WO2003102710A1

WO2003102710A1 - Apparatus and method of controlling low frequency load currents drawn from a dc source in a telecommunications system

Info

Publication number: WO2003102710A1
Application number: PCT/US2002/032586
Authority: WO
Inventors: Yan-Fei Liu; Raymond Orr; Kai Xu
Original assignee: Catena Networks, Inc.; Potentia Power Systems Inc.
Priority date: 2002-05-31
Filing date: 2002-10-11
Publication date: 2003-12-11
Also published as: AU2002340179A1; AU2002340179A8

Abstract

A circuit (Figure 4B) controls the low frequency load currents drawn by components of telecommunications systems. The circuit includes a power converter, a first sense circuit (Vavg input into 412), a second sense circuit (input into 414), a comparator (414), and a power converter control circuit (412). The power converter control circuit controls the power converter's duty cycle in accordance with the input from the first sense circuit and Verror.

Description

APPARATUS AND METHOD OF CONTROLLING LOW FREQUENCY

LOAD CURRENTS DRAWN FROM A DC SOURCE IN A

TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[01] The present invention relations to a circuit for controlling low frequency noise currents drawn from DC power sources by loads requiring substantial AC energy at low f equencies. [02] In telecommunication systems, fans are generally used to reduce equipment's temperature rise. The fan's speed is controlled by a motor, which is usually controlled by a voltage applied across its terminal. A motor speed controller is used to control the motor speed and maintain a desired voltage level. The motor speed controller is often required because the telecommunication system's battery voltage often varies over a wide range. For example, the voltage range of a 48V system can vary from 36V to 75 V, with a transient up to 100V. Thus, the motor speed controller provides a constant voltage to the motor terminals to maintain the constant motor speed when the battery voltage changes over a wide range.

[03] It is well known that a direct current (DC) motor will draw a current that has a significant low frequency alternating current (AC) component. For example, referring to Figure 1, a waveform is resulting from a DC motor with 24V/1.5A (36W) output is illustrated. With 24V DC voltage applied to the motor, the DC value of the motor current is about 1.5 A. However, the AC component is 2.5 A peak to peak. The frequency of the AC current is about 275Hz. Additionally, there are significant harmonic components in the waveform. [04] The motor speed controller is a DC to DC switching power supply with an inherently fast response for maintaining the output voltage at a constant level.. The low frequency AC component of the motor current is reflected in the input of the motor speed controller. Therefore, the input current of the motor speed controller has a similar shape, which includes a significant low frequency AC component.

[05] Existing telecommunication equipment standards require that the input current of the motor controller must meet both wide band and voice band noise limits, which are much lower than the AC current, described above. In the example illustrated in Figure 1, the noise of the AC current is approximately 43dbrnc and the standard requires that the noise should be less than 9dbrnc. For a 3db noise margin, a 37dbrnc (43 - 9 + 3) attenuation of the AC current is required. [06] Referring to Figure 2, a standard method for attenuating the AC current is illustrated. An inductor-capacitor (LC) low frequency filter is added between the telecommunications equipment power source and the motor speed controller. A current I_motor between the motor speed controller and the fan comprises a large low frequency AC current component. There is also a significant amount of low frequency AC current in an input current I_Q of the motor speed controller. The value of capacitor Cl and inductor LI is very large, thus the impedance of capacitor Cl, XC1, is very small and the impedance of LI, XL1, is very large. Therefore, a low frequency AC current I_ac flows through the capacitor Cl and a DC current Ia_c flows through the inductor LI . As a result, the input battery current, I _at s DC.

[07] However, since the frequency of the AC current is very low, approximately 275Hz in the above example, the values of LI and Cl should be very large. In the above example, in order to meet the requirements set by the standard, the values for LI and Cl are selected as Cl = 2200uF and LI = lOOOuH. The size of such an inductor is fairly large, increasing its cost and space requirement. Furthermore, although the normal operating voltage for the system is 48V, the voltage rating for the capacitor Cl should be higher than 48V because the input voltage may range between 36V and 75V or even wider. Such a capacitor further adds to the cost and space requirement for the system. [08] Referring to Figure 3, an alternate solution to the problem is illustrated. In this solution, an active filter is placed between the telecommunications equipment power source and the motor speed controller. An active filter controller controls the voltage across MOSFET Q in such a way that the terminal characteristics of the MOSFET, that is the voltage across drain to source and the current through the drain to source, behaves like a large inductor. [09] However, the problem with the active filter is a large power loss in the MOSFET Q. The voltage across the MOSFET Q (VDS) should be higher than the worst case ripple voltage across capacitor Cl in order for the active filter to operate properly. The worst case ripple voltage happens at minimum input voltage when the input current is at maximum value. Another limitation is the gain of the MOSFET Q is very small when it operates at low drain to source voltage region. In a practical situation, the voltage across MOSFET Q should be larger than IN, and is typically between 2 - 3 V. This causes significant power loss in the MOSFET Q. [10] Further, it should be noted that in other applications, it is required to attenuate low frequency noise generated by electronic loads other than a motor of a fan. Such loads present the same difficulties as that described for fan.

[11] It is an object of the present invention to obviate or mitigate at least some of the above mentioned disadvantages.

BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION [12] In accordance with an aspect of the present invention, there is provided a circuit for reducing low frequency noise currents drawn from a DC power supply by a load circuit requiring AC power at low frequencies. The circuit comprises the following components. A power converter converts an input voltage to a desired output voltage. A first sense circuit senses an input current signal to said power converter. A second sense circuit senses a voltage signal at the load. A comparator is coupled with the second sense circuit for deteraiining, and providing as its output, a signal representative of a difference between the signal at the load and a predefined reference voltage. The comparator has a limited bandwidth as compared to the AC load requirement. A power converter control circuit has its inputs coupled with the first sense circuit and the comparator output, and its output is coupled with the power converter for controlling a duty cycle of the switch. The duty cycle is controlled in accordance with a relationship between the input signal and the comparator output. [13] The present invention relates to a load voltage controller that inhibits low frequency AC current generated by a load from transmitting into the input voltage rail of the load voltage controller. It is an advantage of the present invention that the cost of the implementation is lower and the size is smaller than that used by existing voltage controllers.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[14] An example of the present invention will now be described by way of example only with reference to the following drawings, in which:

[15] Figure 1 is a graph illustrating a typical motor current waveform;

[16] Figure 2 is a schematic diagram of a low frequency filter for attenuating a motor's AC current (prior art); [17] Figure 3 is a schematic diagram of an active filter for attenuating a motor's AC current (prior art);

[18] Figure 4a is a schematic diagram of a voltage control circuit in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. [19] Figure 4b is a more detailed schematic diagram one implementation of the voltage control circuit illustrated in Figure 4a. [20] Figure 5a is a graph illustrating the input voltage V_sense; [21] Figure 5b is a graph illustrating the average input voltage V_avg; [22] Figure 5 c is a graph illustrating the input current I_Sense; [23] Figure 6a is a graph illustrating the fan current;

[24] Figure 6b is a graph illustrating the output voltage V_out'_. and [25] Figure 6c is a graph illustrating the error voltage V_error.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION [26] For convenience, like numerals in the description refer to like structures in the drawings. The invention provides a method for controlling low frequency noise currents drawn from a DC supply by load circuits that require substantial AC energy at low frequencies. In a telecommunication embodiment, frequencies in the voice band require very large inductors and capacitors to form a conventional filter with adequate attenuation. This type of requirement arises when loads drawing pulses of current at low frequencies are connected to the battery. A cooling fan is one example of this type of load.

[27] Referring to Figures 4a and 4b, an embodiment of the invention illustrated generally by numeral 400. A battery terminal 402 of the telecommunication equipment (not shown) is coupled with a power converter 406 via a high frequency filter 404. A sense resistor R_sense is coupled between the high frequency filter 404 and the power converter 406. The power converter 406 is coupled to a low frequency generating load, such as a fan motor, 408. A capacitor 407 is coupled in parallel between the power converter 406 and the load 408. Generally, the capacitor 407 is a component of the power converter 406, but is shown in the drawing for illustrative purposes. [28] A low pass filter 410 has, as its input, a voltage V_sense sensed across the sense resistor

R_sense- The low pass filter 410 has its output coupled to a power converter control circuit 412. A voltage error amplifier 414 has, as its inputs, a Voltage V_out sensed at the load 408 and a reference voltage V_ref. The reference voltage V_ref is the desired voltage across the load. The voltage error amplifier 414 has its output coupled to the power converter control circuit 412. [29] In the present embodiment, the power converter 406 is a buck regulator. However, in practice any one of many switching power topologies may be chosen to provide the power conversion. These topologies include buck-derived topologies such as the forward, the push- pull, the half-bridge or the full-bridge. Furthermore, flyback and boost topologies are also suitable, as will be appreciated by a person skilled in the art. [30] The voltage control circuit 400 uses two control loops 416 and 418 for controlling the average value of the input current I_Q to the power converter. The average value of the current drawn from the battery terminal 402 will be same as the average value of I_Q. The first loop 416 comprises the sense resistor R_sense_. the low pass filter 410, the power converter control circuit 412, and the power converter 406. The second loop 418 comprises load 408, the voltage error amplifier 414, the power converter control circuit 412, and the power converter 406. [31] The operation of the voltage control circuit 400 is described as follows. The power converter 406 includes a switch that switches on and off at a high frequency to provide a desired average voltage at its output. The switching is controlled by a control signal 420 from the power converter control circuit 412. The greater the duty cycle of the control signal 420 the longer the switch remains on, resulting in a greater average voltage at the output of the power converter 406. Conversely, the lesser the duty cycle of the control signal the shorter the switch remains on, resulting in a lower average voltage at the output of the power converter 406. The average voltage at the output of the power converter 406 is then provided to the load 408. [32] As a result of the power converter switching, however, the input current I_sense to the power converter appears as an AC current. This AC component frequency, unlike that induced by the load, is a high frequency component, and is the same as the switching frequency. The high frequency component of the current is filtered by the high frequency filter 404 to avoid adversely affecting the voltage at the battery terminal. Implementing a high frequency filter is known in the art and does not have the problems associated with implementing a low frequency as described in the prior art. That is, an effective high frequency filter is relatively cheap to implement and requires little space. [33] The first control loop 416 is described as follows. Referring to Figure 5a the sense voltage V_senSe sensed across the resistor R_sense as the power converter switches on and off is illustrated. Since voltage has a linear relationship to current, the graph also represents a scaled version of the input current I_sense. which is illustrated in Figure 5c. Referring to Figure 5b, the average value of the sense voltage V_sense is illustrated. The average voltage is obtained by passing the sense voltage V_sense through the low pass filter 410, and is one input to the power converter control circuit 412.

[34] The second control loop 418 is described as follows. The voltage V₀ across the load is sensed and input to the voltage error amplifier 414. The reference voltage V_ref is also input to the voltage error amplifier 414. The voltage error amplifier 414 determines and amplifies the difference between its two input signals and outputs an error voltage Verror- Error voltage V_error is input to the power converter control circuit 412. It should be noted that the bandwidth of the second control loop 418 is designed to be much slower than the frequency of the AC component of the load. This is achieved by selecting the proper resistor and/or capacitor values for the voltage error amplifier 414. The bandwidth desired, as well as the resistor/capacitor values to achieving such a limitation will be apparent to a person skilled in the art in accordance with the implementation. Typically, a design criterion is to limit the bandwidth of the voltage loop to at least 10 times less than the frequency of AC component of the load. In the present embodiment, the frequency of the motor's AC current is approximated 350Hz. Thus, the bandwidth of the voltage loop is designed to be 20Hz or less. As a result, the low frequency component of the voltage V₀, that is the voltage related to the AC load current, across the load is filtered and the error voltage Ver_ror has a DC value without a low frequency component. .The AC current from the load is then forced to flow through the capacitor 407. Referring to figure 6a-c, waveforms of the load current IQ, voltage V₀, and error voltage V_en-_or are illustrated. Referring to Figure 6a, the low frequency load current is represented by a sinusoidal waveform. Referring to Figure 6b, the output voltage waveform is also sinusoidal. However, the bandwidth of the error amplifier is much lower than the load current. Therefore, referring to Figure 6c, the V_error waveform has DC form. [35] The operation of the power converter control circuit 412 is described as follows. The circuit 412 receives, as its input, the average voltage V_avg of the sense voltage V_sense and the error voltage Verror- Typically, the sense resistor R_sense is small so as not to use too much power. As a result, the average voltage V_avg is small (in the order of millivolts). Thus, the control circuit 412 amplifies the average voltage V_avg so that it is on a comparable scale to the voltage Verror- As previously described, the voltage V_err0r is an amplified version of the difference between the output voltage and the reference voltage. Typically, it is preferable to compare the two voltages when they are in the order of volts.

[36] The power converter control circuit 412 tracks the average voltage V_avg to the error voltage V_en-_or and adjusts the pulse width of the control signal 420 to the power converter 406 accordingly. The ability of the power converter control circuit to track the average voltage V_avg to the error voltage V_en-_or s an important factor in limiting the amount of low frequency AC current introduced at the input of the power converter 406. Thus, the type of circuit used for the power converter control circuit depends largely on how pure of a DC signal is desired at the input. In the preferred embodiment, the power converter control circuit is achieved using an average current mode controller, as will be appreciated by a person skilled in the art. However, in actual implementation, peak current mode control pulse width modulation circuits can also be used in order to reduce the cost. In this case, the input current will contain a small amount of low frequency AC current. The low frequency AC current remaining, however, falls within the requirements set by the standard for telecommunication applications. Other implementations will become apparent to a person skilled in the art. [37] As described above, the average voltage V_avg tracks the error voltage V_error- This is illustrated in the following example. The voltage control circuit 400 is implemented in a telecommunication environment to control the motor speed of a fan in an equipment cabinet. If the temperature in the cabinet rises, for whatever reason, the fan speed needs to increase to cool the equipment cabinet. In order to the increase the fan speed, the voltage at the input to the fan needs to be increased. This is achieved by increasing the reference voltage. As the reference voltage increases, the voltage V_error increases, since the difference between the desired voltage and the actual voltage increases. Since the average voltage V_avg is tracked to the voltage Verror. it is increased. As a result, the duty cycle of the power converter is increased, resulting in an increased voltage at the output V₀. [38] Furthermore, the average value of the voltage V_avg, as illustrated in Figure 5b, is tracked to the voltage V_error. which is a relatively pure DC signal. Therefore, the average value of V_avg will be equal to V_error- Consequently the average value of the input current I_Q over will be same. Therefore, the input current I_Q, will contain a DC component and high frequency switching components, which can easily be filtered by a high frequency filter. It does not contain the low frequency components related to the load current. As previously described, a high frequency filter does not have the same practical difficulties associated with it as does a low frequency filter.

[39] This combination of the two control loops 416 and 418 forces the power controller and load to appear as a voltage controlled current source when observed from the input power terminals and as a voltage controlled power source when observed from the load terminals. [40] Although the invention has been described with reference to certain specific embodiments, various modifications thereof will be apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as outlined in the claims appended hereto.

Claims

WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:

1. In a telecommunications system, a circuit for reducing low frequency noise currents drawn from a DC power supply by a load circuit using AC power at low frequencies, said circuit comprising: a) a power converter that converts an input voltage to a desired output voltage by repeatedly switching said input voltage on and off; b) a first sense circuit that senses an input signal to said power converter; c) a second sense circuit that senses a load signal at said load circuit; d) a comparator, coupled to said second sense circuit, that determines and provides as its output a difference signal representative of a difference between said load signal at said load circuit and a predefined reference voltage, wherein said comparator has a limited bandwidth as compared to an AC load requirement; e) a power converter control circuit, having its inputs coupled to said first sense circuit and said comparator output, and its output coupled to said power converter, that controls a duty cycle of switching of said power converter in accordance with a relationship between said input signal and said difference signal of said comparator.

2. A circuit as defined in claim 1, wherein said first sense circuit further includes a low pass filter that provides an average value of said input signal.

3. A circuit as defined in claim 2, further comprising an input amplifier that amplifies said input signal.

4. A circuit as defined in claim 3, wherein said comparator further includes a difference amplifier that amplifies said difference.

5. A circuit as defined in claim 4, wherein said input amplifier and said difference amplifier amplify said input signal and said difference, respectively, to a common order of magnitude.

6. A circuit as defined in claim 1, further comprising a high frequency filter, coupled between said DC power supply and said power converter, that reduces a high frequency noise component introduced by switching of said power converter.

7. A circuit as defined in claim 1, wherein said load circuit comprises a fan that cools said telecommunications system.

8. In a telecommunications system, a circuit for reducing low frequency noise currents drawn from a DC power supply by a load circuit using AC power at low frequencies, said circuit comprising: a) power converter means for converting an input voltage to a desired output voltage by repeatedly switching said input voltage on and off; b) first sense circuit means for sensing an input signal to said power converter means; c) second sense circuit means for sensing a load signal at said load circuit; d) comparator means, coupled to said second sense circuit means, for determining and providing as its output a difference signal representative of a difference between said load signal at said load circuit and a predefined reference voltage, wherein said comparator means has a limited bandwidth as compared to an AC load requirement; e) power converter control circuit means, having its inputs coupled to said first sense circuit and said comparator output, and its output coupled to said power converter, for controlling a duty cycle of switching of said power converter means in accordance with a relationship between said input signal and said difference signal of said comparator means.

9. A circuit as defined in claim 8, wherein said first sense circuit means further includes low pass filter means for providing an average value of said input signal.

10. A circuit as defined in claim 9, further comprising an input amplifier means for amplifying said input signal.

11. A circuit as defined in claim 10, wherein said comparator means further includes difference amplifier means for amplifying said difference.

12. A circuit as defined in claim 11, wherein said input amplifier means and said difference amplifier means amplify said input signal and said difference, respectively, to a common order of magnitude.

13. A circuit as defined in claim 8, further comprising high frequency filter means, coupled between said DC power supply and said power converter means, for reducing a high frequency noise component introduced by switching of said power converter means.

14. A circuit as defined in claim 8, wherein said load circuit comprises fan means for cooling said telecommunications system.