JP6675092B2 - Judgment system, judgment method, and judgment program - Google Patents

Description

The present invention relates generally to the determination system, determination method, and relates to the determination program. More specifically, the determination system that utilizes consumption information regarding the consumption of resources in customer facilities, relates to the determination method, and determining program.

  2. Description of the Related Art Conventionally, a display system has been proposed in which usage data indicating the power usage of a customer house (customer facility) is displayed on an indoor display device in the customer facility (see Patent Document 1).

  The display system described in Patent Literature 1 is configured to display data on the amount of power consumption (power consumption) transmitted from a power meter on an indoor display device such as a personal computer or a tablet terminal. Here, Patent Literature 1 describes that power consumption is measured for each household electric appliance such as an air conditioner, an electric water heater, and a microwave oven, and is displayed on an indoor display device. In addition, Patent Document 1 describes displaying a change in power consumption on an indoor display device. In other words, the indoor display device is a display device that displays the usage status of power in a customer facility in a real-time manner so as to be able to be grasped in detail, and stimulates the customer's awareness of power saving.

JP 2014-130015 A

  However, in the display system as described above, the consumption information relating to the consumption amount of the resource (electric power) in the customer facility is displayed on the display device only for the purpose of improving the power saving awareness, and the consumption information is used more effectively. It is desired.

The present invention has been made in view of the circumstances described above, the consumption information regarding the consumption of resources in customer facilities, and to provide a more efficient use can be determined systems, determination method and determination program.

A determination system according to one aspect of the present invention includes an information acquisition unit, a determination unit, a notification unit, an evaluation acquisition unit, and a control unit. The information acquisition unit is configured to acquire consumption information regarding a resource consumption amount in a customer facility. The determination unit is configured to determine an operation state of a target device in the customer facility based on the consumption information. The notification unit is a determination result of the determination unit, a request for evaluation of the determination result, a first option for evaluating that the determination result is correct, and that the determination result is incorrect It is configured to notify a request including a second option for evaluation . The evaluation obtaining unit is configured to obtain an evaluation result for the request. The control unit, based on the evaluation result, the same request as the request when the determination result is at least one of a correct answer and an incorrect answer, so as to control the notification unit so as not to be notified from the notification unit It is configured.

A determination method according to an aspect of the present invention includes a process of acquiring consumption information regarding a resource consumption amount in a customer facility, and a process of determining an operation state of a target device in the customer facility based on the consumption information. A determination result of the operation status, and a request for evaluation of the determination result, wherein a first option for evaluating that the determination result is correct and a second option for evaluating that the determination result is incorrect. A process of notifying a request including two options, a process of acquiring an evaluation result for the request, and the request when the determination result is at least one of a correct answer and an incorrect answer based on the evaluation result. And causing the computer to operate so that the same request is not notified .

  A determination program according to an aspect of the present invention causes the computer to execute the determination method.

  ADVANTAGE OF THE INVENTION According to this invention, the consumption information regarding the resource consumption in a customer facility can be utilized more effectively.

FIG. 1 is a configuration diagram illustrating an overall configuration of a determination system according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 2 is a configuration diagram of a terminal device used in the above determination system. FIG. 3A is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of the determination information displayed on the display unit of the terminal device. FIG. 3B is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of the questionnaire information displayed on the display unit of the terminal device.

  Hereinafter, a determination system 100 according to an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to FIGS. 1 to 3B.

  The determination system 100 is a system that determines the operation status of the target device 50 in the customer facility (facility) H1. The customer facility H1 means a facility of a customer who uses resources such as electric power, for example. However, the customer facility H1 includes not only a facility that receives power supply from an electric power company such as a power company but also a facility that receives power supply from a private power generation facility such as a solar power generation facility. The operation status of the target device 50 means an operation of the target device 50, for example, whether or not the target device 50 is operating (operating). In addition, the customer includes a person who uses the customer facility H1, and when the customer facility H1 is a detached house, means a resident of the customer facility H1. When there are a plurality of residents of the customer facility H1, the customer facility H1 may refer to one of the residents, or may refer to two or more (including all of the residents). The resources are not limited to electric power, but also include gas, water, heat, and the like consumed in the customer facility H1. Hereinafter, a case where the resource is electric power will be described as an example. Hereinafter, a detached house will be described as an example of the customer facility H1. In the following, for convenience of explanation, the customer of the customer facility H1 may be referred to as a resident of the customer facility H1.

  The target devices 50 are various devices installed in the customer facility H1. For example, the target device 50 is an electric device such as a lighting fixture, an air conditioner (air conditioner), a washing machine, a dishwasher, a cooking home appliance, or the like. That is, the target device 50 means a device that consumes resources (electric power) in the customer facility H1.

  As shown in FIG. 1, the determination system 100 includes an information acquisition unit 1, a determination unit 2, a notification unit 3, an evaluation acquisition unit 4, a recording unit 5, and a control unit 6. In the present embodiment, the determination system 100 is realized by the server device 10. That is, the server device 10 includes the information acquisition unit 1, the determination unit 2, the notification unit 3, the evaluation acquisition unit 4, the recording unit 5, and the control unit 6. The server device 10 is connected to a terminal device 20 described later via a network N1. The network N1 is, for example, the Internet. The server device 10 mainly has a computer having a CPU (Central Processing Unit) and a memory. The CPU executes a program stored in the memory, thereby causing the computer to function as the control unit 6. In the present embodiment, the program is recorded in the memory of the computer in advance, but may be provided through an electric communication line such as the Internet, or may be recorded in a recording medium such as a memory card and provided.

  The information acquisition unit 1 is configured to acquire consumption information relating to the consumption of resources (electric power) in the customer facility H1. In the present embodiment, the information acquisition unit 1 acquires consumption information from the measuring device 30 installed in the customer facility H1.

  The measuring device 30 is connected to the server device 10 via a network N1. The measuring device 30 has a function of measuring the amount of resource consumption in the customer facility H1 and transmitting consumption information on the amount of consumption to the server device 10. The measuring device 30 measures at least one of the power consumption and the power consumption of the target device 50 as the consumption. For example, the measuring device 30 measures at least one of the power consumption and the power consumption as the consumption for each of the plurality of branch circuits in the customer facility H1.

  More specifically, the measuring device 30 includes, for example, a plurality of current sensors. In the measuring device 30, the plurality of current sensors are provided for the plurality of branch breakers of the distribution board in the customer facility H1, and the target device 50 is determined based on the values (current values) of the currents flowing in the plurality of branch circuits. At least one of the power consumption and the power consumption is measured as the power consumption. Here, a plurality of branch circuits means a plurality of circuits branched from a trunk line by a plurality of branch breakers. Each branch circuit includes a wiring connected to each branch breaker, a device such as a lighting fixture or a cooking home appliance, an outlet (outlet), a wall switch, and the like. Note that the consumption may be power consumption representing instantaneous power, or power consumption representing power consumption (usage) in a certain period of time. Hereinafter, as an example, a case will be described in which the power consumption is the power consumption obtained by integrating the power consumption for a certain period of time (for example, one minute).

  The determination unit 2 is configured to determine the operation status of the target device 50 based on the consumption information acquired by the information acquisition unit 1. For example, the determination unit 2 determines the operation status of the target device 50 according to a predetermined algorithm. The operation status of the target device 50 that can be determined by the determination unit 2 includes various items. In the present embodiment, the operation status of the target device 50 that the determination unit 2 determines is whether the target device 50 is operating. Alternatively, operations such as start and end of the operation of the target device 50 will be exemplified.

  The determining unit 2 determines that the target device 50 is operating if the power consumption of the target device 50 is equal to or greater than a predetermined threshold. On the other hand, if the power consumption of the target device 50 is less than the predetermined threshold, the determination unit 2 determines that the target device 50 is stopped. When the power consumption of the target device 50 increases from substantially zero to a predetermined threshold or more, the determination unit 2 determines that the target device 50 has started operation. On the other hand, when the power consumption of the target device 50 decreases from a predetermined threshold value or more to substantially zero, the determination unit 2 determines that the target device 50 has finished operating. In the present embodiment, since the measuring device 30 measures the power consumption as the consumption for each of the plurality of branch circuits in the customer facility H1, the determination unit 2 determines the consumption information acquired by the information acquisition unit 1. The operation state of the target device 50 is estimated based on (power consumption).

  The notifying unit 3 is connected to a later-described receiving unit 7 (see FIG. 2) of the terminal device 20 via the network N1. The notification unit 3 is configured to notify the terminal device 20 of the determination result of the determination unit 2 and a request for evaluation (evaluation request) for the determination result. In the present embodiment, when the operation state of the target device 50 is determined by the determination unit 2, the notification unit 3 notifies the terminal device 20 of the determination result of the determination unit 2 and the evaluation request. In the present embodiment, the notification unit 3 simultaneously notifies the determination result and the evaluation request.

  The determination result is, for example, information that notifies the end of the operation of the target device 50 such as a washing machine. For example, the judgment result is text information “washing seems to be completed”. The evaluation request is, for example, a questionnaire in which the resident of the customer facility H1 evaluates the determination result of the determination unit 2, and the determination of the operation status of the target device 50 (for example, the end of the operation of the washing machine) is correct. It is information for having the resident judge whether or not. For example, the evaluation request is text information of “correct answer” and “wrong”.

  In the server device 10, the determining unit 2 determines the operation status of the target device 50 based on the consumption information acquired by the information acquiring unit 1. It can be used more effectively than the described display system.

  Here, in the server device 10, the notification unit 3 does not need to notify the terminal device 20 of all of the operation statuses of the target device 50, and therefore the determination unit 2 needs to notify the operation status of the target device 50. It is configured to determine only a specific operation situation. For example, the determination unit 2 determines that a specific operation situation has occurred when the target device 50 has finished operating.

  The evaluation acquisition unit 4 is connected to a later-described transmission unit 11 (see FIG. 2) of the terminal device 20 via the network N1. The evaluation obtaining unit 4 is configured to obtain the evaluation result transmitted from the transmitting unit 11. The evaluation obtaining unit 4 is configured to output the obtained evaluation result to the recording unit 5.

  The recording unit 5 is configured to record the evaluation result obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4. Further, the recording unit 5 is configured to output the evaluation result obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 to the control unit 6. Information on the target device 50 is recorded (registered) in the recording unit 5. Information on the target device 50 is registered in the recording unit 5 by a resident of the customer facility H1. The number of devices registered as the target device 50 may be one or more. Of course, a plurality of devices of the same type may be registered as the target device 50, or a plurality of devices of different types may be registered as the target device 50.

  The control unit 6 generates, based on the determination result of the determination unit 2, determination information G1 (see FIG. 3A) including text information associated with the determination result (for example, text information indicating that “washing is completed”). It is configured as follows. That is, in the present embodiment, the information displayed on the display unit 8 (see FIG. 2) of the terminal device 20 described later is generated by the server device 10. The control unit 6 is configured to notify the generated determination information G1 from the notification unit 3 to the terminal device 20 as a determination result of the determination unit 2. Thereby, the notification unit 3 can notify the terminal device 20 of the determination result of the determination unit 2. Here, the determination information G1 is information based on the determination result of the determination unit 2, and means a message to be notified to a resident of the customer facility H1.

  In addition, based on the determination result of the determination unit 2, the control unit 6 transmits questionnaire information G2 (for example, text information of “correct answer” and “wrong”) associated with the determination result, as shown in FIG. 3B. ) Is generated. The control unit 6 is configured to notify the generated questionnaire information G2 from the notification unit 3 to the terminal device 20 as an evaluation request. Thereby, the notification unit 3 can notify the terminal device 20 of the evaluation request.

  In the present embodiment, as shown in FIG. 3B, the evaluation request (questionnaire information G2) includes a first option A1 for evaluating that the determination result is correct, and a first option A1 for evaluating that the determination result is incorrect. The second option A2 is included. The first option A1 includes, for example, text information “1. Correct answer”. The second option A2 includes, for example, text information “3. The owner of the terminal device 20 (for example, a resident of the customer facility H1) confirms that the operation of the washing machine has ended and the washing machine is in a stopped state, for example, and then displays “washing is completed” on the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20. It appears that the process is finished ", the first option A1 is selected. On the other hand, even though the owner of the terminal device 20 does not use the washing machine (for example, does not wash), information indicating “washing is completed” is displayed on the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20. In this case, the second option A2 is selected. Here, the terminal device 20 may be inside the customer facility H1 or outside the customer facility H1. That is, the resident of the customer facility H1 may be inside the customer facility H1 or outside the customer facility H1.

  As shown in FIG. 3B, the evaluation request further includes a third option A3 for evaluating that the determination result is unknown. The third option A3 includes, for example, text information “4. Unknown”. Here, "the determination result is unknown" means that the determination result of the determination unit 2 is neither a correct answer nor an incorrect answer, and means, for example, a case where the resident of the customer facility H1 cannot determine (does not understand). . In other words, the owner of the terminal device 20, for example, when the operation of the washing machine has been completed and it is not possible to confirm that the washing machine is in the stopped state, the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20 states "washing is completed". When the information is displayed, the third option A3 is selected.

  Further, as shown in FIG. 3B, the evaluation request further includes an evaluation option (fourth option) A4 for the notification timing of the notification unit 3. The fourth option A4 includes, for example, text information “2. Timing is late”. The owner of the terminal device 20 displays, for example, on the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20 after a predetermined time (for example, 30 minutes) has elapsed after confirming that the operation of the washing machine has been completed and the washing machine has been stopped. When the information that "the laundry seems to be finished" is displayed, the fourth option A4 is selected.

  The control unit 6 is configured to control the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result from the recording unit 5. In the present embodiment, when the evaluation result indicating that the determination result is incorrect is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4, the control unit 6 determines the same as the determination result when the evaluation result is determined to be incorrect and the evaluation request. The notification unit 3 is controlled so that the result and the request are not notified from the notification unit 3. That is, when the evaluation result from the terminal device 20 is incorrect after the notification unit 3 notifies the determination result of the determination unit 2 from the notification unit 3, when the determination unit 2 performs the same determination again, The same determination result is not notified from the notification unit 3 to the terminal device 20. In short, if the determination result of the determination unit 2 is incorrect, the control unit 6 controls the notification unit 3 so as not to notify the determination result from the notification unit 3 from the next time. Accordingly, in the determination system 100, even when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination (determination result) once again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again. It is possible to suppress erroneous notification of the operation status. As a result, in the determination system 100, the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 can be improved, and the reliability of the system can be improved.

  When the evaluation result indicating that the determination result is correct is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4, the control unit 6 notifies the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request as the evaluation request when the evaluation result is determined to be correct. The notification unit 3 is controlled so as not to be performed. In other words, when the control unit 6 notifies the determination result of the determination unit 2 and the evaluation request from the notification unit 3 and the evaluation result from the terminal device 20 is correct, the determination unit 2 performs the same determination again. Then, the same evaluation request is not notified from the notification unit 3 to the terminal device 20. In short, if the determination result of the determination unit 2 is correct, the control unit 6 controls the notification unit 3 so that the notification unit 3 notifies only the determination result from the next time. Thus, in the determination system 100, when the determination unit 2 makes a once correct determination (determination result) again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request. For example, the resident of the customer facility H1 Requesting a response to the same questionnaire. As a result, in the determination system 100, it is easier for the resident to answer the questionnaire than in the case where the same questionnaire answer is requested many times.

  The determination method according to the present embodiment includes: a process of acquiring consumption information; a process of determining an operation state of the target device 50; a process of notifying a determination result and an evaluation request; a process of acquiring an evaluation result; And causing the computer to perform the process of operating based on the. Such a determination method is realized by the CPU executing a program stored in the memory in the server device 10 (that is, the determination system 100) mainly including a computer as in the present embodiment.

  The above-described determination system 100 can be embodied not only by the above-described determination method but also by the following determination program. Even when the determination system 100 is embodied by the following means, the above-described various configurations and modified examples described below can be appropriately combined and applied.

  The determination program according to the present embodiment is a program for causing a computer to execute the above-described determination method. For example, the computer of the server device 10 can implement the determination system 100 by executing the above-described determination program.

  Next, the terminal device 20 will be described with reference to FIG.

  The terminal device 20 is used for the determination system 100. The terminal device 20 is connected to the server device 10 via a network N1. The terminal device 20 is configured to display the determination result and the evaluation request from the server device 10 on the display unit 8.

  The terminal device 20 is, for example, a smartphone including a touch panel display. The terminal device 20 includes a receiving unit 7, a display unit 8, an input unit 9, a transmitting unit 11, and a control unit 12. The terminal device 20 mainly includes a computer having a CPU and a memory, and the CPU executes a program stored in the memory to cause the computer to function as the control unit 12. In the present embodiment, the program is provided through a telecommunication line such as the Internet. That is, the terminal device 20 realizes the function as the control unit 12 by installing dedicated software (application software) and activating the application software. The program is provided through an electric communication line such as the Internet, but may be provided by being recorded on a recording medium such as a memory card, or may be recorded in a memory of a computer in advance.

  The receiving unit 7 is connected to the notification unit 3 of the server device 10 via the network N1. The receiving unit 7 is configured to receive the determination result and the evaluation request from the notification unit 3. The display unit 8 is configured to display the determination result and the evaluation request received by the receiving unit 7. The input unit 9 is configured to receive an operation of the owner of the terminal device 20 (in this embodiment, a resident of the customer facility H1). The input unit 9 is configured to accept an input of an evaluation result by a resident of the customer facility H1 in response to the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. In the present embodiment, the display unit 8 and the input unit 9 constitute a touch panel display.

  Here, the trigger by which the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request is, for example, a push notification from the server device 10, but is not limited thereto, and may be, for example, an operation on the input unit 9 of the terminal device 20. . It is desirable that the push notification from the server device 10 be switchable between on (valid) and off (invalid) in the terminal device 20.

  The transmission unit 11 is connected to the evaluation acquisition unit 4 of the server device 10 via the network N1. The transmission unit 11 is configured to transmit the evaluation result input by the input unit 9 to the evaluation acquisition unit 4. In the present embodiment, since the terminal device 20 is a smartphone, the transmission unit 11 and the reception unit 7 are connected to the network N1 via a mobile phone network (carrier network) provided by a communication carrier. The mobile phone network is, for example, a 3G (third generation) line or an LTE (Long Term Evolution) line. Note that the transmission unit 11 and the reception unit 7 may be connected to the network N1 via a wireless LAN (Local Area Network).

  The control unit 12 is configured to control the receiving unit 7, the display unit 8, the input unit 9, and the transmitting unit 11. When the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request, the control unit 12 causes the display unit 8 to display the determination result and the evaluation request. In the present embodiment, when the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request, the control unit 12 first causes the display unit 8 to display the determination information G1 as shown in FIG. 3A. Next, when a predetermined operation (for example, a tap operation) is input to the input unit 9 in a state where the determination information G1 is displayed on the screen of the display unit 8, as shown in FIG. G2 is displayed on the screen of the display unit 8. That is, the display unit 8 displays the operation status of the target device 50 (for example, a message indicating that “washing seems to be completed”), and after the predetermined operation is input to the input unit 9, A questionnaire for having the resident of the customer facility H1 evaluate the determination result is displayed.

  The controller 12 responds to the questionnaire information G2 displayed on the display unit 8 when the resident of the customer facility H1 inputs the evaluation result through the input unit 9 (that is, one of the plurality of options A1 to A4). Is selected), the transmission unit 11 transmits the evaluation result to the server device 10.

  The terminal device 20 as described above can notify the resident of the customer facility H1 that is the owner of the terminal device 20 of the operation status of the target device 50 in the customer facility H1. Therefore, the resident of the customer facility H1 can visually confirm the operation status of the target device 50 in the customer facility H1 by looking at the information (the determination information G1) displayed on the display unit 8. In addition, the terminal device 20 can have the resident of the customer facility H1 evaluate the determination result of the determination unit 2 (can request a response to a questionnaire). Therefore, the resident of the customer facility H1 evaluates the determination result with respect to the information (questionnaire information G2) displayed on the display unit 8, and the server device 10 determines that the determination result of the determination unit 2 is correct. Can be determined. Thereby, in the server device 10, it is possible to prevent the erroneous determination result from being notified from the notification unit 3 again, and to prevent the determination unit 2 from once making an erroneous determination.

  The control method according to the present embodiment is used for the terminal device 20. This control method includes a process of causing the receiving unit 7 to receive the determination result and the evaluation request from the notification unit 3 and a process of causing the display unit 8 to display the determination result and the evaluation request. The control method described above includes, for example, a process of receiving an input of an evaluation result by a resident of the customer facility H1 and a process of causing the transmission unit 11 to transmit the evaluation result to the evaluation acquisition unit 4. Such a control method is realized by the CPU executing a program stored in the memory in the terminal device 20 mainly including a computer as in the present embodiment.

  The above-described terminal device 20 can be embodied not only by the above-described control method but also by the following control program. Even when the terminal device 20 is embodied by the following means, the above-described various configurations and modified examples described below can be appropriately combined and applied.

  The control program according to the present embodiment is a program for causing a computer to execute the above control method. The computer of the terminal device 20 functions as the control unit 12 by executing the above-described control program, and can display the determination result and the evaluation request on the display unit 8, and the evaluation input by the input unit 9. The result can be transmitted from the transmission unit 11.

  Hereinafter, operations of the server device 10 and the terminal device 20 will be described with reference to FIGS. 1 to 3B.

  When the information acquisition unit 1 acquires the consumption information from the measuring device 30, the determination unit 2 of the server device 10 determines the operation status of the target device 50 based on the consumption information. The control unit 6 causes the notification unit 3 to notify the terminal device 20 of the determination result of the determination unit 2 and the evaluation request.

  When the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request from the server device 10, the control unit 12 of the terminal device 20 causes the display unit 8 to display the determination result and the evaluation request. When the resident of the customer facility H1 inputs the evaluation result with the input unit 9 in response to the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8, the control unit 12 transmits the evaluation result from the transmission unit 11 to the server device 10. Let it.

  When the evaluation result from the terminal device 20 is acquired by the evaluation acquisition unit 4, the control unit 6 of the server device 10 controls at least one of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result. Thereby, in the server device 10, it is possible to prevent the erroneous determination result from being notified from the notification unit 3 again, and to prevent the determination unit 2 from once making an erroneous determination. In other words, in the determination system 100, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50.

  Incidentally, it is preferable that the evaluation request (questionnaire information G2) includes information related to the customer facility H1. The information related to the customer facility H1 means, for example, information (value-added information) useful for residents of the customer facility H1, that is, so-called useful information. The information related to the customer facility H1 is, for example, weather information. The weather information is information regarding any one of past, present, and future weather in the area of the customer facility H1. In the present embodiment, the weather information is appropriately acquired by the server device 10 from a server (for example, a weather server) that provides information such as a weather forecast. Information related to the customer facility H1 may be displayed together with the questionnaire information G2 when the questionnaire information G2 is displayed on the screen of the display unit 8, or the resident may evaluate the evaluation result (response to the questionnaire). May be displayed on the screen of the display unit 8. Thereby, the server device 10 can provide not only the questionnaire information G2 but also useful information to the resident of the customer facility H1. It will be easier for you to go.

  The above-described determination system 100 is merely an example of the present invention, and the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and a range other than the above-described embodiment does not depart from the technical idea of the present invention. Then, various changes can be made according to the design and the like. Hereinafter, modified examples of the present embodiment will be listed.

  If the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is incorrect is continuously obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 a predetermined number of times (for example, three times), the control unit 6 transmits a part of the determination result and the evaluation request to the notification unit. 3 may be configured to control the notification unit 3 so as not to be notified. However, some determination results and evaluation requests that are not notified from the notification unit 3 are the same determination results and evaluation requests as when the evaluation result is incorrect for a predetermined number of consecutive times. . Even in this case, in the determination system 100, when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again. False notification can be suppressed.

  In this case, in the determination system 100, for example, an evaluation result in the case where a resident of the customer facility H1 owning the terminal device 20 erroneously evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8 is transmitted to the control unit 6. It can be prevented from being used. Therefore, in the determination system 100, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50, as compared to the case where the determination result is incorrect based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is incorrect. The reliability of this system can be further improved.

  The control unit 6 does not notify the evaluation unit 4 of some evaluation requests when the evaluation obtaining unit 4 continuously obtains the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is correct for a predetermined number of times (for example, three times). May be configured to control the notification unit 3 as described above. However, some of the evaluation requests to be prevented from being notified from the notification unit 3 are the same evaluation requests as the evaluation requests when the correct answer is evaluated a predetermined number of times in succession. Even in this case, in the determination system 100, when the determination unit 2 makes a correct determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request. Requesting the same questionnaire answer can be suppressed.

  Also in this case, in the determination system 100, for example, the evaluation result obtained when the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8 is used for the control unit 6. Can be prevented. Therefore, in the determination system 100, the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 can be improved as compared with the case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is correct. The reliability of the system can be further improved.

  If the frequency at which the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is incorrect is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 is equal to or greater than a specified value, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of some determination results and evaluation requests. May be configured to control the notification unit 3 as described above. However, some judgment results and evaluation requests that are not notified from the notification unit 3 are the same as the judgment results and evaluation requests when they are evaluated as incorrect at a frequency equal to or higher than the specified value. is there. The frequency at which the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is incorrect is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 means, for example, a ratio of the number of times that the evaluation result is incorrect among a predetermined number of evaluation results. For example, when the number of times the evaluation result is incorrect is eight out of ten times, the control unit 6 notifies the determination result and the evaluation request when the evaluation result is incorrect eight times from the notification unit 3. The notification unit 3 is controlled so as not to be performed.

  Even in this case, in the determination system 100, when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again. False notification can be suppressed. Also in this case, in the determination system 100, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with the case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result that the determination result is incorrect. And the reliability of this system can be further improved. Further, in this case, in the determination system 100, even when the evaluation result is not incorrect for a predetermined number of consecutive times, the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. The evaluation result in the case can be prevented from being used by the control unit 6. The case where the evaluation result is not incorrect for a predetermined number of consecutive times means, for example, the case where the result is incorrect, correct, or incorrect.

  When the frequency at which the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is correct is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 is equal to or greater than a prescribed value, the control unit 6 controls the notification unit 3 so that some of the evaluation requests are not notified from the notification unit 3. 3 may be configured to be controlled. However, some of the evaluation requests to be prevented from being notified from the notification unit 3 are the same evaluation requests as those when the correct answer is evaluated at a frequency equal to or higher than the specified value. The frequency at which the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is correct is obtained by the evaluation obtaining unit 4 means, for example, a ratio of the number of times that the evaluation result is correct among a predetermined number of evaluation results. For example, when the number of times that the evaluation result is correct is eight out of ten, the control unit 6 notifies the notification unit 3 of notifying the evaluation request when the evaluation result is evaluated eight times as being correct. 3 is controlled.

  Even in this case, in the determination system 100, when the determination unit 2 makes a correct determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request. Requesting the same questionnaire answer can be suppressed. Further, in this case, the determination system 100 can improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with a case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is correct. Thus, the reliability of the system can be improved. Further, in this case, in the determination system 100, even when the evaluation result is not correct for the predetermined number of consecutive times, the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. Can be prevented from being used by the control unit 6. The case where the evaluation result is not correct for a predetermined number of consecutive times means, for example, the case where the result is correct, incorrect, or correct.

  The evaluation acquisition unit 4 may be configured to acquire attribute information related to the determination result of the determination unit 2. The attribute information is, for example, the time (determination time) when the determination unit 2 determines the operation status of the target device 50. That is, the determination unit 2 is configured to add the determination time as attribute information to the determination result when determining the operation status of the target device 50. In this case, the control unit 6 controls at least one of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result and the attribute information. For example, when the determination time of the end of the operation of the washing machine is night and the evaluation result is incorrect, the control unit 6 again determines that the determination time of the end of the operation of the washing machine is a night time zone (for example, 21:00), the notifying unit 3 is controlled so that the notifying unit 3 does not notify the judgment result of the judgment time and the evaluation request. Accordingly, in the determination system 100, in addition to the evaluation result from the terminal device 20, the operation state of the target device 50 can be determined using the attribute information related to the determination result. The determination accuracy can be further improved.

  Further, the evaluation acquisition unit 4 acquires attribute information (second attribute information) related to the evaluation result from the terminal device 20 in addition to the attribute information (first attribute information) related to the determination result of the determination unit 2. May be configured. The second attribute information is, for example, ID information added to the terminal device 20 or the like. The ID information is information that can identify the owner of the terminal device 20. Furthermore, the evaluation acquisition unit 4 may be configured to acquire both the first attribute information and the second attribute information. That is, the evaluation acquisition unit 4 may be configured to acquire attribute information related to at least one of the determination result of the determination unit 2 and the evaluation result from the terminal device 20.

  As described above, the determination system 100 of the present embodiment includes the information acquisition unit 1 that acquires consumption information on the amount of resource consumption in the customer facility H1 and the target device 50 in the customer facility H1 based on the consumption information. A determination unit for determining an operation state; In addition, the determination system 100 includes a notification unit 3 that notifies a determination result of the determination unit 2 and a request for evaluation of the determination result, an evaluation acquisition unit 4 that obtains an evaluation result for the request, and a determination unit based on the evaluation result. 2 and a control unit 6 for controlling at least one of the notification unit 3.

  According to this configuration, the operation status of the target device 50 is determined based on the consumption information acquired by the information acquisition unit 1, so that the consumption information on the resource consumption in the customer facility H1 can be more effectively utilized. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to prevent the erroneous determination result from being notified from the notification unit 3 again, and to prevent the determination unit 2 from once making an erroneous determination, and to determine the accuracy of the operation status of the target device 50. Can be improved.

  As described above, the request includes the first option A1 for evaluating the determination result as being correct and the second option A2 for evaluating that the determination result is incorrect. Is preferred.

  According to this configuration, for example, when the resident of the customer facility H1 owning the terminal device 20 evaluates the determination result, a plurality of options (the first option A1 and the second option) displayed on the screen of the display unit 8 are evaluated. It is only necessary to select one option out of A2). Therefore, the resident can easily evaluate the determination result.

  It is preferable that the request further includes the third option A3 for evaluating that the determination result is unknown, as described above.

  According to this configuration, when the control unit 6 stops the control of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 when the evaluation result is unknown, the control unit 6 determines the evaluation result when there is no corresponding option and the resident appropriately evaluates. Use can be prevented. Thereby, the control unit 6 can suppress erroneous control of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3. However, this configuration is not an essential configuration of the determination system 100, and can be omitted as appropriate.

  Preferably, the request further includes an option (fourth option) A4 for evaluating the notification timing of the notification unit 3 as described above.

  According to this configuration, the control unit 6 can determine whether the notification timing from the notification unit 3 is late. Thereby, the control unit 6 can correct the timing of the notification from the notification unit 3.

  As described above, when the evaluation result that the determination result is incorrect is acquired, the control unit 6 notifies the same determination result and request as the determination result and the request when the evaluation result is incorrect. It is preferable to control the notification unit 3 so as not to be notified from the unit 3.

  According to this configuration, even when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again. It is possible to suppress erroneous notification of the operation status of the target device 50. Therefore, with this configuration, it is possible to further improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50, and it is possible to improve the reliability of the determination system 100.

  The control unit 6, when the evaluation result indicating that the same determination result is incorrect is continuously obtained a predetermined number of times, is the same as the determination result and the request when the evaluation result is incorrect for the predetermined number of times consecutively It is preferable to control the notification unit 3 so that the determination result and the request are not notified from the notification unit 3.

  Even with this configuration, when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again, so that the operation status of the target device 50 is erroneously determined. Notification can be suppressed. Further, according to this configuration, the evaluation result when the resident of the customer facility H1 owning the terminal device 20 erroneously evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8 is used for the control unit 6. Can be prevented. Therefore, with this configuration, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with the case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is incorrect. Thus, the reliability of the determination system 100 can be further improved.

  When the frequency at which the evaluation result is determined to be incorrect for the same determination result is equal to or higher than a specified value, the control unit 6 determines the determination result and the request when the evaluation result is determined to be incorrect at a frequency equal to or higher than the specified value. It is preferable to control the notification unit 3 so that the same determination result and request are not notified from the notification unit 3.

  Even with this configuration, when the determination unit 2 makes an erroneous determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the erroneous determination result from the notification unit 3 again, so that the operation status of the target device 50 is erroneously determined. Notification can be suppressed. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to improve the accuracy of the determination of the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with the case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is incorrect. Thus, the reliability of the determination system 100 can be further improved. Furthermore, according to this configuration, even when the evaluation result is not incorrect for a predetermined number of consecutive times, the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. Can be prevented from being used by the control unit 6.

  As described above, when the evaluation result that the determination result is the correct answer is obtained, the control unit 6 notifies the notification unit 3 that the same request as the request when the evaluation result is the correct answer is not sent from the notification unit 3. It is preferable to control the part 3.

  According to this configuration, when the determination unit 2 makes a once correct determination (determination result) again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request, so that the resident of the customer facility H1 is notified. Requesting the same questionnaire answer can be suppressed. As a result, in the determination system 100, it is easier for the resident to answer the questionnaire than in the case where the same questionnaire answer is requested many times.

  When the evaluation result that the correct answer is obtained for the same determination result is obtained continuously for a predetermined number of times, the control unit 6 sends the notification request that is the same as the request when the correct result is evaluated for the predetermined number of times continuously. It is preferable to control the notification unit 3 so that the notification unit 3 is not notified.

  Even with this configuration, when the determination unit 2 makes a correct determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request, so the same questionnaire is sent to the resident of the customer facility H1. Requesting a response from the user can be suppressed. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to prevent the control unit 6 from using the evaluation result when the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. Therefore, with this configuration, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with a case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is correct, The reliability of the determination system 100 can be further improved.

  If the frequency at which the evaluation result indicating that the answer is correct for the same determination result is equal to or higher than the specified value, the control unit 6 determines that the same request as the request when the correct result is evaluated at a frequency equal to or higher than the specified value, It is preferable to control the notification unit 3 so as not to be notified from the notification unit 3.

  Even with this configuration, when the determination unit 2 makes a correct determination result again, the control unit 6 does not notify the notification unit 3 of the same evaluation request, so the same questionnaire is sent to the resident of the customer facility H1. Requesting a response from the user can be suppressed. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50 as compared with a case where the determination result is determined based on only one evaluation result indicating that the determination result is correct, The reliability of the determination system 100 can be further improved. Furthermore, according to this configuration, even when the evaluation result does not become the correct answer consecutively for a predetermined number of times, the resident of the customer facility H1 incorrectly evaluates the evaluation request displayed on the display unit 8. The evaluation result can be prevented from being used in the control unit 6.

  It is preferable that the evaluation acquisition unit 4 is configured to acquire attribute information related to at least one of the determination result and the evaluation result. In this case, it is preferable that the control unit 6 controls at least one of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result and the attribute information.

  According to this configuration, in addition to the evaluation result from the terminal device 20, the operation status of the target device 50 can be determined using attribute information (for example, determination time and ID information) related to the determination result. It is possible to further improve the accuracy of determining the operation status of the device 50.

  Preferably, the request includes information related to the customer facility H1.

  According to this configuration, the determination system 100 can provide not only the questionnaire information G2 but also useful information to the resident of the customer facility H1. Therefore, according to this configuration, it is easier for the resident to answer the questionnaire than when only the questionnaire information G2 is provided.

  As described above, the determination method according to the present embodiment determines the operation status of the target device 50 in the customer facility H1 based on the process of acquiring the consumption information on the resource consumption in the customer facility H1 based on the consumption information. The computer causes the computer to perform a process of causing the computer to perform a process of notifying a determination result of the operation status and a request for evaluation of the determination result, a process of acquiring an evaluation result for the request, and a process of operating based on the evaluation result.

  According to this configuration, since the operation status of the target device 50 is determined based on the consumption information, the consumption information on the resource consumption in the customer facility H1 can be more effectively utilized. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to prevent the erroneous determination result from being notified from the notification unit 3 again, and to prevent the determination unit 2 from once making an erroneous determination, and to determine the accuracy of the operation status of the target device 50. Can be improved.

  As described above, the determination program of the present embodiment causes the computer to execute the above-described determination method.

  According to this configuration as well, since the operation status of the target device 50 is determined based on the consumption information, the consumption information on the resource consumption in the customer facility H1 can be used more effectively. Further, according to this configuration, it is possible to prevent the erroneous determination result from being notified again from the notifying unit 3 or to prevent the determining unit 2 from making an erroneous determination once again, thereby improving the accuracy of determining the operation status of the target device 50. Can be improved.

  As described above, the terminal device 20 of the present embodiment is a terminal device used in the determination system 100. The terminal device 20 includes a receiving unit 7 that receives the determination result from the notification unit 3 and the request, and a display unit 8 that displays the determination result received by the receiving unit 7 and the request. In addition, the terminal device 20 includes an input unit 9 that receives an input of an evaluation result by a user, and a transmission unit 11 that transmits the evaluation result input by the input unit 9 to the evaluation acquisition unit 4.

  According to this configuration, the determination result and the evaluation request can be displayed on the display unit 8, and the evaluation result input by the input unit 9 can be transmitted from the transmission unit 11.

  As described above, the control method of the present embodiment is a control method used for the terminal device 20. This control method includes a process of causing the receiving unit 7 to receive the determination result and the request from the notifying unit 3, a process of displaying the determination result and the request on the display unit 8, and a process of receiving an input of the evaluation result by the user. And causing the transmitting unit 11 to transmit the evaluation result to the evaluation acquiring unit 4.

  With this configuration as well, the determination result and the evaluation request can be displayed on the display unit 8, and the evaluation result input by the input unit 9 can be transmitted from the transmission unit 11.

  As described above, the control program of the present embodiment causes a computer to execute the control method described above.

  With this configuration as well, the determination result and the evaluation request can be displayed on the display unit 8, and the evaluation result input by the input unit 9 can be transmitted from the transmission unit 11.

  The determination system 100 is realized by the server device 10, but is not limited thereto, and may be realized by, for example, the server device 10 and the terminal device 20. Further, the determination system 100 may be realized by the server device 10 and the measurement device 30. Further, the determination system 100 may be realized by the server device 10, the terminal device 20, and the measuring device 30. That is, the determination system 100 may be realized by various combinations of the server device 10, the terminal device 20, and the measuring device 30, and may be realized by not only one device but also a plurality of devices. Further, the determination system 100 may be realized by a cloud (cloud computing).

  The server device 10 may be configured to accumulate consumption information on the consumption amount measured by the measurement device 30 for a certain period (for example, for one month). In this case, the determination unit 2 determines the operation status of the target device 50 based on the accumulated consumption information.

  The notification unit 3 is configured to simultaneously notify the determination result and the evaluation request, but is not limited to this configuration. For example, the notification unit 3 may be configured to notify the evaluation request after notifying the determination result.

  The evaluation acquisition unit 4 is configured to record the acquired evaluation result in the recording unit 5, but is not limited to this configuration. The evaluation obtaining unit 4 may be configured to output the evaluation result to the control unit 6 without recording the obtained evaluation result in the recording unit 5.

  The control unit 6 is configured to control the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result from the recording unit 5, but is not limited to this configuration. The control unit 6 may be configured to control the determination unit 2 based on the evaluation result from the recording unit 5. For example, when the evaluation result from the terminal device 20 is incorrect, the control unit 6 controls the determination unit 2 so that the determination unit 2 does not perform the same determination again. That is, if the determination result of the determination unit 2 is incorrect, the control unit 6 corrects the predetermined algorithm in the determination unit 2 so that the determination unit 2 does not perform the same determination again. In this case, in the determination system 100, it is possible to prevent the determination unit 2 from erroneously determining the operation status of the target device 50 again based on the consumption information acquired by the information acquisition unit 1.

  Further, the control unit 6 may be configured to control the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result from the recording unit 5. That is, the control unit 6 may be configured to control at least one of the determination unit 2 and the notification unit 3 based on the evaluation result from the recording unit 5.

  The terminal device 20 is not limited to a smartphone, and may be a portable information terminal other than a smartphone such as a tablet terminal, or an information terminal device connectable to a network N1 such as a personal computer or a television (television) having a communication function. .

  The display unit 8 and the input unit 9 constitute a touch panel display, but are not limited thereto. The display unit 8 may constitute a display (for example, a liquid crystal display), and the input unit 9 may constitute an input device (for example, a keyboard, a pointing device, or a mechanical switch).

  When the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request, the control unit 12 may simultaneously display the determination information G1 and the questionnaire information G2 on the screen of the display unit 8. That is, when the receiving unit 7 receives the determination result and the evaluation request, the control unit 12 may display the determination information G1 and the questionnaire information G2 on the same screen of the display unit 8.

  The target device 50 includes a device such as a private power generation facility that generates electric power or a sensor device such as a temperature sensor.

  In the present embodiment, the information related to the customer facility H1 is weather information, but is not limited to this. The information related to the customer facility H1 may be, for example, an electricity rate or power regulation information.

  Further, in the present embodiment, the detached house is described as an example of the customer facility H1, but not limited to this example, the customer facility H1 may be a house other than the detached house such as each dwelling unit of an apartment house. Alternatively, it may be a non-residential house such as an office or a store.

  In the present embodiment, a communication path (first communication path) between the server device 10 and the measurement device 30 and a communication path (second communication path) between the server device 10 and the terminal device 20 are shared by the common network N1. , But is not limited to this configuration. The first communication path and the second communication path may be configured by different networks.

  Further, in the present embodiment, the resource consumption in the customer facility H1 is the power consumption or the power consumption of at least one of the plurality of branch circuits, but is not limited thereto. The resource consumption in the customer facility H1 may be the power consumption or power consumption of the main line on the primary side of the main breaker of the distribution board, that is, the total power consumption of the entire customer facility H1.

  In the present embodiment, the information (the determination information G1 and the questionnaire information G2) displayed on the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20 is generated by the server device 10, but is not limited thereto. The information displayed on the display unit 8 of the terminal device 20 may be generated by, for example, the terminal device 20 or may be generated by a device (external device) other than the server device 10 and the terminal device 20.

  The first option A1 includes text information of “correct answer”, but may include, for example, text information of “notification arrived immediately after washing is completed”. Further, the second option A2 includes text information of “wrong”, but may include text information of, for example, “notification has been received even though washing has not been performed”. Further, the third option A3 includes text information “unknown”, but may include text information “unknown”, for example. Further, the fourth option A4 includes text information of “timing is late”, but may include text information of “timing is early”. In this case, the fourth option A4 may include text information that “information has been received even though laundry is being performed”. In addition, the evaluation request may include text information “timing is late” as the fourth option A4, and text information “timing early” as the fifth option.

  In the present embodiment, the notification of the end of the operation of the washing machine is described. However, the present invention is not limited to this. It may be a notification of forgetting to start. Here, the notification of forgetting to start the operation of the washing machine means a notification for causing the resident of the customer facility H1 to determine whether the washing machine is operating at the set time. In this case, the determination information G1 includes, for example, text information “Did you forget to move the washing machine?”. Further, in this case, the first option A1 includes, for example, text information that “the laundry was not washed at the time when the notice was given”. The second option A2 includes, for example, text information that "already washed, but a notification has arrived". The third option A3 includes, for example, text information “I do not understand”.

  Further, in the present embodiment, in addition to the washing machine, the notification of forgetting to start the operation of the rice cooker, the dishwasher, or the like may be provided. For example, in the case of a notification that the operation of the rice cooker has been forgotten, the first option A1 includes, for example, text information that “Rice was not cooked at the time when the notification was made”. The second option A2 includes, for example, text information that “we have already cooked rice, but have received a notice”. The third option A3 includes, for example, text information “I do not understand”. If the notification is that the operation of the dishwasher has been forgotten, the first option A1 includes, for example, text information that "the dishwasher was not used at the time when the notice was given". The second option A2 includes, for example, text information that "the dishwasher has already been operated, but a notice has been received". The third option A3 includes, for example, text information “I do not understand”.

DESCRIPTION OF SYMBOLS 1 Information acquisition part 2 Judgment part 3 Notification part 4 Evaluation acquisition part 6 Control part 7 Reception part 8 Display part 9 Input part 11 Transmission part 20 Terminal device 50 Target apparatus 100 Judgment system A1 1st option A2 2nd option A3 3rd option A4 Option 4 (Options for evaluation of notification timing)
H1 customer facility

Claims (13)

An information acquisition unit that acquires consumption information about the amount of resources consumed at the customer facility;
A determination unit that determines an operation state of a target device in the customer facility based on the consumption information,
A determination result of the determination unit, a request for evaluation of the determination result, a first option for evaluating that the determination result is correct, and a second option for evaluating that the determination result is incorrect. A notification unit for notifying a request including the two options ;
An evaluation acquisition unit that acquires an evaluation result for the request,
A control unit that controls the notification unit so that the same request as the request when the determination result is at least one of a correct answer and an incorrect answer based on the evaluation result is not notified from the notification unit . A determination system characterized in that:   The request further includes a third option for evaluating that the determination result is unknown.
  The determination system according to claim 1, wherein:   The request further includes an option for evaluating the notification timing of the notification unit.
  The determination system according to claim 1 or 2, wherein:   The control unit, when the evaluation result that the determination result is incorrect is obtained, the same determination result and the request as the determination result and the request when evaluated as the incorrect, the request, Controlling the notification unit so that it is not notified from the notification unit
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein:   The control unit is configured such that, when the evaluation result that the same determination result is incorrect is obtained continuously for a predetermined number of times, the determination when the evaluation result is incorrect for the predetermined number of times is performed. The notification unit is controlled so that the same determination result and request as the result and the request are not notified from the notification unit.
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein:   When the frequency at which the evaluation result is incorrect for the same determination result is obtained is equal to or higher than a specified value, the control unit determines that the frequency is equal to or higher than the specified value. The notification unit is controlled such that the same determination result and request as the determination result and the request are not notified from the notification unit.
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein:   The control unit, when the evaluation result that the determination result is a correct answer is obtained, the same request as the request when evaluated as the correct answer, the notification so as not to be notified from the notification unit Control the department
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein:   When the evaluation result that the answer is correct for the same determination result is continuously obtained a predetermined number of times, the control unit is the same as the request when the correct answer is evaluated for the predetermined number of times continuously. Controlling the notifying unit so that the request is not notified from the notifying unit
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein:   The control unit, when the frequency of obtaining the evaluation result that is correct for the same determination result is equal to or more than a specified value, the request when evaluated as the correct answer at a frequency equal to or more than the specified value Controls the notifying unit so that the same request is not notified from the notifying unit.
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein:   The evaluation obtaining unit is configured to obtain attribute information related to at least one of the determination result and the evaluation result,
  The control unit controls at least one of the determination unit and the notification unit based on the evaluation result and the attribute information.
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 9, wherein:   The request includes information related to the customer facility.
  The determination system according to any one of claims 1 to 10, wherein:   Processing for acquiring consumption information regarding the amount of resource consumption at the customer facility;
  A process for determining the operation status of the target device in the customer facility based on the consumption information,
  A determination result of the operation status, and a request for evaluation of the determination result, wherein a first option for evaluating that the determination result is correct and a second option for evaluating that the determination result is incorrect. A process of notifying a request including two options;
  A process of acquiring an evaluation result for the request;
  A process of operating based on the evaluation result so that the same request as the request when the determination result is at least one of a correct answer and an incorrect answer is not notified.
  Let the computer do it
  A determination method characterized in that:   The computer is caused to execute the determination method according to claim 12.
  Judgment program for

Images