Method of simulating an attack with chemical warfare agents and the training substance.
The invention relates to a method of simulating an attack with chemical warfare agents, comprising dispersal of a liquid training substance by a burst produced by explosive technology. Further the invention relates to a training substance for use in the method, and a liquid composition intended to be mixed with water for producing the training substance.
In research, tests and evaluations of protection against chemical warfare agents, real CW agents may rarely be used owing to the risks this would imply. Instead use is made of a simulant compound which in some respect has properties similar to those of a CW agent but does not have the biological activity thereof. For example, the simulant compound may have physical properties such as water solubility, volatility, density, vaporisation heat, decomposition temperature, surface tension, viscosity etc, which closely conform with those of the real substance, or have chemical properties that make it react in a similar way on decontaminants. A simulant compound of the latter type is described in United States Statutory Invention Registration H270.
General simulant compounds, i.e. compounds corresponding to a CW agent in terms of more than two to three properties, are difficult to obtain. Instead several similar compounds for a CW agent will have to be obtained and then the most suitable for a given application is to be chosen.
In combat training, where the scenario involves combat troops being exposed to CW agents, training substances are used, which may consist of one simulant compound or mixtures of simulant compounds. The purpose of such training is to train the soldiers in using detection equipment and take the necessary measures of precaution. Training substances that are used for exposing training personnel to the substance are comparatively innocent chemicals, and various safety requirements can be set, stating the simulant compounds that are allowed in training substances.
It has been found difficult in combat training to provide sufficient realism in the actual dispersal of the training substance so that the soldiers are given an appropriate feeling for the seriousness behind the training operation. One way of significantly increasing the realism in combat training is to eject above the battle area a container
with a training substance and burst the container in the air by means of a small explosive charge. The idea of this operation is that the training substance will rain down on the ground below while at the same time a drifting gas cloud forms. Unfortunately it has been found difficult to apply the method to frequently occurring simu- lant compounds since they are inflammable organic substances and much inclined to catch fire when dispersed by the explosive charge. In particular methyl salicylate (MES), which is a frequently used training substance and a simulant compound for mustard gas, has been found far too inflammable to be dispersed in this manner.
An object of the invention is to provide a method of simulating an attack with chemical warfare agents by explosive dispersal of a training substance.
One more object of the invention is to provide a training substance which allows explosive dispersal without catching fire although simulant compounds included in the substance are inflammable organic compounds.
Another object of the invention is to provide a composition for easy production of the training substance.
This is achieved by a method, a training substance and a composition as defined in the claims.
A distinguishing feature of the invention is that the training substance is an oil-in- water emulsion containing an organic simulant compound for a chemical warfare agent as emulsified phase.
The amount of simulant compound and tenside in the emulsion varies depending on the simulant compound used. The amount of simulant compound in the emulsion should be sufficiently low to ensure that inflammation does not take place in the explosive dispersal while at the same time it is normally desirable to have such a high concentration of simulant compound as possible to give a clear effect in the drop-off area. For a relatively polar simulant compound such as MES, the oil-in-water emulsion can consist of 25-60% by weight of simulant compound, 1-10% by weight of tenside and the balance water.
The training substance can be obtained in the form of a liquid composition which is mixed with water for preparing the emulsion in connection with use. The liquid composition can contain, for instance, 85-96% by weight of simulant compound and 4-15% by weight of tenside.
Methyl salicylate (MES) is the simulant compound which is most frequently used when training personnel are to be exposed to a training substance. At the same time MES is a highly inflammable substance that has been found well suited to be dispersed in emulsion form by explosion according to the present invention.
Since the training substance is usually dispersed in natural environment, the tenside should be biologically degradable and otherwise toxicologically acceptable. Nonionic tensides are preferred, and particularly good results have been obtained with Berol 797, Berol 537, Berol 535 and OMA4 (Akzo Nobel Surface Chemistry AB).
The invention will now be described in more detail with reference to the accompanying figures and the examples below.
Fig. 1 is a section through a CW training shell which is suited for explosive dispersal of the training substance.
Fig. 2 shows schematically how the CW training shell is fired from a launching tube and is made to explode in its trajectory for dispersing of the training substance.
The CW training shell 1 according to'Fig. 1 consists of a container 4 which is filled with the training substance 5 and provided with a removable lid 6. The lid also serves as the projectile base of the shell and contains a propellant charge 7 for ejecting the shell from a launching tube 2 (Fig. 2), an ignition charge 8 for igniting the propellant, a time delay charge 9 and an explosive charge 10 for bursting the container and dis- persing its contents into the air when the shell is positioned in its trajectory.
Fig. 2 shows how the CW training shell is fired from a launching tube 2 and is made to explode in the air to form a cloud 3 of liquid droplets of the training substance. Large droplets will fall to the ground relatively directly while very small droplets may remain suspended in the form of an aerosol and drift with the wind.
Examples:
A number of emulsions of MES, different tensides and water were prepared and tested with respect to the stability of the emulsion, and some of these mixtures were then tested by firing and dispersing by using the above-described CW training shell. In addition to the necessity of the training substance not catching fire in dispersal, it was aimed at the training substance being easy to handle under active-service conditions. Stock mixtures of MES and tenside should be made ready for use by adding a certain amount of water and manual shaking for a while in connection with use. To prevent the simulant compound from catching fire in dispersal, it was important that the emulsion obtained by this simple procedure should be stable for at least a few hours.
Stock mixtures of MES and six different tensides were prepared, two different concentration levels of tenside being selected, nominally 5% and 10% respectively. From each of these stock mixtures, two different test mixtures were then prepared by adding different amounts of water so that the test mixtures would contain nominally 30% and 50% MES respectively. Table 1 shows the totally 24 test mixtures that were prepared. The designations 5-30, 10-50 etc. for Test Composition (nominally) relate to the nominal tenside content of the stock mixture (5%, 10%) and the nominal MES content of the test mixture (30%, 50%).
The emulsifying tests were carried out at room temperature. The test mixtures were prepared by weighing in glass test tubes with screw stoppers. After vigorous manual shaking for 1 minute, the emulsions were left at rest. Subsequently, it was investigated by intermittent ocular inspection to what extent the original emulsion seemed to be stable or whether a homogenous macrophase formed after some time. Berol CMA5 and Berol 533 could be excluded as less suitable emulsifiers for MES. Even after a few minutes, an oil phase began to separate. Of the remaining tensides, Berol OMA4 gave the least stable emulsion although it was a matter of several hours before oil droplets could be observed. Especially the 10-50 emulsion seemed to be less stable. As regards the remaining emulsions, no droplets could be observed even after several days of intermittent monitoring.
Then field experiments were carried out by dispersing test mixtures by means of the above-described CW training shell. Since the laboratory experiments showed that 5% tenside in the stock mixture was sufficient to give sufficiently stable emulsions of MES, only such stock mixtures were prepared for the field experiments. 165 g tenside was mixed with 3135 g MES. Stock mixtures were prepared using the tensides Berol 797, OMA4, 535 and 537. Test mixtures containing 30% and 50% respective- ly of MES were prepared by these stock mixtures being diluted with water, shaken manually in plastic bottles and poured into the container 4 of the CW training shell. 30 trail shots in all were made and none of them caused ignition of the test mixture. The temperature on the test occasion was 12°C. CAM instruments reacted as expected and gave distinct indication in all cases close to the drop-off area. The
mixtures containing Berol 797 and OMA4 were assessed to give the same effect on trichromatic indicator paper as pure MES. Large indication spots (> 10 mm) of the mixtures containing Berol 535 and 537 seemed initially to give a colour with a slight tinge of yellow (nerve gas indication) in the centre of the spot SJO as to develop after a while the correct colour over the entire indication. Small spots gave the impression of being genuinely red. On the whole, all tested emulsions were assessed to be sufficient for training purposes as regards shade of colour as well as intensity.