TESTING OF BREATH
Technical Field This invention relates to the testing of breath, and more particularly provides methods and devices for the qualitative and quantitative assessment of malodorous or bad breath.
Background Art Bad breath (halitosis) is a common social problem, but simple and effective methods for its assessment have not become available. Efforts have been made to establish testing criteria, using human testers, but this is not practical for everyday assessment. Attempts to establish instrumental methods have generally involved the use of laboratory-scale equipment, such as gas chromatographs, which are relatively expensive and cumbersome to use. See the references listed below. Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) in the breath is known to be a major cause or bad breath. Portable apparatus for measurement of the hydrogen sulphide concentration in the atmosphere is known, one manufacturer being Drager. The Drager apparatus has a tube containing mercuric chloride (HgCl2) supported on a suitable carrier. A predetermined amount of air is sucked through the tube, by a pump or a spring-loaded bellows.
Hydrogen sulphide reacts with the mercuric chloride to produce mercuric sulphide, resulting in a colour change. The length of the tube, over which the colour change occurs, provides a quantitative estimate of the hydrogen sulphide content of the air. The pressure required to draw air through this tube is
about 250 mmHg (1 mHg = 133 Pa) . This device has not been proposed for use in analysis of breath.
Summary of the Invention The present inventors have realised that a similar method can be employed for the detection of hydrogen sulphide in breath, making possible the assessment, both qualitative and quantitative, of a breath sample, to provide an indication of the degree to which it constitutes "bad breath". Such a device is particular for use by a person who wishes to test their own breath alone e.g. at home. In one aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of testing breath, comprising passing an expired breath sample through a flow passage containing a porous body of material carrying a component which undergoes a visible colour change on reaction with hydrogen sulphide. The method may be performed by a direct expiration from the lungs into the flow passage, or by capturing an expired sample, for example in an inflatable bag, and subsequently passing the sample through the flow passage. In both cases, a predetermined volume of breath is preferably passed through the flow passage. However, for a qualitative assessment, the volume of the sample does not need to be accurately determined. Breathing through the flow passage for an approximate amount of time, for example between 5 and 15 seconds, can provide an approximate qualitative assessment. In a second aspect, the invention provides a device for use in testing breath, having a flow passage containing a porous body of material carrying a component which undergoes a visible colour change on reaction with hydrogen sulphide, the
flow property of the passage being such that a gas volume of at least 500 ml passes through the porous body in 5 s when the pressure difference between the ends of the passage is 5 mmHg. Since normal out-breathing pressure (pressure of expired breath) during gentle breathing is at a pressure in the range of 1 to 5 mmHg above atmospheric pressure, this device is suitable for use in the method of testing by breathing through it. A typical volume of expired air to be passed through the device is in the range 200 to 1000 ml, which amounts to 1 or 2 normal breaths. Preferably the colour change occurs progressively along the porous body as the amount of hydrogen sulphide reacted increases, so that the location of the boundary of the colour change provides a measure of the total amount of hydrogen sulphide in the air sample passed. The flow passage is preferably in a tube having openable seals at each end, to protect the colour-change compound from contact with the atmosphere and moisture before the breath test. The porous material carrying the colour change compound may be held between porous plugs in the tube . The tube may be of glass or suitable transparent or translucent plastics material, and the seals may be flexible non-porous removable plugs or caps or adhesive peelable foils. Alternatively the seals may be breakable elements, for example glass end closures of a glass tube, which can be readily snapped off. Such a glass tube, having breakable glass closures, may be enclosed within a second tube which is flexible in order to permit breakage of the glass closures, without direct contact of the user with the glass. Such a tube may be a plastics material tube having locations of
relatively high flexibility (e.g. bellows portions) permitting localised flexing of the tube to allow breakage of the glass closures. Preferably the broken-off parts of the glass closures are retained within the second tube, without hindering the air flow, to avoid risk of harm to the user. The preferred compound which undergoes a visible colour change on reaction with hydrogen sulphide is mercuric chloride. The reaction is H2S'1 + HgCl2->HgS + 2HCl . Other compounds which provide a suitable colour change are lead acetate (Pb (CH3COO) 2) and silver chloride (AgCl) . This material is mounted on a suitable support, which provides the porous body. The support may be a monolithic body, or may be in the form of a body of particles held in place within the device, for example between porous walls in a tube. In the case of mercuric chloride, a suitable concentration of mercuric chloride in the porous body through which the breath sample is passed is in the range 10~8 to 10"5 g/cm3, more preferably 5 x 10"8 to 2.5 x 10"6 g/cm3, most preferably 2.5 x 10"7 to 1.25 x 10"6 g/cm3. Suitable materials of the support are silica, alumina and glass or plastics material beads of high surface area. The device of the invention may be in a form of a tube which has one end suitable for the user to blow into and a second end which opens into a inflatable bag sealed to the tube. The volume of the inflatable bag is suitable for receive a sample of expired breath which permits the desired measurement. This volume is preferably in the range of 200 to 1000 ml. One embodiment of the device of the invention is a tube 5 cm long and 1 cm in diameter, having a volume of
approximately 4 cm3. With a packed density of the carrier for the colour-change compound of 1, about 4 g of the substrate is loaded with an amount of mercuric chloride in the range 2xl0~7 g to 10~4 g of mercuric chloride, preferably in the range lxlO-6 to 5xl0~5 g. Such a device containing mercuric chloride in an amount at or near the upper end of the range is suitable to give a detectable colour change for a sample on one litre of breath, containing in the range 20 parts per billion (ppb) to 6 parts per million (ppm) of hydrogen sulphide (by weight) . 1 litre of air containing H2S at 20 ppb has a weight content of
H2S of 2.586 x 10"8 g, which reacts with 2.075 x 10"7 g of HgCl2. The colour change caused even by 20 ppb of H2S is visible.
Brief Description of the Drawings Fig. 1 of the accompanying drawings shows a test device of the invention. Fig. 2 shows a modified part of the device of Fig. 1. Fig. 3 shows alternative test devices.
Detailed Description of the Drawings In the device of Fig. 1, an inflatable air-impermeable plastics material bag 1 has an open side 2 across which the bag walls are heat-sealed together along a seal line 3. Passing through the open side 2 and sealed to the bas walls is a double tube structure 4. The. tube structure 4 has an outer plastics material tube 5 having apertures 6 in its ends covered by metal mesh 7. Held inside the tube 5 is a glass tube 8 having narrower elongated closed ends 9. Within the glass tube 8 and confined between fixed porous plugs 10 is a porous body of particulate carrier material 11 supporting the compound which undergoes colour
change on reaction with hydrogen sulphide, as described above. The closed ends 9 are circumscribed by score lines 12 so that they are easily snapped off, to allow air passage through the tube 8. The outer tube 5 has circumferential locations 13 of bellows-like conformation which are relatively more flexible than the remainder of the tube 5. To use the device, the user flexes the tube 5 to break off the ends 9 and then blows through the tube structure 4 to fill the bag 1 (which starts empty) with a predetermined volume of expired breath. The volume of the bag 1 when filled and the flow properties of the tube structure 4 (when open for through flow) are described above. Fig. 2 shows a modified form of the glass tube 8 of Fig. 1. Between the porous plugs 10, the porous body 11 of particles carrying the mercuric chloride or other colour- change material is conical in shape, increasing in cross- sectional area in the flow direction. This increases accuracy of assessment of H2S concentration at the lower end of the detectable concentration range. Figs. 3A, 3B and 3C show other forms of test devices of the invention, having the flow properties defined above. Each device is a substantially rigid tube 20 of transparent plastics material containing a body 21 of particulate material, such as silica, carrying the colour change material, such as HgCl2, held between fixed porous plugs 22. In Fig. 3A, the tube has removable seals in the form' of impermeable plugs 23 inserted into its ends to create a seal. In Fig. 3B, the end seals are flexible impermeable caps 24 which seal over the tube ends. In Fig. 3C the end seals are peelable discs 25 of impermeable film or foil sealed by adhesive to the tube ends.
References
Rosenberg (1992) J. Periodontol. 63:776-782 Shimura M (1996) J. Periodontol. 67:396-402 Suarez FL (2000) J. Dent. Res. 79 (10) : 1773-1777