US20220364956A1

US20220364956A1 - Method and Apparatus for Steady State and Transient Generation of NO2 and NO for Use with Burner-Based Exhaust Replication Systems

Info

Publication number: US20220364956A1
Application number: US17/302,889
Authority: US
Inventors: Ryan C. Hartley; Robert T. Henderson; Cary A. Henry
Original assignee: Southwest Research Institute SwRI
Current assignee: Southwest Research Institute SwRI
Priority date: 2021-05-14
Filing date: 2021-05-14
Publication date: 2022-11-17

Abstract

This invention relates to exhaust replication systems and methods, such as systems for testing automotive exhaust aftertreatment devices. More particularly, methods for steady state and transient generation and flow of NO2 and/or NO from a fluid such as nitric acid for introduction into the burner-based exhaust replication system.

Description

FIELD

This invention relates to exhaust replication systems and methods, such as systems for testing automotive exhaust aftertreatment devices. More particularly, methods for steady state and transient generation and flow of NO₂and/or NO from a fluid such as nitric acid for introduction into the burner-based exhaust replication system.

BACKGROUND

In today's automotive vehicles, exhaust aftertreatment devices remove potentially harmful gases and particulates from the engines' exhaust. Examples of these are the catalytic converters common on gasoline vehicles as well as diesel oxidation catalysts, diesel particulate filters, and selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalysts.
The desire for reduced automotive emissions has led to the need for test systems that rapidly and cost effectively evaluate and age exhaust aftertreatment devices. This allows both performance and durability to be tested.
Conventionally, tests of exhaust aftertreatment devices have been conducted on engine test stands. However, burner-based systems are also used. An example of a burner-based system is the Exhaust Component Transient Operation Laboratory (ECTO-Lab™) developed by Southwest Research Institute.
To test the various exhaust aftertreatment devices in use for today's engine-driven vehicles, a burner-based test system must be capable of replicating the exhaust produced by the engines. Two pollutants of interest are NO (nitric oxide) and NO₂(nitrogen dioxide).
Methods and systems are therefore still needed to provide a source of NO and/or NO₂along with techniques to provide steady state and transient generation and flow of such compounds for introduction into the exhaust streams of exhaust replication systems.

SUMMARY

A burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system, comprising a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a decomposition reactor output line that splits into a first and second line and at least one of the first and second lines include a mass flow measurement device and at least one of the first and second lines include a flow regulating valve. At least one of the first and second lines is an open exhaust line and at least one of the lines is in communication with the burner-based exhaust test system. The system operates to alter the injection rate of NO₂into the burner-based exhaust test system.
A burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system comprising a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a NO₂accumulator operable to store generated NO₂wherein the accumulator includes first and second output lines. The first output line is in communication with a NO₂reduction reactor operable to produce NO for delivery into the burner-based exhaust test system. The second output line is in communication with the burner-based exhaust test system and the system operates to control the injection of NO₂and NO into the exhaust test system.
A method of using a burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system, comprising providing a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a decomposition reactor output line that splits into a first and second line and at least one of the first and second lines include a mass flow measurement device and at least one of the first and second lines include a flow regulating valve. At least one of the first and second lines is an open exhaust line and at least one of the lines is in communication with the burner-based exhaust test system. One may then inject NO₂into the burner-based exhaust test system at a selected injection rate.
A method of using a burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system comprising providing a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a NO₂accumulator operable to store generated NO₂wherein the accumulator includes first and second output lines and wherein the first output line is in communication with a NO₂reduction reactor operable to produce NO for delivery into the burner-based exhaust test system and the second output line is in communication with the burner-based exhaust test system. One may then inject NO₂and/or NO into the burner-based exhaust test system.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 illustrates a burner-based test system for testing automotive exhaust aftertreatment devices, having a NO₂generation system in accordance with the invention.

FIG. 2 illustrates a first embodiment of an NO₂generation system for producing NO₂in the exhaust stream of the test system of FIG. 1.

FIG. 3 illustrates a second embodiment of an NO₂generation system for producing NO₂in an exhaust stream of the test system of FIG. 1.

FIG. 4 illustrates a variation of the NO₂generation system of FIG. 3.

FIGS. 5 and 6 illustrate how the NO₂generation system of FIG. 4 may be used to control NO₂generation by varying the flow rates of N₂and HNO₃into the decomposition reactor.

FIG. 7 illustrates how the NO₂generation system of FIG. 4 may be used to control NO₂generation by varying the residence time of HNO₃in the decomposition reactor.

FIG. 8 illustrates the NO₂:NOx ratio produced by the NO₂generation system of FIG. 4 as a function of residence time within the decomposition reactor.

FIG. 9 illustrates a transient nitric acid decomposition system.

FIG. 10 illustrates the thermodynamic equilibrium curve of a mixture of NO and NO₂in the presence of 15% O₂.

FIG. 11 illustrates a configuration for NO and/or NO₂generation using nitric acid as the single precursor.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

The following description is directed to a method and apparatus for replicating automotive exhaust gas in a burner-based test system. The method produces NO₂(nitrogen dioxide), a gaseous air pollutant composed of nitrogen and oxygen and one of a group of related gases called nitrogen oxides, or NOx. The method provides for accurate generation and control of NO₂in a burner-based test system. This allows the test system to generate a desired NO₂:NOx ratio within its exhaust stream, where NOx is reference to the combined amount of NO and NO₂. Typically, the method is used to generate NO₂for testing automotive exhaust aftertreatment devices, but it could be used for any “exhaust replication system” in which NO₂is needed as a component to replicate engine exhaust.
For purposes of example, the NO₂production method is described in the context of use with a burner-based ECTO-Lab test system. As described in the Background, the ECTO-Lab test system is for aftertreatment testing, accommodating full-sized catalysts from light-duty gasoline engines to large, heavy-duty diesel and natural gas engines. It is a multi-fueled, burner-based system designed to replicate exhaust conditions generated by internal combustion engines. The ECTO-Lab system can simulate lean and stoichiometric exhaust gas conditions using gasoline, diesel, natural gas, or propane fuels. It meets testing requirements for a wide range of full-size aftertreatment catalysts and devices. However, the present invention may be used with any burner-based automotive test system that requires NO₂and/or NO in its exhaust stream.
FIG. 1 illustrates a burner-based test system suitable for use with the present invention. System 100 is designed to replicate engine exhaust in terms of temperature and flow rate. As described below, system 100 has a NO₂generation system 30, which is capable of providing a desired amount of NO₂into the exhaust stream.
As stated in the Background, an example of such a system is the ECTO-Lab™ system, developed by Southwest Research Institute. Exhaust gas conditions are preferably generated through computer control and allow various combinations of flow, temperature, exhaust component concentrations.
A burner 112 combusts a hydrocarbon fuel, such as gasoline or natural gas, thereby producing an exhaust stream. A wide range of air-fuel ratios may be combusted. A blower 111 is used to produce a desired air flow into burner 112.
A heat exchanger 113 allows the exhaust gas temperature delivered from system 100 to be controlled. A typical range of outlet temperatures for system 100 is 400 to 1200 degrees centigrade.
An exhaust line 119 delivers the exhaust to an exhaust after-treatment device 120 that is being tested. An oil injector allows oil to injected into the exhaust line 119. This feature of system 100 is significant for aging various aftertreatment devices. A secondary air injector allows an amount of fresh air to be injected into the exhaust line 119.
In the example of this description, device 120 is a selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalyst. SCR catalyst testing is of particular interest because of the need to achieve a desired NO₂:NOx ratio at the front face of the catalyst to simulate its use in a vehicle.
A controller 130 allows system 100 to implement programmable aging cycles. Parameters affecting the exhaust flow and content, such as exhaust temperature, flow rate, combustion air-fuel ratio, secondary air injection, and oil injection, may be varied. Although not shown in FIG. 1, system 100 has appropriate valves, injectors, and other mechanisms for achieving these controls. Input lines for oil injection and secondary air injection are shown in FIG. 1, although not necessarily used for purposes of NO₂generation.
Controller 130 may incorporate the various control features described below, or those features may be implemented with separate controllers.
Most systems 100 have a modular design, which allows components to be added to the base burner and heat exchanger. The system 100 can be modified as desired to simulate stoichiometric or lean-burn multi-fuel engines, as well as to replicate full transient exhaust traces.
FIG. 2 illustrates a first embodiment of an NO₂generation system for producing NO₂in an exhaust stream of test system 100. In this embodiment, NO₂is produced by combustion of burner 112.
A reservoir 21 contains a fluid that produces NO₂when that fluid combusts. Using meter 25, a desired amount of this fluid is metered into burner 112, where it combusts along with the “normal” burner fuel. The NO₂producing fluid may be injected directly into the combustion zone of the burner.
An example of an NO₂-producing fluid is nitric acid. Nitric acid (HNO₃) is known to decompose thermally or by light according to the equation 4HNO₃→2H₂O+4NO₂+O₂. The nitric acid may be used in an aqueous form to reduce any caustic effects on equipment and personnel.
The decomposition extent and products may require precise temperature and control, both of which can be integrated into a closed-loop control scheme of system 100.
FIG. 3 illustrates a second embodiment of an NO₂generation system 30 for producing NO₂in an exhaust stream of test system 100. In this method, NO₂is produced externally to system 100 and introduced into the exhaust stream of system 100, directly into exhaust line 119.
A reservoir 27 stores an NO₂-producing fluid, such as nitric acid. The NO₂-producing fluid is delivered to a decomposition reactor 28 where it is heated to a desired temperature for a desired length of time to produce NO₂. To increase the reaction rate, a decomposition catalyst, may be used within reactor 28. An inert surface area promoter, such as glass or ceramic raschig rings, may be additionally or alternatively used.
A controller 29 has a meter, such as a mass flow meter, to meter the flow of gaseous NO₂into the exhaust line 119 of system 100. The controller 29 may be installed on either side of reactor 28. Controller 29 also controls the temperature of the reactor 28. Control of the residence time of the NO₂-producing fluid within reactor 28 may be controlled by metering the flow rate into reactor 28 as described below.
The NO₂injection point may be anywhere downstream of burner 112 and upstream the aftertreatment device 120. Typically, the injection point will be a sufficient distance in front of device 120 to ensure mixing and therefore uniformity of NO₂within the exhaust mixture. If desired, the line 29 a carrying the NO₂to the exhaust line 119 may be heated.
FIG. 4 illustrates a variation of the NO₂generation system of FIG. 3. In system 400, HNO₃and nitrogen (N₂) are stored in respective reservoirs 41 and 42, respectively. The N₂is used as a carrier gas to help achieve steady and repeatable NO₂formation within decomposition reactor 45. Carrier gases other than nitrogen may be used, such as ambient air or carbon dioxide. Other suitable carrier gases are any non-radioactive noble gas, such as helium, neon, argon, krypton, and xenon.
Both fluids have an associated meter, such as a mass flow controllers (MFC) 41 a and 42 a, which meter the respective fluids to decomposition reactor 45. Reactor 45 comprises a heater and possibly a reduction catalyst and surface area promoter. As with system 30, a controller 49 controls the temperature of reactor 45. It also controls meters 41 a and 41 b to control the residence time of HNO₃and N₂within the reactor.
FIG. 5 illustrates how system 400 may be used to control NO₂generation by varying the flow rates of N₂and HNO₃into reactor 45. Using meters 41 a and 42 b, the individual flow rates may be varied. In example experimentation, the sum of the HNO₃and N₂flow rates were maintained at a constant value of 36.0 l/min, and the individual flow rates were varied. The decomposition reactor 45 was maintained at a temperature of 550° C. Under these conditions, all nitric acid is decomposed and the NO₂:NOx value was maintained between about 55-62%. Based on this the NO₂:NOx value may be tuned from about 5-62% by using nitromethane/nitroethane as the source of NO and HNO₃as the source of NO₂.
FIG. 6 illustrates how decomposition is affected by lower temperatures of decomposition reactor 45. In the example experiment of FIG. 6, the decomposition reactor 45 was reduced to a temperature of 400° C. As in FIG. 5, 20 a constant total flow of the sum of HNO₃and N₂was maintained at 36.0 l/min, and the HNO₃and N₂flow rates were individually varied. By reducing the temperature of the decomposition reactor 45, the NO₂:NOx ratio can be increased to a value of >95%. The NO₂and NO+NO₂plots overlap. At lower temperatures, the NO₂:NOx ratio has a larger controllable range into the exhaust stream.
FIG. 7 illustrates how decomposition is affected by the residence time of HNO₃within the decomposition reactor 45. In this example experiment, the flow rate of HNO₃was kept constant at 30.2 g/min and the N₂flow rate was progressively increased. The decomposition reactor 45 was maintained at 550° C. By increasing the N₂flow rate in such a manner, the residence time of HNO₃within the decomposition reactor 45 was progressively decreased and the effect on the NO₂:NOx was quantified.
FIG. 8 illustrates the NO₂:NOx ratio produced by the NO₂generation system of FIG. 4 as a function of residence time within decomposition reactor 45. From these data, it is apparent that an increase in residence time of HNO₃within decomposition reactor 45 results in a reduced NO₂:NOx ratio when the decomposition reactor was maintained at 550° C.
The above-described data demonstrate that an appropriate decomposition reactor temperature and HNO₃residence time can be selected if a high NO₂:NOx ratio is to be achieved while mitigating HNO₃breakthrough.
Decomposition of nitric acid to NO₂and its other products may reach completion (100% conversion) at temperatures as low as 200° C. and 1 atm. If nitric acid is given sufficient decomposition time, complete decomposition may be possible at temperatures as low as 120 degrees C.
Using the above-described methods, the test system is capable of achieving a desired NO₂:NOx ratio at the front face of an exhaust aftertreatment device, such as an SCR catalyst. No oxidation catalyst is needed.
It should next be noted that the system described herein is preferably suitable for steady-state operation, but transient or variable control would be even more preferable. This is believed to be due to the relatively substantial NOx rise time duration, which is measured from the start of HNO₃dosing until a relatively steady-state NOx has been achieved. To therefore preferably enhance transient or variable flow operation, the decomposition of HNO₃and injection into the exhaust stream for analysis is now preferably decoupled.
Reference is therefore initially made to FIG. 9. As can be seen, the illustrated apparatus or system 900 splits the outgoing flow from the decomposition reactor 910. As noted above, the decomposition reactor herein can produce NO₂from the decomposition of a fluid, such as nitric acid and stream such NO₂to an output line or conduit. Such decomposition reactor output line conduit then is split into a first and second line, where a mass flow meter (MFM) 920 is positioned on one of the split lines which simply exhausts. A valve 930 is then positioned on the second split line, such as the line that is in communication with the exhaust test system 940 to regulate NO₂flow. This arrangement may also be altered, wherein the MFM 920 is positioned at the location of the valve 930 and the valve is positioned at the location of the MFM 920.
Accordingly, this control scheme therefore uses mass flow meter (MFM) feedback to adjust the position of the valve 930 which in turn provides the ability to alter the injection rate of NO₂into the exhaust test system 940, or more particularly, to an exhaust stream output of the exhaust test system. As alluded to above, one may place the mass flow measurement (MFM) device on either one or both of the split lines or conduit emerging from the decomposition reactor and a flow regulating valve on either of the split lines which operates to control the injection rate of NO₂into the exhaust test system 940. Preferably, the injection rate of NO₂into the exhaust test system 940 may be in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute. In addition, as also illustrated in FIG. 9, one may introduce directly into the exhaust test system 940 nitromethane or nitroethane through a mass flow controller (MFC), which controls the flow rate of such compounds, which compounds can then combust in the exhaust test system 940 to provide a source of NO.
It is next noted herein that control of the NO₂:NOx ratio herein, has as noted relied upon the combustion of nitromethane/nitroethane. It is therefore now disclosed that both NO and NO₂can be produced by the decomposition of HNO₃, thereby eliminating the need for a separate source of NO. Reference is made to FIG. 10 which provides the thermodynamic equilibrium curve of a mixture of NO and NO₂in the presence of 15% 02. At temperatures of <250 degrees C. the mixture is comprised of over 95% NO₂while at temperatures >600 degrees C., the mixture is nearly all NO. Accordingly, by leveraging the thermodynamic equilibrium of NOx mixtures, a portion of the NO₂generated by HNO₃may now be reduced to NO.
Reference is made to FIG. 11 which illustrates a system configuration 1100 for the generation of both NO₂and NO utilizing a single precursor such as nitric acid. Nitric acid is metered into the decomposition reactor 1102 which is preferably set to a temperature of less than 600° C. to produce a gaseous mixture of NO₂, H₂O and O₂. The carrier gas, as illustrated, is preferably nitrogen. The NO₂so produced is then preferably stored in the NO₂accumulator 1104. From this point the output gas stream from the NO₂accumulator split and can follow one of two lines or pathways. First pathway 1106 introduces the gas stream containing the NO₂and O₂into the NO₂reduction reactor 1108 which is preferably at a temperature of 600° C. which temperature will preferably maximize the production and yield of NO. The NO so produced may then proceed to a NO accumulator 1110 which then may be metered into the exhaust test system. Second line or pathway 1108 allows for introduction of NO₂through a mass flow controller and into the exhaust test system. The described system therefore allows for the separate transient control of NO and NO₂and therefore the NO₂/NOx ratio within the exhaust test system exhaust stream while only relying upon a single NOx precursor. Preferably, one may therefor inject NO₂into the exhaust test system at a rate of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute and/or inject NO into the exhaust test system at a rate of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

Claims

What is claimed is:

1. A burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system, comprising:

a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a decomposition reactor output line that splits into a first and second line and at least one of the first and second lines include a mass flow measurement device and at least one of the first and second lines include a flow regulating valve;

wherein at least one of the first and second lines is an open exhaust line and at least one of the lines is in communication with the burner-based exhaust test system; and

wherein the system operates to alter the injection rate of NO₂into said burner-based exhaust test system.

2. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 1 wherein the fluid is nitric acid.

3. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 1 wherein the exhaust test system is in communication with a mass flow controller which mass flow controller is in communication with a source of nitromethane or nitroethane.

4. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 1 wherein an exhaust aftertreatment device is installed on the output exhaust line of said burner-based exhaust test system and wherein the generated NO₂is introduced into said exhaust aftertreatment device.

5. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 1 wherein the injection rate of NO₂is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

6. A burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system comprising:

a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a NO₂accumulator operable to store generated NO₂wherein said accumulator includes first and second output lines;

where said first output line is in communication with a NO₂reduction reactor operable to produce NO for delivery into said exhaust test system;

wherein said second output line is in communication with said burner-based exhaust test system; and

wherein the system operates to control the injection of NO₂and NO into said burner-based exhaust test system.

7. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 6 wherein the fluid is nitric acid.

8. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 6 wherein an exhaust aftertreatment device is installed on the output exhaust line of said burner-based exhaust test system and wherein the generated NO₂and NO is introduced into said exhaust aftertreatment device.

9. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 6 wherein the injection rate of NO₂into said burner-based exhaust test system is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

10. The burner-based exhaust test system of claim 6 wherein the injection rate of NO into said burner-based exhaust test system is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

11. A method of using a burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system, comprising:

providing a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a decomposition reactor output line that splits into a first and second line and at least one of the first and second lines include a mass flow measurement device and at least one of the first and second lines include a flow regulating valve;

injecting NO₂into said burner-based exhaust test system at a selected injection rate.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein the fluid is nitric acid.

13. The method of claim 11 wherein the burner-based exhaust test system is in communication with a mass flow controller which mass flow controller is in communication with a source of nitromethane or nitroethane.

14. The method of claim 11 wherein an exhaust aftertreatment device is installed on the output exhaust line of said burner-based exhaust test system and wherein the generated NO₂is introduced into said exhaust aftertreatment device.

15. The method of claim 11 wherein the injection rate of NO₂is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

16. A method of using a burner-based exhaust test system having an exhaust line that carries an exhaust as an output of the test system comprising:

providing a decomposition reactor operable to receive a fluid that decomposes to generate NO₂including a NO₂accumulator operable to store generated NO₂wherein said accumulator includes first and second output lines and wherein said first output line is in communication with a NO₂reduction reactor operable to produce NO for delivery into said burner-based exhaust test system and said second output line is in communication with said burner-based exhaust test system; and

injecting NO₂and/or NO into said burner-based exhaust test system.

17. The method of claim 16 wherein the fluid is nitric acid.

18. The method of claim 16 wherein the burner-based exhaust test system is in communication with a mass flow controller which mass flow controller is in communication with a source of nitromethane or nitroethane.

19. The method of claim 16 wherein an exhaust aftertreatment device is installed on the output exhaust line of said burner-based exhaust test system and wherein the generated NO₂is introduced into said exhaust aftertreatment device.

20. The method of claim 16 wherein the injection rate of NO₂is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.

21. The method of claim 16 wherein the injection rate of NO is in the range of 0.1 liters/minute to 40.0 liters/minute.