WO2014087017A1

WO2014087017A1 - Process for the preparation of levulinic acid esters

Info

Publication number: WO2014087017A1
Application number: PCT/EP2013/075963
Authority: WO
Inventors: DE Arie RIJKE; Gerardus Wilhelmus Adrianus Hangx; Rudy Francois Maria Jozef Parton; Barthel ENGENDAHL
Original assignee: Dsm Ip Assets B.V.
Priority date: 2012-12-07
Filing date: 2013-12-09
Publication date: 2014-06-12

Abstract

The invention relates to a process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, said process comprising: - subjecting the composition to distillation and recovering a residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone; and - subjecting the recovered residue to an esterification reaction comprising an alkanol under conditions and time and temperature to produce the levulinic acid ester. The process is simple and affords levulinic ester at high yields.

Description

PROCESS FOR THE PREPARATION OF LEVULINIC ACID ESTERS

Field of the invention

The present invention relates to a process for the preparation of levulinic acid ester.

Background of the invention

Levulinic acid esters can be used as fuel additives or as plasticisers and solvents and can be prepared from levulinic acid. Examples of levulinic acid esters are ethyl levulinate and methyl levulinate.

As in most reactions, levulinic acid as a reactant to make levulinic esters must be pure. Commonly used purification techniques include solvent-solvent extraction and distillation.

Commercially, levulinic acid is made from furfuryl alcohol. When levulinic acid is produced from furfuryl alcohol, it can be isolated e.g. by distillation.

It is also possible to produce levulinic acid by acid hydrolysis of biomass although this is not commercially practiced. In addition to levulinic acid, biomass hydrolysates usually also contain low-boiling compounds such as formic acid, acetic acid, and proprionic acid.

The inventors have surprisingly found that when such biomass hydrolysate is subjected to distillation in order to separate the levulinic acid from the biomass hydrolysate, the levulinic acid yield is unsatisfactory.

The inventors have tried hard to increase the yield of levulinic acid in the distillate, because low yields of levulinic acid after the distillation would mean that the yield, and therefore the economics of the production of levulinic acid esters would also be poor.

Summary of the invention

invention provides an improved process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, said process comprising: subjecting the composition to distillation and recovering a residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone; and subjecting the recovered residue to an esterification reaction comprising an alkanol under conditions and time and temperature to produce the levulinic acid ester. The process is suitable for making levulinic acid esters from compositions made by acid hydrolysis of a lignocellulosic biomass, and also for compositions be made by acid hydrolysis of sugar such as glucose and fructose.

Detailed description of the invention

The invention provides a process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, said process comprising:

subjecting the composition to distillation and recovering a residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone; and

subjecting the recovered residue to an esterification reaction comprising an alkanol under conditions and time and temperature to produce the levulinic acid ester.

The inventors surprisingly found that when a biomass hydrolysate is subjected to distillation in order to isolate levulinic acid, angelica lactone is formed during the distillation. The inventors have realized that levulinic acid esters can be efficiently produced from a biomass hydrolysate by recovering a distillation residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone and then subjecting the residue to an esterification reaction. The process of the invention is particularly advantageous when carried out as a batch process.

The boiling temperature is measured at standard conditions, namely at 1 atmosphere, or 760.00 mm Hg. At this pressure, the boiling temperature of pure water is 100°C, and the boiling point of levulinic acid is 245°C.

The distillation preferably comprises reactive distillation. The distillation is preferably done under reactive conditions such that levulinic acid may be converted to angelica lactone. The distillation temperature is preferably 80°C or more, more preferably between 120 and 150°C. The pressure is preferably 10 mbar or higher. Such pressures and temperatures may result in a distillation residue having at least 1 wt% angelica lactone. Preferably, during said distillation levulinic acid goes into the gas phase, where reactive distillation to angelica lactone may take place, which may be recovered as a distillation residue.

The compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C preferably has a boiling temperature of at least 90°C.

The composition may comprise formic acid, acetic acid, furfural, and/or propionic acid. That is, the compound having a boiling point of less than 245°C may comprise formic acid, acetic acid, furfural, and/or propionic acid (i.e. may comprise each one of these compounds or a combination of two or more of these compounds).

The composition may comprise a biomass hydrolysate. Acid hydrolysis of biomass or C6 sugars may not only result in formation of levulinic acid, but usually also results in the formation of formic acid, boiling temperature 100°C. Often a range of other low boiling compounds are produced such as acetic acid, furfural, and proprionic acid, all having a boiling temperature of 90°C or higher, but lower than the boiling temperature of levulinic acid. The biomass may be or may be derived from grass, cereal, starch, algae, tree bark, hay, straw, leaves, paper pulp, paper sludge, or dung. Paper pulp, or simply pulp, is a lignocellulosic fibrous material prepared by chemically or mechanically separating cellulose from wood, fibre crops or waste paper. Pulp is rich in cellulose and other carbohydrates. Paper sludge, or simply sludge, is a lignocellulosic fibrous containing cellulose fibres too short for usage in the paper industry. The biomass may comprise lignocellulosic biomass. Lignocellulosic biomass typically has a fibrous nature and comprises a bran fraction that contains the majority of lignocellulosic (bran) fibers. As an example, corn fiber is a heterogeneous complex of carbohydrate polymers and lignin. It is primarily composed of the outer kernel covering or seed pericarp, along with 10-25% adherent starch. Carbohydrate analyses of corn fiber vary considerably according to the source of the material. The lignocellulosic biomass may comprise hemicellulose.

In one embodiment, the composition is a biomass hydrolysate made by acid hydrolysis of lignocellulosic biomass.

In another embodiment, the composition is a made by acid hydrolysis of C6 sugars, particularly of fructose or glucose or mixtures thereof. Sucrose (C12H22O11) can be broken down into one molecule of glucose (C₆H₁₂0₆) plus one molecule of fructose (also C₆H₁₂0₆, an isomer of glucose), in a weakly acidic environment by a process called inversion. Fructose can also be made by enzymatic isomerization of glucose. Sucrose is commonly produced from biomass such as beet, corn and cane.

The conditions for the acid hydrolysis of biomass or C6 sugars are such it results in the formation of at least levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C and preferably also of tar and/or humins. Suitable acids include sulphuric acid, hydrochloric acid, and phosphoric acid. A preferred acid is sulphuric acid, preferably diluted sulphuric acid, for example at a concentration between 1 .5 - 3%. The temperature in the acid hydrolysis may depend on the source of carbohydrates, and may range between 150-250°C, preferably between 170-240°C, more preferably between 190-230°C, even more preferably between 200 and 220°C. The acid hydrolysis may comprise one, two, or more stages. The pressure may also depend on the source of carbohydrates, as well as on the temperature, and may be anywhere between 1 and 50 bar, preferably between 5 and 40 bar, even more preferably between 10 and 30 bar. Suitable reactors include plugflow reactors, backmix reactors, and CSTR reactors. Different reactors for different stages may be used.

The distillation residue may comprise levulinic acid, i.e. it may be a mixture comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone and levulinic acid.

The composition may be an aqueous liquid (e.g. solution or suspension).

The composition may also comprise an organic liquid, such as e.g. an organic phase obtained by solvent-solvent extraction.

Liquid-liquid extraction is a process for separating components (the solutes) of a liquid (the feed) by contact with a second liquid phase (the solvent). The two liquids must not be completely mutually miscible. The process takes advantage of differences in the chemical properties of the feed components, such as differences in polarity and hydrophobic/hydrophilic character to separate them (T.C. Frank, L.Dahuron, B.S. Holden, W.D. Prince, A.F. Seibert, L.C. Wilson, Liquid-liquid extraction and other liquid- liquid operations and equipment in Perry's Chemical Engineering Handbook, 8th Edition, Section 15). Two streams result from the liquid-liquid extraction process: the extract, which is the solvent rich solution containing the desired extracted solute, and the raffinate, the residual feed solution containing little solute. Solvent extraction commonly (but not necessarily) takes place with an aqueous solution as one liquid and an organic solvent or mixture of solvents as the other. Numerous solvents with various properties are used in solvent extraction (Y.Marcus, Principles of Solubility and Solutions, in J. Rydberg, M. Cox, C. Musicas, G.R. Chopin (Editors), Solvent Extraction Principles and Practice, 2nd Edition, Chapter 2, Marcel Dekker Inc., New York). Extraction capacity of a solvent can be adjusted by changing process parameters like temperature or pH.

Before subjecting the composition to the distillation to produce the distillation residue, the composition may undergo one or more additional steps, preferably non- chemical steps. Examples of such steps include concentration, e.g. by flashing, solvent-solvent extraction, solid/liquid separation. A combination of two or more of these steps is also possible. Suitable solid-liquid separation techniques include filtration and centrifugation. A flashing step may combine cooling of a biomass hydrolysate after acid hydrolysis and concentration of such biomass.

The amount of angelica lactone on the residue is at least 1 wt% relative to the total weight of the residue. Preferably the amount is at least 2%, at least 5%, at least 10%, more preferably at least 15%, at least 20%, more preferably at least 30%, at least 40%, even more preferably at least 50%, at least 60%, even more preferably at least 70%, at least 80%, or at least 90%, even more preferably at least 95 wt%.

The composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling point of less than 245°C may further comprise humins, tar, and/or char.

Tar and char represent organic material which is insoluble in water, which is dark in colour and which tends to become viscous and very dark to almost black when concentrated. Tar can be formed during heating of organic material, for example by pyrolysis, but is also formed when carbohydrates are subjected to acid hydrolysis, particularly when done at high temperatures. Char usually refers to solid material, for example the remains of solid biomass that has been incompletely combusted, such as charcoal if wood is incompletely burned. Tar usually refers (viscous) liquid, e.g. derived from the destructive distillation of organic matter.

Humins may also be produced by acid hydrolysis of carbohydrates. Yang and Sen (Chem. Sus. Chem. 2010, vol. 3, 597-603) report the formation of humins during production of fuels from carbohydrates such as fructose. They speculate that the humins are formed by acid-catalyzed dehydration. According to US7,896,944 the molecular weight of humins ranges from 2.5 to 300 kDa.

In the context of the invention, "char" is understood to include "tar"

The presence of tar is undesired, amongst other reasons because it may stick to the wall of a reactor. It may also cause problems in a distillation. If a distillation process consists of more than one unit, which is often the case, any char present in the feed of a distillation char may accumulate in later distillation units and will be even more viscous and darkly-coloured, and will also be more concentrated in the bottom, because products exit the "train" via the top sections.

Before subjecting the distillation residue to the esterification reaction to produce the levulinic acid ester, the recovered residue may undergo one or more additional steps, preferably non-chemical steps. Examples of such steps include concentration, e.g. by flashing, solvent-solvent extraction, solid/liquid separation, and/or distillation. A combination of two or more of these steps is also possible.

The distillation residue may be used in an esterification reaction as such, or for example as a distillate of a subsequent distillation. The esterification reaction involves subjecting the residue (or processed form thereof) to an alkanol, preferably methanol or ethanol in the presence of a catalyst. The catalyst may be an acid catalyst, which may be already present in the residue, for example in the form of sulphuric acid, or which may be added to the residue. A catalyst and/or one or more co-reactants may be added to the residue, and the residue may be subsequently subjected to conditions of time and temperature to produce the levulinic acid ester. Of course it is also possible to first subject the residue to the suitable esterification reaction conditions and then adding the catalyst and/or co-reactant(s). The skilled person may find all necessary details for the esterification in hand books such as in "Organikum", Berlin, 1977, Schwetlick et al. pp 499.

In an embodiment, the invention includes a process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, said process comprising; optionally subjecting said composition to a solid-liquid separation to yield a solid fraction and a liquid fraction and collecting said liquid fraction;

optionally subjecting said composition or said liquid fraction to solvent-solvent extraction by adding a solvent, preferably MTHF to yield an organic phase comprising at least some of the levulinic acid and optionally at least some of the compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, and an aqueous phase, and recovering the organic phase;

subjecting said composition or said liquid fraction or said organic phase to a first distillation to yield a first residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone, and a first distillate, and recovering said first residue; optionally subjecting said first distillation residue to a second distillation to yield a second distillate comprising angelica lactone and optionally levulinic acid, and a second distillation residue, and recovering said second distillate;

subjecting said recovered first residue or said recovered second distillate to an esterification reaction comprising an alkanol under conditions and time and temperature to produce the levulinic acid ester; and

optionally isolating the levulinic acid ester.

In another embodiment, the invention includes a process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a biomass hydrolysate said process comprising:

optionally subjecting said biomass hydrolysate to a solid-liquid separation to yield a solid fraction and a liquid fraction and collecting said liquid fraction;

optionally subjecting said biomass hydrolysate or said liquid fraction to solvent- solvent extraction by adding a solvent, preferably MTHF to yield an organic phase comprising at least some of the levulinic acid, and an aqueous phase, and recovering the organic phase;

subjecting said biomass hydrolysate or said liquid fraction or said organic phase to a first distillation to yield a first residue comprising at least 1 wt% angelica lactone, and a first distillate, and recovering said first residue;

optionally subjecting said first distillation residue to a second distillation to yield a second distillate comprising angelica lactone and optionally levulinic acid, and a second distillation residue, and recovering said second distillate;

optionally isolating the levulinic acid ester.

In a further aspect the invention provides the use of reactive distillation in a process for the preparation of levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C. EXAMPLES

All compounds were analysed by GC.

LA, levulinic acid

LA, angelica lactone

FA, formic acid

MTHF, methyl tetrahydrofuran

Example 1

100g wood chips were impregnated for 90 minutes. After impregnation, the temperature was raised to the hydrolysis temperature and the slurry was hydrolyzed in the presence of approximately 5 wt% hydrosulphuric acid without stirring. After solid- liquid fractionation the liquid fraction of the resulting biomass hydrolysate was analyzed. The analysis results and the hydrolysis conditions are stated in Table 1 .

Table 1

concentration on total mass (liquor + wood)

Example 2

The reaction suspension of Example 1 is cooled via evaporation of the liquid reaction product. The resulting vapor is condensed resulting in an aqueous solution of approximately 1 wt% formic acid, 0.02 wt% acetic acid and 0.02 wt% levulinic acid.

Example 3

A biomass hydrolysate was enriched with pure levulinic acid to a levulinic acid concentration of 9.07 wt%, and with formic acid to a formic acid concentration of 1 .89 wt%, in order to simulate the flash step in Example 2. A total of 2.1 kg enriched biomass hydrolysate was extracted 5 times with each time 1 .7kg of fresh methyltetrahydrofuran at 60°C. After the fifth extraction 99.1 wt% of the levulinic acid and 98.8 wt% of the formic acid present in the reaction solution could be collected in the organic layer.

Example 4

Nine kg of the collected organic layer form the extraction described above was batch wise distilled. The initial concentrations were: levulinic acid, 1 .74wt%; formic acid, 0.33 wt%; acetic acid, 0.1 wt%. The organic phase was distilled to remove the extraction solvent with a falling film evaporator in a 3m BX column with a diameter of 7cm at 500mbar with a reflux ratio of 2. Eight kg of distillate was collected containing MTHF and water, and trace levels of formic acid, acetic acid and levulinic acid (all below 100 ppm). One kg of distillation residue was found to contain 92 wt% of the levulinic acid feed, and 100 wt% of the formic acid feed, respectively.

Example 5

The residue of the distillation of Example 4 is subjected to a further distillation to remove any low boiling compounds, the decreasing the pressure from 500mbar to 20mbar and increasing the temperature from 125°C to 175°C. The first fraction contains (nearly) pure methyltetrahydrofuran. The second fraction contains 75 wt% methyltetrahydrofuran and 20 wt% formic acid. The third fraction (bottom temp, 142°C) contains 20 wt% methyltetrahydrofuran, 65 wt% formic acid and 8 wt% acetic acid. No fraction can be isolated containing any detectable amounts of levulinic acid. Instead, the distillation residue is rich in levulinic acid and angelica lactone, and contains no detectable amounts of formic acid or acetic acid.

Example 6

A residue of a distillation as described in Example 5 which rich in angelica lactone and levulinic acid is subjected to a further distillation to remove any high boiling substances such as humins. This distillation yields a distillate containing angelica lactone and levulinic acid, and contains no detectable amounts of other compounds.

Example 7 A mixture of 50 wt% angelica lactone and 50 wt% levulinic acid was contacted with methanol at a ratio of 1 :5 of (angelica lactone + levulinic acid) : methanol. As catalyst 1 wt% methane sulphonic acid was added to the solution. The solution was reacted for 60 min at 105°C. The reaction yielded 96.5 wt% methyl levulinate and 0.8 wt% levulinic acid, and no detectable amounts of angelica lactone

Example 8

Angelica lactone was mixed with methanol in a ratio of 1 :5 and 1wt% methane sulphonic acid catalyst for 60 min at 105°C to yield 98.6 wt% methyl levulinate with no detectable amounts of levulinic acid and angelica lactone.

Example 9

Angelica lactone was mixed with methanol in a ratio of 1 :5 and 1wt% methane sulphonic acid catalyst for 60 h at 22°C to yield 95.8 wt% methyl levulinate with 0.27 wt% levulinic acid and no detectable amounts of angelica lactone.

Example 10

A residue according to Example 5 is reacted with methanol in a ratio of 1 :5 of (angelica lactone + levulinic acid) : methanol for 1 hour and 105°C to yield methyl levulinate; and no detectable amounts of levulinic acid and angelica lactone. No separate catalyst is added.

Comparative example A

Levulinic acid was mixed with methanol in a ratio of 1 :5 and 1wt% methane sulphonic acid catalyst for 60 min at 105°C to yield 96.0 wt% methyl levulinate with 1 .4 wt% levulinic acid.

Claims

1 . Process for the preparation of a levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C, said process comprising:

2. Process according to claim 1 where the distillation comprises reactive distillation.

3. Process according to claim 1 or 2 where the composition comprises formic acid, acetic acid, furfural, and/or propionic acid.

4. Process according to any one of claim 1 -3 wherein the composition comprises a biomass hydrolysate.

5. Process according to 4 wherein said biomass hydrolysate made by acid hydrolysis of lignocellulosic biomass.

6. Process according to any one of claim 1 -3 wherein the composition is made by acid hydrolysis of fructose or glucose or a combination thereof.

7. Process according to any one of claim 1 -6 wherein the process is carried out as a batch process.

8. Use of reactive distillation in a process for the preparation of levulinic acid ester from a composition comprising levulinic acid and optionally a compound having a boiling temperature of less than 245°C.