CEL -BASED ASSAY SYSTEMS FOR EXAMINING HCV NS3 PROTEASE ACTIVITY
Field of the Invention
This invention is directed to cell-based plasmid expression systems for analyzing the activity of hepatitis C virus NS3 protease upon its viral protein substrates, and hence, for the analysis and discovery of compounds having a potential for inhibiting viral replication.
Background of the Invention
Hepatitis C virus ("HCV") is a parenterally transmitted, hepatotropic virus that causes acute and chronic hepatitis, as well as hepatocellular carcinoma; approximately 2% of the world's population is afflicted with HCV infections, many of which remain chronic. No vaccine for HCV is currently available, present treatment generally being limited to interferon monotherapy, or the combination of alpha-interferon with the nucleoside analog ribavirin (Bartenschlager and Lohman (J. Gen. Virol. 81, 1631-1648 (2000)); Choo et al . (Science 244, 358- 362(1989)); Kolykhalov et al . (Science 277, 570-574, (1997)); Neuman et al . (Science 282, 103-107 (1998)); Saito et al . (Proc. Natl . Acad. Sci . USA 87, 6547-6549 (1990)); Tong et al . (Lancet 345, 1058-1059 (1995))).
HCV is a positive-stranded RNA virus having a genome 9.6 kb long comprised of a single, uninterrupted open reading frame encoding a polyprotein of about 3000-3011 amino acids; this polyprotein is a precursor to the individual HCV proteins necessary for replication, packaging and infectivity. The structural region of the polyprotein precursor (including the C, El, E2 and p7 proteins) is processed by host cell signal peptidases. The nonstructural region of the precursor (including the NS2, NS3, NS4A, NS4B, NS5A and NS5B proteins) is processed
between NS2 and NS3 by NS2-3 protease, while processing in the NS3-NS5B region of the polyprotein is accomplished by
NS3 protease activity (Bartenschlager et al . (J. Virol.
68, 5045-5055 (1994)); Eckart et al . (BBRC 192, 399-406 (1993)); Grakoui et al . (J. Virol. 67, 2832-2843 (1993));
Lin et al . (J. Virol. 68, 5063-5073 (1994)); Lin et al .
(J. Virol. 68, 8147-8157 (1994))).
HCV NS3 protease is thus an essential enzyme for HCV replication and viral infection (see, e. g., Kolykhalov et al. (J. Virol. 74, 2046-2051 (2000)); compounds which inhibit NS3 protease activity would therefore be useful as anti-HCV agents. Several studies have been reported detailing the biochemical features of the NS3 protease in the cell free assay systems (Bartenschlager et al . (J Virol. 67, 3835-3844 (1993)); Baftenschlager et al . (J Virol. 68, 5045-5055 (1994)), (J Virol. 69, 7519-7528 (1995)); Failla, et al . (J. Virol. 68, 3753-3760 (1994)) Gallinari et al . (J. Virol. 72, 6758-6769 (1998)); Grakoui et al. (J. Virol. 67, 2832-2843 (1993)); Lin et al . (J Virol. 68, 8147-8157 (1994)); Lin and Rice (Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. (USA) 92, 7622-7626 (1995)); Shimizu et al . (J Virol. 70, 127-130 (1996)). Additionally, three dimensional structural features of this enzyme have also been described both by x-ray crystallography as well as by NMR studies, utilizing NS3 protease domain alone, full- length NS3 (includes both protease and RNA helicase domains), NS3 tethered with its cofactor NS4A (Kim et al . (Cell 87, 343-355 (1996)); Love et al . (Cell 87, 331-342 (1996)); Yan et al . (Prot. Sci. 7, 837-847 (1998))). Compared to all this detailed knowledge about physical and biochemical properties of the NS 3 protein, very little is known about the characteristics of NS3 protease and its substrate proteins in a cellular system. Several studies have been made into cellular localization and activity of NS3 , but results are inconsistent among different HCV
strains, and cell types (Harada et al . (J. Gen. Virol. 76,
1215-1221 (1995)); Ishido et al . (Biochem. Biophys . Res. Comm. 230, 431-436 (1997)); Koch and Bartenschlager (Virol. 237, 78-88 (1997)); Muramatsu et al . (J. Virol. 71, 4954-4961 (1997)); Sakamuro et al . (J. Virol. 69, 3893-3896 (1995)); Wolk et al . (J. Virol. 74, 2293-2304 (2000)); Sho i et al . (Virol. 254, 315-323 (1999))).
Lack of an efficient cell-culture system and a convenient small animal model, as well as the low titers of infectious virus typically found in samples obtained from afflicted subjects has hampered progress in the discovery and development of anti HCV chemotherapy. This has also affected our understanding of the molecular mechanism of HCV replication and the functioning of HCV proteins, including NS3 (see, e.g., Bartenschlager and Lohman, 2000) . Rather, most of the studies have been limited to in-vitro analysis of HCV proteins.
Accordingly, there is a need for the identification of compounds able to inhibit viral replication and hence, to treat HCV infections, including by inhibiting HCV NS3 protease activity. This invention provides such an identification means, through its assays involving transfection of mammalian cells with DNA encoding both HCV NS3 protease activity and an HCV polyprotein substrate including an NS3 cleavage site, thus allowing for assessment of NS3 activity in the cells, as well as the inhibition of such activity through the use of particular compounds .
Summary of the Invention
This invention provides a method of assessing the protease activity of HCV NS3 protein in mammalian cells, said method comprising the step of first transfecting a mammalian cell with cDNA corresponding to the HCV nucleic
acid sequences encoding the NS3 protease cleavage activity and an HCV NS3 protease substrate polyprotein sequence including an NS3 cleavage site, wherein the 5' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a methionine codon and the 3 ' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a termination codon; said mammalian cells are incubated for a period of time effective for translation of the cDNA, and then lysed. Subsequently, the cell lysate is analyzed for the presence of mature, i.e., processed, HCV NS3 protease substrate, the presence of such processed substrate in said cell lysate being indicative of the presence of NS3 protease activity in the cell.
Results of the assessment are useful, for example, in determining the ability of a compound to inhibit HCV NS3 protease cleavage activity. This is accomplished by conducting the assay in the presence and absence of the compound, wherein a higher level of NS3 protease activity in the absence of the compound than is exhibited by the transfected cells in its presence is indicative of the activity of the compound in inhibiting NS3 protease activity. Moreover, the results are useful for demonstrating the expression of HCV nonstructural proteins in cell-based expression systems.
Expression of HCV NS3 protein herein is expressed as either (1) constitutive or (2) inducible. NS3 protein is expressed as (1) the protease catalytic domain, (2) full- length NS3 protein comprised of both the protease and helicase catalytic domains, (3) full-length NS3 protein followed by NS4A-NS4B polyprotein, (4) protease catalytic domain or full-length catalytic domain coexpressed with another NS3 protease substrate (e.g., NS5A-NS5B polyprotein) , (5) full-length NS3 protein followed by NS4A-NS5B polyprotein, or (6) mutant NS3 protease.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIGURE 1. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining
Inhibition of HCV N3-NS4B Polyprotein Region
Processing - as measured using inhibitors A, B and C on HepG2 cells, human hepatocarcinoma cell line, transfected with the plasmid pCXN2/NS3-4B
(see Figure 3) . Bold arrow: NS4B protein; I: no inhibitor present; II: untransfected cells; III: cells incubated in the presence of inhibitor A; IV: inhibitor B; V: inhibitor C; VI: Peflabloc™
(A: 125 »M; B: 500 »M) ) .
FIGURE 2. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Assessing Activity of Protease-Defective Mutant NS3 Protein on NS4B Processing - as measured using
HepG2 cells transfected with pCXN2/NS3-4B or p CXN2 /NS3m (mutant ) -4B DNA (see Figure 3). Bold arrow: NS4B protein; I: wild-type NS3 protein (pCXN2/NS3-4B) ; II: mutant NS3 protein (pCXN2/NS3m-4B) .
FIGURE 3. Schematic Representations of NS3 Expression Plasmids and NS Substrate Polyproteins . Bold arrows indicate NS3 protease cleavage sites on substrate polyproteins; "NS3*": NS3 protease catalytic domain; "5A*-5B*": recombinant pCDNA3 expression plasmid containing C-terminal NS5A through N-terminal NS5B sequence (including the NS5A-5B cleavage site); "NS3" : full-length NS3 protease; "NS3/4A/4B": full-length polyprotein comprising HCV sequence from the NS3 N-terminus to the NS4B C-terminus (including the NS3-NS4A and NS4A-NS4B cleavage sites) .
FIGURE 4. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Protein Processing by NS3 Catalytic Domain - as measured
using HepG2 cells co-transfected with DNA's corresponding to both the NS3 protease domain and a polyprotein encoding NS5A and NS5B. A: Schematic representations of full-length NS3- NS5B domain (top) and NS3 catalytic domain and recombinant ("r") NS5A/5B (bottom). B - I: Untransfected cells; II: NS3 catalytic domain + rNS5A/NS5B; III: inhibitor; IV: rNS5A/NS5B; V: NS5A (truncated) .
FIGURE 5. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Cleavage of Recombinant NS5A/NS5B by Wild-Type (Full-Length) NS3 Protein - as measured using HepG2 cells co-transfected with pCXN2/NS3 and pCDNA3/NS5A5B plasmid DNA, and then incubated in the presence and absence of an NS3 -specific inhibitor. A: Schematic representations of full-length NS3-NS5B domain (top) and NS3 and rNS5A/NS5B (bottom). B - I : No inhibitor; II: inhibitor concentration; III: untransfected cells; IV: NS5A (truncated) .
FIGURE 6. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Cleavage of HCV Polyprotein by Wild-Type NS3 Protein - as measured by cotransfection of HepG2 cells with pCDNA3 /NS5A5B and pCXN2/NS3-4B plasmid DNA in the absence and presence of NS3- specific inhibitor. A: Schematic representations of full-length NS3-NS5B domain (top) and NS3-NS4B full length (bottom left) and rNS5A/NS5B (bottom right). B - I: Untransfected cells; II: no inhibitor; III: inhibitor concentration; IV: NS4B (full length); V: NS5A (truncated) .
FIGURE 7. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining
Tetracycline-Induced Cleavage of HCV NS3 /NS4B Polyprotein - as measured using HepG2 cells co- transfected with pTRE/NS3-4B and ptet/ON plasmid DNA in the presence (A) and absence of doxycyclin. I: NS3/NS4A polyprotein; II: NS4B protein.
FIGURE 8. Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Ecdysone-Induced Cleavage of NS3-NS4B
Polyprotein - as measured using HepG2 cells co- transfected with pIND (Spl) /NS3-NS4B and pVGRXR plasmid DNA incubated in the presence of ecdysone (I: Ponasterone®; I: 15 »M; II: 5«M; III: 0 -M) . II (arrow): NS4B protein.
Detailed Description of the Invention
This invention provides a method of assessing the protease activity of hepatitis C virus ( "HCV" ) non- structural 3 ("NS3") protein, said method comprising the steps of: (a) transfecting a mammalian cell with cDNA corresponding to the HCV nucleic acid sequence encoding the NS3 protease cleavage activity and an HCV nucleic acid sequence encoding an NS3 protease substrate, containing an NS3 cleavage site - the 5 ' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a methionine codon and the 3 ' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a termination codon; (b) incubating said mammalian cells for a period of time effective for translation of the cDNA of step (a) ; (c) lysing said incubated mammalian cells of step (b) ; and, (d) detecting the presence of cleaved HCV NS3 protease substrate in the cell lysate of step (c) , the presence of such substrate in said cell lysate being indicative of the presence of NS3 protease activity in the cell.
HCV being a positive-stranded RNA virus, a cDNA copy of said RNA is made for transfections herein according to procedures well known in, and readily practiced by, the art. "Transfecting" as used herein means any process generally accepted in the art for introducing nucleic acid sequences into cells such that the sequences are capable of being translated into proteins; these include, for example and without limitation, transfection by encapsulation of the nucleic acids in liposomes as well as by electroporation. Transfection of mammalian cells herein is by introduction into the cells of a plasmid comprising a cDNA which comprises from 5 ' to 3 ' in operable linkage a methionine codon, the NS3 protease activity-encoding sequence, the NS3 substrate-encoding sequence and a termination codon, or by cotransfection of a plasmid comprising a cDNA which comprises from 5 ' to 3 ' in operable linkage a methionine codon, the NS3 protease- activity encoding sequence and a termination codon and a plasmid comprising a cDNA which comprises from 5' to 3 ' in operable linkage a methionine codon the NS3 substrate- encoding sequence and a termination codon. "Operable linkage" of a codon, such as a methionine codon or a termination codon to another DNA sequence is well known in the art, and is taken herein, to mean linkage of the codon to the additional DNA sequence such that the codon functions for its intended purposes during transcription and translation of that sequence. "Mammalian cells" transfected are any such cells into which nucleic acids can be introduced and then subsequently translated; most preferably herein the mammalian cell transfected is a human hepatocarcinoma cell such as HepG2 , although other cell types, e.g., the human transformed embryonic kidney 293 cell line, and human hepatocarcinoma cell line , Huh- 7, also yield similar results or are also useful.
Transfected cells are incubated according to step (b) of this invention's method for a period of time effective for translation of the transfected cDNA; such incubation is under conditions most suitable for growth of cells of a particular type, these being either known to those of ordinary skill in the art or readily determined by them without undue experimentation. An "effective period of time, " and that generally preferred herein, for incubation is about 20 hours, although this period may be longer or shorter as needed. After incubation for the effective period, the cells are lysed so as to release their protein contents intact so that the presence of HCV proteins in the lysates can be detected; such lysis is under conditions suitable for subsequent detection of specific proteins in the lysate and is by methods well known to ordinarily skilled artisans (see, e.g., Example 1 hereinbelow) . Protein detection is also by means, and using techniques, well known to, and readily practiced by, the artisans.
NS3 protease cleaves its HCV polyprotein precursor substrate into individual viral proteins at specific cleavage sites on the precursor. Thus, transfection into mammalian cells, as provided herein, of NS3 protease- encoding and substrate-encoding sequences allows for the assessment of protease activity on the substrate in vivo; such activity assessment, in turn, allows for examination of its inhibition by particular compounds of interest inside cells.
Thus, this invention further provides a method of assessing the activity of a compound in inhibiting the activity of HCV NS3 protease, said method comprising conducting the assay provided herein in the presence, and absence, of the compound whose inhibitory activity is being assessed. Production of HCV proteins from NS3
polyprotein substrates by NS3 protease in the absence and presence of the particular compound is compared, a decrease in such production in the presence of the compound over that exhibited in its absence being indicative of inhibition of NS3 activity by the compound. NS3 protease activity in this system is assessed on almost all of its natural cleavage sites, and in a biologically relevant context. The anti-NS3 protease activity of potential compounds on various NS3 cleavage sites is assessed inside cells, giving a direct suggestion of their potency in whole virus, and hence its replication.
Since NS3 -mediated protein cleavage is necessary for HCV replication, compounds discovered by such a screening method to be NS3 inhibitors are also useful as HCV replication inhibitors. Thus, this invention also provides a means of treating a mammal afflicted with a hepatitis C virus infection, said method comprising the steps of administering to the mammal a pharmaceutical composition comprising a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier and a therapeutically effective amount of a compound found, by the assay and screening means provided herein, to be NS3 activity inhibitors.
Administration is, for example, by various parenteral means. Pharmaceutical compositions suitable for parenteral administration include various aqueous media such as aqueous dextrose and saline solutions; glycol solutions are also useful carriers, and preferably contain a water soluble salt of the active ingredient, suitable stabilizing agents, and if necessary, buffer substances. Antioxidizing agents, such as sodium bisulfite, sodium sulfite, or ascorbic acid, either alone or in combination, are suitable stabilizing agents; also used are citric acid and its salts, and EDTA. In addition, parenteral solutions can contain preservatives such as benzalkonium
chloride, methyl- or propyl-paraben, and chlorobutanol .
Alternatively, compositions can be administered orally in solid dosage forms, such as capsules, tablets and powders; or in liquid forms such as elixirs, syrups, and/or suspensions . Gelatin capsules can be used to contain the active ingredient and a suitable carrier such as but not limited to lactose, starch, magnesium stearate, stearic acid, or cellulose derivatives. Similar diluents can be used to make compressed tablets. Both tablets and capsules can be manufactured as sustained release products to provide for continuous release of medication over a period of time. Compressed tablets can be sugar-coated or film-coated to mask any unpleasant taste, or used to protect the active ingredients from the atmosphere, or to allow selective disintegration of the tablet in the gastrointestinal tract.
"Therapeutically effective amounts" of a particular compound are any amounts of the compound effective to treat the infected mammal. Such amounts, typically from about 1 to 1000 mg per kg of the body weight of the mammal, are readily determined by ordinarily skilled artisans given the teachings of this invention, e.g., by dose-ranging trials.
This invention still further provides a method of expressing HCV nonstructural proteins in a cell-based expression system, said method comprising the step of first transfecting a mammalian cell with cDNA corresponding to the HCV nucleic acid sequences encoding the NS3 protease cleavage activity and an HCV NS3 protease substrate including an NS3 cleavage site, wherein the 5' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a methionine codon and the 3 ' end of said cDNA is operably linked to a termination codon. The cells incubated for a period of time effective for translation of the transfected cDNA,
and cell lysates are then collected - the presence of cleaved HCV NS3 protease substrate in the lysates demonstrates that NS3 protease had been expressed in the transfected.
The examples provided hereinbelow further describe the invention provided herein. However, those of ordinary skill in the art will readily understand that said examples are merely illustrative of the invention, as defined in the claims following immediately thereafter.
Examples Example 1
Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Inhibition of HCV N3-NS4B Polyprotein Region Processing
2xlOδ HepG2 or 293 cells were electroporated with 2»g of pCXN2/NS3-NS4B plasmid DNA, the electroporated cells were immediately diluted with cell culture medium such as Dulbecco-modified MEM (DMEM) supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum and penicillin-streptomycin mix (Gibco BRL) and plated into 6 well plates, which were incubated in a standard C02 incubator at 37 degrees Celsius for 20-24 hrs in the presence or absence of the compounds to be tested. Synthesis of the NS3 protease and its substrates begin within hours after DNA introduction into the cells; compounds were therefore added to the cell culture medium within few minutes after the transfection. Incubated cells were harvested by scraping, centrifugation and then aspiration of the cell culture media. The cells were lysed with commercially available lysis buffer (GIBCO BRL) . The protein in the cell lysates were separated by standard SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and transferred from gel onto nitrocellulose membranes, which were subsequently used for immunoblot analysis by methods described in Sambrook et al . (Molecular Cloning: A laboratory Manual, Second Edition, Cold Spring Harbor
Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY) and Ausubel et al . (Current Protocols in Molecular Biology, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.). HCV-infected human patient serum, containing antibodies against several HCV proteins including NS4B and NS5 proteins, was used as the source of primary antibody; HRP conjugated goat antihuman antibody was used as the secondary antibody for immunobloting.
Results, presented in Figure 1 herein, demonstrate the presence of NS4B protein in transfected, but not untransfected cells; NS4B protein is also produced in cells exposed to the non-NS3 specific inhibitors A and C, and its substantial absence in cells exposed to increasing concentrations of the NS3 -specific Inhibitor B and to increasing concentrations of Peflabloc®, a commercially available inhibitor of chymotrypsin-like serine protease enzymes .
Example 2 Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Assessing Activity of Mutant NS3 Protein on NS4B Processing
HepG2 cells were transfected with either pCXN2/NS3-4B or pCXN2/NS3m-4B DNA plasmid DNA (where "m" represents an active site, non-functional mutation of the NS3 protease) in the manner described in Example 1. Results (presented in Figure 2) demonstrate expression of NS4B in cells transfected with pCXN2/NS3-4B, but not in either untransfected cells or in cells transfected with pCXN2/NS3m-4B; thus demonstrating that the NS4B released in these cells is through the action of NS3 protease, and not due to the activity of a nonspecific host cellular protease.
Example 3 Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Protein Processing by NS3 Catalytic Domain
HepG2 cells were, according to the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove, co-transfected with a plasmid encoding the NS3 protease catalytic domain
("NS3*") and a plasmid encoding recombinant ("r") NS5A/5B DNA, incubated for twenty hours, lysed and analyzed by the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove. Results, presented in Figure 4, demonstrate processing of rNS5A/NS5B, and production therefrom of truncated NS5A, in transfected, but not in untransfected cells, as well as decreased processing at increasing inhibitor concentrations .
Example 4
Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Cleavage of Recombinant NS5A/5B by Wild-Type (Full-Length) NS3 Protein
HepG2 cells were co-transfected with a pCXN2/NS3 and pcDNA3/NS5A-5B plasmids incubated for twenty hours, lysed and analyzed by immunoblotting according to the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove. Results, presented in Figure 5, demonstrate production of NS5A protein
(truncated) with no NS3 protease inhibitor present, but not in untransfected cells, as well as decreasing production at increasing inhibitor concentrations.
Example 5
Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Cleavage of HCV Polyprotein by Wild-Type NS3 Protein
HepG2 cells were co-transfected with pCXN2/NS3-4B and pcDNA3/NS5A-5B, incubated for twenty hours incubated in the absence and presence of NS3-specific inhibitor, lysed and analyzed by immunoblotting according to the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove. Results, presented in Figure 6, demonstrate production of both NS4B and NS5A (truncated) proteins with no inhibitor present, but not in untransfected cells or at increasing inhibitor concentrations .
Example 6
Gel Electrophoresis Immunoblot Examining Tetracvcline- Induced Cleavage of HCV NS3/NS4B Polyprotein HepG2 cells were co-transfected with pTRE/NS3-4B and ptet/ON, incubated for twenty hours, in the absence ("-") and presence ("+") of doxycyclin (an activator of the gene expression in this plasmid system) , lysed and analyzed by immunoblotting according to the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove. Results, presented in Figure 7, demonstrate decreasing production of 4B protein at decreasing doxycyclin concentrations and the absence of production in the absence of doxycyclin. In the absence of Doxycyclin there is no expression of NS3-NS4B polyprotein, hence, there is no NS3 protease activity. These results clearly establish that the band on the immunoblots corresponding to NS4B is NS4B protein, and is produced as a result of NS3 protease activity, as it is only seen in the cells treated with Doxycyclin, but not in the untreated cells.
Example 7
Ecdysone®-Induced Expression of NS3-4B Polyprotein in HepG2 Cells HepG2 cells were co-transfected with pIND (Spl) /NS3-4B and pVGRXR plasmids, incubated for twenty hours, lysed and analyzed by immunoblotting according to the procedures described in Example 1 hereinabove. Results, presented in Figure 8, demonstrate decreasing production of NS4B protein in the presence of ecydsone (Ponasterone®, an activator of gene expression in this system) , and the substantial absence of production in its absence.