SG195497A1 - Pilot wire differential protection apparatus for multi-end circuit based on phase comparison principle - Google Patents

Pilot wire differential protection apparatus for multi-end circuit based on phase comparison principle Download PDF

Info

Publication number
SG195497A1
SG195497A1 SG2013039243A SG2013039243A SG195497A1 SG 195497 A1 SG195497 A1 SG 195497A1 SG 2013039243 A SG2013039243 A SG 2013039243A SG 2013039243 A SG2013039243 A SG 2013039243A SG 195497 A1 SG195497 A1 SG 195497A1
Authority
SG
Singapore
Prior art keywords
translay
phase
relay
pilot wire
relays
Prior art date
Application number
SG2013039243A
Inventor
Liu Jiankai
Yu Zhemin
Original Assignee
Schneider Electric Ind Sas
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Schneider Electric Ind Sas filed Critical Schneider Electric Ind Sas
Publication of SG195497A1 publication Critical patent/SG195497A1/en

Links

Classifications

    • HELECTRICITY
    • H02GENERATION; CONVERSION OR DISTRIBUTION OF ELECTRIC POWER
    • H02HEMERGENCY PROTECTIVE CIRCUIT ARRANGEMENTS
    • H02H3/00Emergency protective circuit arrangements for automatic disconnection directly responsive to an undesired change from normal electric working condition with or without subsequent reconnection ; integrated protection
    • H02H3/26Emergency protective circuit arrangements for automatic disconnection directly responsive to an undesired change from normal electric working condition with or without subsequent reconnection ; integrated protection responsive to difference between voltages or between currents; responsive to phase angle between voltages or between currents
    • H02H3/28Emergency protective circuit arrangements for automatic disconnection directly responsive to an undesired change from normal electric working condition with or without subsequent reconnection ; integrated protection responsive to difference between voltages or between currents; responsive to phase angle between voltages or between currents involving comparison of the voltage or current values at two spaced portions of a single system, e.g. at opposite ends of one line, at input and output of apparatus
    • H02H3/30Emergency protective circuit arrangements for automatic disconnection directly responsive to an undesired change from normal electric working condition with or without subsequent reconnection ; integrated protection responsive to difference between voltages or between currents; responsive to phase angle between voltages or between currents involving comparison of the voltage or current values at two spaced portions of a single system, e.g. at opposite ends of one line, at input and output of apparatus using pilot wires or other signalling channel
    • H02H3/302Emergency protective circuit arrangements for automatic disconnection directly responsive to an undesired change from normal electric working condition with or without subsequent reconnection ; integrated protection responsive to difference between voltages or between currents; responsive to phase angle between voltages or between currents involving comparison of the voltage or current values at two spaced portions of a single system, e.g. at opposite ends of one line, at input and output of apparatus using pilot wires or other signalling channel involving phase comparison
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H02GENERATION; CONVERSION OR DISTRIBUTION OF ELECTRIC POWER
    • H02HEMERGENCY PROTECTIVE CIRCUIT ARRANGEMENTS
    • H02H1/00Details of emergency protective circuit arrangements
    • H02H1/0061Details of emergency protective circuit arrangements concerning transmission of signals
    • H02H1/0084Details of emergency protective circuit arrangements concerning transmission of signals by means of pilot wires or a telephone network; watching of these wires

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Power Engineering (AREA)
  • Emergency Protection Circuit Devices (AREA)
  • Testing Of Short-Circuits, Discontinuities, Leakage, Or Incorrect Line Connections (AREA)

Abstract

A pilot wire differential protection apparatus and method for a power transmission and distribution lines including three or more connecting ends. The apparatus comprises: three or more TRANSLAY relays, which are sequentially connected at the corresponding connecting ends of the power transmission and distribution lines, respectively. Summation transformers of the respective relays are connected to an a phase, a b phase, a c phase and a neutral point at the connecting ends of the corresponding protected circuits, and a pilot wire first connecting terminal and a pilot wire second connecting terminal of the respective relays (are connected with each other in parallel, respectively. Respective phase comparators compare corresponding phases of U1 and t111 so as to obtain a phase difference, U1 is a voltage at a secondary winding side of the relay of the phase comparator, Ull is a voltage at a auxiliary transformer side of the relay of the phase comparator. A false state in the lines is judgedaccording to the phase difference Arg--.± . At each of the connecting ends, a pilots padding Ullresistor Rpp of the relay is adjusted so that Rpp + Rw = k * R0 is satisfied, k is a setconstant, Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire, and Ro is a linear impedance of the TRANSLAY relay. When To<Tr or To>Tr, a value of k satisfies a condition of— n* k —1 <—I < —(i1* k + n)* T0 I Tr + n —1 or a condition of FIGURE: FIG 5

Description

PILOT WIRE DIFFERENTIAL PROTECTION APPARATUS FOR MULTI-END CIRCUIT
BASED ON PHASE COMPARISON PRINCIPLE
TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention relates to a protection apparatus and method for power transmission and distribution lines in a middle/short distance. In particularly, the present invention relates to a pilot wire differential protection apparatus and method for multi-end circuit based on a phase comparison principle.
BACKGROUND
[0002] As a protection apparatus for power transmission and distribution lines in the middle/short distance, a TRANSLAY relay manufactured, for example, by General Electric
Company (GEC) in UK or similar products manufactured by other companies may be utilized to form the pilot wire differential protection apparatus. The TRANSLAY relay utilizes a phase comparator to form a judgment element and thus has excellent properties.
[0003] Fig.l is a view illustrating main structure of the TRANSLAY relay. Respective elements in the Fig.1 are: a summation transformer Tj, a secondary winding Tt, a secondary winding Ts, an auxiliary transformer Ty, an operating winding To, a restraining winding Tr, a non-linear resistor RVD, a linear impedance Ro, a pilots padding resistor Rpp, a phase comparator @. la, Ib, Ic and In are currents in an a phase, a b phase, a ¢ phase and a neutral point of a protected circuit end, respectively. Px and Py are two terminals connecting with the pilot wires.
[0004] The summation transformer Ty is used for transforming three-phase currents into a single-phase summated current. The secondary winding Tt is used for providing one phase comparison voltage. The secondary winding Ts is used for outputting the single-phase summated current at the secondary side of the summation transformer Ty. An output circuit of the auxiliary transformer Ty is used for providing the other phase comparison voltage. The operating winding To is used for providing an operation current of protection. The restraining winding Tr is used for providing a restraining current of protection. A difference between the operating current and the restraining current is a protection start current. The non-linear resistor RVD is used for voltage stabilization. The linear impedance Ro is a linear impedance on a single-phase summated current loop at the secondary side. The pilots padding resistor
Rpp is used for matching a total resistor in a pilot wire loop to a set value, and an aim of the matching is to perform adjustment so as to remain the total resistor unchanged, since the total resistor on the pilot wire must be fixed and preset according to a TRANSLAY pilot wire protection principle. The phase comparator @ is used for comparing phases of two voltages and judging an in-zone/out-zone fault based on the phase difference between the two comparison voltages, wherein the phase comparator is an analogous phase comparator or a digital phase comparator. A protecting mechanism will be triggered when the start current is greater than a set threshold value and it is judged as the in-zone fault by the phase comparator.
[0005] However, both a wiring manner and an action equation of a current pilot wire longitudinal differential protection apparatus composed of the TRANSLAY relays are based on a protection for the two-end circuit and therefore can only be applied to protect the two-end circuit. Unfortunately, no protection apparatus or method based on the TRANSLAY relays is proposed for the multi-end circuit in the lines of the power transmission and distribution.
[10006] In view of the above disadvantages in the prior art, the present invention proposes a pilot wire differential phase-compared apparatus and method being applicable to the multi-end circuit, which may extend a usage range of the TRANSLAY relay.
SUMMARY
[6007] An object of the present invention is to make up the disadvantages existed in the current pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus and method for the power transmission and distribution lines based on the TRANSLAY relay and to provide a pilot wire differential phase-compared apparatus and method for the power transmission and distribution lines based on the TRANSLAY relay, which may be applied to the multi-end circuit.
[0008] According to an aspect of the present invention, there is provided a pilot wire differential protection apparatus for a power transmission and distribution lines including three or more connecting ends, comprising:
[0009] three or more TRANSILAY relays, which are sequentially connected at the corresponding connecting ends of the power transmission and distribution lines, respectively,
[0010] wherein summation transformers of the respective TRANSLAY relays are connected to an a phase, a b phase, a ¢ phase and a neutral point at the connecting ends of the corresponding protected circuits, and a pilot wire first connecting terminal and a pilot wire second connecting terminal of the respective TRANSLAY relays are connected with each other in parallel, respectively,
[0011] wherein the TRANSLAY relays comprise corresponding phase comparators, respectively, for comparing corresponding phases of U) and Uy, in the respective TRANSLAY relays so as to obtain a corresponding phase difference Arg 2 , wherein Uj is a voltage at i one side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a secondary winding side of the relay,
Up 1s a voltage of the other side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a auxiliary transformer side of the relay, and a false state of the power transmission and distribution lines 1s judged according to the corresponding phase differences Arg = ,
I
[0012] wherein, at each of the connecting ends, a pilots padding resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay is adjusted so that Rpp+ Rw=Fk* R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant, Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire, and Ro is a linear impedance of the TRANSLAY relay,
[0013] wherein a value of k satisfies a condition of ~nFk-l<-l<—~(n*k+n)*7T,/Tr+n—-1 when To<Ty, or the value of k satisfies a condition of —(n*k+n)*7T /Tr+n-1<-1<-n*k-1 when To>Tr, To is number of turns of an operating winding in the TRANSLAY relay and Tr is number of turns of a restraining winding in the TRANSLAY relay.
[0014] It is judged that a system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in an in-zone fault state and the pilot wire differential protection apparatus is triggered to perform protection, when at least one of the phase differences in the phase comparators of the respective TRANSLAY relays does not satisfy 90° Arg >-90° and a start current of . i the relay is greater than a set threshold value.
[0015] It is judged that the system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in a normal operation state or an out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Uy and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays satisfy 90° = Arg 2 ~90°. il 10016] The phase comparator is an analogous phase comparator or a digital phase comparator,
[0017] According to another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for a pilot wire differential protection apparatus, comprising steps of:
[0018] measuring phases of corresponding U; and Up of respective TRANSLAY relays, wherein Uy is a voltage at one side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a secondary winding side of the relay, and Uy is a voltage of the other side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a auxiliary transformer side of the relay;
[0019] comparing, by corresponding phase comparators in the TRANSLAY relays, the phases of Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays so as to obtain a corresponding or u, phase difference Arg —L ; and
Uy
[0020] judging a false state of the power transmission and distribution lines according » : oo U, to the corresponding phase differences Arg 5 , i"
[0021] wherein, at each of the connecting ends, a pilots padding resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay is adjusted so that Rpp+ Rw=k* R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant, Rw is a resistor on the pilot wire, and Ro is a linear impedance of the
TRANSLAY relay,
[0022] wherein a value of k satisfies a condition of ~a*k-l<-l<—-(m*k+n)*T,/Tr+n~1 when To<Tr, or the value of k satisfies a conditionof —(n*k+n)*1,/Tr+n-1<~1<~-n*k~1 when To>Tr, To is number of turns of an operating winding in the TRANSLAY relay and Tr is number of turns of a restraining winding in the TRANSLAY relay.
[0023] It 1s judged that a system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in an in-zone fault state and the pilot wire differential protection apparatus is triggered to perform protection, when at least one of the phase differences in the phase comparators of the respective TRANSLAY relays does not satisfy 90° = Arg 2 >-90° and a start current of
It the relay is greater than a set threshold value.
[0024] It is judged that the system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in a normal operation state or an out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays satisfy 90° > Arg or = 90°, 1
[0025] The phase comparator is an analogous phase comparator or a digital phase comparator.
[0026] The pilot wire differential phase-compared apparatus and method of the present invention which are applicable to the multi-end circuit extend a usage range of the
TRANSLAY relay.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0027] The present invention will become more fully understood from the detailed description of the exemplary embodiments given hereinafter in connection with accompanying drawings. It should be understood that the described embodiments are given by way of illustration and example only, and the present invention is not limited thereto. The spirit and scope of the present invention are defined by contents stated in the accompanying claims attached. Below is a brief description for the drawings and wherein:
[0028] Fig 1 is a diagram illustrating a main structure of the TRANSLAY relay;
[0029] Fig 2 is an exemplary view illustrating a wiring in a pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to a three-end circuit according to a first embodiment of the present invention;
[0030] Fig 3 is an equivalent circuit diagram for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the three-end circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention; {0031} Fig 4 is a motion trajectory of a differential protection for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the three-end circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention; 10032] Fig 5 is an exemplary view illustrating a wiring in a pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to a multi-end circuit according (0 a second embodiment of the present invention;
[0033] Fig 6 is an equivalent circuit diagram for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the multi-end circuit according to the second embodiment of the present invention,
[0034] Fig 7 is a motion frajectory of a differential protection for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the multi-end circuit according to the second embodiment of the present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0035] The pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus and method according to the present invention will be explained now with reference to the accompany drawings.
[0036] Fig 2 is an exemplary view illustrating a wiring in a pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to a three-end circuit according to a first embodiment of the present invention.
[6037] Three sets of TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3 are connected at the end 1, end 2, end 3 of the power transmission and distribution lines, respectively, summation transformers Ty of the respective TRANSLAY relays Relay], Relay2, Relay3 are connected to an a phase, a b phase, a ¢ phase and a neutral point at the protected circuit end, and pilot wire connecting terminals Px and Py of the respective TRANSLAY relays Relay], Relay2, Relay3 are connected with each other at nodes j1 and j2 in parallel, respectively.
[0638] In the above connection, configurations of each set of the TRANSLAY relays at the end 1, end 2, end 3 should be same completely. That is, all of other elements and parameters in the relays illustrated in Fig 1 are the same without considering errors, other than the Rpp. The connections and configurations at the three ends are same, therefore the three ends are symmetrical completely.
[0039] Thus an equivalent circuit diagram for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the three-end circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention shown in Fig 2 may be illustrated as Fig 3. Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire in Fig 3.
[0040] At each of the ends, a resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay is adjusted so that Rpp + Rw =Fk*R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant.
[0041] According to the structure of the TRANSLAY relay, by making the protection at the relay Relayl end as an example, currents flowing through the To, Tr and Ro of the
Relayl may be calculated as follows, respectively, from Fig 3: [I ((3-1)*L ~(L +L, )A3*k+3) and ((3*k+1)%1,+(I,+1,))/(3%¥k +3), wherein I,
I, and I, are current flowing through the To of the Relay], current flowing through the To of the Relay? and current flowing through the To of the Relay3, respectively.
[0042] According to a design principle of the TRANSLAY relay, voltages at the windings Tt and Ts are in-phase, and voltage on the Ro is approximatively same as that on the
Ts, therefore a voltage at the Tt side of the phase comparator satisfies an equation (1), wherein Kj is a calculation constant.
[0043] U=K ¥(@*k +) 1, +, +L (1) 10044] A voltage at the Ty side of the phase comparator is decided by two primary windings To and Tr and satisfies an equation (2), wherein Kj; is a calculation constant.
[0045] U mK, ¥ (BF +3)*T Tr =3+0) 1 + (1, +1) (2) : + CL
[0046] Given p, == which is a current ratio between the sum of current 1 vectors in remote ends and the current in local end, then: ’ So (=F Ff —
[0047] 00° > Argobwe prgePZE3TEZN gee 3)
U, OL —(—G*k+3)*T, / Tr +3-1)
[0048] Assuming a value of k selected suitably, that is, the value of k satisfies a condition of -3%k—-1<-1<—-3*k+3)*T/Tr+3-1 when To<Tr, or the value of k satisfies a condition of ~(3*k+3)*T,/Tr+3~1<~1<~3*k~1 when To>Tr, a region corresponding to the current ratio between the sum of current vectors in remote ends and the current in local end in the equation (3) is circular on a complex plane. Fig 4 is a motion frajectory of a differential protection for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the three-end circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention. hd
[0049] When the system operates normally or has an out-zone fault, p, = 5 is 1 -1 under ideal conditions, therefore a portion inside the circle corresponding to the py is a restraining zone or stable zone.
[0050] Further, when the system has an in-zone fault, a portion outside the circle corresponding to the p; is an operating zone.
[0051] Thus the in-zone fault and the out-zone fault may be judged by comparing the phases of Uy and Uy.
[0052] In particularly, in an actual application, when 90° > Arg2t 290°, the
H system operates normally or is in the out-zone fault state; if 90°> Arg ct -90° is not il satisfied and a start current of the relay is greater than a set threshold value, the system is in the in-zone fault state.
[0053] That is, it is judged whether the 90°> Arg tx 90° is satisfied if fault
H occurs in the system: it is the in-zone fault if the 90°2 Arg =-90° is not satisfied and
IF the start current of the relay is greater than the set threshold value; and it is the out-zone fault ifthe 90°2 Arg > ~90° is satisfied. 11
[0054] Above descriptions are made by taking the relay Relayl end as an example, and the phase differences between the U; and Uy in the Relay? and Relay3 also can be used fo make judgment. The phase differences between the Uy and Uy in the respective
TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3 are independent of each other.
[0055] It is also obviously that, when the system operates normally or has the out-zone fault, p, = Lith , Py = hth ceerens hth are -1 under the ideal
I I, I, conditions, therefore portions inside the circles corresponding to the respective p are the restraining zones or stable zones. Further, when the system has the in-zone fault, portions outside the circles corresponding to the respective p are the operating zones.
[0056] It is judged that the system is in an in-zone fault state, when at least one of the phase differences between the Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relay1, Relay2,
Relay3 does not satisfy 90° = Argh —-60° and the start current of the relay is greater
It than the set threshold value,
[0057] It is judged that the system is in a normal operation state or an out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Uj and Uy; in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3 satisfy 90° = Arg > 90°. 1}
[0058] When the system is in the in-zone fault state, the pilot wire differential protection apparatus for the three-end power transmission and distribution lines is triggered to perform the protection.
[0059] Fig 5 is an exemplary view illustrating a wiring in a pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to a multi-end circuit according to a second embodiment of the present invention.
[0060] In Fig 5, a plurality of sets of TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2,
Relay3, ......, Relayn are connected at the end 1, end 2, ......, end n of the power transmission and distribution lines, respectively, the summation transformers Ty of the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn are connected to an a phase, a b phase, a ¢ phase and a neutral point at the protected circuit end, and pilot wire connecting terminals Px and Py of the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2,
Relay3, ......, Relayn are connected with each other in parallel, respectively.
[0061] In the above connection, configurations of each set of the TRANSLAY relays atthe end 1, end 2, ......, end n should be same completely. That is, all of other elements and parameters in the relays illustrated in Fig I are the same without considering errors, other than the Rpp. The connections and configurations at the plurality of ends are same, therefore the plurality of ends are symmetrical completely.
[0062] Thus an equivalent circuit diagram for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the multi-end circuit according to the second embodiment of the present invention shown in Fig 5 may be illustrated as Fig 6. Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire in Fig 6.
[0063] At each of the ends, a resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay is adjusted so that Rpp+ Rw=Fk* R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant, and the values of k in each of the TRANSLAY relays are identical.
[0064] According to the structure of the TRANSLAY relay, by making the protection at the relay Relayl end as an example, currents flowing through the To, Tr and Ro of the
Relayl may be calculated as follows, respectively, from Fig 6: [ ((n=D*I ~ (I, ++ I) ¥k+n)and ((n*k+10)*1 +, +... +1 0W(n*k+n).
[06065] According to the design principle of the TRANSLAY relay, voltages at the windings Tt and Ts are in-phase, and voltage on the Ro is approximatively same as that on the
Ts, therefore a voltage at the Tt side of the phase comparator satisfies an equation (4), wherein K; is a calculation constant.
[0066] UsK 5((n*k+)*1 + (I, +..+1)) (4)
[0067] A voltage at the Ty side of the phase comparator is decided by two primary windings To and Tr and satisfies an equation (5), wherein Ky, is a calculation constant.
[0068] U,=K, ¥((n¥k+m)*T, [Tr =a) *L + (I, +41) (5)
Lad CL :
[0069] Given pg, = —5 which is a current ratio between the sum of current i vectors in remote ends and the current in local end, then:
U yy = (=n ke ~1
[0070] 00° > Arg DL = arg PL =CNK=D ge (5
Uy, p= (r¥k+m)*T, [Tr +n ~1)
[0071] Assuming a value of k selected suitably, that is, the value of k satisfies a condition of —n*k~1l<-1<-(a*k+n)*T,/Tr+n~1 when To<Tr, or the value of k satisfies a condition of —(n*k+m)*T, /Tr+n-1<-1<-n*k-1 when To>Tr, a region corresponding to the current ratio between the sum of current vectors in remote ends and the current in local end in the equation (6) is circular on a complex plane, as illustrated in Fig 7.
[0072] Fig 7 is a motion trajectory of a differential protection for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the three-end circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention,
[0073] When the system operates normally or has an out-zone fault,
Led, CL p= Tr is -1 under ideal conditions, therefore a portion inside the circle 1 corresponding to the py is a restraining zone or stable zone.
[0074] Further, when the system has an im-zone fault, a portion outside the circle corresponding to the py is an operating zone.
[0075] Thus the in-zone fault and the out-zone fault may be judged by comparing the phases of Uy and Uy. 10076] In particularly, in an actual application, when 90°> Arg ot 290°, the 11 system operates normally or is in the out-zone fault state; if 90°2 Arg 72 -90° 1s not
H satisfied and a start current of the relay is greater than a set threshold value, the system is in the in-zone fault state. i
[0077] That is, it is judged whether the 90° Arg <b> 90° is satisfied if fault 1 occurs in the system: it is the in-zone fault if the 90°32 Arg >-90° 1s not satisfied and i the start current of the relay is greater than the set threshold value; and it is the out-zone fault if the 90° > Arg == z-90° is satisfied.
II
[0078] Above descriptions are made by taking the relay Relayl end as an example, and the phase differences between the Uj and Uy in the Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn also can be used to make judgment. The phase differences between the U; and Uy; in the respective
TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn are independent of each other.
[0079] It is also obviously that, when the system operates normally or has the
AE [ot Lt Load out-zone fault, pH atetd, . Shedd, ves Py hth are -1
I 1, I, under the ideal conditions, therefore portions inside the circles corresponding to the respective p are the restraining zones or stable zones. Further, when the system has the in-zone fault, portions outside the circles corresponding to the respective p are the operating zones.
[0080] It is judged that the system is in the in-zone fault state, when at least one of the phase differences between the Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2,
Relay3, ......, Relayn does not satisfy 90° > rg 2 >-90° and the start current of the relay ji 1s greater than the set threshold value.
[0081] It is judged that the system is in the normal operation state or the out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Up and Uy in the respective
TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn satisfy 90° > argc >-90°,
Ii
[0082] When the system is in the in-zone fault state, the pilot wire differential protection apparatus for the three-end power transmission and distribution lines is triggered to perform the protection.
[0083] Thereafter will describe a method for the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus according to the first embodiment and the second embodiment of the present invention. 10084] The pilot wire differential phase-compared protection method according to the present invention is applied to the above power transmission and distribution lines having three-end or multi-end connection. Following description is made by taking the pilot wire differential phase-compared protection apparatus applied to the multi-end circuit according to the second embodiment of the present invention as an example.
[0085] At step 1, measuring the phases of the voltage Uy at the Tt side of the phase comparator and the voltage Uy at the Ty side of the phase comparator in the respective
TRANSIAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn;
[0086] at step 2, comparing the phases of Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn so as to obtain the respective phase differences arg JL ;
Uy
[0087] at step 3, judging whether the phase differences between the U; and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn satisfy 90° > Arg Uy = -90°.
Uy,
[0088] It is judged that the system operates normally or is in the out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Up and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays
Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn satisfy 90°> Arg = ~90°,
I
[0089] It 1s judged that the system is in the in-zone fault state, when at least one of the phase differences between the U; and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays Relayl, Relay2,
Relay3, ......, Relayn does not satisfy 90° > Arg > -90° and the start current of the relay n is greater than the set threshold value.
[0090] At step 4, the pilot wire differential protection apparatus for the multi-end power transmission and distribution lines is triggered to perform protection when the system is in the in-zone fault state. 10091] The pilot wire differential phase-compared apparatus and method of the present invention which are applied to the multi-end circuit can judge the in-zone fault and out-zone fault in the multi-end circuit efficiently, extends an application range of the
TRANSLAY protection apparatus and enhance a market value of the TRANSLAY protection apparatus. 10092] Although the exemplary embodiments considered in the invention has been illustrated and described, those skilled in the art may understand that many changes and amendments may be made or some elements may be replaced with other equivalences without departing from the real scope of the invention, with developments in the technique.

Claims (8)

WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:
1. A pilot wire differential protection apparatus for a power transmission and distribution lines including three or more connecting ends, comprising: three or more TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn), which are sequentially connected at the corresponding connecting ends (end 1, end 2, ......,end n) of the power transmission and distribution lines, respectively, wherein summation transformers of the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) are connected to an a phase, a b phase, a ¢ phase and a neutral point at the connecting ends of the corresponding protected circuits, and a pilot wire first connecting terminal and a pilot wire second connecting terminal of the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) are connected with each other in parallel, respectively, wherein the TRANSLAY relays comprise corresponding phase comparators, respectively, for comparing corresponding phases of U; and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) so as to obtain a corresponding phase difference Argh, wherein Uj is a voltage at one side of the phase comparator, that 1s, a voltage at a If secondary winding side of the relay, Uy is a voltage of the other side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a auxiliary transformer side of the relay, and a false state of the power transmission and distribution lines is judged according to the corresponding phase differences Arg JL , Uy wherein, at cach of the connecting ends, a pilots padding resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay is adjusted so that Rpp + Rw=k* R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant, Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire, and Ro is a linear impedance of the TRANSLAY relay, wherein a value of k satisfies a condition of ~n*k—~l<~l<—(n*k+m*7T,/Tr+n-1 when To<Tr, or the value of k satisfies a condition of i5
—(n*hk+n)*T Tr +n—-1<~1<-n*k-1 when To>Tr, To is number of turns of an operating winding in the TRANSLAY relay and Tr is number of turns of a restraining winding in the TRANSLAY relay.
2. The pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 1, wherein, it is judged that a system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in an in-zone fault state and the pilot wire differential protection apparatus is triggered to perform protection, when at least one of the phase differences in the phase comparators of the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay?, Relay3, ......, Relayn) does not satisfy 90° = Arg or > -90° and a start current of the relay is greater than a set threshold value. iI
3. The pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 1, wherein, it is judged that the system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in a normal operation state or an out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Uj and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) satisfy U 90° 2 Arg == -90°. Uy
4. The pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 1, wherein, the phase comparator is an analogous phase comparator or a digital phase comparator.
5. A method for a pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 1, comprising steps of: measuring phases of corresponding Uy and Uy of respective TRANSLAY relays (Relay, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn), wherein Uj is a voltage at one side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a secondary winding side of the relay, and Uy is a voltage of the other side of the phase comparator, that is, a voltage at a auxiliary transformer side of the relay; comparing, by corresponding phase comparators in the TRANSLAY relays, the phases of
Uy and Uy in the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) so as to obtain a corresponding phase difference Arg ; and I judging a false state of the power transmission and distribution lines according to the U, corresponding phase differences Arg = , i wherein, at each of the connecting ends, a pilots padding resistor Rpp of the respective TRANSLAY relay 1s adjusted so that Rpp + Rw=Fk™* R, is satisfied at each of the ends, k is a set constant, Rw is a resistance on the pilot wire, and Ro is a linear impedance of the TRANSLAY relay, wherein a value of k satisfies a condition of ~n*k~1<-1<—(n*¥k+m*1,/Tr+n-1 when To<Tr, or the value of k satisfies a condition of -n*k+my*T,/Tr+n—1<-1<-n*k-1 when To>Tr, To is number of turns of an operating winding in the TRANSLAY relay and Tr is number of turns of a restraining winding in the TRANSLAY relay.
6. The method for the pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 5, wherein, it is judged that a system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in an in-zone fault state and the pilot wire differential protection apparatus is triggered to perform protection, when at least one of the phase differences in the phase comparators of the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) does not satisfy 90° > Arg > 90° and a start current of the relay is greater than a set threshold value. H
7. The method for the pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 5, wherein, it is judged that the system of the power transmission and distribution lines is in a normal operation state or an out-zone fault state when all of the phase differences between the Uj and Up in the respective TRANSLAY relays (Relayl, Relay2, Relay3, ......, Relayn) satisfy
U 90° = Arg —1 2 -90°. Uy
8. The method for the pilot wire differential protection apparatus of claim 5, wherein, the phase comparator is an analogous phase comparator or a digital phase comparator.
SG2013039243A 2012-06-06 2013-05-21 Pilot wire differential protection apparatus for multi-end circuit based on phase comparison principle SG195497A1 (en)

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201210184733.6A CN103474971B (en) 2012-06-06 2012-06-06 Based on the multi-point circuit guide wire differential protection than facies principle

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
SG195497A1 true SG195497A1 (en) 2013-12-30

Family

ID=48805646

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
SG2013039243A SG195497A1 (en) 2012-06-06 2013-05-21 Pilot wire differential protection apparatus for multi-end circuit based on phase comparison principle

Country Status (4)

Country Link
CN (1) CN103474971B (en)
GB (1) GB2504594B (en)
MY (1) MY172416A (en)
SG (1) SG195497A1 (en)

Family Cites Families (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
GB2098417B (en) * 1981-05-09 1984-10-24 Northern Eng Ind Pilot wire line protection systems
CN100350707C (en) * 2004-12-02 2007-11-21 浙江大学 Split-phase zero-sequence fault component braking method for preventing malfunction for transformer protection
CN100375357C (en) * 2005-10-26 2008-03-12 许继集团有限公司 Double end testing method in power transmission line longitudinal difference protection
EP2502318B1 (en) * 2009-11-17 2013-09-11 Alstom Technology Ltd. Fuzzy interference relay and method for current differential protection of a transmission line

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
GB201309864D0 (en) 2013-07-17
MY172416A (en) 2019-11-25
CN103474971A (en) 2013-12-25
GB2504594A (en) 2014-02-05
GB2504594B (en) 2016-04-06
CN103474971B (en) 2016-03-23

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US10739414B2 (en) Determining status of electric power transmission lines in an electric power transmission system
CN104297627B (en) For controlling and protecting the method and system of direct current subsea power system
US7535686B2 (en) Control of circuit breakers in a multi-phase power system
US6888709B2 (en) Electromagnetic transient voltage surge suppression system
US20150171615A1 (en) Breaker circuit configurations for multi-terminal DC systems
Jovcic et al. Topology assessment for 3+ 3 terminal offshore DC grid considering DC fault management
CN108780989B (en) Improvements in or relating to electrical power systems
SG195497A1 (en) Pilot wire differential protection apparatus for multi-end circuit based on phase comparison principle
JP2009198442A (en) Voltage abnormality detection device and voltage protection relay device
US20130262003A1 (en) Current measurement and comparing assembly for a power distribution system and method for measuring and comparing current
US8891219B2 (en) Open neutral protection
EP3893345A1 (en) Differential protection scheme
US1779724A (en) Electric protective arrangement for a. c. power circuits
Valbuena et al. Loss of Coordination in a Protection Scheme due to DG assessed by means of Reliability Analysis
CN108603901B (en) Current measuring device protected against surge voltage when circuit is open
JP6729483B2 (en) Ratio differential relay
CN116114132B (en) Power distribution device
Ed Zientek Loading considerations when paralleling transformers
US8837095B2 (en) DC electrical power system
RU2529684C2 (en) Method of selective protection from earth-faults in electrical network with small earth-fault currents
Putri et al. Study Coordination Design of Over Current Relay on The Kiln Area Electrical System
JP4836663B2 (en) Loop system protection device and method
JP2009027825A (en) Protective relay device
US1339394A (en) Protection of electric distribution systems
CN110140270A (en) Inductance element protection in power-supply system