BCL-2 SPLICING VARIANTS
Field of the invention
This invention relates to transcripts of genes that encode regulators of mammalian
cell viability and to the manipulation of cell viability through the targeting of variants of such transcripts .
Background to the invention
Mammalian cell viability is determined by a continual balance between pro- and anti- death signals. The best understood process is that of apoptopic cell death.
Bcl-2 is an inhibitor of apoptosis. The functions of the Bcl-2 protein include
protection against mitochondrial changes associated with apoptosis. This is achieved
by inhibiting pro-apoptotic proteins and by preventing mitochondrial permeability
transition. Apoptosis can be triggered by release of cytochrome c and other pro-
apoptotic components from the mitochondria: Bcl-2 is believed to inhibit such
events. Consistent with these functions the Bcl-2 protein is predominantly localised
to the mitochondria. Bcl-2 may also have additional anti-apoptotic functions yet to be
described. It may also block mitochondrial-independent pathways involved in
apoptosis.
The human Bcl-2 gene encodes mRNA transcripts of (i) 720 nucleotides in length for
Bcl-2 and (ii) of 618 nucleotides in length for Bcl-2β (see Figure 1). Bcl-2 ,and
Bcl-2β represent normal, alternatively spliced variants of the same Bcl-2 gene.
Abnormal and/or constitutive expression of functional Bcl-2 can protect mammalian
cells from undergoing apoptosis. Such an effect favours continued cell survival and
proliferation, and can initiate and/or maintain abnormal and/or cancerous growth.
m colorectal cancer cells evidence for a novel Bcl-2 - p53 axis has been reported for
a number of established human colorectal carcinoma cells lines, including the LoNo
and SW48 cell lines. Co-pending patent application GB0306148.8 relates to the
silencing of Bcl-2 by RΝA interference. p53-dependent apoptosis is induced
indicating that Bcl-2 constitutively suppresses a pro-apoptotic function of p53 in
colorectal cancer cells. Importantly, this pro-apoptotic function of p53 does not
require activation of the p53 protein by genotoxic stress or by other means.
Constitutive Bcl-2 suppression of p53-dependent apoptosis is likely to contribute to
the survival of human colorectal cancer cells.
There is a need to identify cell growth control targets for treating malignancies in
humans and other mammalian species.
Statements of the invention
According to the present invention there is provided a method of regulating apoptosis
in a cell, said method comprising targeting an abnormally or alternatively spliced
mRΝA, an abnormally or alternatively structured niRΝA. or a product of either.
The term 'regulate' is used to refer to the situation where the threshold of apoptosis
in a cell is controlled or adjusted to a particular specification or requirement and may
refer to either 'up regulation', wherein the threshold of apoptosis is increased as
compared to that which is observed in said cell, in absence of performance of the
method, or down regulation, where the threshold of apoptosis is decreased as
compared to that which is observed in said cell, in absence of performance of the
method.
Within genes, DNA serves as a template for the production of messenger RNA,
which in turn is a template for the production of proteins. Messenger RNA molecules
typically contain protein-coding regions called "exons" as well as non protein-coding
regions called 'introns'.
It is known that mammalian RNA transcripts are modified in the nucleus by additions
to the 5' and 3' ends of the molecule and by internal splicing to remove the introns.
The splicing event requires breakage of the exon-inrron junctions and joining of the
ends of the exons. By comparing the nucleotide sequence of mRNA with that of the
structural gene, the junctions between exons and introns can be assigned. The
junctions have well conserved, though rather short consensus sequences. The really
high conservation is found only immediately within the intron at the presumed
junctions. An intron starts with the dinucleotide GT and ends with the dinucleotide
AG. Accordingly, the junctions are often described as conforming to the GT-AG
rule. The GT-AG rule describes the splicing sites of nuclear genes of many (perhaps
all) eukaryotes.
However, the above is a very simplistic view of gene splicing. With the advent of information generated by various genome sequencing programmes it is evident that alternative pre-mRNA splicing is frequently used to expand the coding capacity of
genomes. Splicing motifs are being continually discovered and tissue specific splicing patterns are emerging. Exonic splicing silencers (ESS) are exonic cis- regulatory elements that inhibit splicing, often leading to exon skipping. Thus the permutations of genetic information expressed via a single gene can be amplified and regulated.
The Bcl-2 gene encodes 3 exons. The interspersed introns must be precisely snipped away from Bcl-2 messenger RNA and the remaining exons must be accurately spliced together, with no 'exon skipping', if a normal Bcl-2 protein is to be produced. The splicing machinery in the cell nucleus cuts and pastes (due to a "lariat" intermediate) to generate a single, properly spliced Bcl-2 messenger RNA molecule. Normally two alternative splice variants are detected, Bcl-2c- and Bcl-23, to give protein products of 239 and 205 amino acids respectively.
Exon skipping due to mutations in Bcl-2 and many other genes is frequently, if not always, caused by the disruption of "exonic splicing enhancers," or ESEs. ESEs are sequences within exons that stimulate messenger RNA splicing. Diverse mutations in genes lead to RNA splicing defects and in turn, to various diseases.
The term 'abnormally or alternatively spliced' is used interchangeably to refer to the
situation where mRNA is spliced using a splice sequence not normally used in
processing the normal transcript(s) and the resulting mRNA sequence is different to
that of the full-length normal sequence transcripts. Internal structures within the
mRNA transcript, for example stem loops and pseudo knots, can also affect the
information flow from transcript to translated protein product.
Preferably the method involves targeting the junctions of mRNA molecules that are
abnormally or alternatively spliced or abnormally or alternatively structured.
The term 'junction' is used to refer to the particular nucleotide sequence that is
created by the attachment or joining together of the alternatively spliced mRNA.
The term 'junction' also encompasses the apparent junction created by the presence
of secondary RNA structures wilhin the mRNA: such structures can cause looping
out from a lateral stem on the mRNA such that the apparent linear sequence
resembles that of a spliced junction upon amplification by RT-PCR. For Bcl-2
mRNA from colorectal carcinoma cells evidence for such structures has been
discovered using Abgene reverse blender RT-PCR amplification at 47°C; and the
Two-step Sigma RT-PCR kit at 47°C. Both these procedures give shorter spliced
Bcl-2 cDNAs and, importantly, the apparent splicing conserves the triplet reading '
frame for Bcl-2 mRNA (Figure 1). However, when RT-PCR is carried out using
Quiagen sense-script reverse transcriptase at 50°C, the cDNA product is for full
length Bcl-2 mRNA. These results indicate that Bcl-2 mRNA from colorectal cancer
cells contains highly ordered loop structures.
Alternatively the method involves targeting a protein product following translation of
an abnormally/alternatively spliced mRNA or abnormally/alternatively structured
mRNA.
Preferably the method comprises selective silencing of abnormal splice variants of
the Bcl-2 gene.
The term 'selectively silencing' is used to indicate that the silencing is specific for
the target gene and that there is no interference with normab endogenous gene
expression which might be detrimental to normal non-cancerous cells.
Preferably the method involves the targeting of any of the abnormal splice variants
Bcl-2α-591, Bcl-2c-588, Bcl-2α-480, Bcl-2c--633, Bcl-2/3-489, Bcl-2/3-474, Bcl-2/3-
420 and/or Bcl-2/3-315. More preferably the method involves targeting the mRNA
sequence flanking the splice junction between nucleotides 111 and 241 of Bcl-2α-
591.
In one embodiment the method of the invention involves targeting an
abnormally/alternatively spliced or abnormally/alternatively structured mRNA or a
product of either, by introducing into a cell containing a gene which is abnormally
spliced and which is to be targeted, an RNA construct having a nucleotide sequence
which is homologous to mRNA within said cell wherein said mRNA includes genetic
information of the gene element that is abnormally spliced.
Is is known that the introduction of dsRNA into cells initiates RNA interference
(RNAi). RNAi induces sequence-specific degradation of homologous mRNA. hi
mammalian cells RNAi can be achieved using small interfering dsRNAs (siRNAs),
preferably up to 28 nucleotides long and more preferably 21-22 nucleotides long.
The term 'homologous' is used to indicate at least 50%, preferably 85%, more
preferably 90%, more preferably 95% and most preferably 100% homology to the
reference nucleic acid sequence.
The present invention relates to the discovery of abnormal splice variants of Bcl-2
mRNA in human colorectal carcinoma cells. Sequence alignments are given in
Figure 1. The novel splice junctions conserve the normal triplet framing of the
spliced mRNA products and the functional BH1, BH2, BH3 and BH4 domains of the
Bcl-2 protein are also conserved (where BH stands for 'Bcl-2 homology domain').
Abnormal alternatively spliced variants of Bcl-2 may function constitutively to
suppress apoptosis in human and other mammalian cells, enabling abnormal cell
survival and abnormal cell proliferation. The expression of abnormally spliced
variants of Bcl-2 may thus represent a key oncogenic event in the development of
cancer. The abnormal splice junctions of the Bcl-2 mRNA molecules represent
selective targets for intervention via RNA interference or other means. The mRNA
sequence at these abnormal splice junctions is not present in the normally spliced full
length Bcl-2 mRNAs.
These abnormal Bcl-2 mRNA transcripts are shorter than the full length 'wild type'
Bcl-2 mRNA. In contrast analysis of the genomic Bcl-2 by PCR amplification gives
the predicted length for wild type Bcl-2 DNA (Figure 2). This indicates that the
shorter abnormal Bcl-2 mRNA transcripts are indeed generated by alternative
splicing of RNA, rather than genomic events with loss of DNA coding sequence from
the human Bcl-2 gene.
The abnormal alternative spliced variants of Bcl-2 mRNA expressed in human
colorectal cancer cells remain in-frame for the triplet genetic code and retain all
known functional domains of the Bcl-2o- and Bcl-2/3 proteins (see Figure 1) and are
functional in the suppression of apoptosis. Functionality is also evident in colorectal
carcinoma cell lines in which Bcl-2 expression may comprise solely of the abnormal
alternative mRNA form(s). hi such cells the selective silencing of Bcl-2 expression
by RNA interference induces apoptosis (Jiang and Milner, 2003).
In one embodiment of the invention, selective silencing of alternatively spliced Bcl-2
expression is achieved by RNA interference. Alternatively silencing may be
achieved by any other 'silencing means' such as small molecules, peptides and/or
related molecules that inhibit Bcl-2 either directly or indirectly, and also Bcl-2
derived products including abnormal Bcl-2 splice variants. Anti-sense RNA,
shRNA. miRNA and any other RNA and/or DNA based strategies may also be used.
Tumour cells other than colorectal cancer cells may similarly be treated, such as
ovarian cancer cells.
In one embodiment the present invention provides a nucleotide construct with a
nucleotide sequence that is homologous to mRNA transcribed from an abnormally or
alternatively spliced gene.
Preferably the nucleotide construct comprises dsRNA. Preferably the construct is 30
or less nucleotides long. More preferably the RNA construct is 20 to 30 nucleotides
long. Most preferably the RNA construct is 21 to 22 nucleotides long.
In one embodiment the invention provides a nucleotide construct such as anti-sense
RNA, shRNA or miRNA as means for silencing the expression of an abnormally or alternatively spliced gene for use as a medicament.
In an alternate embodiment the invention provides an agent selected from the group
consisting of: small molecule or protein, polypeptide; peptide; aptamer; chemical;
antibody; nucleic acid; polypeptide or nucleotide probe which agent interacts with or
binds with a protein expressed by an abnormally spliced mRNA for use as a
medicament. Preferably the agent comprises a sequence or molecular structure that is
complimentary to or of sufficient homology to give specific binding to the target.
In an alternative embodiment the invention provides a nucleotide construct such as anti-sense RNA, shRNA or miRNA for the manufacture of a medicament for the
treatment of cancerous cell growth.
In an alternate embodiment the invention provides an agent selected from the group
consisting of: small molecule or protein, polypeptide; peptide; aptamer; chemical;
antibody; nucleic acid; polypeptide or nucleotide probe which agent interacts with or
binds with a protein expressed by an abnormally spliced mRNA for the manufacture
of a medicament for the treatment of cancerous cell growth.
The mvention also provides a pharmaceutical composition comprising a nucleotide
construct such as anti-sense RNA, shRNA or miRNA and a pharmaceutically acceptable diluent or carrier.
In an alternate embodiment the invention provides an agent selected from the group
consisting of: small molecule or protein, polypeptide; peptide; aptamer; chemical;
antibody; nucleic acid; polypeptide or nucleotide probe which agent interacts with or
binds with a protein expressed by an abnormally spliced mRNA and a
pharmaceutically acceptable diluent or carrier.
According to a further aspect of the invention there is provided a DNA or RNA
expression vector as a delivery means for, for example, an antisεnse or an RNAi
molecule that is used in the targeting of an abnormally spliced mRNA or a product
thereof.
i one embodiment of the invention a viral vector is used as delivery means.
Preferably the vector includes an expression cassette comprising the nucleotide
sequence selected from the group consisting of; a) the nucleic acid sequence of the abnormally spliced gene element as shown in Fig 1; b) a nucleic acid molecule which hybridizes to the nucleic acid sequence of
(a) ; c) a nucleic acid molecule which has a nucleic acid sequence which is degenerate because of the genetic code to the sequences in a) and b) and any sequence which is complimentary to any of the above sequences; wherein the expression cassette is transcriptionally linked to a promoter sequence.
Preferably the vector including the expression cassette is adapted for eukaryotic gene
expression. Typically said adaptation includes, by example and not by way of
limitation, the provision of transcription control sequences (promoter sequences)
which mediate cell/tissue specific expression. These promoter sequences may be
cell/tissue specific, inducible or constitutive.
Promoter elements typically also include so called TATA box and RNA polymerase
initiation selection sequences which function to select a site of transcription
initiation. These sequences also bind polypeptides that function, inter alia, to
facilitate transcription initiation selection by RNA polymerase.
Adaptations also include the provision of selectable markers and autonomous
replication sequences which both facilitate the maintenance of said vector in either
the eukaryotic cell or prokaryotic host. Vectors that are maintained autonomously are
referred to as episomal vectors. Further adaptations which facilitate the expression of
vector encoded genes include the provision of transcription termination sequences.
These adaptations are well known in the art. There is a significant amount of
published literature with respect to expression vector construction and recombinant
DNA techniques in general. Please see, Sambrook et al (1989) Molecular Cloning: A
Laboratory Manual, Cold Spring Harbour Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbour, NY and
references therein; Marston, F (1987) DNA Cloning Techniques: A Practical
Approach Vol UJ IRL Press, Oxford UK; DNA Cloning: F M Ausubel et al, Current
Protocols in Molecular Biology, John Wiley & Sons, hie. (1994).
Detailed Description of the Invention
The present invention will now be described by way of example only and with
reference to the following diagrams;
Figure 1 Sequence alignments of human Bcl-2 splice variants in colorectal cell lines
(including LoNo; SW48 and HCT116). Boxed areas indicate functional domains of
Bcl-2. Note that Bd-2α-591; -cό88; -Q-480; -α633 and Bcl-2β-489; -0474; J3420 and
— /3315 retain all functional domain sequences. Dashes indicate missing sequences
from abnormally spliced Bcl-2 variants.
Figure 2
Sizing of Bcl-2 genomic DNA following PCR amplification from individual human
colorectal cell lines as indicated, using primers designed to span all abnormal splice
sites identified to date. The predicted size for the intact genomic Bcl-2 DNA PCR-
generated sequence, using the chosen primers, is 570 base pairs. This is the size
observed in all colorectal cell lines tested to date, as indicated on the gels. [Note that
genomic Bcl-2 is normally only spliced to generate the Bcl-2α and Bcl-2β variants].
Figure 3
Expression of abnormal alternatively spliced variants of human Bcl-2 in vitro and
immunoprecipitation with anti-Bcl-2 antibodies. Bcl-2 mRNA from human colorectal
cancer cells was reverse transcribed to produce a cDNA template from which cRNA
was transcribed and translated. Translation was performed in the presence of 35S-
methionine and radiolabelled protein was visualised by autoradiography following
immunoprecipitation and resolution by SDS-PAGE. Three abnormal splice variants
are shown (Bcl-2α-591; Bcl-2β-489; and Bcl-2β-420 as indicated).
Figure 4 Table summarising the truncated RNA products derived from the Bcl-2 gene and
detected by PCR in samples of different colorectal cell lines. HCT = HCT116 with
six individual clones which fall into three isogenic pairs with knock-out for p53; p21 and Bax genes, as indicated.
Figure 5
Radiolabelled Bcl-2 proteins following in vitro transcription and translation using
rabbit reticulocyte lysate. Proteins were resolved by SDS-PAGE and visualised by
autoradiography. Upper band = full length Bcl-2α; lower bands = protein products
generated via alternatively spliced alternatively structured Bcl-2 mRNA.
Materials and Methods
Bcl2 detection and cloning by RT-PCR
The primers used for Bcl2 amplification in colon cancer cell lines were as follows: 5'→ 3'
Bcl-2up ccatcgatggcgcacgctgggagaac
Bcl-2dn(α) ccggaattcacttgtggcccagatagg
Bcl-2dn(β) ccggaattcagcccagactcacatcacca
Bcl-2up2 ccgggagatagtgatgaagtaca
Bcl-2dn2 cctggatccaggtgtgcaggt
Bcl-2dn3 tgccggttcaggtactcagtc
The RT-PCR. is performed using lOOng total RNA, bc!2up and bcl2dn with one-step
RT-PCR kit from ABgene (cat. AB-0844 or AB-0844/b) in a thermal cycle as
follows: 47°C 30min, 94°C 2min, then 35 cycles of 94°C, 45sec, 58°C, 45sec, 72°C,
lmin, followed by 72°C for 5min. There are only shortened Bcl-2 products amplified
using above method. The full-length Bcl-2 product can only be amplified using
Qiagen one-step RT-PCR kit in a thermal cycle as below: 50°C 30min, 94°C 15min,
then 35 cycles of 94°C, 45sec, 58°C, 45sec, 72°C, lmin, followed by 72°C for
lOmin.
The PCR products were purified and digested with EcoRI and CM, and cloned into
pBSK+, then transcribed using T7 polymerase and translated using Promega RRL in
vitro. The translated protein were immuno-precipitated with various Bcl-2
antibodies: BD (BD biosciences), C-2, N-19 (Satan Cruz), Ab-1, Ab-2, and Ab-4
(Oncogene).
Bcl-2 antibodies employed in this study - positions of their epitopes:
Bcl-2 (BD) Against 49-179aa. From current study, it can be refined to 81-88aa.
Bcl-2 (C-2) Against a recombinant protein corresponding to amino acids 1-205. From the current study, it can be refined to 81-88aa.
Bcl-2 (N-19) Against a peptide mapping at the amino terminus of Bcl-2. From the current study, it can map at l-23aa.
Bcl-2 (Ab-1) 41-54aa.
Bcl-2 (Ab-2) 20-34aa.
Bcl-2 (Ab-4) 61-76aa.
Cloning and expression of abnormal alternative splice variants of Bcl-2 in vitro.
Abnormal alternative splice/structural variants of Bcl-2 mRNAs have been cloned from colorectal cancer cells and expressed in vitro. The results demonstrate that the abnormal alternative splice/structural variants of Bcl-2 are expressed as protein (Figure 3).
Lack of specific Bcl-2 epitopes was observed for the protein products encoded by the abnormal alternatively spliced Bcl-2 variants. Abnormal splicing in some way interferes with epitope availability for antibody recognition. It is proposed that epitope loss may prove to be a useful indicator of alternatively spliced Bcl-2
expression. For example, the variant Bcl-2α-591 appears to contain a novel splice
junction between nucleotides 111 and 241 (Figure 1): the protein expressed endogenously from this splice variant in human cells reacts poorly with the N19 anti- Bcl-2 antibody in immunoblots (Jiang and Milner, 2003), and in immunoprecipitation reactions following its expression in vitro (Figure 3). Loss of antibody reactivity may also be evident in tissue sections stained by imrnunocytochemistry. Epitope loss or modification may prove to be of clinical and diagnostic importance for identifying the expression of abnormal alternative spliced variants of Bcl-2 in human tissues. The same principles apply to tissues of other mammalian species.
Alternative abnormal spliced variants of Bcl-2 may represent a tumour-related abnormality. This abnormality may not be restricted to cancers arising from
colorectal epithelial cells. Other tumour types may also be affected, including other
epithelial tumours and/or tumours/malignancies arising from other cell types. Any
tumour-related abnormality represents a promising target for selective therapy
designed to selectively target malignancies in humans and in other mammalian
species. Such therapies may, in principle, be designed to suppress gene expression
using, for example, RNA interference. An alternative approach would be to target
abnormal mRNA structures using selective binding molecules. An alternative
approach would be to target functional protein-protein interactions by, for example,
small molecules designed to disrupt essential molecular interfaces between the Bcl-2
protein and its functional protein partners. Any differences in protein structure
created as a result of abnormal alternative splicing of Bcl-2 mRNA represent
potential tumour-specific targets for novel anti-cancer molecules and/or other
reagents.
References:
1. Jiang M & Milner J. Bcl-2 constitutively suppresses p53-dependent apoptosis in colorectal cancer cells. Genes & Development, 17; 832-837 (2003).