PRE-APPLIED THREADLOCKER/THREADSEALANT WITH IMPROVED SHELF-LIFE
FIELD OF THE INVENTION:
The present invention relates to an adhesive composition useful for threadlocking and
sealant applications. More particularly, the present invention is especially suitable for use as
a pre-applied, on-part-stable threadlocking composition for extremely catalytic metallic
substrates such as brass and copper, which are known to accelerate the cure speed of
anaerobic adhesive compositions.
BACKGROUND OF RELATED TECHNOLOGY:
Adhesive compositions useful as threadlockers, such as for nut and bolt assemblies
and the like, are well-known. Anaerobic adhesives have long been known to be especially
useful in preventing such threaded assemblies from loosening by filling up the interstitial
space between the mating threads of a nut and a bolt. These compositions have generally
been applied in liquid form at the time of mating of the parts.
Pre-applied threadlocking compositions are also well-known in the art. Such
compositions are designed to be applied to a threaded part, which can then be stored for later
use. Early preapplied threadlocking compositions consisted of a dry-to-the-touch film which
was skinned-over a flowable or gel-like unreacted monomer. Threading of mating parts
having the pre-applied composition therebetween ruptured the skin and subsequently cured
underlying reactive monomer. These compositions, however, were subject to premature
rupturing of the skin which housed the reactive monomer. Coated nuts and bolts and other
threaded assemblies are often stored in large bins, one on top of the other, and consequently
are subjected to the weight and sharp angles of adjacent parts, all of which can rupture the
skinned-over monomer, causing it to ooze. The result is a loss of usable threaded assemblies.
Dry-to-the-touch latex emulsions have been used to carry microencapsulated
monomers and/or initiators and catalysts. For example, U.S. Patent No. 4,417,028 describes
a co-reactive system including a polymerizable monomer, an initiator, a polymerization
accelerator and a binder. The initiator is described as a peroxide microencapsulated initiator.
This patent describes ethoxylated Bisphenol A dimethacrylate in amounts of about 35-40%
by weight. The composition is an aqueous dispersion of the polymerizable components and
the binder and initiator. The binder system is an anhydride copolymer. These compositions
are generally formulated for high strength applications, such as those requiring high break
and prevail torque.
Other threadlocking formulations which include reactive monomer compositions and
a polymerization initiator are described in U.S. Patent No. 5,397,812. This patent discloses a
threadlocker composition in which the reactive monomer, the initiator and activator are
encapsulated and dispersed in a binder. The binder comprises a photocurable resin
composition. The binder may also include a photoinitiator for curing via suitable radiation.
These compositions require hardening of the binder on a part using photoradiation, followed
by breaking of the microcapsules during threading of the parts. These compositions are also
designed for relatively high strength applications.
Some threadlocking compositions have focused on using photocurable (meth)acrylate
containing monomers to fix or partially cure the composition on the threaded part. The final
or secondary cure then follows once the part is mated with a complimentary threaded part.
For example, certain patents discuss pre-applied silicone threadlocking compositions,
whereby reactive silicone (meth)acrylate compounds are emulsified in aqueous medium and
applied to parts. U.S. Patent No. 5,635,546 describes a pre-applied silicone threadlocking
composition which includes a reactive silicone (meth)acrylate emulsified in aqueous medium
and a microencapsulated peroxy initiator. The dual curing silicone (meth)acrylate monomer
cures both anaerobically as well as through photoradiation. Amounts of curable monomers
disclosed as useful range from about 30-90% by weight (dry) of the composition.
Additionally, a nonsilicone (meth)acrylate monomer is also optionally combined with the
silicone (meth)acrylate composition. These resins are also designed to provide relatively high
strength break and prevail torques on threaded parts.
To date, threadlocking compositions have been designed for general use on metal
parts. It is known, however, that certain metals such as brass and copper are considered "hot"
due to their high catalytic affect on the curing of anaerobic monomers, while other metals
such as stainless, cadmium and zinc are considered "slow" or substantially non-accelerating
substrates. Known anaerobically curable liquid and preapplied threadlockers cure faster on
these "hot" metals then on such surfaces as stainless steel, cadmium or zinc. The on-part life
(shelf- life) of known anaerobic threadlocking and adhesive compositions are greatly
shortened due to the tendency of the "hot" brass or copper surface to catalyze prematurely the
reactive monomer. This results in a pre-applied threadlocking assembly which is instable and
commercially unacceptable. Such threadlocking compositions cannot be pre-applied to brass
or copper surfaces and commercially stored for any significant time period even at room
temperature without experiencing a certain amount of procure. This problem is worsened at
higher temperatures, such as those experienced in warehouse or manufacturing facilities.
Additionally, known preapplied anaerobic threadlocking and sealing compositions
have traditionally been designed to be used to impart relatively high break and prevail torques
once the mating threaded parts are assembled and cured. High break and prevail torques may
be useful in many applications where an assembly is not intended to be frequently
disassembled, but are problematic when low torque applications are required, for example,
when frequent disassembly is desired. For example, pneumatic assemblies on trucks and
automobiles require relatively frequent disassembly for maintenance or repairs. Such
applications require excellent sealing capability between the threaded fittings, but low
adhesive break and prevail torques.
One method of addressing this problem using known preapplied compositions is to
lower the amount of the preapplied composition present on the part. Such a method is
impracticle because it requires tailoring the amount of monomer covering the surface of a part
for each different application, thereby defeating the ability to standardize a composition for
industry-wide application.
Commercial anaerobic preapplied threadlocking compositions sold under the brand
name Loctite Dri-Loc-200 and Dri-Loc-205 are representative of conventional high strength
compositions and which exhibit on-part shelf-life in stability on "hot" substrates such as
brass, copper and the like. These compositions contain reactive monomers in the range of 35-
37%o weight and while widely used in the industry for many applications, are not desirable for
use on low strength, high sealing applications and particularly on applications where brass,
copper or other highly active metal catalytic surfaces are present.
The present invention seeks to overcome the disadvantages of the prior art
threadlocking compositions on highly catalytic surfaces such as brass and copper. The
present invention is designed to overcome the instability problems associated with the prior
art compositions and allows for a pre-applied threadlocking composition which exhibits
significantly greater on-part life then the aforementioned compositions. Moreover, the
compositions are designed to be low strength, high sealing compositions which can be used
as preapplied, dry-to-the touch threadlockers in applications requiring ease of disassembly of
parts.
Other objects and advantages of the invention will be more fully apparent from the
ensuing disclosure and appended claims.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION:
In one aspect, the present invention provides an anaerobically curable composition
useful as a preapplied threadlocker or sealant composition comprising an aqueous emulsion
or dispersion of: (a) at least one (meth)acrylic polymerizable monomer present in amounts of
about 4%o to about 15% by weight; (b) a water-soluble or dispersible binder, and (c) an
effective amount of a free, radical initiator isolated in said emulsion or dispersion from said
polymerizable monomer. Mono- and multi-functional (meth)acrylate monomers are useful.
Di(meth)acrylate monomers have been found to be particularly useful. Combinations of
monomers are contemplated so long as their combined weight product is in the
aforementioned range. It has been discovered that amounts of reactive (mefh)acrylate
monomers outside this range do not exhibit the stability on brass and copper surfaces.
The binder may be selected from a wide range of materials but is most desirably an
acrylic latex binder, but may be chosen from a wide variety of materials, its primary purpose
being to serve as a carrier matrix for applying and afixing the reactive monomer system to the
part. The free-radical initiator is most desirably a microencapsulated peroxy compound, but
may also be selected from a wide variety of free radical generators.
In another aspect, the present invention provides a brass or copper surfaced article,
coated with a film formed by evaporation of water from an adhesive composition, said
composition comprising an emulsion or dispersion in water of: (a) at least one polymerizable
(meth)acrylic monomer present in amounts of about 4 to about 15%o by weight; (b) a water-
soluble or dispersible binder; and (c) a microencapsulated free-radical initiator present in an
amount effective to initiate cure of said monomer.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS:
Figure 1 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at room
temperature on the commercially available threadlocker sold under the brand name Loctite
Dri-Loc 200. This figure graphically plots the averages of certain data compiled in Table II.
Figure 2 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at
accelerated aging temperature on the commercially available threadlocker sold under the
brand name Loctite Dri-Loc 200. This figure also graphically plots the averages of certain
data compiled in Table II.
Figure 3 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at room
temperature on the commercially available threadlocker sold under the brand name Loctite
Dri-Loc 205. This figure graphically plots the averages of certain data compiled in Table II.
Figure 4 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at
accelerated aging temperatures on the commercially available threadlocker sold under the
brand name Loctite Dri-Loc 205. The figure graphically plots the averages of certain data
compiled in Table II.
Figure 5 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at room
temperature on the inventive adhesive composition. This figure graphically plots the average
of certain data compiled in Table III.
Figure 6 is a graphic representation of the results of precure testing performed at
accelerated aging temperature on the inventive adhesive composition. This figure graphically
plots the averages of certain data compiled in Table III.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION:
The polymerizable monomers useful in the present invention include a wide variety of
poly- and mono- functional (meth)acrylate esters. One class of polymerizable monomers is
the poly- and mono- functional acrylate and (mefh)acrylate esters having the general structure
CH2=C(R)COOR, where R is H, CH3, C2H5 or Cl, and R1 is C,.g mono- or bicylcoalkyl, a 3 to
8-membered heterocyclic radial with a maximum of two oxygen atoms in the ring, H, alkyl,
hydroxyalkyl or aminoalkyl where the alkyl portion is C g straight or branched carbon atom
chain.
Among other desirable polymerizable monomers useful in the present invention
include those which fall within the structure:
where R2 may be selected from hydrogen, alkyl of 1 to about 4 carbon atoms,
hydroxyalkyl of 1 to about 4 carbon atoms or
O
II — H2C — O— C — C=CH2
I
R3
R3 may be selected from hydrogen, halogen, and alkyl of 1 to about 4 carbon atoms
and Cj.g mono- or bicycloalkyl, a 3 to 8 membered heterocyclic radical with a maximum of 2
oxygen atoms in the ring;
R4 may be selected from hydrogen, hydroxy and
m is an integer equal to at least 1, e.g., from 1 to about 8 or higher, for instance from 1
to about 4;
n is an integer equal to at least 1, e.g., 1 to about 20 or more; and
v is 0 or 1.
Other desirable acrylate ester monomers are those selected from the class of urethane
acrylates conforming to the general structure:
(CH2 = CR5.CO.O.R6.O.CO.NH-)2R7
wherein R5 is H, CH3, C2H5 or Cl; R6 is (i) a C,.8 hydroxyalkylene or aminoalkylene group, (ii)
a C,.6 alklamino-C,.8 alkylene, a hydroxyphenylene, aminophenylene, hydroxynaphthylene or
amino-naphthalene optionally substituted by a C,.3 alkyl, C,.3 alkylamino or di- .3
alkylamino group; and R7 is C2.20 alkylene, alkenylene or cycloalkylene, C6.40 arylene,
alkarylene, aralkarylene, alkyloxyalkylene or aryloxyarylene optionally substituted by 1-4
halogen atoms or by 1-3 amino or mono- or di- .j alkylamino or C1-3 alkoxy groups; or said
acrylates having the general formula;
(CH2 = CR5.CO.O.R6.O.CO.NH.R7.NH.CO.X-)nR8
wherein R5, R6, and R7 have the meanings given above; R8 is the non- functional residue of a
polyamine or a polhydric alcohol having at least n primary or secondary amino or hydroxy
groups respectively; X is O or NR9 where R9 is H or a C 7 alkyl group; and n is an integer
from 2 to 20.
Among the specific monofunctional polymerizable acrylate ester monomers
particularly desirable, and which correspond to certain of the structures above, are
hydroxypropyl methacrylate, 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate, methyl methacrylate,
tetrahydrofurfuryl methacrylate, cyclohexyl methacrylate, 2- aminopropyl methacrylate and
the corresponding acrylates.
Specific polyfunctional monomers which are desirable include polyethyleneglycol
dimethacrylate and dipropylene glycol dimethacrylate.
Other desirable polymerizable acrylate ester monomers useful in the instant invention
are selected from the class consisting of the acrylate, methacrylate and glycidyl methacrylate
esters of Bisphenol A. The most desired among all of the free-radical polymerizable
monomers mentioned is ethoxylated Bisphenol-A-dimethacrylate (EBIPMA).
Mixtures or copolymers of any of the above-mentioned free-radical polymerizable
monomers can be employed.
Polymerizable vinyl monomers may also be optionally incorporated and are
represented by the general structure:
R10-CH=CH-R10
where R10 is alkyl, aryl, alkaryl, aralkyl, alkoxy, alkylene, aryloxy, aryloxyalky, alkoxyaryl,
aralkylene, -OO=C-R', where R! is defined above, can also be effectively employed in the
instant composition.
Copolymers or mixtures of monomers disclosed herein with other compatible
monomers are also contemplated.
The basic purpose of the binder is to support the monomer and other ingredients,
allowing for easy deposition on a part. It is desirable that the binder not interfere with the
polymerization of the monomer. The binder should be at least partially soluble in water and
readily soluble.
Generally, the monomer, along with the accelerator of polymerization, is added to the
binder which is at least partially in aqueous solution. The monomer, together with the
accelerator are dispersed or suspended into small droplets in the binder.
The monomer droplet size must not be too small as to cause poor adhesion and
subsequent peeling, not too big as to be unable to wet the substrate surfaces. Generally, the
dispersed monomer droplets are in the size range of about 50 to about 500 microns and
desirably about 100 to about 200 microns.
Upon application of the adhesive composition to a part, the water in the composition
is allowed to evaporate either at room temperature or under heat supplied by any of the
conventional methods such as induction heat, convection heat, radiant heat, infra-red, or
microwave. The resultant preapplied coating or film is dry to the touch once the water has
been evaporated.
Initiators of free-radical polymerization useful in the instant composition include
peroxides, hydroperoxides, peresters, and peracids. Peroxides are desirable and benzoyl
peroxide is the more desirable. Such initiators are generally present in the adhesive
composition in the amounts of about 0.1 %> to about 10%> by weight of the monomer, and
desirably about 0.1% to about 2.0%> by weight. As previously mentioned, a two-part
adhesive composition is desirable, one part composing an encapsulated initiator which is
added to the dispersion prior to application of the adhesive composition to a part.
Commonly known accelerators of polymerization include amines and sulfimides.
Tertiary amines, such as N,N-dimethylparatoluidine, and sulfimides such as 3-oxo-2,3-
dihydrobenz-[d]isothiazole- 1,1 -dioxide, commonly known as saccharin, are particularly
useful. However, the most desired accelerators are organometallic compounds, desirably
organometallic polymers containing a metallocene moiety such as a ferrocene moiety.
Suitable metallocenes in related compositions are disclosed more fully in U.S. Pat. No.
3,855,040 which is incorporated by reference herein. These metallocene compounds, as well
as the accelerators mentioned above, are desirably added to the monomer in amounts of about
0.01%) to about 1.0% by weight of the composition prior to forming the dispersion. Other
metallo-containing materials which are non-polymeric have also been found to be effective at
these levels.
Inhibitors and chelators, well recognized in the art for imparting stability to
polymerizable compositions, are recommended. It is desirable that they be added to the
monomer prior to forming the dispersion or emulsion. Those inhibitors useful in the present
composition are usually selected from the group consisting of hydroquinones, benzoquinones,
naphthoquinones, phenanthraquinones, anthraquinones, and substituted compounds of any of
these. Among the chelators which may be optionally present in the adhesive composition are
the beta-diketones. ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and the sodium salt of EDTA.
Both the inhibitors and chelators may be effectively employed in levels of about 0.1 to about
1%) by weight of the monomer, without adversely affecting the speed of cure of the
polymerizable adhesive composition.
Thickeners, plasticizers, pigments, dyes, diluents, fillers, and other agents common to
the art can be employed in any reasonable manner to produce desired functional
characteristics, providing they do not significantly interfere with the monomer
polymerization. Inert fillers are present in relatively high amounts as compared to
conventional threadlocking systems. Most desired are fillers which add lubricity and sealing
characteristics to the compositions. Teflon (polytetrafluoroethylene) and polyethylene are
non- limiting examples.
The instant adhesive compositions exhibit a marked improvement over the prior art
with regard to on-part life on brass and copper surfaces.
Additionally, the preapplied adhesive compositions of the instant invention have an
on-part life which exhibits improved resistance to heat aging.
The invention will be more fully understood by the following examples, which are not
intended in any way to restrict the effective scope of the invention.
A desirable method of preparing the instant composition is to slowly mix the binder
into deionized water which has been heated to a temperature of about 90 °C. The binder is
mixed until most of it is dissolved and the batch is clear and free from lumps. The batch is
cooled to about 60 °C and the pH adjusted.
The polymeric ferrocene compound is added, followed by 15 minutes of mixing and
the same is done for the inorganic filler. Next the pigment is mixed in and finally the
polymerizable monomer is added and the batch mixed 25 °C until it is uniform and has the
desired dispersion particle size distribution.
EXAMPLES
A composition of the present invention may include the following components:
1) water in the amount of about 25-32%> and desirably in the amount of 28-38%>
2) a film forming binder or matrix material which is an aqueous medium and
forms an aqueous dispersion or emulsion with the reactive monomer and is
present in amount of about 30-40% and desirably in amount of 36-37%>;
3) optional, but desirable, inert fillers such as lubricating thickeners, pigments
and the like, present in amounts of about 16 to about 30%> and desirably in
amounts of 25.5 to about 26.5%;
4) (meth)acrylate monomer such as di (meth) acrylate monomer present in
amounts of about 4 to about 15% and desirably 6 to about 7%>;
5) an optional, but desirable, ferrocene cure accelerator present in amount of
about 0.0005%) and desirably in amounts of up to about 0.01%>;
6) an optional, but desirable, EDTA chelator present in amounts of about 0.2 to
about 1.0% and desirably in amounts of about 0.47 to about 0.57%>;
7) microencapsulated benzoyl peroxide present in amounts of about 3 to about
5%.
Compositions formulated in accordance with the above-described general formula and
more specifically in accordance with Table I below were applied to threaded nuts and bolt.
Due to the large degree of inert fillers and low quantity of reactive monomer, the
threadlocking strength of the resultant preapplied composition is designed to be relatively
low. However, it functions well as a sealant and low strength threadlocker in applications
which require repetitive disassembly. In particular, compositions falling within the general
ranges above, and the specific ranges of Table I were found to be extremely stable on brass
and copper containing surfaces.
Table I shows commercially available threadlocking compositions and the inventive
threadlocking composition. These compositions were tested for on-torque, breakaway and
prevailing torque values. The bolts used were 3/8 - 16 brass bolts and the mating nuts were
certified 3/8 - 16 phos-oil nuts. Testing was performed on a snap-on Torquemeter.
Test specimens were degreased in a naphtha hydrocarbon based cleaner and allowed
to dry. The bolts were then coated with the compositions in Table 1 in a conventional
manner and allowed to dry in an oven at 158 °F for 20 minutes.
The nuts and bolts were assembled at 24, 48, 72, 96,168, 336, 504, 1008 and 5040
hours after coating. Upon assembly, the on-torque was recorded. On-torque is the amount of
torque required to assemble the coated bolts to the nuts. This torque reading is indicative of
the stability of the preapplied composition on the substrate. A higher on-torque is indicative
of premature polymerization, i.e. precure, caused by the catalytic affect of the brass substrate,
which generally contains a high quantity of copper, with the reactive polymerizable monomer.
After curing 72 hours at room temperature, the breakaway and maximum prevailing
off-torque (within 360° of break) were recorded. The same tests were repeated subsequent to
storing the coated fasteners at 105°F as a test for accelerated aging and long term storage stability.
As will be noted from Tables II and III, as well as Figures 1-6, the present invention
exhibits increased on-part stability as evidenced by a relatively level on-torque value over
time as compared to the commercially available threadlocking compositions (which are
believed to be the closest prior art to the present invention). On-torque valves which do not
significantly increase with on-part time indicate that the composition is not prematurely
reacting.
While the invention has been described herein in reference to various illustrative
aspects and embodiments, it will be appreciated that the utility of the invention is not thus
limited, but rather is susceptible to numerous variations, modifications, and other
embodiments, and accordingly all such variations, modifications and other embodiments are
therefore contemplated within the spirit and scope of the invention as claimed.
TABLE I
COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE AND INVENTIVE THREADLOCKING/SEALANT COMPOSITIONS
Table II
Precure Testing on Dn-Loc 200 on 3/8-16 brass bolts with P/O nuts (values in Inch-Lbs)
Room Temperature 105 °F
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 24 hrs 0 15 5 5 25 10
2 24 hrs 0 25 15 5 15 5
3 24 hrs 0 35 15 5 20 5
4 2 hrs 0 33 15 5 25 5
5 24 hrs 0 10 5 5 10 10
Average 0 24 11 5 19 7
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 48 hrs 2 10 10 5 20 15
2 48 rs 2 20 20 10 60 30
3 48 hrs 2 30 15 5 25 15
4 48 hrs 2 27 25 6 19 15
5 48 hrs 2 47 15 5 10 10
Average 2 27 17 6 27 17
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 72 hrs 2 30 10 56 35 15
2 72 hrs 2 30 15 43 30 15
3 72 hrs 2 13 10 47 33 20
4 72 hrs 2 15 15 46 30 30
5 72 hrs 2 26 26 44 30 15
Average 2 23 15 47 32 19
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 96 hrs 5 30 30 13 17 10
2 96 hrs 4 30 15 14 25 10
3 96 hrs 2 15 10 51 50 30
4 96 hrs 3 20 10 35 25 10
5 96 hrs 3 10 5 32 20 10
Average 3 21 14 29 27 14
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 168 hrs 2 10 10 45 40 20
2 168 hrs 2 20 10 30 30 15
3 168 hrs 3 30 15 45 60 30
4 168 hrs 3 20 10 30 20 10
5 168 hrs 2 20 10 30 20 10
Average 2 20 11 35 34 17
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 336 hrs 5 40 20 100 125 75
2 336 hrs 5 50 25 150 175 100
3 336 hrs 5 30 15 125 195 100
4 336 hrs 5 35 20 180 210 100
5 336 hrs 5 25 15 150 160 75
Average 5 36 19 141 177 90
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 504 hrs 5 15 15 120 125 125
2 504 hrs 5 40 15 175 125 125
3 504 hrs 5 55 60 75 75 75
4 504 hrs 5 35 15 150 100 100
5 504 hrs 5 20 10 175 100 100
Average 5 33 23 139 105 105
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 1008 hrs 5 20 20
2 1008 hrs 5 20 20
3 1008 hrs 5 30 30
4 1008 hrs 5 30 30
5 1008 hrs 5 20 20
Average 5 24 24
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 5040 hrs 5 50 20
2 5040 hrs 5 40 20
3 5040 hrs 5 50 20
4 5040 hrs 5 30 10
5 5040 hrs 5 30 40
Average 5 40 22
Table II
Precure Testing on Dri-Loc 205 on 3/8-16 brass bolts with P/O nuts (values in Inch-Lbs)
Room Temperature 105 °F
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 24 hrs 0 13 5 61 60 60
2 24 hrs 0 150 25 41 49 40
3 24 hrs 0 26 5 46 55 55
4 24 hrs 0 70 30 52 55 55
5 24 hrs 0 120 40 46 40 40
Average 0 76 21 49 52 50
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 48 hrs 2 150 50 35 50 50
2 48 hrs 2 200 50 35 50 50
3 48 hrs 2 175 50 57 80 80
4 48 hrs 2 180 50 47 60 60
5 48 hrs 2 150 40 37 50 50
Average 2 171 48 42 58 58
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 72 hrs 2 100 50 6 75 75
2 72 hrs 2 225 150 9 50 50
3 72 hrs 2 110 50 9 65 65
4 72 hrs 2 210 150 9 50 50
5 72 hrs 2 100 25 11 40 40
Average 2 149 85 9 56 56
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 96 hrs 2 200 60 40 50 50
2 96 hrs 2 110 25 50 50 50
3 96 hrs 2 150 50 25 30 30
4 96 hrs 2 175 50 60 75 75
5 96 hrs 2 205 100 41 50 50
Average 2 168 57 43 51 51
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 168 hrs 2 100 25 37 50 50
2 168 hrs 2 140 25 42 50 50
3 168 hrs 2 130 30 27 25 25
4 168 hrs 2 160 50 27 25 25
5 168 hrs 2 150 40 60 75 75
Average 2 136 34 39 45 45
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 336 hrs 2 200 100 15 25 25
2 336 hrs 2 150 50 30 25 25
3 336 hrs 2 200 100 45 50 50
4 336 hrs 2 225 150 30 40 40
5 336 hrs 2 200 100 30 30 30
Average 2 195 100 30 34 34
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 504 hrs 5 100 25 25 15 15
2 504 hrs 5 175 100 30 30 30
3 504 hrs 5 200 175 70 50 50
4 504 hrs 5 150 75 35 25 25
5 504 hrs 5 100 75 25 15 15
Average 5 145 90 37 27 27
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 1008 hrs 5 500 200
2 1008 hrs 5 500 200
3 1008 hrs 5 500 100
4 1008 hrs 8 300 150
5 1008 hrs 5 300 150
Average 6 420 160
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 5040 hrs 10 120 30
2 5040 hrs 15 110 20
3 5040 hrs 30 120 20
4 5040 hrs 15 120 30
5 5040 hrs 20 110 20
Average 18 116 24
Table III
Precure Testing on Inventive Composition on 3/8-16 brass bolts with P/O nuts (values in Inch-Lbs)
Room Temperature 105 °F
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing
1 168 hrs 13 45 30 10 21 15
2 168 hrs 10 62 30 11 23 15
3 168 hrs 13 68 40 12 24 15
Average 12 58 33 11 23 15
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing 1 504 hrs 15 70 50 15 20 20
2 504 hrs 15 70 50 15 20 20
3 504 hrs 15 60 40 15 20 20
Average 15 67 47 15 20 20
Sample No Time to Assemble On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing On Torgue Breakaway Prevailing 1 1008 hrs 20 60 30 33 30 30
2 1008 hrs 15 60 30 45 41 30
3 1008 hrs 23 60 30 55 35 30
Average 19 60 30 44 35 30