US3891344A

US3891344A - Steam turbine system with digital computer position control having improved automatic-manual interaction

Info

Publication number: US3891344A
Application number: US298081A
Authority: US
Inventors: Andrew S Braytenbah
Original assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corp
Current assignee: CBS Corp
Priority date: 1972-10-14
Filing date: 1972-10-16
Publication date: 1975-06-24
Anticipated expiration: 1992-06-24

Abstract

An improvement in the operation of an electric power plant utilizing a steam turbine controlled, in an automatic mode, by means of a digital computer, is accomplished by simplifying the interaction between the programmed automatic process control and the manual backup control. The position setpoint for each of a plurality of valves in the system to be controlled is established as a direct digital holding function in a respective bistable relay register. In addition, a single valve control holding register is provided which is coupled to all of the valve position controls in parallel. Automatic operation is then possible in either single valve or programmed sequential valve modes, and the programmed interaction to accomplish switching from manual to automatic control is simplified by updating the automatic control status until the single valve holding register has a setting equal to the manual control representation before consummating the manual to automatic switching. The direct digital holding registers also improve total system operation in eliminating drift with respect to the valve positions represented so as to extend the period of reliable operation in the manual mode, and also make it possible to retain the last valid position setpoints held in the respective registers prior to a computer power failure.

Description

Elnite States Patent [191 Braytenhah June 24, 1975 1 STEAM TURBINE SYSTEM WITH DIGITAL COMPUTER POSITION CONTROL HAVING IMPROVED AUTOMATIC-MANUAL INTERACTION [75] Inventor: Andrew S. Braytenbah, Pennsauken,

[73] Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation,

Pittsburgh, Pa.

[22] Filed: Oct. 16, 1972 [21] Appl. No.: 298,081

Related US. Application Data [62] Division of Ser. No. 80,710, Oct. 14, 1972, Pat. No.

Primary Examiner-C. J. Husar Attorney, Agent, or FirmH. W. Patterson THROTTLE PRESSURE DETECTOR STEAM GENERATING SYSTEM [5 7 ABSTRACT An improvement in the operation of an electric power plant utilizing a steam turbine controlled, in an automatic mode, by means of a digital computer, is accomplished by simplifying the interaction between the programmed automatic process control and the manual backup control. The position setpoint for each of a plurality of valves in the system to be controlled is established as a direct digital holding function in a respective bistable relay register. In addition, a single valve control holding register is provided which is coupled to all of the valve position controls in parallel. Automatic operation is then. possible in either single valve or programmed sequential valve modes, and the programmed interaction to accomplish switching from manual to automatic control is simplified by updating the automatic control status until the single valve holding register has a setting equal to the manual control representation before consummating the manual to automatic switching. The direct digital holding registers also improve total system operation in eliminating drift with respect to the valve positions repre sented so as to extend the period of reliable operation in the manual mode, and also make it possible to retain the last valid position setpoints held in the respective registers prior to a computer power failure.

3 Claims, 6 Drawing Figures POWER DETECTOR GENERATOR CONDENSER :sa L SPEED p DETECTOR so HYDRAULIC THROTTLE UATOR POSITI N CONTROLS u r n ofi s R 42 l 44 HYDRAULIC HYDRAULIC HYDRAULI THOE E GOVERNOR J W c ACTA ACTUATORS 5s UATORS ACTUATORS L posli'lo l men PRESSURE com'noll s HYDRAULIC FLUID SUPPLY PATENTEIJJUN 24 ms SHEET mommmuomm EFEwu mmBOa STEAM TURBINE SYSTEM WITH DIGITAL COMPUTER POSITION CONTROL HAVING IMPROVED AUTOMATIC-MANUAL INTERACTION This is a division, of application Ser. No. 80,710 filed Oct. 14, 1972, now US. Pat. No. 3,741,246.

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION 1. System and Method For Operating a Steam Turbine and An Electric Power Generating Plant by T. C. Giras and M. E. Birnbaum, Ser. No. 722,779, filed Apr. 19, 1968, and assigned to the same assignee'as the present invention.

2. Improved Computer Positioning Control System 'With Manual Backup Control by T. C. Giras and W. W.

Barnes, Ser. No. 815,882 filed Apr. 14, 1969, now US. Pat. No. 3,552,872 assigned to the present assignee.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION The present invention relates to computer process control systems and more particularly to electric power plant steam turbines and digital computer control systems arranged to operate such turbines.

The flow of steam through a steam turbine is determined by positioning the turbine admission valves in order to control the turbine speed and/or load. Turbine valve positioning may additionally be directed to throttle pressure control where such control is required for the steam generating system.

In the aforementioned Birnbaum and Giras copending patent application, there is presented a survey of the prior steam turbine control art. Generally, automatic steam turbine valve control has developed from essentially mechanical and mechanical-hydraulic type control systems to essentially electrohydraulic type control systems. The Birnbaum and Giras application (reference 11 above) discloses a further advanced automatic digital electrohydraulic turbine control system which employs a programmed digital computer in its preferred form. A paper entitled Digital Control For Large Steam Turbine-Generators presented to the American Power Conference during Apr. 23-25, 1968 by M. Birnbaum and T. Giras describes a similar computer type turbine control system.

In addition to automatic control, safety and reliability in steam turbine operation usually makes it desirable to employ manual backup control. To interface the manual control with the automatic control and the steam turbine, it is necessary to provide suitable conditions for bumpless or other appropriate transfer from automatic to manual control and from manual to automatic control. In turn, the character of the automatic valve positioning control as well as the character of the interfacing arrangement itself enter into determining the efficiency and economy with which automatic/manual steam turbine control is provided. This is particularly so. in relation to large steam and other turbine control systems which involve positioning control over a plurality of steam turbine admission valves.

Prior art electrohydraulic control systems typically might provide for manual backup control but such schemes are limited to analog type systems. The Giras and Barnes application (reference 2 above) is directed to a digital positioning control'system and particularly a steam turbine valve positioning control system in which a digital computer provides a relatively fast and 2 accurate positioning operation and with which a manual backup positioning control is interfaced.

The Giras and Barnes application (reference 2 above) describes a digital computer system wherein time series turbine valve position setpoint control words are converted to analog valuesand multiplexed for application to track and hold circuits associated with respective electrohydraulic turbinevalveposition control loops. During manual operation, a manual con trol applies a setpoint control signal to all of the track and hold circuits in parallel. A read multiplexer, keeps the computer updated on valve positions during manual control. 2

While the Giras and Barnes system provides the first interface between the automatic operation of the ,digital computer and a manual backup positioning control it has certain limitations.

During automatic operation the computer mustgenerate a relatively large number of setpoint control words and further the system must provide forthe conversion of these control words into analog values before they become effective to establish the desired setpoint control. During manual operation theread multiplexing operation requires a comparable number of inputs in order to keep the computer updated with respect to the manual control. Accordingly, while the Giras and Barnes system is relatively fast with respect to the prior art and provides an important improvement with respect to the interfacing of automatic and manual controls it is limited with respect to the speed ofir put and output because of the number of control words which must be transmitted or received in order to operate.

A further limitation in the operation of the system of the copending application is in the period during which manual control may be effective. Since the system of the copending application relies upon track and hold circuits, periods in excess of a week of operation cannot be reliably maintained due to the relative drift which will occur among the various setpoint signals.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION In accordance with the broad principles of the present invention, a digital computer positioning control system has improved performance through the introduction of a simplified interaction between the programmed automatic process control and the manual backup control. The position setpoint for each of the plurality of valves in the system to be controlled is established as a direct digital holding function in a respective bistable relay register. In addition, a'single valve control holding register is provided which is coupled to all of the valve position controls in parallel. The hybrid or combined analog-digital control part of the system then provides for the digital to analog conversion of the setpoint value in a control register with the converted value of the setpoint in the single valve holding register during automatic operation or that value provided by the manual control during manual operation.

Automatic operation becomes possible then in either a single valve or programmed sequential valve mode, and the programmed interaction required to accomplish switching from manual to automatic control is simplified with respect to the technique of the copending application by updating the: automatic control status until the single valve holding register has a setting equal to the manual control representation before consummating the manual to automatic switch.

The direct digital holding registers also improve total system operation in eliminating drift with respect to valve positions which are represented so as to extend the period of reliable operation in the manual mode, permitting a virtually unlimited period of manual operation. The use of bistable relays is also important as a specific improvement of the invention since these make it possible to retain the last valid position setpoint held in a respective register prior to a computer power failure. The manual backup control operation is presumed, in order to gain full advantage of this feature to have an independent power supply. In the preferred embodiment of the invention, an improvement in the specific operation of the manual control itselfis accomplished through the use of a digital up/down counter which is responsive to RAISE and LOWER input signals and provides control signals which are summed with any of the then remaining setpoint signals developed during the terminated automatic operation.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS FIG. 1 shows a schematic diagram of a large steam turbine system, the valves of which are controlled according to the present invention;

FIG. 2 shows a schematic diagram of a digital computer control system operable with the steam turbine system of FIG. 1, such computer control system being utilized to provide the digital setpoint signals employed in the control system of the present invention;

FIG. 3 is a schematic diagram showing how the system of the present invention is interconnected with the computer control system of FIG. 2 to provide the improved functioning of the invention;

FIGS. 4A and 4B show two types of manual control circuits, one utilizing a digital up/down counter and the other using an analog track and hold amplifier; and

FIG. 5 is a schematic diagram of a suitable form of output and multiplexing system for use in the system of FIG. 3.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT FIGS. 1 and 2 are similar to those described in the aforementioned copending patent applications constituting references (1) and (2) above and therefore will be just briefly reviewed herein.

Reference is made to FIG. 1 where steam from a suitable generating system 26 is shown as passing through throttle valves TVl-TV4 to governor valves GVl-GVS providing steam input to a high pressure turbine section forming part of a turbine-generator system 10. The positions of the valves are controlled by respective control systems, the throttle valves being controlled through position controls 50 and actuators 42 and the governor valves being controlled through controls 52 and actuators 44. Various setpoint signals are shown as being applied to the controls, representing digital output words, as will be discussed in further detail with respect to FIGS. 3 and 5 herein.

Although consideration herein will be directed primarily to the control of governor valves GVl through GVS it will be understood that the principles herein developed are applicable as well to throttle valve control or to the control of other valves such as intercept and stop valves shown following reheater 28 in FIG. 1.

In FIG. 2 the relationship between central processor 62 and various means utilized according to the present invention is shown in block diagram form. It will be noted that the processor 62 provides certain output signals applied to contact closure output system 86 which direct computer words to the valve position control output system 90. Control output system 90 also receives an input from manual control 92, a specific form of which is provided by the present invention. It will be noted that processor 62 receives certain input signals through an analog input system 72 including signal AMSV (auto-manual single valve) from a point 140 shown in FIG. 3. Signal AMSV will be discussed in connection with FIG. 3 as being a feedback signal referencing the position of the manual or single valve automatic control to facilitate the bumpless transfer between automatic and manual modes of operation.

Reference is now made to FIG. 3 where it will be noted that setpoint control words provided by processor 62 are passed through output system 86 to

digital multiplexers

102 and 104. The function of the multiplexers will be considered in detail with reference to FIG. 5. Multiplexer 102 is coupled to a series of registers referenced as GVRl...GVR8 corresponding to governor valves GVl through GV8, and is also coupled to a register SVR providing the holding means for single valve control. Multiplexer 104 is coupled to a similar control network (not shown) for throttle valve control coupled to each setpoint storage register, is a digital-to-analog converter referenced, in the case of the governor valves, as: DAC-Gl. .DAC-G8 and, in the case of the single valve control, as: DAC-SV.

Converter DAC-SV is also referenced as to show that it corresponds to the means for converting set point representations from digital to analog form at a control point, specified also as means 100 in reference (2) above.

It will be noted that wherever the means employed according to the present invention are the same as those of reference (2) the same reference number is used. Relay contact 136 in FIG. 3, corresponds to the contact of the same number in the copending application, and is used to switch from manual control to automatic. It is shown in a position making contact with point 136M, corresponding to the manual mode of operation. During automatic operation, the contact is transferred to make contact with point 136A, at which time the setpoint value of register SVR is effective through converter DAC-SV to provide a single valve control signal.

Point 140 in FIG. 3 is the common control point for either automatic or manual and is applied to a series of summing impedances which may be resistors referenced as 134-1 to 134-8 corresponding to eight governor valve controls. It will be understood, of course, that as governor valves are grouped for control, the number of control functions is thereby reduced. For example, in a typical operation utilizing the invention, governor valves GVl to GV4 may be controlled together so that setpoint register GVRl is then utilized to provide a single position setpoint for valve GV1-GV4. In this case register GVRl could be renamed as: GVR1-4. If the remaining governor valves are controlled individually then registers GVRS, GVR6, GVR7 and GVR8 would be employed. The invention may be utilized in any combination to provide the desired control.

The signal at point 140 is also fed back to analog input system 72 as signal AMSV for computer programmed tracking of the manual control signal prior to the switching back to automatic. The actual transfer of switch 136 from manual to automatic is a complex computer control function.

The governor valve setpoints stored in registers GVRl-GVRS are converted through their respective digital to analog converters DAC-Gl through DAC-GS to output signals which are applied through resistors 124-1 124-8 to summing junctions 125-1 125-8 connected to respective servo amplifiers SAl SA8 Also connected to summihgjunctions 125 are feedback position signals PDGl PDGS, applied through summing resistors 126-1 126-8, respectively. For example, signal PDGl is fed back through resistor 126-1 to summing point 125-] connected to servo amplifier SAl.

It will be noted that a system similar to that just described. with respect to controlling the governor valve actuators may also be provided for throttle valve control. This is indicated by the showing of multiplexer 104 having an output connected to various throttle valve controls.

Switching power through appropriate means 145 is applied through contacts 116-1 116-8 to respective governor valve registers during automatic operation. Contacts 116 are opened during the manual control mode and registers GVR1-GVR8 then hold the last setpoint established by the computer. It is important therefore that registers .GVR be bistable relays as shown in FIG. 5 which do not require power to hold their states. Since manual control may have been enterecl into due to a computer malfunction, the automatic removal of switching power from the set point storing registers provides an effective means of preventing an inadvertent change in these values. Once manual control begins through means 92, the signal developed by manual control is applied to point 140 and then modifies the position or signal input to the actuators in parallel by applying such modifying signal through resistors 134.

Reference is now made to FIG. 4A where one form of manual control provided by the invention is shown. In FIG. 4A analog comparator 921 receives the output signal of DAC-SV and also that of converter 927 (DAC-M). During automatic operation output signals references as INC and DEC produced by comparator 921 are utilized to develop UP (INC) and DOWN (DEC) control signals for a counter 925 by means of logic 923. This will bediscussed in detail below. During manual operation, the UP and DOWN control signals for counter 925 are derived through logic 923 as a function of input signals: RAISE and LOWER. Comparator 921 and counter 925 are conventional devices well known in the art and will not be described in detail herein.

During manual control each time a RAISE signal is applied through logic 923, counter 925 is incremented at a predetermined rate in an UP direction and the output of counter 925 is converted into an analog signal through converter 927. This analog signal passes through relay switch 136 to point 140 and thence to impedances 134 shown in FIG. 3. A similar operation occurs when a LOWER signal is applied through logic 924 to counter 925, causing it to be reduced in value and the analog equivalent of counter 925 is supplied through point to resistors 134. In this manner, digital tracking of the manual control is continuously updated through counter 925 which provides a stable manual control reference suitable for long time period utilization without drift. Furthermore, when the system is in the automatic mode of operation, the counter 925 is caused to continuously follow the setpoint value entered into register SVR so that when switchover occurs from automatic to manual, there is a bumpless" transfer with respect to the signal at point140.

The logic for means 923 may be expressed in a generalized and simplified form as follows:

UP (INCA RAISE.M).R

DOWN (DEC.A LOWERM) R,

Where A represents automatic control, M represents manual control, R represents runback, R represents the not-runback case. INC, DEC. RAISE and LOWER are previously defined. The dot is the logical and and the plus is the logical or". The prime is used to represent the complement.

According to this logic the UP control to counter 925, causing counting up at a predetermined rate, is provided in response to signal INC for automatic control and in response to signal RAISE for manual control, the UP control being disabled by the condition R during runback.

The DOWN control for counter 925 is provided by the logic of decrease (DEC) for automatic, or lower (LOWER) for manual, or during runback control R.

The system may be switchedfrom automatic to manual without any discontinuity in control since all values in registers GVRl-GVRS remain undisturbed'once switching power is removed and the value of the signal at point 140 is taken over by the manual control." I

The transition from manual. to automatic involves computer tracking control in order to insure that the setting of register SVR conforms to signal AMSV feedback through input system 72.

If the long term drift stability of counter 925 is not required and the advantage of certain simplicity is desired, the alternative embodiment of FIG. 48 may be employed. In this embodiment, the comparator function provided by circuit 921 is effectively accomplished through

resistors

922 and 924 when contact 931 is in its upper position 931A for the automatic operation. In this case, amplifier 928 acts as a tracking amplifier and continuously charges a capacitor 926 to cause it to follow the value of the setpoint entered into register SVR. When switching to manual is made, whereby contact 136 assumes position 136M, and contact 931 assumes position 931M, track and hold amplifier 928 provides the bumpless transfer whereby the signal applied to point 140 and resistors 134 are not disturbed. After the transfer to manual control the value of the output signal of amplifier 928 may be adjusted by control signals RAISE and LOWER by applying suitable negative and positive voltage through resistor 930 and switch 931 to the amplifier.

It will be understood that although relay switching has been specified herein, the broad concept of the invention is not so limited. The term switch therefore as utilized herein is intended to be a generic term covering any means accomplishing the desired end result.

In the above discussion it has been assumedjthat the means providing digital word communication between the central processor and the various setpoint storage registers is a multiplexer such as that referenced as means 102 in FIG. 3. In the broad context of the invention, however, any means suitable for directing setpoint control words to the appropriate register will serve this function. To illustrate a suitable control technique FIG. 5 is provided where the central processor 62 is assumed to include means for providing an input outputcontrol instruction referenced as CON including an operation code IOA specifying input or output from the accumulator, a control bit representing I/O where a l represents input and a represents output and a channel address code for selecting an appropriate receiving register in the case illustrated. In addition, the processor includes an accumulator ACC which is filled with the setpoint to be routed to the addressed register. The output system 86 then is controlled by the channel address to select, through-appropriate digital output gating, which of the registers is to receive the setpoint.

It is assumed in the illustrative case of FIG. that there are a plurality (M) of bistable relay registers and a corresponding plurality of digital to analog converters coupled thereto. Each register is referred to as a contact output register and the references COR] CORM are provided to represent the plurality of registers and associated control functions Only the specific details of CORl will be considered since the control functions may be identical in all registers. Considering specifically the control for set and reset armatures SRll and RR] 1, it will be noted that a transfer contact TCll may assume either of two possible bistable states under the control of the set and reset armatures. Sufficient magnetism remains in each armature to hold contact TCC] in whatever position it is placed without power so that if switch 116 is opened, as previously discussed, and power is removed from the system contact TCll and other similar contacts will remain in whatever state they have been placed prior to power removal. Reset armature RRll is controlled through a timing circuit TC110 and set armature SRll is controlled through a timing circuit TClll each of which receives a signal to an appropriate gate G11 receiving its signal through the digital output gating. The function of gate G1] is to operate timing TC110 when the input bit is a zero and to operate timing circuit TCl 11 when the input bit is a one. The purpose of the timing circuits is to hold a control signal on the appropriate relay armature for a minimum period of five milliseconds after the digital output gating has terminated so as to permit the processor to continue its operating functions while providing a sufficient current actuation time for the relatively slow acting relay.

Corresponding to contact output relay control CORll there are a total of N similar or identical circuits within contact output register control CORl only the first and the nth in this'series are shown and specific details of the bistable relay are shown only in CORll. Corresponding to the number of setpoint register controls required there are M circuits like CORl and within each of these are a number (N) of relay control circuits that have been described corresponding to the number of binary bits in the control words which is utilized to specify the setpoint in the system.

During the automatic computer operation the socalled multiplexing is accomplished by program control and setting up the appropriate setpoint value in the accumulator ACC and establishing the corresponding channel address and input output control as noted above. If the program is made to automatically sequence setpoint entry for all registers it may then be considered to be multiplexing program, but the invention may be operated to control only a single register during a particular program subroutine such as may be utilized for tracking the manual operation just prior to the switching to automatic control.

From the foregoing description it should now be apparent that the present invention provides an important improvement in means for improving the operation of an electric power plant with particular emphasis upon an automatic-manual control technique whereby the valves of a steam turbine may be positioned either automatically through a computer program or by means ofa manual backup control system. The invention simplifies the tracking which is required for either manual to automatic or automatic to manual switching and eliminates drift with respect to valve position so as to extend the period of reliable operation in the'manual mode. The specific use of the bistable relay control provides a further improvement in that computer power failure will not cause the loss of the last setpoint position and the invention makes it further possible to take over manual control from the last setpoint position and to increase or decrease the position signals then existing.

I claim:

1. A method for operating a steam turbine system for controlling power output to a generator connected to said turbine as a function of the position of the series of governor valves said method comprising: establishing individual governor valve setpoints for each respective valve during a sequential mode of operation; establishing a single valve setpoint applied in parallel to all of said governor valve controls during a single valve control; applying a single common manual control signal to all of said valves in parallel during a manual mode of operation, said single valve control signal and said manual control signal being switchably combined through an automatic-manual control; and summing the switchably combined automatic and manual control signal with the individual sequential governor valve control signal to form a composite governor valve control signal suitable for application to respective governor valve actuators.

2. A method for controlling the valves of a turbine to improve automatic-manual interaction, said method comprising: providing individual valve setpoints of digital words during a sequental valve control operation; providing a single valve setpoint during a single valve setpoint operation and applying said single valve setpoint in parallel to all valves; summing said parallelapplied single valve setpoint individually with each respective separate valve setpoint; and switchably introducing a single valve control during manual operation to a point common with said point of application of said single valve setpoint.

3. An improved method for automatic turbine valve control comprising: separately producing a governor valve series of setpoint control signals, a single valve setpoint signal, and a manual control signal; selectively switching either said single valve control signal or said manual control signal to a common control point; and summing the signal output of said common control point with individual separate valve control signals to form a plurality of valve actuator signals.

Claims

2. A method for controlling the valves of a turbine to improve automatic-manual interaction, said method comprising: providing individual valve setpoints of digital words during a sequental valve control operation; providing a single valve setpoint during a single valve setpoint operation and applying said single valve setpoint in parallel to all valves; summing said parallel-applied single valve setpoint individually with each respective separate valve setpoint; and switchably introducing a single valve control during manual operation to a point common with said point of application of said single valve setpoint.