times, with washing solution containing an osmoticum glucose) in a concentration giving a lower osmolarity than PFS and potassium, sodium and calcium salts. The fusion procedure is carried out at a temperature in the range between 16* and 20*C, preferably 18*C. The concentration of PEG in the fusion mixture is gradually decreased with each consecutive washing step (see e.g.

Example Each washing step should take at least minutes to allow the protoplasts to adjust slowly to the lower osmolarity of the medium, to avoid bursting of the cells. After the washing steps have been accomplished the fused protoplasts should be in the range of 105 to 106 protoplasts per ml. The obtained fusion products may be regenerated in the presence of non-fused parental protoplasts or after optical selection from the culture.

Such optical selection may be performed by micromanipulation of the cells, e.g. according to the procedure disclosed by Patnaik et al., Plant Science Letters 24 (1982) 105, hereby incorporated by reference, for the manual isolation and identification of plant heterokaryon.

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -19- When employing the selection strategy, the parental protoplasts are for example stained with fluorescent dyes, e.g. fluorescein diacetate. When fluorescein diacetate is used with protoplasts of hypocotyl origin it will stain yellow under a UV light. Protoplasts from leaves will contain chloroplasts which give red autofluorescence under UV light.

The obtained fusion products are cultivated in an appropriate culture medium comprising a well-balanced nutrient supply for protoplast growth. The medium contains micro- and macro-elements, vitamins, amino acids and small amounts of carbohydrates, e.g. various sugars such as glucose. Glucose serves as a carbon source as well as an osmoticum. The culture medium also comprises plant hormones (auxins and cytokine) which are able to regulate cell division and shoot regeneration.

Examples of suitable auxins include naphtyl acetic acid (NAA), 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and indoleacetic acid (IAA). Examples of suitable cytokinins include benzyl aminopyrine (BAP), zeatin (Zea) and gibberellic acid (GA3). In general NAA and 2,4-D are used in combination with BAP to initiate cell division. The ratio of auxin/cytokinin must then be high, for example greater than 1. Two or three days after the fusion treatment, the medium is largely WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 replaced by culture medium (BP) which comprises agarose, by which the fusion products and the parental protoplasts are embedded.

After 14 days, the concentration of auxins is diluted by addition of other culture media containing no or substantially less auxins. Star-shaped micro calli will generally develop after 3 to 4 weeks. Such micro calli are then transferred to a regeneration medium to initiate shoot formation, preferably after adaption in an intermediate regeneration medium to differences in composition and physical properties between the culture medium and the regeneration medium. For shoot formation the ratio auxin/cytokinin in the regeneration medium should conveniently be low, e.g. below 1:10. In general it will be preferable to employ the auxin NAA in combination with the cytokinins Zea and BAP for shoot regeneration. The regeneration media, BR and K3, are relatively poor media compared to the culture medium.

They contain less vitamins, the content of carbon source is lower, they comprise solely sucrose and xylose as carbon source and do not contain amino acids. The regeneration media also have a higher viscosity that the culture medium. The regeneration medium Br is a solid medium and contains the growth regulators 2,4-D, NAA and BAP, with the ratio of auxin to cytokinin being less WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -21than 1. Medium K3 contains Zea, GA3 and also silver nitrate to promote the shoot development.

After two weeks regeneration on Br medium, calli of approximately 3 mm in diameter are transferred to K3 regeneration medium containing a low sucrose concentration. At this stage shoots will develop within 2 to 3 weeks. The obtained shoots are then rooted on a basic medium, such as B5, without additional hormones.

The nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA of the obtained plantlets may then be identified in a manner known per se, e.g. employing suitable restriction endonuclease and comparing the thus obtained DNA digest pattern of the fusion products with that of the parental lines.

Brassicaoleracea protoplasts and inactivated protoplasts of a Polima CMS Brassicaoleracea plant, employed herein as starting material may be obtained in a manner known per se from the corresponding plant cells. Cell wall-free cells, i.e. protoplasts are obtained from green plant material e.g. leaf material and from white plant material e.g. etiolated seedlings, according to the method disclosed by Glimelius, Phvsioloqia Plantarum 61 (1984) 38, hereby incorporated by reference, for the regeneration of hypocotyl protoplasts. Where optical selection of the fusion products is intended, the starting materials will be conveniently selected from a WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -22green plant or where they are from white-plant material they will advantageously be stained to facilitate selection. The inactivated protoplasts of a Polima CMS Brassicaoleracea plant are obtained in a manner known per se corresponding to Polima CMS Brassicaoleracea plant cells or protoplasts, for example, by irradiation.

The inactivation of the nucleus by irradiation can be effected with the aid of gamma, UV or X-rays. Where irradiation is effected with an X-ray source, nucleus inactivation will in general be obtained by applying a dose of e.g. 10 krad. min for 3 to 20 minutes. The appropriate X-ray dosage may for example be established by determining the minimum level of X-ray irradiation killing 100% of the protoplast population: the percentage of dead cells is estimated by counting the number of formed colonies after 10 to 20 days in culture.

As described above, after the fusion, the allogenic cells are regenerated to form Brasicaoleracea plants containing the CMS cytoplasm. These plants may be subsequently crossed with other Brassicaoleracea plants.

It will be appreciated that the Brassicaoleracea plant of this invention may be employed as starting material for the preparation of other Brasicaoleracea varieties having WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -23- Polima CMS by in vitro and/or crossing techniques. Such in vitro and crossing techniques are known in the art by the skilled breeder.

WO 97/09873 WO 979873PCT/US95/1 1497 -24- Solutions employed include: A. ENZYME SOLUTION (IL) g mannitol 0.0272 g KHIPO, 0. 1 g KNO 3 0.246 g MgSO 4 7H120 0.0008 g KI 0.00025 g CuSO, 51,0 1.4 g CaCI, 1.1 gMNES 6 g Cellulase RIO 1 g pH 5.8 Macarozyme WASHING SOLUTIONS (W5) (IL) 18.4 g CaCi,. 211,0 4.91 g NaCl 0.372 g KC1 0.901 g glucose pH 5.8 C. WASHING SOLUTION (IL) 18.4 g CaCi, 21120 4.91 g NaClI 0.372 g KC1 0.90 1 g glucose 9.76 g IVES pH 5.8 SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26) WO 97/09973 WO 9709873PCTIUS9SII 1497 D. CPW 16S (IL) 160 g sucrose 0.0272 g KH 2

PO

4 0.1 g KNO 3 1.45 g CaCI., -2H 2 0 0.2469g MgSO 4 2H 2 0 0.0008 g KI 0.000025 g CUSO 4 -5H 2 0 pH 5.5-5.8 E. PEG fusion solution (PFS) 18.8% PEG (MW 4000) 0.06 M CaC1 2 -2H 2 0 0. 1 M mannitol 0.025 M glucine DMS0 SPA SOLUTION (IL) g SeaPlaque agarose [00 g Sucrose TABLE 1: COMPOSITION OF THE MS MEDIA (MGIL) 8P MAC Br K3 B 5 MS KNO, 956 956 1556 1556 3000 1900

NH

4 NO3 600 600 250 250 1650 MgSO, 2H.,O 300 300 250 250 250 370 4 164 164 170 CaCi, 2H.,O 600 600 300 300 150 440 KCI 300 300 RECTIFIED SHEET(RULE 91) WO 97/09873 WO 9709873PCT/US95/1 1497 -26-

(NH

4 2 S0 4 134 134 134 K 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.83 MvnSO 4 10 10 10 10 10 22.3 HB0 3 3 3 3 3 3 6.2 ZnSO 4 2 2 2 2 2 8.6 2H.,O NaMoO4- 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25

C

4 S0 4 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 4HO CoC1, 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 6H,O Fe-EDTA 40 40 40 40 40 43 Thiamine- 10 10 10 10 10 0.1

HCL

Pyridoxine- 1 1 1 1 1

HCL

Nicotinic 1 1 1 1 1 acid Sodium 20 20 pyruvate Citric Acid 40 40 Maleic acid 40 40 Furnaric 40 40 acid Glycine 2 Xylose 250 Inositol 100 100 Sucrose 50,000 80.000 40,000 10,000 20,000 Glucose 40,000 SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26) WO 97/09873 WO 979873PCTIUS95/I 1497 -26A- Casein 250 250 hydrolysate Agarose 16,000 Agar 8,000 8,000 8,000 NAA 0.1 0.1 0.1 2,4-D 1 0.2 0.1 Zeatin 0.26 BAP 0.5 0.5 0.5

GA

3 0.006 jAgNO 3 57 *see examples By way of example, and not limitation, examples of the present invention will now be given.

SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26) WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -27- Example 1: Seed sterilization and germination Seeds of Brassica oleracea, broccoli with Polima CMS (hereinafter designated B. oleracea, 904005-1) are dipped for approximately 10 seconds in alcohol and sterilized in a 1.5% sodium hypochlorite solution for two times for 10 minutes at 20 0 C. Afterwards extensive rinsing with sterile distilled water is required. The seeds are placed on the MS nutrient medium (see Table 1) with 3% sucrose and without hormones. To obtain green sterile plants, the seeds are grown in glass jars in the light (8000 lux), for a 16 hour photoperiod with temperatures of 25 0 C day and 20 0 C night. Sterile shoots are subcultured under the same conditions in plastic containers. To obtain white tissue for protoplast isolation, e.g. hypocotyls, the seeds are grown in petri dishes in the dark at 0

C.

Example la: Crosses leading to 904005-1 904005-1 is the seed harvested from plant number 1 in entry number 904005.

904005 was a backcross of CMS Polima 892731-2 and a normal fertile broccoli.

892731-2 SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26) WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -28is the seed harvested from plant selection 2 in entry 892731. This was backcross of CMS Polima 89094-2 and a normal fertile broccoli.

89094-2 is the seed harvested from plant selection 2 in entry 89094. This was a backcross of CMS Polima 89022 and normal fertile broccoli.

89022-4 is the seed harvested from plant 4 in entry 89022.

Example 2 Analogous to the procedure of Example 1, seeds of Brassicaoleracea, cultivar DE70, are sterilized and germinated. Cultivar DE70 is a fully fertile inbred cauliflower line that is used as a parental line.

However, any typical Brassicaoleracea plant can be used for the protoplast fusion.

Example 3: Isolation of protoplasts Leaves of four week old shoots of plant material according to Example 1 are cut into small pieces and incubated in an enzyme solution for 16 hours at 25'C on a gyratory shaker at 40 rpm. The suspension is filtered through a nylon mesh (40 Am) and washed with two-thirds of a volume of CPW 16S solution by centrifugation at 817 rpm for 5 minutes. This results in flotation of the intact protoplasts. The protoplasts are collected and WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -29rinsed twice with W5 solution by centrifugation at 708 rpm for 5 minutes. The protoplasts are diluted to a density of 1 x 10 5 protoplasts per ml W5 solution before being used for fusion experiments.

Example 4 Six to eight day old hypocotyls of the plant material according to Example 2 are isolated according to the process of Example 3, except that during the enzyme treatment 3 Ag/ml of fluoresceinediacetate is added. Stained protoplasts for hand selection and for determination of fusion frequency are obtained.

Example 5: Irradiation of protoplast Freshly isolated protoplasts according to Example 3 are plated in a 6 cm petri dish in W5 solution (2 to 3 ml). The protoplasts are irradiated using an X-ray source (Baltograph CE100), at a dose of 3500 Gy during minutes. After irradiation, the inactivated protoplasts are washed with W5 solution by centrifugation at 708 rpm for 5 minutes. The protoplasts are diluted to a density of 1 x 10 protoplasts per ml W5 solution before being used for fusion experiments.

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 Example 6: Fusion procedure Protoplasts according to Example 4 and 5 re mixed 1:3 in a final concentration of 1 x 105 protoplasts per ml W5 solution. Three droplets of 100 Ml are placed in an uncoated 6 cm petri dish and the protoplasts are allowed to settle for 5 to 10 minutes. Three hundred microliters of PFS solution is added in the center of the three droplets to induce agglutination for minutes. Thereafter, 300 Al of W5 solution is added to the mixture and again after 10 minutes and again after minutes. The W5 medium is replaced by two times concentrated 8P solution and the protoplasts are cultivated for one to three days at 25'C in the dark.

Example 7 The entire fusion mixture according to Example 6 is cultured for one to three days in the dark at 25*C. The cells are collected by centrifugation at 548 for minutes and diluted to a density of 1 x 10 5 protoplasts per ml two times concentrated 8P medium. An equal volume handwarm SPA medium is added and the cells are plated in 5 droplets of 100 gi in a coated petri dish.

Also 5 droplets of 100 Al with feeder cells are added.

After two weeks, the droplets with feeder cells are removed and 2 ml MAC medium per petri dish is added.

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -31- After two weeks the droplets are dispersed on solid Br medium. After two to three weeks the individual colonies are transferred to a petri dish with solid K3 medium. The microcalli are cultured in low light intensity (2500 lux) at 25*C with a photoperiod of 18 hours.

Example 8: Selection and growth of fusion products Fused cells, which can be recognized visually by the presence of double fluorescence, are picked up with a micromanipulator. The hybrid cells are cultured in 100 gl agarose droplets SeaPlaque) at a density of 2000 to 50,000 protoplasts per milliliter. The droplets are placed in a liquid nurse culture system (Costar- Transwell col) with feeder cells and incubated at in the dark. The droplets are dispersed on solid Br medium after two weeks. Small calli are transferred to solid K3 medium and incubated at 25'C in low light intensity (2500 lux) with a photoperiod of 16 hours.

Example 9: Plant regeneration The calli according to Example 7 and 8, having developed to a size of 2 to 5 mm in diameter, are transferred to fresh K3 medium at normal light intensity (8000 lux) at 25°C with a photoperiod of 16 hours.

WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -32- Small shoots are transferred to B5 medium with 1% sucrose without hormones and rooted on the same medium.

Example 10: Molecular analysis of the fusion products a) Nuclear DNA composition Characterization of the nuclear DNA composition of the fusion product is effected by using specific DNA probes. Probe ES, a clone containing a 820 kbp Bgl 1 fragment from cauliflower nuclei DNA hybridizes with various bands in an endonuclease digest pattern of nuclear DNA of the Polima CMS donor, Brassica oleracea breeding lines that are used as acceptor for the CMS trait (see Figure 1).

b) Mitochondrial DNA composition Characterization is effected with CMS Bras 4 DNA, a clone containing a 1950 bp Bgl II fragment from cauliflower mitochondrial DNA. This clone produced a band of 4 kbp with CMS polima mitochondrial DNA and a band of 6 kbp with mitochondrial DNA from the acceptor breeding lines e.g. DE70 (see Figure 2).

Characterization is also effected by PCR amplification of a 500 bp DNA fragment, using primers 94RS01 and 94RS02. The sequence of the forward primer 94RS01 is CCA ACT GCT TTC ACA CCG-3' and of the reverse primer 94RS02 5'-CTT GGC TCT CTG CGA ATG TC-3'. This WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -33- 500 bp fragment is amplified from CMS polima mitochondrial DNA, but not from mitochondrial DNA of acceptor lines, e.g. Example 11: Embryo Rescue Generally, an embryo is rescued 18-19 days after a cross is made.

In order to effectuate an embryo rescue. siliques are required. The siliques required are those having as large as possible embryos with a seed coats that have not yet hardened.

Prior to the removal of the embryo, the siliques must first be disinfected. The siliques are disinfected by placing them in a 10% chloride solution such as sodium or potassium chloride for about twenty minutes min.). The siliques are rinsed three times in sterile water at 2, 5 and minutes.

The embryo is rescued by cutting the siliques open in a longitudinal direction, removing the developing seeds and then preparing the embryo out of the seed under a microscope.

After the embryo is cut out of the seed, it is placed on a suitable growth medium. Any medium that will facilitate the growth of the embryo can be used. For example, an MS medium with 3 sucrose and 0.4 mg/l thiamin and 0.2 mg/l IDA can be used.

RECTIFIED SHEET(RULE 91) WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -34- Example 12: The maintenance of sterility of CMS Brassicaoleracea plants at high and low temperatures In order to determine if the cytoplasmic male sterile plants containing the polima CMS cytoplasm remained sterile at high and low temperatures, broccoli cultivars 915095, 915107, 915100 and 915144 were hybridized with red cabbage to check if 100% hybridity was achieved. Cultivars 915095-915144 were crossed with red cabbage. When the seeds of these cultivars are pollinated with a normal broccoli maintainer and are sown, the hypocotyl color and leaf color of the seedling is normally green. If these cultivars are crossed with red cabbage then the hybrid seeds are intermediate and the seedlings show a strong authocyan (purple) expression, while inbreds remain green. Seeds of 915095, 915107, 915100, and 915144 were sown and plants of each cultivar were put together with red cabbage plants in a plastic covered cage outside. In the summer, the temperature of the cage varied from during the day.- The temperatures in the cage were recorded once a week. A sample of the seed harvested from 915095, 915107, 915100 and 915144 were sown and all resulting plants were hybrid indicating no presence of selfing and no leaking of the polima CMS cytoplasm. At WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 no time did any of the plants result in partial male sterility.

The crosses which lead to 915095, 915107, 915100 and 915144 are shown below.

88125 x broccoli (=bc (broccoli pollinator line)) 88132 x bc 89022 x bc 89036 x bc 89046 x bc 89094 x bc 89102 x bc 89083 x bc 89133 x bc 892731 x bc 892733 X bc 892736 x bc 892737 x bc 904005 x bc 904006 x bc 904008 x bc 904045 x bc 915095 915100 915107 91144 When two or more arrows go from one cross (i.e.

88132 x bc), then each arrow represents a cross with a different broccoli genotype.

Example 13: Female Fertility Listed below is the seed yield data obtained after crossing by hand CMS "Polima" types with broccoli. The data shows that the seed yield of CMS "polima" is higher than those of broccoli inbreds. This is because WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -36replicated inbreeding affects the fertility. A better comparison is made between the broccoli F,'s and the CMS Ogura crosses. The results show that the seed yield of the CMS polima is in the same range as the other two types of crosses.

Broccoli Seed Yields 1991-1994 (Hand pollination) Year Type of Cross Number of Seeds per Cross 1991 (CMS Polima x Broccoli)F, 114 (n=4) (Broccoli inbred x Broccoli)FI 64 (n=23) (Broccoli FI x Broccoli)Fi 116 1992 (CMS Polima x Broccoli)Fi 146 (n=66) (Broccoli inbred x Broccoli)F, 100 (n=76) (Broccoli Fi x Broccoli)F, 135 (n=28) (CMS Ogura x Broccoli)FI 140 (n=32) 1993 (CMS Polima x Broccoli)Fi 79 (n=41) (Broccoli inbred x Broccoli)F 1 53 (Broccoli F, x Broccoli)F 1 80 (CMS Ogura x Broccoli)F 144 1994 (CMS Polima x Broccoli) Fi 93 (n=9) (Broccoli inbred x Broccoli)F, 47 (Broccoli Fi x Broccoli)F, 84 (CMS Ogura x Broccoli)F, 74 (n=9) Weighted means (CMS Polima x Broccoli)FI 115 (n=120) (Broccoli inbred x Broccoli)FI 60 (n=227) (Broccoli Fi x Broccoli)FI 103 (n=143) (CMS Ogura x Broccoli)FI (127)((n=40)) Although the invention has been described primarily in connection with the special and preferred WO 97/09873 PCT/US95/11497 -37embodiments, it will be understood that it is capable of modification without departing from the scope of the invention. The following claims are intended to cover all variations, uses or adaptions of the invention, following, in general, the principles thereof and including such departures from the presented disclosure as come within known or customary practice in the field to which the invention pertains, or as are obvious to persons skilled in the field.

Claims (9)

1. A method for producing cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and which contain polima CMS cytoplasm, the method comprising the steps of: a) crossing Brassica campestris cultivar 87110 having ATCC Accession Number 97246 with Brassica oleracea cultivar 87101 and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; b) regenerating said seeds into Brassica napus plants which contain a haploid set of chromosomes; ij c) doubling the chromosomes of the plants of step b to provide Brassica napus plants containing a diploid set of chromosomes; d) crossing Brassica campestris cultivar 87118 having ATCC Accession Number 97247 with Brassica oleracea cultivar 87101 and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; I 1 e) regenerating said seeds from step d into Brassica napus plants which contain a haploid set of chromosomes; f) doubling the chromosomes of the plants of step e to provide Brassica napus plants containing a diploid set of chromosomes; g) crossing the plants of step f with Brassica napus cultivar 87102 which is 20 male sterile and contains polima CMS cytoplasm and collecting the seeds resulting from 0. said cross; oo h) regenerating said seeds of step g into Brassica napus plants containing 00 the polima CMS cytoplasm; i) crossing the plants of step c with the plants of step h and collecting the 25 seeds resulting from said cross; *0 j) regenerating said seeds of step i into Brassica napus plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; k) crossing the plants of step j with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and collecting the seeds resulting from said cross; 1) removing the embryos from the seeds of step k and regenerating said embryos into FI plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; m) backcrossing the plants from step 1 with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and collecting the seeds resulting from said backcrossing; [R:\LIBVV]02102.doc:SSD I s 39 n) removing the embryos from the seeds of step m and regenerating said embryos into plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm; o) backcrossing the plants from step n with a Brassica oleracea cultivar and collecting the seeds resulting from said backcrossing; and Sp) regenerating said seeds of step o into Brassica oleracea plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm.

2. A method according to claim 1 further comprising the steps of crossing the plants from step p with a Brassica oleracea; collecting seeds resulting from the cross; and regenerating said seeds into Brassica oleracea plants which are male sterile and contain the polima CMS cytoplasm.

3. A method according to claim 1 or claim 2 wherein the plants of step p are selected from the group consisting of: cauliflower oleracea L. convar. botrytis Alef. var. botrytis brussel sprouts oleracea L. convar. oleracea var. gemmifera S white cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. alba DC), oxheart 15 cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. alba red cabbage (B. oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. rubra DC.) savoye cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. sabauda turnip cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica portugese cabbage oleracea. var. tronchuda syn. costata), curly kale cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. 20 sabellica kohlrabi (Brassica oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. gongylodes and broccoli oleracea L. convar. botrytis Alef. var. cymosa Duch.).

4. A method for producing cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and which contain polima CMS cytoplasm, 25 the method comprising the steps of: a) fusing a protoplast from a male sterile Brassica oleracea produced by a method according to any one of claims 1 to 3 which contains the polima CMS cytoplasm and which remains sterile at high and low temperatures with a protoplast from a Brassica oleracea having commercially desirable characteristics to produce allogenic cells; b) regenerating the obtained allogenic cells into CMS Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and which contain polima cytoplasm. [R:\LIBVV]02102.doc:SSD A method according to claim 4 wherein the Brassica oleracea plants of step b are selected from the group consisting of: cauliflower oleracea L. convar. botrylis Alef. var. botrytis brussel sprouts oleracea L. convar. oleracea var. gemmifera white cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. alba DC), oxheart s cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. alba red cabbage (B. oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. rubra DC.) savoye cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. sabauda turnip cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica portugese cabbage oleracea. var. tronchuda .syn. costata), curly kale cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica kohirabi (Brassica oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. gongylodes and broccoli oleracea L. convar. botrylis Alef. var. cymosa Duch.).

6. A method according to claim 4 or claim 5 further comprising the steps of crossing the regenerated CMS Brassica oleracea containing polima cytoplasm with Brassica oleracea plants containing commercially desirable characteristics. S7. A method for producing cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and which contain polima CMS cytoplasm, substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of the Examples.

8. Cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants produced by a method S 20 according to any one of claims 1 to 7 which are sterile at high and low temperatures and contain polima CMS cytoplasm. 0

9. Plants according to claim 8 wherein the plants are selected from the group consisting of: cauliflower oleracea L. convar. botrytis Alef. var. botrytis brussel sprouts oleracea L. convar. oleracea var. gemmifera white cabbage (B. oleracea L. convar. capita/a Alef. var. alba DC), oxheart cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. alba red cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. rubra DC.) savoye cabbage oleracea L. convar. capitata Alef. var. sabauda turnip cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica portugese cabbage oleracea. var. tronchuda syn. costa/a), curly kale cabbage oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. sabellica kohlrabi (Brassica oleracea L. convar. acephala Alef. var. gongylodes and broccoli oleracea L. convar. boirytis Alef. var. cymosa Duch.). [R:\LIBVV]02102.doc:SSD 41 Cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and contain polima CMS cytoplasm, substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of the Examples.

11. Seed containing polima CMS cytoplasm and which results in cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures, said seed being produced by plants according to any one of claims 8 to

12. Seed from cytoplasmic male sterile Brassica oleracea plants which are sterile at high and low temperatures and contain polima CMS cytoplasm, substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of the Examples. Dated 9 December, 1999 Seminis Vegetable Seeds, Inc. Patent Attorneys for the Applicant/Nominated Person SPRUSON FERGUSON 9**9 0 9 *9OO 9* 9 LIBVV\02102