WO2007058652A1

WO2007058652A1 - Method of agile reduction of radar cross section using electromagnetic channelization

Info

Publication number: WO2007058652A1
Application number: PCT/US2005/041445
Authority: WO
Inventors: Al Messano
Original assignee: Ross, Alan
Priority date: 2005-11-15
Filing date: 2005-11-15
Publication date: 2007-05-24
Also published as: CA2632220C; EP1958291A1; CA2632220A1

Abstract

A method for reducing radar cross section of an object that has conductive portions and that is expected to be scanned by radar, which includes providing the object with a multiple layer radar cross section reducing structure that reduces or entraps or dissipates radar waves therein so that the size or configuration of the object cannot be correctly detected by radar scanning. The invention also relates to the radar cross section reducing structure alone or associated with an object such as an aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle that may enclose or transport personnel or equipment . The structure can be provided on an object that previously has no stealth capability or it can be applied to an object that already has stealth capability for the purpose of increasing capability or providing agility in order to prevent detection by threat or other radar systems. The incident radar waves are trapped and channelized towards an appropriate outlet, like an antenna.

Description

METHOD OF AGILE REDUCTION OF RADAR CROSS SECTION USING ELECTROMAGNETIC CHANNELIZATION

Technical Field This invention relates to technology for providing an active method of reducing Radar

Cross Section (RCS) of aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles being scanned by threat detection or other types of radars.

Background of the Invention Radar, an acronym for "Radio Detection and Ranging", systems was originally developed many years ago but did not turn into a useful technology until World War II.

One component of a basic radar system is typically a transmitter subsystem which sends out pulse of high frequency electromagnetic energy for a short duration. The frequencies are typically in the Gigahertz (GHz) range of billions of cycles per second. When such a pulse encounters a vehicle made of conducting material (such as metal), a portion of the energy from the incoming pulse is reflected back. If this reflected energy is of a sufficient magnitude, it may be detected by the receiver subsystem of the radar. The computer subsystem which controls the radar system knows when the pulse was transmitted and when the reflected pulse is received. This computer is capable of calculating the round-trip time, t, between the transmitted and received pulses of this electromagnetic energy. These pulses travel at roughly the speed of light, c, which is approximately 186,000 miles/sec (299,999 km/sec). This distance, D, to the detected target is:

D = ct / 2 Examples of current radars and their associated operating frequency bands and uses are as follows:

The relationship between radar wavelength, λ, and radar frequency, v is: λ = c/v

The strength, or power, of the reflected signal is described very adequately by the Radar Equation which relates radiated power of the transmitting antenna, the size and gain of the antenna and the distance to the target and the apparent size of the target to the radar at the operating frequency of the radar. This equation is as follows:

P_r = (P, G .2^z Λλ 2^z σ) / ((4π)^J R⁴) where:

P_r is the average received power

P_t is the transmitted power

G is the gain for the radar λ is the radar's wavelength σ is the target's apparent size

R is the range from the radar to the target

This apparent size of the target, σ, at a given radar wavelength (or frequency) is referred to as the "Radar Cross Section" or RCS. All other things being equal, it is the RCS that dictates the strength of the reflected electromagnetic pulse from a target at a specified distance from the radar transmitter. From a practical standpoint, the RCS is the sole characteristic of the target which dictates whether the target is detected or not. The current generation of Stealth technologies relies on five elements used in combination to minimize the size of the RCS of a target:

• Radar Absorbent Material (RAM)

• Internal Radar-Absorbent Construction (IRAC) • External Low Observable Geometry (ELOG)

• Infrared Red (IR) Emissions Control

• Specialized Mission Profile

The RAM approach to Stealth incorporates the use of coatings containing iron ferrite material which basically transforms the electric component of the incoming radar wave into a magnetic field. Consequently, the energy of the incoming radar wave is allowed to dissipate. This is an undesirable outcome of the RAM approach.

The IRAC approach creates special structure known as "re-entrant triangles" within the outer skin covering the airframe of the Stealth aircraft. These structures capture energy from the incoming radar wave within spaces that approximate the size of the wavelength of a particular radar frequency. The problem with this approach is that the triangles can only protect against a particular radar frequency, so that multiple triangles are required for the aircraft to avoid detection by different frequencies.

The ELOG approach is what gives Stealth aircraft the characteristic angular geometry clearly visible to even a lay observer. This flat, angled shape allows incoming radar waves to reflect or "skip" off the external geometry in all directions. Such a geometric design limits the design possibilities for the aircraft.

IR emissions control techniques deal with the heat (IR) signature of vehicular engine output but this requires a different control technique for each different engine signature.

The combination of the above four techniques is highly effective in reducing the RCS of Stealth aircraft in their own right. Additionally, each Stealth mission is carefully laid out so as to present only the minimized RCS to threat detection radars which have been identified and located prior to the mission. Thus a very specific and well-choreographed flight profile incorporating altitude, airspeed, angle-of attack and other flight parameters is flown by Stealthy aircraft on each and every mission. This causes complication of the mission so that improvements are desirable.

In addition, there are short fallings with existing Stealth technologies such as the use of toxic chemicals in the construction, susceptibility to the effects of weather and abrasive materials such as sand, as well as continued high levels of maintenance. But most importantly, there are two major flaws with current Stealth technology. First of all, the techniques outlined above are a permanent fixture of the airframe and cannot be altered or removed without adversely affecting the either the Stealthy or the aerodynamic characteristics of the Stealth aircraft. As such, non-Stealthy aircraft and other vehicles can not be made to take on Stealthy characteristics once they are constructed, commissioned and deployed.

Secondly, Stealth technologies currently in use cannot alter, adjust, adapt or modulate the RCS of a particular Stealthy design in response to new, different or varying radar frequencies employed by an adversary. As such, current Stealth techniques are static, not dynamic, once deployed.

In summary, this invention seeks to improve upon existing Stealth technology by providing agile radar selectivity, dynamic airframe compatibility, elimination of toxic and/or fragile external coatings, improved reliability and maintainability, cost reduction and upgradability in response to new technological threats.

Summary of the Invention

The invention relates to a method of reducing radar cross section of an object that has conductive and nonconductive portions and that is expected to be scanned by radar. The method comprises providing the object with a multiple layer radar cross section reducing structure that first entraps then dissipates radar waves therein so that the size or configuration of the object cannot be correctly detected by radar scanning, i.e. reduces RCS. The structure can be provided on an object, such as a vehicle that transports personnel or equipment, that previously has no stealth capability or it can be applied to an object that already has stealth capability for increasing its capability to prevent correct detection by radar scanning. The layers typically comprise one or more fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; one or more variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; or one or more layers each comprising an interference generating pattern ("IGP") for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation. Preferably, the structure includes a combination of at least two fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; at least two variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; at least two layers each comprising an IGP for deflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; a layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; or 2, 3, or all of the previously mentioned layers. The method can include altering the electromagnetic properties of one or more of the dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar. This provides protection against varying wavelengths of electromagnetic waves used for such radar scanning. That function can instead be achieved by providing one or more additional dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar, thereby providing selectable tuning to the scanning radar frequencies.

Generally, the conductive portions of the object are made of metal or metallic materials and the dielectric or interference generating pattern layers are made of a non-conductive, dielectric material. If desired, the structure can include a layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation. The method can also include focusing, dissipating and redirecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation by an output antenna system that is coupled to the combination of layers.

The invention also relates to a Radar Cross Section (RCS) reducing structure of the types described herein that reduces or entraps and dissipates radar waves therein. The structure can include means for altering properties of one or more of the dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar.

The invention also relates to a combination of an object that has conductive portions and one of the radar cross section reducing structures disclosed herein. Preferably, the object is an aircraft or other vehicle, and the structure is a coating applied to an exterior portion of the aircraft, vessel, structure or other vehicle.

Brief Description of the Drawings

Preferred embodiments of the invention are disclosed in the following drawing figures, wherein: Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of a typical Stealth "Layer Cake" comprised of active and passive dielectric materials;

Figure 2 describes the functions and properties of each layer in the Layer Cake structure;

Figure 3A thru 3J illustrate the transmitted and refracted wave components for each layer of the Layer Cake;

Figure 4 illustrates the net wave channelization and redirection effect; and Figure 5 illustrates the computer interface and its operative association with the Layer Cake. Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments

This invention, known as Method of Agile Reduction of Radar Cross Section Using Electromagnetic Channelization (MARRCS), relates to technology for providing an active method of reducing Radar Cross Section (RCS) of aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles being scanned by threat detection radars. This technology will be both portable and scalable to accommodate a variety of aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles not equipped with existing "Stealth" technology. It may also to provide dynamic and agile stealth capabilities to aircraft currently deployed with only the existing static Stealth technology. It is intended to use nanotechnology, where appropriate, reduce weight, provide support and insure airframe conformity. This technology will not adversely affect the operating characteristics of the aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles.

Furthermore, the technology will be active in that it will provide selectable, optimized protection from radars operating at different or varying frequencies. The net result will be an agile radar "sponge" which will selectively absorb the transmitted energy of radar signals, thereby reducing RCS. By doing so, the returned radar signal will not be accurate so that the scanner appears to be viewing a different or smaller object. It is desired to absorb as much of the radar waves as possible so that the object is not viewed at all. It is also possible according to the invention to redirect the absorbed energy and directionally repropagate it away from the aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle, possibly for decoy purposes. This invention relates to technology for providing an active method of reducing the

RCS of aircraft, vessels, structures or vehicles being scanned by threat detection radars.

Contrary to existing Stealth methods, this innovative technology is designed not to reflect incoming radar but to capture as much of the incoming electromagnetic energy as possible. Thus it creates a radar "sponge" for this energy which is then channeled and directed away from the aircraft. Essentially, it behaves as a radar energy waveguide.

The technology is designed to operate in all radar bands, as in the above chart, from L through W bands. This encompasses frequencies from 2 GHz through 110 GHz. However, since threat detection radars operate in the X, Ku and Ka bands, these frequencies will be discussed in greater detail than the others. The technology is adaptable to the higher frequency Q, V and W bands as well. Materials used could have K values as high as 400. These materials would have corresponding values of n as high as 20.

Channelization of the incoming electromagnetic waves in the above radar frequencies is accomplished through the use of a vertical and horizontal multiple-layer structure referred to as a Layer Cake herein. The materials utilized in this structure are generally active and passive dielectrics. Passive dielectrics are those which retain a fixed dielectric constant, K, for all frequency ranges concerned. Active dielectrics are those whose dielectric constant, K, may be changed by electrical, mechanical or electronic methods over the frequency ranges concerned. The magnitude of the dielectric constant, K, is related to the magnitude of the index of refraction, n, as follows:

K = n²

It is the value of n of each layer which determines the amount of energy refracting into the next lower layer of dielectric and reflected into the above layer. A typical Stealth Layer Cake is depicted in Figure 1. Each layer in such a Layer Cake has a specific function. These functions are outlined in Figure 2. The outermost layer (also referred to as Layer 1) is composed of a layer of dielectric material referred to herein as an Aeroskin. The refractive index of this layer should be close to that of atmospheric air whose n = 1 so that a preferred Aeroskin index would be approximately n = 1.1. Selection of this index of refraction, greater than that of air, will allow most of the radar wave to"bend" or refract into the Aeroskin. A small amount of energy would then be reflected off the Aeroskin. Suitable materials for the Aeroskin include low drag dielectric plastic or rubber materials with those made of fluorinated polymers such as Teflon being preferred.

The next layers (Figure 1 depicts two such layers) are comprised of fixed dielectric constant (K), therefore index of refraction (n), materials of successively increasing values.

The attached Figures 3-A thru 3-J show typical values of n as well as the percentage of energy transmitted through an interface between layers or reflected off that interface.

Figure 1 depicts an n = 2 for the first fixed layer (Layer 2 called Trap 1). The dielectric for the next fixed layer (Layer 3 referred to as Trap 2) so the index is n = 4. These increasing values of n will continue to allow the incoming wave to bend or refract deeper into the structure. The majority of the energy is again transmitted through the layers, although there will be some radar energy reflected off each succeeding surface of layered material. However, this reflected energy will be prevented from leaving the structure as it encounters a higher layer of lower dielectric which bends it back into the structure. Channelization will continue to be reinforced as the radar wave is refracted further into the structure. The structure of the Layer Cake may comprise more than two layers of fixed dielectric.

The next layers in the structure (Figure 1 depicts two such layers) are comprised of active layers of variable dielectric material. In Figure 1, these layers (designated layers 4 and 5) Radar Band 1 and Radar Band 2. Materials utilized in these layers are composed of dielectrics which capable of altering their values of dielectric constant through electrical and electronic means. Consequently, these layers act as filters which selectively refract radar waves of specific frequencies deeper into the Layer Cake. There may be more than two layers of active dielectric, although Figure 1 depicts only two. These layers have succeeding higher dielectric constants, yielding indices of refraction of approximately 4.5 and 6, respectively. Channelization continues to be reinforced as electromagnetic waves are refracted deeper into the Layer Cake.

The next layers (Figure 1 depicts two such layers numbered 6 and 7) are comprised of carbon nanotubes (CNT) shaped into a specific Interference Generating Pattern (IGP). Such IGPs and their design and function are disclosed in U.S. patent 6,785,512 Bl, and US patent application 10/846,975 filed May 14, 2004, the entire content of each of which is expressly incorporated herein by reference thereto. These CNT's are "doped" with dielectric materials thus creating doped CNT's or DCNT's. The IGP is generally one that may be nonconductive and is or includes a pattern, such as a grating, cone, sphere, polygon or other shape and/or pattern, of an inorganic material. Preferably, the IGP is provided as a support member configured in the appropriate pattern and includes a coating of a non-conductive material having a high dielectric constant thereon. The dielectric materials include families of materials of high dielectric constant, K, ranging from values of 2 to more than 400, and including compounds of silicon and of carbon, refractory materials, rare earth materials, or semiconductor materials. The coating is applied at a generally uniform thickness upon the pattern configured as a support member.

The IGP described herein is advantageously configured to attenuate radio frequency radiation in the appropriate radar range of 2 to 11 OGHZ. Advantageously, interference generating pattern reduces the radio frequency signal by at least 2OdB. The numbers of IGP layer may depend on the number of radar frequency bands of concern. While only two such layers as depicted in Figure 1 , more IGP layers may be added to included channelization for additional radar frequencies.

The method can include superimposing a plurality of support members to provide IGPs that attenuate the entire range of radio frequency radiation. Alternatively, the support member can be comprised of different IGP 's so as to substantially attenuate the entire range of radio frequency radiation. The pattern of the support member can be provided in the form of a grating, cone, sphere or polygon or other shape and/or pattern. Also, the IGP may be comprised of different patterns constructed with different physical dimensions for each pattern depending on the radar frequency of concern. For example, the IGP may be comprised of vertical layering of the different multiple patterns, or of horizontal layering of the different multiple patterns. Also, the IGP may be comprised of vertical or horizontal layering of the different multiple patterns which are axially offset from each other. The IGP layer will permit a tuned antenna to be created, thereby retransmitting the incident waves back into the Layer Cake.

The last layer, identified as layer 8 in Figure 1 , is a reflective layer composed of fixed high dielectric material or a conductive or metallic backplane. This implies that the index of refraction will be high. Figure 1 depicts a Layer Cake with an n = 20 or greater. Thus essentially all incident waves, which have passed through previously higher layers in the Layer Cake will be reflected back into previous layers. Because the index of refraction of these layers is less, these waves will be trapped within the structure.

The arrangement of dielectric materials within the Layer Cake enables incident radar waves to become trapped within the structure. Once trapped, they cannot escape and may be channelized towards an appropriate outlet. The outlet is created by allowing the structure to terminate at one end by a broad band conductive termination. By broad band, it is meant that all the radar frequencies concerned (for example X, Ka, Ku, V and W) would be reflected equally back through the structure and then from the outlet. At the other end of the structure is a termination which is matched to the radar bands selected. This termination is then coupled to an antenna. The intent is to contain as much of the radar energy within the active Radar Band layers (layers 4 and 5) and the IGP layers (layers 6 and 7) since these layers are more selective than the succeeding layers (Layers 1,2 and 3). Figure 4 depicts the net Channelization of the Layer Cake.

The antenna may be a conventional microwave antenna with good gain characteristics across the entire range of radar frequencies in question. It also would be possible to include a provision for coherent microwave output emissions, as in a maser. The antenna may be mechanically or electrically steerable and may use Micro Mechanical/Electrical Systems (MEMS) technology to alter the focal length of the antenna. This allows the absorbed waves to be dissipated away from the vehicle in a controlled manner to prevent correct detection of the size or configuration of the vehicle by radar scanning.

The goal is for the RCS structure to capture as much incident radar energy as possible by virtue of the layers, and channelize it within the successive layers of the Layer Cake. By creating a radar "sponge", reflection from the structure would be minimized, thus reducing the RCS. By projecting the radar energy from the outlet and away from the aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle, any increase in thermal signature would be minimized. Furthermore creation of a radar decoy is also possible. Proper gain control of the antenna subsystem could be employed to create "MASER-like" output.

A major consideration of this invention is to not detrimentally affect the aerodynamic, hydrodynamic or other functional characteristics of the aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle. Consequently, the Layer Cake structure must be thin and light, and also have a low dynamic factor of friction. The use of nanotube technology has been cited in the construction of the IGP layers (layers 6 and 7 in Figure 1). However, nanotubes doped with dielectric material of either the active or fixed kind, may be utilized in some or all other layers. It is intended that this Layer Cake structure be constructed in different physical dimensions. Thus, these structures may be engineered as to be mounted on existing non- Stealthy aircraft. This would provide a certain level of active Stealth capability. Similarly, these structures may be mounted on existing Stealthy aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles utilizing fixed Stealth capabilities in order to provide them with an active Stealth capability which they currently do not possess.

It is also intended that the Layer Cake structure offer an agile radar defense. As stated previously, layers 4 and 5 would be active in that they would provide variation of index of refraction according to selected radar frequency. Figure 5 depicts how this would work. Existing avionics systems are able to determine which frequencies are scanning the aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle. Typically the radar system puts that data on the avionics bus (PCI, Mil or other bus types) in a manner as to provide an alert to the pilot and/or REO. Currently, this threat detection warning is typically in the form of an "idiot light" that illuminates upon detection of the radar waves. However, the frequency data on the bus could be transmitted as well to a simple defense industry compliant single board computer (SBC) in an avionics bay of the aircraft. This SBC is referred to as the Electromagnetic

CounterMeasure (ECM) computer in Figure 5. The ECM would drive the Layer Excitation Electronics (LEE) necessary to alter the dielectric constant of the active layers in the Layer Cake. The ECM power requirements should be on the order of a few tens of watts. Solid state materials (i.e., InGaAs, etc.) that are known to be capable of changing their dielectric constant can be used for this purpose.

Consequently, this MARRCS invention would result in a radar-frequency agile threat intervention system. Existing avionics would detect radar scans and discriminate those scanned frequencies. The existing avionics bus would pass this data on to the ECM computer in real-time. The ECM computer, in turn would drive the LEE into real-time arrive layer response. Thus, radar energies of various frequencies would be captured, channelized and dissipated by the antenna in a controlled manner.

The RCS structure can be applied to the entire object or at least to significant portions of the object. On an aircraft, for example, the structure would at least be applied to the lower half of the fuselage and to the bottom of the wings to shield against ground radar. Of course, the entire outer portions of the aircraft body and wings can receive the structure as a coating or flexible "skin" that confirms and is adhered to the aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle.

Claims

THE CLAIMSWhat is claimed is:

1. A method or reducing radar cross section of an object that has conductive portions and that is expected to be scanned by radar, which comprises providing the object with a multiple layer structure that entraps and dissipates radar waves therein so that the size or configuration of the object cannot be correctly detected by radar scanning.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein the structure includes: one or more fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; one or more variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; or one or more layers each comprising an interference generating pattern for deflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation.

3. The method of claim 2 which further comprises altering properties of one or more of the dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar.

4. The method of claim 2 which further comprises providing one or more additional dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar.

5. The method of claim 2 wherein the conductive portions of the object are made of metal or metallic materials and the dielectric or interference generating pattern layers are made of a non-conductive material.

6. The method of claim 1 wherein the structure includes at least one layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein the structure includes a combination of: at least two fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; at least two variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; at least two layers each comprising an interference generating pattern for deflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; at least one layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; or

2, 3, or all of the previously mentioned layers.

8. The method of claim 7 which further comprises focusing, dissipating and redirecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation by an output antenna system that is coupled to the combination of layers.

9. The method of claim 1 which further comprises applying the structure to an aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle to provide stealth capability to the vehicle.

10. The method of claim 1 which further comprises applying the structure to an aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles that already has stealth capability to increase such capability.

11. A radar cross section reducing structure comprising a plurality of layers that reduces or entraps and dissipates radar waves therein.

12. The structure of claim 11 wherein the layers comprise: one or more fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; one or more variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; or one or more layers each comprising an interference generating pattern for deflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation.

13. The structure of claim 12 which further comprises means for altering properties of one or more of the dielectric layers to shield against different wavelengths of radar.

14. The structure of claim 12 wherein the dielectric or interference generating pattern layers are made of a non-conductive material.

15. The structure of claim 1 1 which further includes at least one layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation.

16. The structure of claim 11 as a combination of: at least two fixed dielectric layers or providing broadband radiation channelization; at least two variable dielectric layers for providing selective broadband radiation absorption; at least two layers each comprising an interference generating pattern for deflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; at least one layer comprising a reflector for reflecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation; or

2, 3, or all of the previously mentioned layers.

17. The structure of claim 11 which further comprises an antenna system for focusing, dissipating and redirecting certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation.

18. A combination of an object that has conductive portions and the structure of claim 1 1 associated therewith so that the size or configuration of the object cannot be correctly detected by radar scanning.

19. The combination of claim 18 wherein the object is an aircraft, vessel, structure or vehicle for transporting personnel or equipment.

20. The combination of claim 19 wherein the object is an aircraft, vessels, structures and vehicles and the structure is a coating applied to an exterior portion of the object.