US2439513A - Adipic acid process - Google Patents

Description

April 1948. c. H. HAMBLET ET AL 2,439,513

QDIPIG ACID PROCESS Filed Nov. 30, 1945 0X lD/Z E D PRODUCTS IIIIIIIII WIIII'IIIIII ORGAN/CS Patented Apr. 13, 1948 ADIPIC ACID PROCESS Clement H. Hamblet and Ambrose McAlevy, Wilming'ton, Del., assignors to E. 1. du Pont de Nemours & Company poration of Delaware Wilmington, Del., a cor- Application November 30, 1945, Serial No. 632,081

This invention relates to the production of adipic acid and related aliphatic dibasic acids and more particularly to the production, of adipic acid bythe oxidation of cyclohexane.

Production of pure dibasic acids by oxidation of cycloparaflins is of considerable commercial interest because of the increasing use of such acids in the manufacture of synthetic resins and the ready availability of the hydrocarbon starting materials from various sources. Direct oxidation of cyclanes, however, leads in general to a variety of products, from which separation of the derived acid in a reasonable state of purity is difiicult and yields of any one acid are low. For example, in the oxidation of cyclohexane to adipic acid, yields in the range 18-24% have been reported (M kowinkofi Ann., 302, I, 1898; Nameutkin, Russ. Phys. Chem. Soc, 40, 1570, 1908). Usually the reported yields have been much lessiin the neighborhood of approximately 4%. i

Overall yields of dibasic acids can be improved by carrying out the oxidation in a series of stages, in each of which the degreeof oxidation of that portion of the charge which is attacked is controlled. Such oxidations as are described in the D. J. Loder Patents 2,223,493 and 2,223,494 where-' in cyclohexane is oxidized to cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone might be considered as the preliminary step in such a process. When this oxidation is carried out at a temperature between '75 and 175 C. under 50 to 250 p. s. 1. pressure, and with oxygen absorption limited to that corresponding to attack of of the hydrocarbon charged, combined yields of cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone in the neighborhood of 70% may be obtained, the yields falling off as the attack on the hydrocarbon is increased.

To effect separation of the products from such an oxidation, the unreacted cyclohexane may be first stripped from the crude reaction product by steam distillation under a fractionating column and recycled as feed to the preliminary oxidation step. After removal of the hydrocarbon, cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone may be recovered as a mixture by further distillation with fractionation techniques. The cyclohexanol may 3 Claims. (Cl. 260-533) inary stage' is far from theoretical and is usually in the neighborhood of 40%. Such processes suffer from the further disadvantage that extensive and expensive refining, accompanied by considerable handling losses, is required in the intermediate stages in order to give a final product of satisfactory purity. i

This invention has as one of its objectives an improved process for converting cyclohexane to adipic acid. Another object is to provide a process for the preparation of adipic acid from cyclohexane whereby excellent yields of adipic acid of high purity are obtained. Another object is to provide an improved process for the production, from cyclic saturated hydrocarbons, of dibasic acids containing the same number of carbon atoms as the hydrocarbon treated, and more particularly to obtain adipic acid from cyclohexane by air oxidation of cyclohexane followed by nitric acid oxidation of the air oxidation product. A further object is to provide an improved technique for nitric acid oxidation of organic compounds. Other obiects and advantages of the invention will hereinafter appear.

It has been found that a surprisingly better yield of adipic acid can be obtained from the cyclic hydrocarbon, cyclohexane, by the process of this invention than can be obtained from heretofore known processes. Generally, the process involves subjecting cyclohexane to air oxidation and thereafter subjecting all of the air oxidation products after the removal of the hydrocarbons toa nitric acid oxidation step. In contradistinction to prior processes wherein cyclohexane was oxidized with air and the cyclohexanone and cy- 5 clohexanol separated prior to their oxidation, this steam and separated by conventional vacuum\ be further air oxidized to cyclohexanone arid all of the cyclohexanone then air oxidized to adipic acid'by known techniques.

Even when these latter air oxidation steps are carried out under optimum known conditions, however, overall adipic acid yield based on the ucts left, nitric acid oxidized- Although dibasic acids of a smaller number of carbon atoms than the hydrocarbon treated may be formed, the

dibasic acids produced are predominantly of the same number of carbon atoms as the hydrocaramount of cyclohexane consumed in the prelimbon oxidized.

3 One feature of the invention involves the nitric acid oxidation of the oxidized cyclic hydrocarbon product. Any suitable process for the oxidation of the cyclane may be employed such, for example, as the lmown liquid-phase air-oxidation process conducted at temperatures between 75 and 200 C. and under pressures from 50 to 500 p. s. i. in which process catalysts such as the metal salts of organic acids have been found useful and more particularly the cobalt naphthenates, cobalt stearates, and the like. Other oxidation processes may. however, be employed such as, for example, those disclosed in the U. S. Patents 2,223,493 and 2,223,494.

While it is preferred to employ in this process the mixture of products obtained by the air oxidation of the cyclanes such as cyclohexane, nevertheless, any other suitable method for the oxidation of the cyclane may be employed although it has been found advisable that in oxidizing these cyclic hydrocarbons to products which are subsequently to be nitric 'acid oxidized togive organic acids, the oxidation of the cyclic hydrocarbon should result in what is called a partial oxidation in which from Vi to 2 moles of oxygen reacts per mole of the reacted cyclic hydrocarbon. and preferably from 0.75 to 1 mole of oxygen per mole of reacted cyclic hydrocarbon. It has been found that while improvements can be obtained in overall yield of dibasic acid, when the oxidation of the hydrocarbon falls outside these ranges, nevertheless, for optimum results it is recommended that the preliminary oxidation be conducted within these ranges.

Prior to subjecting the products from the oxidation of cyclohexane or other cyclanes to nitric acid oxidation, it is desirable first to remove the hydrocarbons present and this may be accomplished by distillation although preferably steam distillation is employed to remove unreacted cyclohexane. The hydrocarbon may be recycled to the air or equivalent oxidation process. If desired livesteam may be passed directly into the oxidation product and the hydrocarbon stripped from this product prior to the nitric acid oxidation of the product.

After removal of the unreacted hydrocarbon, all of the oxidation products, which include cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone, are subjected to further oxidation by means of nitric acid. Although the art of oxidizing organic compounds by means of nitric acid has long been practiced, disclosures in general show yields which are far from ideal and give products of questionable purity. For example. in the laboratory technique for prepare ing adipic acid by oxidation of cyclohexanol described in Organic Syntheses (Gilman, Coll., vol. I, p. 18 (1932)), a yield of only 58-60% of crude acid melting at 141-149 C. is reported. In addition to giving impure acid such oxidations are excessively costly unless some means of recovery and reuse of nitric acid is devised; because of the highly corrosive nature of the mixture a practical method for achieving this has long been sought. Furthermore because of the large amount of heat evolved in such oxidations, temperature control, which is necessary for obtaining optimum yields, is difllcult in commercial installationaa factor which greatly restricts the unit scale on which such reactions can be performed. In the case of adipic acid preparation, removal of heat by conventional methods such as cooling surfaces is also seriously handicapped by crystallization of the product on the cooling surfaces. All of these disadvantages are overcome by another feature in the invention.

This feature involves the nitric acid oxidation of the product, obtained after removing the cyclane from the preliminary oxidation products, which is effected by subjecting such a product to nitric acid oxidation under pressures above atmospheric and in the presence of a suitable catalyst. The oxidation with nitric acid may be effected in a single stage but is preferably effected in two stages.

If the single stage nitric acid oxidation is employed, he reaction is eflected at a temperature between and 150 C. and under a pressure above atmospheric preferably between 15 and 500 p. s. 1. While oxidation in accord with the single step nitric acid procedure will give yields superior to those heretofore obtainable; nevertheless, its superiority over heretofore known processes can be augmented by conducting this phase of the process in two stages. 1

In the preferred two-stage process, the first stage is carried out under mild conditions in which the reactants fiow around a closed circuit; and in the second stage, the products from the first or circulating stage are further oxidized at a somewhat higher temperature. This feature of the invention has solved for the first time the problems presented by nitric-acid oxidation of organic compounds generally and particularly the nitric-acid oxidation of cyclane oxidation products by way of a continuous process in contradistinction to a batch process.

A preferred method of operating the nitricacid oxidation step is illustrated in the accompanying drawing, which is a diagrammatic crosssectional plane view of a tubular converter.

The jacketed tube l is of considerable length and .formed as shown in the drawing in a rectangular shape although it may be constructed in any desired shape with inlets 2 and 3 for the introduction of the reactants. Tube is surrounded by jacket 4 through which circulates a heat-exchange fluid for controlling the reaction in the desired temperature range. A pump 5 is provided in tube l for maintaining a flow of reactants through this tube. An automatically controlled valve 8 operates to deliver prodcatalyst into tube I through inlet 3 and forcing it around through the tube by means of pump I.

The mixture ot'products from air oxidation of.

the cyclone is then introduced-through inlet 2 and the flow of heatzexchange fluid in the jacket I regulated to maintain 'the temperature of the reaction within the designated. range. when the reaction has proceeded for an average of from 1 to 10 minutes the valvet is brought into operation and a part of the str'e'am of reactants passing through tube I is introduced into preheater 9 and reaction tube 'I-Mherein its temperature is raised and theoxidationcompIeted. The exidation products issue f the. reactor through the outlet l0.

The essential features tinuous nitric-acid oxi' step are: The cyclane-free product of pelin' inary oxidation and a nitric acid solution 9 {30-70% ,strength, preferably 50-60% strength, based on volatile content, containing a-suitable catalyst are septhe two-stage conarately and continuously introduced under a pressure of 2-10 atm. into the rapidly flowing stream containing nitric acid, catalyst, water, and productsof the reaction in tube l. .The weight ratio of flows of the nitric acid. mixture to organic feed added to the circulating mixture should be in the range of 5-40, preferably -25, at the point of mixture; weight ratios of 100% nitric acid in the feed to organic feed should be in the range 2.5-6.0. gPump 5 recirculates the nitric acid mixture through the tubular system, the rate of recirculation being such that the fluid flow is in the turbulent range. The temperature of the recirculating mixture should be maintained between 4090 0., preferably between 6080 C. by means of suitable jacket coolants. Gases formed in the oxidation are preferably separated at some point in the recirculation system, as for example, a pipe (not shown in the drawing) vertically positioned on tube l. The rate of admit tance of organic feed to the recirculation system should be such that the average contact time in this part of the equipment is of the order of 110 minutespreferably about 5 minutes.

Although various types of catalysts ma be used, those preferred are mixtures containing dissolved copper salts and dissolved vanadium or manganese salts, total concentration of catalyst being in the range 0.01-0.5 weight present based on the nitric acid solution being fed. The vanadium catalyst may be obtained in soluble form by, e. g. treatment of an aqueous or nitric acid suspension of vanadium pentoxide with nitrogen dioxide, nitric oxide, or nitrogen trioxide or gaseous mixtures containing one or more of these nitrogen oxides.

The oxidation mixture is continuously with-,

drawn from the circulating stage, the rate of withdrawal hearing such a relation to the rate of feeding that the volume of liquid mixture in the circulating system remains substantially constant. The eilluent is then conducted to the second nitric acid oxidizing reaction, preferably after being preheated. The mixture is held during this phase of the reaction (which may be conducted in, a tubular unit as illustrated in the drawing or an autoclave) at a higher temperature between 90- 120 C., and preferably between 95-100 0., for

an average period of 3-20 minutes, preferably about 7 min. The reaction is exothermic and the low temperature. In the case of adipic acid crystallization, the preferred temperature is in the vicinity of 5 C. The crude acid may be recovered from the slurry by known techniques such as filtration or centrifuging, and the mother liquor may be recycled as part of the nitric acid feed to the oxidation step. To assure purity of the recovered acid, a portion of the mother liquor is vacuum flash distilled under pressures in the range 30-300 mm. and at temperatures in the range -150 C., the distillate being preferably recycled with the remainder of the mother liquor.

In cases where vanadium compounds are used in the catalyst mixture, this element may be recovered from the tails from the flash distillation of themother liquor by diluting to give a solution which is homogeneous at room temperature and adjusting the pH of the solution to a value in excess of 1.0 by addition of an inorganic base such as sodium carbonate or hydroxide. Under these conditions the vanadium has been found to practically quantitatively precipitate in the form of an organic complex. The latter may be recovered by filtration and recycled to "the nitric acid oxidation step.

The following examples will illustrate preferred embodiments of the invention in which parts are by weight unless otherwise stated.

Example 1.Cyclohea:ane-air oxidation to alco- 7101 and Icetone, separately oxidizing the alcohol toketone and oxidizing the ketonev to adipic acid A charge containing 1997.1 parts of cyclohexane, 6.0 parts of cyclohexanone and 1.2 parts of cobalt naphthanate was air oxidized in a one gallon stainless steel autoclave operated at 142-445 C. under 100 p. s. 1. pressure for 77 minutes at an air space velocity of 91 volumes (S. T). P.) per volume of charge per hour. The product was then discharged and unreacted hydrocarbon was recovered by steam distillation under a fractionating column operating at atmospheric pressure. Unreacted hydrocarbon, recovered as the water azeotrope boiling in the range ,68-80 C. amounted to 1748.8 parts, corresponding to a consumption of 248.3 parts or 12.5% during oxidation.

Exhaustive steam distillation of the residue 1 from the above distillation gave 233.2 parts of mixture should be cooled to maintain the temperature within the designated range.

The reacted mixture issuing from the second stage reaction may be bleached by countercurrent treatment with'air at a temperature between 70 and 100 C. and preferably at about 90 C. The off-gas from the bleaching operation contains nitrogen oxides which may be recovered as nitric acid by adsorption in water or nitric acid solution by known methods. The air flow to the bleaching operation should consequently be at least great enough to provide sufficient oxygen for complete oxidation of the nitrogen oxides to nitric acid.

Monobasic acids are formed in the oxidation of many cyclanes. In the case where products from air oxidation of cyclohexane are converted to adipic acid by nitric acid treatment, the presence of n-vaierlc and n-caproic acids in particular, make the recovery of high quality adipic acid difflcult and these and similar acids should be removed by fractional distillation prior to the crysoil 'boiling azeotropically with water in the range 93-100" C. By vacuum fractionation of the oil, after drying, 86.2 parts of cyclohexanone and 84.4 parts of cyclohexanol were recovered, corresponding to a net combined yieldof 56.3% based on cyclohexane consumption. a

The cyclohexanol was converted to cyclohexanone and all of the cyclohexanone was then converted to adipic acid by air oxidation according to known techniques. In a large number of tests adipic acid yield based on cyclohexanone and cyclohexanol was invariably less than 176 partsor 70%, corresponding to an overall adipic acid yield of less than 0.71 part of adipic acid per v part of cyclohexane consumed.

Example 2.-O:ridation of cyclohexane followed by nitric acid oxidationoj the oxidized product.

A similar cyclohexane oxidation product after stripping of the unconverted cyclohexane and partially drying but without removing any cyclohexanone or cyclohexanol was found by analysis to contain 28.4% cyclohexanone, 29.6% cyclohexanol, 0.6% cyclohexcnyl cyclohexyl ether, 3.2 cyclohexyl esters, some cyclohexanediol- 71.2. and 222% of material which was not volatile with steam. The non-volatile traction was found to contain adipate mters. t-iorinyl valeric acid, e-hydron caproic acid and its esters, along with lower homologues.

506.3 parts of this mixture was added gradually over a period of 120 minutes. to a mixture containing 1490 parts of nitric acid. 1010 parts of water, 1.25 parts of ammonium metavanadate and 3.75 parts of freshly dissolved copper, said mixture being maintained at 60' C. in a stirred stainless steel autoclave. The mixture was then heated to 110-114 C. for a period of 60 minutes and discharged from the autoclave. After crystailizing at C. and centriiuglns, 473.4 parts 01 wet crude adipic acid containing 445.7 parts of 100% adipic acid were recovered. An additional 20.9 parts of 100% adipic acid was shown to be recoverable from the converter wash and mother liquor, giving a total yield of 466.6 parts of adipic acid or a superficial yield of 108% based on the cyclohexanone and cyclohexanol content 0! the charge, corresponding to an overall yield of 1.06 parts 0! adipic acid per part of cyclohexane consumed.

These examples show that in the nitric acid oxidation of products obtained by air oxidation oi cyclohexane yield was not only greater but was in excess or that which can theoretically be obtained by separate air oxidation of the cyclohexanone and cyclohexanol formed in the preliminary air oxidation.

By substituting other cyclanes for cyclohexane,

other dibasic acids may be obtained in acceptable yields from cyclopentane-glutaric, cyclobutanesuccinic and from higher cyclanes correspondingly higher dibasic acids.

Etample 2a.-'Vapor phase oxidation of cyclohezane followed by nitric acid oxidation of the oxidized product Cyclohexanevapors and air in the ratio 1:5 by volume are preheated to 300 C. and passed over a silver oxide catalyst maintained at a temperature between 400 and 450 C. The catalyst may be supported on asbestos or any other suitable support and the cyclohexane passed over the catalyst at a space velocity suiiicient to give a contact time of approximately 0.3 second. The

eiliuents were cooled, the unconverted cyclohex-' ane removed by distillation and the residue subjected to nitric acid oxidation by a process simi lar to that described in Example 2. Abetter yield. of adipic acid is obtainable by this method than is obtainable by a separation or the cyclohexanone and cyelohexanol from the oxidized cyclohexane and subjecting these alcohols and ketones to a separate oxidation.

Example a-oeigmon mixture of cucloheaml oalerate and cuciohezanol I 297.8 partsoi cyclohexyl valerate were similarly oxidized by nitric acid in a stirred autoclave. Adipic acid formed amounted to 179.3 parts. corresponding to a yield of 75.8%. Similarly 487.5 parts of cyclohexanol gave 655.4 parts of adipic acid, corresponding to a yield of 92.0%.

when a mixture containing 241.5 parts of cycloor adipic acid obtained from cyclohexyi valerate was raised from 75.8% to 86.1% as a result of oxidizing these materials simultaneously.

Example l.-Nitric acid oxidation at two temperature levels Mixtures containing 50% cyclohexanol and 50% cyclohexanone were passed with approximately 7' parts of 60% nitric acid containing 0.05% ammonium vanadate catalysts through a jacketed tubular'converter similar to that illustrated by the drawing maintained at 71-76 C. at such rates that the total contact time varied in.the range 8.5-17.6 minutes. At the different rates of flow. yield of adipic acid did not vary outside the range Gil-70.6%. Furthermore by changing the temperature inthe range 71-125 C.,.yield did not vary outside the range 64.3-

71.5%. By varying the temperature during passage through the tubular unit, however, considerable improvement in yield was noted. Thus, when the first 46% of the volume of the converter was maintained at 60 C. and the remainder was maintained at C. at total contact times in the range 11.0-11.7 minutes, adipic acid yields in the range oi 78.3-78.6% were obtained.-

Ezample 5.--Nitric acid oxidation with recirculatori! system In a series of reactions, cyclohexane air-oxidation products were fed with 9 parts of 50% nitric acidcontaining 0.05% ammonium vanadate and 0.15% dissolved copper into a tubular unit operated under 30 p. s. i. at such a rate that contact time in the first section which was maintained at 60 C. was about 1 minute while the contact time in the secondsection which was maintained at 100C. wasaboutQ minutes. Average yield in 14. such tests was 0.877 part .of adipic acid per part of organic teed.

In a similar series of reactions the same organics to nitric acid ratio and catalyst concentration were maintained but the nitric acid feed and organic feed were introduced into the 60 C. section at different points and the reaction mixture was recirculated in the 60C reaction at a rate which was 5-7 times greater than the total feed rate. Adipic acid yield was appreciably improved amounting to 0.929 part per part 01' organic feed.

\ The crude reaction mixture obtained from the second nitric acidoxidation stage contains appreciable quantities of nitric acid and it likewise contains along with. the adipic acid, monobasic acids in amounts ranging from 0.4 to about 1% based on the-crude reaction mixture. The monobasic acids contaminants must be removed if a pure acid is desired and various methods have been .tried torattaining this result. For example, the monobasic acids may be removed from the crude reaction mixture by subjecting it to steam distillation. By this method a clean separation is possible. Inasmuch as, however, there are appreciable quantities of nitric acid in the crude mixture appreciable amounts'of this acid are distilled over with the monobasic acid and are recovered only with diiiiculty from the dilute distillate. This method of purification is quite expensive and does not separate monobasic acids from all of the nitric acid.

It has been found that the nitric acid can be recovered without unconscionable losses if the crude reaction mixture is introduced into a mid section of a distillation column. The vapors resulting from boiling the tails from those portions 9 of the reaction mixture that descend the column are introduced into the bottom of the column and water is introduced into the top of the column. By operating in this manner only inappreciable amounts of nitric acid distill over with the monobasic acids. Moreover, adipic acid can be crystallized from the tails of the column free from substantial impurities of the monobasic acid and from the mother liquor the nitric acid can be easily recovered. Example 6 illustrates this feature of the invention.

Example 6.-360.5 parts of the same crude mixture were fed to the center of a distillling column which it descended countercurrent to 240 parts of its own tails vapor. Simultaneously 160 parts of distilled water were fed, to the top of the column. The distillate contained only 0.2% nitric acid and adipic acid crystallized from the tails contained only 0.07% monobasic organic acids calculated as valeric.

The example given below illustrates a preferred method of purifying the reaction mixture to recover adipic acid free from monobasic acids and to recover appreciable quantities of the nitric acid used.

Example 7.-When the nitric acid oxidation of cyclohexane oxidation products was carried out as described in Example 2 and the crude product was concentrated in a column with water reflux as described in Example 6, crude adipic acid, after dryin melted at 151.5-151.9 C. and had a purity of 98.9:0.4% in a large number of batches. Recrystallization from water gave refined acid which after drying melted at 151.9-152.1 C. and had a purity of 99.9i0.05%. Cf. Gi-lmans product, supra.

We claim:

1. In a process for the preparation of adipic acid by the oxidation of cyclohexane, the steps which comprise oxidizing cyclohexane with air at a temperature between 75 and 175 C. and under a pressure from 50 to 250 p. s. i. until from 0.75 to 1 mole of oxygen reacts per mole of cyclohexane attacked, separating the unoxidized cyclohexane from the reaction mixture and oxidizing the cyclohexane-free reaction mixture with nitric acid at a temperature between 50 and 150 C. and at a pressure of 15 to 500 p. s. 1.

2. In a process for the preparation of adipic acid by the oxidation of cyclohexane, the steps which. comprise oxidizing cyclohexane with air at a temperature between 50 and 175 C. and under a pressure between 50 and 500 p. s. 1. until from 0.5 to 2 moles of oxygen react per mole of cyclohexane attacked, separating the unoxidized cyclohexane from the reaction mixture and oxidizing the cyclohexane-free reaction. mixture with nitric acid at a temperature between 50 and 150 C. and at a pressure between and 500 p. s. i. to adipic acid.

3. In a process for the preparation of adipic acid by oxidation of cyclohexane, the steps which comprise oxidizing cyclohexane with air at a temperature between and 175 C. and under a pressure from 50 to 250 p. s. i. until from 0.5 to 2 moles of oxygen react per mole oi cyclohexane attacked, separating the unoxidized cyclohexane from the reaction mixture and oxidizing the cyclohexane-free reaction mixture to adipic acid with a nitric acid solution of 30 to strength based on volatile content and conducting the oxidation in this acid at a temperature between 50 and C. and at a pressure between 15 and 500 p. s. i.

CLEMENT H. HAMBLET.

AMBROSE McALEVY.

REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the file of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 1,921,101 Schrauth Aug. 8, 1933 1,960,211 Perkins et al. May 22, 1934 2,168,844 Nelles Aug. 8, 1939 2,193,562 McAllister Mar. 12, 1940 2,223,493 Loder Dec. 3, 1940 2,223,494 Loder Dec. 3, 1940 2,228,261 Ellingboe Jan. 14, 1941 2,285,601 McAllister June 9, 1942 2,285,914 Drossbach June 9, 1942 2,286,559 McAllister June 16, 1942 2,291,211 Cavanaugh July 28, 1942 2,343,534 Cavanaugh Mar; 7, 1944 2,386,372 Wagner Oct. 9,

Images