SENSORS AND SENSING METHODS FOR DETECTING ANALYTES BASED ON CHANGES IN pKa OF A SENSING POLYMER
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0001] This application claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. §119 (e) of Provisional Applications No. 60/222,276, filed July 31, 2000, 60/258,486, filed December 27, 2000, and 60/261,334, filed January 12, 2001, and to the co-pending provisional application titled "Poly (aniline boronic acid) : A New Precursor to Substituted Poly (aniline) s", Serial No. , filed on
July 30, 2001 and naming Eiichi Shoji and Michael S. Freund as inventors, each of which is incorporated by reference herein.
TECHNICAL FIELD [0002] This invention relates to sensor systems for detecting analytes in fluids.
BACKGROUND [0003] The development of chemical sensors has been the focus of intense research since the 1960s. Recently, conjugated polymers have received considerable attention for use in sensor applications, both as electronic conductors and as active sensing elements with ligands coupled to the polymer backbone. Poly (aniline) , in particular, has received attention due to its proton coupled redox chemistry and its resulting pH dependant properties. For example, poly (aniline) has been used as a pH electrode and has been coupled to reactions that generate or consume protons to create sensors.
SUMMARY [0004] In general, in one aspect, the invention features methods for detecting analytes in a fluid. According to the
methods, a sensor is provided that includes a polymer capable of undergoing a proton-coupled redox reaction, which polymer includes a plurality of reactive substituents capable of undergoing a reaction with an analyte. The sensor is exposed to a fluid containing the analyte, and a response is detected based on a change in the pKa of the polymer.
[0005] In general, in another aspect, the invention features non-enzymatic sensor systems for detecting an analyte in a fluid. The systems include a fluid volume, a sensor in operable contact with the fluid volume, and a detector configured to detect a response when the sensor is exposed to a fluid in the fluid volume. The sensor includes a substrate having a surface, and a sensor film deposited on the substrate surface. The sensor film includes a polymer capable of undergoing a proton- coupled redox reaction. The polymer includes a plurality of reactive substituents capable of undergoing a reaction with an analyte. The response is detected based on a change in the pKa of the polymer.
[0006] Particular embodiments can include one or more of the following features. The plurality of reactive substituents can include two or more chemically different reactive substituents. The two or more chemically different reactive substituents can have selectivity for different analytes and/or different effects on the pKa of the polymer. One or more of the reactive substituents can have an inductive effect and/or a resonance effect on the pKa of the polymer. The analyte can react with one or more of the reactive substituents upon exposure of the sensor film to the fluid to cause a change in the pKa of the polymer. [0007] The sensor can include one or more conjugated polymers. At least one of the conjugated polymers can be selected from the group consisting of polyaniline, poly(o- phenylenediamine) , poly (o-aminophenol) , polyphenoxazine,
polyphenothiazine, and poly (aminonaphtalene) . The polymer can be a functionalized polyaniline, such as a poly (aniline boronic acid) (e.g., a homopolymer of 3-aminophenylboronic acid). [0008] At least a plurality of the reactive substituents can be selected from the group consisting of boronic acids, pyridines, bipyridines and thiols. The analyte can be selected from the group consisting of polyols, fluorides, and amines. The analyte can be a metal selected from the group of metals capable of forming a complex with a ligand selected from the group consisting of pyridines, bipyridines and thiols. One or more of the reactive substituents can be capable of undergoing a reversible or irreversible reaction with the analyte. The polymer can be a poly (aniline boronic acid), and the analyte a polyol .
[0009] The response can be a change in the electrochemical potential of the sensor relative to a reference electrode, or a change in pH, conductivity, impedance, color, or mass of the sensor.
[0010] The analyte can be identified based on the detected response. Where one or more of the reactive substituents is capable of reacting with a plurality of different analytes, the analyte can be identified by distinguishing between at least one analyte in the fluid and at least one of the plurality of different analytes capable of reacting with the reactive substituents based on the detected response. Similarly, where one or more of the reactive substituents is capable of reacting with a plurality of different analytes, the analyte can be identified by distinguishing between a plurality of different analytes in the fluid based on the detected response. The concentration of the analyte in the fluid, or a change in that concentration, can be identified based on the detected response. If the sensor is exposed to the fluid for a time sufficient to
allow the reaction between the reactive substituents and the analyte to reach an equilibrium, the response can be measured at the equilibrium.
[0011] The details of one or more embodiments of the invention are set forth in the accompanying drawings and the description below. Other features, objects, and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the description and drawings, and from the claims.
DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS [0012] FIG. 1 illustrates one embodiment of a sensor system for detecting an analyte in a fluid.
[0013] FIG. 2 is a response curve of a poly (aniline boronic acid) electrode as a function of time upon addition of 6.8 mM: a) α-Methyl-D-glucoside; b) D-glucose; and c) fructose in pH 7.4 PBS.
[0014] FIG. 3a is a D-Glucose response curve of a poly (aniline boronic acid) electrode in pH 7.4 PBS as a function of time. Additions resulted in the following series of concentrations: 1) 3.4; 2) 6.8; 3) 10.2; 4) 13.6; 5) 17.0; 6) 20.4; 7) 23.8; and 8) 40.8 mM. [0015] FIG. 3b illustrates calibration curves of D-glucose (filled circles) for a poly (aniline boronic acid) electrode and of D-glucose (open circles) for poly (aniline) coated electrode in pH 7.4 PBS.
[0016] Like reference symbols in the various drawings indicate like elements.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION [0017] FIG. 1 illustrates one implementation of a sensor system 100 for detecting an analyte or analytes in a fluid (which, as used in this specification, includes liquid and
gaseous solutions containing an amount of the analyte, as well as substantially pure liquid or gaseous samples of the analyte alone) . System 100 includes a sensor 110 situated in operable contact with a sampling volume 120 and a detector 130 operably coupled to sensor 110. Sensor 110 includes a sensor substrate 140, such as a conventional glassy carbon electrode or the like, and a sensor film 150 deposited on a surface of the sensor substrate. Sensor film 150 is formed from a functionalized polymer 160 that is capable of undergoing a proton-coupled redox reaction. Polymer 160 is functionalized with a plurality of reactive substituents, which can be chemically identical (e.g., as in a homopolymer derived from a plurality of monomers bearing an identical or different substituents) or chemically different
(e.g., as in a copolymer derived from monomers bearing different substituents), such that the introduction of a fluid containing a target analyte or analytes into sampling volume 120 results in a measurable response based on a change in the pKa of the polymer. Optionally, sensor 110 can include multiple sensors of similar or diverse construction, as in a sensor array.
[0018] Polymer 160 can be any polymer that is capable of undergoing a proton-coupled redox reaction, and is functionalized with one or more reactive substituents that are capable of undergoing a selective reaction with one or more target analytes. Those skilled in the art will recognize that the selection of a particular reactive substituent or substituents is based on the particular analyte or class of analytes in question. Thus, for example, boronic acids are known to undergo selective, reversible complexation with polyols
(e.g., compounds containing more than one hydroxy group, such as glucose and other saccharides) , fluorides and amines. Accordingly, boronic acid substituents can be selected where sensor selectivity for these compounds is desired. Some
examples of other potentially useful substituents include pyridines, bipyridines, and thiols, which are known to selectively form complexes with metals such as iron, iridium, and gold.
[0019] In other embodiments, the reactive substituents may undergo irreversible reactions with the target analyte or analytes. For example, boronic acid substituents may undergo facile ipso-substitution reactions under mild conditions with a variety of compounds such as halogens, nitrates, thiols and the like, as described in the co-pending provisional application titled "Poly (aniline boronic acid): A New Precursor to
Substituted Poly (aniline) s", Serial No. , filed on July
30, 2001 and naming Eiichi Shoji and Michael S. Freund as inventors, which is incorporated by reference herein, resulting in replacement of the boronic acid substituent with a substituent derived from the analyte. Such irreversible reactions can form the basis of sensor systems for detecting the presence of target analytes, as will be described in more detail below.
[0020] In a preferred embodiment, discussed below, polymer 160 is a conjugated polymer such as a functionalized polyaniline. However, those skilled in the art will recognize that other polymers are capable of undergoing proton-coupled redox reactions, and are therefore suitable for use in the sensors and sensing methods described herein. Some other examples of such polymers include poly (o-phenylenediamine) , poly (o-aminophenol) , polyphenoxazine, polyphenothiazine, poly (aminonaphtalene) .
[0021] Without wanting to be bound by theory, preferably the reactive substituents exert an effect (e.g., an inductive or resonance effect) on the pKa of the polymer, which effect changes upon reaction of the substituent with the target analyte or
analytes, thereby changing the polymer's pKa. Thus, upon exposure of the sensor film to a target analyte, the analyte reacts with the reactive substituent. The resulting change in the properties of the reactive substituent causes a change in the polymer' s pKa, which can be detected by a variety of known techniques.
[0022] Detector 130 is configured to receive and process response signals based on changes in the pKa of polymer 160. In various implementations, detector 130 can be configured to receive and process such signals based on a variety of conventional measurements reflecting changes in sensor pKa, which can include, for example, changes in electrochemical potential, conductivity, or impedance of the sensor polymer. In addition, changes in pKa can be associated with changes in the polymer' s color or mass resulting from reaction of the analyte with the reactive substituents.
[0023] Optionally, detector can include appropriate signal- processing electronics and/or a programmable processor for processing the response signals. In some embodiments, detector 130 is coupled to a computer system 170, such as a general purpose computer system of conventional construction, that may include a programmable processor running a signal processing program for identifying analytes and/or characteristics thereof based on the response signals received from sensor 110. [0024] A method 200 of using sensor system 100 to detect the presence of an analyte is illustrated in FIG. 2. A fluid is introduced into sampling volume 120 (step 210) . If the analyte is present in the fluid, reactive substituents associated with the sensor film interact with the analyte (step 220) , thereby causing a change in the pKa of the polymer. Detector 130 detects and records response signals from sensor 110 (step 230). Optionally, detector 130 (or a processor of computer 170)
processes the response signals further to detect and/or characterize an analyte or combination of analytes (step 240) . The results of this detection and processing can be reported to a user, or can prompt computer 170 to initiate other appropriate action.
[0025] Sensor systems 100 can be fabricated using known techniques. Techniques for preparing conducting polymers are well known (e.g., electrochemical polymerization), and can be used to prepare functionalized conducting polymers as films or layers on suitable sensor substrates (e.g., on the surface of a glassy carbon electrode) , such as is described in the provisional application entitled "Poly (aniline boronic acid): A New Precursor to Substituted Poly (aniline) s", filed July 30, 2001, which was incorporated by reference above. Optionally, stabilizing agents can be incorporated in the polymer film - for example, the immobilization of polyanions such as polystyrene sulfonate or Nafion during polymerization of polyaniline is known to increase the redox stability of polyaniline films, as reported by P. N. Bartlett et al., J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1996, 92, 4137-4143.
[0026] Sensors 110 can be incorporated into a sensing system 100 by electrically coupling sensor 110 to an electrical measuring device in detector 130. The device measures changes in signal at sensor 110, preferably as the signal varies over time. The signal can be, for example, open circuit potential, conductivity, impedance or some other physical property of the sensor material capable of changing in response to the presence of the analyte in the fluid. The device can include signal processing electronics, and can be used in conjunction with a computer and data structures for identifying an unknown analyte or analytes by, for example, comparing a given response or
response profile to a structure-response database for qualitative and quantitative analysis.
[0027] In one mode of operation, sensor 110 incorporates one or more sensor polymers that respond differently to changes in analyte concentration or identity. Thus, detector 130 detects and records a first response when sensor 110 is exposed to a first fluid containing an amount of a first analyte, and a second response when sensor 110 is exposed to a second analyte or to a second amount of the first analyte. [0028] In some implementations, sensor 110 will be constructed so that the reaction between the reactive substituents is a reversible reaction (e.g., complexation of boronic acids with polyols as described above) , such that sensor 110 is capable of continuously monitoring for the presence or concentration of an analyte or analytes in a fluid, or for changes in composition of an analyte mixture. Alternatively, sensor 110 can be constructed as a single use sensor, useful, for example, simply to detect whether the sensor has been exposed to an analyte, in which case the reactive substituents may undergo irreversible reaction with the target analyte or analytes. Thus, for example, a poly (aniline boronic acid) sensor can be used to detect the presence of a molecular halogen in a solution simply by locating the sensor in a headspace above the solution. Exposure of the sensor to halogen vapor from the solution can lead to an ipso-substitution reaction replacing the sensor's boronic acid substituent (s) with halogen groups as described above, which may, in turn result in a change in the substituent' s inductive effect on the pKa of the polymer (i.e., where the inductive properties of the new substituent differ from those of the original boronic acid substituent) . The resulting change in the polymer pKa can be detected by
monitoring, e.g., the conductivity of the polymer, as discussed above .
[0029] Thus, for example, one embodiment of a sensor system 100 provides a non-enzymatic glucose sensor based on the reversible complexation reaction between boronic acid and diols, illustrated in Scheme 1, below.
Scheme 1 .
[0030] Poly (aniline) 1 consists of benzenoid diamine and quinone diimine groups, where the distribution of these groups is a function of the oxidation state of the polymer, and the degree of protonation of the polymer is a function of the pH.
[0031] Since the redox chemistry of 1 involves both electrons and protons, the open circuit voltage, Eoc, is sensitive to changes in pH. Likewise, it can be shown that the Eoc will be a function of Ka. For example, the acid-base reaction associated with the quinone diimine group in 1 can be written as:
Q+2H+ = QH2 + (1) with the corresponding acid dissociation constant:
Ka=[Q] [H+]2/[QH2 2+] (2) The reduction of the protonated quinone diimine structure is given by:
QH2 2++2e" s=t QH2 (3) with the corresponding Nernst expression:
E=E°'QH22 QH2+(RT/2F)ln[QH2 2+]/[QH2] (4)
It follows that the net proton coupled redox reaction, (combining eqs 1 and 3) is:
Q+2H++2e" *=e QH2 (5) Substituting the expression for [QH2 2+] obtained from eq 2 into eq 4 yields the corresponding Nernst expression for the net reaction, which is a function of Ka:
E=E°'QH_. QHi+( T/2F)ln[Q] [H+]2/Ka[ QH2] (6) It then follows that stabilizing QH2 2' by increasing the electron donating ability of a substituent group, in this case converting boronic acid into the boronate anion complex (Scheme 1, above) , will reduce the Ka of the protonated quinone diimine group (increasing Eoc, see eq 6) .
[0032] A sensor incorporating a poly (aniline boronic acid) film was prepared by the electrochemical polymerization of 3- aminophenylboronic acid on a glassy carbon electrode in the presence of Nafion as described in the following Examples, which are intended to illustrate the methods and apparatus described above, and not to otherwise limit the scope of the claims that follow below. EXAMPLES
[0033] Reagents. 3-aminophenylboronic acid (ABA), Nafion (40 wt% alcohol-water mixed solution) , sodium fluoride, D-glucose (GL) , fructose (FR) , and α-methyl-D-glucoside were purchased from Aldrich and used as purchased. Phosphate buffer saline (PBS) stock solution, pH 7.4, (xlO concentrated stock) was purchased from EM Science. The water that was used for all experiments was purified and deionized (18.3 mega ohm) by pure water system (Branstead, Model: Easy pure RF) . [0034] Instrumental setup. Glassy carbon electrodes (3 mm diameter) were purchased from Bioanalytical Science. The open circuit potential measurements were performed on an electrochemical workstation system (CH Instruments, model 660)
connecting PC computer (Dell Optiplex GX-1) . Cyclic voltammetry was performed with a potentiostat (EG&G Model: 362). In the voltammetric experiments, a three-electrode configuration was used including a platinum wire (length: 50 cm, diameter: 0.2mm) counter electrode and a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) as reference. XPS spectra were recorded with an M-Probe surface spectrometer (Surface Science Instruments) . All spectra were recorded with focused and monochromatized Al K ι,2 irradiation (hv=1486.6 eV) , and the X-ray beam was incident on the surface at an angle of 55° with respect to the surface normal. The analyzer was also positioned at an angle of 55° with respect to the surface normal.
[0035] Open circuit measurements. 25 mL of phosphate buffer saline (PBS, commercially available stock solution as 137 mM NaCl, 2.7 mM KCl, 10 mM phosphate buffer, pH 7.4) was placed in an electrochemical cell. A PABA electrode, equilibrated in PBS was placed in the cell and an open circuit measurement was made versus an SCE. The solution in the cell was stirred continuously during the measurements. Analyte was injected from a concentrated stock solution. For example, for glucose, 612.5 mg of D-glucose was dissolved in 4 mL PBS and the resulting solution was used as concentrated stock solution allowing 3.4 mM changes in concentration per 100 μL injection. Measurements were made under ambient conditions (ca.25 °C) with no strict control over temperature.
[0036] Deposition of Poly (aniline boronic acid). The oxidative polymerization of 3-aminophenylboronic acid was performed producing poly (aniline-3-boronic acid) (PABA) as follows: 3-aminophenylboronic acid (40 mM) and sodium fluoride (40 mM) were dissolved in 25 mL sulfuric acid aqueous solution (0.5 M) containing 5 mM Nafion (commercially available 40 wt% Nafion alcohol-water mixture solution was used) . The
potential of the GC electrode was scanned between 0.0 and 1.1 V vs. SCE at a scan rate of 100 mV/s. Polymerization was halted when the charge passed for the reduction of the deposited polymer reached 0.34 mC. The production of the PABA layer had a deep greenish blue color similar to that obtained upon the formation of poly (aniline) . X-ray photoelectron spectra of 2 showed that after equilibrating in PBS, all fluoride was exchanged out of the film. After careful washing of the layer with pure water, the electrode was stored in pH 7.4 PBS buffer to settle its chemical potential
[0037] Measurement of Open Circuit Potentials for Different Diols. The state of the polymer was followed by monitoring Eoc versus SCE in PBS as the sensor was exposed to solutions containing varying concentrations of α-methyl-D-glucoside, glucose and fructose, as illustrated in FIG. 2. The difference in sensitivity of the sensor for these three analytes is shown by the change in Eoc upon the addition of the same concentrations of the different sugars, and qualitatively follows the difference in binding constants with phenylboronic acid reported in neutral aqueous solutions (fructose > glucose > α-methyl-D-glucoside) .
[0038] Due to the sensitivity of 1 to pH, it is expected that the Eoc will be sensitive to the local pH drop within the film associated with the formation of the complex (Scheme 1) . This was confirmed by observing increases in Eoc for 1 coated with poly (vinylphenylboronic acid) upon the addition of glucose. However, as expected, the responses associated with local pH changes were transient in nature due to the rapid return to equilibrium with the bulk solution. Similar transient increases in Eoc are observed as spikes in FIG. 2 upon the addition of different sugars.
[0039] The slower steady-state responses that are observed in FIG. 2 are consistent with a change in pKa of 1 and subsequent protonation. It should be noted that the positive change in Eoc is in contrast to the change in redox behavior expected for the inductive effect on an isolated redox center that does not involve the transfer of protons. For example, according to the results obtained with the boronic acid substituted ferrocene/ferrocenium redox couple, reported by A. Moore et al., Can. J. Chem. 1999, 77, 681-686, the apparent formal potential decreases upon formation of the electron donating boronate anion structure.
[0040] Measurement of Open Circuit Potentials for Changing Glucose Concentration. FIG. 3 illustrates the use of a poly (aniline boronic acid) sensor to detect varying concentrations of glucose, including a response profile for the exposure of the sensor to eight different glucose concentrations at pH 7.4, as well as calibration curves of glucose for the poly (aniline boronic acid) sensor film and a polyaniline control. As FIG. 3 shows, the addition of glucose results in a stepwise increase in Eoc- A control experiment using only polyaniline 1 exhibited similar increases in Eoc. but the total shift of the potential was clearly smaller. Reversibility of the sensor was confirmed by the return of the Eoc to its initial value upon exposure to blank PBS.
[0041] A number of embodiments of the invention have been described. Nevertheless, it will be understood that various modifications may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. For example, while the sensors and sensing methods have been described in the context of particular polymers, reactive substituents and analytes, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the sensors and sensing methods can be implemented using other reactive
substituents as well, and in particular that any of a variety of known ligand/substrate systems may be suitable for use in the sensors and sensing methods described herein. Likewise, while the sensor polymers illustrated herein are typically substantially homopolymers having one or more reactive substituents coupled to each monomer, those skilled in the art will recognize that the sensors and sensing methods can be implemented using functionalized copolymers having different reactive substituents coupled to different monomers, or, in some implementations, using less than one reactive substituent per monomer so long as the sensor response upon exposure to the relevant analyte levels is sufficiently high for the chosen detection technique. Accordingly, other embodiments are within the scope of the following claims.