SYSTEM, METHOD AND COMPUTER PROGRAM PRODUCT FOR ESTIMATING CLUB SWING CONDITION(S) FROM BALL LAUNCH
MEASUREMENTS
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The embodiments of the present invention relate generally to techniques for estimating one or more golf swing conditions and, more particularly, to techniques for estimating one or more of the spin loft, the club speed, the angle of the attack and the club path.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Many golfers work consistently to improve their game. One tool that has been developed to assist golfers in analyzing their golf shots is a golf ball launch monitor. Golf ball launch monitors are used extensively to provide detailed information regarding the velocity of the ball, the launch angle of the ball, the side spin of the ball and the like. As such, golf ball launch monitors are quite useful in training sessions to evidence the manner in which swing changes affect the resulting golf shots. Similarly, launch monitors are quite useful in club fitting to provide feedback on the golf shots hit by a golfer with different clubs such that the golfer can more intelligently select the most suitable set of clubs for their game. Further details regarding launch monitors are provided in the U.S. Patent Application No. 10/360,196, filed February 7, 2003, entitled "Methods, Apparatus and Computer Program Products for Processing Images of a GoIf BaIl", the contents of which are incorporated herein in their entirety.
However, golf ball launch monitors generally only provide information regarding the golf ball following the impact of the club head with the golf ball. Since the swing of the golf club up to and including impact with the golf ball
AttnyDktNo 034686/297380
dictates the manner in which the golf ball will be launched, it is also commonly desirable to obtain information regarding the golf swing itself. In this regard, information regarding those golf swings that result in poor golf shots could be analyzed in relation to those golf swings that result in better golf shots in an attempt to identify the characteristics of the golf swing that led to the different results so as to provide feedback on aspects on the golf swing that should be corrected to more consistently hit good shots in the future.
Accordingly, it would desirable to provide an apparatus and method that is capable of providing information regarding a golf swing without requiring golfers or golf professionals to purchase additional training equipment. If information regarding the golf swing could be gathered, however,, the attributes of the golf swing that lead to good and bad golf shots could be determined in order to provide a golfer with valuable information that identifies those characteristics of their golf swing that need to be monitored in order to consistently produce good golf shots.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
A method, system and computer program product are provided according to embodiments of the invention which address at least some of the needs and shortcomings identified above. In this regard, the method, system and computer program product may be capable of determining a plurality of launch conditions of a ball, such as by means of a launch monitor. Based upon the launch conditions of the ball, the method, system and computer program product may also be capable of determining, such as by means of a computing device, a component of momentum PN normal to the colliding surfaces of the club and the ball as well as a component of momentum Pj tangential to the colliding surfaces of the club and the ball. Further, the method, system and computer program product may be capable of determining at least one club swing parameter based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and PT. In this regard, the club swing condition may be spin loft, club speed, angle of attack and/or club path. As such, in one embodiment, a golf ball launch monitor may be employed to determine a number of launch conditions of a ball and then to process those measured launch conditions to determine one or more club swing conditions. As such, the club
2
AttnyDktNo. 034086/297380
swing parameters of one embodiment can be determined in a manner that is independent of any direct measurements of the club swing. Once determined, the club swing conditions may then be utilized by a golfer to determine the impact of various club swing conditions upon the resulting golf shots. In one aspect, the determination of the tangential component of momentum
PT may be based upon the radius of the ball, the spin of the ball and the moment of inertia of the ball. Additionally, the determination of the normal component of momentum PN may be based upon the mass of the ball, the velocity of the ball and the tangential component of the momentum Px. According to another aspect, the determination of the spin loft may be based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and Pj, the respective masses of the club head and the ball, the radius of the ball, the respective moments of inertia of the ball and the club head, the velocity of the ball and the distance in a tangential direction between the center of gravity of the club head and the location of impact between the club head and the ball. Additionally, the determination of the club speed may be based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and PT, the respective masses of the club head and the ball, and the spin loft.
According to a further aspect of the present invention, the determination of the tangential component of momentum Pτ and the spin loft is based upon the back spin of the ball without consideration of other spin components of the ball. Additionally, the determination of the angle of attack may be based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and PT, the launch angle of the ball and either the loft angle of the club or the spin loft. Still further, the determination of the tangential component of momentum
PT and the spin loft may be based upon the side spin of the ball without consideration of other spin components of the ball. In addition, the determination of the club path may be based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and Pτ, the launch angle of the ball, and the spin loft. Accordingly, methods, systems and computer program products are provided according to the various embodiments of the present invention to permit golf swing conditions, such as spin loft, club speed, angle of attack and club path,
3
AttnyDktNo. 034686/297380
to be determined without direct measurements of the club swing and, instead, to be based upon the launch conditions of the ball. As a result, a launch monitor can be utilized to capture the launch conditions of the ball such that the club swing conditions can then be determined. The golfers are accordingly provided meaningful information regarding their club swing conditions that will assist the golfer in improving their game without having to invest in additional training equipment.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWING(S) Having thus described the invention in general terms, reference will now be made to the accompanying drawings, which are not necessarily drawn to scale, and wherein:
Figure 1 is a block diagram of a system according to one embodiment of the present invention; Figure 2 is a schematic representation of a club head and ball upon impact;
Figure 3 is a schematic representation of the angle of attack of a golf club relative to the launch angle of the golf ball and the vector normal to the face of the golf club; and
Figure 4 is a schematic representation of the angle of attack of a golf club relative to the launch angle of the golf ball and the spin loft of the golf club.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION The present inventions now will be described more fully hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which some, but not all embodiments of the invention are shown. Indeed, these inventions may be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will satisfy applicable legal requirements. Like numbers refer to like elements throughout.
A system 10 for estimating for at least one club swing condition according to embodiments of the present invention is shown in Figure 1. The system typically includes a launch monitor 12 for determining the plurality of launch conditions of a ball. While the system, method and computer program product of
4
AttnyDktNo. 034686/297380
the embodiments of the present invention will generally be described hereinafter in conjunction with the swing of the golf club, the system, the method and computer program product of other embodiments in the present invention may be employed in conjunction with other types of balls, such as baseballs, softballs, etc., and in conjunction with other types of clubs, such as baseball and softball bats, etc.
In the embodiment in which the launch monitor 12 is monitoring the launch of golf ball, the launch monitor may be of the type generally described by the above referenced U.S. Patent Application No. 10/360,193. In this regard, the launch monitor generally includes a sensor 14 positioned, typically in front of or to the side of the golfer, to measure a plurality of initial launch conditions. The initial launch conditions may include initial ball velocity, vertical launch angle, lateral launch angle, dispersion angle, back spin and side spin and potentially a number of other launch parameters. The sensor can advantageously include an image sensor and, more particularly, one or more camera(s) for capturing at least two images of the ball immediately after launch from which the foregoing initial launch conditions can be measured.
The system 10 of the illustrated embodiment also includes a computing device 20, such as a processor, a personal computer or the like, that operated under control of a computer program stored in memory 16 as well as any other combination of hardware, such as an electronic circuit, an ASIC or the like, software or firmware, for thereafter estimating at least one club swing condition based upon the launch conditions of the ball. As is shown, this system can also optionally include a display 18 for depicting the launch conditions of the ball and/or the club swing conditions determined therefrom. The computing device 20 generally models the collision between the club head and the ball using the guiding principles relating to the conservation of momentum of rigid bodies. The relevant parameters associated with this modeling process are shown in Figure 2 in which the impact of the club head 22 with the ball 24 is shown from a top view looking downward onto the club head and ball. As illustrated in Figure 2, the club has a swing speed Vc at the time of impact and impacts the ball at an angle θ, termed the spin loft, which is the angle between the velocity vector and the vector normal to the ball at the impact location. The impact
5
AttnyDktNo 034086/297380
location can be defined relative to the center of gravity of the club head by dN which is the distance component in the normal direction, e.g., in the direction normal to the ball at the impact location, and dj which is the distance component in the tangential direction (the direction tangential to the ball at the impact location). The impact location can also be defined relative to the center of gravity of the ball by the radius RB of the ball.
The momentum that is involved in the collision between the club head and the ball has two components. The normal component of momentum PN acts in the direction normal to the colliding surfaces of the clubhead and ball, while the tangential component of momentum Pτ acts in the direction tangential to the colliding surfaces, as also shown in Figure 2.
As described above, the launch monitor 12 determines a number of launch conditions of the ball and, based upon these launch conditions and principles relating to the conservation of momentum, the computing device 20 determines one or more club swing conditions. In this regard, assuming the club head is not spinning prior to impact and neglecting smaller terms that involve the product of both dN and dp, the normal component of momentum PN can be defined as follows:
where me is mass of the club head, me is mass of the ball, Ic is the moment of inertia of the club head in the plane containing PN and Pj, and e is the coefficient of restitution which, in turn, is defined as the velocity of separation divided by the velocity of approach of the club head and ball in the normal direction. While me, me and Ic may be defined in advance and dγ can be measured by the launch monitor 12 (or assumed to be equal to 0 for impact locations at or near the sweetspot of the club head), it is noted that a number of the other parameters are club swing conditions or otherwise cannot be directly measured by the launch monitor 12. Assuming there is no relative velocity or sliding in the tangential direction when contact ceases and by making the same assumptions and simplification as in
6
AttnyDktNo. 034δ86/29738Q
equation (1), the tangential component of momentum PT can be similarly defined as follows:
where IB is the moment of inertia of the ball. As noted above, while me, mβ, IB and RB may be defined in advance, it is noted that a number of the other parameters are club swing conditions or otherwise cannot be directly measured by the launch monitor. In reality, different ball types have different spin characteristics due to the different material properties and the different types of layered constructions. The foregoing expressions are not intended to model the velocity and spin characteristics of different ball types, but are intended to relate the spin change and velocity change of a given ball for different club head swing speeds and spin lofts. Based upon the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and
PT, the post-impact velocity VB of the ball and spin ωB on the ball can then be defined as follows:
(3,4) V8 = In13-1Vp]TPT 2 and ωB = IB-' (RBPT )
It should be noted that the spin COB represents the total spin and θ represents the total spin loft. The spin COB can be further defined to be comprised of sidespin cos and backspin COBS- Similarly, the total spin loft θ of the ball can be further defined to be comprised of θs representing the effective open and close angle of the face at impact and ΘL representing the effective loft at impact.
Based upon equations (1) and (2), the club speed Vc can be defined in terms of the normal and tangential components of momentum as follows:
AttnyDktNo. 034686/297380
Based upon equations (3) and (4), the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and PT can then be defined as and determined by the computing device 20 as follows:
(7) Pτ =^k
As will be noted, the computing device 20 can determine the tangential component of momentum Px based upon the measurements of the launch conditions provided by the launch monitor 12 since the launch monitor can measure the spin OOB as well as the parameters which define the moment of inertia of the ball, while the radius of the ball RB is predefined. Once the tangential component of momentum Pj has been determined, the computing device can determine the normal component of momentum PN since the velocity of the ball VB is measured by the launch monitor and the mass of the ball me is predefined.
It is also noted that equations (5) and (6) include spin loft θ. The spin loft θ can be defined from the normal and tangential components of momentum defined by equations (1) and (2) as follows:
However, these expressions contain the clubspeed Vc and therefore the
AttnyDktNo. 034686/297380
computing device 20 cannot directly determine the spin loft θ from the launch conditions measured by the launch monitor 12 utilizing equations (9) and (10). However, equations (9) and (10) can be rearranged to arrive at the following equation for spin loft that is independent of the club speed Vc:
It should be noted that equation (11) includes e which is usually related as a function of club speed. In general terms, e varies in an inverse relationship to club speed such that swings having a faster club speed have an e with a lower value, and vice versa. However, the computing device 20 can employ an approximation for e such that equation (11) no longer has any dependence upon the club speed. In this regard, e may be approximated as a predefined value, such as 0.83. Alternatively, e may be defined as a function of the velocity of the ball VB since the velocity of the ball is almost linearly proportional to the club speed. In any event, equation (11) is not particularly sensitive to the value of e such that an approximation of e still yields accurate values of spin loft. Moreover, as the remainder of the terms of equation (11) can either be measured by the launch monitor (dj) or computed by the computing device from the launch conditions measured by the launch monitor (PT and PN) or are predefined (me, me, Ic, IB and RB), the computing device can now determine spin loft θ without having to directly measure any club swing parameter. Furthermore, it is noted that since the mass terms me and me are both in the numerator and denominator and since RB and IB dominate relative to the mass terms, spin loft θ as defined by equation (11) is not sensitive to the mass terms.
After determining the normal and tangential components of momentum PN and PT and the spin loft θ in accordance with equations (7), (8), and (11), respectively, the computing device 20 can determine the club speed Vc utilizing equations (5) or (6) above. As will be noted, the computing device can
9
AttnyDktNo. 034Θ86/297380
advantageously determine the club speed Vc based, directly or indirectly, on measurements of the launch conditions of the ball as obtained by the launch monitor 12 as well as predefined values without any direct measurement of the club swing or club swing parameters. Thus, the system 10, method and computer program product of exemplary embodiments of the present invention can indirectly determine club swing parameters, such as the club speed Vc and the loft angle Θ, in a manner independent of any direct measurement of the club swing.
The angle of attack (AofA) of the club head relative to a ball also provides useful information to the golfer and gives quantifiable information on how his/her swing affects launch conditions. AofA can also be calculated by the computing device 20 from the measured launch conditions, and the predefined loft angle of the clubhead. hi this regard, Figure 3 depicts an exemplary AofA and its relationship to the launch conditions of the ball. It should be noted that Figure 3 is a side view and shows the club and ball in the vertical plane and that AofA is negative.
The face of the club head has a loft angle as shown which is an inherent and predefined property of the club and the normal vector of the club head, that is, the vector normal to the face of the club, at the impact location is shown. The AofA is defined as the orientation of the clubhead relative to the horizontal axis at impact and may be defined as AofAi as follows:
(12) AofAi = Launch Angle + delta - Loft Angle
where delta is given by
P-,
(13) delta = arctan - TBS
V ΓN
Unlike the foregoing description of the tangential component of momentum
PT which was based upon the total spin COB of the ball, the tangential component of momentum PTBS utilized in the equations (12) and (13) utilizes only the backspin
10
AttnyDktNo. 034086/29738Q
COBS of the ball and not the sidespin cos or other spin components. In other words, the computing device 20 determines the tangential component of momentum PTBS utilizing only the backspin COBS of the ball as follows:
However, the computing device 20 determines the normal component of momentum PN in the same manner as described above. Thus, the computing device can determine delta based upon launch conditions of the ball that have been measured by the launch monitor 12 as well as predefined values. Once delta has been determined, the computing device can determine AofAi as defined above by equation (12) with the launch angle also being determined by the launch monitor as a launch condition of the ball and the loft angle being a predefined property of the club face. Thus, the system 10, method and computer program product of the foregoing embodiment of the present invention can also determine the angle of attack, another club swing condition, based upon measurements of the launch conditions of the ball and predefined values associated with the ball and the club without any direct measurement of the club swing.
Another way to define AofA is to be the angle the swing path makes with the horizontal axis at the time of impact as shown in Figure 4. As with Figure 3, the AofA is shown to be negative in Figure 4 as the AofA extends below the horizontal axis.
As indicated by Figure 4, spin loft is defined as the angle ΘL in the vertical plane between the swing path and the normal vector, that is, the vector normal to the club face at the impact location. Unlike the definition of spin loft θ described above and set forth in equation (11) which is based upon the total spin COB of the ball, the definition of spin loft ΘL utilized to determine the AofA is premised upon a tangential component of momentum PTBS that is based only upon the backspin COBS of the ball and not the sidespin cos or other spin components. As such, the computing device 20 determines the tangential component of momentum PTBS as
11
AttnyDktNo 034686/297380
set forth by equation (14) above and, in turn, determines the spin loft in the vertical plane ΘL in accordance with equation (11), albeit utilizing PJBS as opposed to Pγ.
As shown schematically by Figure 4, the AofA2 may be determined by the computing device 20 as follows:
(15) AofA2 = Launch Angle + delta - Spin Loft
which takes into account the swing path (through the spin loft component) and not just the orientation of the club face to a horizontal axis as In this regard, spin loft ΘL in the vertical plane and delta can be determined as described above with reference to equation (13) in regards to delta and the launch angle can be measured as a launch condition by the launch monitor 12. As such, the system 10, method and computer program product of the foregoing embodiment of the present invention can also determine AofA2, another club swing condition, based upon measurements of the launch conditions of the ball and predefined values associated with the ball and the club without any direct measurement of the club swing. This expression takes into account the swing path and not just the orientation of the clubface relative to the horizon as in equation (12).
Another club swing parameter is club path which is defined as the path of the club head in the horizontal plane prior to impact. The clubpath is usually referred to as being "in to out" or "out to in" meaning that a component of the path traveled by the club head was moving in directions generally away from the golfer and toward the golfer, respectively. The computing device can determine club path in a comparable manner to that described above in conjunction with AofA. In this regard, the club path may be defined as follow:
(16) Club path = Spin Loft - Launch Angle - delta
Because the club path is in the horizontal plane, the tangential component of momentum Pγs utilized to determine delta and the spin loft utilizes only the sidespin ωs of the ball and not the backspin COBS or other spin components. In other
12
AttnyDktNo. 034086/29738Q
words, the computing device 20 determines the tangential component of momentum PTS utilizing only the sidespin ωs of the ball as follows:
(17) /> = -£-*- R0
The computing device 20 then determines delta and spin loft (actually the component of spin loft that defines how open or closed the clubface is at impact) utilizing equations (7) and (11), respectively, albeit with PTS as opposed to PT. Since the launch angle is a launch condition of the ball that has been measured by the launch monitor 12, the computing device can determine the club path in accordance with equation (16). As with the other club swing conditions that have been described above to be determined by the computing device, the system 10, method and computer program product of the foregoing embodiment of the present invention can also determine the club path based upon measurements of the launch conditions of the ball and predefined values associated with the ball and the club without any direct measurement of the club swing.
Accordingly, methods, systems and computer program products are provided according to the various embodiments of the present invention to permit golf swing conditions, such as spin loft, club speed, angle of attack and club path, to be determined without direct measurements of the club swing and, instead, to be based upon the launch conditions of the ball. As a result, a launch monitor can be utilized to capture the launch conditions of the ball such that the club swing conditions can then be determined. The golfers are accordingly provided meaningful information regarding their club swing conditions that will assist the golfer in improving their game without having to invest in additional training equipment.
Many modifications and other embodiments of the inventions set forth herein will come to mind to one skilled in the art to which these inventions pertain having the benefit of the teachings presented in the foregoing descriptions and the associated drawings. Therefore, it is to be understood that the inventions are not to be limited to the specific embodiments disclosed and that modifications and other
13
AttnyDktNo. 034686/297380
embodiments are intended to be included within the scope of the appended claims. Although specific terms are employed herein, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purposes of limitation.
14
ΛttnyDktNo. 034686/297380