CHIRAL SEPARATION MEDIA
This application is a continuation-iri-part
of application Serial No. 406,141 filed September 12, 1989.
This invention relates to a composition used
for separation of optical isomers or chiral compounds, as well as other isomeric and non-isomeric compounds, by means of gas chromatography and, more particularly, to the separation of enantiomers by capillary gas
chromatography. The composition used is a media
of an ether derivative of a cyclodextrin such as
a permethylated hydroxy or a dialkyl trifluoroacetyl ether of cyclodextrin.
The configuration of a chiral molecule is
generally what determines its biological and
pharmaceutical activity and effectiveness. One
of the enantiomers of the chiral molecule may be
active and the other may be inactive or even toxic.
It is therefore essential to be able to separate
the different enantiomers from each other to obtain
an isolated enantiomer in pure form. The isolated
enantiomers are used in the pharmaceutical, pesticide and/or herbicide industries, among others.
A conventional way to separate enantiomers is by gas chromatography using a chiral stationary phase. Chiral stationary phases can rapidly and reversibly form diastereomeric association complexes with chiral analytes. Successful chiral stationary phases for wall-coated capillary tubes should have some characteristic properties. They need to be highly viscous even at elevated temperatures and have the proper surface tension to wet the capillary wall completely. They should be able to form rapid and reversible diastereomeric associate complexes with the chiral analytes via various interactions such as hydrogen bonding, dispersion, dipole-dipole and steric interactions to give reasonable chiral selectivity. Other desirable properties include high temperature stability, no racemization at
elevated temperatures and low levels of bleeding.
Most of the early work on chiral stationary phases for gas chromatography used amino acids, peptides, and various derivatives thereof. Some efforts have been made to use other naturally occurring chiral molecules as chiral stationary phases such as tartaric acid, malic acid, mandelic acid and
chrysanthemic acid. Despite a large amount of
work in this area, the only resulting widely available
and commercially viable chiral stationary phase
for gas chromatography has been Chirasil-Val from
Macherey-Nagel of the Federal Republic of Germany
which consists of a siloxane copolymer to which
L-valine-tert-butylamide was coupled.
There are a number of limitations to these
early amino acid based gas chromatography chiral
stationary phases. First, they do not seem to
be widely applicable. Most of the reported separations were of racemic amino acid derivatives. Just as
significant was the fact that, using these early
chiral separation phases, the high column temperature needed for gas chromatography often results in
racemization, decomposition and bleeding of the
chiral stationary phase. Even the moderately successful
Chirasil-Val is not recommended to be used at temperatures much above 200°C. Also, the enantioselectivity
of the chiral stationary phase decreases significantly at the higher temperatures needed for gas chromatography.
Previously there have been a number of efforts
to use alpha- and beta-cyclodextrin as gas chromatography stationary phases. It was apparent from the early
gas chromatography and more recent liquid chromatography work that cyclodextrins had potential as gas chromatographic stationary phases. Unfortunately, the cyclodextrin
gas chromatography stationary phases were not as successful as the liquid chromatography bonded
stationary phases. Although interesting selectivities, mainly for achiral solutes, were obtained, the
efficiency and reproducibility were less than desirable. Cyclodextrins are crystalline solids and had to
be dissolved or suspended in another solvent prior to coating the separation column. The fact that
native cyclodextrins and their simple derivatives
(dimethyl, acetyl, etc.) are crystalline solids
with high melting or decomposition points, makes
them difficult to use directly as gas chromatography stationary phase coatings. Recently, there have
been reports on derivatized cyclodextrins that
are liquids or lower melting point amorphous solids and therefore can be used directly as stationary
phase coatings. All of these previous compounds
are lipophilic derivatives of cyclodextrin (such
as perpentyl-beta-cyclodextrin).
Cyclodextrins (also called "Schardinger dextrins") are known to be cyclic oligosaccharides composed
of glucose residues bonded together by alpha 1,4
bonds. The six, seven and eight membered rings
are called alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrin, respectively. The cyclodextrins have different
chemical and physical properties from the linear
oligosaccharides derived from starch in that they
are non-reducing dextrins and the ring structure
is widely used as a host for the inclusion of various compounds, usually organic compounds for the food, pharmaceutical, and chemical fields.
As is also well-known, cyclodextrins are produced from starch of any selected plant variety such
as corn, potato, waxy maize and the like which
may be modified, or unmodified starch derived from cereal or tuber origin and the amylose or amylopectin fractions thereof. The selected starch in aqueous slurry at selected concentrations up to about 35%
by weight solids is usually liquefied as by gelatinization or treatment with a liquefying enzyme such as bacterial alpha-amylase enzyme and then subjected to treatment with a transglycosylase (CGT) enzyme to form the
cyclodextrins.
The amount of the individual alpha-, betaand gamma-cyclodextrins produced by treating the
starch with the CGT enzyme will vary depending
on the selected starch, selected CGT enzyme and
processing conditions. The parameters to select
for the CGT enzyme conversion for the desired result in the amount of each individual cyclodextrin to
be produced is conventional and well-described
in the literature.
Conventionally, the DE of the liquefied starch is maintained below about 20 DE, the starch solids concentration is below about 35% by weight, the
pH for conversion may be about 4.5 to 8.5 at a
selected temperature from ambient up to about 75°C for a selected period of time, typically from about
10 hours up to seven days and more. The amount
of CGT enzyme used for conversion is conventional
and well-known in the art.
It has now been discovered that ether derivatives of cyclodextrin such as permethylated hydroxy ethers of cyclodextrin and dialkyl trifluoroacetyl ethers
of cyclodextrin can be used to separate a wide
variety of optical isomers. The optical isomers
resolved include chiral alcohols, diols, polyols,
amines, amino alcohols, halohydrocarbons, ketones,
lactones, alpha-halocarboxylic acid esters, carbohydrates, epoxides, glycidyl analogues, haloephihydrins,
nicotine compounds, pyrans, furans, bicyclic and
heterocyclic compounds and other miscellaneous
compounds.
The permethylated hydroxy ether of cyclodextrin is hydrophilic and relatively polar compared to
previous cyclodextrin derivatives used as chiral
stationary phases. The dialkyl trifluoroacetyl
derivative is of intermediate polarity. Both of
these ether derivatives of cyclodextrin have better coating properties on fused silica capillaries
than the hydrophobic cyclodextrin derivatives.
The more hydrophilic permethylated hydroxy ether
of cyclodextrin and the dialkyl trifluoroacetyl
derivatives have different selectivities for the
enantiomers as compared to the hydrophobic cyclodextrin derivatives. Also, they can be used at higher
temperatures than Chirasil-Val without racemization.
With respect to the ether derivative of cyclodextrin which is a permethylated hydroxy cyclodextrin,
the degree of substitution (DS) of the hydroxy
ether groups for the hydroxyl groups on the underivatized cyclodextrin molecule is from about 10% to about
75% of the available hydroxyl groups on the cyclodextrin. For example, for alpha-cyclodextrin the DS for
the hydroxy ether groups is about 2 to about 12;
for beta-cyclodextrin, about 2 to about 14; and
for gamma-cyclodextrin, about 2 to about 16. More preferably, the DS is about 25% to about 60% of
the available sites and more preferred is about
40%. It is important that the degree of substitution of the cyclodextrin hydroxy groups by the ether
side chains be random and non-uniform.
The DS of the methyl groups for the remaining hydroxyl groups on the cyclodextrin and the hydroxyl groups on the ether side chains of the cyclodextrin is greater than about 90% and more preferably above about 95%. Ideally, all of the available hydroxyl sites on the hydroxy ether of cyclodextrin are
methylated; although this is sometimes difficult
to achieve.
The permethylated hydroxy ether of cyclodextrin is made in a conventional manner starting from
either individual cyclodextrin or mixtures of the
alpha-, beta- and/or gamma-cyclodextrins. However, it is preferred to use only a single cyclodextrin, i.e. either alpha-, beta-, or gamma-cyclodextrin.
The separation and/or purification of the alpha-,
beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrin may be done before,
after, or at any stage of the derivatization process.
The procedure for making the hydroxy ether of cyclodextrin and the subsequent step of methylating are accomplished in a conventional manner. The order of reaction
for forming the permethylated hydroxy ether cyclodextrin derivative is first to make the hydroxy ether and
then to methylate it.
In order to etherify the underivatized cyclodextrin, the cyclodextrin is suitably reacted with an epoxide.
Suitable epoxides include ethylene oxide, propylene oxide, butylene oxide, amylene oxide, glycidol
(hydroxypropylene oxide), butadiene oxide, glycidyl methyl ether, glycidyl isopropyl ether, alkyl glycidyl ether, styrene oxide, and t-butyl glycidyl ether.
Preferably, the epoxide is selected from the group consisting of propylene oxide, glycidyl methyl
ether, glycidyl isopropyl ether, alkyl glycidyl
ether, t-butyl glycidyl ether and styrene oxide.
Good results have been obtained with an epoxide
selected from the group consisting of propylene
oxide, glycidyl methyl ether and glycidyl isopropyl ether.
As is known, the reaction of cyclodextrin
with the above noted epoxides produces an ether
of cyclodextrin with two hydroxy groups on adjacent carbon atoms on the side chains. Such hydroxy
ethers of cyclodextrin are sometimes referred to as dihyύroxyalkyl ethers of cyclodextrin.
The preferred permethylated ether derivatives of cyclodextrin for use in the present invention
include hydroxy propylated cyclodextrin, hydroxy propylated methyl ether cyclodextrin, hydroxy propylated isopropyl ether cyclodextrin, hydroxy propylated
vinyl ether cyclodextrin, hydroxy propylated t-butyl
ether cyclodextrin, and hydroxy ethylated phenyl
cyclodextrin. Good results have been obtained
with hydroxy propylated cyclodextrin, hydroxy propylated methyl ether cyclodextrin and hydroxy propylated
isopropyl ether cyclodextrin.
With respect to the ether derivative of cyclodextrin which is a dialkyl trifluoroacetyl cyclodextrin,
the degree of substitution (DS) of the alkyl groups
for the hydrogens of the hydroxyl groups on the
underivatized cyclodextrin molecule to form the
etherified derivative is from about 20% to about
80% of the available hydrogens on the cyclodextrin.
For example, for alpha-cyclodextrin the DS for
the alkyl groups is about 1 to about 15; for beta-cyclodextrin, about 1 to about 16; and for gamma-cyclodextrin,
about 1 to about 18. More preferably, the DS is
about 40% to about 70% of the available sites and
more preferred is about 65%. Generally, the alkyl
groups will substitute for the hydrogens on the
2 and 6 carbons. It is important that the degree
of substitution of the cyclodextrin hydroxy groups
by the ether side chains be random and non-uniform.
The DS of the trifluoroacetyl group for the
hydrogen of the remaining available hydroxyl group
on the cyclodextrin is greater than about 90% and
more preferably above about 95%.
The dialkyl trifluoroacetyl ether of cyclodextrin is made in a conventional manner starting from
either individual cyclodextrin or mixtures of the alpha-, beta- and/or gamma-cyclodextrins. However, it is preferred to use only a single cyclodextrin, i.e. either alpha-, beta-, or gamma-cyclodextrin.
The separation and/or purification of the alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrin may be done before, after, or at any stage of the derivatization process. The procedure for making the ether of cyclodextrin and the subsequent step of esterifying are accomplished in a conventional manner. The order of reaction
for forming the cyclodextrin derivative is first
to make the ether derivative and then to esterify
it.
In order to form the dialkylated ether derivative of cyclodextrin, the cyclodextrin is first suitably reacted with an alkyl halide to form an ether derivative. Suitable alkyl halides include chlorinated, brominated, iodiated or fluorinated alkanes such as methane,
ethane, propane, butane, pentane or hexane. The
alkanes may be straight-chained or branched. Preferably, the alkyl halide is selected from the group consisting of n-propyl bromide, n-propyl chloride, n-butyl
chloride, n-butyl bromide, n-pentyl bromide and
n-pentyl chloride. Best results have been obtained with n-pentyl bromide.
Suitably, in order to esterify the ether derivative of cyclodextrin, fluorinated anhydrides are used. It is more preferred to use fluorinated anhydrides such as trifluoroacetic anhydride, trifluorobutanoic anhydride, or trifluoropropanoic anhydride. It is most preferred to use
trifluoroacetic anhydride.
The preferred dialkyl trifluoroacetic ether derivatives of cyclodextrin for use in the present invention include dipentyl trifluoroacetic ether cyclodextrin, dipentyl trifluoroacetic ether cyclodextrin, dipentyl trifluorobutanoic ether cyclodextrin and dipentyl trifluoropropanoic ether cyclodextrin.
The gas chromatography is performed in a conventional manner.
It is preferred to use fused silica capillaries when performing the gas chromatography operation. Fused silica capillaries are much more flexible, practical and easier to handle than conventional glass capillaries.
The ether derivatives of cyclodextrin of the present invention are liquids at room temperature and can be used to coat undeactivated fused silica
capillaries. They are nonvolatile and are thermally stable at temperatures up to about 300°C in the absence of oxygen.
The gas chromatography can also be performed by administering the ether derivative of cyclodextrin of the present invention to a packed column by
means of a carrier such as polysiloxane or polyethylene glycol. The admixture of the ether derivative
of cyclodextrin of the present invention with the carrier and the administration of this admixture to the column is performed in a conventional manner.
The solid support in the packed column may
be any suitable support such as diatomaceous earth. Teflon powder, or fine glass beads. The selection of the type, size and shape of the solid support depends on the molecules being isolated and the
flow rate desired. The determination of which
solid support to use is conventional and well-known to those of skill in the art.
Although it is less common, enantioselective reversals also can occur among like-derivatized
alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrins. Reversals in elution order have been observed between alphaand beta-cyclodextrin and between beta- and gammacyclodextrin.
Further details and advantages of the present invention may be more fully understood by reference to the following examples.
EXAMPLE 1
This example illustrates making a permethylated hydroxypropylated ether derivative of cyclodextrin of the present invention.
The permethyl hydroxypropyl ether derivative of cyclodextrin were made in two steps. First, propylene oxide, sodium hydride and the desired cyclodextrin (either alpha-, beta-, or gamma-) were dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) at
60°C and allowed to react for one hour with stirring. After cooling to room temperature for 15 hours, the mixture was further cooled in an ice bath.
Excess methyl iodide was added dropwise. After
24 hours the reaction was complete.
EXAMPLE 2
This example illustrates the making of the dialkyl trifluoroacetyl ether derivative of
cyclodextrin of the present invention. The alkane used herein is pentane.
3.0 g of dried cyclodextrin and excess 1-bromopentane were added to 30 ml dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO).
The reaction was carried out at 60°C for 6 hours. Water was then added to the reaction mixture and a waxy precipitate was obtained. The raw product was dissolved in chloroform (CHCl3) and the solution was washed with water. CHCl3 was removed under vacuum and the product was used for the next reaction without further purification.
The above material and an excess of
trifluoroacetic anhydride were added to 30 ml
tetrahydrofuran (THF). The mixture was boiled for 2 hours, then poured over ice to precipitate the product. The precipitate was washed with cold water and dissolved in CHCl3. The CHCl3 solution was extracted three times with 5% aqueous sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) and three times with water.
The CHCl3 layer was collected and dried with
anhydrous sodium sulfate (Na2SO4). CHCl3 was
allowed to evaporate in a vacuum desiccator and the final viscous liquid was dried in a vacuum overnight to form the final product of dipentyl trifluoroacetyl ether cyclodextrin derivative.
EXAMPLE 3
This example illustrates separating optical isomers using the media made in Example 1 above.
The optical isomers were derivatized in order to decrease their volatility for better resolution in the gas chromatograph process.
Fused silica capillary tubes (0.25 mm ID)
were obtained from Alltech or Supelco. The capillaries were coated with the cyclodextrin derivatives of the present invention via the static method.
Untreated 10 m capillary columns were placed in a water bath at 36°C. A 0.2% w/v ether solution of the cyclodextrin derivative of the present invention filled the capillary. One end of the capillary
was sealed and the other connected to a vacuum
line. It took about 4 hours to coat a 10 m column.
The column efficiency was tested at 100°C by using n-hydrocarbons (C11 and C12) as test solutes.
Only columns that produced ≥ 3600 plates per column meter were used.
Racemic mixtures of amines and alcohols to
be resolved were derivatized with trifluoroacetic anhydride, acetic anhydride or chloroacetic anhydride. Other compounds containing hydroxyl and/or amine functionalities were also derivitized. All chemicals were obtained from Aldrich Chemical Co., Sigma
Chemical Co., or Fluka Chemical Co. In each case, approximately 1.0 mg of the racemic analyte was
dissolved in 0.5 ml of methylene chloride and 200 μl of the desired anhydride added. After reacting for about 5-30 minutes, dry nitrogen was bubbled through the solution to remove excess reagent,
The solution residue was dissolved in 0.5 ml of
ether or methanol for chromatographic analysis.
Racemic mixtures of sugars to be resolved were trifluoroacetylated by the above procedure except that tetrahydrofuran was used as the solvent.
Also, because this reaction was somewhat slower and the trifluoroacetic anhydride was volatile, three additional aliquots of trifluoroacetic anhydride were added at seven minute intervals.
Both Hewlett Packard (5710A) and Varian (3700) gas chromatographs were used for all separations.
Split injection and flame ionization detection
were utilized. The injection and detector port temperatures were 200°C and nitrogen was used as the carrier gas. Gas velocity was about 10-15
cm/sec. A split ratio of 100/1 was used for all the columns and at all of the column temperatures.
The injection volume was 0.5 μl.
Referring to the following tables, the separation factor, α, is a measure of the separation between the eluted peaks. The greater the separation between the peaks, the greater is α. Mathematically, α is defined as the ratio of the corrected retention times of the two peaks being compared (i.e.,
where t' = corrected retention time, t = uncorrected time and t
0 = retention time of an unretained compound. Traditionally, the longest retained peak time,
t2, is put in the numerator so that ot will be greater than 1. An α-value of 1 means that there is no separation (the peaks co-elute).
Tables IA, IB and IC illustrate the separation results using permethylated hydroxypropyl ether
cyclodextrin (PHCD) as the ether derivative of
cyclodextrin. Tables IA, IB and IC show the results using alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrin,
respectively. The permethylated hydroxypropyl
ether cyclodextrin was made in accordance with
Example 1 above.
This example illustrates separating nonderivatized optical isomers using the media of permethylated hydroxypropyl ether derivative of cyclodextrin as made in Example 1 above.
The capillary tubes, the gas chromatographs and the determination of α were as set forth in Example 3 above.
Tables IIa, IIb and IIc illustrate the results using alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrin, respectively.
EXAMPLE 5
This Example illustrates separating enantiomers using the media of dipentyl trifluoroacetyl ether
derivative of cyclodextrin as made in Example 2
above .
Table III illustrates the separation results
using the dipentyl trifluoroacetyl ether cyclodextrin
(DP-TFA-CD) as the ether derivative of cyclodextrin.
The capacity factor of the first eluted enantiomer, k, is determined as follows:
where k' = retention time of the eluted solute; and
k" = retention time of an unretained compound.
The column in the Table for "Stationary Phase" indicates which cyclodextrin was used for the ether
derivative. "A" indicates that the ether derivative was dipentyl trifluoroacetyl alpha cyclodextrin;
"B" that it was dipentyl trifluoroacetyl beta cyclodextrin; and "G" that it was dipentyl trifluoroacetyl ether
gamma cyclodextrin.
The capillary tubes, the gas chromatographs
and the determination of α were as set forth in
EXAMPLE 6
This Example illustrates retention and selectivity results of homologous racemic amines, diols, and α-halocarboxylic acid esters using the media of dipentyl trifluoroacetyl ether cyclodextrin as
made in Example 2 above. These results are set
forth in the following Table IV.
The capillary tubes, the gas chromatographs and the determination of α were as set forth in
Example 3 above.
The capacity factor and the indication of
the base cyclodextrin used were as set forth in
Example 4 above.
EXAMPLE 7
A test was made to determine if the stereochemistry of the ether side chain has any effect on separation.
Three different media were prepared,
permethyl-(S)-hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin;
permethyl-(R)-hydroxypropyl-beta cyclodextrin; and permethyl-(racemic)-hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin.
Three identical columns were coated with these materials and a series of tests were run. Each
of the three columns produced essentially identical separations.
It will be understood that it is intended
to cover all changes and modifications of the preferred embodiments herein chosen for the purpose of illustration which do not constitute a departure from the spirit and scope of the invention.