US3901522A

US3901522A - Vibration damped ski

Info

Publication number: US3901522A
Application number: US499726A
Authority: US
Inventors: Herbert C Boehm
Original assignee: Olin Corp
Current assignee: SITCA ACQUISITIONS Inc (SITCA) A CORP OF WA; SITCA ACQUISITIONS Inc A Corp OF; Olin Corp
Priority date: 1973-07-18
Filing date: 1974-08-22
Publication date: 1975-08-26
Anticipated expiration: 1992-08-26

Abstract

A ski structure of the multi-layer type having a core and one or more intermediate load-bearing layers between top and bottom surfaces of the ski, wherein at least one of the intermediate layers is a laminate comprising a layer of material having a relatively high modulus of elasticity with elastomeric material bonded to opposite faces of the high modulus of elasticity material, with at least a portion of the elastomeric material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties and the remainder of the elastomeric material being rubber.

Description

United States Patent Boehm Aug. 26, 1975 [S4] VIBRATION DAMPED SK] 466380 2/1969 Switzerland .1 280/1 1.13 L 1,961.48! 7 i970 G 28011.13 L U5] Inventor: Boehm, Hamdsm Conn- 1 304 830 811962 280 1.13 F 73 Assignefiz Olin Corporation New Haven 459,026 8/1968 Switzerland 280/11.13 F

Conn.

Primary ExaminerRobert B. Reeves [22] Flled 1974 Assistant Examiner-Charles A. Marmor [21] App]. No.: 499,726 Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Donald R. Motsko; William Related us. Application Data Jones [63] Continuation of Scr. No. 380,308, July 18, 1973,

abandoned [5 7] ABSTRACT A ski structure of the rnulti-layer type having a core [52) 280/1143 and one or more intermediate 1oad-bearing layers be- [51] Int. Cl. t. A63C 5/12 58 M is h 280 l I 3 F l I 3 L tween top and bottom surfaces of the ski, wherein at l l o earc least one of the intermediate layers is a laminate comprising a layer of material having a relatively high [56] References Cited modulus of elasticity with elastomeric material bonded UNITED STATES PATENTS to opposite faces of the high modulus of elasticity ma- 3.537,7l /l 0 Caldw ll 1. ZED/11.13 F terial, with at least a portion of the elastomeric mate- 3,6l2,556 l0/l 7l S a ll 80/ L rial possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties and 16351482 1/1972 Holman 280/1 L the remainder of the elastomeric material being rub- 3 635 483 1/1972 Barriball et a1 ZED/11.13 L bet FOREIGN PATENTS OR APPLICATIONS 6 Clauns, 4 Drawing Figures 680,647 2/1964 Canada ZED/11.13 L

PATENTEU AUGZBIQYS 9 U1 .5? 2

sum 1 05 3 FIG -1 22 .FIG-4 VIBRATION DAMPED SKI This is a continuation of application Ser. No. 380,308 filed July 18, 1973, now abandoned.

This invention relates to a ski structure which is highly damped against vibration, and more particularly, to a ski structure utilizing viscoelastic material as the vibration damping agent, the viscoelastic material being disposed internally of the ski body.

The skier who favors a fast style and the racer who must control his skis at high speeds demand a ski that remains in steady contact with the slope even at high speeds and a ski that absorbs vibrations caused by uneven places in the terrain. A highly vibratory ski is not responsive for precise turns on icy slopes, this fact having been verified by many years of testing. To execute a proper carving or sliding turn, the steel edge of the ski must be in precise contact with the slope surface in such a way that the skier can balance his moment forces against the resistance forces of the slope. Not every ski meets these requirements. The metal skis use under these conditions is precluded by its tendency to vibrate at high speeds. After an intensive investigation into the factors which influence the steadiness and vibration characteristics of the ski, it was recognized that there are two physical parameters that deserve attention: the vibrational frequency and the vibrational damping of the ski. Where vibration is not desired, a design with high shock absorbtion capabilities or vibration damping is necessary.

Having recognized the fact that a highly vibration damped ski has desirable characteristics, the prior art has made several attempts to provide this vibration damping feature to a ski. Most modern high performance skis are made up ofa plurality of layers of various materials such as fiberglass, metal, wood, synthetic resins, and rubber which are bonded together to form the ski, the various materials being carefully selected for certain desirable characteristics which they contrib ute to the ski. Thus the search for a means to damp vibration of the ski has been concentrated or focussed upon the multilayer type of skiv U.S. Pat. No. 2,995,379 issued Aug. 8, 1961 to H. Head and U.S. Pat. No. 3,194,572 issued July 13, 1965 to J. Fischer disclose the use of an internal layer of rubber which is utilized to damp vibtation of the ski imparted thereto during use. While rubber does contribute a vibration damping function to a multilayer ski, the amount or degree of vibration damping imparted to the ski by rubber is minimal, and for example, it is not enough to damp a metal ski sufficiently so that it may be used at high speeds on hard, icy slopes.

Other efforts have been made to modify multi-layer ski construction to improve vibration damping and have provided adequate damping, but have included other drawbacks not related to vibration damping. For example, hardwood cores have been used to improve vibration damping of a ski, but hardwood cores are heavy and expensive, thus adding to the cost of the ski and undesirably increasing the weight of the ski. Glass reinforced polyester resins have been used in place of epoxy resin, to increase internal friction, but polyester resin is not durable enough thus resulting in a low fatigue life for the ski. Plastic top edges rather than metal top edges have been used, but plastic top edges are softer than metal top edges thus giving inferior edge protection. Cracked steel running edges rather than continuous steel running edges have been used, however, cracked steel running edges are extremely expensive, thus undesirably adding to the cost of the ski.

Still another means for damping the vibration of a ski is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,537,717 issued Nov. 3, 1970 to D. B. Caldwell. A conventional ski is damped according to the Caldwell patent by applying to the top surface of the ski a laminate of a layer of viscoelastic material and a stretch resistant constraining layer, such as metal, with the viscoelastic layer being sandwiched between the top surface of the ski and the constraining layer and serving to bond the constraining layer to the top surface of the ski. This method of damping the ski displayed superior results, however, it also featured some pronounced disadvantages. Specifically, the disadvantages to this method are: that the viscoelastic material and constraining layer are exposed to mechanical forces such as shocks or impact by the other ski, and weathering; the constraining layer is attached to the ski only by the viscoelastic material, thus resulting in poor durability; when applied to the top surface of an already engineered ski, the constraining layer influences other characteristics of the ski, such as overall stiffness, stiffness balance, frequency of the ski, and temperature balance; and the constraining layer must be relatively short when compared to the full length of the skis since the constraining layer, when placed on the top surface of the ski, must terminate at the binding area. Thus the damping system disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,537,717 does improve the vibration damping characteristics of a ski, but has sufficient disadvantages to render it of little practical value for use on commercially produced skis.

It will be noted that the disadvantages of the structure shown in prior art viscoelastic vibration damping system arise chiefly from the fact that the vibration damping laminate is secured to the top surface of the ski. It will be readily apparent that these disadvantages could be eliminated by disposing the vibration damping laminate inside of the ski rather than on its top surface, however, it has been demonstrated that a simple transfer of the vibration damping laminate shown in U.S. Pat. No. 3,537,717 from a location on the top surface of the ski to a location internally of the ski in fact may produce a ski whose vibration damping characteristics are actually worsened. Test results demonstrating this worsening of vibration damping characteristics are presented hereinafter in Table l.

The vibration damping characteristics of a ski can be greatly improved by incorporating a constrained viscoelastic damping laminate into the interior of a multilayer ski as a part of the overall ski structure without encountering the problems attendant with the prior art viscoelastic vibration damping system. The internally incorporated constrained viscoelastic laminate includes a constraining member of a material of relatively high modulus of elasticity, such as aluminum, steel, fiberglass, or the like, wherein the constraining member is substantially completely surrounded by viscoelastic material. This latter-most discovery is disclosed in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 380,309, filed July 18, 1973 now U.S. Pat. No. 3,844,576 to Hermann Schultes.

l have discovered that similar improved vibration damping can be achieved by an internal vibration damping laminate comprising a constraining member of a high modulus of elasticity material, such as aluminum, steel, fiberglass, or the like, which constraining member is isolated over its major portion from the remaining components of the ski by a layer of viscoelastic material on one side of the constraining member, and a layer of rubber on the other side of the constraining member. By utilizing both viscoelastic material and rubber to isolate the constraining member from the rest of the ski, a cost savings and a toughening of the vibration damping laminate are accomplished as compared to encasing the constraining member in viscoelastic material. In order to operate properly, the viscoelastic material must be interposed between the constraining member and a vertically adjacent load-bearing component of the ski. The constraining member can, if desired, be secured directly to the remainder of the ski at one point, preferably spaced as far as possible away from the shovel area of the ski, with the securement being in the form of an adhesive, screws, or the like, however, the remaining surfaces of the constraining member must be isolated from the remainder of the ski structure by the viscoelastic material or the rubber. In order to maximize the vibration damping performance of the internal constrained viscoelastic and rubber laminate, it should be positioned as far as possible away from the neutral axis of the ski, preferably below the neutral axis of the ski so as to be free from contact with binding screws conventionally embedded in the ski at the binding area.

By utilizing a constrained viscoelastic and rubber laminate as an internal component of a multi-layer ski, the vibration damping laminate can be properly designed in conjunction with the remaining ski components to accurately control proper ski flexibility, frequency, and the like. The vibration damping laminate is protected against delamination, impact, weathering and other adverse influences. The viscoelastic material is protected and reinforced by other stronger compo nents of the ski. Internally positioning the vibration damping laminate permits the designer to use a constrained laminate substantially equal in length to the length of the ski which doubles the maximum shear strain in the laminate as compared to the system disclosed in US. Pat. No. 3,537,717. When the constraining member is attached directly to the tail end of the ski, it can be shown that the maximum shear strain is about 4 times that of the system disclosed in US. Pat. No. 3,537,717.

It is, therefore, an object of this invention to provide a damped ski having a constrained viscoelastic and rubber vibration damping laminate incorporated into the interior portion of the ski.

It is yet another object of this invention to provide a ski of the character described wherein the constraining member of the vibration damping laminate is substan tially completely isolated from the remaining compo nents of the ski by an elastomeric material, at least a portion of which possesses pronounced viscoelastic properties and the remainder of which is rubber.

It is a further object of this invention to provide a ski of the character described wherein the constrained viscoelastic and rubber laminate is protected from adverse effects by the remaining components of the ski.

These and other objects and advantages of the ski of this invention will become more readily apparent from the following detailed description of an embodiment of a ski formed in accordance with the invention taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:

FIG, 1 is a sectional view of a preferred embodiment of a ski made in accordance with the invention;

FIG. 2 is a sectional view of a prior art ski;

FIG. 3 is a sectional view of a modified prior art ski; and

FIG. 4 is a vertical sectional view of the tail end of a modified embodiment of a ski formed in accordance with this invention.

Referring to the drawings, a multi-layer laminated fiberglass ski 2 is shown in FIG. 1. The top layer 4 is an ABS decorative layer. Beneath the top layer 4 are disposed top protective edges 6 of metal such as aluminum or steel. A load-bearing layer of fiberglass 8 is positioned below the top layer 4 and between the top edges 6 respectively and above a wood core 12. A binding plate 14 may be embedded in the wood core 12 for strengthening the binding area of the ski. Sidewall layers 16 of phenolic resin extend from the top edges 6 to a further load bearing fiberglass layer 18 beneath the core 12. Steel running edges 20 are bonded to the fiberglass layer 18 by means of an intermediate rubber layer 22. The bottom running surface of the ski is a polyeth ylene layer 24 sold under the trademark P-Tex. Sandwiched between the running surface layer 24 and the lower fiberglass layer 18 is the vibration damping laminate which comprises a layer 26 of highly viscoelastic material preferably juxtaposed to the top and side surfaces of a constraining member 28 of a material having a high modulus of elasticity, such as aluminum, steel, fiberglass, or the like. The viscoelastic material layer 26 is elastomeric and inherently adhesive so as to bond itself to the constraining member 28 and the fiberglass layer 18 and the rubber layer 22, however, this bond may be strengthened by proper application of epoxy resin which is used to bond the remaining layers to gether to form the ski.

It will be noted that the rubber layer 22 passes between the running edges 20 and the fiberglass layer 18, thence downwardly between the viscoelastic material 26 and the running edges 20, and thence across the ski between the constraining member 28 and the running surface layer 24. Thus the rubber layer 22 isolates the bottom surface of the constraining member 28 from the running surface layer 24. The rubber layer 22 is secured to the constraining member 28 and other adjacent layers by adhesive. It will further be noted that the viscoelastic material 26 isolates the constraining member 28 from the next vertically adjacent load-bearing member, the fiberglass layer 18. Preferably the damping laminate extends for substantially the entire length of the ski. The constraining member 28 may be completely surrounded by viscoelastic material and rubber layer 22, or the constraining member may be permitted to project beyond the viscoelastic material and rubber isolating material at its rear terminal at the rear end of the ski so that the projecting portion of the constraining member can be directly secured to the remaining layers of the ski with a screw S, as shown in FIG. 4, adhesive, or the like. In any event, the major portion of the constraining member should be isolated from the rest of the ski layers by the viscoelastic material and rubber for best performance.

It will be noted that the particular ski structure illustrated in FIG. I is only one of many possible ski structures of the multi-layer type with which the invention may be used to improve vibration damping characteristics. While the load'bearing members of the ski structure of FIG. I are referred to as being fiber glass, they could also be made of metal or other conventional load-bearing material without departing from the spirit of the invention. Similarly, the core structure need not shorter the Half Life Time, the better vibration damping characteristic of the ski.

Generally, when determining the vibration damping characteristics of a ski, the Frequency is also deterbe wood, but could instead be made from a rigid plastic 5 mined, the Frequency being defined as the number of foam, a metal honeycomb, or any other con entional complete vibration cycles, or cycles of motion in a unit an kn wn m i l il r COWS 0f k of time, wherein by international convention, 1 cycle It is noted that most materials exhibit some degree of per seeond equals 1 Hertz. viscoelasticity, an elastic material being defined as a Tests showing the vibration damping ability of the material whose stress is proportional to strain, and a structure h w i FIG, 1 were conducted with comviSC S m ri l eing fin as a ri Whose parisons being made between this structure and the stress is proportional to strain rate. A viscoelastic matestructures h w i FIG, 2 and FIG. 3 which are rerial is a material whose behaviour is a mixture of these ri l a i ll available prior art ski and a two simple cases. In order to be useful in providing viski structure similar thereto but incorporating as an inbration damping in accordance with this invention, the ternal component, the prior art viscoelastic vibration elastomeric material used must possess pronounced damping composite shown in US. Pat. No. 3,537,717, viscoelastic properties. By pronounced viscoelastic n t d above, referred to hereinafter as the Modified properties, it is meant that the loss tangent of the visco- P i Art" ki Th prior art ki u ed in m ari elastic material must be greater than about 0.8. When tests was of the same construction shown in FIG. 2, it a viscoelastic material is subjected to a sinusoidal being noted that the rubber layer 22 extends in a strain, the resultant stress is approximated by a sine straight line laterally across the full width of the ski. wave which leads the strain by the phase angle B. The The space between the rubber layer 22 and running relationship between the components of the tension or ba 24 was filled with a viscoelastic clear polyethylene compression modulus ofany specimen is defined by the material 27. The Modified Prior Art ski used in the equation: 25 comparison test was of the same construction shown in FIG. 3. It will be noted that the constraining member E* E i E 28 is not surrounded with viscoelastic material and rubber. The viscoelastic material is sandwiched only be Where? tween the constraining member 28 and the fiberglass is the Complex modulus of elasticity: layer 18, the side surfaces of the constraining member is Storage modulus of elasticity; 28 are adjacent the running edges 20 and the bottom iS the 1055 modulus; and surface of the constraining member is adjacent the run- 1 IS the square root Of l. ning surface layer 24,

The 1055 tangent is the tangent of the Phase angle {3 Other numerals in FIGS. 2 and 3 denote structural which equals AS Previously noted the loss members similar to those described in connection with gent of the viscoelastic material must be greater than FIG 1, about (18 to be Useful Vibration damping in The vibration damping characteristics of both the ance ith his in n n shovel and the entire forebody area of the skis were The constraining member which forms a P of the measured with the results thereof being set forth in vibration damping laminate must be ofa material hav- 40 T bl 1 b l 1 measuring th ib ti d i ing a relatively high modulus of elasticity, such as steel, h t ri ti of the shovel a ea, the skis were aluminum, fiberglass, or the like. clamped approximately midway between the shovel Several measurements which may e made t d t rand binding areas and the shovel end of the ski was demine the amount of vibration damping present in 14 ki flected and released to vibrate. In measuring the vibrainclude: the Log Decrement which is defin d as th tion damping characteristics of the forebody, the skis natural logarithm of the ratio of any two successive viwere clamped at the binding area and the shovel end of bration amplitudes wherein: the ski was deflected and released to vibrate. The viscoelastic material used in the skis was made generally in Log Decremem In A2 accordance with the disclosure of Kalleberg and it being noted that the greater the value of the Log Dec- Turner US. Pat. No. 3,062,683 except that the glass rement, the better vibration damping characteristic of fibers were omitted from the viscoelastic material and the ski; and the viscoelastic material was carried on a plastic skrim The Half Life Time which is defined as the time per cloth.

TABLE I SHOVEL FOREBODY LOG HALF FRE- LOG HALF FRE- OUENCY OUENCY SKI DECRE- LIFE( sec) (Hertz) DECREA LIFE( sec) (Hertz) MENT MENT Prior Art 052 .45 28.4 .064 .75 14.0 2. Modified Prior Art .050 .48 30,5 .056 .84 14.6 3. FIG. 1 Ski Completely Isolated .127 .18 27.0 .102 .55 13.0

iod required for the vibration amplitude to decay to one-half of its initial value, it being noted that the As will be noted from the above results shown in Table I, the vibration damping characteristics of the ski construction shown in FlG. l was vastly superior to the vibration damping characteristics of either the prior art ski construction or the Modified prior art ski construction wherein the vibration damping laminate of U.S. Pat. No. 3,537,7l7 was incorporated into the ski as an internal component thereof.

In fact it will be noted, contrary to what one might expect, the vibration damping characteristics of the Modified Prior Art ski tested were shown to be inferior to vibration damping characteristics of the prior art ski as evidenced by the decrease in Log Decrement and the increase in vibration Half Life Time. The Modified Prior Art ski displayed the poorest vibration damping characteristics of the three skis tested. The poor vibration damping characteristics of the Modified Prior Art ski is the result of the failure to isolate the constraining member 28 from the remainder of the ski with elastomeric material. The Log Decrement of the ski made in accordance with this invention increased by more than l% in the shovel area test and by more than 80% in the forebody area test. Furthermore, the vibration Half Life for both the shovel and forebody portions of the ski was dramatically decreased. ln the test specimens having an internal constraining member, e.g. Specimens 2 and 3, the internal constraining member extended for substantially the entire length of the ski. Specimen 3 had the constraining member completely isolated by viscoelastic material and rubber.

It will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art that the vibration damping technique disclosed herein will result in much quieter and more skiable skis. This invention allows the ski designer to put as little or as much damping in a ski as required. Also, the other characteristics of the ski can be designed at optimum values. By varying five factors set forth below which control the amount of damping obtained from the constrained viscoelastic laminate, the ski designer can tune the ski to obtain optimum damping. The five factors are:

l. The loss tangent of the viscoelastic material (should be greater than about 0.8).

2. The thickness of the viscoelastic material.

3. The volume of the viscoelastic material.

4. The magnitude of the shear strain in the viscoelastic material.

5. The modulus of elasticity and crosssectional area of the constraining member.

It should be noted that while the constraining member shown in the embodiment of the invention specifi cally disclosed above is in the form ofa sheet-like member, the constraining member could also be in the form of a rod, tube, wire, or other such form without departing from the spirit of the invention.

Since many changes and variations of the disclosed embodiment of the invention may be made without de parting from the inventive concept, it is not intended to limit the invention otherwise than as required by the appended claims.

What is claimed is:

l. A laminated ski structure of the type comprising a top surface, a bottom surface, and a plurality of intermediate layers disposed between said top and bottom surfaces, the improvement comprising at least one ol said intermediate layers being a vibration damping laminate comprising a high modulus of elasticity member substantially completely surrounded by elastomeric material a portion of said elastomeric material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties and having a loss tangent greater than about 0.8 and the remainder of said elastomeric material being rubber, said material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties being insulated from external environment by outwardly adjacent material possessing substantially lower viscoelas' tic properties.

2. The ski structure of claim 1, wherein said vibration damping laminate extends for substantially the entire length of the ski.

3. The ski structure of claim 1, wherein said vibration damping laminate is offset downwardly from the neutral axis of the ski.

4. The ski structure of claim 1, wherein said high modulus member includes a rearward portion projecting from said elastomeric material, and further comprising means for securing said rearward portion to a tail end portion of the ski.

5. The ski structure of claim 1, wherein said elastomeric material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties is sandwiched between said high modulus member and a vertically adjacent load-bearing member.

6. A laminated ski structure comprising a top surface, a bottom surface and one or more interbonded inter mediate layers disposed between said top and bottom surfaces, at least one of said intermediate layers being a vibration damping laminate comprising a layer of material having a relatively high modulus of elasticity, a layer of material having pronounced viscoelastic properties and having a loss tangent greater than about 0.8 bonded to one surface of said high modulus layer, and a layer of rubber bonded to an opposite surface of said high modulus layer, said viscoelastic layer and said rubber layer serving to substantially completely isolate said high modulus layer from the remainder of the ski, and said viscoelastic layer being insulated from external environment by outwardly adjacent material possessing substantially lower viscoelastic properties.

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION Patent No. 3 I 1, 522 Dated August 26, 7

Inventor(s) H. C. Boehm It is certified that error appears in the above-identified patent and that said Letters Patent are hereby corrected as shown below:

In Column 5, line 49, the equation Log Decrement ln A should be deleted and the equation "Log Decrement ln l/A inserted.

Signed and Scaled this twenty-third Dal) of December 1975 [SEAL] A ttesr:

RUTH C. M A SON C. MARSHALL DANN Arresting Office Commissioner uj'larents and Trademarks

Claims

1. A laminated ski structure of the type comprising a top surface, a bottom surface, and a plurality of intermediate layers disposed between said top and bottom surfaces, the improvement comprising at least one of said intermediate layers being a vibration damping laminate comprising a high modulus of elasticity member substantially completely surrounded by elastomeric material a portion of said elastomeric material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties and having a loss tangent greater than about 0.8 and the remainder of said elastomeric material being rubber, said material possessing pronounced viscoelastic properties being insulated from external environment by outwardly adjacent material possessing substantially lower viscoelastic properties.

6. A laminated ski structure comprising a top surface, a bottom surface and one or more interbonded intermediate layers disposed between said top and bottom surfaces, at least one of said intermediate layers being a vibration damping laminate comprising a layer of material having a relatively high modulus of elasticity, a layer of material having pronounced viscoelastic properties and having a loss tangent greater than about 0.8 bonded to one surface of said high modulus layer, and a layer of rubber bonded to an opposite surface of said high modulus layer, said viscoelastic layer and said rubber layer serving to substantially completely isolate said high modulus layer from the remainder of the ski, and said viscoelastic layer being insulated from external environment by outwardly adjacent material possessing substantially lower viscoelastic properties.